A Critical Ethnographical Exploration of Disability Under Apartheid Conditions: the Promising Potential of Palestinian Higher Education Institutions Yasmin Snounu
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Eastern Michigan University DigitalCommons@EMU Master's Theses, and Doctoral Dissertations, and Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations Graduate Capstone Projects 2019 A critical ethnographical exploration of disability under apartheid conditions: The promising potential of Palestinian higher education institutions Yasmin Snounu Follow this and additional works at: https://commons.emich.edu/theses Part of the Disability Studies Commons, Education Commons, and the Educational Sociology Commons Recommended Citation Snounu, Yasmin, "A critical ethnographical exploration of disability under apartheid conditions: The promising potential of Palestinian higher education institutions" (2019). Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations. 959. https://commons.emich.edu/theses/959 This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Master's Theses, and Doctoral Dissertations, and Graduate Capstone Projects at DigitalCommons@EMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@EMU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Critical Ethnographical Exploration of Disability under Apartheid Conditions: The Promising Potential of Palestinian Higher Education Institutions by Yasmin Snounu Dissertation Submitted to the College of Education Eastern Michigan University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in Educational Studies Concentration in Urban Education Dissertation Committee: Joe Bishop, Ph.D., Chair Ethan Lowenstein, Ph.D. Christopher Robbins, Ph.D. Kristine Ajrouch, Ph.D. January 2019 Ypsilanti, Michigan Running head: DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION ii Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to my mother, Feryal Snounu, and to my child, Habiba Kenda, who both continue to give me strength throughout my life. You have been the source of inspiration. This dissertation is completed in the hopes of better understanding the Palestinian voices. DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION iii Acknowledgments This journey would not have been a success without the support of my family and friends. Those behind the stage inspired my Ph.D. journey. My mother, Feryal Snounu, who is my model, hero, and best friend, spent countless hours through Skype giving academic and personal pieces of advice and listening to me talk for hours. She has limitlessly supported me emotionally and financially, as well as shared her own experience as an educator with me. I have no words to thank you. You continue to be a source of my pride and my strength. I look up to you and love you with all my heart. My daughter, Habiba Kenda, was born on my first day of my Education, Communities, and Globalization course during the beginning of my doctoral program. You have been the best girl I could ever ask for, thank you for comforting me, for cheering me up, for attending all my classes and for giving me company during all stages of this journey. You have my love. My father, my sisters and my brothers, Haneen, Mahmoud, Aya, Nozha, Mohammed, Sofyan, Abdelrahman, and my brother-in-law, Mahmoud Al Fiqy, thank you for all the family time together, for all the sister talks at times when I felt down. Thank you all for cooking and babysitting Habiba while I was collecting data in Palestine and for taking me around the West Bank and driving me to the universities. My professors in the Educational Studies program, especially my dissertation committee members, Dr. Ethan Lowenstein, Dr. Christopher Robbins, and Dr. Kristine Ajrouch. I am honored to have been able to accomplish my doctoral degree under your guidance. A special thanks goes to Dr. Kristine Ajrouch, who never hesitated to make time DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION iv for me. Thank you for great lunches and conversations we had together. Thank you for always thinking about me. Dr. Phil Smith, the amazing professor who strongly believed in my work, inspired this journey with his unique critical perspectives on disability. Thank you for all the unlimited academic support you provided, and for keeping me in the loop through sharing several conferences opportunities. I cannot thank you enough. I also extend my appreciation to my American parents, Ruth and Andrew Zweifler, who have welcomed me as a member to their family since 2010. They gave me a home always from home. I cherish you with all my heart. And to my friend Veronica Konglim, thank you for babysitting Habiba when I would lecture on campus. Thank you for listening to me every time I needed an ear. To Esther Gunel, your unlimited support and care on many levels academically and personally facilitated my Ph.D. journey. I look up to you and appreciate you as a mentor and as an activist. Thank you, Esther, for providing me with a GA during my first two years of my doctoral program. To Laura Kovick, I owe you a lot. Thank you for all your time and efforts editing my work. I appreciate your patience and enthusiasm about my work. You are truly amazing. Your input was valuable, and our discussions were insightful. To Dr. Martha Kinney-Sedgwick, former Head of Teacher Education Department, I appreciate all the support especially granting me a doctoral fellowship. To Dean Micheal Sayler, thank you for all the support you provided, especially the small grant you provided me to help with transcriptions. In Palestine, I extend my deep gratitude to my friends Raqia Amr, Sa’ad Amr and Samia Hawamda, who all work at Birzeit University. They did not spare any effort to help DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION v me move my dissertation forward, especially during data collection in Palestine. I greatly value my friendship with you. Finally, my sincere appreciation goes to my dissertation chair and mentor, Dr. Joe Bishop. Thank you for everything you have done to support me. I appreciate your continuous support and guidance. You have always challenged me to think more critically. You truly empowered me during this journey. You gave me many opportunities to grow as a professional academic, especially through having me co-teach graduate and undergraduate courses with you. I am grateful to you for believing in me. Thank you for simply being you. DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION vi Abstract Utilizing a critical ethnographical methodology, this dissertation explores the experiences and practices of professors and administrators towards accommodating disabled students mainly in Palestine, but also taking into consideration the importance of the both political and disability contexts of the United States, primarily in light of critical disability studies, while also drawing from critical discourse analysis in regard to aspects of language, power hierarchies, and identity. Elements of teacher development theories are used in relation to transformational ways of thinking and the role of educators in combating stigma and promoting/adopting inclusive pedagogical practices towards accommodating disabled students in higher education. My understanding of experiences and practices of Palestinian and American faculty and administrators in higher education is derived from semi-structured interviews, observations, field notes, and pictures between October 2015 and December 2015, and September and December 2017. My findings show that disability in Palestine is associated with Israeli apartheid, creating what I call “a triple matrix of maiming Palestinians.” Such a matrix begins with targeting the Palestinian body, then continues to destroy the Palestinian infrastructure, and finally maintaining dominance. It creates internal divisions and scattered efforts towards disability services and also impacts the ability of the Palestinian Authority to serve the Palestinian people. Secondly, the complexity of stigma in Palestine includes heroic stigma, resulting from Israeli practices, which is positive, and stigma that is associated with disability from birth, which is perceived negatively. Most importantly, my findings show that Palestinian higher education institutions are a promising arena for providing an educationally inclusive environment under apartheid conditions. My study also shows that Palestinian DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION vii faculty and administrators advocate for disabled students on campus and local and international non-governmental organizations (NGOs) contribute to serve disabled Palestinians, but the work of the NGOs still exhibits discrepancies. In the U.S., unclear policies for professors on how to handle accommodations for students with disabilities and lack of training on inclusion create ableism. Stigma is still salient in the academic discourse and is connected to race and social status, generating “racialization of disability.” Keywords: Israeli apartheid, Palestinian higher education institutions, faculty and administrators, stigma, advocacy, community, NGOs, American higher education. DISABILITY IN HIGHER EDUCATION viii Table of Contents Dedication ................................................................................................................................. ii Acknowledgments.................................................................................................................... iii Abstract .................................................................................................................................... vi List of Tables……..………………………………………………………………………………………xi List of Figures…………………………………………………………………………………………...xii Chapter 1: Review of Literature ..............................................................................................