DRAFT
HICKS LAKE INTEGRATED AQUATIC
VEGETATION MANAGEMENT PLAN – 2017
Prepared for City of Lacey
Prepared by
Herrera Environmental Consultants, Inc.
Note:
Some pages in this document have been purposely skipped or blank pages inserted so that this document will copy correctly when duplexed.
HICKS LAKE INTEGRATED AQUATIC
VEGETATION MANAGEMENT PLAN – 2017
Prepared for City of Lacey
420 College Street Southeast Lacey, Washington 98503
Prepared by
Herrera Environmental Consultants, Inc.
2200 Sixth Avenue, Suite 1100
Seattle, Washington 98121 Telephone: 206-441-9080
Funded by
Washington State Department of Ecology
Aquatic Weeds Management Fund
Grant Number WQAIP-2017-LacePW-00001
DRAFT
November 15, 2016
CONTENTS
Executive Summary .......................................................................................................................................................iii 1. Problem Statement ...............................................................................................................................................1 2. Plant Management Goals....................................................................................................................................3 3. Lake and Watershed Characteristics...............................................................................................................5 4. Beneficial Uses of Hicks Lake...........................................................................................................................11 5. Aquatic Plant Community.................................................................................................................................13
5.1. Plant Distribution ........................................................................................................................................13 5.2. Targeted Plant Descriptions....................................................................................................................17
6. Past Management Efforts..................................................................................................................................19 7. Aquatic Plant Control Alternatives ................................................................................................................20 8. Aquatic Plant Control Scenarios.....................................................................................................................23
8.1. Noxious Floating-Leaved Plant Management..................................................................................27 8.2. Native Nuisance Submersed Plant Management...........................................................................27 8.3. Maintain Lake Health.................................................................................................................................28 8.4. Contingency Management......................................................................................................................28
9. Selected Action Strategy & Implementation.............................................................................................31
9.1. Action Strategy ............................................................................................................................................31 9.2. Implementation ...........................................................................................................................................33
10. Public Involvement..............................................................................................................................................35 11. Monitoring and Evaluation Plan.....................................................................................................................37
11.1. 11.2. 11.3.
Aquatic Plant Surveys....................................................................................................................37 Water Quality Monitoring............................................................................................................37 Annual Evaluation...........................................................................................................................37
12. References...............................................................................................................................................................39
i
kg 15-06169-000_hickslakeiavmp2017.docx
APPENDICES
Appendix A Hicks Lake LMD Steering Committee and Public Meeting Notes
Appendix C Invasive Aquatic Plant Identification Appendix D Public Awareness Signs
TABLES
Table 1. Physical Characteristics of Hicks Lake and Watershed. ...............................................................5 Table 2. Comprehensive Plant List, Hicks Lake Surveys 1995-2016a. ....................................................14 Table 3. Summary of Permitted Aquatic Herbicide Use for Hicks Lake................................................19 Table 4. Aquatic Plant Control Options Considered for Hicks Lake.......................................................21 Table 5. Plant Coverage on Hicks Lake.............................................................................................................23 Table 6. Preliminary Annual Costs of Aquatic Plant Control Scenarios for Hicks Lake in
Lacey, Washington...................................................................................................................................25
Table 7. Fragrant Waterlily Management Options on Hicks Lake..........................................................27 Table 8. Common Water-Nymph Management Options on Hicks Lake.............................................28 Table 9. Annual IAVMP Costs for Hicks Lake Selected Action Strategy...............................................31
FIGURES
Figure 1. Watershed and Surrounding Vicinity for Hicks Lake, Lacey, Washington............................6 Figure 2. 1995 – 2015 Trophic Status Indices for Hicks Lake.......................................................................7 Figure 3. May through October 2015 Profiles of Temperature, Dissolved Oxygen, pH, and Conductivity for Hicks Lake...........................................................................................................8
Figure 4. Hicks Lake Aquatic Vegetation Density Map, Lacey, Washington.........................................16 Figure 5. Hicks Lake Aquatic Vegetation Control Map, Lacey, Washington.........................................26
ii
kg 15-06169-000_hickslakeiavmp2017.docx
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Hicks Lake lies within the City of Lacey in the Henderson Inlet watershed in Thurston County, Washington. The 160-acre lake experiences dense growth of nonnative and native aquatic plants that inhibit the recreational usability and aesthetics of the lake. In 2015, members of the Hicks Lake community worked with the City of Lacey to establish the Hicks Lake, Lake Management District (LMD). The LMD applied for a grant to create Hicks Lake’s first Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan (IAVMP).
Hicks Lake has a large population of nonnative fragrant waterlilies (Nymphaea odorata) that has been present on the lake for many years. Recently, native submersed aquatic plants, primarily common water-nymph (Najas guadalupensis), have colonized most of the nearshore area of Hicks Lake. The presence of these two plant species is a safety concern for people swimming in the nearshore area or those trying to access deeper waters. Boating access and fishing are also hindered in the nearshore area by these plants. Some fragrant waterlilies have been treated with herbicide in the past, but the common water-nymph has never been treated at Hicks Lake.
This IAVMP details strategies for continued management of fragrant waterlily with the herbicide glyphosate, as well as the control of the nuisance native common water-nymph with the herbicide diquat. This IAVMP is a planning document developed to ensure that the Hicks Lake LMD community have considered the best available information about the water body and the watershed prior to initiating control efforts. To tackle the difficult task of generating community awareness and action for an environmental issue, a core group of residents formed a steering committee, which includes ten lake residents and one staff person from the City of Lacey. Members of the Hicks Lake LMD Steering Committee worked in partnership with Herrera Environmental Consultants, Inc. (Herrera) to develop this IAVMP for Hicks Lake using a grant to the City of Lacy from the Washington State Department of Ecology Aquatic Weeds Management Fund.
The goal of this IAVMP is to establish a maintenance level of control to meet recreational goals with an integrated approach that minimizes the use of herbicides to reduce the potential impacts of chemical inputs to the lake.
This 2017 IAVMP details a plan for management of the following aquatic plants.
•
Noxious Floating-Leaved Plants – Treat one-third of fragrant waterlily (excluding the conservation area) with glyphosate annually for the first 3 years (approximately 8 acres each year from 2017 through 2019). Each treatment will involve an initial treatment, followed up by a second treatment a few weeks later to treat any plants that may have been missed because the pads had not surfaced or the herbicide washed off the leaves. After 3 years, all waterlilies targeted for control will have been treated. Follow up spot treatments to maintain recreational access to open water habitat will take place in
November 2016
- Draft Hicks Lake Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan – 2017
- iii
Years 4 and 5 (2020 and 2021). If needed, floating waterlily root mats will be moved or removed under Contingency Management (see below).
•
Native Nuisance Submersed Plants – Treat 34.6 acres of medium to high density
growth of common water-nymph once every other year with diquat. (This treatment area is less than permit maximum of 49.5 acres, based on 50 percent of the littoral zone.) One treatment of this area will be made at the beginning of the growing season (late May or early June), followed by a second treatment approximately one month later to treat any regrowth from seed germination. In Year 1 (2017) it is assumed that all 34.6 acres of the medium to high density growth of common water-nymph will be treated. The cost estimate assumes that in following treatment years (Years 3 and 5 [2019 and 2021]) up to 15 acres will be treated. It is possible that other native submersed plants may become dominant in the lake following the first year of treatment. For example, perennial plants such as pondweeds with extensive rhizomes often become dominant following treatment of annual plants such as common water-nymph. Therefore, treatments in Years 3 and 5 may target medium to high density growth of other native submersed plants, but are still expected to be limited to an area of 15 acres.
The aquatic plant community will be surveyed and mapped every other year to evaluate general changes in the plant community and effectiveness of the treatments, and to detect the presence of new invasive species. The control strategy is taking an incremented approach to treating target species to preserve the water quality of the lake; therefore, the presence of targeted plants such as fragrant waterlily does not alone indicate success or failure of the IAVMP tor achieve the desired results. Success will be largely determined by public perception of whether the desired beneficial uses of Hicks Lake are being maintained through the implementation of this IAVMP.
A water quality monitoring program will continue to be conducted every year to track long-term trends in water quality within the lake.
Public education and awareness programs and workshops for lake residents will be focused on exotic plant prevention, and will provide general pollution prevention and best management practices information to lake residents.
The LMD Steering Committee and interested lake residents will be involved in development of the yearly plant control strategy and will be responsible for soliciting volunteers for surveys and planning of plant control activities. This will ensure long-term involvement of lake residents in lake management decisions and activities.
An annual report will be prepared documenting past and planned aquatic plant treatment activities, aquatic plant survey and water quality monitoring results, and public education and awareness activities.
The following contingency management options may be conducted as the need arises.
November 2016
- iv
- Draft Hicks Lake Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan – 2017
••
Fragrant Waterlily Root Mats – Remove floating waterlily root mats and associated lake sediments in selected areas to improve access to the lake.
New Noxious Submersed Plant Control – If the lake becomes infested by another
noxious submersed plant such as Eurasian watermilfoil (Myriophyllum spicatum) or Brazilian elodea (Egeria densa), then immediately use hand-pulling or an herbicide to eradicate the infestation.
•
Noxious Emergent Plants – Treat emergent noxious weeds that are known to occur on the Hicks Lake shoreline, such as Japanese knotweed (Fallopia japonica), reed canarygrass (Phalaris arundinacea), and yellow flag iris (Iris pseudacorus) with glyphosate annually when observed during waterlily treatment to eradicate or keep populations low.
November 2016
- Draft Hicks Lake Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan – 2017
- v
1. PROBLEM STATEMENT
Hicks Lake is a 160-acre lake within the City of Lacey in Thurston County, Washington. The lake lies within the Woodland Creek Watershed, which is within the Henderson Inlet watershed. Many of the residents around the lake have enjoyed a long history of living on the lake and are dedicated to preserving the beauty and recreational value of the lake. The Hicks Lake, Lake Management District (LMD) was formed in 2015 with the goal of preserving the aesthetics and recreational opportunities of Hicks Lake through removal of problematic aquatic vegetation. The Hicks Lake LMD Steering Committee is spearheading the development of Hicks Lake’s first Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan (IAVMP) to address aquatic vegetation issues.
Recently, native submersed aquatic plants, primarily common water-nymph (Najas guadalupensis), have colonized most of the nearshore area of Hicks Lake. They interfere with activities in nearshore areas of the lake that are less than about 14 feet deep. The density and extent of these plants are a safety concern for people swimming in the nearshore area or those trying to access deeper waters. Boating access and fishing is also hindered in the nearshore area by these plants.
Hicks Lake also has a large population of nonnative fragrant waterlilies (Nymphaea odorata). The fragrant waterlilies, a Class C noxious weed, are most abundant on the south shore. These lilies have been treated with the herbicide glyphosate at some properties in this area. Decaying roots (rhizomes) from the treatments have resulted in floating lily mats, which can interfere with lake use and present a safety risk to boaters when they drift across the lake.
Since 1995, plant surveys on Hicks Lake have identified several other aquatic plant species that are listed as “noxious” because of their tendencies to overtake a lake. Small populations of swollen bladderwort (Utricularia inflata) have been found primarily on the steep (eastern) shore of the lake, and curly-leaf pondweed (Potamogeton crispus) was once found near the public boat launch. These plants were not found during the aquatic vegetation survey of the lake conducted in 2016 for this IAVMP. However, a plan for prevention and detection is needed to reduce the potential for new plant invasions that could become problematic.
Emergent plant species (plants that grow along the edges of lakes, rivers, and streams) are present at Hicks Lake and include several noxious weeds that are not required to be controlled. Yellow flag iris (Iris pseudacorus) is expanding and restricts lake access in some areas, but is not yet a serious issue. Purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria) or garden loosestrife (Lysimachia vulgaris) have been reported at a few locations, but their presence is unconfirmed. Cattails and other emergent plants are not considered to be a problem by lake residents.
November 2016
- Draft Hicks Lake Integrated Aquatic Vegetation Management Plan – 2017
- 1
2. PLANT MANAGEMENT GOALS
Aquatic plants in Hicks Lake provide important natural habitat for fish, waterfowl, and small wildlife. Excessive aquatic plant growth, however, may impact the aquatic habitat. Recent increases in the cover and abundance of aquatic plants have impacted recreational opportunities and aesthetic beauty the lake offers to residents who live on and nearby the lake. To address concerns of the Hicks Lake community, the Hicks Lake LMD Steering Committee is acting to create an IAVMP for controlling excessive growth of noxious weeds and native, nuisance vegetation in Hicks Lake. The Steering Committee is composed of ten lake residents (Danny Kaiser, Ken Callaghan, Margaret Hollinger, Mike Mahoney, James Tilque, Glenn Edstrom, Jay Monti, JJ Baker, Rob Krell, and Roxine Mahoney) and one staff from the City of Lacey (Tom Palmateer).
The Hicks Lake LMD Steering committee met three times during the drafting of the IAVMP to discuss the goals of the plan, as well as to discuss possible methods for control of the problem species to meet the goals, and finally to select a preferred method(s) for achieving those goals. These meetings took place on July 26, October 19, and October 26, 2016. In the third meeting, all members of the Hicks Lake LMD were invited to attend and provide input for the IAVMP. Notes and presentations for each meeting are provided in Appendix A.
With the implementation of the IAVMP, the Hicks Lake LMD Steering Committee will direct aquatic vegetation management activities to ensure a high-level of lake health while balancing the recreational, wildlife, water quality, and aesthetic needs of Hicks Lake. To accomplish this, the LMD established the following aquatic plant management goals.
••
Provide for safe swimming in private and public areas Provide safe lanes of access to open water for swimming and boating from shorefront properties
•
Monitor for plants that can become a problem and have a ready strategy for their control
••
Develop a long term invasive species prevention plan Maintain good water quality and prevent toxic algae blooms
Because the studies and plans necessary to determine the condition of the lake and identify potential solutions for improving conditions are to be conducted as components of this plan, the above goals are broadly defined. Work plans will be developed annually for implementation of specific activities and recommendations based on current conditions and past successes.