Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Technical Reports (CIS) Department of Computer & Information Science January 1993 Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure Ruzena Bajcsy University of Pennsylvania David J. Farber University of Pennsylvania Richard P. Paul University of Pennsylvania Jonathan M. Smith University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/cis_reports Recommended Citation Ruzena Bajcsy, David J. Farber, Richard P. Paul, and Jonathan M. Smith, "Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure", . January 1993. University of Pennsylvania Department of Computer and Information Science Technical Report No. MS-CIS-93-11. This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/cis_reports/422 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure Abstract Advanced manufacturing concepts such as "Virtual Factories" use an information infrastructure to tie together changing groups of specialized facilities into agile manufacturing systems. A necessary element of such systems is the ability to teleoperate machines, for example telerobotic systems with full- capability sensory feedback loops. We have identified three network advances needed for splitting robotic control from robotic function: increased bandwidth, decreased error rates, and support for isochronous traffic. Theseeatur f es are available in the Gigabit networks under development at Penn and elsewhere. A number of key research questions are posed by gigabit telerobotics. There are issues in network topology, robot control and distributed system software, packaging and transport of sensory data (including wide-area transport), and performance implications of architectural choices using measures such as cost, response time, and network utilization. We propose to explore these questions experimentally in a joint research effort combining the Distributed Systems Laboratory (DSL) and the General Robotics and Sensory Perception (GRASP) Laboratory at the University of-Pennsylvania. The proposed experiments should provide important early results. A detailed research program is described. Comments University of Pennsylvania Department of Computer and Information Science Technical Report No. MS- CIS-93-11. This technical report is available at ScholarlyCommons: https://repository.upenn.edu/cis_reports/422 Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure MS-CIS-93-11 GRASP LAB 344 DISTRIBUTED SYSTEMS LAB 15 Ruzena Bajcsy David J. Farber Richard P. Paul Jonathan M. Sil~ith U11iversit.yof Penrisylvania School of Ellgir~eeringarid Applied Science Con~pnterand Informat,ion Science Department PIiiladelpl~ia,PA 19104-6389 January 1993 Gigabit Telerobotics: Applying Advanced Information Infrastructure Ruzena Bajcsy, David J. Farber, Richard P. Paul, Jonathan M. Smith Computer and Information Science, University of Pennsylvania 200 South 33rd St, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6389 ABSTRACT Advanced manufacturing concepts such as "Virtual Factories" use an information infras- tructure to tie together changing groups of specialized facilities into agile manufacturing sys- tems. A necessary element of such systems is the ability to teleoperate machines, for example telerobotic systems with fullcapability sensory feedback loops. We have identified three net- work advances needed for splitting robotic control from robotic function: increased bandwidth, decreased error rates, and support for isochronous traffic. These features are available in the Gigabit networks under development at Penn and elsewhere. A number of key research questions are posed by gigabit telerobotics. There are issues in network topology, robot control and distributed system software, packaging and transport of sen- sory data (including wide-area transport), and performance implications of architectural choices using measures such as cost, response time, and network utilization. We propose to explore these questions expel'imentally in a joint research effort combining the Distributed Systems Laboratory (DSL) and the General Robotics and Sensory Perception (GRASP) Laboratory at the University of-Pennsylvania. The proposed experiments should pro- vide important early results. A detailed research program is described. 1. Introduction One of the major difficulties facing the United States is the inability to rapidly design, develop, and deploy complex systems, such as software and manufactured systems. Although our competitors on the world scene have made sub- stantial progress in the ability to rapidly produce variants of established products, all nations seem to have difficulty in the creation and deployment of new systems. With the proposed project, the University of Pennsylvania's Com- puter and Information Science Department stands ready to develop technology that will help address these prob- lems. This project represents an integration of disciplines that could, in the future, offer the same magnitude of pay- off that the integration of computers and communications has. The core problem has been, and continues to be, one of distributed resource management. A recent National Research Council study [I] on the United States Air Force's software projects found that a principle cause of the failure of the systems to achieve on-time and on-budget delivery was the inability to produce software systems in which pieces of the system were designed and built by different, geographically-distributed organizations. Similar problems arise in the integration of aircraft control systems into airframes and components of airframes with other components. We propose applying the University of Pennsylvania's leading-edge work in robotics and manufacturing tech- nology, together with our expertise in very high speed networking (as illustrated in the AURORA[S] project) towards the solution of these problems. We are too realistic to promise great solutions immediately. We believe, however, that a reasonable start can be made and that short term benefits that will help our industrial base can be realized. Our proposal is described in the sections of this white paper. The unifying theme is that of a "Virtual Distributed Factory" (VDF). The VDF is geographically-distributed and multi-organizational [2]. It is composed of design centers [3], fabrication facilities, and test stands, in addition to supercomputers for modeling, all integratedvia a very high speed communication net- work. Integration of control and related actuation equipment (by humans or machines) requires teleoperation. 1.1. Teleoperation Distributed digital teleoperation provides for the remote visual, audio, and kinesthetic access of an operator to a physical system. While many believe that visual access is all that is necessary, reflection (and experience!) reveals the difficulty of interpreting graphics displays and the impossibility of visually ascertaining how parts are connected together when partially mated. Kinesthetic feedback simplifies the manipulation of images and of parts. Combining audio information as well provides for an even stronger sense of reality. The use of more than one form of task feedback provides us with the capability to fuse sensory information, providing more complete knowledge of the state of a task and its performance. Kinesthetic feedback is a basic sense, and provides a very natural interface to systems. This interface is one reason that teleoperation is so direct and simple to use. In distributed digital teleo- peration the operator interacts with a remote site via graphics displays, master manipulators, audio feedback, etc. There is nothing, however, in the system to tell the operator that she or he is interacting with a real remote system. We could replace the real remote world with a simulation. If we did this we would have created a virtual reality. While there is much research interest in virtual realities there is none, or very little, in distributed virtual reality. If a distributed digital teleoperation system existed it could be connected to a remote virtual reality allowing an operator to interact with products that have not yet been created. In the area of modem manufacturing the rapidity of development, and comectness, of a new design is of utmost importance [3]. This is illustrated by CADICAM systems which are the forerunners of virtual reality sys- tems. In the area of architectural design, virtual realities are used to allow users and architects to evaluate designs long before they are committed to paper. In manufacturing, we expect similar systems to become available; systems in which it is possible to "kick the tires" long before a product goes into detail design and prototype production. Such evaluation systems are of vital importance, as there is no longer time or money to go through the lengthy pro- totype and testing phases of the past. This exploration and evaluation process can be expanded such that 1. Multiple parts suppliers can test the assembly of the whole system electronically and make quick adjustments before the manufacturing process begins; 2. Physical constraints are made less relevant. For example, designers and production facilities may be in dif- ferent physical locations, e.g., production is located in remote areas because real estate is cheaper (or zoning is less restrictive), while designers are typically concentrated in urban areas. 3. CAD systems are enhanced with physical simulators,
Recommended publications
  • Object Recognition Using Vision and Touch
    OBJECT RECOGNITION USING VISION AND TOUCH Peter Allen and Ruzena Bajcsy Department of Computer and Information Science University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA 19104 number of false recognitions. However, the model primitives must ABSTRACT be computable from the sensed data. More complex object models A system is described that integrates vision and are being built [8] but they are of limited power unless the sensing tactile sensing in a robotics environment to perform systems can uncover the structural primitives and relationships they object recognition tasks. It uses multiple sensor systems contain. The approach used here allows complex and rich models (active touch and passive stereo vision) to compute of objects that extends the kinds of generic objects that can be three dimensional primitives that can be matched recognized by the system. This is due to the rich nature of the sur• against a model data base of complex curved surface face and feature primitives the sensors compute. Surfaces are the objects containing holes and cavities. The low level actual parts of an object that we see; the primitive computed is sensing elements provide local surface and feature exactly this. Holes and cavities are important visual and tactile matches which arc constrained by relational criteria features; these are also computed by integrating touch and vision. embedded in the models. Once a model has been Further, the system described here is viewpoint independent. The invoked, a verification procedure establishes confidence problems caused by visual occlusion are overcome by the ability to measures for a correct recognition. The three dimen* use active touch sensing in visually occluded areas.
    [Show full text]
  • Active Perception
    Active Perception RUZENA BAJCSY, MEMBER, IEEE Invited Paper Active Perception (Active Vision specifically) is defined as a study II. WHATIS ACTIVESENSING? of Modeling and Control strategies for perception. By modeling we mean models of sensors, processing modules and their interac- In the robotics and computer vision literature, the term tion. We distinguish local models from global models by their “active sensor” generally refers to a sensor that transmits extent of application in space and time. The local models repre- (generally electromagnetic radiation, e.g., radar, sonar, sent procedures and parameters such as optical distortions of the lens, focal lens, spatial resolution, band-pass filter, etc. The global ultrasound, microwaves and collimated light) into the envi- models on the other hand characterize the overall performance ronment and receives and measures the reflected signals. and make predictions on how the individual modules interact. The We believe that the use of active sensors is not a necessary control strategies are formulated as a search of such sequence of condition on active sensing, and that sensing can be per- steps that would minimize a loss function while one is seeking the formed with passive sensors (that only receive, and do not most information. Examples are shown as the existence proof of the proposed theory on obtaining range from focus and sterolver- emit, information), employed actively. Here we use the term gence on 2-0 segmentation of an image and 3-0 shape parametri- active not to denote a time-of-flight sensor, but to denote za tion. a passive sensor employed in an active fashion, purpose- fully changing the sensor’s state parameters according to sensing strategies.
    [Show full text]
  • Winter and Spring), and T C
    COMPUTER SCIENCE DEPARTMENT REPORT TO COMPUTER SCIENCE ADVISORY COMMITTEE October 1973 FACULTY AND STAFF Don Knuth has returned from a year's leave spent in Norway. George Dantzig is on sabbatical leave for the current academic year. Roger Schank is on leave and Harold Stone is here but on research leave for the academic year. John T. Gill of the Electrical Engineering Department has been named to the list of affiliated faculty. Two of our faculty received distinguished awards in the past year Dantzig was awarded the Honorary Degree of Doctor of Science by Technion- Israel Institute of Technology. Knuth was made a Fellow of the American Academy of Science. Visiting faculty members for the current year are Peter Franaszek, Terry Winograd, C.A.R. Hoare (Autumn quarter), Joseph Oliger (Winter quarter), Robert M. Keller (Winter and Spring), and T C . Hu (Spring quarter). The department's resources are augmented by about 19 professional people who are research associates, research computer scientists, etc. Also several professionals from the local area serve as lecturers helping with the teaching program of the department. OTHER VISITORS In addition to the visiting faculty listed above, there are a number of other visitors who have come here to participate in the research acti- vities of the department. Among these are Mario and Luigia Aiello from Italy, Gheorghe Dodescu from Romania, Geoffrey Dromey from Australia, lan Duff from England, Kjell Overholt from Norway and F. yon Henke from Germany. STUDENTS AND ENROLLMENTS We have approximately 115 graduate student majors in our Department but there is no undergraduate major.
    [Show full text]
  • (Autumn Q. .Ter), Josep! Iger ■ La Robert M
    1 COMPUTER SCIENC3 Di P-RTMEN. TO COMPUTER SCjPiMCE ADV ...PRY CO- ' -tooer 197? pPuiflY AND STAFF Don Knuth has returned from a year's le "way. G- ; ritzig is on sabbatical, leave for che current aco . /-ear. Roger Sc'J Ls on leave and Harold Stone is here but or. reseax . t^ave for ;he acadein year. John T. Gill of the Electrical Engineering I tment has been nam* 1 1 the list of affiliated faculty. Two of our faculty received distinguished a .-" "■"': h 3t yes Dantzig was awarded the Honorary Degree of Doctor i/, lechnion- ] srael Institute of Technology. Knuth was made a ."' . th Ameri< '■ :demy of Science. Visiting faculty members for the current yeaj ?■ isz. ['erry Winograd, C.A.R. Hoare (Autumn q. .ter), Josep! Iger ■ La Robert M. Keller (Winter and Spring;, and T C. IP 9 lg .uarterp The department's resources are augmented by p.rofe3^.ior >eople 'ho are r -search associates, research commute., scientists, etc. Also several professionals fr..-- the local area serve as curers helj ./ith the teaching program of ti i 'partment. OTHER VISITORS In addition to the visiting faculty listed ..re re a : ■Z other visitors who have come here to participate ses. .. Ac tes of the department. Among these are Mario ar. Aie: L; fr, ■rghe Dodescu from Romania, Geoffrey Dromey from ] Dv: ( ■ il'ml, i'.,i'-ll 'v -riu IM. iVi'iu Norway aiP ("' "■-a FT< i-j ■ . i>. ■■■i'lNlS AND ENROL! PENIS We have approximately 115 graduc p- student m; , separtm< .. there is no undergraduate major.
    [Show full text]
  • IJCAI Organization
    IJCAI Organization Trustees Former Trustees Serving on the President: Francesca Rossi (University of Padova, Italy) Executive Committee Craig Knoblock (University of Southern California, USA) Hiroaki Kitano (Sony Computer Science Laboratories, Inc., Japan) Sebastian run (Stanford University, USA) Ramon López de Mántaras (Spanish Scientific Research Council, Spain) Michael Wooldridge (University of Oxford, UK) Craig Boutilier (University of Toronto, Canada) Qiang Yang (Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Fausto Giunchiglia (University of Trento, Italy) Hong Kong) Anthony G. Cohn (University of Leeds, UK) Gerhard Brewka (University of Leipzig, Germany) Hector Levesque (University of Toronto, Canada) Subbarao Kambhampati (Arizona State University, USA) Luigia Carlucci Aiello (Universita' di Roma, Italy) Toby Walsh (University of New South Wales, Australia) Michael P. Georgeff (Georgeff International Inc, Australia) Fahiem Bacchus (University of Toronto, Canada) C. Raymond Perrault (SRI International, USA) Carles Sierra (Artificial Intelligence Research Institute of the Spanish Wolfgang Wahlster (German Research Center for AI, Germany) Research Council, Spain) Barbara J. Grosz (Harvard University, USA) Trustees Elect Wolfgang Bibel (Darmstadt University of Technology, Germany) Alan Bundy (University of Edinburgh, UK) Jeffrey Rosenschein (e Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel) Alan Mackworth (University of British Columbia, Canada) Jérôme Lang (University Paris Dauphine, France) Patrick J. Hayes (IHMC-UWF, USA) D. Raj Reddy (Carnegie
    [Show full text]
  • Robots Being Exhibited.No Link 1
    Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence 445 Burgess Drive Menlo Park, CA 94025 (650) 328-3123 www.aaai.org For press inquiries only, contact: Sara Hedberg (425) 444-7272 2008 Robot Workshop and Exhibition Backgrounder July 14-16, 2008 Hyatt Regency McCormick Place, Chicago, Illinois Second Level, Hyatt Regency Conference Center, CC23 In conjunction with the AAAI-08 Conference This year AAAI is sponsoring two Robot Workshops and Exhibitions – one on Robots and Creativity (pages 1-9) and one on Mobility and Manipulation (pages 10-14). Below are schedules, descriptions of the robots to be presented, and brief biographies of the researchers involved. Exhibits will be showcased on July 15 and 16. This gives audiences opportunities to see and experience what was discussed in the Workshop. Workshop on Robotics and Creativity July 14, 2008, 8:20a.m.-12:30 p.m. This workshop explores the roles that creativity plays in robotics. This includes research where robots employ cognitive models and computation to display creativity. Also explored are partnerships among artists, scientists and engineers to generate a creative synergy and stimulate breakthroughs. Format A distinguished panel will kick off the workshop by providing a broad overview of the area, emerging paradigms and exciting opportunities. Those invited to exhibit at AAAI, will give short 10-minute briefs. These talks provide examples and personal thoughts of creativity and robotics. The workshop concludes with a 60-min Discussion Forum to capture thoughts and generate
    [Show full text]
  • Internati Nal W Men's
    _________________________________ WOMEN IN THE DIGITAL SPACE United Nations _________________________________ Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization 8 MARCH INTERNATI NAL W MEN’S DAY ______________________________ “Mary Allen Wilkes, programmer, with a LINC at M.I.T. in the early 1960’s. _______________________________ © Joseph ”C. Towler, Jr. Published in 2019 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization Division for Gender Equality, Cabinet of the Director-General 7, place de Fontenoy 75352 Paris 07 SP France TABLE OF CONTENTS Message of the Director-General p3 Foreword by the Director for Gender Equality p5 Debate p7 “Women Online: Challenges for Gender Equality Women in the Online Space“ Launch of EQUALS Policy Paper p8 “I’D BLUSH IF I COULD: Closing gender divides in digital skills through education” #Wiki4Women p9 Exhibition p10 “Remarkable Women in Technology” MESSAGE OF THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL This year’s International Women’s Day, we celebrate women’s contributions to society – particularly in the digital space – and reflect on how we can ensure women fully enjoy their rights. Digital technologies are affecting the ways in which we work, learn, teach and live together. Unfortunately, women are not necessarily fully benefitting from this technological revolution. A recent report by the Broadband Commission, co- authored by UNESCO, concluded that the gender digital divide is actually increasing: in 2016, there were over 250 million fewer women online than men that year. Women are not only less connected, but benefit less from digital literacy and skills training, are less likely to be hired by tech companies, and often earn less than their male colleagues.
    [Show full text]
  • 6/30/21,2021 Pioneer in Tech Award Recipient Gladys West,20 Members
    News on the Radar: 6/30/21 Here is a brief round-up of information and news that crossed NCWIT’s radar recently and which we think will be of interest to you. The practices or content of the news gathered (while not endorsed or vetted by NCWIT) is meant to spark new conversations and ideas surrounding the current diversity statistics and trends in the tech workforce. We encourage you to add your two cents on this month’s topics in the comments below. Did you know that policy interventions can help improve equity in colleges and universities? A recent report by the Institute for Higher Education Policy examines policies that lead to the overrepresentation of white students at colleges and universities, particularly those institutions considered to be “selective,” and makes several recommendations for improvement. An article by Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed summarizes the report’s findings. The report points out that many of the institutions that are “best positioned to invest financially in underserved students’ success” tend to “prioritize recruiting white and affluent high schoolers.” Instead, the report suggests, “Colleges should adjust their policies on recruiting students to focus on minority students, poor students and students who may not be the colleges’ prime target.” Other recommendations include rethinking “demonstrated interest” and “early decision” policies, which have the effect of favoring students who have more resources to devote to the college application and selection process. In addition, the report recommends eliminating standardized tests, legacy admissions, and questions about applicants’ experience with the criminal justice system, all of which have the potential to reproduce systemic biases, and it encourages schools to invest more in need-based financial aid.
    [Show full text]
  • Grand Challenges for Computer Science and Engineering by Ruzena Bajcsy CITRIS Director University of California 665 Soda Hall Berkeley, CA 94720
    Grand Challenges for Computer Science and Engineering By Ruzena Bajcsy CITRIS Director University of California 665 Soda Hall Berkeley, CA 94720 I divide my position paper into two sections: 1. Computer Science: The Science of and about Information and Computation 2. Computer Engineering: The Impact on Society Computer Science: The Science of and about Information and Computation In the March, 2002 issue of Communication of the ACM, Vol. 45. No. 3, I espoused some ideas under the same title. My main point has been that while physics has the domain of inquiry into the physical world and biology has living nature, the Computer Science has its domain of inquiry: Information. The difficulty, yet at the same time, the opportunity with the Information world is that it is both synthetic and analytic. One can create synthetic worlds as in Virtual Reality, while also having measurements and reflection/models of the real world, both coming from living and non-living real worlds. So the opportunity we now have is that we can create new worlds - domains, as combinations of the measurements and synthetic data. Given the information domain of inquiry, the challenge is to find the theoretical foundations and tools that are the most suitable for this domain in order to analyze and make verifiable models? My next assertion is that these models depend on physical implementation, in which the information resides and, hence the computation is performed. The current possibilities are analog computers, discrete/digital computers and hybrid computers. Only the future will tell if we are right to reduce all our models to only one, especially digital models.
    [Show full text]
  • Cciscommuniqué Spring 2013 – 14 Volume 18 Number 4 Meet Hani! Hyun Kyung Doh by Dolly Verplank
    CCISCommuniqué Spring 2013 – 14 Volume 18 Number 4 Meet Hani! Hyun Kyung Doh by Dolly Verplank ani came to Stanford in July of 2013 were competitive to enter, well known and the two traditional songs, much to the enjoy- Hwith her husband who is a Ph.D. student supported by the government so as to maintain ment and surprise of the audience. in the Mechanical Engineering Department. the interest and practice of traditional music. Hani reports being very impressed that They live in Escondido Village. She had been For four more years, Hani continued her there are many free programs here for inter- to the U.S. once before for a short three week musical studies earning her degree at the Kore- nationals to learn English. She has benefit- vacation in Virginia. This five-year period was an National University of Arts. She performed ted from meeting with her EIA partner and to be a new adventure. with the Seoul Metropolitan Youth Traditional studying with her Palo Alto Adult School class. Music Orchestra as well as volunteering with a She describes herself as making a “really good small group of musicians “to introduce Korean adjustment” although it was hard at first. music to older citizens” in the community. Love of cooking in Korea inspired Hani to She expressed a real passion to share music take cooking classes at Bechtel. She enjoyed with those who would otherwise have little Bob Paugh’s class on American cooking. She chance to hear it. loved learning English in that context, as well What has Hani been up to since her arrival? as learning about American cookware and She has been so active--a wonderful example to typical dishes.
    [Show full text]
  • Artificial Intelligence Has Enjoyed Tre- List of Offshoot Technologies, from Time Mendous Success Over the Last Twenty five Sharing to Functional Programming
    AI Magazine Volume 26 Number 4 (2006)(2005) (© AAAI) 25th Anniversary Issue Artificial Intelligence: The Next Twenty-Five Years Edited by Matthew Stone and Haym Hirsh ■ Through this collection of programmatic state- that celebrates the exciting new work that AI ments from key figures in the field, we chart the researchers are currently engaged in. At the progress of AI and survey current and future direc- same time, we hope to help to articulate, to tions for AI research and the AI community. readers thinking of taking up AI research, the rewards that practitioners can expect to find in our mature discipline. And even if you’re a stranger to AI, we think you’ll enjoy this inside e know—with a title like that, you’re peek at the ways AI researchers talk about what expecting something awful. You’re they really do. on the lookout for fanciful prognos- W We asked our contributors to comment on tications about technology: Someday comput- goals that drive current research in AI; on ways ers will fit in a suitcase and have a whole our current questions grow out of our past re- megabyte of memory. And you’re wary of lurid sults; on interactions that tie us together as a Hollywood visions of “the day the robots field; and on principles that can help to repre- come”: A spiderlike machine pins you to the sent our profession to society at large. We have wall and targets a point four inches behind your eyes with long and disturbing spikes. Your excerpted here from the responses we received last memory before it uploads you is of it ask- and edited them together to bring out some of ing, with some alien but unmistakable existen- the most distinctive themes.
    [Show full text]
  • When and Where Will AI Meet Robotics? Issues in Representation
    Articles When and Where Will AI Meet Robotics? Issues in Representation Ruzena Bajscy and Edward W. Large I Because perception-action systems are necessarily tems and agents interacting with the physical constrained by the physics of time and space, world, but AI deals mostly with abstract prob- robotocists often assume they are best described lems that lend themselves to symbolic repre- using differential equations, a language that is spe- sentations. cialized for describing the evolution of variables The environment: Roboticists seek to that represent physical quantities. However, when design systems that function in physical envi- it comes to decision making, where the represen- tations involved refer to goals, strategies, and pref- ronments that are always changing and intrin- erences, AI offers a diverse range of formalisms to sically unpredictable. Software agents generally the modeler. However, the relationship between operate in human-designed worlds where one these two levels of representation—signal and can have some measure of control over change symbol—are not well understood. If we are to or at least an a priori knowledge of the possibil- achieve success in modeling intelligent physical ities. agents, robotics and AI must reach a new consen- The tools: AI more commonly uses discrete sus on how to integrate perception-action systems mathematics, but robotics and machine per- with systems designed for abstract reasoning. ception make use of continuous mathematics. These tools also differentiate the typical educa- n the early days of AI, robotics was an inte- tional background that characterizes the two gral part of our research effort. All our major areas: AI has more computer scientists, but IAI laboratories had research programs in robotics has more electrical and mechanical robotics in the late 1960s and early 1970s.
    [Show full text]