A PUBLICATION OF THE NATIONAL FORENSIC LEAGUE V O LU M E 87 I S S U E 5 Rostrum JANUARY 2013 INSIDE: Answering the Call for College and Career Readiness Top Policy Lab with Top Policy Lab with with Lab Policy Top Dr. Ryan Galloway, who was voted Dr. Ryan Galloway, who was voted voted was who Galloway, Ryan Dr. 3rd Best Collegiate Policy Debate 3rd Best Collegiate Policy Debate Debate Policy Collegiate Best 3rd Judge of the Decade. Judge of the Decade. Decade. the of Judge Don’t miss Don’t miss miss Don’t legendary July 4th legendary July 4th 4th July legendary Celebration Celebration Celebration T h e S a m f o r d U n i v e r s i t y D ebate Team T h e S a m f o r d U n i v e r s i t y D ebate Team Team ebate D y t i s r e v i n U d r o f m a S e h T Sunday, June 23rd — Saturday July 6th, 2013 Sunday, June 23rd — Saturday July 6th, 2013 2013 6th, July Saturday — 23rd June Sunday, Why choose Samford Debate Institute? Prices Why choose Samford Debate Institute? Prices Prices Institute? Debate Samford choose Why Samford is committed to maintaining low prices Samford is committed to maintaining low prices prices low maintaining to committed is Samford Learn from a national – caliber staff at a during tough economic times. Learn from a national – caliber staff at a during tough economic times. times. economic tough during a at staff caliber – national a from Learn Limited financial aid is available. Limited financial aid is available. available. is aid financial Limited reasonable price. reasonable price. price. reasonable Beginning debaters are a priority. Residents Beginning debaters are a priority. Residents Residents priority. a are debaters Beginning The program emphasizes 21st century debating skills. $1,450.00 (including $50.00 deposit) The program emphasizes 21st century debating skills. $1,450.00 (including $50.00 deposit) deposit) $50.00 (including $1,450.00 skills. debating century 21st emphasizes program The At least 15 critiqued practice debates in two weeks are At least 15 critiqued practice debates in two weeks are are weeks two in debates practice critiqued 15 least At guaranteed. Commuters with meals guaranteed. Commuters with meals meals with Commuters guaranteed. Samford has a track record of success. Program $1,100.00 (including $50.00 deposit) Samford has a track record of success. Program $1,100.00 (including $50.00 deposit) deposit) $50.00 (including $1,100.00 Program success. of record track a has Samford graduates have been in deep elimination rounds of graduates have been in deep elimination rounds of of rounds elimination deep in been have graduates every major high school tournament. Commuters without meals every major high school tournament. Commuters without meals meals without Commuters tournament. school high major every Instruction is offered for all skill levels in Policy, $950 (including $50.00 deposit) Instruction is offered for all skill levels in Policy, $950 (including $50.00 deposit) deposit) $50.00 (including $950 olicy, P in levels skill all for offered is Instruction P F D P F D D F P Lincoln-Douglas and ublic orum ebate. Lincoln-Douglas and ublic orum ebate. ebate. orum ublic and Lincoln-Douglas Learn from mature, responsible adult staff. Learn from mature, responsible adult staff. staff. adult responsible mature, from Learn 800 Lakeshore Drive 800 Lakeshore Drive Drive Lakeshore 800 Birmingham, AL 35229 Birmingham, AL 35229 35229 L A Birmingham, For more information, contact Dr. Ryan Galloway at For more information, contact Dr. Ryan Galloway at at Galloway Ryan Dr. contact information, more For 205-726-2695 205-726-2695 205-726-2695 Don’t miss Don’t miss Celebration Celebration legendary July 4th legendary July 4th 35229 35229 L L ebate Team ebate Team D D Prices Samford committedis maintaining to low prices toughduring economic times. Limited financial aid available.is Residents $50.00 deposit) $1,450.00 (including meals with Commuters $50.00 deposit) $1,100.00 (including meals without Commuters $50.00 deposit) $950 (including 800 Lakeshore Drive Birmingham, A atDr. Ryan Galloway Forinformation, contact more 205-726-2695 Prices Samford committedis maintaining to low prices toughduring economic times. Limited financial aid available.is Residents $50.00 deposit) $1,450.00 (including meals with Commuters $50.00 deposit) $1,100.00 (including meals without Commuters $50.00 deposit) $950 (including 800 Lakeshore Drive Birmingham, A atDr. Ryan Galloway Forinformation, contact more 205-726-2695 Saturday July 6th, 2013 Saturday July 6th, 2013 — — olicy, olicy, P P Top Policy with Lab Top Policy with Lab n i v e r s i t y n i v e r s i t y Judge of the Decade. Judge of the Decade. ebate. ebate. U U D D 3rd Best CollegiatePolicy Debate 3rd Best CollegiatePolicy Debate Dr. Ryan Galloway, was who voted Dr. Ryan Galloway, was who voted orum orum F F ublic ublic P P caliber staff at a caliber staff at a – – a m f o r d a m f o r d S S Sunday, June 23rd Sunday, June 23rd h e h e reasonable price. reasonable price. every major high school tournament. every major high school tournament. Learn from a national Beginning debaters are a priority.The program emphasizes 21stAt century least 15debating critiqued skills. practiceguaranteed. debates in two weeks Samfordare has a track record of success. Program Instruction is offered for all skill levels in Learn from mature, responsible adult staff. Learn from a national Beginning debaters are a priority.The program emphasizes 21stAt century least 15debating critiqued skills. practiceguaranteed. debates in two weeks Samfordare has a track record of success. Program Instruction is offered for all skill levels in Learn from mature, responsible adult staff. T T graduates have been in deep elimination rounds of graduates have been in deep elimination rounds of Lincoln-Douglas and Lincoln-Douglas and Why choose Samford Debate Institute? Why choose Samford Debate Institute? UniversityUniversity ofof TexasTexas NationalNational InstituteInstitute inin ForensicsForensics ! !"#$%&'()&'*"#+,,"#,&#"'-.%,Join us in Austin, /&#'&+'*! Texas ,#/),#&'*"#&)+0 in 2013! , TheThe UTNIF competitive would season like to is once now again in full congratulate swing and we all encourage of the very you fine to competitors keep the andUTNIF coaches in mind. who Itgave is never their tooall atearly last tosummer’s begin thinking NFL National about plans Tourn forament the future in Indianapolis,and what you Indiana. will do to prepare yourself for the highest levels of competitive excellence. Choosing the UTNIF’s rigorous course of practice and study is a Asgood the step culmination in the right of alldirection. the passion, Join usdedication, next summer and hardand see work for of yourself the season, why thethe NFL UTNIF tournament is one of thetruly largest repres andents most the bestsuccessful of our speechcommunity. and debate In 2013, the UTNIFworkshops will continuein the country. to do its Our part alumni in contributing have won toLeague the NFL’s championships long tradition and of excellencefinal rounds and in integrity the House, in speechthe Senate, and Publicdebate Forum, education. Policy Debate, U.S. Extemp, Extemp Commentary, Impromptu Speaking, Dramatic Interpretation, Humorous As you begin the new competitive year, we encourage you to keep us in mind. Interpretation, Poetry, and more. Join us next summer and see for yourself why the UTNIF is one of the largest and most successful speech and debate workshops in the country. Our alumni have won NFL championships and NFL final rounds in the House, the Senate, Public Forum, Policy Debate, US Extemp, Extemp Commentary, Impromptu Speaking, Dramatic Interpretation, Humorous Interpretation, Poetry and more. UTNIFUTNIF www.utspeech.net Dept.Dept. of of Communication Communication Studies Studies www.utdebatecamp.comwww.utdebatecamp.com 11 University University Station, Station, A1105 A1105 phone: (512) 471-5518 Austin,Austin, TX TX 78705 78705 [email protected]@austin.utexas.edu Chief Air Guitar Officer. Chief I’m Still Cool Officer. Chief Got Your Back Officer. Chief Life Officer. You’re the boss of your life. Your own Chief Life Officer – responsible for what happens today and planning for tomorrow. That’s why Lincoln Financial offers products designed to help you protect the ones you love, and secure your future. Ask your financial professional how Lincoln can help you take charge and be your own Chief Life Officer. Take charge at lincolnfinancial.com/clo. Life. Income. Retirement. Group Benefits. Advice. You’re In Charge SM Lincoln Financial Group is the marketing name for Lincoln National Corporation and insurance company affiliates, including The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, Fort Wayne, IN, and in New York, Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York, Syracuse, NY. Variable products distributed by broker/dealer-affiliate Lincoln Financial Distributors, Inc., Radnor, PA. Securities and investment advisory services offered through other affiliates. © 2011 Lincoln National Corporation. LCN1109-2059283 www.nationalforensicleague.org In this Issue : Volume 87 : Issue 5 : JAN u AR Y 2 0 1 3 From the Cover Inside 13 Speech & Debate: Making the Case for 4 From the Editor the Common Core by Emily Wallace, J.D. 5 2012-13 Topics 16 Answering the Call for College and Career Readiness 32 Academic All Americans compiled by Chris Riffer and Adam J. Jacobi 33 Diamond Coach 30 Middle Level Engagement: Speech & Debate Recognition and the Common Core by Adam J. Jacobi 36 Student Service Citations 41 Welcome New Schools Features 46 Coach Profile: 9 AASHTO: The Importance of Freight Investment Robert S. Littlefield by Chris Smith 48 District in Detail: 42 A Conversation with Margaret Riley Kentucky with her son, John Riley 50 NDCA Coaches' Corner by Joshua Brown 54 District Standings GiveYouthAVoice.org Returns This Winter.