In the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 03 rd DAY OF APRIL 2014 BEFORE: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND BYRAREDDY WRIT PETITION Nos.51937-51938 OF 2013 (EDN-EX) CONNECTED WITH WRIT PETITION Nos.26338-26364 OF 2013 (EDN-AD) WRIT PETITION Nos.24702 AND 25191 AND 25192-25478 AND 25829 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION Nos.26124-26128 of 2013 (EDN-AD) WRIT PETITION Nos.25650-25716 OF 2013 (EDN-AD) WRIT PETITION Nos.25837-25844/2013 (EDN-AD) WRIT PETITION Nos.25867-25914 OF 2013 (EDN-AD) WRIT PETITION Nos. 24610-24674 and 24675 OF 2013 (EDN- AD) IN W.P.Nos.51937-51938/2013 BETWEEN: 1. Miss. Srinija Dasari, Daughter of Sri. D. Ranga Rao, Aged about 19 years, 2 2. Miss. Patel Mansi Suresh Bhai, Daughter of Suresh Bhai Patel, Aged about 18 years, Both are the students studying in BDA Course in Oxford Dental College, Bommanahalli, Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560 068. …PETITIONERS ( By Shri. Vinod Prasad, Advocate ) AND: 1. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, 4th ‘T’ Block, Jayanagar, Bangalore -560 011, Represented by its Registrar. 2. The Oxford Dental College, Bommanahalli, Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560 068. By its Principal. 3. The State of Karnataka, By its Secretary, to Health and Family Welfare (Medical Education Department) M.S.Building, Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore – 560 001. …RESPONDENTS (By Shri. N.K.Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent No.1 3 Shri. B. Veerappa, Additional Government Advocate for Respondent No.3 Respondent No.2 served and unrepresented) ***** These Writ Petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying to direct the first respondent, Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences to approve the admission of the petitioners for the BDS course for which they have taken admission during the academic year 2012-2013 in the second respondent Oxford Dental College, Bangalore. IN W.P.Nos.26338-26364/2013 BETWEEN: 1. S.B.Patil Dental College and Hospital Naubad, Bidar: 585 402, Represented by its Principal. 2. Mr. Surwase Vijay, Son of Subhash Rao, 3. Mr. Pokala Akhil, Son of P. Rajashekhar, 4. Mr. Fathepurkar Aditya, Son of Avinash, 5. Ms. Haseena T.P, Daughter of Mammupockr Haji, 6. Ms. QurratulAin Zainab, Daughter of Khaja Moinuddin Ahmed, 4 7. Ms. Aiman Sidru, Daughter of Md. Asifuddin, 8. Ms. Raveena Srivastava, Daughter of Anil Kumar, 9. Ms. Gamini Vijayadurga, Daughter of G. Nagesh Babu, 10. Ms. K. Lavanya Mahitha, Daughter of K. Venkat Raman, 11. Ms. Kokkanda Satya Mansha, Daughter of K. Laxmipathi, 12. Ms. Saradhy Samhitha, Daughter of S. Pratap Ray, 13. Ms. B. Sayantikar, Daughter of B.V. Jayaraman, 14. Ms. Sriramla Yamini, Daughter of Shiman Naragana, 15. Ms. Sumayya Fatema, Daughter of Mohd. Rafiq Khan, 16. Ms. Pooja Pawar, Daughter of Dev Singh, 17. Ms. Bethala Swathipriya, Daughter of Bethala Ramanakumar, 18. Mr. MG Medara Ramakanth, 5 Son of Ramchandraiah, 19. Mr. Mayank Dwivedi, Son of R.K. Dwivedi, 20. Ms. Boppana Mounica, Daughter of B. Nageshwar Rao, 21. Ms. Sarangi Mohandas, Daughter of P.M. Mohandas, 22. Ms. Rajapuram Naya Manusha, Daughter of R. Sathyanander, 23. Ms. Dara Rani Mrudula, Daughter of Dara Ratan George, 24. Ms. Vryyatala Priyadarshini, Daughter of V. Madhusudhan Rao, 25. Mr. Ravipate Ramesh Babu, Son of R. Venkateshwar Rao, 26. Ms. Shimaila Fatima, Daughter of Abdul Bari, 27. Singh Supriya, Daughter of Bhikam Singh, Petitioners 2 to 27 are all Aged about 18 years and all are Students studying in First Year BDS Course at S.B.Patil Dental College and Hospital, Naubad, Bidar – 585 402. …PETITIONERS 6 (By Shri. L.M. Chidanandayya, Advocate) AND: 1. State of Karnataka By its Principal Secretary, Medical Education, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Vikasa Soudha, Bangalore – 560 001. 2. The Dental Council of India, Iwan-E-Galib Marg, Kotla Road, New Delhi – 110 002, Represented by its Secretary. 3. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences for Karnataka, 4th ‘T’ Block, Jayanagar, Bangalore – 560 041, Represented by its Registrar. …RESPONDENTS (By Shri. B. Veerappa, Additional Government Advocate for Respondent No.1 Shri. N.K. Ramesh, Advocate for Respondent Nos. 2 and 3) These Writ Petitions filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India praying to call for the records which ultimately resulted in passing the impugned communication vide Annexure-A dated 10.6.2013 passed by the third respondents and to quash the communication vide Annexure-A dated 10.6.2013 passed by the third respondent disapproving the admissions of petitioners 2 to 27 for the study of first year BDS Course from the academic year 2012-2013. 7 IN W.P.Nos. 24702 AND 25191 AND 25192-25478 AND 25829/2013 BETWEEN: 1. D.A. Pandu Memorial R.V. Dental College [an institution established by Rastreeya Sikshana Samithi Trust] No.CA 37, 24 th Main, 1st Phase, J.P.Nagar, Bangalore – 560 078, Represented by its Pricipal, Dr. M.R. Dinesh, Son of M.S.Ramshetty, Aged about 49 years, Resident of Bangalore. 2. Miss. Pamini Vaddavalli, Venkateswarlu .V, Aged about 19 years, 3. Mr. Huirem Nopur Viyas, Huirem Nimai Chand Singh, Aged about 23 years, 4. Miss. Ornelya Marissa Fernandes, Leo Francis Mariano Fernandes, Aged about 18 years, 5. Mr. Ashiq Ajit, Ajith C Kumar, Aged about 19 years, 6. Miss. Hanan Safiyath Akbar Ali, P.M. Akbar Ali, 8 Aged about 19 years, 7. Miss. Roselent Joseph, K.J.Joseph, Aged about 19 years, 8. Miss. Namratha Sanchez, Nelson Christananda, Aged about 19 years, 9. Miss. Thingleiphy Lungleng Linganung Lungleng, Aged about 18 years, 10. Miss. Akshaya L Reddy, Laxmi Narayana Reddy B.S., Aged about 19 years, 11. Miss. Aastha Kamra, Yogesh Kamra, Aged about 19 years, 12. Miss. Shanta Giri .S, Daughter of Sarvottam Giri, Aged about 19 years, 13. Mr. Kaushik Raju .M, Son of Thirumala Raju .M, Aged about 20 years, Petitioners 2 to 13 are studying in 1st year BDS Course at D.A. Pandu Memorial R.V. Dental College, No.CA 37, 24 th Main, 9 1st Phase, J.P.Nagar, Bangalore – 560 078. 14. Krishnadevaraya College of Dental Sciences and Hospital, Bangalore – 562 157, Represented by its Principal, Dr. H. Nanda Kumar, Son of Sri. R. Hanumanthaiah, Aged about 63 years, Residing at Bangalore. 15. Rituparna Saha, Bikash Chandra Saha, Aged about 20 years, 16. Khencha Bosai, Duwang Bosai, Aged about 18 years, 17. Chanum Heankhe, Heanwang Heankhe, Aged about 19 years, 18. Priyanka .S, Sunil Kumar Tiwari, Aged about 18 years, 19. Parvati Nair, N. Pradeep Kumar, Aged about 19 years, 20. Shefali Tripathy, Sushanta Kumar Tripathy, Aged about 18 years, 10 21. Sravan Kumar, M. Chandra Shekar, Aged about 18 years, 22. Prasanta Majumder, Kamalesh Majumder, Aged about 18 years, 23. Polusani Prathik, P. Madhukar Reddy, Aged about 18 years, 24. Chandrakanth .C, Chandramohanan Pillai, Aged about 18 years, 25. Manju M.S., Manikandan Pillai .T, Aged about 18 years, 26. Lekha Raj .M, L. Muthuraj, Aged about 18 years, 27. Archana Patil, Ashok Patil, Aged about 18 years, 28. Aishwarya Jha, Sri Akhilesh Kr Jha, Aged about 18 years, 29. Khushboo Mishra, Shambhu Mishra, 11 Aged about 19 years, 30. Nikhita Bhalla, Amitabh Bhalla, Aged about 18 years, 31. Koduri Harshitha Reddy, K. Ram Mohan Reddy, Aged about 18 years, 32. Namineni Puneetha, N. Govardhan Babu, Aged about 19 years, 33. Muzamil Nabi, Hakeem Lh. Nabi, Aged about 20 years, 34. Linthoingambi Devi .N, N. Tompok Singh, Aged about 17 years, 35. Theertha .M, Muraleedharan .M, Aged about 18 years, 36. Hema .C, R. Chandran Unnithan, Aged about 18 years, 37. Amrutha Mary Paulose, Paulose T.J., Aged about 18 years, 38. Gladies Thomas, 12 Thomas Chacko, Aged about 18 years, 39. Revathi .D, Venkata Subba Reddy. D, Aged about 18 years, 40. Radam Rachana, R. Balakrishna, Aged about 18 years, 41. Reshmi .U, Ravi P.K., Aged about 18 years, 42. Tejeswini Ramashetty Amarnath, R.N. Amarnath, Aged about 18 years, 43. Nafseera N.K., Usman C.P., Aged about 18 years, 44. Rohit, Jafar Hussain, Aged about 18 years, 45. Megha Mohan, Mohanan V.K., Aged about 19 years, 46. Vikas Kumar, Jitendra Kumar, Aged about 18 years, 13 47. Shanib .T, Hameed .T, Aged about 19 years, 48. K.B. Arathy, K.B. Benny, Aged about 20 years, 49. Seemala Jyotsna, S. Sreerahulu, Aged about 19 years, 50. Vishnu Bose .C, Chandra Bose A.K., Aged about 19 years, 51. T.A. Manasa, T.M. Ashok Kumar, Aged about 18 years, 52. N. Varsha, P.M. Narayana Swamy, Aged about 19 years, 53. H. Arshada, R. Hemantraj Savalge, Aged about 19 years, 54. Asha K Joseph, Aneesh K Joseph, Aged about 18 years, Petitioners 15 to 54 are studying In 1 st year BDS Course at Krishnadevaraya College of 14 Dental Sciences and Hospital, Bangalore – 562 157. 55. Vokkaligara Sangha Dental College and Hospital, K.R.Road, V.V. Puram, Bangalore – 560 004, Represented by its Principal, Dr. H.C. Usha, Daughter of N. Nagaraja Reddy, Aged about 53 years, Residing at Bangalore. 56. Manasa K.N, Daughter of K.V. Nanda Kumar, Aged about 18 years, 57. Bhargavi .R, Daughter of Reddappa K.C, Aged about 18 years, 58. Janet Jose, Daughter of K.P.Jose, Aged about 18 years, 59. Swetha N.S., Daughter of N.P. Sasindran, Aged about 18 years, 60. Anusha .R, Daughter of Ramanna, Aged about 18 years, 61. Deepika Medhi, Daughter of Gupta Mani, 15 Aged about 19 years, 62. Treasa Richa Roy, Daughter of Roy Paul, Aged about 19 years, 63. Siddhartha Dhanda, Son of Mukesh Dhanda, Aged about 18 years, 64. Monica .B, Daughter of Balakrishna .S, Aged about 18 years, 65.