THE DIAPASON AN INTEKNATIONAL MONTHLY DEVOTED TO THE ORGAN, THE HARPSICHORD AND CHURCH MUSIC

Seventieth ,Annj,oerrary Year

Sttltmtielh Year, No.5. Whole No. 8!H A Scranton Gilletle Publication ISSN 0012·2378 FEBRUARY, 1978

American Institute of Organbuilders Sixth Annual Convention

The sixth annual convention of the American Institute of Organbuilders was held last October 8 - 11 in the neighbor­ a report by ing cities of Fargo, North Dakota, and Moorhead, Minnesota. Not generally thought of as an organ mecca, the area proved nevertheless to have its share of organs and organ interest. The three and one-haU days were well-scheduled with varied Charles McManis programs; careful pacing and efficient organization charac­ terized the events, which were attended by a group number­ and ing around one hundred. AIO members and other interested parties had come from all over the country - a conscious effort is made by the organization to schedule each year's convention in a different location - and several organbuilders Arthur Lawrence from other countries were also present. Notable among the (Continued, page 10) THE DIAPASON &labUshed in 1900

An International Monthly Devoted 10 the Organ, Ihe Harpsichord and Church Mwi, Official Journal ollhe .-fmn-ienn Indilute 0/ Orgtu.builders

FEBRUARY. 1979 Elli,., ARTHUR LAWRENCE FEATUllES Iylin... Ma..... , AlDerlcaD. lutlhale 01 Otgaabta1JUnl DAVID M. McCAIN Slxth Aanual CoOYeotloa All/lt.", fdiJ., by ChmlQ Mc:Mcmb cmd Artbur Lcnn-eot:e J. 10. 12·14. WESLEY vas

The Orqaa. _ M~WD or Meuage? In this issue, snarled by two winler storms that have all but shut down by GUUcm Well' II, ~7 lARRY PALMEII. the midwest, we call your attention to articles which were occasioned by Burled Treas\lfts (II) Horpddlord more pleasant times. The American Institute of Organbuilders, which hos by Lany P,dmeJ' • JAMES McCRAY. CknoIMook grown from an uncertain beginning six years ago to a vital group today, IIEVIEWS had its annual convention last faJl. Member-builder Charles McManis hos HUDSON LADD, Music for Vole.. and Orgcua joined the editor in recounting the events, which we hope you will find of hI' Jam .. McCret!' 4. • Car'" interest. aecordl; .or a Wlal.r Party br Arthut Lawnnce 5•• DAlE CARl A different kind of article is the one by Gillian Weir, in which she ad­ dresses some of the problems of performance in a thought-provoking man­ G'OIlJ"U_" EDITORIAL 2 LADY JENKINS ner. Based on her lecture at the AGO national convention in Seattle, her Iood.. thoughts carry a message which should be important to anyone concerned LETTER to THE EDITOR 2 P,lces: with the communication of music. She has been kind enough to transcribe I yr.-$7.5O NEWS and edit the material particularly for publication in these pages. 2 ,n.-$.3.00 AzulOUDC'emeaw 2, II 51.... COPy-51.DO Over a period of some years, a number of articles on a given topic will Memo.emellt 2 NvmIM,-$J.75 have appeared in The Diapason and readers interested in a particular Bcupslchord. • Sac' subject will from time to time appreciate an accounting. Thus, contribut· Appamlmaata 11 (mfU_ """. 2 ,It. old, ing editor Larry Palmer's column this month deals with articles on the HeCO 14 HeN & Th.,. I, 15 THE DIdPd.mr. harpsichord and related subjects which have been published during the Nunc DlIIllltSs 18 Pub/Is/,.d mon,III, ,., past five yean. Sc:r"n'on GiII(!Ue Cot",nun/cadom, Inc. CALEHDAB 17-10 04 Sm,,11 rV.lllls/, ,hllmue. Chic",,,, III. 60605. PI,one (512) 421·51-19 CLASSIFIED ADVEBTIBEMEHTS ZI.a3 Second·c/fUS i,os'lige 114id at It is quite fascinating to see what articles will be considered important Gllied,". Ill., ,!tid ., adl illmu" enough (or irritating enoughl) by readers to stir them to write. Quite mailing olllee. Publicalioll riO. 156480. predictably, Donald Willing's guest editorial which appeared last month Rouline i'ems lor 11"",irll,i"" ,mu' I,t' received not later than the lst 0/ the hOIS already stirred up a stonn of written commentary, both pro and con, AU IUbIcrlben are otJrd 10 aend month '0 Q.JJ:ure i,uer,iotl in tile in"c a representative portion of which will appear as letters to the editor. dwll<' of .dd...... -plly 10 !he lor ",e "ext mo",II. Fur ndl'tf'lid,,~ -A.L. office 01 The Dlapa-. a...... coJry. ti,e dosi,,; lillie is tlu 5111 , Mnltf'ials fnr rellln,' dwu/tl reael, must reach UI before the 10th or the 'he o/fice by 'he Is' oj 'he fJreviow month preceding the elate or the month. Prospective contributors 0/ Coven colloga by David M. McCain of American Institute of Orgonbuilders' logo and Ont laue to be mailed 10 the: new articles should request a style sheet. photograph of Hohkomp organ 01 Trinity lutheran Church, Moorhead. Minnesota, by 11. Erik Swee. addreu. The Diapason cannot pm­ T/ds journal is indexed in The .lde duplkate caples mlatd bcawe )tUlic Index, annolated In Mutk or • IUhlcribdl bllure to nodfy. Article Guld~. and abstraded in RILM Abltlllcti.

tival and at two regional AGO con­ Announcements Management ,·entions, The acquisition of Belwln-Mill5 There is still time for organists to Westminster Choir College has a n­ Publishing Corp. has been announced enter the National Organ Playing nounced its third summer organ tour, by Esquire, Inc., which bought the Compelilion sponsored by the Ruth European Organ Cullure, which this large music publisher for approxi­ and Clarence Mader Memorial rear will include instruments in Hol­ mately $7 million. The Delwin-Mills Scholarship Fund - the deadline for land, North Germany, and France, headquarters will remain in Melville, receivjng tapes and applicatioD forms lor July 19-Aug. 2. joan Lippincott NY, where it will be the nucleus of is Murch 30. Awards of $1,000, $300, will serve as the coordinator, with a new Esquire group which operates and $200 are offered to winners, participation by Hamid Vogel and in the areas of "educatioo, lighting, whose transportation aod accommoda­ Klaas Bolt. Demonstrations, recitals, and communications-leisure," The di­ lions for the April 28 performance and programs of early music will be versified corporation formerly owned will be provided. For further informa­ given on the most important historic Esquire Magazine; the Delwin firm tion, write the fund at P.O. Box 94-C, organs between Amsterdam, Lubeck, itself bought up a number of smaUer Pasadena, CA 91104. Strasbourg, Paris, and Souvigny. Fur­ music pubJishers in recent years. ther information is available from Summer Session, 'Vestminster Choir College, Princeton, Nj 08540; (609 ) Letter to the Editor 924-7416. To the Editor: "An approved pipe organ of up 10 The University of Evansville will As an organist for the Church of Jesus five ranks may be installed in new ward Christ of Laller~dDy Saints, J sometimes meetinghouses with fuU·size cbapels. As hold its 131h Annual Church Music hear comments from other orllUlists and with stake centers, Church participa­ Festival Mar. 2-4. Guest artis ... wiU church musicians concerning the policy oC tion on pipe organs for ward meeting­ include Robert Glasgow, Helen Kemp, pipe: orgaos in LOS meetinghouses. Refer­ houses is based on the cost of approved Leona.rd Van Camp, and Michael AI. ence is often made to an article in the electronic organs, but the excess cost Sept. 1975 issue of The Dlapt1Son, entitled should be financed 100% by a few "estrom. In addition to an organ re­ "Mormons Ban Pipc OrglUlS from New named individuals in the local unit cital and masterclasscs by Dr. Glas­ Meetinghouses," which included a policy [congregation] who ore interested in gow, there will be lectures, demonstra­ statement from LDS Cburch headqullrters, paying for a pipe organ. The QCCSS Phillip Truckenbrod has announced tions, liturgical art exhibitions, and a erfeclive May 20, 1915. The policy indi· should not be flnanced from a general coled that only certain approved electronic membership fund drive. the representation of Larry Smith, concluding festival service. Further in· who has joined the list of international organs were to be installed in new LOS "When replacement of orgaRS in ex­ formation is available from Prof. Churches. isting buildings is necessary and justi­ concert organists on the roster of Arts Douglas Reed, Music Department, The ,LOS Church on Aug, 5, 1977. is· fied. pipe oraans may be installed. on Image Ltd. Dr. Smith is assistant pro­ University of Evansville, Evansville, sued a revised policy on the Joslallation of the same basis as described above for organs in meetinghouses, which cleared new buildings. fessor of music at Kent State Univer­ IN 47702; (812 ) 479-2H2. sity in Ohio and serves as organist­ the way for LOS congregations across the "A list of approved organs is avail· country 10 purcbll5e pipe orllUlS if de­ Dble from the PhYSitlll Fllcilities "Depart­ choirmaster of the Kent United Swan Randall will present a redtal sired. Perhaps it would be of interest to ment, SO East North Temple, Salt Lake Church of Christ. From 1971 through lor the Chicago Club of Women Or­ other organists and cburch musicians. City, UT 84150." mid-1978 he held a similar position ganists on Mar. 18 a t 3 :30 pm in St. The revised policy reads in pan: This policy gives local congregations con­ at Converse College, Spartanburg, SC. Church, 655 \V. Fullerton, Chi­ (For stake centers:] "If desired .•• siderable freedom in selection and installa­ Paul's pipe organs of up to nine ranks may be tion of pipe organs, and comes as welcome He is a graduate of Duke University cago. Miss Randall is a student of Dei­ selected from en approved list, but news to LOS members. and holds graduate degrees from Syra­ bert Disselhorst at the University of Church participation on [the purchase James B. Welch elise University and the Eastman Iowa and was the co-winner of the oU pipe orlans will be limited to nor­ Organist, Santa "Barbaro. lrd ward, mal ratioJ applied to the cost of an elec­ LOS Clurch School of Mwic. He hIlS made recilal 1978 Grucnstein Memorial Contest, tric orlm. The state must pay 100% Univ. Orpnist, Univ. of Calif. at appearances at the Tanglewood Fcs- sponsored by the club. of the excess cost. Santa Barbara

2 THE DIAPASON The Organ - Medium or Message? by Gil/ian Weir A few years ago, I was invited to talk about doing it. Once again, the means have become individual resonances and corporate blend. An and demonstrate the organ at the Royal Albert the end. The fatal fascination of the organ it­ organ is, in exactly the same way, an orchestra Hall in London to a London organ dub. I un­ self has deflected us from our purpose - the or a choir of individuals; for the color comes earthed a fair amount of infonnation on its communicating of the composers' ideas. The from the homogeneous blending of each har­ history, including some choice anecdotes con­ new movement started splendidly, with the ex­ monically rich and lively pipe. But what would cerning the opening ceremonies after its rebuild­ amination of the unquestionably great instru­ you think of an orchestra or choir which dip­ ing at the beginning of this century. One such ments from the period in which flowered the ped and swayed in pitch and amplitude, parti­ anecdote had been reported in The Times: indisputably great composers, as well the study cularly in the music of the Baroque? Neverthe­ "The noise of the newly rebuilt organ at the of the performance practice of the time. We less this is what is advocated for the organ. Royal Albert Hall last night was used to cover noted, for example, that encased organs had Once again - and let the warning bells ring up the sound or the disturbance when an un­ a homogeneity, a projection and a focus which loud at this - the instrument has been placed popular decision was given by the Belgian unencased organs lacked. We noted, when we outside the musical world through the danger­ referee after the evening's wrestling match be­ thought a little more deeply, that the separately ously misleading arguments of its protagonists. tween England and Belgium." A less grateful encased divisions, each with its own distinct Certainly the organist, like the violinist, must commentator, writing a week or so later in the personality (gained by its relative pitch struc­ be able to employ a rich vibrato for an appro­ same August journal, said tartly that the sound ture and by its architectural disposition), pro­ priate effect j and hence we have a tremulant of the organ wafting through the vast building vided the essential physical counterpart of the device for just that purpose, though it must be into the corridors had "curled the milk in the music of the High Baroque with its passages of used with discretion, and in the full understand­ restaurant's milk jugs." My intention of liven­ contrast of moods and textures. Thus we con­ ing of musical style. Let us see what Bach says ing up the sometimes rather too serious pro­ cluded (logically and correctly) that encasement about wind pressure. In a letter he wrote ceedings of an organ dub gathering took a knock is good. Then we turned to the action, and saw The old wind chests must all be taken out when I arrived at the Royal Albert Hall and that what speaks instantly and allows the per­ and freshly supplied with such wind con­ was greeted by a forthright man who had fanner to demonstrate his sensitivity, is obvi­ duction that one stop alone and also all worked on the rebuilding of the organ and had ously preferable to that which controls him. the stops together can be used without come to help me with facts and figures. "This So - mechanical action, with its direct linkage alteration of the pressure, which has not organ," he said, afire with enthusiasm, "has X and instantaneous speech, is good. But grad­ been possible in the past and yet is ab­ number of pipes of which the largest is so many ually the aims and objects of our research be­ solutely essential. feet long; It is the largest organ in the world came forgotten or blurred, and a general feel­ Many enthusiasts will admit the logic, but and in my opinion the best!" I found this rather ing that "old is good" - simply because it's old then smile charmingly and say, ''But I like it daunting. While I admire the craftsmanship as­ - grew up and became tacitly accepted. A ship that way!1t That is why the old Romantic view, sociated with organbuilding, instruments such without a rudder goes aground, and the organ far from being ousted by the new authenticity as the one in the Royal Albert Hall are not movement began to lose its rudder. Thus, when or baroque or classical or pre-baroque or what­ really related to the performance of organ mu­ it was discovered that some old organs (and have you view, is still with us. Romanticism in sic but rather to orchestral transcriptions and the word "oldl! itself, being relative, is ulti­ thinking - as opposed to the use of the word perhaps playing "Abide with Me" at big mo­ mately impossible to define) had an unsteady to describe a perfectly honest period in historical ments in wrestling matches. But what really wind supply, we said, "Old is good, so let's style - might be described as the unchecked stopped me in my tracks was the sight of 300 have an unsteady wind supply." Evidence can expression of the individual's likes and dislikes. people solemnly moving in reverent procession always be gathered to support any contention, It is the antithesis of the truly baroque view along the front of the organ, past the console and it is interesting to note the arguments ad­ which presented a logically worked out musical and on to their seats. I was amazed at the pas­ duced to support this one. "Singers, flute play­ argument or idea, full of passion and feeling and sions that could be aroused by something which ers, violinists,.' we are told, "all cmploy a wit and love and humor, but not related to the was simply lying there, inert. Yet this attitude vibrato, which is part of the intrinsic beauty mere whim of the performer. It is also the has been with us for a long time. Even now, of their tone. Therefore organs should reflect antithesis of the meaning of instrument, which I sometimes descend from the stage or the or­ this." We might cynically note, in passing, is Utool" - something which conveys or serves. gan 10ft after a concert and meet an oncoming that it is rather difficult to provide a steady Thus the person who says "I don't care if tubas line of people. I prepare to greet them - but supply of wind to an organ, but cynicism nnd super-octaves are not right for the contra­ with a fixed, hypnotic stare and a measured aside, let us examine the argument. We find puntal balance of Bach, I like it that way," tread, they walk straight past, narrowly missing that until comparatively recently, vibrato in and the person who says "I don't care if un­ me as I leap asidc at the last minute as from an string playing was clearly understood to be an steady wind or whatcver cannot be justified avalanche. So they continue until they reach "ornament,U and it was so described in all thc historically or on tenns of comparison with any the console where they stand silently worship­ string instrument tutors until well into the 19th other fonn of music, music-making or instru­ ping it - plastic keys, chipped pistons, music century. Indeed in vocal music, in baroque ment, I like it that way," are in fact one and desk and all. This obsession with the organ for times, there was frequent resistance to any vi­ the same person. brato. But, employed as an ornament it was its own sake, as a technological marvel, an en­ The bland and lifeless sound which unsteady ~neering fact, has been often remarked. So used in two ways: firstly, a very slight vibrato wind pressure is often called upon to remedy, has been the history of its unfortunate results was used for wannth, and secondly, a more is truly an appalling defect in an organ. My which, amanA' other things, produced the mini­ pronounced tremolo was used to amplify the point is that the thinking which has produced telephone-exchange of the Hope-Jones organ sound. The second was used only very occasion­ this so·called remedy is confused. Far from be­ and the mini-Concorde organ of the mid-20th ally because by its nature it gives an unaccept­ ing products of a scholarly and historically in­ century. How many unsuspecting tourists have able vagueness of pitch. So, a vibrato which is fanned search for authenticity, many of the con­ been frightened out of their wits in an English enforced on the player (and the listener) be­ clusions which have been reached arise from Cathedral when they have walked past a con­ cause of a basically unstable wind supply through exactly the same misconceptions that brought cealed 64' pipe just as its power was unleashed! the whole organ is not only "unauthentic" in Ihe organ into disrepute in the musical world terms of historical practice: it also produces the Yet the obsession with size and power is usually (and virtually into annihilation) at the tum ,arne effect on the music at a deeper level that considered to be confined to the Romantic era. of the century. Having been brought at last U\Ve are wiser now,'1 we sayj "we no longer the despised tuba-laden monster produced - on to centre stage of the world of music, it now a non-musical practice, and solely an u _ worship tubas for their own sake, or thrill to organ stands in real danger of being dragged off again the sound of decibels unlimited. We are con­ effect" which the player has to accept and into the opposite wing. ccrned now - at last - with music on the which cannot be altered. But further, the com­ parison with the voice and other instruments The only reliable guide can be a pragmatic organ." is a prime example of confused thinking. A flute and objective viewpoint gained from study of I wish fervently that I could believe that. player uses a pipe, within which the flow of the whole subject and from putting music first, Rather, I fear that we have exchanged one set the air always, by its nature, must be unsteady. and not a subjective one which puts the instru­ of prejudices or obsessions for another, and that This has a liveliness which is attractive - it is ment first. Pragmatism selVes a principle or they in fact embody exactly the same basic "real,1! one might say, as a piece of pottery is ideal j it seeks to transmit a particular idea, to error. Of course the intentions have been the Ureal" while a seemingly flawless reproduction fulfil a particular purpose. In working prag­ best, i.e. to bring to the organ a revived knowl- , in plastic is "unreal," lacking its own, indepen­ matically the musician in no way surrenders his edge of the authentic practices of its heyday, dent life. The precise counterpart of the flute creative originality, lessens the dramatic possi­ the 17th and early 18th centuries, and thus to pipe is the single organ pipe. It too will always, bilities of his art, or allows its expressive fervor restore its integity as an instrument in its own inevitably, have an unsteady flow of air - to be diminished. It is a misunderstanding of right rather than as a substitute orchestra or an , uch are the laws of physics.' Nevertheless, the that point which has led to the extraordinary accompanimental munnur in the background. corporate vibrancy of an orchestra's tone, de­ view of Baroque music as something akin to But we have forgotten one thing - why we're rived from the idiosyncracies of the tone pro­ what is sometimes called sewing-machine music, duction of each instrument in that orchestra, without humor or what we call feeling, rigid This article is a reviud version 0/ the address Miss in its structure, and emotionless. Weir delivered at .he rua.ional con~ntion 0/ .he is genuine and therefore valid. Similarly, a American Guild 0/ Or,aniJu in Seattle last June. choir's quality derives from the combination of (CD.fi.U8d, ,..g.6)

FEBRUARY, 197\? 3 Reviews ... • • • • • • • • Choral Music Music for Voices and Organ ARTISTS' MANAGER by James McCray Choral Music for Easter This is the second half of an article here to Baroque traditions to style and work which could be performed by any devoted to music for Lent, Passiontide harmony. This new work will be of group; because it is so easy (or the and Easter; the first half appeared in interest to those choir directors hav­ singers and organist, it could serve as last month's issue. The works below ing good soloists to feature and who an additional Easter piece or be sung arc suitable (or Easter and have texts want to present a longer work for as a solo or duet for an offertory. which concentrate on the Resurrection. Easter. If organ is used as the ac­ If there is a specific topic that you companiment it will require a good Hail the nay That Sees Him Rise. would like me to concentrate on, perfonner - there arc many difficult Allanson Brown, SSATB with organl please write me; I will be happy to passages. Both German and English piano; Belwin-Mills Publications, devote an article to the requested area. texts are provided, with the instru­ GCMR 3388; 35¢ (M-). Recent articles have featured such di­ mental parts available separately from There arc many short sections, each verse topics as music for the Jewish this complete choral score. with its own character and material. faith, music for young choirs, music Some divisi in the soprano aids the (or summer choirs and 19th-century Sing Alleluia, Jesus Lives. Leland B. traditional harmony, with the accom­ music. Let me hear from you about Sateren, SA TB, junior choir, comet, paniment primarily doubling the voices. your choral interests and needs. organ, and congregation; Sacred Mu­ There are several key changes and-an sic Press, S-166; 35¢ (M). abundance of alleluias interspersed Each verse or refrain receives a Douglol Butler The Strife i.r O'er. Warner Hutchison, among the sections. The homophonic Marsho Foxgrover SA TB and organ; European-American different treatment, such as unison piece closes with a free rhythm sec­ Music Corp., EA 372; 40¢ (M-). with comet, four-part chorale style, lion followed by a celebrative alleluia. ~fuch of this anthem is in unison or rour-part with jr. choir descant, etc. two pans, making it accessible to any The final refrain has everyone, includ­ A Shout of Sacred Joy. Keith Clark, church choir. The tessitura is good ing congregation, in unison and has SATB and organ with optional per­ (or inexperienced singers, designed to modulated up a whole step to intensi­ cussion; Hope Publishing Co., A 486; gi\'e a (ull, but not strained, sound to f)' the mood. The organ material is 45¢ (M). Ihe choir. The organ music is not dif­ not di££icult but somewhat repetitive The text tells of Christ's ascension ficult yet is important in that the har­ for the various verses and refrains. A and is most appropriate for Ascension monic interest is kept, and it also has fine hymn-anthem setting. Sunday, although it could be sung on brief solo areas. The music is written Easter as well . The percussion is in­ Samuel Porter Robert Prichard on two slaves with pedal directions A Feast of Joy. Walter L. Pelz, SATB, cluded as a separate line on the cho­ and some registration recommenda­ 3 trumpets, 2 trombones, timpani, and ral score and requires several drums tions. It closes with a short but majes­ organj Augsburg Publishing House, 11- (high, medium and low) and a high tic alleluia. 9116;$1.75 (M+). hat. The syncopation and changing There are separate choir and in­ meters in combination with the per­ East" Proclamation. Albert Zabel, strumental scores, reducing the overall cussion and harmony give thi.!l a "jazz­ SSA TB and organ or brass with op­ cost for this 23-page work. This fes­ like" character. The chorus has some tional handbells; Harold Flammer tive piece has the chorus in unison, shouting areas and a shouted glissan­ (Shawnee Press), A-5737; 40¢ (M ). in four-parts and sometimes with di­ do. It is the type of anthem that would The brass parts arc included in the visi sections, yet it is more difficult be attractive to a high school youth score and call for 2 trumpets and 2 for the brass than the organ or chorus. choir in a church. trombones. There is a fanfare qualhy There is good craftsmanship in this to this anthem that would make it very composition, which has rhythmic and The Day 0/ R esurrection. Henry Smart appropriate as a call to worship. The harmonic interest throughout. Its ex­ (1813-1879), SAffB, brass quartet, choral music is easy and in five parts; citing tempos and changing meters and organ; Theodore Presser Co., 312- the handbell addition is very simple, propel it forward after the slower mid­ 41193; 50¢ (M ). within the capability of any young dle section which is more contempla­ The brass pari! call for 2 trumpets handbell choir, and the brass parts are tive. TIle score is a reproduction of and 2 trombones and their music is suitable for high school performers. the original hand-copied setting but included with the choral score. The The stately character will set everyone still very readable. This work is highly edition is by Leonard Van Camp, with in a celebrative mood and give the recommended to those directors want­ the chorus in two parts (SAffB). proper Easter atmosphere. ing an extended modem setting for There is a three-verse organization Arno Schoendedt Easter. The dissonances are mild and with each verse in a new key, with a Germany Oh, T remble and Falter. Wilhelm this joyful work should appeal to !light variation. The work is very sim­ Friedemann Bach (1 710-1784), SA TB everyone. ple for the chorus and places an equal with SATB soloists and organ or or­ role on the instrumentalists. chestra; Delwin-Mills Music, BC 2; The Angel Said to the Women. Harald $3.00 (M). Rohlig, SA or unison and keyboardj Entrata FeJtiv4. Flor Peeters, wUson This new scholarly edition by Oscar Concordia Publishing House, 98-2287; chorus, 2 trumpets, 2 trombonC.!l, tim­ Foellmer and Friedrich Schall of W. F. 35¢ (E). pani, and organ; C. F. Peters Corp., Ruth Plummer, Artists' Represontanve Bach's Easter cantata is 50 pages long The additional alto part only occurs 6159; (M ). 2525 H,perlonAve., Los Angelos, CA90027 with a duration of 30 minutes. There in a few brief sections; the majority The chorus part is sold separately Telephono (213) 665-3814 are seven movements, of which only of this piece is in unison. The first for IS¢ a copy and its material is very the opening and closing are for cho­ half is a set of verses with the same brief, consisting of three phrases. The rus; the other five are recitatives, music. There is one full page of a total work, is 8 pages long, very joy­ arias, and duets for the soloists. The single-note melody which receives an ous in character; the bilingual text is first is quite extensive and has a full ever-changing harmonic accompani­ (Latin and English 1 in the final vocal range, requiring a good tenor ment, followed by a faster dance-like section only. There are some disso­ section. The last is brief, in a four­ alleluia which avoids barlines, although nances and none of the parts is parti. part chorale style. The instrumental the divisions are evident. This little cularly difficult, although the brass parts are very busy at times and ad- work is different in format, but is a (Continued, page 9)

CHURCH Perry, Iowa THE BRISTOL COLLECTION OF Carl Staplin, arganist Gontemporary Hymn Tune r:.T~,,,t..!I "'=ro~l,co~'UI,,~,,O" playing Couperin-OHertoi,e sur lei B,ands ieuK Preludes for Organ -,,-,--.. "- (from the "Convent Mosl'#) d'Aquin-Noel lur les ieuK d'onches Edited by Lee Hastings Bristol, Jr. Bach-Prelude and Fugue in 8 MInor Hoydn-Flofenuhr (The MUI;coi C'oci.} Volumes One, Two and Three Allegro moderofo Works by Ronald Arnatt, Lee Hastings Andantino Vivoce "Der Koff ..ldotsch" Bristol, Jr., Gerre Hancock, Derek Hol­ Dupri-Vifro;I (first recording) man, Peter Hurford, Francis Jackson, Gigout-Scheno In E Maior Thomas Matthews, Mathilde McKinney, GuUlou-l.a Chapelle de. A&lmes Holtkamp mechanical action (fin. recording) Arthur Wills, Alec Wyton. organ - 48 ranks Flnt United Methodld Church Available from: Box 237 HAROLD FLAMMER, INC. WATER OAP, PA 18321 $8.50 postpaid Perry, Iowa 50220

THE DIAPASON • • • • • • • • • • • • • .. Records RAGNAR BJORNSSON HEINZ LOHMANN Records for a Winter Party (lcel .. nd), "Played with exceptional (Ccrllldilyl \I,lltd and Il''>po ll,>thle brilliance and tUumlnated with char­ thrH:qh flldrkl'dJy rndlvldual d re by Arthur Lawrence a"tensUe sound colors:'-Morgen­ frt',>tllllgly 1l 0 1l rll!'! Ild n l( .11 quality bla~et, Oslo, Norway !"lJ'ol( AG O m c CO Ghastly winter weather, in addition includc the specification. This record to providing extra difficulties for the will be of inlerest for its sound-effects ALBERT BOLLIGER MARTIN LliCKER musician who must travel any distance - and how many other current re­ (Switzerland) ' Of all orgalllsts we (Germany) "Already a most Impres­ to rehearsals and services, is somc­ cordings are thcre of this bizarre in­ have heard, Bolliger is the one WilD sive virtuoso, he will ~ertainly soon timcs conducivc to party-giving. The strument? best lllterprets Rach:'- Dialio de become a major figure among im­ cold encourages us to stay inside and "'ellolca, Spain portant organlsts:'-la Presse, have a sip by the fire; maybe it would Montreal even be fun to hear all amusing record Dances, Romances, I'oetry and Pomp. or two. Thus I have culled from the Calvin Hampton at the organ of Col­ DAVID BR()CE-PAYNE DAVID McVEY vary Episcopal Chnrch, New York (England) " Dazzling facUity and (USA) Plelycd v.rth unusual technr .seemingly-unending review pile a few good Judgement - he has all the pre­ c al por~e ')nd rll\JSICill in~igllt discs that strike me as appropriate for City. Chopin: Polonaise ("Military"); requlsites:'-St.louls Post-Dispatch arlestmg brll!rance and 1rlipilCl. an organ buff's party. Tchaikovsky: Song without Words; - Seln Diego Union Sibelius: Romance; Grieg: I\."larch ot the Dwarfs; l\lassenet: Elegiej Sinding: L'Orgue bourgeois sous Ie second em­ Rustle of Spring; Rachmaninolf: IJre_ NICHOu\S DANBY JANE PARKER-SJ't)\TH (England) "A Bilch plilyer with great (England) "Daxzllng " . memorable pire. I'ierre Guillot at the Letc organ lude in C# lVlinor; Granados: Spanish masterly gesture illld eminent self , 1 ... It was a smashing debut!"- The ( 1847) in the abbey church 01 Nan­ Dance; Palmgren: May Night; 1 ade­ confidence:'-General Anzeiger, Star ~ Ledger, Newark, N.J. tua. Batistc: Olfertoire de Sainte rewski: Minuet in G; fibitch: Poem; Bonn, Germany Cecile, Communion, Elevation, Olfer­ Rim s k y-Korsakav: }'rocession of toire, OHertoire-Fantaisie-Oragc, Vcr­ Nobles. l\lusical Heritagc Socicty RAYMOND DAVEl()y OOILE PIERRE set; Lefcbure-'Vcly: Romance sans stereo MHS 3525 ($4.95 ). (Canada) ''A thorough display of (France) " Never hilS the ol~iln paroles, Bolero de concert. Erato STU­ The perpetrators of this recold may technique and musicfanshlp!,,-The sounded bettel. cleilrer. or Illore i1049. not appreciate having the review of it Montreal Star va ried" , ullIivaled milstery:' - Toledo This was ubviously produced as a located in this particular column, but, Blade, Ohio serious recording, to show a now-for­ if it wasn't intended for a party, 1'm gotten style played on a period instru­ sure I don t know what it "as in­ ROBERTA GARY THOMAS RICHNER ment. So the performance, which i! tended for. It is certainly enjoyable (USA) "Broad ilnd secure technique, (USA) pianist/organist "A paradigm