Open Access Digital Repositories: an Indian Scenario

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Open Access Digital Repositories: an Indian Scenario RESEARCH Open Access Digital Repositories: An Indian Scenario Open access digital repositories give barrier-free access to literature for study and research to users worldwide. They solve the pricing and permission crises for scholarly materials. This paper deals with open access digital repositories in India. The results of the study reveal that the repositories contain both published and unpublished documents, like seminar proceedings, conference papers, theses, dissertations, research reports, books, and so on. The results also point out that open access digital repositories in India are mostly subject specific and commonly use open source information repository software like DSpace, Greenstone Digital Library Software, and GNU EPrints. It is observed that generally the open access digital repositories use OAI-PMH (protocol for metadata harvesting), so that they can be accessed using search tools such as Web search engines, whereas a few don’t use it but provide direct access to their documents through their websites. pen access to scholarly libraries cannot afford to subscribe Fayaz Ahmed Research Scholar, information has been to most of the journals that their Department of Library a hot topic of debate faculty need for their research and and Information O Science, University of among librarians, scholars, and teaching (Chan, 2004). The only Kashmir. publishers over the last few years. solution to these problems is open The scholarly communication access to scholarly information. Contact him at [email protected]. crisis encompasses two distinct Open-access (OA) literature is though inter-related problems. On digital, online, free of charge, the one hand, serial-subscription and free of most copyright and Rafiq Rather costs, particularly for science licensing restrictions. The main Contractual Lecturer, and medical journals, have been aim of open access is to facilitate Department of Library increasing rapidly over the last two the free flow of refereed literature and Information Science, University of decades, often at rates far above among researchers in different Kashmir. the cost of inflation. At the same disciplines over the Internet. There time, research library budgets have are a variety of definitions of Contact him at rafiq_rather@yahoo. been decreasing, or are otherwise “open access,” and the concept is co.in. unable to keep pace with price still evolving; however, several key increases. The result is that libraries documents, which build upon each are spending more, but they are other, collectively comprise the best in fact getting less in terms of current definition of this term. journal titles and new monograph acquisition, as more of the budget On his website, Peter Suber is consumed by serial subscriptions, mentioned that “By ‘open access’ we so even the richest university mean the free availability of literature on 16 Volume 2 Issue 1, March 2007 KnowGenesis International Journal for Technical Communication (IJTC) the public Internet, permitting any users that can be accessed through the value of open-access publishing in to read, download, copy, distribute, print, Internet and intranet to retrieve developing countries. Open-access search, or link to the full texts of these information. The British Library publishing enables researchers in articles, crawl them for indexing, pass defines Digital Repository as“An developing countries to establish them as data to software, or use them organization that has responsibility for priority for their research, which for any other lawful purpose, without the long-term maintenance of digital they could use later to defend their financial, legal, or technical barriers other resources, as well as for making them intellectual property. It removes than those inseparable from gaining access available to communities agreed on by the access barriers in terms of both to the internet itself. The only constraint depositor and the repository.” price and permission, enhances on reproduction and distribution, and national research capacity, and the only role for copyright in this domain, Open Access Digital Repositories improves visibility for developing- should be to give authors control over the have already started emerging in country research. Open access thus integrity of their work and the right to be different parts of the world. The enables a global platform for this properly acknowledged and cited.” University of Nottingham (UK) research and collaboration, and and Lund University (Sweden) reciprocates the information flow Completely open access removes officially launched OpenDOAR from South to North and East to price barriers (subscriptions, (Directory of Open Access West among all countries. licensing fees, pay-per-view Repositories) on January 27, 2006. fees) and permission barriers OpenDOAR presently contains Objectives of the Study (most copyright and licensing 792 repositories belonging The main objective of the study restrictions). Much has been said about the value of open-access is to provide Open access is comprehensive publishing in developing countries. Open-access publishing online access, information but it does not enables researchers in developing countries to establish about the open exclude print priority for their research, which they could use later to access digital access to the defend their intellectual property. repositories in same works. India. Open access is free of charge to to different countries of the readers, but it does not exclude world. Several enablers have priced access to print versions motivated the development of Scope of the Study The present study covers the of the same works, because print open-access publishing. These open access digital repositories in editions are expensive to produce, include global movements and India. Some of the repositories are they tend to be priced rather initiatives for open access like multidisciplinary in coverage and than free. Open access does not the Open Archives Initiative, the some are subject specific. exclude printouts by users or Budapest Open Access Initiative, print archives for security and Scholarly Publishing and Resources long-term preservation. Open Coalition, and Free Online Methodology access helps to ensure long- Scholarship, as well as initiatives The study was completed in three term access to scholarly articles. undertaken by International stages using the observation Unlike articles that are licensed Council for Science (ICSU) and method. In the first stage, a in traditional article databases, UNESCO. Other important list of the open access digital libraries and others can create local enablers are the availability repositories of India was prepared copies and repositories of these of free online publishing and by accessing different sources, like resources. Libraries, by working digital repository management the “Directory of Open Access together to make repositories of software such as Greenstone Repositories” on the Internet. open access literature, can ensure Digital Library Software, and In the next stage, the selected continued access to these scholarly protocols for metadata harvesting, repositories were evaluated to publications into the distant future. like OAI-PMH. Using these obtain the required information The Digital Repository is one standard protocols for metadata regarding them. However, a few type of open access source where allows interoperability among the repositories that were not accessible literature is available free of cost in repositories for sharing information in the aforesaid period due to some digital form. A Digital Repository and providing centralized services. technical problems were excluded. is a collection of digital resources Much has been said about the In the final stage, the collected KnowGenesis International Journal for Technical Communication (IJTC) Volume 2 Issue 1, March 2007 17 data was presented in tabular form, IR on behalf of the organizations and categorized under different concerned (Rajasekhar, 2003). headings, like subject, language, Table 1 lists the digital repositories documents available, number of covered in this study. items, software used, etc. to depict E-mail Alerts Yes No the findings. Findings Open Access Initiatives 1. The movements towards OAI-PMH Compliant No in India open access initiatives have Yes started in various states In India, there are many of India. The institutes noncommercial research and of different backgrounds development institutions, both have taken initiatives to Software Used DSpace DSpace academic and research laboratories. establish open access digital For example, there are more than repositories, and libraries No. of Items 191 300 universities that offer both are playing a key role. 427 graduate and research programs. 2. Most of the open access There are also many R&D digital repositories are laboratories operating within subject specific, dealing government science agencies with a particular branch of knowledge (e.g. DSpace Documents available Publications Publications; Conferences; that cover domains like industrial Theses research, defense research, at the National Chemical Laboratory, Pune) and agricultural research, medicine, some are multidisciplinary ecology, the environment, Language English (e.g. Digital library at the English information technology, space, Indian Statistical Institute, energy, and ocean development. Bangalore). These institutions produce a good 3. The collection in the open amount of literature on almost all access digital repositories is branches of
Recommended publications
  • Is Sci-Hub Increasing Visibility of Indian Research Papers? an Analytical Evaluation Vivek Kumar Singh1,*, Satya Swarup Srichandan1, Sujit Bhattacharya2
    Journal of Scientometric Res. 2021; 10(1):130-134 http://www.jscires.org Perspective Paper Is Sci-Hub Increasing Visibility of Indian Research Papers? An Analytical Evaluation Vivek Kumar Singh1,*, Satya Swarup Srichandan1, Sujit Bhattacharya2 1Department of Computer Science, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, INDIA. 2CSIR-National Institute of Science Technology and Development Studies, New Delhi, INDIA. ABSTRACT Sci-Hub, founded by Alexandra Elbakyan in 2011 in Kazakhstan has, over the years, Correspondence emerged as a very popular source for researchers to download scientific papers. It is Vivek Kumar Singh believed that Sci-Hub contains more than 76 million academic articles. However, recently Department of Computer Science, three foreign academic publishers (Elsevier, Wiley and American Chemical Society) have Banaras Hindu University, filed a lawsuit against Sci-Hub and LibGen before the Delhi High Court and prayed for Varanasi-221005, INDIA. complete blocking these websites in India. It is in this context, that this paper attempts to Email id: [email protected] find out how many Indian research papers are available in Sci-Hub and who downloads them. The citation advantage of Indian research papers available on Sci-Hub is analysed, Received: 16-03-2021 with results confirming that such an advantage do exist. Revised: 29-03-2021 Accepted: 25-04-2021 Keywords: Indian Research, Indian Science, Black Open Access, Open Access, Sci-Hub. DOI: 10.5530/jscires.10.1.16 INTRODUCTION access publishing of their research output, and at the same time encouraging their researchers to publish in openly Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) has become one accessible forms.
    [Show full text]
  • Will Sci-Hub Kill the Open Access Citation Advantage and (At Least for Now) Save Toll Access Journals?
    Will Sci-Hub Kill the Open Access Citation Advantage and (at least for now) Save Toll Access Journals? David W. Lewis October 2016 © 2016 David W. Lewis. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Introduction It is a generally accepted fact that open access journal articles enjoy a citation advantage.1 This citation advantage results from the fact that open access journal articles are available to everyone in the word with an Internet collection. Thus, anyone with an interest in the work can find it and use it easily with no out-of-pocket cost. This use leads to citations. Articles in toll access journals on the other hand, are locked behind paywalls and are only available to those associated with institutions who can afford the subscription costs, or who are willing and able to purchase individual articles for $30 or more. There has always been some slippage in the toll access journal system because of informal sharing of articles. Authors will usually send copies of their work to those who ask and sometime post them on their websites even when this is not allowable under publisher’s agreements. Stevan Harnad and his colleagues proposed making this type of author sharing a standard semi-automated feature for closed articles in institutional repositories.2 The hashtag #ICanHazPDF can be used to broadcast a request for an article that an individual does not have access to.3 Increasingly, toll access articles are required by funder mandates to be made publically available, though usually after an embargo period.
    [Show full text]
  • Piracy of Scientific Papers in Latin America: an Analysis of Sci-Hub Usage Data
    Developing Latin America Piracy of scientific papers in Latin America: An analysis of Sci-Hub usage data Juan D. Machin-Mastromatteo Alejandro Uribe-Tirado Maria E. Romero-Ortiz This article was originally published as: Machin-Mastromatteo, J.D., Uribe-Tirado, A., and Romero-Ortiz, M. E. (2016). Piracy of scientific papers in Latin America: An analysis of Sci-Hub usage data. Information Development, 32(5), 1806–1814. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0266666916671080 Abstract Sci-Hub hosts pirated copies of 51 million scientific papers from commercial publishers. This article presents the site’s characteristics, it criticizes that it might be perceived as a de-facto component of the Open Access movement, it replicates an analysis published in Science using its available usage data, but limiting it to Latin America, and presents implications caused by this site for information professionals, universities and libraries. Keywords: Sci-Hub, piracy, open access, scientific articles, academic databases, serials crisis Scientific articles are vital for students, professors and researchers in universities, research centers and other knowledge institutions worldwide. When academic publishing started, academies, institutions and professional associations gathered articles, assessed their quality, collected them in journals, printed and distributed its copies; with the added difficulty of not having digital technologies. Producing journals became unsustainable for some professional societies, so commercial scientific publishers started appearing and assumed printing, sales and distribution on their behalf, while academics retained the intellectual tasks. Elsevier, among the first publishers, emerged to cover operations costs and profit from sales, now it is part of an industry that grew from the process of scientific communication; a 10 billion US dollar business (Murphy, 2016).
    [Show full text]
  • Eprints Institutional Repository Software: a Review
    Partnership: the Canadian Journal of Library and Information Practice and Research, vol. 5, no. 2 (2010) Eprints Institutional Repository Software: A Review Mike Beazley Academic librarian Vaughan Memorial Library, Acadia University [email protected] Keywords Institutional Repository, Eprints, Review, Software, Open-Source Abstract Setting up an institutional repository (IR) can be a daunting task. There are many software packages out there, some commercial, some open source, all of which offer different features and functionality. This article will provide some thoughts about one of these software packages: Eprints. Eprints is open-source, and the software is easy to modify. This presents clear advantages for institutions will smaller budgets and that have programmers on staff. Installation and initial configuration are straightforward and once the IR is up and running, users can easily upload documents by filling out a simple web form. Eprints is an excellent choice for any institution looking to get an IR up and running quickly and easily, although it is less clear that an institution with an existing IR based on another software package should migrate to Eprints. Introduction Setting up an institutional repository (IR) can be a daunting task. There are many software packages out there, some commercial, some open source, all of which offer different features and functionality. This article will provide some thoughts about one of these software packages: Eprints. Eprints was one of the first IR software packages to appear and has been available for 10 years. It is under continual development by its creators at the University of Southampton and the current version is v3.2.3.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Access Self-Archiving of Refereed Research: a Post-Gutenberg Compromise Stevan Harnad University of Southhampton, [email protected]
    Against the Grain Volume 23 | Issue 2 Article 9 April 2011 Open Access Self-Archiving of Refereed Research: A Post-Gutenberg Compromise Stevan Harnad University of Southhampton, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/atg Part of the Library and Information Science Commons Recommended Citation Harnad, Stevan (2011) "Open Access Self-Archiving of Refereed Research: A Post-Gutenberg Compromise," Against the Grain: Vol. 23: Iss. 2, Article 9. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7771/2380-176X.5786 This document has been made available through Purdue e-Pubs, a service of the Purdue University Libraries. Please contact [email protected] for additional information. However, many publishers either do not make our collective understanding of the type of de- Journal Article Versioning is … any changes to the version of record or display mands from scholarly readers and practitioners from page 20 non-standard indicators when such changes oc- for article versioning standards. cur. SAGE is prepared to contribute to shared practices to release material of the highest pos- efforts toward clear and acceptable practices sible quality, published within known patterns for iterations beyond the version of record. Endnotes and bearing standard mechanisms of cataloging SAGE is prepared to launch another wave of 1. The summer 2010 survey was conducted and archiving, such as ISSNs and DOIs. Jour- production and platform enhancements to our by NISO across representatives of key nal article version metadata are now a facet of journals publishing program that allow clear groups — repository managers, librarians, publishers’ responsibilities in disseminating indications of changes to an article’s version and journal publishers and editors — to learn scholarly material online.
    [Show full text]
  • Getting Started Eprints Training: Repository Configuration Exercises
    EPrints Training: Repository Configuration Exercises Exercise 1: Getting Started The PCs provided for this session have been pre-installed with an EPrints demo repository. 1.1 Logging In To log into the machine enter the username eprints, Press return, and when asked enter the password you have been given. You will the be logged into the desktop. If you©re not familiar with Linux, don©t panic! Things work more or less the same as in Windows. 1.2 Entering Commands A terminal allows you to type commands directly. This is how you will issue commands to EPrints. Click the right mouse button on the desktop and select Open Terminal from the popup menu. Enter the following command: eprints> cd /opt/eprints2 (eprints> means ªtype this as user eprintsº) 1.3 Starting a Text Editor Each of the exercises in this session require you to edit one or more EPrints configuration files. To start a text editor application, click on the Applications button on the top left hand corner of the screen, select Accessories, then Text Editor. To edit the file: /opt/eprints2/archives/myid/cfg/template-en.xml click the Open button on the toolbar, then double-click on Filesystem in the left hand pane of the Open File.. dialog box. In the right hand pane, double-click opt, then eprints2 etc. until you reach template- en.xml. Double-click template-en.xml to open it for editing. 1.4 Starting a Web Browser After editing the EPrints configuration files, you will use a Web browser to check the results.To start a Web browser application, click on the Applications button, select Internet, then Firefox Web Browser.
    [Show full text]
  • Notes from the Interoperability Front: a Progress Report on the Open Archives Initiative
    Notes from the Interoperability Front: A Progress Report on the Open Archives Initiative Herbert Van de Sompel1, Carl Lagoze2 1Research Library, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM mailto:[email protected] 2Computing and Information Science, Cornell University Ithaca, NY USA 14850 [email protected] Abstract. The Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting (OAI-PMH) was first released in January 2001. Since that time, the protocol has been adopted by a broad community and become the focus of a number of research and implementation projects. We describe the various activities building on the OAI-PMH since its first release. We then describe the activities and decisions leading up to the release of a stable Version 2 of the OAI-PMH. Finally, we describe the key features of OAI-PMH Version 2. 1 Introduction Over a year has passed since the first release of the Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata harvesting (OAI-PMH) in January 2001. During that period, the OAI- PMH has emerged as a practical foundation for digital library interoperability. The OAI-PMH supports interoperability via a relatively simple two-party model. At one end, data providers employ the OAI-PMH to expose structured data, metadata, in various forms. At the other end, service providers use the OAI-PMH to harvest the metadata from data providers and then subsequently automatically process it and add value in the form of services. While resource discovery is often mentioned as the exemplar service, other service possibilities include longevity and risk management [19], personalization [16], and current awareness. The general acceptance of the OAI-PMH is based on a number of factors.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Access Self-Archiving: an Introduction
    Open access self-archiving: An introduction May 2005 Alma Swan Key Perspectives Limited 48 Old Coach Road, Playing Place, TRURO, Cornwall, TR3 6ET, UK (Registered Office) Tel. +44 (0)1392 879702 www.keyperspectives.co.uk www.keyperspectives.com Note to readers The pages that follow constitute the Introduction, Executive Summary and References from a document written in May 2005 reporting the findings of a large-scale survey of scholarly researcher behaviour with respect to open access, specifically the ‘green’ route to OA via self-archiving. The Introduction serves as a stand-alone starter document for those wishing to acquaint themselves with self-archiving without too much pain. The full study report, for those who are interested, can be found at any of the following URLs: www.keyperspectives.co.uk/OpenAccessArchive/2005_Open_Access_Report.pdf http://www.jisc.ac.uk/uploaded_documents/Open%20Access%20Self%20Archiving- an%20author%20study.pdf http://cogprints.org/4385/ Open Access Briefing Paper A two-page Briefing Paper on Open Access, which covers the principles and issues of open access in a very concise form, is published by the Joint Information Systems Committee (JISC) and is available at: http://www.jisc.ac.uk/uploaded_documents/JISC-BP-OpenAccess-v1-final.pdf EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This, our second author study on open access, was carried out to determine the current state of play with respect to author self-archiving behaviour. The survey was carried out during the last quarter of 2004. There were 1296 respondents. The survey also briefly explored author experiences and opinions on publishing in open access journals to follow up our previous study on this topic for JISC and the Open Society Institute.
    [Show full text]
  • Monitoring Compliance with Open Access Policies
    Monitoring Compliance with Open Access policies Monitoring Compliance with Open Access policies Author: Mafalda Picarra, Jisc Reviewers: Alma Swan, EOS December 2015 Introduction In the last few years, academic communities have seen an increase in the number of Open Access (OA) policies being adopted at the institutional and funder levels. In parallel to policy implementation, institutions and funders have also been engaged in developing mechanisms to monitor academics and researchers compliance with the existing OA policies. This study highlights a few of the cases where compliance is being effectively monitored by institutions and funders. In the first section, Open Access is briefly overviewed and the rationale for monitoring OA policy compliance is explained. The second section looks at best practices in monitoring policy compliance with OA policies by funders and institutions. The case studies reflect on compliance with the UK Funding Councils and the USA National Institutes of Health OA policies. The third section makes recommendations on what processes and procedures universities and funders should adopt to monitor compliance with their OA policies. The final section recapitulates some of the key ideas related to monitoring policy compliance. I. Open Access and monitoring compliance Open Access policies: An overview OA policies have been adopted by universities, research institutions and funders from as early as 2003. The Registry of Open Access Repository Mandates and Policies (ROARMAP) currently records the existence of 738 OA policies across the world, of which 440 have been implemented by universities (347) and funders (53) in Europe. OA policies provide information on the set of criteria that authors are required or encouraged to comply with in order to make their research outputs available on Open Access.
    [Show full text]
  • Shadow Libraries and You: Sci-Hub Usage and the Future of ILL
    Shadow Libraries and You: Sci-Hub Usage and the Future of ILL Gabriel J. Gardner, Stephen R. McLaughlin, and Andrew D. Asher* Scholars have shared copyrighted material outside official channels for decades, but recent market forces, profes- sional pressure, and novel technical exploits have allowed the large-scale automation of these practices. As a re- sult, millions of scholarly articles, chapters, books, and papers have been aggregated in illicit collections known as “shadow libraries,”1 available for free download by anyone with an Internet connection. The best-known shadow libraries are Library Genesis (LibGen) and the associated website Sci-Hub, which uses pooled university credentials to access articles and add them to LibGen’s repository. AvaxHome and the defunct website Library. nu are two others, with numerous smaller collections scattered across the web. Since Elsevier, in June 2015, filed a civil suit against Sci-Hub, its creator Alexandra Elbakyan, LibGen, and several John Does associated with LibGen,2 many articles and opinion pieces have been published on the role and possible effects of shadow libraries in the scholarly communication ecosystem. Though they clearly violate U.S. copyright law, many scholars are quick to offer praise rather than condemnation for the site. Sci-Hub is easy to use, offering simple and fast access to full-text articles in PDF format in a manner more straightforward than many library or publisher websites. To date, however, only a few scholars have examined the phenomenon em- pirically. There is a dearth of information on questions such as whether shadow libraries will reduce publishers’ revenues and disrupt the scholarly publishing industry, and whether they are affecting academic library usage or decreasing the use of interlibrary loan.
    [Show full text]
  • Das Zeitschriftenmanagement Wissenschaftlicher Bibliotheken Und Die Implikation Der Open-Access-Initiative
    DAS ZEITSCHRIFTENMANAGEMENT WISSENSCHAFTLICHER BIBLIOTHEKEN UND DIE IMPLIKATION DER OPEN-ACCESS-INITIATIVE Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doctor philosophiae (Dr. phil.) eingereicht an der Philosophischen Fakultät der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin von Miriam Judith Albers geb. Lorenz Präsidentin der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin: Prof. Dr.-Ing. Dr. Sabine Kunst Dekanin: Prof. Dr. Gabriele Metzler Gutachter/in: 1. Prof. Dr. Peter Schirmbacher 2. Prof. Dr. Simone Fühles-Ubach Datum der Einreichung: 18.07.2017 Datum der Disputation:17.10.2017 I Inhalt Zusammenfassung .................................................................................................................. IV Abstract .................................................................................................................................... V Danksagung ............................................................................................................................. VI Abkürzungsverzeichnis ........................................................................................................ VII Tabellenverzeichnis ................................................................................................................. X Abbildungsverzeichnis ........................................................................................................... XI 1 Einleitung ............................................................................................................................. 1 2 Merkmale des Zeitschriftenmanagements
    [Show full text]
  • Mainstream” and “Peripheral” Science1
    Open Access and the divide between “mainstream” and “peripheral” science1 Jean-Claude Guédon Université de Montréal 1 Introduction: scientific “fields” and scientific forms of power The discussions that have accompanied the development of Open Access have involved many different, actors, each with a particular point of view. As a result, the ensuing debates have been marked by the complex criss-crossing of various forms of discourse that often fly past each other without meeting. A fair degree of opacity has resulted from this situation, with the consequence that some of the concerns that should have been placed at the heart of the Open Access strategies have largely been neglected. For example, the stratified, competitive nature of science is largely admitted by most, but its evolution into what increasingly appears as an oligarchic power structure is less present in discussions and left unquestioned. Clearly, the structure of scientific power is affected by Open Access, and, as result, that structure should be kept in mind while framing strategies aimed at fostering Open Access. It is difficult to imagine, except rhetorically, how advocating for Open Access can be divorced from working for a different structuring of power in science. This issue is particularly important for developing and emerging countries. A theoretical detour will help set up the issue of power in science more sharply. Since the 1970's, Pierre Bourdieu, the well-known French sociologist, has argued that all cultural and intellectual activities should be analyzed in specific terms. The quest for success in literature may structurally be analyzed in terms that are structurally similar to those used to approach science, but the particulars are altogether different.
    [Show full text]