Who Is Afraid of European Economic Diplomacy?

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Who Is Afraid of European Economic Diplomacy? APRIL 2016 Who is Afraid of European Policy Brief Economic Diplomacy? European Union (EU) institutions are stepping up their effort to develop a coordinated, coherent European approach to economic diplomacy. This includes the addition of a distinct EU element to policy and action in this field, complementing that of EU member states, many of which have strengthened economic diplomacy efforts in recent years. With the globalization-induced, fast-paced changes in the balance of power and a Global Strategy on Foreign and Security Policy in the making, the time seems ripe for the EU to embark on this road. Yet Brussels needs to be clear on its objectives and on the added value of European economic diplomacy for EU member states and for European businesses. Failing short-term benefits and a long-term strategy entailing offensive and defensive elements, European capitals and companies will end up contesting the EU’s efforts – worried about EU competence creep – and will leave extra-European actors unimpressed about the EU as a global force with which to be reckoned. Towards Joint European policy of EU capitals.2 The following year, Economic Diplomacy?1 Deputy Director-General for Enterprise and Industry Antti Peltomäki led another EU Mission for Growth to China, this time to In July 2013, [then] Vice-President of the Chengdu. These EU missions ran parallel to European Commission Antonio Tajani led the high-profile bilateral trade missions that Montesano & Francesco Saverio Okano-Heijmans Maaike a ‘Mission for Green Growth’ to Beijing some seventeen EU member states organized with representatives from approximately to China between 2013 and 2015. Often, 50 European companies. A packed agenda, the aim here was to maximize the ability ranging from ministerial-level meetings to of domestic businesses to outpace their EU–China business matchmaking sessions, competitors – frequently from neighbouring sought to ‘add value’ to the otherwise EU countries – in the burgeoning Chinese predominantly national initiatives on trade market. and investment promotion and the foreign 2 See the following EU-webpages: http://ec.europa. eu/enterprise/initiatives/mission-growth/missions- for-growth/files/asia/china/will-you-miss-the- 1 The authors would like to thank all reviewers for m4g-to-china_en.pdf; and http://ec.europa.eu/ their constructive comments to earlier drafts of this enterprise/initiatives/mission-growth/missions-for- Policy Brief. growth/files/asia/china/programme_en.pdf. Clingendael Policy Brief While EU institutions in Brussels are synergic rather than adversarial dynamics? ratcheting up their efforts towards the This question is particularly pressing in development of more coordinated economic Europe’s relations with economic powers like diplomacy, intra-EU competition to access China, as growing trade with and investment new markets is clearly still very much alive. from this country also gives it increasing This raises the question of what in fact is leverage in European capitals. What should the ‘added value’ of the EU Missions for be the objectives and targeted actions of Growth, as a part of EU/European economic European economic diplomacy? Clearly, a diplomacy. Advocates of a state-centred long-term vision and short-term benefits to approach, convinced that business support such an approach need to be analysed so is best done at the national level, are critical as to engage European stakeholders and of any EU involvement, using a principled, (relevant) extra-European actors. Failing legalistic perspective to EU action to argue to do so will have European stakeholders that the EU has no competence in the area worried about EU competence creep, and of trade promotion or foreign policy. Pointing extra-European actors unimpressed about to the European countries’ relative loss of the EU as a global force. economic and political influence to new and bigger economies, others emphasize the Aiming for a Comprehensive need to work from a common framework Approach that combines efforts, thus adding scale to The strategy and action of key economic gain leverage. In the long run, the argument diplomacy strands – in particular, commercial goes, Europe will only be competitive on the diplomacy, development cooperation and global stage if it is perceived as a ‘common trade diplomacy – have been evolving in economic power’.3 Europe for several years already, both at the member state and EU level.5 This is not This Clingendael Policy Brief explicates surprising, as the growing global economic recent efforts in Brussels to develop interconnectedness has increased the a European economic diplomacy, and relative weight of economic and trade-related discusses whether there could indeed issues within the foreign and security policy be added value to European economic realm, thereby also raising the relevance of diplomacy – including a distinct EU element4 economic diplomacy.6 Governments of EU – for EU member states and European member states, including the Netherlands, businesses. Our analysis moves from a conceptual distinction between European economic diplomacy, which refers to the collection of strategies and actions of the EU 5 This Clingendael Policy Brief adopts a and EU member states (in coordination with comprehensive definition of economic diplomacy, private actors) in this field, and EU economic including activities in the field of trade and diplomacy, which only includes the policies investment promotion (commercial diplomacy), trade negotiations, global financial governance, and activities of EU institutions. Such a development assistance efforts and sanctions. distinction is important, as it highlights how This differs from the narrow definition of some EU the EU level is just one building block of countries, which regard economic diplomacy as the European Union, and its purposes are little more than business support. For more on this, quite broad in that they include both internal as well as on recent trends in economic diplomacy, (intra-EU) and external elements. see Maaike Okano-Heijmans, 2016, ‘Economic Diplomacy’, in: Costas Constantinou, Paul Sharp Could joint economic diplomacy be a way for and Pauline Kerr (eds), The SAGE Handbook of Europe to stop punching below its weight Diplomacy, London: SAGE (forthcoming in June). in the global (economic) arena, by fostering 6 For more on this, see, for example, Peter A.G. Van Bergeijk, Maaike Okano-Heijmans and Jan Melissen (eds), 2011, Economic Diplomacy: Economic and Political Perspectives, Leiden and Boston: Brill; and Stephen Woolcock, 2012, 3 See, for example, Chad Damro, 2012, ‘Market Power European Union Economic Diplomacy: The Role of Europe’, Journal of European Public Policy, 19 (5). the EU in External Economic Relations, Burlington, 4 See also the paragraphs below on Adding Value. VT and Farnham: Ashgate, esp. pp. 10–11. 2 Clingendael Policy Brief Denmark, the United Kingdom (UK) and the EU to step up its efforts in the field of Germany, have strengthened trade and economic diplomacy. This appears to be all investment promotion abroad, or commercial the more relevant given that around 90 per diplomacy. In addition, companies – rather cent of global growth is now coming from than non-governmental organizations – outside of Europe, hence making the need returned to centre stage in the delivery of to tap effectively into the ‘new markets’ even development assistance. The trend is to move stronger. A more sophisticated European away from global social quality thinking in economic diplomacy could contribute to development towards stimulating progress European Commission President Jean- by way of creating economic opportunities. Claude Juncker’s central policy goal of In this regard, improving access to finance strengthening growth and employment levels for European companies by broadening in the EU. For this to be possible, however, the mandate and the scope of action of the the still-standing unnatural dichotomy European Investment Bank (EIB) could prove between trade policy and trade promotion very useful for developing new projects – will have to be overcome, in EU legislation as which could contribute to growth and greater well as in economic practice. Moreover, in a stability, also in Europe’s neighbourhood.7 world of shifting power balances, fostering policy linkages across various fields – as Brussels’ new EU trade strategy of per High Representative/Vice-President October 20158 displays a similar and Federica Mogherini’s aspiration – is a dire unprecedented willingness to use political necessity. The need for more sophisticated tools for economic objectives and economic policies that ‘connect the dots’ between instruments for political purposes in new trade and investment, resource and food ways. Free-trade agreements are now a security, migration, global economic and tool not only to promote (economic) value, financial governance, and (sustainable) but also European values – ranging from development are now more essential than labour rights and civil liberties to sustainable during earlier times. development and market capitalism.9 This heralds a new era in EU trade diplomacy, To argue that synergies between policy wherein normative content is incorporated areas can and should be improved is into the more effective sides of the EU’s clearly not to say that EU action in (m)any clout. Economic power undoubtedly has of these fields is new. International trade the lion’s share herein. and investment negotiations, international financial regulation, environmental policy
Recommended publications
  • The Modernization of the European Union's Customs Union with Turkey
    Working Paper SWP Working Papers are online publications within the purview of the respective Research Division. Unlike SWP Research Papers and SWP Comments they are not reviewed by the Institute. CENTRE FOR APPLIED TURKEY STUDIES(CATS) | WP NR. 05, SEPTEMBER 2020 The Modernization of the European Union's Customs Union with Turkey Turkey's Pro-Customs Union Rhetoric and Recent Approach of Turkish Political and Business Decision-Makers Doruk Arbay Contents The project 3 The future of the EU's Customs Union with Turkey 3 Summary 4 Current Status and Approach of Turkish Political and Business Decision-Makers 4 A Brief Recap of the Customs Union and Transformation 6 Origins of Motivation for a Modernized Customs Union 9 Current Stance of the Turkish Administration, Political Parties and Business Organizations towards Modernization of the Customs Union 10 Government and the Administration 10 Opposition Parties and the Nationalist Movement Party 22 Business Decision-Makers 26 Future and Conclusion 31 Abbreviations 34 The project The future of the EU's Customs Union with Turkey Still a candidate for membership in the European Union, Turkey has outgrown the status of one-sided dependency on the EU. Ankara developed a more independent foreign policy that entails both areas for cooperation with Brussels but also for conflicts with the EU and its member states. Cases in point are the cooperation on migration on the one hand side and tensions with Greece and Cyprus in the eastern Mediterranean on the other. The EU needs working channels for communication and cooperation with Turkey. However, membership negations stall, talk on visa liberalization stuck, and the European Council blocks the opening of talks to re-negotiate the Customs Union.
    [Show full text]
  • Smes Going International! the Network of Czechtrade Agency Offices Abroad
    Published by www.cebre.cz volume X, 4-2011 News Flash >Better access to finance The CzeCh RepubliC shaRes for start-up Businesses The Czech Republic launched the ConCeRns of illiCiT TobaCCo TRade programme INOSTART that will EU faces an uphill battle to stem the flow of illegal will mean huge costs for retailers along with an explosion help start-up businesses get credit cigarettes pouring through its borders and across its in black market, presenting a threat to more than half a needed for their running or expansion Member States, warned the International Tax and million small retail businesses in the EU,” said Giovanni in the field of innovation business. The Investment Centre (ITIC) the participants at a meeting on Risso, Chairman of the CEDT as well as President of the start-up businesses will obtain a state intellectual property, counterfeiting and piracy hosted by Federation of Italian Tobacconists. Retailers’ livelihoods guarantee up to 60% of their credit. the European Parliament’s Kangaroo Group on May 26 are already suffering the impact of illegal cigarettes sold at Total budget of this programme is in Brussels. Illegal cigarettes account for approximately low prices, with businesses closing down in some cases. CZK200 million and each project 9% of all cigarettes consumed across the EU, costing Standardized packaging would make products even can be guaranteed in the range of governments an estimated €10 billion in lost tax revenues easier to counterfeit and banning ingredients would simply CZK500.000 to CZK15 million. each year. However, the consequences of illicit trade reach mean that smugglers would bring in the very products the far beyond government revenue loss.
    [Show full text]
  • PARTNERS Is a EUROCHAMBRES Initiative, Supported by the European Commission Under the 2003 Regional CARDS Programme. It Is A
    PARTNERS is a EUROCHAMBRES initiative, supported by the European Commission under the 2003 Regional CARDS Programme. It is a capacity building programme for Chambers of Commerce and Industry and other business organisations in Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Serbia and Montenegro, in the area of intra-regional trade and international trade services Introduction Co-operation with the Western Balkans continues to rank high in the EU post-2004 Enlargement agenda. The prospect of EU membership represents an incentive for growth of the Western Balkan economies. In this favourable environment, Chambers of Commerce, especially at the regional and local level, should be empowered to drive forward the economic recovery and assist enterprises in carrying out their local or international ambitions. The PARTNERS project, launched by EUROCHAMBRES with the support of the European Commission, therefore focused on the enhancement of Chambers’ capacity in the areas of internationalisation and local development. Amongst other activities, PARTNERS included the establishment of 15 partnerships between selected Chambers from the Western Balkans and the EU-25 countries. The idea behind these partnerships is that a new service or management change be implemented in Western Balkan Chambers, thanks to the transfer of know-how from their EU counterparts. After the selection and match-making phase, 15 detailed action plans were drawn on the basis of the information gathered and ideas exchanged during the inception visits carried out by each EU Chamber to their partner. The partnership projects were launched at the joint kick-off meeting which was held in Zagreb (Croatia) on 16-17 December 2004.
    [Show full text]
  • Contracting Authority: EUROCHAMBRES Eu4business: Connecting Companies Project Reference: ENI/2019/411-865
    Contracting Authority: EUROCHAMBRES EU4Business: Connecting Companies Project Reference: ENI/2019/411-865 Call for Proposals Guidelines for grant applicants with the modifications published in the ERRATUM Selection of Business Support Organisations Deadline for submission1 of applications: 30 April 2021 at 17:00 (Brussels date and time) NOTICE Eligibility of the full grant proposal will be checked against the checklist of the grant applications forms and supporting documents requested in the present guidelines. To apply to this call for proposals organisations must submit the full grant application forms through the e-submission form (see section 2.2.5 of the guidelines). The aim of the e-submission form is to increase the efficiency of the management of the call for proposals and to offer a better service to business support organisations through a new panel of functionalities such as the online submission and the possibility to follow up online the processing of their application. All organisations can find the call, the e-submission form and the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) published together with all the documents to be provided for this call on the website of the project. You may also contact our technical support team via the online support form in the e-submission pages. 1 Online submission via e-submission is mandatory for this call for proposals (see Section 2.5.2). Dates and times are expressed in Brussels time. Applicants should note that the IT support is open Monday to Friday from 00:00 to 12:00 and from 13:00 to 17:00 Brussels time (except for public holidays).
    [Show full text]
  • Working for European Business Our Network 44 National Chamber Organisations
    Working for European Business Our Network 44 National Chamber Organisations +1,941 Chambers of Commerce THE NETWORK +18,873,000 Enterprises 120,000,000 Employees OUR MEMBERS 44 National Chamber Organisations 44 National Chamber Organisations 1. Albania 16. Georgia 32. Poland 2. Armenia 17. Germany 33. Portugal 3. Austria 34. Romania 18. Greece 4. Azerbaijan 35. Russia 5. Belarus 19. Hungary 36. Serbia & Montenegro 6. Belgium 20. Iceland 37. Slovakia 7. Bosnia & 21. Ireland 38. Slovenia Herzegovina 22. Israel 39. Spain 8. Bulgaria 40. Sweden 23. Italy 9. Croatia 41. Switzerland 10. Cyprus 24. Latvia 42. Turkey 11. Czech Republic 25. Lithuania 43. Ukraine 12. Denmark 26. Luxembourg 44. United Kingdom 13. Estonia 27. FYR of Macedonia 14. Finland 28. Malta 15. France 29. Moldova 30. Netherlands 31. Norway EU 25: 1,048 Chambers of Commerce Malta 1 Luxembourg 1 Denmark 1 Estonia 1 Lithuania 6 Cyprus 6 Mandatory Affiliation Latvia 8 Portugal 8 Voluntary Affiliation Slovakia 10 Austria 10 Sweden 13 Slovenia 14 The Netherlands 22 Finland 22 Hungary 24 UK 52 Ireland 60 Greece 60 Belgium 60 Czech Republic 85 Spain 93 Germany 94 Italy 123 Poland 129 France 181 0 50 100 150 200 Number of Chambers NON EU: 803 Chambers of Commerce A zerb aijan 1 Iceland 1 M o ld o va 1 Israel 7 Mandatory Affiliation Geo rg ia 7 A rmenia 12 Voluntary Affiliation N o rway 16 FYROM 16 Bosnia-Herzegovina 16 Switzerland 20 C ro at ia 21 Serbia & M ontenegro 21 U kraine 28 B ulg aria 29 A lb ania 37 B elarus 38 R o mania 42 Russian Federation 162 T urkey 365 0 50 100 150
    [Show full text]
  • Host Entrepreneurs
    Registration Guide- Host entrepreneurs SuppSuppo Erasmus for Young Entrepreneurs Support Office co/EUROCHAMBRES 1 http://www.erasmus-entrepreneurs.eu Table of contents Background and purpose of the guide................................................................ 3 STEP 1 – Preparing your registration ................................................................. 3 Eligibility criteria................................................................................................. 3 Minimum quality standards ............................................................................... 4 The motivations and expectations should be clearly expressed ......................... 4 STEP 2 – Register! .............................................................................................. 5 Welcome page of the application form for host entrepreneurs ......................... 6 Your Profile ........................................................................................................ 7 Motivation ......................................................................................................... 9 Languages ........................................................................................................ 11 Business sector ................................................................................................. 12 Geographical preferences ................................................................................ 13 Duration and period of the exchange period...................................................
    [Show full text]
  • European Alliance for Apprenticeships: Good for Youth, Good for Business
    Good for Youth Good for Business European Alliance for Apprenticeships Social Europe Manuscript completed in September 2019 Neither the European Commission nor any person acting on behalf of the Commission is responsible for the use that might be made of the following information. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union, 2019 © European Union, 2019 Reuse is authorised provided the source is acknowledged. The reuse policy of European Commission documents is regulated by Decision 2011/833/EU (OJ L 330, 14.12.2011, p. 39). © Shutterstock, 2019 unless specified For any use or reproduction of photos or other material that is not under the EU copyright, permission must be sought directly from the copyright holders. Print ISBN 978-92-76-09821-8 doi:10.2767/141129 KE-03-19-626-EN-C PDF ISBN 978-92-76-09822-5 doi:10.2767/040603 KE-03-19-626-EN-N Good for Youth Good for Business European Alliance for Apprenticeships EUROPEAN ALLIANCE FOR APPRENTICESHIPS Content Preface ........................................................................................................................................................................................................6 Foreword ....................................................................................................................................................................................................7 The policy context ................................................................................................................................................................................8
    [Show full text]
  • Registration Guide- New Entrepreneurs
    Registration Guide- New entrepreneurs SuppSuppo Erasmus for Young Entrepreneurs Support Office co/EUROCHAMBRES 1 http://www.erasmus-entrepreneurs.eu Table of contents Background and purpose of the guide ............................................................... 3 STEP 1 – Preparing your registrFation ............................................................. 3 Eligibility criteria................................................................................................. 3 Minimum quality standards ............................................................................... 4 STEP 2 – Register! ........................................................................................... 5 Welcome page of the application form for new entrepreneurs ......................... 6 Your Profile ........................................................................................................ 6 Motivation ......................................................................................................... 7 Languages ........................................................................................................ 10 Business sector ................................................................................................. 10 Geographical preferences ................................................................................ 12 Duration and period of the exchange period ................................................... 13 Selection of an Intermediary Organisation and submission .............................
    [Show full text]
  • Eurochambres
    Eurochambres Eurochambres is the Association of European Chambers of Commerce and Industry. The association is one of the largest business representative organisations in Brussels, representing over 20 million companies through 45 members (43 national associations of chambers of commerce and industry and 2 transnational Eurochambres logo chamber organisations) and a European network of 1,700 regional and local Chambers. More than 93% of these businesses are small and medium sized enterprises. Eurochambres' direct members are national associations of Chambers of Commerce based in 26 European Union countries, European Free Trade Association countries, and some Eastern European, Western Balkans and Mediterranean countries. Eurochambres represents, serves and promotes European Chambers of Commerce and Industry through lobbying, development of projects and services to members. Contents History Current leadership Members See also External links History Eurochambres was founded 28 February 1958 as the "Conférence Permanente des Chambres de Commerce et d’Industrie de la CEE" by six members with the mission to promote the views of Chamber organisations on the unification of national legislation at the European level and to form opinions regarding the modifications to be made to commercial legislation. An important objective of the Conférence was also to bring closer competences in order to provide an example of the European cooperation of the highest quality level. The Conférence Permanente held its first assembly in Strasbourg on 28 February 1958. Initial members were national association of Chambers of Commerce and Industry from Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg and Netherlands. The year 1961 saw the creation of the first technical committees and 4 new members joined.
    [Show full text]
  • EUROCHAMBRES Economic Survey 2020
    1 EUROCHAMBRES Economic Survey 2020 Contents Foreword ........................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgments ............................................................................................ 4 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 5 Methodology ..................................................................................................... 5 E xecutive S ummary .......................................................................................... 6 Results ............................................................................................................... 7 Policy Recommendations ............................................................................. 16 Notes .............................................................................................................. 18 Appendix ......................................................................................................... 19 Summary infographic available here 2 EUROCHAMBRES Economic Survey 2020 Foreword Nearly 53.000 entrepreneurs from 28 European countries contributed to the 27th edition of the EUROCHAMBRES Economic Survey. Our respondents are less optimistic this year and identified a range of challenges for 2020. The results, gathered by national Chambers across the EUROCHAMBRES network, reveal domestic demand and a lack of skilled workers as the main concerns of European businesses. Europe’s
    [Show full text]
  • Economic Transitions in Central and Eastern Europe: Any Lessons for the Arab Spring?
    ISSN 1883-1656 Центр Российских Исследований RRC Working Paper Series No. 36 Economic Transitions in Central and Eastern Europe: Any Lessons for the Arab Spring? Peter Havlik June 2012 RUSSIAN RESEARCH CENTER INSTITUTE OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH HITOTSUBASHI UNIVERSITY Kunitachi, Tokyo, JAPAN Economic Transitions in Central and Eastern Europe: Any Lessons for the Arab Spring? By Peter Havlik The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies (wiiw) Executive summary This paper discusses the key reform agenda and economic characteristics of selected Middle East and North Africa (MENA) countries in comparison with transition countries in Central, East and Southeast Europe (CESEE). By looking at the latter’s transition experi- ences we draw policy lessons for current MENA transitions in the wake of the Arab Spring. Policies aiming at the liberalization of domestic and international markets, privatization and increased competition in the state-controlled sectors, as well as institutional reforms an- chored in the international context are broadly similar tasks facing both regions. However, there are also a number of substantial differences in development levels, demographic, social and other characteristics. MENA have not (at least so far) suffered from ‘transforma- tional recessions’ like the CESEE in the early 1990s; they were also largely spared the effects of the recent crisis which hit the CESEE disproportionally hard. The main task in the MENA countries will typically be a thorough modernization and ex- pansion based in part on already existing structures with the help of external assistance and foreign direct investment (FDI). Most MENA countries have been lagging behind in terms of export performance, competitiveness and trade restructuring.
    [Show full text]
  • EUROCHAMBRES Declaration of European Solidarity and Recovery
    15 April 2020 EUROCHAMBRES Declaration of European Solidarity and Recovery The COVID-19 pandemic is the greatest crisis encountered since the EU project began. It is of course first and foremost a public health emergency, but the impact will reverberate across the continent’s economy and society for many years to come. Containment remains the priority and our current focus is naturally on those closest to us. Notwithstanding this, pan-European cooperation is essential to our revival: we are confronted with a symmetric recession, so we need to work together to identify and pursue a coordinated response. European integration was born out of crisis and its subsequent development has been based on the principles of collaboration and solidarity, in both good times and bad. We are now encountering the toughest of times and must remain resolute to these principles. Half measures are not an option in responding to this unprecedented and damaging economic slowdown; we must put in place a robust, ambitious strategy and ensure the necessary financial resources for an extraordinary recovery effort. Our economic recovery depends on the full engagement of all citizens, all stakeholders and all levels of governance across Europe. With this declaration, the Presidency of EUROCHAMBRES demonstrates the commitment of the Chamber network to cooperate with policy-makers and civil society to define and implement a plan for Europe’s revival. Chambers of Commerce & Industry have never been closer to their members than they are now. Based on this proximity to millions of European businesses across 43 countries, we are pleased to provide below our initial input for the forthcoming EU Recovery Roadmap and Action Plan.
    [Show full text]