A Playing Comparison of British and American Courses

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Playing Comparison of British and American Courses 1 ! ,-- '* _ A Playing Comparison of British and American Courses by JAY SIGEL, British Amateur Champion; Walker Cup Team; World Amateur Team; Aronimink Golf Club, Newtown Square, Pennsylvania Jay Sigel the ball from up to 40 yards off the Aronimink last year, I really hadn't green. Of course, the fairways were also given much thought to differences in HEN MEMBERS OF an Amer­ very close-cropped. The rough was very golf course management practices. Now Wican club discuss the condition high and variable in growth and plant I wonder why have we moved so far of their golf course, the conversation population. You'd have to call it rugged away from the conditioning like the typically dwells on color, not on play- compared to ours. courses where the game originated and ability. I suspect that television has A lie in the rough in Britain or Scot­ away from an emphasis on good play- helped to develop these attitudes; I have land requires a very delicate shot just to ability? I guess part of the answer is that been in a number of TV production move a ball back to the fairway. On our the average American golfer's fetish for facilities and noted their great concern courses, a lie in the rough can some­ soft, lush turf often pressures the super­ for the TV viewer and on how they times be better than one we might have intendent into applying more water and might color the picture to make it more in the fairway. Sand in their bunkers is fertilizer. This in turn increases Poa appealing for the viewer. This is also extremely firm, and the bunkers them­ annua encroachment and related prob­ the prime reason for overseeding dor­ selves are very deep. I've had conver­ lems of summer turf weaknesses. By mant bermudagrass fairways with rye­ sations about water with a number of forcing growth and color, we increase grasses, to make the event more attrac­ people, and of the four courses I played, maintenance requirements which in tive for the viewer, not to improve the the only watering system I saw was at turn increases budget expenditures. dormant bermudagrass playing surface. Hillside, where the British Amateur was Does forcing growth then make good Twenty-five years ago my home played, although I understand that St. golf sense? course didn't have watered fairways. Andrews has an irrigation system. As for the better player, I don't think Each year our grass turned brown. In general, only a few British courses he minds Poa annua one bit, as long as During the six to eight weeks of sum­ have watering systems, and I know of it is cut closely. He doesn't become con­ mer, I also remember the high level of none as sophisticated as ours. Their cerned if the turf turns brown and the playability of that golf course, the greens are very firm, but certainly not as Poa annua thins out or dies as long as feeling of being able to control a shot good to putt as our greens. They are he can strike the ball cleanly with the from the turf because that turf was firm. grainier than ours and very close-cut. club face. We all recognize that this is I know that the older players also en­ American players liked their firmness. the way golf is played in Great Britain. joyed this because they got more roll. They were very consistent. Golf there is played on grass, not color. Also, the speed of the greens certainly I believe Tony Jacklin recently said If the American golfer could play from a was faster; the overall pace of the course that one of the reasons American players firm surface, he would be able to control was much quicker, and it seemed to produce generally better results is that the ball better. In my opinion he would translate into faster play. they are better putters, and that better improve his game and he would enjoy Let's compare the British and the putters are developed on better greens. golf more. American golf courses as I see them. Our putting surfaces are far more smooth Shouldn't we try to give this play- The British courses have no motorized than those on the four courses that I saw. ability back to the game? Wouldn't that carts at all that I could see on the four conserve energy and precious water? courses we played — St. Andrews and HE BRITISH DO NOT play win­ Wouldn't that save dollars for clubs that Muirfield, in Scotland, and Hillside and Tter rules; they do not even know now are experiencing troubled times? I Royal Birkdale in England. The color of what winter rules are! I found that pose these questions though I certainly these golf courses is drab, like the interesting. They don't know what don't have the answers. I thank you all weather there. Height of the grass, I mulligans are either. That alone must for helping me to better understand think, is of interest. Approach fringes spare their first tees from much abuse. some of your problems in the regret­ were very, very short, enabling us, I must admit that until I became a tably brief association I've enjoyed with during the Walker Cup Match, to putt member of the Green Committee at you. Thank you for inviting me. 4 USGA GREEN SECTION RECORD .
Recommended publications
  • Walker Cup Memories
    USGA JOURNAL: AUGUST, 1949 5 Walker Cup Memories By FRAiNCIS D. OUIMET MEMBER, USGA WALKER CUP TEAM 1922-23-24-26-28-30-32-34; CAPTAIN, 32-34-36-38-47-49 When George Herbert Walker con­ obliged because of time and space to ceived the idea of bringing together ama­ mention only a few of the most promin­ teur golfers representing the USGA and ent matches. Unfortunately, I must forego the Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St. the foursome matches. Though they are Andrews, Scotland, he was hopeful of fully as important in the final outcome accomplishing two things. The first and as some of the singles, they are played most important was to have the players first and their true value is sometimes understand one another and thereby overlooked in the enthusiasm that follows bring about a closer friendliness between the concluding individual contests. the two great nations they represented. Yet I would be lacking in candor and Secondly, by this close association in a fairness if I did not mention the great sporting match they could better keep British foursome team of Cyril Tolley the standard of the game on the highest and Roger Wethered. In the early possible plane. Twenties, they were about as fine a That his sound reasoning has borne combination as one could ask for, and fruit must be a source of great satisfac­ they gave their American opponents a tion to Mr. Walker. I know of no inter­ hard day. national contest that is played more keen­ Nor can I soon forget the gallant show ly or with more consideration toward put on by Alec Hill and Cecil Ewing the opponent than the Walker Cup at Pine Valley in 1936 against George Matches.
    [Show full text]
  • Walker Cup Thursday, May 6, 2021 Juno Beach, Florida, USA Seminole Golf Club Stuart Wilson Alex Fitzpatrick Past
    Walker Cup Thursday, May 6, 2021 Juno Beach, Florida, USA Seminole Golf Club Stuart Wilson Alex Fitzpatrick past. Do you feel like you're bringing a little bit of John Murphy experience and wisdom to the team? Joe Long ALEX FITZPATRICK: Not particularly, being honest with you. I think obviously having some experience from that GB&I Press Conference last one is important to bring, but a lot of these guys, if not all of them, have all played some form of match play before, so everyone is used to either playing foursomes or OLIVIA MCMILLAN: I am delighted to welcome some of singles, and everyone is used to being in that environment, the members of the GB&I team to our virtual press and I think that's what's good about our team is that we've conference today. We are joined by Captain Stuart Wilson, all played that, and I feel like some of the Americans just Alex Fitzpatrick, Joe Long and John Murphy. Thank you all haven't been in that format and obviously playing very much for joining us. foursomes together. I will begin with Stuart, please. Can you give us a little bit, OLIVIA MCMILLAN: John, you're getting ready to head out talk to us about what the last few days have been like and to Seminole this morning to have another practice round. how the team's preparations are going. What have your preparations been like and what have you been focusing on? STUART WILSON: Yeah, thanks, Olivia. Obviously we've been out here for a few days now.
    [Show full text]
  • Watsonian Golf Club Competitions & Honours
    Watsonian Golf Club Competitions & Honours Club Championship – Roberts Trophy The Watsonian Club Championship comprises the the top 8 scratch scores from the Muirfield outing, who then play off in matchplay for the Roberts Trophy. The inscription reads: ‘The Roberts Trophy presented by George St C Murray Esq to The Watsonian Golf Club In Memory Of Lieut. George Roberts, Gordon Highlanders. Scottish Golf Internationalist 1937 & 1938. Scottish Rugby Internationalist 1938 & 1939. Taken Prisoner Singapore 1942. Died in Captivity 1943.’ The Roberts Trophy has been awarded to the winner of the Club Championship since it started in 1994. 1994 AK Helm 1995 AJ Hogg 1996 AJ Hogg 1997 AL Turner 1998 JR Johnston 1999 JR Johnston 2000 BJH Tait 2001 JR Johnston 2002 RJ Craig 2003 JR Johnston 2004 AL Turner 2005 RJ Craig 2006 AH Williams 2007 MDG Hopley 2008 JR Johnston 2009 BJH Tait 2010 RJ Craig 2011 RJ Craig 2012 WJ Main 2013 JR Johnston 2014 JR Johnston 2015 GD Johnston 2016 GD Johnston 2017 RJ Craig 2018 RJ Paterson Previously the Roberts Trophy was awarded to the lowest scratch score at the Western Gailes outing and then the lowest scratch at the Luffness outing. 1947 RB Johnston 1948 WA Whitelaw 1949 CK White 1950 RB Johnston 1951 CB Hendry 1952 TC Brown 1953 RB Johnston 1954 ED Smith 1955 DC Stewart 1956 RB Johnston 1957 DC Stewart 1958 AS Flockhart 1959 AS Flockhart 1960 DC Stewart 1961 GD Millar 1962 DC Stewart 1963 PR Bryce 1964 RA Davie 1965 RB Johnston 1966 GD Webster 1967 GD Millar 1968 GD Millar 1969 DED Neave 1970 GE Robertson 1971 CN Hastings 1972 AF Brown 1973 AF Brown 1974 DED Neave 1975 P McNeil 1976 CN Hastings 1977 RP White 1978 P McNeil 1979 P McNeil 1980 P McNeil 1981 RM McNeil 1982 GJN Gemmel 1983 P McNeil 1984 KG Cameron 1985 RGB Mavor 1986 P McNeil 1987 GW Thomson 1988 P McNeil 1989 KG Cameron 1990 1991 AF Brown 1992 BJG Bingham & BJH Tait 1993 WatsonianGolfClub.com Gold Medal The Gold Medal is the oldest competition of the Watsonian Golf Club, first played for in 1889.
    [Show full text]
  • Walker Cup Match by WILLIAM P
    10 USGA JOURNAL AND TURF MANAGEMENT: JUNE, 1951 The Walker Cup Match By WILLIAM P. TURNESA CAPTAIN, USGA WALKER CUP TEAM; FORMER USGA AND BRITISH AMATEUR CHAMPION Every now and then one hears isolated the recent event at the Birkdale Golf Club, queries as to whether the Walker Cup Southport, England. series should be continued. The thirteenth He was 3 under 4s for the 35 holes of Match in the series was held last month, his singles victory over Charley Coe. Ian and the United States has won all but Caldwell is a very promising youngster, once from the British amateur teams. just 21. John Langley and John Morgan will bear watching in the future with their Those who have ever had the fun of sound styles of play. Certain it is that the being in the show know that the value of British have come upon and have devel­ the Walker Cup competition far trans­ oped some very fine players under the cends the mere winning and losing of a watchful eye of their splendid Walker Cup handsome silver trophy. It has been dem­ Team Captain, Raymond Oppenheimer. onstrated repeatedly that the event serves If the British amateurs were to practice a wonderful purpose in friendly interna­ as diligently and to play in competition tional relations, so sorely needed today. as extensively as do our boys, the Walker The recent Match demonstrated not Cup might have a different inscription for only that point but also that Great Britain 1951. In play from trouble, particularly has some really fine amateur golfers with with the wedge from bunkers, and on the which to challenge us in future.
    [Show full text]
  • The Legend Of
    The Legend of Charlie Coe Sports aficionados know that this Sooner could have been one of the immortals who took professional golf into its golden age -if he had not put family before fame. BY JAY C. UPCHURCH a few months, the northwest cornerIof Constitution Street and Par Drive in Norman will be home to a 6,200-square-foot, state-of-the-art practice and teaching facility that will house the University of Oklahoma men's and women's golf programs. Serving as a link between Sooners past, present and future, the Charlie Coe Golf Learning Center honors the greatest golfer in OU history. While Charlie Coe himself might point to the accomplishments ofplay- ers like Andrew Magee, Jim Vickers and Walter Emery, no other Sooner has done more to put Oklahoma on the golfing map than the gifted Ardmore native. For more than half a century, Coe quietly has been this state's am- bassador to the world of golf. During that span, Coe established himself as the finest amateur golfer of When Charlie Coe won his first U .S .G .A. National Amateur Championship in 1949, his his era and one of the greatest of all wife, Liz, was beside him, as she has been for all his triumphs, "every step of the way." time . He won two U.S . Amateur titles 26 SOONERMAGAZINE and etched his name along side those of Instead, a shortage in traveling funds champions like Arnold Palmer, Ben forced then-OU coach Bruce Drake to Hogan, Jack Nicklaus and Sam Snead. take only his top two players to the NCAA But with all ofthe accolades, with all Tournament at Princeton, New Jersey .
    [Show full text]
  • Swinging Around Golf Proved Plans Totaling $100,000
    Ron Ziikle goes from manager's post at , Everett (Wash.) G&CC to similar position at Columbia-Edgewater CC, Portland, Ore. Joe Cote is new manager at May- nard (Mass.) CC . Sam Fisher now man- ager at Oak Ridge (Tenn.) CC . Hewitt t Roddy now managing Oaks CC, Beaumont, Tex. Walter Smith recently appointed manager of Alamogordo (N.M.) CC . John F. Sutter now pro at Great Neck CC, Wareham, Mass. The Golf Writers Association, which often is taken advantage of by free listen- , ing radio men, set up a perimeter defense at the PGA Championship to balk the sportscasters who planned to tape the writers' interviews with the scoring lead- ers . The writers' group doesn't object SWINGING to the host club or sponsors taping the interviews, but it is totally opposed to ra- AROUND f dio men who reap the benefit of the con- versations between players and newspa- permen . The GWA also is trying to GOLF convince collegiate officials that holding the NCAA golf tournament the week of News of the Golf the Open isn't a smart policy . The college golfers score approximately zero- World in Brief zero in publicity when they're competing against the copy that pours out of the Open site . Another thing that the By HERB GRAFFIS GWA is taking a stand on is the indis- criminate distribution of "Working Press" credentials at some of the tournaments . Unauthorized holders of press badges FRONT COVER usually disrupt tournament coverage. Photographer Bill Mark rounded up 15 Copies of an article by Jack Raba, "I former PGA champions and took this unusual photo when the PGA Champ- t Caddied for Amie", which appeared in ionship was played in Columbus.
    [Show full text]
  • History of the Kenridge Invitational
    HISTORY OF THE KENRIDGE INVITATIONAL A group of men attempted to establish a golf and country club in the Charlottesville/Albemarle County area a number of times before succeeding with Farmington County Club in 1929. Before Farmington, the local alternative was a nine- hole course, “Albemarle Golf Club”, located off of Meade Avenue in Charlottesville. However, the success of Farmington Country Club brought about the demise of Albemarle Golf Club. A 1931 article in ‘Golf Illustrated’ noted that “they” acquired a parcel of land, some one thousand acres, for development of a community and golf course. Fred Findlay received the commission to design the original eighteen-hole venue, which opened in May 1929. Findlay was born in Scotland, and after serving in the British Army spent the rest of his life as an amateur painter and professional golf course architect. Records show that Findlay designed more golf courses in the Commonwealth of Virginia than any other individual. Fred Findlay’s son-in-law, Raymond F. Loving, actually began work on the golf course in early 1927, prior to the official formation of Farmington Country Club. Loving’s effort led to his appointment as the Club’s General Manager, before the golf course was even finished! To serve as Golf Professional, Jack Robertson was hired from The Cascades, and he remained until 1934. Amongst the early Farmington members, Dr. Rice Warren, Dr. M.L. Rea and W. Fritz Souder established themselves in golfing circles. Soon after Farmington’s founding, it joined the Appalachian Golf Association which had existed for some fifteen years.
    [Show full text]
  • Chicago Golf Club
    INFORMATION FOR GUESTS Historical Notes The Chicago Golf Club was founded in 1892 by Charles Blair Macdonald and other prominent Chicagoans who wanted to play the game they had experienced during their travels to Scotland. The USGA recognizes the original course they built in Belmont (now Downers Grove) as the first 18-hole course in the United States. In 1895, Chicago Golf opened Macdonald’s new course, built on more spacious land that the Club had acquired in Wheaton. Macdonald, who also became the first U.S. Amateur Champion, wanted the course built in keeping with the style and tradition of the great courses in Britain. Macdonald’s belief that trees were not an appropriate hazard opened great vistas across the course and subjected play to the vagaries of the wind. Macdonald evolved this style over the next quarter century as he became the first golf course architect of renown in the U.S. At Macdonald’s suggestion, Chicago Golf was redesigned by his protégé Seth Raynor, with the new course opening in 1923. Chicago Golf’s 21st century course is still Raynor’s original design. The “modern” course features several prototype Macdonald/Raynor holes that are considered among their best – the “Road Hole” 2nd, the “Biarritz” 3rd, the “Redan” 7th, “Punchbowl” 12th were modeled on the great holes in European golf, while the “Cape” 4th and 14th holes were based on an original Macdonald/Raynor design. James Foulis from St. Andrews, Scotland, was the Club’s first professional. An excellent player and clubmaker, Foulis won the second U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • SEPTEMBER!! It's Been a Bit of a Wet August. We Thank You
    WELCOME SEPTEMBER!! It’s been a bit of a wet August. We thank you for working with us to keep the course in great condition by follow- ing the 90 degree or cart path only rules on the extra wet days. Looking Table of Contents forward to September, its looking like we will have some warm weath- A LOOK FORWARD PG. 2 er with hopefully less rain days. Golf is always fun but even more so A LOOK BACK PG. 3 when you can drive to your ball. Here’s to a wonderful Fall season. NOBODY CARES, PG. 5 MOVE ALONG LIGHTEN UP PG. 8 The Comeback: Ti- PG. 9 ger's journey against the 'Tiger Effect' generation What's coming up PG. 18 Here is a look back though time at some golf history from September. Credit to Colin Brown, USGA https://www.usga.org/clubhouse/2016-ungated/09-ungated/september--this-month-in- golf-history.html Sept. 2, 1973: After failing to qualify in two previous attempts, Craig Stadler won the U.S. Amateur. Then a junior at the University of Southern California who had yet to be dubbed “The Walrus,” Stadler defeated David Strawn, 6 and 5, at Inverness Club in Toledo, Ohio. Sept. 3, 1936 : The USA Walker Cup Team, captained by three-time USGA champion Francis Ouimet, defeated Great Britain and Ireland, 9 -0, at Pine Valley Golf Club. This was the first of two Walker Cups to be played at the venerable New Jersey club, the only USGA champi- onships ever contested there. Sept.
    [Show full text]
  • The Boardwalk Trophy and the Eastern Hockey League Part 1: the Sea Gulls, the Rovers, the Olympics and the Cutters by Chuck Miller (Hockey Ink! Vol
    FROM ATLANTIC CITY TO TORONTO: The Boardwalk Trophy and the Eastern Hockey League Part 1: The Sea Gulls, the Rovers, the Olympics and the Cutters By Chuck Miller (Hockey Ink! Vol. III, Iss. 2-3) True story - The Atlantic City Boardwalk Trophy, a prize handed from champion to champion of the old Eastern League, was found in a storage shed. Brian Elwell, a former player/coach for the old Syracuse Blazers, became a successful bar and grille owner after his retirement from hockey. As we talked about the proposed new AHL team for Syracuse, Elwell reminisced about his days in the Eastern Hockey League. "You know," he said to me, "somebody dropped this trophy off at my restaurant. It's been in my storage shed for a while. Seems like I remember seeing this once or twice in my playing days." I drove to Syracuse, hoping against hope that the pilgrimage wouldn't be just a 150-mile sightseeing journey. And when Elwell brought out a missile-shaped trophy with "THE BOARDWALK CHALLENGE TROPHY," carved into its side, the engravings drowning in a sea of tarnish and dirt, I knew this was something big. -=- Our journey begins in the fall of 1930. Lincoln Dickey, manager of the Atlantic City Auditorium, imported some Montreal-based hockey players, set them up against the toughest amateur and professional teams on the East Coast, and the Atlantic City Sea Gulls were born. Led by coach Redvers McKenzie, the Gulls hosted everybody from the New York Rangers to college teams, and by 1932 they were one of the top amateur hockey squads.
    [Show full text]
  • Walker Cup Match
    46TH WALKER CUP MATCH MEDIA GUIDE SEPTEMBER 9-10, 2017 The Los Angeles Country Club | Los Angeles, Calif. 46TH WALKER CUP MATCH SEPTEMBER 9-10, 2017 The Los Angeles Country Club (North Course) Los Angeles, Calif. Par: 35-35–70 Yardage: 7,397 Golf Course Architect: George C. Thomas Jr., 1927 Golf Course Restoration: Gil Hanse, 2010 2017 CONDITIONS OF PLAY THE TEAMS The Walker Cup Match is contested by male amateur golfers, one team from the United States of America and one team comprised of players from England, Ireland, Scotland and Wales. The teams consist of not more than 10 players and a captain. LOCATION & SCHEDULE OF PLAY The Match is conducted every two years, alternately in the USA and in Great Britain or Ireland. In 2017, the 46th Walker Cup Match will be played on the North Course at the Los Angeles Country Club in Los Angeles, Calif. Saturday, Sept. 9 Four foursomes matches (18 holes) Eight singles matches (18 holes) Sunday, Sept. 10 Four foursomes matches (18 holes) 10 singles matches (18 holes) SCORING Victory in a match scores one point. When a match goes 18 holes without a decision, one-half point is awarded to each side. 2017 UNITED STATES WALKER CUP TEAM CAMERON CHAMP DOC REDMAN 22, of Sacramento, Calif. 19, of Raleigh, N.C. DOUG GHIM SCOTTIE SCHEFFLER 21, of Arlington Heights, Ill. 21, of Dallas, Texas STEWART HAGESTAD BRADEN THORNBERRY 26, of Newport Beach, Calif. 20, of Olive Branch, Miss. MAVERICK MCNEALY NORMAN XIONG 21, of Portola Valley, Calif. 18, of Canyon Lake, Calif.
    [Show full text]
  • Walker Cup Saturday, May 8, 2021 Juno Beach, Florida, USA Seminole Golf Club Nathaniel Crosby Cole Hammer up in the Afternoon
    Walker Cup Saturday, May 8, 2021 Juno Beach, Florida, USA Seminole Golf Club Nathaniel Crosby Cole Hammer up in the afternoon. But yeah, the ball rolls incredibly true, United States Press Conference but you have to be really careful or else you'll have six-, seven-, eight-foot comebackers. THE MODERATOR: Thank you for joining us. We're Q. Nathaniel, can you take me through your emotions joined by captain Nathaniel Crosby and Cole Hammer. from this morning through the afternoon in terms of The U.S. is holding a 7-5 lead after the first day of the 48th just what it was like to go through everything today, Walker Cup here at Seminole Golf Club. Captain Crosby, given obviously all the circumstances that have gone if you could comment on your assessment of how the day on with the bug and whatnot and whether your lineup went in the morning and in the afternoon. would be able to stay the way you thought it would? What was it like for you to watch this whole thing play NATHANIEL CROSBY: I was a nervous parent all day is out? what it felt like to me. A lot of ebbs and flows in the matches, and I feel that the U.S. is very fortunate to have a NATHANIEL CROSBY: There were a lot of violent mood narrow lead going into tomorrow. So very happy about the swings today. It was amazing because we kind of altered whole turn of events, especially at the end with Cole -- the R&A and the USGA were really ahead of the curve hanging on to his match and Austin winning his match.
    [Show full text]