DOCSLIB.ORG

2. Letter from Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham to the Parole 2.1

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
2. Letter from Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham to the Parole 2.1 Section 2 2. Letter from Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham to the Parole Commission after the initial hearing, 6/14/91 2.1. Biographical information on Chief Judge Peckham Chief Judge Peckham wrote to the Parole Commission after he heard that the initial hearing examiners had recommended a maximal continuance until Larry could again be eligible for parole. In his letter, he reiterates his reasoning for sentencing as he did, describes the mitigating circumstances and the numerous pleas from leniency he received from jurors, prosecution witnesses, former Peoples Temple members, family members who lost loved ones in Jonestown, and Larry *s family and friends. c c Vnite6 States IDistrict (Z^urt IWihcnt IHstrict of (UUfomta Sftfi Trancisco. (EftUfomia 94102 June 14, 1991 Carol Pavilack Getty Chairman United States Parole Commissioner or Acting Commissioner for the Western Region 1301 Shoreway Road, 4th Floor Belmont, CA 94002 RE: LAYTON, Laurence John Reg. No. 20752-053 CR 80-0416 RFP INITIAL PAROLE HEARING - JUNE, 1991 FCI Terminal Island Dear Chairman Getty: La^oir^eai^^Mr. sentencing Layton appeared judge before in methe for Laurence sentencing Johnon March 3, 1987, after I presided over his two lengthy trials which extended over a substantial time. riaxs wnich appeared for his initial parole hearing on June 4, 1991, at the Federal Correctional Institution Terminal Island. I understand that the recommendations of the ' consideration for ae purpose of ttis letter is to express my concern about the latter reconunendation of the examiners and to offer you mv perspective regarding a just disposition in this casL AidingAidino^Sd and Abetting Conspiracy the Murder ofto a Congressman,Kill a Congressman, Consoiracv to Protected Person, and Aiding and Abetting Attempted Murder of resultedan Internationally in a mistrial, Protected wito to^jSryPerson v^ingfMr 2 acquittal on the "Conspiracy" charges and seven I notednitod on the'/Aiding day of sentencing, and Abetting" the four Counts charges.) on which LarryAs ^yton was convicted strike at the very heart of a representative democracy and carry possible sentences that reflect their severity. Congressman Ryan alone was unwilling to ignore the reports of intolerable conditions existing in Jonestown, and he alone had the courage to travel with his party to Guyana to Investigate whetter Jonestown was the idyllic paradise described by Jim Jones. His death was a tragic loss to his family, to the ? this nation. His courage and conviction have sorely missed**^' * leadership has been silenced and is it tragic death of Congressman Ryan, the events brutal ^ November 18, 1978, resulted in the memberfff attempting 4.? three newsmento escape theand horror Patty ofParks, Jonestown. a People's The Temple terrible events of that day also resulted in the serious iniurv forSer^Peoni«/^®J® members, individuals. Vernonalso attempting Gosney and to Monicaescape Bagbyf ^^®»®®Jves shot and seriously injured by the tragedy^ -4.^ with P®®Pl® them for will the carry rest theof theirheavy liv^. burden of this ^^agic circumstances that occurred in Guyana one must first attempt to focus on the enviroraent that existed in Jonestown, Guyana Following the shooting at the airport, the fact that 914 Jones committed suicide bespeaks of the sieh i ine^licable way of life that pervaded Jonestown. reeoT-doS K? Unique in modern history, in all of remotelyreino?f?w approaches there have the massbeen suicidefew occurrences in Guyana. that even destroyed any individual will to live that Jonestown, and caused the deaths of 914 adults and which to. Layton has been convicted, this final atrocitv is livIS at Jonest^?'^®''®^""'^"^ environment in which.he himself, a victim. Many of these lettersopinions are powerful ttat^rr!J and L?lon"as winv^n« testimony to the madness of Jonestown and to the spell cast over Jones. A juror expresseddominating her feeling and regardingauthoritarian the preseScfo? circumstances Jim circumstancescirfSme^a®^ were^ stating almost "We unbearable." (the jury) "Thedo feel vast that numbers the who ?j!m JoneSextraordinary power ( c Another Jonestown victim, Vern Gosney, wrote of the extreme pressure that Layton and others in Jonestown were under due to "a systM 24 hours per day, rules enforced so humiliation? dwere of publicthose who meetings broke the rules.«involving "it was thea '^iffged community and he (lAyton) was extremely needy of Jones' approval." Mr. Gosney concluded by stating "I don't feel he is a ttreat to anyone." Another victim of Jonestown, Jean Brown Clancey, noted in a letter to me: Jim Jones b^an his harangues about »the conspiracy' against him ~ a reflection of his own degraded mental state ~ Souaht®thA%J»'®.;- documents to show that he Stenus and^ D others e p a rwere t m e plotting n t , I nto t edestroy r p o l , him.S e When n a t o I rwas Pat^c^nn ^ A*® taken on a walk in the jungle by Sev K ® f®®e®sed Temple member. She told me that ^ ''y 'Nazis' and had picked up German lan^age radio transmissions^® ®®™"ttnity in theirhad beenvicinity. fully The disclosed. I bring it up only to further my point that Larry's thinkina was completely captive - it was not his thinking toat you will see the Ncomplexities e r l e t t e r b y involvels t a t i n a " in i s thilcase i n c e r a i v ash n n s ®^^i9®ting circumstances." Ms. Clancey's husband. People s Temple member Tim Clancey. also %/ro^e to mo thatstating you "At will worst, give deep Larry consideration is a victim ofto lircuSslanwIthe mitigating" ! i Lr>^ circumstances in this case." "j-tiga^iing daughter committed suicide at Jonestown you ponder his sentence I pray you will w2Hold what him accountable,his actions inbut Guyana have mercy have — alreadymercy thatcost stems'from him." »n lived°"^^ paranoid, twisted reality in which they m In most Conspiracy convictions, and in most multi-defenda*nt criminal cases, the court has before it a number of co- conspirators and defendants, and it must assess the relative ®®°'' ^® «^®f®n<i®'»ts and sentence them accordingly. Mr. Layton's role in the offense, as established bv two trials?"®® established ?^,.^® thatN®® Mr. secondary.Layton was Theapproached testimony by someat the of Jones top leaders and asked to stop certain Peonle's Temoie members (the "defectors") from leaving Guyana. Congressman Rvan provided transportation,anyone andwanting they towould leave be Jonestown allowed towould leave be Larry Layton was asked to board an airplane (the first scheduled to leave with the "defector") and to shoot the pilot of the plane, after it became airborne. At the time this ( c plan was adopted, it was believed that Congressman Ryan and his ^ 9roup and that the CongJessMn wd insure that* everyone going to whospend wanted another to leave night was at Jonestownpermitted to todo so. After the plane was loaded and as it waited at the end runway, approximately 300 yards away from the Rven ^ SLSES g E::,ErEiE?"KESSl"Vf SjtSE'fSEiS'"" " • i"5ES"SStS,?"'*'" t«. Even though the circumstances at the Port Kai^uma ^ ^ obligationobiloa?y" to unique, assess the that defendant's did not relieve relative theblame coSrt for -fcho of it^ doubt that,AS Jim I noted Jones on was, the day himself, of sentencingT primarily resnonsibio thew fnr- «-k deaths and serious injuries inflirtfd at the pllt Sait^a ® airstrip on November 18, 1978. All agree to ttil Jact!^ The court was also convinced, after hearina all murderI^rry Layton's role in the conspiracy to " wasmurder less Congressman significant Ryan than and that^SI^ Deputy „^e?Chief o?of m4cs«s<i#%m oihe? coSSlra?::^®'' ? Z Although he committed a serious and unpardonable crime in ' • shooting two innocent people and attempting to shoot a third, his role in the conspiracy for which he has been convicted was not as significant as that of many of the other conspirators. Seven psychiatric reports were submitted to the court in and tteee by the defense.5^^® reports Dr. Otto were Bendheim provided also by the provided government a psy^iatric autopsy" report on Jim Jones. The government to defendant's psychiatrist, while differing as IZ of Larry Layton at the time of the commission of JSnes"^"4t?iig!®'®*'* domination of Jim Jones in the report that Jim Jones initially to *■ ^'fople's^hem, Temple manipulated members, and exploited but them. then lied If tte'end'^he";;iUertt^!"' doc|ments at length the many techniques of coercive t<® ^ ? Jones, including constant discussions of psychologicali®"""^ coercion suicide, aimed physical at destroying intimidation family and ties prohibiting members from leaving Guyana and deprivation from privacy, sleep, free speech, and frXe associationT "raddi^ion members Of People's Temple were subject to degrading punishment' and public humiliation, food deprivation and hard labor. Despite some disagreement among the psychiatrists as to whether constitute a legal defense to the charges, there was no disagreement, even by the primary prosecution psvchiatrist nr- "coerciveSeymour persuasion." Pollock, that ThisMr. Layton persuasion hL been was sSSjectedimposed by ^ow4rf^ Ji^JonL hisoyer SIX Layton to seven s ten monthyear involvement stay at Jonestown. in People's I noted Temple at andthe durinotime of sentencing that in remainedthe end, JimIn Jonestown, Jones destroyed and^cautSI any over individual people to take their own lives and the lives of their chfldren. second trial, I received four letters form jurors sking for leniency for Mr. Layton. One juror wrote "I realize thrLmX^?!!/? ®J! ® horrSfe crL" iul at todanrt 1 ?wish believe you would he giveis as some much thought a victim to my asposition a participant, Of his being victimized and show leniency in your judgment." 2«.XiX2®?®® T I ^®^^®r '®T J?® to Pfos®c«tionme "I plead.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • California Supreme Court by Gerald F
    WESTERN LEGAL HISTORY THE JOURNAL OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT HISTORICAL SOCIETY VoLumE 2, NUMBER I WINTER/SPRING 1989 Western Legal Historyis published semi-annually, in spring and fall, by the Ninth judicial Circuit Historical Society, P.O. Box 2558, Pasadena, California 91102-2558, (818) 405-7059. The journal explores, analyzes, and presents the history of law, the legal profession, and the courts - particularly the federal courts - in Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Washington, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands. Western Legal History is sent to members of the Society as well as members of affiliated legal historical societies in the Ninth Circuit. Membership is open to all. Membership dues (individuals and institutions): Patron, $1,000 or more; Steward, $750-$999; Sponsor, $500-$749; Grantor, $250-$499; Sustaining, $100-$249; Advocate, $50-$99; Subscribing )non- members of the bench and bar, attorneys in practice fewer than five years, libraries, and academic institutions, $25-$49. Membership dues (law firms and corporations): Founder, $3,000 or more; Patron, $1,000-$2,999 Steward, $750-$999; Sponsor, $500-$749; Grantor, $250-$499. For information regarding membership, back issues of Western Legal History, and other Society publications and programs, please write or telephone. POSTMASTER: Please send change of address to: Western Legal History P.O. Box 2558 Pasadena, California 91102-2558. Western Legal History disclaims responsibility for statements made by authors and for accuracy of footnotes. Copyright 1988 by the Ninth judicial Circuit Historical Society. ISSN 0896-2189. The Editorial Board welcomes unsolicited manuscripts, books for review, reports on research in progress, and recommendations for the journal.
    [Show full text]
  • In Memory of Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham Wayne D
    Hastings Law Journal Volume 44 | Issue 5 Article 1 1-1993 In Memory of Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham Wayne D. Brazil Jordan Eth Thelton E. Henderson Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/hastings_law_journal Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Wayne D. Brazil, Jordan Eth, and Thelton E. Henderson, In Memory of Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham, 44 Hastings L.J. 973 (1993). Available at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/hastings_law_journal/vol44/iss5/1 This Comment is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Hastings Law Journal by an authorized editor of UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. In Memory of Chief Judge Robert F. Peckham Robert F Peckham was born on November 3, 1920, in San Francisco. His grandfather, Robert Francis Peckham, was a district attorney and county judge in Santa Cruz; his father, R. F. Peckham, was a San Jose and San Franciscoattorney for many years. Peckham moved to Palo Alto at age seven, where he would reside for the rest of his life. Judge Peckham earned his bachelor's degree at Stanford University in 1941. He then attended Yale Law School for one year before coming back to Stanford to earn his LL.B. in 1945. He practicedprivately for two years before becoming assistant United States Attorney for the Northern District of California, a position he held for five years before resigning to reenterprivate practice in 1953. During this time, he met and married his first wife, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Years in Paradise. Leaves from a Society Reporter's Note-Book. by Mary Bowden Carroll
    Ten years in Paradise. Leaves from a society reporter's note-book. By Mary Bowden Carroll TEN YEARS IN PARADISE. Leaves from a Society Reporter's Note-Book. ...BY... MARY BOWDEN CARROLL. Price, - $2.50. COPYRIGHT, 1903, BY MARY BOWDEN CARROLL. Press of POPP & HOGAN, San Jose, Cal. TO Mrs. Fannie P. McGehee, A friend, tried and true, I affectionately dedicate this volume. PREFACE. Ten years in Paradise. Leaves from a society reporter's note-book. By Mary Bowden Carroll http://www.loc.gov/resource/calbk.169 It is with pleasure that I present this volume to the public. Not a single fact in it has been exaggerated, and the conditions described are true even to the smallest detail. I am no stranger, for a residence of a quarter of a century here, and nearly twenty years of active work on the local newspapers have made me familiar with this valley and its people. This work was not prepared in the interest of any organization, but in the hope that it might, to some extent, be the means of attracting desirable people to this fertile valley, where Dame Nature wears her brightest robe through all the year, and where are found sun-kissed bowers, cool glades, and hills bedecked with myriads of flowers, as if by the touch of some fairy wand the choicest blossoms had been showered over all this favored land. MARY BOWDEN CARROLL. Endorsement of Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber of Commerce of the County of Santa Clara hereby endorse the work published by Mary Bowden Carroll, entitled “Ten Years in Paradise—Leaves from a Society Reporter's Note- Book.” The book truthfully portrays the past and present conditions of Santa Clara Valley, and meets with our approval.
    [Show full text]
  • San Jose State Uni., Calif.. SPONS/AGENCY National Science Foundation, Washington, D.C
    C DOCUMENT RESUME . ED 212 253' IR Q09 947' AUTHOR Fitting, Marjorie A. TITLE Computer Use in Santa Clara County schools. INSTITUTION' 'San Jose State Uni., Calif.. SPONS/AGENCY National Science Foundation, Washington, D.C. 1317B DATE Jun 80 GRANT .' SPI-7902349 NOTE EDRS PRICE MF01/PC03 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS , *Computer Assisted Instruction; Computer Programs; 'Computers.; *-Computer Science Education; Elementary Secondary Education; Input Output Devices; *Meichandise Information; Professional Associations; *Publications; School Surveys IDENTIFIEBS *Santa. Clara Unified School District CA .. ' ABSTRACT This publication provides not'only a directory of schools in Santa Clara County and nearby with information onthir use of computers, butlistings of sources for various resources on educational use of computers, information about using and obtaining software, and-descriptions of three news making events. The first section lists the Santa Clara County Schools and some nearby-schools by district, and provides the name of the contact person., address, ; , telephone number, equipment, and projected uses for each school in the district. The next section includes addresses and4descriptions of eight professional associations; addresses of 13 user groups; ., information about 18 publications on computers; a list of computer science courses offered at San Jose State University.; specifications . for computers used in Santa ClaraCounty; local suppliers; and dates of upcoming events. The third section provides brief descriptions of computer managed
    [Show full text]
  • 1 US COURT of APPEALS for the NINTH CIRCUIT Judicial Profile
    U.S. COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT Judicial Profile: Carlos Bea COURT: Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals APPOINTED: 2003, by President George W. Bush BORN: April 18, 1934 LAW SCHOOL: Stanford Law School PREVIOUS EXPERIENCE: San Francisco Superior Court Bench, 1990-2003 After long wait, Bea ascends federal bench Jason Hoppin The Recorder November 18, 2003 Carlos Bea can breathe a little bit easier now. Not only are his chambers in the Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals much larger than his old haunt at the San Francisco Superior Court, but he no longer has to wonder what kind of federal judge he'd have made. He's about to find out. The longtime litigator and dedicated Republican had been on the superior court a little more than a year when the first President Bush tapped him for the Northern District federal bench. His nomination died without a hearing, however, and Bea waited a decade before being offered his current post. The former Olympian is still fit at 69 years old. The white hair, dark complexion and crisp shirts project the dignity of an ambassador. Bea seems to fit right in at the beaux-arts Ninth Circuit headquarters on Seventh and Mission streets. His enormous office is decorated with paintings from his personal collection -- portraits and scenes painted in a classical style. Weathered antiques have been imported in a feeble attempt to fill the cavernous space. On the superior court, Bea required decorum in the courtroom. Some lawyers say he can come across as imperious.
    [Show full text]