The Futility of the Great Lockdown Melodrama
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Q ua dr a nt $8.90 Australia I M arch 2021 How the I highest levels V ol.65 of the police, judiciary and N o.3 politicians in Australia, M plus victim arch 2021 lobby groups, compensation The Futility of the Great lawyers, and journalists, Lockdowneter urphy Melodrama used bogus P M accusations Losing Faith in the Future of Democracy of child sexual David Martin Jones abuse to NEW China:NEW Our Generation’s Greatest Challenge persecute, Ted O’Brien convict The Indigenous Invasion of Aboriginal Australia and jail an Patrick McCauley innocent man. Australian Imams Stand Up for Sharia Mark Durie Black Lives Matter: Myths and Facts William D. Rubinstein THE PERSECUTION OF GEORGE PELL uncovers the To get their man, lawyers, judges and a Royal campaign aimed not only at personally destroying one Commission reversed long-standing legal principles, On George Pell’s Prison Journal Anne Henderson of Australia’s most influential religious leaders, but also including the presumption of innocence, the onus of of trashing the reputation of the Catholic Church. Had proof, and guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Every claim On Woody Allen Rob Long it succeeded, the campaign would have set damaging of child sexual abuse, they insisted, must be believed. On Pearl Buck Ross Terrill precedents for the rule of law in Australia. Pell spent 400 This is the story of profound injustice heaped on one days in prison before a unanimous judgment of the High individual and the social and legal damage caused by On Charles III Joe Dolce Court finally set him free. radical ideologues convinced of their own virtue. Poetry I Stephen Gilfedder, Francine Rochford, Luke Whitington, Frank Corso, Conor Ross, Marc Janssen, Ouyang Yu, FOR YOU, OR AS A GIFT $39.95, plus postage Roger G McDonald, Changming Yuan, Brenda Saunders ONLINE quadrant.org.au/shop/ I POST Quadrant, 2/5 Rosebery Place, Balmain NSW 2041 Fiction Gary Furnell, Duncan Richardson PHONE (03) 8317 8147 www.quadrant.org.au Letters I Environment I Science I Literature I Economics I Religion I Media Theatre I Philosophy I film I Society I History I Politics I Education I Health 33011_QBooks_Ads_V5.indd 1 33011_QBooks_Ads_V5.indd 1 18/11/2019 1:30 PM 18/11/2019 1:30 PM mis 1469 pell book A4 advert.indd 1 3/11/20 4:37 pm NEW 33011_QBooks_Ads_V5.indd 1 18/11/2019 1:30 PM RENODESIGN.COM.AU R33011 RENODESIGN.COM.AU RENODESIGN.COM.AU R33011-39009_FA1 RENODESIGN.COM.AU NEW EXPANDED EDITION BY PETER O’BRIEN A HIGHLY READABLE APPRAISAL THAT BREAKS THE ILLUSION OF ABORIGINAL AGRICULTURE IN BRUCE AUSTRALIA’S SECRET WAR PASCOE’S HOW UNIONISTS SABOTAGED DARK EMU OUR TROOPS IN WORLD WAR II HAL COLEBATCH’s new book, Australia’s Secret War, tells the shocking, true, but until now largely suppressed and hidden story of the war waged from 1939 to 1945 by a number of key Australian trade unions NEW — against their own society and against the men and women of their BITTER HARVEST is a comprehensive appraisal called it ‘the most important book on Australia’. own country’s fighting forces during the perils of World War II. of Bruce Pascoe’s book Dark Emu. Pascoe postulates Its ideas have already been taken up in school texts. that, rather than being a nomadic hunter-gatherer But nothing in Dark Emu justifies its success. Every major Australian warship was targeted by strikes, go-slows and society, Australian Aborigines were actually sedentary Bitter Harvest is a forensic but highly readable sabotage at home. Australian soldiers fighting in New Guinea and agriculturalists with ‘skills superior to those of the examination which reveals that Bruce Pascoe omits, the Pacific went without food, radio equipment and ammunition because white colonisers who took their land and despoiled it’. distorts or mischaracterises important information to of union strikes. Photographs © Australian War Memorial Dark Emu has enjoyed extraordinary public and critical such an extent that, as purported history, Dark Emu is Waterside workers disrupted loading of supplies to the troops and acclaim, winning Premier’s literary awards in New worthless. Even worse, it promotes a divisive, victim- pilfered from ships’ cargoes and soldiers’ personal effects. Other strikes South Wales and Victoria. Professor Marcia Langton based agenda that pits one Australian against another. by rail workers, iron workers, coal miners, and even munitions workers and life-raft builders, badly impeded Australia’s war effort. FOR YOU, OR AS A GIFT $34.95 PLUS POSTAGE FOR YOU, OR AS A GIFT ONLINE quadrant.org.au/shop/ $44.95 ONLINE POST Quadrant, 2/5 Rosebery Place, Balmain NSW 2041, Australia www.quadrant.org.au/store POST PHONE (03) 8317 8147 Quadrant, Locked Bag 1235, North Melbourne VIC 3051, Australia PHONE (03) 8317 8147 FAX (03) 9320 9065 33011_QBooks_Ads_V5.indd 1 18/11/2019 1:30 PM march 2021 No. 574 Volume Lxv, Number 3 letters 2 Phillip Hilton, Douglas Drummond, Patricia Wiltshire editor’s column 4 Cancelling Australian History Keith Windschuttle asperities 6 John O’Sullivan astringencies 8 Anthony Daniels the philistine 10 Salvatore Babones health 12 The Futility of the Great Lockdown Melodrama Peter Murphy politics 20 Losing Faith in the Future of Democracy David Martin Jones 23 Black Lives Matter: The Myths and the Facts William D. Rubinstein 26 The Evolution of the Lineages of Modernity James C. Bennett china 34 The China Question: The Greatest Challenge to Our Generation Ted O’Brien edinburgh letter 39 The Pointless Pursuit of Scottish Independence John Lloyd society 42 The Mad Priest and the Campaign to Get George Pell John Wheelahan 48 Are You an Authoritarian? (Part III) Judy Stove-Wilson aborigines 53 The Indigenous Invasion of Aboriginal Australia Patrick McCauley islam 58 Australian Imams Stand Up for Sharia Mark Durie history 62 An Eyewitness Diary of the Russian Civil War Michael Connor economics 66 Taxing and Spending and Failing Peter Fenwick books 69 Sacred & Profane by Peter Kurti Augusto Zimmermann 72 Prison Journal, Volume I by George Pell Anne Henderson 74 The Washington Diaries of Owen Dixon ed. Philip Ayres Nicholas Hasluck 78 Morality by Jonathan Sacks Rachael Kohn 80 Around the World in the Cinemas of Paris by Theodore Dalrymple Zoe Higgie literature 82 The Confucian Serenity of Pearl Buck Ross Terrill 84 Growing Up in SBS’s Australia Christopher Heathcote 90 Air, War and Words Barry Gillard film 94 In Search of Woody Allen Rob Long 98 King Charles III: A Right Royal Kebab of Lèse-Majesté Joe Dolce 102 Digging for a Timeless Treasure Elizabeth Beare stories 106 A Crocodile Killed Autonomy Gary Furnell 109 Different in a Film Duncan Richardson sweetness & light 111 Tim Blair Poetry 19: Cookbooks for Poets Joe Dolce; Cat/December 26 Christine Hamm; My Friends the Mountains Graeme Hetherington; 22: I Was Right Marc Janssen; 25: Parkour Francine Rochford; 32: Given the Top Four ... Changming Yuan; 33: Two poems Roger G McDonald; Two poems Brenda Saunders; 38: My Mother Only Drinks ... Cassandra Dickinson; 41: I Smoke for My Weight Marc Janssen; 47: After Parthenius; The Commercial Traveller Stephen Gilfedder; 56: my casio watch Arian Ganjavi; 57: The Old Man at the Nursing Home Frank Corso; 65: Indifferent Skies Luke Whitington; 83: 11.01am Ouyang Yu; 89: Two poems Jason Morgan; 93: Two poems Peter Stiles; 104: Martin Place Ghetto Jonathan Grace; 105: scholia 70; Merry Quickness; Possible cacophony Conor Ross LETTERS ment, evaluation and evidence- and experience-based best practice sharing”. This is not mere mana- gerialist jargon. Look how the EDITOR The Debt Trap sleuthing capacities of Victoria Keith Windschuttle Police have recently improved: [email protected] SIR: Professor Wolfgang Kasper’s after insisting for years that there EDITOR, INTERNATIONAL wide-ranging article on China were no African street gangs in John O’Sullivan (December 2020) avoids finance. Melbourne, Victoria Police were LITER ARY EDITOR In late 2020 China owned over recently able to find them and agree Barry Spurr US$1,000,000,000 in Treasury that they were a problem. [email protected] securities. China’s dollar reserves In their continuous improve- have been recycled into US debt. ment in ferreting out crime, Victoria DEPUTY EDITOR & FICTION EDITOR George Thomas These surpluses were built through Police have also been able to scru- [email protected] trade, not money printing. They tinise the Facebook posts of Zoe embody the work of the Chinese Buhler, a private citizen in Ballarat, EDITOR, QUADR ANT ONLINE over decades. The risk to those sur- and detect in them evidence of her Roger Franklin pluses from default or hyperinflation inciting a protest against one of the [email protected] brought on by US money printing Andrews government’s COVID-19 CONTRIBUTING EDITORS warrants a rethink by any Chinese lockdown directions. Theatre: Michael Connor government. Adverse observations This improvement in the detec- Television and Film: Joe Dolce about the CCP explain little. tion of crime by Victoria Police COLUMNISTS Professor Kasper mentions compares favourably with the Anthony Daniels Gorbachev, but, once again, he success of the Stasi in detect- Tim Blair avoids finance, a central factor in ing thought crimes by citizens of Salvatore Babones the collapse of the USSR. The East Germany. For it is very like a Soviet debt trap opened during the thought crime that Zoe Buhler has Subscriptions détente era when industrial produc- been charged with: incitement is an Phone: (03) 8317 8147 tivity decayed. Under Gorbachev indictable offence and is commit- Fax: (03) 9320 9065 the malaise worsened when the ted upon completion of the inciting Post: Quadrant Magazine, energy sector experienced several conduct, even if the incitement fails Locked Bag 1235, crises.