DOCSLIB.ORG

FINAL REPORT Analysis of Heat Pump Installation Practices and Performance Heat Pump Working Group

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
FINAL REPORT Analysis of Heat Pump Installation Practices and Performance Heat Pump Working Group FINAL REPORT Analysis of Heat Pump Installation Practices and Performance Prepared for the Heat Pump Working Group David Baylon Shelly Strand Bob Davis David Robison Erin Kruse December, 2005 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary...................................................................................................... ES-1 1. Introduction.................................................................................................................1 2. Billing Analysis and Field Sample Recruiting............................................................ 2 2.1. Program Description ........................................................................................... 2 2.2. Sample Frame ..................................................................................................... 3 2.3. Utility Consumption Record Recruiting ............................................................. 4 2.4. Field Sample Design........................................................................................... 4 2.5. C&RD / ConAug Sample Recruiting.................................................................. 6 2.6. EWEB Sample Recruiting.................................................................................. 8 3. Billing Analysis.......................................................................................................... 8 3.1. C&RD/ConAug Analysis................................................................................. 11 3.2. Comparison (Control) Group............................................................................ 20 3.3. Realization Rate................................................................................................ 21 3.4. EWEB CheckMe!® Billing Analysis ................................................................ 26 3.5. EWEB Control Comparison Group .................................................................. 31 4. Market Actor Interviews........................................................................................... 32 4.1. HVAC Installers................................................................................................32 4.2. Trends in Heat Pump Manufacturing................................................................ 43 4.3. Interview Findings............................................................................................ 46 5. Field Audits............................................................................................................... 47 5.1. Field Protocol.................................................................................................... 47 5.2. Field Characteristics..........................................................................................48 5.3. Duct System Characteristics ............................................................................. 51 5.4. Heat Pump Characteristics................................................................................ 54 5.5. Field Survey Findings....................................................................................... 55 5.6. Heat Pump HSPF.............................................................................................. 61 5.7. System Sizing....................................................................................................62 5.8. Homeowner Interviews..................................................................................... 65 5.9. Billing Analysis for the Field Sample............................................................... 67 5.10. Field Results..................................................................................................71 6. Laboratory Testing of Heat Pump Performance ....................................................... 73 6.1. Adjustment Factors........................................................................................... 73 6.2. Results: Capacity and COP.............................................................................. 74 6.3. Results: Heating Seasonal Performance Factor ............................................... 78 6.4. Findings............................................................................................................. 82 7. Conclusions............................................................................................................... 73 7.1. Program Savings ............................................................................................... 83 7.2. Heat Pump Commissioning .............................................................................. 84 7.3. Heat Pump Controls.......................................................................................... 87 7.4. Installation and Design Practice........................................................................ 90 7.5. Overall Conclusions.......................................................................................... 91 8. Bibliography and Suggested Reading....................................................................... 92 Technical Appendix A .................................................................................................... A-1 Technical Appendix B .................................................................................................... B-1 Technical Appendix C .................................................................................................... C-1 Technical Appendix D .................................................................................................... D-1 Technical Appendix E......................................................................................................E-1 Analysis of Heat Pump Installation Practices and Performance i Table of Tables Table 1. C&RD & ConAug Heat Pump Installations by Area .......................................... 3 Table 2. Utility Recruitment .............................................................................................. 4 Table 3. Billing Analysis Sample Frame (C&RD / ConAug) ........................................... 5 Table 4. EWEB Sample Frame.......................................................................................... 6 Table 5. Field Sample Attrition ......................................................................................... 8 Table 6. Summary of Savings Estimates by Region........................................................ 12 Table 7. Study Group Climate ......................................................................................... 15 Table 8. NAC Savings by Equipment Type..................................................................... 16 Table 9. NAC Savings by Equipment Type..................................................................... 17 Table 10. Square Footage by Equipment Type for C&RD Single Family ...................... 18 Table 11. Savings by Vintage, Single Family CR&D Cases........................................... 19 Table 12. Untreated Group, NAC kWh Consumption by Year....................................... 20 Table 13: Single Family Realization Rate by Pre-Retrofit System Type ........................ 21 Table 14: Manufactured Home Realization Rate by Pre-Retrofit System Type ............. 22 Table 15: Realization Rate for Entire Sample by Pre-Retrofit System Type .................. 22 Table 16. Analysis Results for Participant Groups.......................................................... 29 Table 17. EWEB Comparison Group Annual Consumption........................................... 31 Table 18. Sample UA and Air Tightness Characteristics ................................................ 49 Table 19. Housing Type and Area ................................................................................... 49 Table 20. Normalized Heat Loss Rate by Vintage .......................................................... 50 Table 21. Normalized Air Leakage Rate by Vintage....................................................... 51 Table 22. Duct UA and Leakage Rates............................................................................ 52 Table 23. Duct Delivery Efficiency by Vintage .............................................................. 53 Table 24. HSPF of Heat Pumps by Region ..................................................................... 61 Table 25. Heat Pump Sizing by Region........................................................................... 65 Table 26: Energy Use Estimates by End Use (N=122).................................................... 69 Table 27: Normalized Energy Use Estimates by Region and End Use ........................... 69 Table 28. Normalized Space Conditioning, Sample vs. RTF.......................................... 71 Table 29. Purdue Adjustment Factors using Refrigerant-Side Capacity Measurements. 73 Table 30. Cd: From Test Data, ARI Default and Back-Calculated................................. 79 Table 31. Defrost Multipliers: From Lab Data and ARI Default .................................... 81 Table 32. Comparison of HSPF results using Carrier YKC Catalog Data with Various Cd and Defrost Multipliers............................................................................................. 82 Table 33. Summary of NAC Consumption and Savings by Region, Treated Cases..... A-1 Table 34. Summary of NAC Consumption by System Type, Treated Cases................ A-3 Table 35. Disaggregation of Savings by End use and Climate Zone............................. A-5 Table 36. Test of Difference Between Regions............................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Investigation of the Impact of Commercial Building Envelope Airtightness on HVAC Energy Use
    NISTIR 7238 Investigation of the Impact of Commercial Building Envelope Airtightness on HVAC Energy Use Steven J. Emmerich Tim McDowell Wagdy Anis NISTIR 7238 Investigation of the Impact of Commercial Building Envelope Airtightness on HVAC Energy Use Steven J. Emmerich Building and Fire Research Laboratory Timothy P. McDowell TESS, Inc. Wagdy Anis Shepley Bulfinch Richardson and Abbott Prepared for: U.S. Department of Energy Office of Building Technologies June 2005 U.S. Department of Commerce Carlos M. Gutierrez, Secretary Technology Administration Phillip J. Bond, Under Secretary of Commerce for Technology National Institute of Standards and Technology Hratch Semerjian, Acting Director ABSTRACT This report presents a simulation study of the energy impact of improving envelope airtightness in U.S. commercial buildings. Despite common assumptions, measurements have shown that typical U.S. commercial buildings are not particularly airtight. Past simulation studies have shown that commercial building envelope leakage can result in significant heating and cooling loads. To evaluate the potential energy savings of an effective air barrier requirement, annual energy simulations were prepared for three nonresidential buildings (a two-story office building, a one-story retail building, and a four-story apartment building) in 5 U.S. cities. A coupled multizone airflow and building energy simulation tool was used to predict the energy use for the buildings at a target tightness level relative to a baseline level based on measurements in existing buildings. Based on assumed blended national average heating and cooling energy prices, predicted potential annual heating and cooling energy cost savings ranged from 3 % to 36 % with the smallest savings occurring in the cooling-dominated climates of Phoenix and Miami.
    [Show full text]
  • Infiltration Modeling Guidelines for Commercial Building Energy Analysis
    PNNL-18898 Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract DE-AC05-76RL01830 DOCKET 12-BSTD-1 DATE RECD. MAY 15 2012 Infiltration Modeling Guidelines for Commercial Building Energy Analysis K Gowri D Winiarski R Jarnagin September 2009 ii Executive Summary This report presents a methodology for modeling air infiltration in EnergyPlus to account for envelope air barrier characteristics. Based on a review of various infiltration modeling options available in EnergyPlus and sensitivity analysis, the linear wind velocity coefficient based on DOE-2 infiltration model is recommended. The methodology described in this report can be used to calculate the EnergyPlus infiltration input for any given building level infiltration rate specified at known pressure difference. The sensitivity analysis shows that EnergyPlus calculates the wind speed based on zone altitude, and the linear wind velocity coefficient represents the variation in infiltration heat loss consistent with building location and weather data. EnergyPlus infiltration input is calculated to be 0.2016 cfm/sf of exterior wall area, assuming that uncontrolled air leakage through the building envelope can be specified by a baseline leakage rate of 1.8 cfm/sf (@ 0.30 in. w.c) of exterior above grade envelope area (based on ASHRAE SSPC-90.1 Envelope Subcommittee recommendation). iii Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4 2. Building Infiltration Rate ...........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Modeling of Airflow Infiltration Through Building Entrance Doors
    Validation of Numerical Modeling of Air Infiltration through Building Entrance Doors Sherif Goubran, Dahai Qi, Wael F. Saleh, Liangzhu (Leon) Wang, Radu Zmeureanu Department of Building, Civil and Environmental Engineering, Concordia University, Quebec, Canada ABSTRACT studies confirm that with the increase of efficiency of equipment and building envelope, the relative percent Air infiltration through building entrance doors has energy loss due to air infiltration is becoming more been the focus of many studies due to the significant significant (in relation to the total energy losses) effect infiltrated air has on the buildings’ energy (Deru, Field, Studer, & Benne, 2011; Ng, Emmerich, performance. Air infiltration models were developed & Persily, 2014). Thus in modern and well insulated for the double swing single and vestibule doors based commercial buildings a larger portion of the heat on previous studies. It was concluded that vestibules losses are contributed to air infiltration; air infiltration doors are effective in reducing air infiltration. is responsible for about 25% of the building heating Currently vestibules are required as an energy saving loads for new buildings (Emmerich & Persily, 1998). measure for most commercial buildings. Our recent With tight building envelopes, the major sources of air studies were focused on investigating the effectiveness infiltration that remain in buildings are the exterior of different entrance doors in reducing air infiltration openings (doors and windows) (Cho, Liu, & Gowri, in buildings. This paper presents the results from a 2010; Emmerich & Persily, 1998; Ng et al., 2014). preliminary effort in our recent studies: the experimental validation of the numerical modeling of Yuill conducted one of the pioneer studies on a 2.44 m air infiltration through single doors (double swing) × 2.44 m × 1.30 m (L × W × H) chamber to estimate using computational fluid dynamics (CFD).
    [Show full text]
  • Influence of Air Infiltration on Combustion Process Changes in A
    processes Article Influence of Air Infiltration on Combustion Process Changes in a Rotary Tilting Furnace Róbert Dzur ˇnák 1,* , Augustin Varga 1, Gustáv Jablonský 1 , Miroslav Variny 2 ,Réne Atyafi 1, Ladislav Lukáˇc 1 , Marcel Pástor 1 and Ján Kizek 3 1 Department of Thermal Technology and Gas Industry, Institute of Metallurgy, Faculty of Materials, Metallurgy and Recycling, Technical University of Kosice, Letna 9, 042 00 Kosice, Slovakia; [email protected] (A.V.); [email protected] (G.J.); rene.atyafi@tuke.sk (R.A.); [email protected] (L.L.); [email protected] (M.P.) 2 Department of Chemical and Biochemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemical and Food Technology, Slovak University of Technology in Bratislava, Radlinskeho 9, 812 37 Bratislava, Slovakia; [email protected] 3 Department of Process Technique, Faculty of Manufacturing Technologies of the TU of Kosice with a Seat in Presov, Technical University of Kosice, Sturova 31, 080 01 Presov, Slovakia; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 24 September 2020; Accepted: 13 October 2020; Published: 15 October 2020 Abstract: Air infiltration into the combustion chambers of industrial furnaces is an unwanted phenomenon causing loss of thermal efficiency, fuel consumption increase, and the subsequent increase in operating costs. In this study, a novel design for a rotary tilting furnace door with improved construction features is proposed and tested experimentally in a laboratory-scale furnace, aimed at air infiltration rate reduction by decreasing the gap width between the static furnace door and the rotating body. Temperatures in the combustion chamber and oxygen content in the dry flue gas were measured to document changes in the combustion process with the varying gap width.
    [Show full text]
  • Factors Affecting Indoor Air Quality
    Factors Affecting Indoor Air Quality The indoor environment in any building the categories that follow. The examples is a result of the interaction between the given for each category are not intended to site, climate, building system (original be a complete list. 2 design and later modifications in the Sources Outside Building structure and mechanical systems), con- struction techniques, contaminant sources Contaminated outdoor air (building materials and furnishings, n pollen, dust, fungal spores moisture, processes and activities within the n industrial pollutants building, and outdoor sources), and n general vehicle exhaust building occupants. Emissions from nearby sources The following four elements are involved n exhaust from vehicles on nearby roads Four elements— in the development of indoor air quality or in parking lots, or garages sources, the HVAC n loading docks problems: system, pollutant n odors from dumpsters Source: there is a source of contamination pathways, and or discomfort indoors, outdoors, or within n re-entrained (drawn back into the occupants—are the mechanical systems of the building. building) exhaust from the building itself or from neighboring buildings involved in the HVAC: the HVAC system is not able to n unsanitary debris near the outdoor air development of IAQ control existing air contaminants and ensure intake thermal comfort (temperature and humidity problems. conditions that are comfortable for most Soil gas occupants). n radon n leakage from underground fuel tanks Pathways: one or more pollutant pathways n contaminants from previous uses of the connect the pollutant source to the occu- site (e.g., landfills) pants and a driving force exists to move n pesticides pollutants along the pathway(s).
    [Show full text]
  • Use of Ductless Mini Split Electric Heat Pumps In
    /i U.S. Department of Houslng and Urtan Development lr Office of Policy Development and Researcf USE OF DUCTLESS MINI.SPLIT ELECTRIC HEAT PUMPS IN RESIDENCES Phase ll - Final Report -i U.S. Department of Houslng and Urban Development 1r office of Policy Development and Researci USE OF DUCTLESS MINI.SPLIT ELECTRIC HEAT PUMPS IN RESIDENCES Phase ll - Final Report USE OF DUCTLESS MINI.SPLIT ELEGTRIC HEAT PUMPS IN RESIDENCES Phase ll - Final Report Prepared for: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Policy Development and Research Prepared by: NAHB Research Center Upper Marlboro, MD lnstrument No. DUl 00K000005897 July 1994 Notice The U.S. Govemment does not endorse products or manufacturers. Trade or manufacturers' names aPPear herein solely because they are considered essential to the object of this report. The contens of this rcport are the views of the contractor and do not necessarily rcflect the views or policies of the U.S. Departnent of Housing and Urban Development or the U.S. Govemment. Acknowledgements This report was prepared by the NAHB Research Center through funding provided by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). The principal author was C. Edward Barbour with technical assistance and review provided by Mark Nowak and Tom Kenney. Data acquisition system installation and operation was provided by Jay Crandell and J. Alben van Overeem. The author acknowledges the contributions and guidance of Mark Gibson and Carol Soble at various times during the project and development of the report. Special appreciation is extended to William Freeborne of HUD for review assistance.
    [Show full text]
  • Identifying Water and Moisture Infiltration Paths in Building Envelopes
    Proceedings: Indoor Air 2002 IDENTIFYING WATER AND MOISTURE INFILTRATION PATHS IN BUILDING ENVELOPES LP Lazure* and J Lavoie Occupational Health and Safety Research Institute Robert-Sauvé, Montréal, Québec, Canada ABSTRACT In the past ten years, fungal contamination of buildings has been linked to many complaints related to indoor air quality. Three elements promote microbial growth in an indoor environment: a) a microbial source, b) nutrients, and 3) water. Controlling the presence of water is generally the most effective means of limiting fungal colonization. The pervasiveness of microbes in our environment and the presence of many nutrient substrates limit the possibilities of rapid and effective intervention at these levels. In order to determine leakage sources and to perform an effective field investigation, the role of building components in preventing moisture intrusion and the mechanisms of moisture migration must be understood. Specialized techniques such as thermography and spray tests can be used to conduct the analysis and the assessment of the integrity of a building enclosure. INDEX TERMS Bioaerosol, Building envelope, Water leakage, Moisture, Microbial contamination INTRODUCTION Studies tend to demonstrate the existence of relationship between mold exposure and the development of some symptoms, particularly respiratory symptoms (Goyer, Lavoie, Lazure et al, 2001). Several of these studies have also noted the presence of high humidity. Among the various elements that contribute to microbial growth in an indoor environment, three are of particular interest: a) a microbial source, b) nutrients, and c) water (ACGIH, 1999). Controlling water accumulation is generally the most effective means of limiting colonization. The pervasiveness of microbes in our environment and the presence of many nutrient substrates such as cellulose, adhesives and other carbon containing materials limit the possibilities of rapid and effective intervention at these levels.
    [Show full text]
  • Reduce Air Infiltration in Furnaces
    INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGIES PROGRAM • The furnace firing rate Reduce Air Infiltration Flue 烟气 • The flue gas velocity through the stack or in Furnaces the stack cross-section area Fuel-fired furnaces discharge combustion H • The burner operating conditions (e.g., products through a stack or a chimney. Hot excess air, combustion air temperature, furnace gases are less dense and more and so on). buoyant than ambient air, so they rise, creating a differential pressure between the For furnaces or boilers using an induced- top and the bottom of the furnace. This draft (ID) fan, the furnace negative pressure depends on the fan performance and differential, known as thermal head, is the Air Leak 空气渗透 source of a natural draft or negative pressure frictional losses between the fan inlet and the point of air leakage. In most cases, it would in furnaces and boilers. Figure 1. Air leakage and gas flow in a typical fuel-fired furnace. 图1. 典型的使用燃料的 be necessary to measure or estimate negative A well-designed furnace (or boiler) is built to 熔炉中的空气渗透和流向 pressure at the opening. avoid air leakage into the furnace or leakage The amount of air leakage, the heat lost in of flue gases from the furnace to the furnace. The cold air becomes heated to the flue gases, and their effects on increased ambient. However, with time, most furnaces furnace exhaust gas temperature and then furnace or boiler fuel consumption can be develop cracks or openings around doors, exits through the flue system, wasting calculated by using the equations and graphs joints, and hearth seals.
    [Show full text]
  • 68320 Na 0.Pdf
    www.caleffi.com Solar Thermal Collector NAS104 Series Installation and Maintenance Guidelines Function Solar thermal collectors are used to capture energy from the sun and efficiently transfer solar energy to heat the solar fluid in the primary circuits of solar heating systems. This heated solar fluid is circulated through a heat exchanger, thus heating domestic water, which is stored in suitable tank. This heated water is then delivered to a conventional water heater for final heating, if required, or direct use. Introduction Caleffi solar thermal collectors are built using the highest quality standards and materials and will perform for many years provided that they are installed and maintained correctly. Please take time to read and understand this booklet thoroughly. Caleffi Solar is unable to provide explicit instructions for every type of roof and building system that will be encountered. This booklet outlines some common situations and provides suggestions, but it is ultimately the installer’s responsibility to determine applicability with local codes, structural integrity of the existing building, and to consult with a Structural Engineer when appropriate Models: NAS10406 Solar Thermal Collector ................................................................................................4‘ x 6.5‘ NAS10408 Solar Thermal Collector ...................................................................................................4‘ x 8‘ NAS10410 Solar Thermal Collector .................................................................................................4‘
    [Show full text]
  • Cooling Load Calculations and Principles
    Cooling Load Calculations and Principles Course No: M06-004 Credit: 6 PDH A. Bhatia Continuing Education and Development, Inc. 22 Stonewall Court Woodcliff Lake, NJ 07677 P: (877) 322-5800 [email protected] HVAC COOLING LOAD CALCULATIONS AND PRINCIPLES TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 OBJECTIVE..................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 2.0 TERMINOLOGY ............................................................................................................................................................................. 2 3.0 SIZING YOUR AIR-CONDITIONING SYSTEM .......................................................................................................................... 4 3.1 HEATING LOAD V/S COOLING LOAD CALCULATIONS........................................................................................5 4.0 HEAT FLOW RATES...................................................................................................................................................................... 5 4.1 SPACE HEAT GAIN........................................................................................................................................................6 4.2 SPACE HEAT GAIN V/S COOLING LOAD (HEAT STORAGE EFFECT) .................................................................7 4.3 SPACE COOLING V/S COOLING LOAD (COIL)........................................................................................................8
    [Show full text]
  • Infiltration and Pressure Differences Induced by Forced Air Systems in Florida Residences
    VA-89-5-4 Infiltration and Pressure Differences Induced by Forced Air Systems in Florida Residences J.B. Cummings J.J. Tooley, Jr. ABSTRACT present results from tracer-gas tests and fan-pressurization Five h9mes were tested by trac=;er gas and blower tests on five homes before and after duct-system repair. We door to assess infiltration caused by leaks in air distribu­ conclude that return plenum leaks can have major impacts tion systems. These homes are not a random sample and on energy use, air-conditioner capacity. and indoor com­ therefore may not give an accurate representation of fort, and that they are relatively easy and cost effective to Florida housing. Techniques used to determine the repair. amount of return leak and the amount of infiltration caus­ ed by duct leaks are described. COMPUTER SIMULATION OF INFILTRATION Average infiltration with the air handler running was Infiltration rates are very important to understanding 1.42 air changes per hour (ach), while with the air handler energy use and indoor humidity conditions in residential off, it averaged only 0.14 ach. The infiltration rate with the buildings. In hot, humid climates, influx of outdoor air adds air handler running is equivalent to an average 290 cubic to the cooling load and raises indoor relative humidity. feet per minute (cfm) (0.1369 m3/sec). Return leaks were Computer simulation results using TARP (Thermal A.naiysis much larger than supply leaks in all five homes. The return Research Program), modified to account for moisture ad­ leak fraction averaged 21 .6%, or an average of 263 cfm sorption and desorption into and ou of building materials (0.142 m 3/sec).
    [Show full text]
  • Achieving a Better Understanding of Air Infiltration When Assessing
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Loughborough University Institutional Repository CIBSE Technical Symposium, Sheffield, UK 25-26 April 2019 Achieving a better understanding of air infiltration when assessing overheating in multi-residential dwellings MICHAEL SWAINSON (PHD)1, CHRISTINA J HOPFE (PHD, CENG, FCIBSE)2, ROBERT MCLEOD (PHD, CENG, MIMECHE) 2, KOSTAS MOURKOS (MSC) 2, CHRIS GOODIER (PHD) 2 BUILDING RESEARCH ESTABLISHMENT 1 SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE, BUILDING AND CIVIL ENGINEERING, LOUGHBOROUGH UNIVERSITY2 [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract In temperate climates the prediction of indoor temperatures using Building Performance Simulation (BPS) is thought to be highly sensitive to assumptions regarding convective and radiative heat transfer processes. This paper investigates whether the way in which infiltration is modelled may be exerting a pronounced effect on the results of overheating studies. An EnergyPlus model, of a dwelling in a multi- residential building in London, was created to investigate the influence of infiltration and exfiltration pathway assumptions on the prediction of overheating. Baseline modelling based on the application of the TM59 methodology to an existing building was compared to scenarios using best practice dynamic modelling procedures. The findings were compared to empirical data and show that the indoor temperatures are highly sensitive to how the infiltration airflow network is modelled. The results of this study provide practical guidance for modellers and building designers on what aspects to consider when creating energy models to ensure more reliable outcomes.
    [Show full text]