Historic Landscapes Beautiful and Challenging from the PRESIDENT STARTERS
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2017 PRESERVATION WINNERS Servaas Award & Williamson Prize EXPLORERS ALERT Check out historic places on tours Historic Landscapes Beautiful and challenging FROM THE PRESIDENT STARTERS BOARD OF DIRECTORS Eli Lilly (1885-1977), Founder OFFICERS Cheri Dick Zionsville Hon. Randall T. Shepard Honorary Chairman Julie Donnell Fort Wayne World’s Fair James P. Fadely Chairman Jeremy D. Efroymson IN MIDDLEBURY, GIANT TOADSTOOLS and a miniature windmill Saving the Spectacular Indianapolis Carl A. Cook adorn an unusual landscape. You might be thinking kitschy ‘70s putt- Past Chairman Gregory S. Fehribach AMONG MY SUMMER READING was Lost Mansions of Indianapolis Parker Beauchamp putt course, but the garden dates back more than 84 years. Krider Mississippi (Mary Carol Miller, University of Mississippi Press, Vice Chairman Sanford E. Garner Nurseries was a thriving mail order business in 1933 when Vernon Indianapolis 1996). It’s a sad tale from page one as the title forewarns. All of Marsh Davis President Judith A. Kanne Krider spotted a golden marketing opportunity in the Century of Rensselaer the splendid landmarks in this book are gone, victims of fire, Sara Edgerton Progress International Exposition, a.k.a. the Chicago World’s Fair. He Secretary/Assistant Treasurer Christine H. Keck flood, Civil War, and just plain neglect. Evansville installed an elaborate garden at the fair and netted around 200,000 Thomas H. Engle Remarkably, some of these mansions survived until recent Assistant Secretary Matthew R. Mayol, AIA new mail-order customers. When the expo closed in 1934, he moved Indianapolis years only to be lost, not to disasters but to abandonment and Brett D. McKamey and rebuilt the garden back in Middlebury where today it is a park Treasurer Sharon Negele Attica disinvestment. As I read, I could not help wondering how in H. Roll McLaughlin, FAIA beloved by locals and connoisseurs of distinctive places. The Krider Chairman Emeritus Cheryl Griffith Nichols Shop for modern times such places were allowed to disintegrate. Where Little Rock, AR “World’s Fair” Garden is just one of many hidden gems featured an Judy A. O’Bannon were the laws and strategies and techniques advanced by Secretary Emerita Martin E. Rahe upcoming book by Indiana Landmarks and IU Press. a Cause Cincinnati, OH historic preservation advocates at the time these Mississippi J. Reid Williamson, Jr. President Emeritus James W. Renne ooking for the mansions were lost? It didn’t take much reflection to realize Newburgh perfect gift for DIRECTORS George A. Rogge this problem is not unique to Mississippi. Gary family or friend? Hilary Barnes Consider the challenges we face in Indiana. Our 2017 10 Most Indianapolis Eric Rowland LSoon you’ll be able to Indianapolis Endangered list includes two spectacular mansions—Newkirk Katrina Basile Indianapolis Doris Anne Sadler shop online for a mix and Speakman. They stand in desperate need of preservation Indianapolis Elaine E. Bedel of the vintage-inspired and embody the complicated stew Indiana Landmarks faces Indianapolis Matthew G. Stegall Richmond products you’ll find in Steven Campbell daily in striving to save such places. That stew’s ingredients Indianapolis Brad Toothaker South Bend our brick-and-mortar include soft real estate markets, private property concerns, Edward D. Clere New Albany Jane T. Walker Landmarks Emporium property valuations, foreclosures, and—of course—the costs Indianapolis shops in the French of rehabilitation. Lick and West Baden OFFICES & HISTORIC SITES Tough challenges, indeed. But I am confident, with your Springs hotels. Bonus: support and the dedication of Indiana Landmarks, that we can Headquarters Southeast Field Office when you shop, your find viable solutions. Our goal, which I’m sure you share, is Indiana Landmarks Center Aurora 1201 Central Avenue 812 926 0983 purchases help us to ensure that a future generation will not ask why we, in our Indianapolis, IN 46202 Southwest Field Office [email protected] Evansville save meaningful time, failed to save these grand Indiana landmarks, and that if 317 639 4534 812 423 2988 800 450 4534 places across the or when someone publishes a Lost Mansions of Indiana, it will Western Regional Office Northwest Field Office Terre Haute state! Keep an eye on Gary 812 232 4534 be the slimmest possible of volumes. 219 947 2657 Huddleston Farmhouse indianalandmarks.org Central Regional Office Cambridge City for details. Indianapolis 765 478 3172 317 639 4534 LEE LEWELLEN Morris-Butler House Eastern Regional Office Indianapolis Cambridge City 317 639 4534 765 478 3172 Veraestau just-off-the-line Fords carried dignitaries Marsh Davis, President Northern Regional Office Aurora South Bend 812 926 0983 in a procession from Meridian Street 574 232 4534 French Lick and West just north of Monument Circle to the Northeast Field Office Baden Springs tours Wabash 866 571 8687 (toll free) new Ford Motor Company Assembly 800 450 4534 812 936 5870 plant on East Washington Street Southern Regional Office Jeffersonville during the Indianapolis Automobile 812 284 4534 Show in 1915. See the factory where A Pompeiian garden inspired Arthur Shurcliff’s design of the formal ©2017, Indiana Landmarks; ISSN#: 0737-8602 the cars were made, a former 10 Most On the garden at Columbus’s Irwin House. Recent renovation takes its cue Indiana Landmarks publishes Indiana Preservation bimonthly Cover from the original design. BY PAIGE WASSEL for members. To join and learn other membership benefits, Endangered site, in its “before” state visit indianalandmarks.org or contact memberships@ on November 11 (details on p. 7). indianalandmarks.org, 317-639-4534 or 800-450-4534. To offer suggestions forIndiana Preservation, contact editor@ PHOTO © FORD MOTOR COMPANY ARCHIVES indianalandmarks.org. 2 INDIANA PRESERVATION 350 indianalandmarks.org 3 AWARD WINNERS HAND expanded its presence on ABOVE, CENTER: She recalls the Circle Theatre designation as a challenge. the block, tackling a late-nineteenth Hamilton County “We had to convince decision-makers that the building could Honoring Heritage Defenders Area Neighborhood century building across the street that Development won a have a positive impact and a new use. Believe it or not, it was NEARLY 30 YEARS AGO, FOUNTAIN COUNTY ABOVE, LEFT: 2016, adding more field trips to local had been vacant 10 years. The awards the Servaas Award threatened,” she says of the jewel-like theater that became the Landmarks figured that the future of Attica’s historic places Inspired by landmarks. “Attica’s citizens, young panel applauded HAND’s restora- in the nonprofit or- home of the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra. Fountain County would eventually depend on those who were in elementary and old, are more appreciative of the tion standards and its commitment ganization category “The difference between then and now? How about Landmarks’ educa- for utilizing historic school at the time. They created a program to introduce tion programs, led community’s past, and better prepared to combining low-income hous- buildings in its mis- night and day?,” Rowland laughs. “People wanted to tear students to Attica’s history and landmarks. Fountain County by Carolyn Carlson to preserve it, because of this pro- ing, preservation, and community sion to provide down historic buildings in favor of new buildings or even Landmarks will receive Indiana Landmarks’ 2017 Servaas (second from left gram,” says Carolyn Carlson, a senti- revitalization. low-income hous- just surface parking lots. Folks who favored preservation and Lee Bauerband Memorial Award for its youth-serving program—still go- ment echoed by two former mayors Preservation and community ing. The group has were viewed as obstructionists and anti-progress. I tried to (second from right), transformed three ing strong—during our annual meeting on September 10 in Attica students and the school superintendent. revitalization have driven the winner nineteenth-century be calm and methodical and talk about advantages. Now Indianapolis. play an active role The Servaas Memorial Award in of the 2017 Williamson Prize for indi- commercial build- people see the value in saving and repurposing historic All Attica fourth graders take a tour that leads them to in their commu- the nonprofit organization category, vidual leadership for 40 years. As head ings in Noblesville places,” she notes. nity (left to right: into apartments, Cottrell Village, a museum complex with a restored church, Dalton DeSutter, which comes with a $2,000 prize, will of Rowland Design, an architecture reviving a blighted “Sallie played a major role in that transformation,” accord- houses, an outhouse, smokehouse and garden. “All the kids do Kate Van Hyfte, be presented to Hamilton County and interior design firm from which area. ing to Indiana Landmarks President Marsh Davis, “in part by the tour in fourth grade, learning Attica’s history and seeing Drew Mandeville, Area Neighborhood Development she is now retired, Sallie Rowland di- injecting joy into the process of preserving historic places.” and Hayden ABOVE, RIGHT: how everything was done in the old days and the effort it took Nichols). Parent Jill (HAND). The organization creates rected high-profile restoration projects Leading by She has remained active as a leader in preservation, steering to make things,” says 10 year-old Hayden Nichols. In the fol- Mandeville (center) housing for low-income people in the across the state. example, 2017 the successful initiative to create downtown design guidelines lowing two years, elementary student council members become is helping to ex- wealthiest county in the state—a steep She led the Indianapolis Historic Williamson Prize when Reid Williamson retired after 30 years as president of docents at Cottrell Village. pand the program challenge when census data sends Preservation Commission beginning winner Sallie Indiana Landmarks in 2005; she served six years on Indiana for high school kids. Rowland was the Dalton Desutter, now a high school senior, took the tour PHOTO BY TINA CONNOR grant funds elsewhere.