Hydraulic Conductivity of Gravelly Soils with Various Fine-Grained Content
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Hydraulic Conductivity of Gravelly Soils with Various Fine-Grained Content Yi Zhou 1,2 and Zhenbin Peng1,2 1 School of Geosciences and Info-Physics, Central South University, Changsha, 410083, China 2 Key Laboratory of Metallogenic Prediction of Nonferrous Metals and Geological Environment Monitoring, Central South University, Changsha, 410083, China e-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT Gravelly soils with a certain clay content has proven to be a good performance anti-seepage material. However, there are many factors affecting the permeability coefficient of gravel soil. For example, the content of fine particles, properties of fines and compactive effort. Laboratory experiments are conducted to study the effect of above factors. The hydraulic conductivities of soils with different fines, coarse grains and mix ratios are measured using the variable water head permeability tests. The test results show that the permeability coefficient of gravelly soils decreases linearly with the increase of fine particle content and then tends to be stable. The permeability coefficient of gravelly soil decreases with the increase of fine material liquid limit and plasticity index.The permeability coefficient of gravelly soils with clay as fine material decreases in the form of exponential function with the increase of compaction effort. KEYWORDS: Gravelly soil; Optimal moisture content; Hydraulic conductivity; Compactive effort INTRODUCTION Gravelly soils can solve the problems of low strength, easy settlement, deformation and cracking of [1-2] clay as impervious material due to its high density, strength and low compressibility after rolling . In [3-5] recent years, it has been widely used as anti-seepage material for core wall of earth-rockfill dam . However, because of the wide range of particle gradation of soil materials, and most of them have the - 1053 - Vol. 24 [2019], Bund. 04 1054 characteristics of non-uniformity, instability and discontinuity, the compacted gravel soil used as core wall filling material in earth-rockfill dam project may can not meet the technical requirements that the permeability coefficient of the impervious core wall is less than 1×10-5 cm/s due to poor gradation. Gravelly soils with a certain clay content have been proved to be a kind of engineering performance, [6] economical and practical anti-seepage material. Xibao Rao through outdoor test demonstrate that under the condition of the same compaction degree, the permeability is not only related to the content of [7] p5, but also related to the content of 0.1mm particles and clay. Ting Yu believes that when the fine particle content of natural gravel soil is small and the anti-seepage and impermeability can not meet the requirements, it is an effective measure to eliminate coarse particles to adjust the gradation of gravel soil and improve its performance. In addition, the drying shrinkage of gravel soil is smaller than that of [8] clay , and the compression modulus is higher than that of clay, which is superior to clay in reducing the horizontal cracks in the core wall. In summary, the strength and deformation performance of gravel impervious material is much better than that of clay. Replacing clay with gravel soil has great advantages and broad engineering application prospects in economy and engineering performance. For soil impervious materials, fine particles usually play a decisive role. For example, the famous Hazeng formula indicates that the permeability coefficient of soil is closely related to D10. Therefore, the content of fine particles should be the key to control the permeability coefficient. In this paper, according to the key factors affecting the anti-seepage performance of gravel soil, the effects of fine particle content, fine physical properties and compaction work on the anti-seepage performance of gravel soil are analyzed. MATERIALS AND METHODS Gradation design and calculation of optimal moisture content It is generally necessary to compaction gravel soil when it is used as impervious material. In order to save the cost and ensure the anti-seepage effect, the test is generally compacted under the optimal moisture content. The gravelly soil with different fine grain content was tested, and the gradation design was shown in Figure 1. Vol. 24 [2019], Bund. 04 1055 Figure 1: Gradation curve of soil sample The standard compaction of soil is carried out by light compaction instrument, and the relationship between soil water content and dry density under various gradation is measured, and the maximum dry density and optimal water content are obtained as shown in figure 2.From the measured results, the relationship between the optimal moisture content and the fine grain content can be estimated by the following formula: ω=ωa×η+ωb×(1-η) In the formula,ωa is the optimal moisture content of fine grain group, ωb is the water content of gravel group, andηis the content of fine grain. Figure 2: Compaction curves for gravel soils Vol. 24 [2019], Bund. 04 1056 Experimental scheme The fine particle content, the physical properties of fine particles and the degree of compaction all have great influence on the permeability coefficient, so the experiments are designed and studied according to the above factors. In order to study the effect of fine particle content on the permeability coefficient of gravel soil, silty clay and bentonite with different mass ratio (10% to 100%) were mixed with coarse sand. The test results are shown in figure 3. In order to study the effect of fine physical properties on the permeability coefficient of gravel soil, five different fine materials (as shown in Table 1) were tested. The experiments carried five kinds of fine-grained soils with pure fine-grained materials, 30% and 40% fine-grained materials mixed with coarse sand (the particle size was 1 to 2 mm). The test results are shown in Table 2. In order to study the influence of compaction effect on the permeability coefficient of gravelly soil, 8, 16, 24and 32 hit / layer were used to compacted soil sample of pure fine-grained soil and gravelly soil, respectively.(Corresponding to the unit volume impact work 295.8, 591.6, 887.4 and 1183.2k J/m3, respectively) , and the permeability coefficient of the soil sample was measured. All the soil samples in the experiment were compacted with the same compaction work (591.6 J/m3) under the optimal moisture content. The soil samples are cylindrical samples with diameter 60mm and height 50mm. The permeability coefficient of saturated soil sample is measured by variable head permeability test. There are five kinds of fine materials used in the test, and their basic physical properties are shown in Table 1. The coarse-grained materials used are coarse sand (with a particle size of 1 to 2 mm) and coarse-grained soil with continuous gradation (the gradation is shown in figure 1). Table 1: Physical properties of fines Maximum dry Optimal moisture Liquid limit Plastic limit Relative density density/(g.cm-3) content (%) (%) (%) (g.cm-3) 1.32 0.34 50.5 28.2 2.73 1.51 0.35 67.8 33 2.75 1.55 0.26 33.7 23.1 2.66 1.78 0.15 25.5 17.5 2.68 1.88 0.14 27.5 14.8 2.73 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Analysis of the influence of fine-grained content The analysis of the influence of fine-grain content can be seen in figure 3, when silty clay is used as fine material, when the fine particle content increases from 10% to 40%, the permeability coefficient decreases sharply, reaches the minimum near 40%, and then increases slowly. The reason Vol. 24 [2019], Bund. 04 1057 for the above change in the permeability coefficient is that when the fine particle content is less than 40%, with the increase of the fine particle content, the gravel soil transitions from the skeleton pore structure to the skeleton dense structure. The more the fine particle content is, the smaller the pore diameter is. The seepage path will become tortuous, these changes will affect the seepage velocity and reduce the permeability coefficient. When the fine particle content is more than 40%, the permeability coefficient increases slightly, because the gravel soil is in the dense suspension [9-10] structure . As the content of fine particles increases, the compaction becomes more difficult. The coarse aggregate does not form a skeleton and only plays a role in reducing the effective permeation area. Therefore, when the fine particles are increased and the coarse particles are reduced, the soil permeability coefficient will be Increased, but the growth rate is not large. At the same time, it can be found that when the fine clay is silty clay, the 10% fine particle content can not guarantee that the soil permeability coefficient is less than 1×10-5cm/s. Similarly, the bentonite and the coarse-grained soil corresponding to the gradation in fig. 1 are mixed according to the mass ratio, which is similar to that of silty clay as fine-grained material, and the permeability coefficient tends to be stable when the bentonite content is more than 30%. The permeability coefficient of pure fine-grained soil is close to that of pure fine-grained soil. Figure 3: Relationship between hydraulic conductivity and fines Analysis of the influence of physical Properties of Fine particles The plastic limit and liquid limit reflect the change process of the moisture content of the weakly bound water (diffusion layer) in clay. In theory, the higher the liquid-plastic limit of fine-grained soil is, the stronger its ability to adsorb water is, so the viscous effect of permeable flow between pores is more obvious, so the smaller the permeability coefficient is. Vol. 24 [2019], Bund. 04 1058 Table 2: Results of permeability of soils with various fines Types of pure soil of fine containing 40% containing 30% fine fine-grained soils grain fine particles particles residual soil 3.5X10-7 4.5X10-7 4.3X10-5 -7 -7 -6 red clay 1.5X10 2.1X10 1.0X10 -7 -5 -4 dolomite 4.0X10 6.1X10 1.8X10 silty clay 4.9X10-5 5.3X10-5 1.7X10-4 silt 3.5X10-7 6.8X10-5 2.4X10-4 The relationship between permeability coefficient and liquid plastic limit of fine grain material is shown in Fig.