Political Reading of Dangarembga's Nervous Conditions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Language Circle: Journal of Language and Literature 14(2) April 2020 P-ISSN 1858-0157 Available online at http://journal.unnes.ac.id/nju/index.php/LC E-ISSN 2460-853X Political Reading of Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions Majed Alenezi Northern Border University, Saudi Arabia Email: [email protected] Abstract This paper explores Tsitsi Dangarembga’s debut novel, Nervous Conditions, from a political perspective. It has been read as portraying of gender relationships, social hierarchies and oppression of African women. This paper takes a different route as it analyses the role of masculinities through a political perspective. The conflict and struggle between genders in the text can be read through a political and historical perspective. This particular reading is permitted through a close analysis of the male characters in the novel. The research argues that male characters resemble or behave in away similar to white colonizers in their treatment of African women. Reading the novel through a political perspective provides the reader with the benefit of understanding the changes that occur in the characters and the role of gender conflict in the text. The triumph of Tambu and Nyasha at the end underscores the failure of colonial power to colonize Zimbabwe. Keywords: Tsitsi Dangarembga/ postcolonial, African literature/ feminist literary criticism. INTRODUCTION people is hardly mentioned in the novel. There is no obvious struggle between the white colonizers Tsitsi Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions and the indigenous African people. According to (1988) is considered a masterwork of modern Af- Sugnet Zimbabwean male authors wrote in the rican literature. It is the first English novel written late 1980s “foreground the chimurenga struggle by a black Zimbabwean woman. The work was for national liberation, Nervous Conditions barely completed in 1984, but it was rejected by local mentioned it” (33). Searle believes that Danga- publishers as it touches upon highly sensitive sub- rembga goes far above the immediate level of jects in African society. “For four years Danga- British colonization found in Things Fall Apart. rembga was rejected by Zimbabwean publishers Many critics have analysed the text through gen- whose attitudes to her writing were that she was der relationships, social hierarchies and oppressi- too much of a feminist” (Tendai 22). After its on of African women, simultaneously male cha- publication, the novel has achieved international racters in the text are only considered in terms success. It has become one of the most important of their interactions with female characters. This literary texts in African literature. Nowadays, the paper takes a different route as it analyses the role text is taught at Zimbabwe schools. Even though of masculinities through a political perspective. Nervous Conditions is a fictional literary work, the The conflict and struggle between genders in the novel’s prestige rests in part on its realistic scenes text can be read through a political and historical of actions and events. The locale of the novel perspective. This particular reading is permitted and the social context are unmistakably the ear- through a close analysis of the male characters ly colonial period of an African community. The in the novel. The research argues that male cha- novel’s internal narrative is set in the late 1960s racters resemble or behaves in away similar to and early 1970s. The author does not build her white colonizers in their treatment of African theme, characters, dialogues, conflicts and plot women. Viewed from a political perspective, the strictly around particular historical events. Yet, female characters signify the colonized nation the characters in the text are caught in a speci- (Rhodesia), whereas male characters represent fic historical and social framework. The female the British Empire. “Dangarembga’s heroine narrator represents the past and present of the suggests that women can reproduce the nation as African community. She reveals both the negative intellectual subjects not just as embodied ones” and positive facets of the traditional and colonial (Stone 113). Yet, there are significant differences experiences. between the white colonizer and African male, The colonial experience as an encoun- since the latter is a product of the former. “Ner- ter between European forces and the colonized vous Conditions nevertheless, shows clearly how Language Circle: Journal of Language and Literature 14(2) April 2020 those men are themselves products of the colo- Colonial domination in Tambu’s world nial system” (Sugnet 36). The other difference manifests itself in all aspects of social life, such as between the two is that African male has an am- defining the age at which African children should bivalent role in the text as colonized and coloni- start school, maintaining a racist agenda against zer. Due to the limitation of space and time, this the indigenes in educational institutions [....] and paper concentrates mainly on Babamukuru and using the selective nature of its educational sys- the two young girls Nyasha and Tambudzai. Yet, tems to limit the educated indigenous population other characters are brought into light to support (79). the above claim. Furthermore, Uwakweh argues that Dan- garembga as a postcolonial writer has shown LITERATURE RIVIEW some political concerns about major issues such as the value of Western education and the exp- Nervous Conditions recounts the story of loitative nature of colonization. “This dialectical two young African girls; Tambudzai and Nyasha. tension in the novel projects the socio-political Tambudzai is the tale orator who is raised in a dimensions of the novel” (Uwakweh 77). In fact, typical African village. Nyasha and Tambudzai’s Uwakweh’s reading of Nervous Conditions provi- personalities and motivations have attracted the des an insightful analysis of the text through the most criticism of Nervous Conditions. The novel is political dimensions. Yet, it seems that Uwakweh about Tambu’s willingness to progress through does not show how Dangarembga highlights the formal education. “ I decided it was better to be political concepts. The exploitative nature of co- like Maiguru, who was not poor and had not lonization is not revealed. been crushed by the weight of womanhood” (16). Sugnet takes a different view in his in- The text reveals how women individually or col- terpretation of the novel. Yet, he is within the lectively seek their identities within traditional fe- framework of feminism. Sugnet argues that the male daily life in colonial Zimbabwe. The female text’s depiction of feminism and anti-colonial na- characters in the novel struggle with what seems tionalism based on Fanon’s conceptual lens. He to be the prevalent rules of the society regarding traces the gradual development of the young Af- race, gender, culture and religion. The only way rican girl. Tambu‘s struggle is seen as a gendered to withdraw from this patriarchy is to refuse it. struggle for national liberation. Nervous Conditions has always been viewed The national liberation struggle is conspi- as a feminist representation of the African com- cuous by its absence in this novel, yet I think munity. Lindsay Aegerter adopts a womanist lens there may be a complex party subterranean rela- in her analysis of Nervous Conditions. She propo- tionship between it and the struggle of the young ses that Nervous Conditions articulates “a dialectic Tambudzai against the immediate manifestation and autonomy community” (231). Aegerter af- of patriarchy in her life (Sugnet 34). firms that the female characters in Nervous Condi- Sugnet goes beyond this idea and argues tions are given voice. They occupy the locus spot that Dangarembga uses Fanon’s concept “on in the text. According to Aegerter, “the African violence as the decisive rapture in the colonial women of Nervous Conditions do not merely react; situation” (39). On several occasions, female they act. And in their very action – in their refusal characters in Nervous Conditions violently resist to live their lives only in response to oppression patriarchal dominations. As an example, he con- lies their resistance” (231). Furthermore, Aeger- siders Nyasha’s resistance when her father punis- ter views Tambudzai’s identity as inextricably hes her. connected to women collectively. Thus, Tambu Dangarembga in one of her interviews dis- and Nyasha demonstrate two sides of one whole tinguishes between the situation in Africa and in person. the West concerning feminist theory. When she The novel demonstrates that African wo- is asked about the unequal treatment of Tambu men face enormous social problems. Uwakweh and her brother within their family, she replies examines the social structure of society. She ar- that the patriarchal system which is adopted by gues that Dangarembga represents African fe- Western feminism can not be applied to Africa males as encountering the double oppression “because the situation in my part of the world has of patriarchy and colonization. More precisely, one variable which makes it absolutely different: Uwakweh concentrates on the negative impact the men are also in a position of powerlessness” of colonization on the social life of the African (qtd. un Holland 121). Dangarembga’s view of community. The negative effects are seen through Africa has a great value to the above research all aspects of social life in Zimbabwe. question as the paper examines the gender rela- 157 Language Circle: Journal of Language and Literature 14(2) April 2020 tionship through a political perspective. Danga- Nervous Conditions reveals many events and rembga in her interview was not talking about the incidents which affirm that the novel can be read male characters in the text, but she was providing above the level of gender struggle in a colonized a realistic view of Zimbabwe. Both genders are nation. In the early stage of the story, Nhamo ta- exposed to a certain degree of oppression. The kes the chance of education, while Tambu faces novel reveals many incidents in which African many impediments and difficulties in her journey males are presented as inferior to the white co- to receive formal education.