47 Liam Payne and and Payne Liam Louis Tomlinson Louis Tomlinson for beginners. beginners. for saying goodbye? saying From left: Are 1D’s 1D’s left: Are From Niall Horan, Styles, Horan, Niall —KENNETH PARTRIDGE NOVEMBER 14, 2015 | WWW.BILLBOARD.COM . Here, when the when the . Here, Graceland Four ong that closes the album’s the album’s closes ong that s “The Lion Sleeps Tonight” s “The Sleeps Tonight” Lion the whimsical orchestration of the whimsical orchestration

As for Beatles-biting bits: Opener “Hey Angel” pairs pairs bits: Opener Angel” “Hey As for Beatles-biting though, the boys references, One Direction what matter No on its last album, 2014’s ballad-heavy ballad-heavy album, 2014’s on its last boys once again go trawling the ’80s for inspiration, they swap they swap for inspiration, the ’80s trawling go once again boys “What a Feeling,” power-schlock like for songs Journey-style third- a soulful enough to be strong someone’s soft-rocker the from in the Wind,” jam. “Walking & Oates Hall favorite deluxe edition, Simon’s is Paul album’s Best of all: the booming stadium-doo-wop oddity “Never amazingly blend which Enough,” with Phil Collins’ “Sussudio.” Collins’ with Phil with a kind of John-and-Yoko and strings guitars psychedelic wish you you you/Do sentiment wish I could be like (“I more has the downbeat guitar “Olivia” me?”). could be like more Better” and of “Getting strokes to The short acoustic ditty “I Want and sweet Lane.” “Penny or “Two of Us.” “Blackbird” a Song” is 1D’s You Write 21st-century a prefab pop they are: wind up sounding what like (most team of and writers producers whose crack machine Scott Jamie Bunetta, Julian longtime collaborators notably rarely that songs out boilerplate love churns Ryan) and John vacuum-sealed bubble-gum feel personal or look 1D’s beyond — a cool synth-pop “Perfect” exceptions are The key world. seemingly co-wrote in response to ex-girlfriend tune Styles — and “Style” kiss-and-tell strikingly similar Swift’s Taylor the jaunty acoustic singal “History,” winking line about “mini-bars, edition. With a standard is the track tattoos,” rooms hotel and new cars, expensive could be of triumph.years end-credits “We music capping five they sing, a little seen,” has ever thing the world the greatest next. As we say bummed but mostly just excited for what’s hello. they say goodbye, X Factor X Factor Made in the the in Made four talented long-haired British British long-haired — the final word from from — the final word forward for forward . Their three subsequent . Their three ck frivolities like 2011’s “What 2011’s like frivolities ck is not a world-changing record, is not a world-changing record, playfulness and melodramatic playfulness and melodramatic Abbey Road Road Abbey Up All Night All Up , their fifth album — the former , their fifth album arrives amid rumors that 1D will take an an 1D will take that amid rumors arrives WITH THE SUDDEN DEPARTURE OF ZAYN ZAYN OF DEPARTURE SUDDEN THE WITH studio LPs also reached No. 1, and with 1, and with No. alsostudio reached LPs — the second single from “Perfect” A.M. Malik in March, One Direction, one of the One Direction, in March, Malik officially became a boybiggest bands in history, bolstered the Beatles This naturally foursome. been making since 2011, have comparisons fans when these new-millennium 200 with their debut toppedlads the Billboard album, co) Made in the A.M. A.M. the in Made

contestants notched their fifth top 10 debut on the Billboard Billboard on the debut their fifth top 10 contestants notched

Made in the A.M. A.M. the in Made be clear, To With these 13 tracks — nine of which the band had a hand the band had a hand — nine ofWith these which 13 tracks

ONE DIRECTION lover-man anguish — and points a way anguish — and points a way lover-man U.K. Four. held by the original Fab a record breaking 100, Hot in 2016 if break extended break to focus on solo But pursuits. this new speculated, as someactually means breakup, have could be the band’s record and Ringo. it or not, And believe the set has George Paul, John, Beatles-esquesome blatantly moments. study photo to the cover people won’t now, from and 50 years dreamboat dreamiest 1D’s Styles — arguably see Harry whether sitting. It’s he’s — is sending with the way some message secret tastemakers the typenot even poptimist of that top 40 album does, It indie kids to like. coolwill deem secretly and dare — tight harmonies, Ginsu- charms many highlight 1D’s however, sharp hooks, a mix of boyish

guys looking pop-ro to transcend guys “Best Song Ever.” and 2013’s Beautiful” You Makes does much better than maturity in writing — One Direction One Direction’s Swan Song (For Now) Song (For Swan One Direction’s Made in the A.M. Columbia/Syco YUI MOK/PA WIRE/AP IMAGES WIRE/AP MOK/PA YUI