Postglacial Water Levels in the Great Lakes Region in Relation to Holocene Climate Change: Thecamoebian and Palynological Evidence
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Postglacial Water Levels in the Great Lakes Region in Relation to Holocene Climate Change: Thecamoebian and Palynological Evidence by Adam Patrick Sarvis, B.Sc. A thesis submitted to the Department of Earth Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science December, 2000 Brock University St. Catharines, Ontario © Adam Patrick Sarvis, 2000 Abstract Various lake phases have developed in the upper Great Lakes in response to isostatic adjustment and changes in water supply since the retreat of the Laurentide Ice Sheet. Georgian Bay experienced a lowstand that caused a basin wide unconformity approximately 7,500 years ago that cannot be explained by geological events. Thecamoebians are shelled protozoans abundant in freshwater environments and they are generally more sensitive to changing environmental conditions than the surrounding vegetation. Thecamoebians can be used to reconstruct the paleolimnology. The abundance of thecamoebians belonging to the genus Centropyxis, which are known to tolerate slightly brackish conditions (i.e. high concentrations of ions) records highly evaporative conditions in a closed basin. During the warmer interval (9000 to 700 yBP), the Centropyxis - dominated population diminishes and is replaced by an abundant and diverse Difflugia dominate population. Historical climate records from Tobermory and Midland, Ontario were correlated with the Lake Huron water level curve. The fossil pollen record and comparison with modem analogues allowed a paleo-water budget to be calculated for Georgian Bay. Transfer function analysis of fossil pollen data from Georgian Bay records cold, dry winters similar to modem day Minneapolis, Minnesota. Drier climates around this time are also recorded in bog environments in Southem Ontario - the drying of Lake Tonawanda and inception of paludification in Willoughby Bog, for instance, dates around 7,000 years ago. The dramatic impact of climate change on the water level in Georgian Bay underlines the importance of paleoclimatic research for predicting future environmental change in the Great Lakes. .....- ;,_.:;' 'if-Utiy ,-. <j "''' .',' </Zh' 'H-r.;"' . U.K. r<iif Ill Acknowledgements The last three years completing this thesis has strengthened my scientific beliefs and inner character. I have many people to thank for their contribution in allowing me to finish this thesis. First, I would personally like to thank Dr. Francine McCarthy in the Earth Sciences department for providing me the opportunity to study this unique topic on climate change and lake levels. Over the years she has shared her wisdom and experiences to broaden my field of study and understanding a graduate student lifestyle. I would like to express my gratitude to Steve Blasco of the Geological Survey of Canada (Atlantic) in providing support through the years for paleoecological research and understanding the importance of Earth Sciences at Brock University. I'm grateful for being part of an extensive research program on Georgian Bay that I hope will continue through the years. Extended gratitude and special thanks to Dr. Jock McAndrews of the Royal Ontario Museum for providing computer software and personal data to this project. The field trips to Midland and Willoughby Bog were very helpful and educational. John Menzies in the Earth Sciences department for advising me through the years. Anne Yagi of the Ministry of Natural Resources for being a secondary editor and for being there when times got tough (Thanks big sister). Special thanks to Jim Pengelly for his fime and personal resources, I enjoyed our talks about the geomorphology of the Wainfleet Bog. I hope you become passionate with your work again very soon. Kevin Gostlin, fellow graduate student in the Earth Sciences department for his advice and good times through the years. Howard Melville in the Jaan Terasmae Radiocarbon Lab in providing the dates for this study and for the lab preparation in the first year course. Mike Lozon the Department draftsman for his expertise and helpfulness in producing the diagrams for this thesis. Diane Gadoury, the Department Secretary for keeping the photocopy room open and all the little things that don't get noticed. Dr. Rick Cheel in the Earth Sciences department for providing a light-hearted atmosphere throughout the years. The librarians Colleen Beard and Sharon Barnes of the Brock University Map Library for their help with the maps and airphotos, and not charging me overdue fees. Roland Seehagel and ! >- ;:>/0 -y^ iiy.,^ --'-f, *^- V ( I. > / ^fivC/' -^.Mi .^ H-Ji IV his staff in the Machine shop at Brock University for constructing the soil probe. Dr. Keith Tinkler and Loris Gasparotto in the Geography department for their time in providing the diagram of postglacial water levels in the Niagara Region. Jim Cook of Environment Canada in 1998 for being cooperative in providing climate information for this research. The Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (N.P.C.A.) for allowing me access to their property at Willoughby Bog and Wainfleet Bog. The volunteer organization Friends of Fort Erie's Creeks (F.F.E.C.) for allowing me to pursue field work in the Wainfleet Bog during the summer of 1998. Thanks to Elmer Miskolczi, Matthew Pilato and the crew of 1998 for their passion in environmental restoration. A special recognition to the memory of Kevin Hartman and Craig Doan, two good friends who were taken from us in 1997 and loved the F.F.E.C. To my parents Fred and Helen, and the rest of my family and close friends I would especially like to thank you for putting up with my crazy moods the last three years. To my brother Fred for providing me a loan to purchase a new computer and Jerry Peters for his computer expertise. Thanks for your help. Steve Steingart and Carol Dohn for coming out with me to Willoughby Bog in 1998 at the last possible minute. Thanks. 1 997 was a dramatic year for my family and I with the passing of my grandmother Elsie. This episode of my life tested my inner strength to continue my academic career. She was beloved and her memories will be close to our hearts. To graduate and undergraduate students who have made this experience worthwhile and enjoyable in the Earth Sciences department throughout the years (Jaime Oxtobee, Peter Kryger, Jennifer Hopkins, Michael Johnson, Sandra Savage, Lee Ann Warrell, Michael Shuker, Christine March, Simon Haynes and others). Thanks. An overall thanks to the faculty and staff of the Earth Sciences department for their generosity through the years in finishing this thesis. 11 Table of Contents Abstract ii Acknowledgements iii Table of Contents v List of Figures ...viii List of Tables vi 1 .0 Introduction 11 1.1 Previous Studies on Georgian Bay 14 1 .2 Previous Studies on Willoughby Bog 17 2.0 Study Areas 17 2. Georgian Bay 17 2.2 Willoughby Bog 22 3.0 Georgian Bay Background Information 22 3.1 Climate of the Great Lakes 22 3.1.1 Climate of Georgian Bay 26 3.2 Vegetation and Soils of Georgian Bay 28 3.3 Hydrology of Georgian Bay 29 3.4 Geology of Georgian Bay 32 3.5 Geomorphology and Quaternary Geology of Georgian Bay 32 4.0 Willoughby Bog Background Information 35 4.1 Climate of Willoughby Bog 35 4.2 Vegetation and Soils of Willoughby Bog 36 4.3 Hydrology of Willoughby Bog 37 4.4 Geology and Geomorphology of Willoughby Bog 37 5.0 Postglacial History of the Late Wisconsinan Period in the Great Lakes Basin 38 5.1 Glacio-Isostasy in the Great Lakes 46 6.0 Palynology 47 6. Palynology and Wetland Environments 49 6.2 Palynology and Lake Environments 50 6.3 Transfer functions 50 6.4 Holocene Climate of Southern Ontario 52 .!.,'' 1 1 VI 7.0 Thecamoebians 55 7. 1 Problems of Thecamoebians as Paleoecological Indicators 58 8.0 Methodology 60 8.1 Field Methods 60 8.1.1 Georgian Bay 60 8.1.2 Willoughby Bog 63 8.2 Laboratory Methods 68 8.2. Stratigraphy and Thermal Analysis (LOI) 68 8.2.1.1 Georgian Bay 68 8.2.1.2 Willoughby Bog 68 8.2.2 Pollen Analysis and transfer functions 69 8.2.2.1 Georgian Bay • 69 8.2.2.2 Willoughby Bog 69 8.2.3 Thecamoebitm Analysis 73 8.2.3.1 Georgian Bay 73 8.2.3.2 Willoughby Bog 73 8.3 Water Budget Modeling 74 9.0 Results 76 9. 1 Georgian Bay 76 9.1.1 LH95-035(Manitoulin Island) 76 9.1.1.1 Transfer functions 76 9. 1 . 1 .2 Thecamoebians 78 9.1.2 LH95-038(Manitoulin Island) 78 9. 1 .2. Transfer functions 78 9. 1 .2.2 Thecamoebians 80 9.1.3 LH95-041 (Tobermory) 80 9. 1 .3. Transfer functions 80 9. 1 .3.2 Thecamoebians 82 9.1.4 97802-020 (Severn Sound) 82 9. 1 .4. Transfer functions 82 9.1.4.2 Thecamoebians 82 9. 1 .4.3 Loss-on-ignition 84 ' v 1 Vll 9.1.5 97802-026 (Severn Sound) 84 9. 1 .5. Transfer functions 84 9. 1 .5.2 Thecamoebians 86 9. 1 .5.3 Loss-on-ignition 86 9.1.6 97802-032 (Severn Sound) 87 9. 1 .6. Transfer functions 87 9. 1 .6.2 Thecamoebians 87 9. 1 .6.3 Loss-on-ignition 87 9.1.7 97802-035 (Severn Sound) 87 9. 1 .7. Transfer fiinctions 87 9. 1 .7.2 Thecamoebians 91 9. 1 .7.3 Loss-on-ignition 91 9.1.8 97802-036 (Severn Sound) 92 9.1.8.1 Transfer functions 92 9. 1 .8.2 Thecamoebians 92 9. 1 .8.3 Loss-on-ignition 92 9.1.9 Transfer functions from Wye Marsh, Porqui Pond and Shouldice Lake 92 9.2 Modem Water Budget for Georgian Bay 94 9.2.1 Historical Climate Records for Georgian Bay 95 9.2.2 Problems with the Georgian Bay Water Budget 100 9.3 Willoughby Bog 101 9.3.1 WB4 (Channel Environment) 101 9.3.1.1 Palynology 101 9.3.