Considering a Progressive Possibility for Alternative Schools. (2014) Directed by Dr
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GREENE, DEBORAH A., Ph.D. An Alternative to the Alternatives: Considering a Progressive Possibility for Alternative Schools. (2014) Directed by Dr. Silvia Bettez. 242 pp. This dissertation is an exploration of alternative schools that are offered to students who might otherwise be kicked out or drop out of public schools. I examine the more traditional options offered by public school systems, as well as more unusual schools that offer a democratic education. My primary research question is: How can a high school create an engaging education around the values of peace and justice? After a discussion of my methods and how they have changed over the course of this project, I look at the history of democratic and progressive schooling, and compare and contrast that history with contemporary practices in public school. Then I look at the philosophy underlying school practices and policy. I examine how neoliberalist policies impact schools today, and then envision the philosophy of an alternative school that better serve students who do not experience success in more traditional public schools. From there I explore current practices, both in traditional schools and in schools that aim to provide a democratic education for students. I look at the benefits of providing an authentic, democratic, multicultural education that incorporates social justice and what I term spirit- learning, which aims to offer tools to students so that they learn how to create peace in their own, personal lives as they learn to work towards creating peace in their communities and in the world they will inherit. AN ALTERNATIVE TO THE ALTERNATIVES: CONSIDERING A PROGRESSIVE POSSIBILITY FOR ALTERNATIVE SCHOOLS by Deborah A. Greene A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of The Graduate School at The University of North Carolina at Greensboro in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Greensboro 2014 Approved by ____________________________ Committee Chair APPROVAL PAGE This dissertation written by DEBORAH A. GREENE has been approved by the following committee of the Faculty of The Graduate School at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro. Committee Chair. ___________________________________ Committee Members. ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ___________________________________ ____________________________ Date of Acceptance by Committee __3/17/2014_______________ Date of Final Oral Examination ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................1 Background ..................................................................................................1 Statement of the Problem .............................................................................2 Values ..........................................................................................................9 Redefining Success and the Purpose of Education ....................................16 Moving Forward ........................................................................................20 II. METHODS ..........................................................................................................21 Research Questions ....................................................................................21 Paradigmatic Framework ...........................................................................22 Qualitative Research ..................................................................................27 Theoretical Research ..................................................................................50 One Final Note about Methods ..................................................................52 III. A BRIEF HISTORY OF DEMOCRATIC AND PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION ..................................................................................................54 Early Thinkers and Experimenters.............................................................54 Activist Education ......................................................................................60 Public Schools as Sites for Brainwashing and Other Possibilities ............65 Contemporary Thought and Practice .........................................................68 Re-envisioning Education ..........................................................................76 In the Shadows ...........................................................................................80 IV. PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION - PRACTICED AND IDEAL ......................85 Neoliberalism .............................................................................................87 Philosophy of a Progressive Alternative School ......................................104 Starting with the End ...............................................................................132 iii V. CONTEMPORARY PRACTICES: TRUE ALTERNATIVES AND ALTERNATIVES IN NAME ONLY .........................................................134 Alternatives in Name Only ......................................................................135 Progressive Alternatives ..........................................................................149 Lessons Learned.......................................................................................187 VI. A VISION FOR A PROGRESSIVE ALTERNATIVE .....................................192 The Problem with the Status Quo ............................................................192 Bringing it all Together ............................................................................197 Final Thoughts .........................................................................................220 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................225 iv CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Background After teaching in the public school system for over ten years, my ideas about education and the role of educators have transformed dramatically. I had come to public school after teaching Freshman Composition in local colleges, and I had little experience in considering a variety of teaching methods, “classroom management,” or “data-driven” instruction. As a Freshman Composition instructor, my ability as a teacher was never challenged, and I felt competent and even successful, despite my inexperience and lack of instruction in various methods or learning styles. When I started teaching in the public school system, I suffered from major culture shock. College students seemed either more open-minded, or simply more willing to go along with the education we provided. They had been more or less successful thus far, and intended to graduate from college and move on to professional work. In contrast, my high school students mistrusted me, doubted the value of what I “taught,” and the climate felt antagonistic, even though I went in with an open-minded attitude. When I began teaching high school students, I was assigned to teach “CP English 11,” which meant American Literature. “CP” meant “College Prep,” so I assumed that my students intended to go to college, and I treated them that way, giving tough reading 1 assignments and assuming they read challenging articles with a dictionary on hand to look up unfamiliar words. My students complained that I worked them too hard. “We’re CP,” they’d tell me. Not yet recognizing that in educational jargon words tend to mean the opposite of what the actual words mean, I asked, “Doesn’t that mean you plan to go to college?” I asked. “No,” they explained. “It means we’re the dumb ones.” I was stunned into silence. I felt sad that they identified themselves as dumb, and also confused that the label “College Prep” told the students that they were dumb. Why prepare to go to college if you’ve been classified as “dumb?” I had a lot to learn. My first few years in the high school classroom were filled with despair. For the majority of my students, school was boring and a constant power struggle. Despite all the courses that I had since taken in order to receive my certification, despite all I had learned about lesson planning, learning styles, and teaching reading and writing, I couldn’t bring my students along with me. I felt like dropping out, myself. At the same time, I was growing more convinced that my struggles had less to do with my individual traits and abilities as a teacher, and less to do with my specific students, but more to do with the public school culture. I could see that what we were expected to teach, despite our school mantra: “Rigor, relationships, and relevance” was irrelevant to students, and they had no power to do anything about it but submit or resist. Statement of the Problem The problem I intend to explore is ultimately a question of how to make education an experience that young people enjoy and find valuable while simultaneously preparing them to create a peaceful, just, and sustainable world. Our current educational system 2 prepares young people for a world of competition with only one right answer. I suspect that many students know that what they learn in school does not reflect reality or prepare them for a successful future. One of the participants in my research, LeLe (all names are pseudonyms) said that school is not preparing her for the future. She explained: ’Cause it’s like after elementary school and middle school, you stop basically learning things you’ll ever need, and they basically tell you that in math, like, ‘You’re not really gonna