Wheelmap: the Wheelchair Accessibility Crowdsourcing Platform Amin Mobasheri1* , Jonas Deister2 and Holger Dieterich2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mobasheri et al. Open Geospatial Data, Software and Standards (2017) 2:27 Open Geospatial Data, DOI 10.1186/s40965-017-0040-5 Software and Standards SOFTWARE Open Access Wheelmap: the wheelchair accessibility crowdsourcing platform Amin Mobasheri1* , Jonas Deister2 and Holger Dieterich2 Abstract Crowdsourcing (geo-) information and participatory GIS are among the current hot topics in research and industry. Various projects are implementing participatory sensing concepts within their workflow in order to benefit from the power of volunteers, and improve their product quality and efficiency. Wheelmap is a crowdsourcing platform where volunteers contribute information about wheelchair-accessible places. This article presents information about the technical framework of Wheelmap, and information on how it could be used in projects dealing with accessibility and/or multimodal transportation. Keywords: Wheelmap, OpenStreetMap, Open data, Crowdsourcing, VGI, Accessibility Introduction provide information for other users on how accessible Wheelmap - a map for wheelchair-accessible places is an a destination is. Thereby, the map contributes to an initiative of the Sozialhelden, a grassroots organisation active and diversified lifestyle for wheelchair users. from Berlin, Germany. On Wheelmap1 everyone from all People with rollators or buggies benefit from this tool over the world can find and add places and rate them by as well. Furthermore, the aim of Wheelmap is to using a traffic light system. The map, which is available make owners of wheelchair-inaccessible public places since 2010, shall help wheelchair users and people with aware of the problem. They should be encouraged to mobility impairments to plan their day more effectively. reflect on and improve the accessibility of their Currently, more than 800,000 cafés, libraries, swimming premises. pools, and many more public places have been captured. As mentioned earlier, Wheelmap is based on Open- While the majority of the places which have been added StreetMap, an open, editable map of the digital open so far are located in Germany, the mapping platform source map of the world. Everyone can search for works globally, as it is based on OpenStreetMap (OSM). places and – provided they have been tagged – get in- The Wheelmap interface is available in Arabic, Danish, formation about how easily accessible the places are. German, Greek, English, Spanish, French, Icelandic, Those who sign up as a user are able to add and rate Italian, Japanese, Swedish, Turkish, Korean, and Polish. new places. An easy traffic light system marks the Wheelchairs or purpose-built cars on the one hand, wheelchair accessibility of a place: Green signifies an elevators and ramps on the other allow people with unrestricted access – e.g. because there are no steps or mobility impairments to plan their day independently there is a permanent ramp, an elevator or other tools to a great extent. But frequently, the last meters de- which allow the entrance. Places which are orange- cide whether the trip to the cinema, beer garden or colored have no toilets but might have a foldable ramp supermarket was worth the effort. Just one single step for example. Places which are red-colored are not ac- at the entrance can be an insurmountable obstacle, cessible for wheelchair users. In general, the more and this is where Wheelmap comes into play. Users people join Wheelmap and add places the more precise and informative the map gets. Sozialhelden is an incorporated, not for profit soci- * Correspondence: [email protected] ety, located in Berlin, Germany. In addition to a small 1GIScience research group, Institute of Geography, Heidelberg University, paid staff, it comprises a network of volunteers en- Heidelberg, Germany gaging in various activities regarding social justice. It Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s). 2017 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. Mobasheri et al. Open Geospatial Data, Software and Standards (2017) 2:27 Page 2 of 7 is financed by taking part in contests, by receiving among other possibilities, can be used by volunteers donations from public and private sponsors, and by to enrich accessibility information in OpenStreetMap. supporting Wheelmap-related activities of social Wheelmap has had a great influence in research pro- engagement. jects. Several studies have used or cited Wheelmap as The main objective is to gather information about the one of the main crowdsourcing platforms in the ac- accessibility of public places (points of interest, POI). cessibility domain [18, 19, 25–31]. Hence, this study Everyone is invited to participate and provide their own aims to introduce this platform for a better under- tagging of places on an OSM-based map at the Wheel- standing and usage in future studies. map website. Implementation Background Wheelmap architecture In the past decade, OpenStreetMap in particular, and Technically, Wheelmap currently comprises two Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI) in general, major applications (Fig. 1). One is the publicly avail- have gained special attention in various research able platform for collaborative tagging, and the other projects. Such free and open datasets have been used in is a platform for developers so that they can test new several application domains including routing and navi- functionality and quality-check new data sources (e.g. gation [1–4], transportation studies [5, 6], urban and sponsored data) before applying it to the live server. environmental challenges [7, 8], as well as disaster man- Wheelmap provides a RESTful API to access and agement [9]. maintain the Wheelmap relevant data within OSM. So far, several efforts have been done regarding The REST requests are to be authorized by an api_- research studies specifically addressing accessibility key, which can be obtained for a Wheelmap account. issues using crowdsourced datasets. This is while Such an account is based on a valid OSM account. there are still research gaps in developing an efficient Registration for Wheelmap is offered at Wheelmap’s framework for accessible transportation. For instance, 2 login website. in one of the early works, Prandi et al., [10] explored the potentials of the crowdsourcing communities in improving data access and services in the field of dis- Resources at GitHub able pedestrian mobility. Similar works have been Public applications and components of Wheelmap are followed by [11–19]. Among those, mPASS [19] pre- hosted as open source at GitHub. sents a valuable mobile pervasive accessibility social Besides the standard web interface, the main applica- sensing framework. mPASS collects data about urban tions for the mobile collaborative crowd-sourcing process and building accessibility to provide personalized are (Fig. 2): paths. Their framework is similar to Wheelmap, be- sides the fact that Wheelmap only focuses on access- Wheelmap-android – An android app for ible points of interests (building, toilets, etc.), while Wheelmap, with full editing and search capabilities, mPASS also considers accessible routes. In another direction pointers as well as a tablet version. study, Salomoni et, al. [16] present the results of field Wheelmap-iPhone – An iOS version of Wheelmap trials with mobile applications that employing differ- ent gamification mechanisms. The authors conclude Recently added functionality includes helpful services that some of the apps are able to drive users to pro- such as: vide more contributions. Further discussions on their study can be found at [16]. Users can add images to a place. Images can be added A main concern regarding using crowdsourced data- from either the camera or from the photo album. sets such as OpenStreetMap is the level of quality The “Get engaged” function shows unmarked places they carry [20]. Several methods exists in assessing nearby. VGI data quality [21]. Among the studies carried out Users can share the link to any place on Wheelmap.org on using VGI data for urban accessibility, some of via Facebook, Twitter, email and SMS. them evaluate, argue and enrich the fitness for Users can ask their network and friends via purpose of this data source [22–24]. For instance, Facebook, Twitter and email if they know the Mobasheri et, al. [23] evaluates the completeness of wheelchair accessibility of an unmarked place and sidewalk information (as well as other relevant data can tag it accordingly. for accessibility) in OpenStreetMap database and The “Route” function shows users a route from discusses the lack of data completeness with applying their current position to a certain place on extrinsic and intrinsic data analysis. Wheelmap, Wheelmap.org. In the list view, a user can see Mobasheri et al. Open Geospatial Data, Software and Standards (2017) 2:27 Page 3 of 7 Fig. 1 The two Wheelmap applications with the Sandbox Developers’ Playground (left), and the live operational platform (right) how far away a place is from the current position Server versions, and standard and high-resolution of the user. versions of the PNG renders. Technologies The RESTful API Wheelmap, as well as OSM, is a Ruby on Rails3 ap- The publicly documented RESTful API of Wheelmap plication. Wheelmap therefore has created a ruby is the most appropriate component to integrate gem4 client, named Rosemary, to easily access the Wheelmap data and facilities into new or foreign ap- current OpenStreetMap API. Furthermore, Maki5 is a plications (Table 1). point of interest icon set made especially for use with Development and testing of applications is done MapBox maps. Each icon is designed 3 times for 12, against a sandbox branch of OSM, which is accessed 18, and 24 pixels wide/tall. Style files6 for ArcGIS by the RESTful Wheelmap API at http://staging.wheel- 10.1+ are available, including both Desktop and map.org/api/.