Ecology of the Bald Eagle and Osprey in Yellowstone National Park, Jon
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ecology of the bald eagle and osprey in Yellowstone National Park, Jon Eugene Swenson by Jon Eugene Swenson A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE in Fish and Wildlife Management Montana State University © Copyright by Jon Eugene Swenson (1975) Abstract: The ecology of the bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) and osprey (Pandion haliaetus) in Yellowstone National Park was studied during the summers of 1972, 1973 and 1974. From historical records, it appeared as though the bald eagle population had remained stable while the osprey population had declined in numbers and distribution. Bald eagles, apparently those which nest in the park, winter along • major rivers, primarily on ungulate wintering areas. Eagle and osprey nest sites were described and compared. Bald eagle territories seemed to be limited by open water at the time of nest initiation. Both species nested later in the park than elsewhere at the same latitude. Ospreys nested later on the lakes (after ice-out) than streams. Bald eagle nest success, 23.3 percent, and productivity per occupied nest, 0.23 percent, were significantly less than in 1960-61. Osprey reproduction has also declined, but nests on Yellowstone Lake had significantly lower nest success and productivity per occupied nest, 28.3 percent and 0.45, respectively, than stream nests, 63.4 percent and 0.95, respectively. This difference appeared to be related to human presence near nests. The corresponding parameters for the entire osprey population were 41.1 percent and 0.64, respectively. In 1972 and 1973, success of osprey nests on Yellowstone Lake was significantly higher for those over 1 km from a backcountry campsite. Bald eagle reproduction was apparently not affected by human presence. Late ice-out was believed to be the cause of delayed nesting and reduced success of ospreys nesting on Yellowstone Lake in 1974. Pesticide residues were detected in osprey eggs from the park. The diet of bald eagles consisted of 57.1 percent birds, 36 percent water-fowl, 25.0 percent fish and 17.9 percent mammals; the diet of ospreys on Yellowstone Lake consisted of about 93 percent cutthroat trout of an average size of 27.6 cm. Osprey foraging parameters from Yellowstone Lake were reported. They seemed to forage over deep water in response to the distribution of the favored size of the major prey species. A hypothesis of population regulation in the bald eagles, based on increased subadult survival in response to reduced competition through lowered natality and adult territorial aggression, is presented to explain the stable numbers despite reduced reproduction. Management recommendations were presented. STATEMENT OF PERMISSION TO COPY In presenting this thesis in partial fulfillment of the require ments for an advanced degree at Montana State University, I agree that the Library shall make it freely available for inspection. I further agree that permission for extensive copying of this thesis for - scholarly purposes may be granted by my major professor, or, in his absence, by the Director of Libraries. It is understood that any copying or publication of this thesis for financial, gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. Signature Date ECOLOGYLOE -THE BALD EAGLE AND OSPREY IN , YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK by JON EUGENE SWENSON A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree ' ofJT X| MASTER OF SCIENCE in Fish and Wildlife Management Approved: Chairman, Examin: Committee ■ [ead, Major Department MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY Bozeman, Montana March, 1975 ill ACKNOWLEDGMENT I wish to extend my sincere appreciation to Dr. Robert L. Eng, Montana State University, for supervision of the study and guidance in preparation of the manuscript; Mr. Glen F. Cole, National Park Service, for advice and assistance; Jim Stradley, for his able piloting which was so important; Messrs. Dale Nuss, Elwood Jones and Pat Ozmunt, National Park Service, for assistance in the field; Messrs. Jack L. Dean and John D. Varley, Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wild life, for help and information on the park fishes; Drs. Don C. Quimby and William R. Gould, for critical reading of the manuscript; the many National Park Service personnel I worked with, especially those in Canyon, for their hospitality and assistance; and to my wife, Hanne, for encouragement, understanding and field assistance. During this study, I was supported by the National Park Service under RSP Project YELL-N-66. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Page V I T A .................................. ................... ii ACKNOWLEDGMENT ................................................ iii LIST OF TABLES ......................... viii LIST OF FIGURES .............................................. xi ABSTRACT .................................................. xii INTRODUCTION .................................................. I DESCRIPTION OF A R E A .......................................... 2 Physiography . in <f cN oo oooooo Climate ..... Vegetation . Primary Study Area METHODS ...... Literature Search ........ Nest Surveys ............. Classification of Immatures Nest Site M e a s u r e m e n t s .................................... 9 Reproductive Terminology .................................... 10 Effects of Human Presence .................................... 11 Egg and Eggshell Analyses ............................. .' . 12 Food Items and Foraging B e h a v i o r ................... 13 Statistical Analyses ........................................ 15 RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS ....................... .............. - 16 Present and Historical Numbers and Distribution ...... 16 Bald E a g l e ................................................ 16 O s p r e y s ................................................... 20 Movements and Migration ...................................... 24 Bald E a g l e ................................................. 24 O s p r e y ..................................................... 30 V TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) Page Nest sites and Nesting Distribution ....................... 32 Nest Site S e l e c t i o n .................................... 32 Factors Affecting Nesting Distribution ................. 34 Relations to Burns ................ 37 Nesting Chronology ........................................ • 38 Egg-laying................ 38 BaZd E a g l e ..................... ,.................... 38 O s p r e y ............ 39 Hatching . ............................................. 40 Bald E a g l e ............ 40 O s p r e y ...............'............................... 40 Fledging .......................................... .. 42 Bald E a g l e .......................................... 42 O s p r e y ............................. 42 Reproduction . ............................................. 43 E g g s ................... ’................................. 43 Bald E a g l e .......................................... '43 O s p r e y .............................................. 43 Y o u n g ................................................... 46 Bald E a g l e .......... 46 O s p r e y .............................................. 48 Nest Success and P r o d u c t i v i t y ......................... 50 Bald E a g l e .......................................... 50 O s p r e y ........................... •.................. 51 vi ' TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) Page Nonbreeding.......................................... 55 Bald E a g l e ........................................ 55 O s p r e y ................................................ 56 Factors Affecting Reproductive Success ..................... 57 Human Presence .......................................... 57 Bald E a g l e ........................... ■............... 57 O s p r e y .................................... ■ ........... 59 W e a t h e r ............................. 69 Bald E a g l e .......................................... ’ . 69 O s p r e y ............................. ,....'......... 69 Pesticides . ; ................................. 72, H i s t o r y ................ 72 Bald E a g l e ............................................ ■ 75 O s p r e y ................................................ 76 Predation................................................ 80 Prey and Foraging Beha v i o r .................................. 80 Prey S p e c i e s ....................... 80 Bald E a g l e ............................................ 80 Osprey ..... ...................................... 84 Osprey Prey Size *...............' ........... 85 Foraging Behavior and Success . ............... 88 Bald. E a g l e ................ 88 O s p r e y ................................................ 89 Feeding of Nestling Ospreys ............................. 95 7 % vii TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) Page Effects of Human Presence on Osprey Foraging ............. 95 Ihtra- and Interspecific Interactions ....................... 97 Bald E a g l e ...............'................................ 97 Osprey . ....................................... 103 Bald Eagle— Osprey .......................................... 104 Other Interactions......................................... 105 DISCUSSION.............................................. 107 Population Status ............................................. 107 Bald E a g l e ........ ................ '..................... 107 O s p r e y ...................................................... 107 A Hypothesis on Population Regulation in the Bald Eagle . H O Management