In G. B. Falda's Engraving of the Vatican Gardens We See the Villa
BRAMANTE AND THE REDISCOVERY OF AXIAL PLANNING
at this time, and to accommodate them the garden APOTHEOSES OF THE who was responsible for several excavations including began to assume the role of outdoor museum. In RENAISSANCE VILLA GARDEN: that of nearby Hadrian’s Villa and for the rediscovery addition to the Belvedere Court at the Vatican, Bra- VILLA D’ESTE AND VILLA LANTE of many antique marbles, mosaics, and other artifacts. mante built a giardino segreto, the so-called Statue Although Castello and the Boboli Gardens contained Being a wealthy humanist collector, Ippolito had, in Court, located between the upper court and the water features symbolically associated with Duke fact, put Ligorio on his payroll as his personal archae- Belvedere, for Pope Julius II’s collection of antique Cosimo’s reputation as a builder of aqueducts, it is to ologist in 1550, the year in which he had been sculpture. In 1584, Cardinal Fernando de’ Medici the Roman Campagna that we must turn to find gar- appointed to the Tivoli post and had begun to dream bought the collection amassed some sixty years ear- dens that apotheosize water and use it with the inven- of a great hillside garden below the palace. One part lier by Cardinal Andrea della Valle, sending the free- tiveness of a choreographer directing the movements of Ligorio’s job was undoubtedly to garner antique standing pieces to Florence to embellish the Boboli of the dance or the creativity of a sculptor exploring marbles to combine with contemporary sculpture in Gardens and keeping the reliefs to decorate the facade the plasticity of clay. These effects were accomplished allegorical compositions throughout the garden. of his villa on the Pincian Hill in Rome. through the ingenuity of sixteenth-century fontanieri, Although Ligorio was himself a sufficiently Inspired by the discoveries of classical archae- virtuosic hydraulic engineers with an understanding accomplished classicist to develop the various icono- ology, patrons commissioned new sculpture. The of metaphysics as well as physics and a reputation graphic themes that would portray the humanistic notion became firmly established that the garden was akin to that of magicians because of the ingenuity of ideals of the cardinal, he was probably assisted by the a setting in which white marble figures should be seen their creations.14 In the gardens of Villa d’Este water cardinal’s resident poet, Marc-Antoine Muret (1526– against dark green foliage or framed by architectural reaches a height of expressiveness that is analogous 1585).15 After 1560, Giovanni Alberti Galvani served niches within building facades and garden walls. The not only with dance and sculpture, but with music as as superintending architect in charge of overseeing humanists’ interest in classical mythology furnished well. For it is the drip and gurgle, the murmur and the construction of masonry stairs, fountains, fish HUMANISM AND THE ROLE OF artists with thematic material, which they wove into roar, the splash and tinkle, as well as the cooling spray, ponds, and other features. Professional fontanieri were SCULPTURE, NATURE, AND narrative itineraries. Familiar literary themes that of water everywhere that has made this garden unfor- hired to develop the water devices that operated the SYMBOLS OF PRESTIGE IN found expression in the garden included those of the gettable to visitors through the centuries. spectacular fountains. GARDEN ICONOGRAPHY Golden Age, Elysium, rustic goodness, Venus presid- Like other superb gardens, Villa d’Este is the The construction of the gardens of the Villa 4.16. Oval court, Villa Pia, Vati- In G. B. Falda’s engraving of the Vatican Gardens we ing over the Garden of Love, Apollo, the Muses, product of a passionate obsession on the part of an d’Este continued over a twenty-two-year period until can Gardens, Rome. Designed see the Villa Pia, also called the Casino Pio, built by Mount Parnassus, and the virtuous hero assigned owner willing to spend extraordinary sums of money the cardinal’s death in 1572, when work stopped by Pirro Ligorio. 1560 Pirro Ligorio for Pope Pius IV in 1560. Like the Villa near-impossible tasks or waylaid by treacherous and with the taste to hire the best design talent avail- abruptly. Contemporary visitors, including the French Giulia it has a spatially ambiguous plan that visually enchantments. able. In 1550, the cardinal of Ferrara, Ippolito D’Este essayist Montaigne (1533–1592), lamented their unfin- pulls one in and through while making physical pas- An important element of Renaissance garden (1509–1572), was appointed governor of Tivoli by ished state, although in the seventeenth century, when sage at first appear occluded. At the same time, it iconography was nature itself. One sees, for instance, Pope Julius III. Tivoli, an ancient Roman summer inheritance problems engendered by Cardinal provides an example of another important Renais- in the bosco above the Belvedere Court and the Villa resort about twenty miles west of Rome, was not Ippolito’s will were finally resolved, Cardinal Alessan- sance Italian contribution to the tradition of garden Pia in the Vatican Gardens, the desire for a wildwood, only the site of Hadrian’s Villa, but of many other sec- dro d’Este undertook some restoration and improve- design: the casino, or summerhouse, built as a retreat an evocation of the sacred grove in antiquity. Simi- ond century C.E. patrician villas. Its desirability then ments. While vegetative growth, alterations, and from the bustle and ceremony of court life. Here the larly, it is reported that Pope Julius III, with his taste as later was due to the waters of the Aniene River, periodic lack of maintenance have blurred some of pope held soirées at which invited scholars sat around for simple country food, peasant dances, and wine fes- which came cascading dramatically down steep the formality seen in a contemporary engraving, we an oval court discussing philosophy, poetry, and reli- tivals, enjoyed strolling in the untamed parts of his precipices; to its salubrious mineral springs; and to can still discern Ligorio’s design and, with the help of gion. Discussion groups had become an important vigna (literally vineyard, the term contemporaries the excellent drinking water that was channeled from modern scholarship, decode the humanist themes that part of the intellectual life of Renaissance men of let- used for a suburban villa retreat). These were abun- several sources along the riverbank to four major are woven into its fabric: Nature’s abundance and gen- ters, and Ligorio’s oval, which is embraced by exedras dant with wildlife, melodious with birdsong, and aqueducts serving the Roman metropolis. An aque- erosity and the relationship between Art and Nature— of carved stone seats, is an architectural expression adorned with works of art. Like their ancient prede- duct carrying water from the Rivellese Spring, the cost one of the central preoccupations of the Renaissance of the humanists’ pleasure in scholarly conversation cessors, Renaissance villa owners wanted their groves of which was borne by both the cardinal and the town (figs. 4.17–4.20). In parsing the humanist meaning of (fig. 4.16). to be haunted by the sculptural representatives of of Tivoli, which also benefited, was built in 1561 after the garden, which besides expressing the Art–Nature The recovery of the art and architecture of river gods, nymphs, satyrs, Pan, Diana, and Venus. work on the garden had begun in earnest. duality has many references to the virtuous mytho- antiquity provided villa designers with immediate Added to this literary agenda was another, more The governor’s palace, a perquisite of the cardi- logical hero Hercules, here identified with Cardinal sources of inspiration. As an archaeologist, Ligorio obvious, motive for the development of Renaissance nal’s appointment, was part of an old Franciscan d’Este, one should remember that the original public himself had thoroughly explored Hadrian’s Villa on garden iconography: the aggrandizement of the gar- monastery beside the Church of Santa Maria Mag- entry to the garden was not from the villa, but rather behalf of the Este family, and the mosaics that embel- den owners’ reputations through symbols, with the giore at the top of a hill adjacent to the western town from a gate in the outer wall set in the hillside below. lish the loggia of the Villa Pia and the arched portals implication that the patrons’ power was being put to wall. Pirro Ligorio was commissioned to oversee the Standing on the balcony of the villa today, the entering the court reveal a renewed appreciation of beneficent use for humankind. Increasingly, after the renovation of the palace into a summer residence suit- visitor looks beyond the verdant mature tree canopy ancient Roman decorative art. Low reliefs in stucco middle of the sixteenth century, Italian gardens able for Cardinal Ippolito, the son of Duke Alfonso I of the gardens to the distant hills. Below is the Car- found on ancient Roman baths, palaces, and villas became manifestations of princely power. This was of Ferrara and Lucrezia Borgia. But the palace was to dinal’s Walk and the rainbow spray of Bernini’s sev- were echoed at the Villa Pia and elsewhere.13 true in Florence as well as in Rome, although such be a relatively minor element of the entire project; as enteenth-century Fountain of the Great Beaker, Along with the wall frescoes and mosaics Tuscan gardens as the Medici villa at Castello the cardinal had already demonstrated at a villa he had which mingles visually with the watery plume of the uncovered by sixteenth-century archaeologists, remained much more conservative in design than did rented on the Quirinal in Rome, gardens were his pas- Fountain of the Dragons beneath it. The dragons ancient marble sculptures were being excavated from the dazzling villa creations of the popes and cardinals sion. In Ligorio he had not only a capable designer but symbolize the ones guarding the Garden of the Hes- the Roman soil. Several great collections were formed in and around Rome. also the foremost archaeologist of his day, the person perides, which were slain by Hercules. Descending
138 139 villa d’este
4.19. Oval Fountain
4.17. Villa d’Este, Tivoli. Designed by Pirro Ligorio. 1550–72. Panoramic view after an engraving by Étienne Dupérac. 1573
The traditional plan of most Italian the garden’s iconography. Nature is dra- as the dramatic sheer spill we see today. enclosed piazza, stands the principal Renaissance gardens—a plan in which matically manifested in the Fountain of The human ability to employ the fountain of the garden, the Fountain of there are compartmentalized beds near Nature, also known as the Water Organ, resources of nature toward fruitful ends Tivoli, or as it is now known, the Oval the villa and, as one approaches the culminating the water axis on the north- constitutes Art, which is celebrated along Fountain (fig. 4.19). A colossal statue of outer limits of the property, a surround- east (fig. 4.18). Following a “concert,” the second major cross-axis, the Alley of Albunea, the Tiburtine Sibyl, presides ing screen of trees—has been reversed which occurred when water pressure the Hundred Fountains (fig. 4.20). The over the cascade, which is furnished by here because of the nature of the site. A was manipulated to trap and release air Alley itself is composed of three conduits water from the River Aniene, which wooded slope with diagonal paths to in its pipes, a fontaniere would flush the symbolizing the three tributaries of the flows into an oval basin surmounted by accommodate the steep grade lies vaulted chambers behind the elaborate Tiber—the Albuneo, the Aniene, and the a ball; its spurting jets delineate the Este directly beneath the retaining wall sup- facade, and a deluge would spill down Erculaneo—which flow toward Rome. fleur de lys. The sources of the Aniene porting the villa terrace. Where the val- the steep slope. This effect was made The art of channeling their waters into and the Erculaneo are represented as ley has been remodeled by an extensive permanent in the twentieth-century Foun- aqueducts was an important factor in the reclining river gods set in naturalistic process of cutting and filling to create tain of the Cascade, an enormous water- life of the recently reborn metropolis. grottoes built into the surrounding slope. an apron of level terrain and a geometri- fall pouring into the pond below. An Along the upper rim, water is channeled Crowning this artificial rock work is a cally pitched northeast side slope, earlier cascade was created here by the between carved obelisks, boats, eagles, statue of Pegasus, the magical horse cross-axes divide the garden into square seventeenth-century architect, sculptor, and fleurs de lys (the last two forms being whose hoofprints supposedly struck compartments. and fountain designer, Gianlorenzo emblematic of the Este family). water out of Mount Parnassos, thereby 4.18. Fountain of Nature, engraving by Giovanni Francesco Venturini, plate 13 from Le 4.20. Alley of the Hundred Fountains The relationship between Art and Bernini (1598–1680); it fell in successive At the northeast end of the Alley of creating the fountain of the Muses and Fontane del Giardino Estense in Tivoli, con li loro prospeti, e Vedute della Cascata del Nature constitutes the principal theme of stages like a natural waterfall rather than the Hundred Fountains, within an proclaiming the power of Art. Fiume Aniene, Parte Quarta. n.d.
140 141 BRAMANTE AND THE REDISCOVERY OF AXIAL PLANNING
one of the diagonal ramps, one comes to the Alley of device with great appeal to the humanist imagination. the Hundred Fountains composed of three conduits Cardinal Gambara was given the bishopric of symbolizing the three tributaries of the Tiber, which Viterbo in 1566, and two years later received confir- flow from the hills of Tivoli toward Rome. Here mation of one of the perquisites of his office, prop- water is channeled between carved obelisks, boats, erty rights in the old hunting park at Bagnaia. His eagles, and fleur de lys (the last two forms being predecessors had enclosed the park, which consisted emblematic of the Este family) and pours from one of the wooded slope of Monte Sant’Angelo, and had basin into another through grotesque animal heads. built the aqueduct that brought water to the town as After visiting the Fountain of Tivoli and the well as to the park. A small hunting lodge was the Fountain of the Rometta, a water feature that was only structure on the property when the cardinal con- fashioned of stucco-covered brick to represent ancient ceived the notion of building a great villa garden Rome in miniature, one returns to descend one arm there. In place of the barco, or park for hunting, there of the sweeping oval staircase and gaze back up at the would be a twenty-acre bosco with the kinds of mes- villa through the spray of the Dragon Fountain. Tak- sages of allusion that a humanist scholar steeped in ing the central staircase, which has channels of clear the literature of antiquity would have sought. Con- water running down its flanking walls, one arrives at tinuing this iconographic narrative, there would be a the next level, that of the fish ponds. Here, looking formal garden in which Art gained the upper hand back toward the villa, one realizes that Ligorio has over Nature, in celebration of the cardinal’s magnifi- repeated Bramante’s design for the Belvedere Court cence and benefactions to the people of Viterbo. as a series of descending terraces organized around The designer of Villa Lante is almost universally a central axis. But there is an important difference: believed to have been the architect Giacomo da Vig- Bramante’s Renaissance garden could be grasped in nola, whose services Cardinal Gambara begged of his its entirety from a single vantage point within the Vat- friend Cardinal Alessandro Farnese, as Vignola was ican Palace, but the Villa d’Este cannot be taken in then engaged upon another important garden com- altogether. Not only is it more spatially intricate than mission at the Villa Farnese nearby at Caprarola. Con- the Bramante prototype, but it is also a programmatic struction proceeded over the next decade, and in garden, one in which the separate parts are meant to August 1579, a lavish banquet was given there for be experienced sequentially as part of a humanist itin- Pope Gregory XIII (papacy 1572–1585), after which erary that celebrates the importance of Cardinal the pontiff promptly canceled Gambara’s pension. sage of the park and its adjacent garden. It develops eled visually for the most part; one walks alongside it, 4.21. The Villa Lante, Viterbo. d’Este and the noble family of which he was the most Knowing that Gambara had been appointed by Pope through design, as at the Villa d’Este, the age-old perceiving it perhaps more powerfully for this very Designed probably by Giacomo Barozzi da Vignola. conspicuous representative. Today, it is shorn of much Gregory’s predecessor, the reform-minded Pius V theme of relationship among humans, art, and reason. And, instead of the architectural climax of the c. 1568–1579 of the sculptural decoration because the cardinal’s (papacy 1566–1572), and that he was a prominent offi- nature, while symbolically portraying the heroic Belvedere exedra, here the central axis simply melts fine collection of antique statuary was sold in the cer of the Inquisition, we may find it strange that he efforts of one man in bringing the three into such an into nature as it ends in the Fountain of the Deluge. eighteenth century. While this loss deprives the villa would build opulently, in a style derived from pagan enriching harmony as to constitute a second Golden of iconographic specificity and thematic continuity, art and literature. That, however, was the mentality Age (figs. 4.21–4.27).16 Thus, the humanistic text EXTRAVAGANT EPITOME OF the garden tour that was once enjoyed by the cardi- of a proud and wealthy aristocrat whose appointment encoded in its design program gives, as does that of HUMANIST ALLEGORY: nal’s guests and subsequent travelers nevertheless had as much to do with politics as with piety. the contemporary Villa d’Este, a literary dimension THE SACRO BOSCO AT BOMARZO remains a memorable experience for modern visitors. While the garden is the renowned part of Villa to the garden experience, and the presence through- We must turn to Bomarzo near Viterbo, the garden Contemporary with the Villa d’Este is Cardinal Lante and the park is often neglected by visitors, one out the garden of the cardinal’s device in the form of of Cardinal Gambara’s friend Count Pier Francesco Giovanni Francesco Gambara’s garden at Bagnaia, should tour the bosco first in order to follow the itin- a crayfish (a visual pun matching his family name, Orsini (1513?–1584), to see the arcane climax of three miles east of the town of Viterbo. It is known erary planned by Cardinal Gambara. The bosco evokes Gambara, with gambero, the word for “crayfish” in Ital- humanism as a programmatic factor in garden design. today by the name of its seventeenth-century own- the Golden Age myth, investing it with another, that ian) suggests his achievement. The epic poem Orlando Furioso, completed in 1532 by ers, the Lante family. Like the Villa d’Este, it offers a of a punishing flood familiar to readers of the Old Tes- Inspired by a sense of ancient geometry and pro- Ludovico Ariosto (1473–1533), as well as Virgil’s virtuosic expression of Bramantian axial planning tament. In the classical version, because of human portion as well as by the iconographic program Aeneid, Dante’s Inferno, and probably the writings of combined with a highly imaginative use of water. Also wickedness, Jupiter, like Jehovah in the Hebrew scrip- derived from antique themes, the Villa Lante can be Petrarch, provided inspiration for this enigmatic land- like the Villa d’Este, the Villa Lante is filled with an tures, became angry and decided to destroy the earth seen in plan as a counterpoint of circles and squares. scape in which Count Orsini manipulated scale and allusive iconography wedding humanist learning to with a flood so mighty that dolphins could be found It is finally this balance and harmony of design, and perspective to create an itinerary of unusual scenes personal glory and family pride. It bears further sim- swimming in the forest. Only two virtuous humans not the messages of a new Golden Age under Pius V studded with bizarre sculpture and architectural mon- ilarity in being a garden that is meant not to be taken were left to repopulate, and their descendants were or Cardinal Gambara’s prestige in the guise of human- uments forming a series of tableaux, each serving as in all at once, but rather as sequential stops along a compelled to labor in order to make the earth fruitful. ism, that account for the deep pleasure that so many a riddle to be decoded by his guests. prescribed route that move the visitor off the central The garden spells out the virtues of Cardinal visitors have experienced in viewing it. In creating a It was only gradually that Bomarzo assumed its axis. Here, however, the garden itinerary has a pro- Gambara, who made the surrounding land more hillside garden built upon a clear, strong axis, its sev- character as an enchanted forest, or sacro bosco, as the logue as one is meant to pass first through the kind of bountiful and, in the tradition of classical civilization, eral terraces linked by stairs, Vignola displayed a debt count developed one part after another into an itin- “dark wood” traversed by certain literary figures as was a patron of the arts enabling the human spirit to to Bramante. But he altered and expanded Bramante’s erary of personal history and symbolical discovery. they started out on their journeys of initiation, a reach its highest potential. This, in brief, is the mes- design means. His axis is aquatic and can only be trav- For instance, the gruesome tableau of a stone giant
142 143 villa lante
Above left: 4.25. Water Chain
Above: 4.26. River Gods representing the Tiber and the Arno
Left: 4.27. Boxwood compartments and Water Parterre