Human Reproduction, Vol.0, No.0, pp. 1–3, 2020 doi:10.1093/humrep/deaa173

OPINION

Genetic relationships between early Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/advance-article/doi/10.1093/humrep/deaa173/5892245 by Univ of Rochester Library user on 26 August 2020 and the behaviour of theca interna during follicular atresia

Raymond J. Rodgers1,* and Joop S.E. Laven2 1Robinson Research Institute, School of Medicine, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia 2Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, Netherlands

*Correspondence address. Robinson Research Institute, School of Medicine, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia. E-mail: [email protected]

Submitted on April 26, 2020; resubmitted on May 24, 2020; editorial decision on June 8, 2020

ABSTRACT: Genetic variants are known to contribute to about 50% of the heritability of the age of menopause and recent studies sug- gest that genes associated with genome maintenance are involved. The idea that increased rates of follicular atresia could lead to depletion of the primoridial follicle reserve and early menopause has also been canvassed, but there is no direct evidence of this. In studies of the transcriptomics of follicular atresia, it was found that in the theca interna, the largest group of genes are in fact down-regulated and associ- ated with ‘cell cycle and DNA replication’, in contrast with the up-regulation of -associated genes which occurs in granulosa cells. Many of the genes down-regulated in the theca interna are the same as or related to the genes in loci associated with early menopause. From these findings, we suggest that early menopause could be due to increased rates of follicular atresia initiated from the theca interna. Key words: menopause / follicle / atresia / genetics / genome maintenance

. Early menopause . studies (GWAS), 29 contained one or more DNA damage response . and genome maintenance genes within 500 kb, and these genes were . Menopause in women is the age-dependent permanent end of ovula- . the nearest genes in 18 of these loci. These genes are also linked with tion and menstrual cycles. It is due to a reduction in the number of . longevity and ageing (Laven et al.,2016; Niedernhofer et al.,2018). . ovarian follicles and on average occurs at age of 51 years. Early meno- . Thus it was suggested that premature ageing of soma could be respon- pause is defined as menopause occurring between ages 40 and 45 . sible for the occurrence of early menopause (Laven et al.,2016), but . years (Laven et al., 2016). In about 1% of women, it can occur prema- . the mechanism of how this process of ageing and the genome mainte- turely, earlier than 40 years old (Luborsky et al.,2003). Women are . nance genes are mechanistically linked to menopause is not known. . diagnosed with premature ovarian insufficiency if they have secondary . Premature ovarian insufficiency (or failure) is also indicated by a pre- amenorrhoea for at least 4 months before 40 years of age and FSH . mature reduction in the number of ovarian primordial follicles and this . levels above 40 IU/l. Premature ovarian insufficiency is considered as a . can be caused by genetics, autoimmunity or toxins (Rebar, 2009; multifactorial, heterogeneous condition and the specific underlying . . Cooper et al.,2011; Jiao et al.,2018). Genes associated with growth cause remains unclear in most of the affected women. However, vari- . and development of follicles or are linked to about 20–25% of ous genetic causes have been determined, and associations with auto- . . cases (Qin et al., 2015; Patino~ et al.,2017; Jiao et al.,2018; Venturella immune diseases and environmental factors, such as smoking, have . et al.,2019). Other studies have obviously focused on follicular dynam- . been reported (Daan et al.,2016). Moreover, sometimes premature . ics and considered early menopause to be associated with either the ovarian insufficiency is part of syndrome, like Turner syndrome, but in . formation of fewer follicles during ovarian development or subse- . the majority of cases, it is not syndromic. Genetic variants are known . quently enhanced rates of either follicular activation or follicular atresia, to contribute to about 50% of the heritability of the age of natural . all of which will lead to an earlier loss of ovarian primordial follicle re- . menopause (Perry et al.,2013). Recent investigations into the genetics . serve (Pelosi et al.,2015). The effects of chemicals such as cigarette of early menopause suggest that genes associated with DNA repair . smoke and chemotherapy and autoimmunity are also well known to . are involved (Day et al., 2015; Laven et al.,2016; Horikoshi et al., . affect ovarian primordial follicle reserve and hence the onset of meno- 2018). Specifically of the 44 loci identified by genome-wide association . pause (Shelling, 2010; Pelosi et al.,2015; Torrealday et al.,2017).

VC The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology. All rights reserved. For permissions, please email: [email protected] 2 Rodgers and Laven

Table I Genes in common between follicular atresia and early menopause.

Genes associated with early menopausea Genes down-regulated in theca interna during atresiab ......

BRCA1 Breast cancer 1. DNA repair and homologous recombination BRCA1 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/advance-article/doi/10.1093/humrep/deaa173/5892245 by Univ of Rochester Library user on 26 August 2020 FANCI Fanconi anaemia complementation group I. Inter-strand crosslink repair FANCI KNTC1 Kinetochore associated 1. Chromosome segregation KNTC1 RAD51 Homologous recombination and inter-strand crosslink repair RAD51AP1 RAD51-Associated Protein 1 CDK12 Cyclin-dependent kinase 12 CDK1 Cyclin-dependent kinase 1 CHEK2 Checkpoint kinase 2 CHEK1 Checkpoint kinase 1 MCM8 Minichromosome maintenance 8. Homologous recombination repair factor MCM2 Minichromosome maintenance 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 MCM3 MCM4 MCM5 MCM6 POLG DNA polymerase gamma, catalytic subunit POLE2 DNA polymerase epsilon 2, accessory subunit

aLaven et al. (2016). bHatzirodos et al. (2014b).

. Follicular atresia . 12 of these genes down-regulated in the theca interna upon atresia . . (Hatzirodos et al.,2014b) are the same or related to 8 of the 37 Follicular atresia occurs as a means of reducing the numbers of follicles . DNA repair genes found in loci associated with early menopause ovulating and controlling the timing of during a reproductive . . (Laven et al.,2016)(Table I). cycle (Byskov, 1978). It involves cell death and during follicle growth . and development, the order of susceptibility to death is the , . . then both the theca interna and membrana granulosa, and lastly at the . Idea late antral stages, just the membrana granulosa (Clark et al.,2004). It . . has been proposed previously that increased rates of follicular atresia . From these findings, we hypothesise that one mechanism by which . early menopause occurs is via the theca interna and the process of fol- lead to increased rates of primordial follicle activation and eventually . . licular atresia. How would this operate? Presumably as proposed pre- depletion of the ovarian primordial follicle reserve leading to early . menopause, however, there is no direct evidence of this (Pelosi et al., . viously, the genes associated with genome maintenance are less . 2015). Indirect evidence is supported by the relationships between the . effective in women who prematurely age and have early menopause declining numbers of primordial follicles and the reduction in the size . (Laven et al., 2016). It they were also less effective in the theca . of the reserve of small antral follicles with ageing (Monniaux et al., . interna, their follicles would be more prone to undergo follicular atre- . sia. Increased rates of follicular atresia in turn would lead to increased 2014). Also, some chemotherapy agents primarily damage growing fol- . licles, leading to increased rates of activation of dormant primordial fol- . rates of primordial follicle activation to produce more growing follicles . to replace those undergoing atresia. This in turn would lead to an ear- licles, in turn leading to an earlier reduction in the primordial follicle . reserve and hence early menopause (Kalich-Philosoph et al.,2013; . lier depletion of the primordial follicle reserve and hence an earlier . menopause. Wang et al.,2019). . When recently reviewing published literature of follicular atresia . . (Hatzirodos et al.,2014a,b), it became apparent that there is a po- . . How could this be tested? tential connection with the genetics of early menopause. In studies . of the transcriptomics of bovine follicular atresia, it was found that . . Firstly, it would be necessary to confirm the bovine data by conducting in the theca interna, the largest group of genes were in fact down- . a study of transcriptomics of human theca interna during atresia. This regulated and associated with ‘cell cycle and DNA replication’ . . would use RNA-seq to identify all of the genes involved in atresia; the (Hatzirodos et al.,2014b). This was in complete contrast to the up- . bovine data were not a complete set of genes as microarray technol- regulation of apoptosis-associated genes in the granulosa cells . . ogy was used (Hatzirodos et al., 2014b). In the absence of human the- (Hatzirodos et al.,2014a). In the theca interna, 38 genes associated . cal cell lines, the study of passaged thecal cells (Nelson et al., 2001) . with cell cycle and DNA replication were significantly down- . from women with a family history and confirmed genetics of early regulated >4-fold (Hatzirodos et al.,2014b). The most significant . menopause could be illuminating. With so many DNA repair genes . pathways identified by Ingenuity Pathway Analysis and GO terms in- . and redundancy, genetic modification of mice is unlikely to be useful. cluded ‘cell cycle control of chromosomal replication’, ‘G2/M DNA . A study of turnover of antral follicles could be possible by repeated ul- . damage checkpoint regulation’, ‘DNA replication initiation’ and ‘mi- . trasonographic examinations of the as has been conducted in totic chromosome condensation’ (Hatzirodos et al.,2014b). In fact, . other species (Madureira et al., 2020). Cause of early menopause 3 . . Kalich-Philosoph L, Roness H, Carmely A, Fishel-Bartal M, Ligumsky H, Conclusion . . Paglin S, Wolf I, Kanety H, Sredni B, Meirow D. Cyclophosphamide If this idea proves to be correct, it heralds the possibility of new . triggers follicle activation and "burnout"; AS101 prevents follicle loss . options for preventing early menopause. . and preserves fertility. Sci Transl Med 2013;5:185ra162. . Laven JSE, Visser JA, Uitterlinden AG, Vermeij, WP, Hoeijmakers, Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/humrep/advance-article/doi/10.1093/humrep/deaa173/5892245 by Univ of Rochester Library user on 26 August 2020 . . JHJ. Menopause: genome stability as new paradigm. Maturitas . 2016;92:15–23. Authors’ roles . . Luborsky JL, Meyer P, Sowers MF, Gold EB, Santoro N. Premature R.J.R. and J.S.E.L. contributed equally to the ideas and writing of this . menopause in a multi-ethnic population study of the menopause . article. . transition. Hum Reprod 2003;18:199–206. . . Madureira G, Motta JCL, Drum JN, Consentini CEC, Prata AB, . Monteiro PLJ, Melo LF, Alvarenga AB, Wiltbank MC, Sartori R. . Funding . Progesterone-based timed AI protocols for Bos indicus cattle I: . evaluation of ovarian function. Theriogenology 2020;145:126–137. Funding was received from the Centre for Research Excellence on . . Monniaux D, Cle´ment F, Dalbie`s-Tran R, Estienne A, Fabre S, Women’s Health in Reproductive Life (GNT1171592) and supported . Mansanet C, Monget P. The of primordial follicles by the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia. . . and the dynamic reserve of antral growing follicles: what is the . . link? Biol Reprod 2014;90: 85. . Nelson VL, Qin KN, Rosenfield RL, Wood JR, Penning TM, Legro . Conflict of interest . RS, Strauss JF, McAllister JM. 3rd, The biochemical basis for in- . creased testosterone production in theca cells propagated from R.J.R. has no competing interests. J.S.E.L. reports grants and personal . . patients with polycystic ovary syndrome. J Clin Endocrinol fees from Ferring, Titus Healthcare and Ansh Labs, during the conduct . . Metab2001;86:5925–5933. of the study. . . Niedernhofer LJ, Gurkar AU, Wang Y, Vijg J, Hoeijmakers JHJ, . . Robbins PD. Nuclear genomic instability and aging. Annu Rev . Biochem 2018;87:295–322. . References . Pati~no LC, Beau I, Carlosama C, Buitrago JC, Gonza´lez R, Sua´rez CF, . . Patarroyo MA, Delemer B, Young J, Binart N et al. New mutations Byskov AG. Follicular atresia. New York: Plenum Press, 1978. . . in non-syndromic primary ovarian insufficiency patients identified Clark LJ, Irving-Rodgers HF, Dharmarajan AM, Rodgers RJ. Theca . . via whole-exome sequencing. Hum Reprod 2017;32:1512–1520. interna: the other side of bovine follicular atresia. Biol Reprod 2004; . . Pelosi E Simonsick E, Forabosco A, Garcia-Ortiz JE, Schlessinger D. 71:1071–1078. . . Dynamics of the ovarian reserve and impact of genetic and epide- Cooper AR, Baker VL, Sterling EW, Ryan ME, Woodruff TK, Nelson . . miological factors on age of menopause. Biol Reprod 2015;92: 130. LM. The time is now for a new approach to primary ovarian insuf- . . Perry JRB, Hsu Y-H, Chasman DI, Johnson AD, Elks C, Albrecht E, ficiency. Fertil Steril 2011;95:1890–1897. . . Andrulis IL, Beesley J, Berenson GS, Bergmann S et al. DNA mis- Daan NM, Hoek A, Corpeleijn E, Eijkemans MJ, Broekmans FJ, . . match repair gene MSH6 implicated in determining age at natural Fauser BC, Koster MP. Reproductive characteristics of women di- . . menopause. Hum Mol Genet 2013;23:2490–2497. agnosed with premature ovarian insufficiency. Reprod Biomed Online . . Qin Y, Jiao X, Simpson JL, Chen Z-J. Genetics of primary ovarian in- 2016;32:225–232. . . sufficiency: new developments and opportunities. Hum Reprod Day FR, Ruth KS, Thompson DJ, Lunetta KL, Pervjakova N, . Update 2015;21:787–808. Chasman DI, Stolk L, Finucane HK, Sulem P, Bulik-Sullivan B et al. . . Rebar RW. Premature ovarian failure. Obstet Gynecol 2009;113: Large-scale genomic analyses link reproductive aging to hypotha- . 1355–1363. . lamic signaling, breast cancer susceptibility and BRCA1-mediated . Shelling AN. Premature ovarian failure. Reproduction 2010;140: DNA repair. Nat Genet 2015;47:1294–1303. . 633–641. . Hatzirodos N, Hummitzsch K, Irving-Rodgers HF, Harland ML, . Torrealday Saioa. Kodaman Pinar. Pal Lubna. Premature Ovarian Morris SE, Rodgers RJ. Transcriptome profiling of granulosa cells . . Insufficiency- an update on recent advances in understanding and from bovine ovarian follicles during atresia. BMC Genomics 2014a; . management. F1000Research. 2017. 6. 2069. 10.12688/f1000 15:40. . . research.11948.1. Hatzirodos N, Irving-Rodgers HF, Hummitzsch K, Rodgers RJ. . Venturella R, De Vivo V, Carlea A, D’Alessandro P, Saccone G, Transcriptome profiling of the theca interna from bovine ovarian . . Arduino B, Improda FP, Lico D, Rania E, De Marco C et al. The follicles during atresia. PLoS One 2014b;9:e99706. . genetics of non-syndromic primary ovarian insufficiency: a system- . Horikoshi M, Day FR, Akiyama M, Hirata M, Kamatani Y, Matsuda K, . atic review. Int J Fertil Steril 2019;13:161–168. Ishigaki K, Kanai M, Wright H, Toro CA et al. Elucidating the ge- . Wang Y, Liu M, Johnson SB, Yuan G, Arriba AK, Zubizarreta ME, . netic architecture of reproductive ageing in the Japanese popula- . Chatterjee S, Nagarkatti M, Nagarkatti P, Xiao S. Doxorubicin tion. Nat Commun 2018;9:1977. . obliterates mouse ovarian reserve through both primordial follicle . Jiao X, Ke H, Qin Y, Chen ZJ. Molecular genetics of premature ovar- . atresia and overactivation. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2019;381: ian insufficiency. Trends Endocrinol Metab 2018;29:795–807. . 114714.