The Master of the Mediaş Altarpiece Painting: The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Résumé. Le retable de chœur de l'église Sainte-Marguerite de Mediaş, avec ses huit scènes du cycle de la Passion du Sauveur peintes à l’extérieur de ses ailes, est THE MASTER OF THE MEDIAŞ considéré comme un ensemble d'importance ALTARPIECE PAINTING: primordiale de l'art médiéval de THE MONOGRAMMIST MSP – THE Transylvanie, et c’est l'une des études de cas du projet de recherche du consortium ARTISTIC CONTEXT AND HIS WORKSHOP composé par plusieurs institutions de recherche de Bucarest et de Cluj, contexte dans lequel nous avons eu l'occasion de passer en revue les informations bibliographiques existantes, qui serront corroborées avec les résultats des recherches multidisciplinaires envisagées. Keywords: Mediaş, Transylvania, Dana Jenei Nuremberg, Vienna, altarpiece, painting, engravings. Wappenprozession, a typical decorative The retable from the choir of program, which here includes wooden St. Margaret’s Church in Mediaş, with its shields at the intersection of the ribs that, Passion Cycle of eight scenes preserved on although evidently repainted, permit the the outer faces of the wings, is considered identification of the heraldry, the most an ensemble of prime importance for the important arms being those of Matthias late medieval art in Transylvania, and is Corvinus from 1487, confirming Soterius’ 2 one of the case studies of the consortium information . Similar wooden painted research project developed by several escutcheons, but illustrating the Credo research institutions from Bucharest and theme, decorate the choir networked-vault Cluj-Napoca. It is in this context that the and reflect the assimilation of heraldry present study reviews existing work on the within late medieval religious monumental altarpiece that in due course will be art3. reinforced by the results of the In the same late phase of construction, multidisciplinary investigations envisaged1. the main altarpiece of the church was created as a Gothic polyptych retable-type, * a Wandelaltar with “hidden architecture”, The church was decorated during being one of the few pieces of late fifteenth several phases of construction, the last one century date preserved in situ and completed in 1488, during the reign of conceived in relation to the space of the Matthias Corvinus (1458–1490), as choir for which it was created, being specified by Georgius Soterius in his connected with the mensa4. It has an Historia Transilvaniae, at the beginning of elongated crowning formed by three the eighteenth century. In addition to the canopies for statues decorated by phinials, older artistic components from c. 1420, that fleurons and coat of arms, a central shrine are themselves superimposed over earlier adorned with a frieze of gilded Gothic elements, fragmentary mural scenes from tracery at the top, fixed and mobile panels, the end of the fifteenth century are and a shrine-type predella that shelters preserved, while the vaults of the nave and another smaller supporting plinth, deriving the southern aisle were embellished with a from a different later piece. This hybrid REV. ROUM. HIST. ART, Série BEAUX-ARTS, TOME LVI, P. 3–18, BUCAREST, 2019 3 conformation, still preserved to this day, Gisela Richter discerned four scenes from was noted by Victor Roth, the first the Life of the Virgin: the Annunciation, researcher to analyse the piece at the the Visitation, the Nativity and the beginning of the twentieth century5. Adoration of the Magi. In the only The altar was the first of its kind to be photography of the altar preserved before restored in Gisela Richter’s workshop in those interventions which radically Brașov in 1972–1973, from whose archive, modified the feast part, one can see the preserved today in Sibiu (Begegnungs- und dividing horizontal line of the figurative Kulturzentrum Friedrich Teutsch), comes a part of the representation and the upper photograph showing the condition of the part-gilded background, the horizon line9. piece before the interventions, with the Only landscape forms are discernible in the transformed inner faces of the wings, and a case of the first panel, but in the second, the later statuary group representing the shape of a roof visible is indeed in keeping Crucifixion, replacing the original statues with that of the stable in the Nativity scene. of the central shrine. Their impression is No contours of the characters are visible to preserved on the gilded background, and confirm the accurate determination of would most likely have consisted of the scenes, but further investigation may well Virgin Mary with the Child between two verify this suggestion. A major merit of the female saints, one of whom would certainly restoration of 1972–1973 was that it have been Margaret, the spiritual patron of brought to light the figures of the two the church. At that stage of the restoration, donors on the wings of the predella10. the original four niches of the predella were The rear of the altarpiece, artfully also reconstructed, the golden background painted, preserves in its entirety the vegetal imitating a curtain with a fold behind each ensemble of Grünerankmalerei type, amongst figure, on which could be discerned which the Master of Mediaş has hidden his impressions of the four statues that may have MSP monogram11. represented the four evangelists or the four The Passion Cycle that decorates the doctors of the Catholic Church6. eight panels of the week part presents in the In 1984, statues were installed in the upper register The Arrest, the Flagellation, rebuilt niches, but removed within the last the Crowning with Thorns, the Ecce homo decade, when the latest restoration work and, in the lower register, the Carrying of brought this part of the altarpiece back to the the Cross, Rast Christi, the Crucifixion and form of the first recording, including the the Resurrection. small later sixteenth-century predella, taken The first scholars to discuss the paintings from a secondary altarpiece in the church7. indicated Martin Schongauer’s engravings as The restoration of the 1970s also removed graphic sources of the figurative scenes, the colonettes attached in the Baroque era opinion advanced by Victor Roth in 1907, and created the new look of the outer part of taken up by Virgil Vătăşianu in 1959, and the panels, each one being centrally fitted further developed by Otto Folberth in the with one of the four symbols of the monograph he devoted to the polyptych in evangelists, carved in relief, in a quadrilobe 197312. In 1979, however, Dietmar Priebisch medallion8. The decorative painted pointed out that seven of the eight panels of background imitates a brocade cloth with the altar are actually based on the engravings diagonal lines that intersect and form of Israhel van Meckenem, which were either rhombs, adorned alternately with lilies, other copied in detail, interpreted, modified or stylised flowers, vases, and eagles around St. completed with elements taken from other John the Evangelist’s symbol. works. The Crucifixion scene was created by Victor Roth showed that initially the the Master of the Mediaş Altarpiece, by intrados of the mobile panels had been assembling details taken from various 13 4 decorated with flat carved reliefs, in which sources . * literally transposes the design (B VI.207.11), representing the Kiss of Judas Israhel van Meckenem of Bocholt (c. at its centre. In the lower left, Peter, the 1445–1503) was one of the most prolific first of the three apostles who witnessed German engravers of the late fifteenth Jesus’s prayer in the Garden of century, and around 600 of his engravings Gethsemane, raises the sword against survive14. His oeuvre represents Gothic Malchus, while in the distance, Jacob and Mannerism par excellence, characterized by John the Evangelist are shown leaving the stylized and conventional figures, whose enclosure hastily by a side-gate. elegant and studied postures, undermine the The Flagellation copies Van Meckenem’s drama of the Passion Cycle scenes. engraving in the smallest details (B According to Geisberg, the first scholar to VI.207.13), including the secondary scene devote serious attention to his life and work, with Jesus before Herod. Van Meckenem, a goldsmith by training, The Crowning with Thorns, with the worked before 1470 with the Master of the Mocking of Christ in the depth plane (B Berlin Passion and with Master E. S. in the Konstanz area, who influenced him in VI.207.15) is the first example of a Van technique and style. Van Meckenem Meckenem composition which has been produced many copies after their work, altered, here by the substitution of a soldier “retouching” them, and even intervening in kneeling in front of Christ, offering him a certain cases directly onto the plates. In the reed as a sceptre with one hand, and holding his hat in the other, a character taken from an middle of his activity, he copied Martin 17 Schongauer’s works and, at its end, he was engraving by Martin Schongauer . inspired by the compositions of the In the Ecce homo scene, Christ is Housebook Master, Hans Holbein the Elder, presented to the agitated crowd that clamours and Albrecht Dürer. for him to be crucified. In the distance, under His engravings served as the models for the arch of the back of the pretorium, is several Gothic artworks such as the altar represented the apocryphal episode of painted by the Meister des Jahreszahlen in Claudia Procula, Pilate’s wife, who asks him 1486 (Warszawa, Muzeum Narodowe), an to spare Jesus’s life; the scene also copies 18 artist trained in Nuremberg and known to Van Meckenem’s engraving (B VI.207.16) . have worked in collaboration with Sebald The Carrying of the Cross was the most Pleydenwurff at Eisleben in 147115. His impressing image for the religious sensitivity work has been already noticed in connexion of the Late Western Middle Ages, referring with the Mediaş altarpiece16.