Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

For discussion TFKT/05/2018 On 29 March 2018

Proposed Rezoning of the Site from “Other Specified Uses” annotated “Tunnel Ventilation Shaft” and “Government, Institution or Community” to “Commercial (9)” Zone at Nos. 3-5 San Ma Tau Street, ,

PURPOSE

This paper seeks Members’ view on the proposed rezoning of the Site at 3-5 San Ma Tau Street (Plan 1) from “Other Specified Uses” annotated “Tunnel Ventilation Shaft” (“OU”) and “Government, Institution or Community” (“G/IC”) to “Commercial (9)” (“C(9)”) zone to enable the proposed commercial / office development. In particular, the Proponent wishes to seek Members’ view on the planning and design of proposed development in terms of, inter alia, land use compatibility, urban design context, visual impact and the improved connectivity between the harbourfront and inner / Ma Tau Kok Area.

BACKGROUND

2. The Site concerned is about 2,038.09m2 in site area. It is bounded by two sections of San Ma Tau Street to its northeast and southwest, to its northwest and Ferry Pier (“KCFP”) Bus Terminus to its immediate southeast. The Site is surrounded by mainly residential development with some industrial development mainly found along To Kwa Wan Road.

3. The Site is zoned “OU” and “G/IC” on the Draft Kai Tak Outline Zoning Plan (“Draft OZP”) No. S/K22/5. Thin strips of the Site along both the north-eastern and south-eastern Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018 boundaries area deemed to fall within the “G/IC” zone due to a discrepancy between the zoning and lot boundaries (Plan 2). The planning intention of the “OU” zone is “primarily for tunnel ventilation shaft use”. Redevelopment of existing industrial building for commercial/office development is neither a column 1 or 2 uses for “OU” or “G/IC” zones, hence rezoning of the Site to “C(9)” is required.

4. The Site falls within area reserved for the alignment of Central Kowloon Route (“CKR”) that serves to link up West Kowloon with East Kowloon as shown on the Draft OZP (Plan 2).

PROPOSED USE

5. The Site is currently occupied by a 11- (including G/F) industrial building, namely Lucky Building completed in 1961.

6. The proposed development comprises one commercial tower with 25 nos. of storeys including G/F and 2 levels of basement and the building height is +100mPD. The total non-domestic GFA of the proposed development is not more than 24,457.08m2. Retail / dining facilities, loading/unloading bays for goods vehicles and E&M facilities will be provided at G/F to 4/F while carparking spaces will be accommodated at the two basement levels. Office floor spaces will be provided from 5/F to 22/F.

7. Taking into account the frequent use of the informal pedestrian walkway, the proposed development has offered a setback of 1.5m along the southeastern boundary to enable the widening of the informal pedestrian alley sandwiched between the existing Lucky Industrial Building and the planter maintained by Leisure and Cultural Services Department. Together with the existing pedestrian alley (about 1m in width), the total width of the

Page 2

Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018 pedestrian walkway will be widened from 1m to 2.5m (Plan 3). A minimum of 1m setback has also been provided on the G/F of the proposed development at the southwestern boundary for widening of footpath along San Ma Tau Street to cater for future additional pedestrian flow (Plan 3).

8. The KCFP Terminus will be re-instated upon the completion of the Central Kowloon Route. The new public transport interchange will be decked over by a landscape deck for the enjoyment of the public. To strengthen and enhance the accessibility and connection between the KCFP, the Site and the inner Ma Tau Kok / To Kwa Wan Area, a connection point for the provision of a possible future footbridge linking the Site with the landscape deck under CKR has been reserved at 2/F of the proposed development (Plan 4). The connection point and detailed design of the footbridge are subject to the approval of relevant Government Departments at later stage of the development.

9. The Architectural Scheme together with the corresponding development parameters and the Landscape Master Plan are appended at Annex A and Annex B respectively.

HARBOUR PLANNING PRINCIPLES

10. We consider that the proposal aligns with the Harbour Planning Principles in the following aspects -

(a) Preserving Victoria Harbour

The proposed development does not involve any reclamation nor destruction to the harbour. Victoria Harbour is preserved as a natural asset to the public. The proposed development is considered not visually incompatible with the existing developments when

Page 3

Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018

viewed from the harbourfront areas including Hoi Sham Park, and Park.

(b) Stakeholder Engagement

During the 3-week public consultation period, all relevant stakeholders can make comments to the S12A Planning Application. The comments received will be thoroughly considered by the Proponent and incorporated into the development proposal as far as possible.

(c) Sustainable Development and Integrated Planning

The proposed development aims to cater for the economic, social and environmental needs of society and are compatible with the harbourfront setting. The retail, dining facilities and office floor spaces would help to achieve a balanced mix of land uses in the predominately residential neighbourhood and provide local job opportunities. The proposed landscape viewing deck would offer a public space for recreational and leisure uses for the enjoyment of the public. The proposed linkage of the development with the landscape deck under CKR will help to integrate with the waterfront promenade as well as the future commercial and dining service node at KCFP.

Various technical assessments have been conducted and the results revealed that the proposed scheme is technically feasible. Moreover, the building height of the proposed development of +100mPD is the same as that of or lower than the surrounding development. Setback of the office tower from San Ma Tau Street (15m or above) as compared with existing industrial building has also enhanced the visual permeability as viewed

Page 4

Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018

from the waterfront.

(d) Proactive Harbour Enhancement The proposed building height will be in keeping with the building height of the surrounding development. A stepped height profile will be formed from Grand Waterfront (+175.535mPD) to the proposed development (+100mPD) and Wyler Gardens (+49.8mPD) to promote visual interest and create an interesting harbour image. With special architectural articulations and distinctive roof-top features, the proposed development has the potential of becoming the landmark building in the area with recognized features to signify the prominent image of the waterfront locality.

(e) Vibrant Harbour and Public Enjoyment

The proposed landscape viewing deck at the proposed development together with the Ma Tau Kok waterfront promenade beautification proposal and the possible commercial and dining node at the KCFP, there would be a great opportunity to revitalize the area surrounding the Site. Retail and dining facilities will be provided at the proposed development for public enjoyment and enhance the liveliness and vibrancy of the waterfront area. The proposed development will bring about diversity in land uses and offer opportunities for on-street pedestrian activities to add life and vitality to the harbour.

(f) Accessible Harbour

The proposed development will enhance the connectivity between Kai Tak waterfront promenade and inner To Kwa Wan / Ma Tau Kok Area by i) setting

Page 5

Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018

back of the development by 1.5m along the southeastern boundary for widening of the existing informal pedestrian walkway from 1m to 2.5m; ii) setting back of the development by minimum of 1m on G/F along the southwestern boundary for widening of the footpath along San Ma Tau Street; and iii) the provision of a possible connection point at the proposed development for a footbridge linkage to the future landscape deck under the CKR project. The three proposals will create great synergy and provide better connectivity to attract people to the harbour.

WAY FORWARD

11. If the proposal is approved by the , subsequent lease modification application and building plan submission will be made to the relevant Government Departments for approval. The project is expected to complete in year 2024.

VIEWS SOUGHT

12. Members are invited to express their views on the above project

Page 6

Task Force on Kai Tak Harbourfront Development

TFKT/05/2018

ATTACHMENTS

Plan 1 Site Location Plan Plan 2 Zoning Context Plan Plan 3 Pedestrian Access Improvement Along Site’s Southeastern and Southwestern Boundaries Plan 4 Possible Connection Point to the Future CKR Landscape Deck

Annex A Master Layout Plan and Development Schedule Annex B Landscape Master Plan

Kenneth To & Associates Limited March 2018

Page 7

Key Development Data of the Proposed Development

Key Parameters Site Area 2,038.09 m2 Plot Ratio 12.0 Maximum GFA (Non- Not more than 24,457.08 m2 domestic) ƒ Retail / Eating Place Not more than 5,978.49 m2 ƒ Office Not more than 18,478.59 m2 No. of Storey 23 storeys (including G/F) and 2 levels of basement Building Height at Main Roof 100mPD Maximum Site Coverage Not more than 62.5% (15m or above) No. of Block 1 Open Space Not less than 1,600 m2 Carparking Spaces ƒ Private Car 118 nos. ƒ Motorcycle 11 nos. ƒ Loading/Unloading Bays 8 nos. (LGV) 4 nos. (HGV)

PLANTER

PV PANEL LAWN PLANTER

LAWN

PLANTER A/C PLANT AREA

LAWN PROPOSED FOOTBRIDGE CONNECTING TO FUTURE CKR LANDSCAPE DECK

MASTER LAYOUT PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright CP98

CP99 CP60 CP61 CP62 CP63 CP64 CP65 CP66

CP97 CP100 RAMP UP TO B1 1:20 CP67

CP96 CP101 CP68

CP95 CP102 CP118 CP117 CP69

CP103

CP94 CP104 CP70

CP93 CP105 CP71

1:20

RAMP E/M LOBBY CP116 CP92 CP106 CP72

1:20

RAMP

CP107

CP91 CP73

CP90 CP115 CP74 CP108 CP109 CP110 CP111 CP112 CP113 CP114

CP89 CP75 RAMP 1:20 CP88 CP76

CP87 CP86 CP85 CP84 CP83 CP82 CP81 CP80 CP79 CP78 CP77

B2/F PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright CP39 CP40 CP41 CP42 CP43 CP01 CP02 CP03 CP04 CP05 CP06 CP07

RAMP DN TO B1 RAMP UP TO GROUND CP38 1:20 1:20 CP08

CP37 CP09 CP45 CP44 CP36 CP10 CP46

CP47

CP35 CP11 CP48

CP34 CP12 CP49 E/M LOBBY CP59 CP33 CP13

1:20 1:20 RAMP CP50 RAMP

CP32 CP14

CP31 CP58 CP15 CP51 CP52 CP53 CP54 CP55 CP56 CP57

CP30 CP16 RAMP 1:20 CP29 CP17

CP28 CP27 CP26 CP25 CP24 CP23 CP22 CP21 CP20 CP19 CP18

B1/F PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright 07 MAR 2018 SCALE 1 : 250 DATE: APPR.: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg Copyright c JOB NO.: CAD REF: DRG. NO.: A GROUND FLOOR PLAN HGV-1 HGV-2 HGV-4 HGV-3 LIFT LOBBY CP01 SAN MA TAU STREET

M06 B B M05 M11 M10 LGV-8 M04 LGV-6 LGV-7 M03 M02 M01 PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON

LGV-5

1:20 RAMP LGV-4 LGV-1 LGV-3 LGV-2

M09 M08 M07

A KAPOK INDUSTRIAL BUILDING INDUSTRIAL KAPOK RETAIL

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

RETAIL

1/F PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright RETAIL

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

RETAIL

POSSIBLE FUTURE CONNECTION TO FUTURE CKR LANDSCAPE DECK

LAWN

2/F PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright RETAIL

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

RETAIL

LAWN

3/F PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright B

OFFICE

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

OFFICE

4-16/F FLOOR PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright B

OFFICE

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

OFFICE

17 & 18 FLOOR PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright B

OFFICE

DIS.

LIFT AHU LOBBY

E/M E/M

OFFICE

19 - 23 FLOOR PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright B

PLANTER

DIS.

LIFT LAWN LOBBY PLANTER

E/M E/M LAWN

PLANTER A/C PLANT AREA

ROOF PLAN SCALE 1 : 250

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 07 MAR 2018 CAD REF: ...\20180307\Model\GF.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright +100.0 mPD R/F

22/F OFFICE

21/F OFFICE

20/F OFFICE

19/F OFFICE

18/F OFFICE

17/F OFFICE

16/F OFFICE

15/F OFFICE

14/F OFFICE

13/F OFFICE

OFFICE B.L. 12/F B.L.

11/F OFFICE @4.05 X 18 STOREYS = 72.85M

OFFICE 95.9m 10/F OFFICE 9/F

8/F OFFICE OFFICE 7/F MIN. 1500 OFFICE 6/F SET-BACK AREA FOR PEDESTRIAN ON GROUND LEVEL 5/F OFFICE RETAIL MERIT INDUSTRIAL CENTRE KAPOK 4/F 4.05 INDUSTRIAL 3/F RETAIL

BUILDING 4.05 RETAIL

2/F 4.55

1/F RETAIL 4.55 TO KWA WAN ROAD BUS TERMINUS +4.5 SHOP +4.1 G/F L/UL LOBBY 5.85

B1 CARPARK +0.6 3.5

B2 CARPARK -2.9 3.5

DIAGRAMMATIC SECTION A-A SCALE 1 : 500

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 14 JULY 2017 CAD REF: ...\20161004\Model\Section.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright +100.0 mPD R/F

22/F OFFICE

21/F OFFICE

20/F OFFICE

19/F OFFICE

18/F OFFICE

17/F OFFICE

16/F OFFICE

15/F OFFICE

14/F OFFICE

13/F OFFICE

OFFICE B.L. 12/F B.L.

11/F OFFICE @4.05 X 18 STOREYS = 72.85M

OFFICE 95.9m 10/F OFFICE 9/F

8/F OFFICE

7/F OFFICE GRAND WATERFRONT OFFICE 6/F

5/F OFFICE POSSIBLE FUTURE CONNECTION TO FUTURE CKR LANDSCAPE DECK RETAIL 4/F 4.05

3/F RETAIL 4.05 RETAIL

2/F 4.55

1/F RETAIL 4.55 SAN MA TAU STREET SAN MA TAU STREET +4.1 +4.4 G/F L/UL LOBBY L/UL 5.85

B1 CARPARK +0.6 3.5

B2 CARPARK -2.9 3.5

DIAGRAMMATIC SECTION B-B SCALE 1 : 500

PROPOSED COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AT JOB NO.: DATE: 14 JULY 2017 CAD REF: ...\20161004\Model\Section.dwg SAN MA TAU STREET, TO KA WAN, KOWLOON DRG. NO.: APPR.: c Copyright PLANTINGS AT 11/F OFFICE