North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

Item 5 North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

13 December 2018

Miscellaneous Items

(a) Development Management

Please note that the appeal documentation for each of the applications listed below can be found by clicking on the application reference number.

Hearings and Inquiries

None.

Appeals Received

None.

Appeals Determined

The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government has determined the following appeals made to him against decisions of the Committee:-

Reference Number Appellants Name Description Appeal Decision and Location NYM/2018/0073/FL Mr Giles Hawkes alterations and construction Appeal Allowed Chapel House, of single and two storey Cold Kirby extensions following demolition of existing single storey extensions (revised scheme to NYM/2016/0215/FL)

Attached at Appendix 1.

(b) Enforcement

Appeal documentation relating to an enforcement matter is currently only available on request.

Hearings and Inquiries

None.

Appeals Received

None.

Appeals Determined

None. (c) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning

A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 2.

[NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given].

(d) List of Enforcement Matters Determined by the Director of Planning

A list of enforcement matters determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 3.

(e) Numbers of Planning Applications Determined

Details of current planning applications which were submitted over 13 weeks ago are attached at Appendix 4.

(f) Hedgerow Applications

A list of hedgerow applications determined by the National Park Officer in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 5.

[The individual files will be available for Members to inspect at the meeting].

Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer)

Chris France Director of Planning

Appendix 1

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 26th September 2018 by Alison Roland BSc DipTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State

Decision date: 9th October 2018

Appeal Ref: APP/W9500/D/18/3205974 Chapel House, Cold Kirby, Thirsk, North Yorkshire, YO7 2HL.  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Dr Giles Hawkes against the decision of the North York Moors National Park Authority.  The application Ref: NYM/2018/0073/FL, dated 1 February 2018, was refused by notice dated 5 April 2018.  The development proposed is alterations and extensions to house- Revised scheme to approval Ref: NYM/2016/0215/FL.

Procedural Matter

1. It was apparent at my site visit that work was well advanced in relation to an earlier scheme Ref: NYM/2016/0215/FL (the former permission).

Decision

2. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for alterations and extensions to house- Revised scheme to approval Ref: NYM/2016/0215/FL, at Chapel House, Cold Kirby, Thirsk, North Yorkshire, YO7 2HL, in accordance with the terms of the application Ref: NYM/2018/0073/FL, dated 1 February 2018, subject to the Schedule of Conditions appended to this Decision.

Main Issue

3. The main issue in this appeal is the implications of the proposal for the character and appearance of the area.

Reasons

4. The appeal building is a detached former chapel building currently undergoing renovation and extension. The former permission allowed a two storey side extension to the property along with the insertion of four dormers to the rear elevation and two dormers to the front elevation. The appeal proposal would see two additional dormers introduced to the front elevation and a single storey side extension added to the earlier approved side extension.

5. The Authority say that the proposals would erode the form and character of the original chapel building and result in a property of much grander domestic proportions and character. I accept that it would result in a slightly larger dwelling Appeal Decision APP/W9500/D/18/3205974

on the site, but cannot concur that it would be of much grander proportions; rather the property would be modestly larger. It would be appreciably larger than the original chapel, but the form of the original building would still be clearly discernible and the extensions would have a subordinate relationship thereto.

6. Moreover, whatever the historic charm and character of the original chapel building, the fact is that the former permission imparted a much stronger domestic character and appearance to the property and included the alteration of what appear from the evidence to be the original vertical window openings and the addition of several dormer windows. A casual glance at the building the subject of that approval would give no cue as to its former use and indeed even to the informed observer, only inspection of the inscribed stone plaque at close quarters above the front door would reveal its history.

7. In these circumstances, I consider the appeal proposal would effectively amount to more of the same. The two additional front dormers would simply replicate those approved on the rear elevation and the single storey addition would amount to a modest and unassuming extension, which following the traditional principles of architectural hierarchy, would have an appreciably lower eaves and ridge height than both the original building and the side extension the subject of the former permission.

8. The guidance in Design Guide Part 4: The Re-use of Traditional Rural Buildings Supplementary Planning Document (August 2011) (SPD) states that traditional rural buildings should be capable of conversion to a new use without the need for any extension. Policy 8 of the North York Moors National Park Authority Local Development Framework Core Strategy and Development Policies Document (November 2008) (CS) adopts a more lenient position of significant extensions. However, the proposal is not strictly for a conversion because the Authority say it was converted into a residential dwelling in the 1970’s. Moreover, the fact that the previous scheme received approval suggests that the Authority applies these terms with a degree of latitude and I shall do likewise, especially given my findings at paragraph 6 above.

9. For these reasons, I conclude on the main issue that the proposal would integrate comfortably with both the host building and wider character and appearance of the area. I thus find no conflict with Policies 3 and 19 of the CS. These seek to ensure that development is of a high standard of design that maintains and enhances the distinctive character of the National Park and that residential extensions do not detract from the character and form of the original dwelling. It would not comply with the advice in the SPD or the letter of Policy 8 of the CS, but I nonetheless consider it acceptable for the reasons given.

10. In addition to the standard condition in relation to the time limit for the commencement of development, a condition confining the approval to specified plans is necessary for certainty. Conditions dealing with external lighting, inscribed stones, details of the stonework to the exterior walls, rooflights and details of door and window frames and their setting in the walls, are all necessary to secure a satisfactory external appearance, particularly given the prominence of the building at a road intersection. Although the application forms specify stonework to match existing, as the building incorporates both random and coursed stonework, I agree this is a detail that should be subject to written approval. The suggested conditions in relation to windows and doors can be

2 Appeal Decision APP/W9500/D/18/3205974

consolidated without losing their intention. The condition relating to matching roof tiles is superfluous as this is stated to be the case on the application forms. Six of the conditions dealing with first floor apex glazing, the vehicle access, outbuilding and tree protection measures in relation to the latter all appear to relate to the former permission which included these matters, but which are not relevant to this appeal. I shall therefore omit them. A condition requiring a Construction Method Statement is suggested, but I have been furnished with no reason why the Authority consider this necessary. Having regard to the site context on a quietly trafficked country lane, I do not consider this condition is necessary.

SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS

1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years from the date of this decision.

2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: Site Location Plan 1:1250 @ A4; Drg No: 04-A: Proposed elevations; Drg No: 03-A Revision C: Proposed floor plans.

3) No external lighting shall be installed on the development hereby permitted until details of such have been first submitted to and agreed in writing by the local planning authority. Any installed lighting shall be in accordance with the approved details.

4) All existing inscribed stones built into the external walls of the building shall be retained in-situ. If any additional inscribed stones shall be revealed in the west facing gable elevation, they shall be retained in-situ or removed and re-used elsewhere in the external walls of the building, in accordance with the prior written agreement of the local planning authority.

5) No work shall commence on the construction of the walls of the development hereby permitted until details or samples of the stone for the walls and dressings, have been first submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The stone used shall be in accordance with the approved details or samples.

6) All new windows, glazing bars, external doors and door frames shall be of timber construction. No work shall commence on any door or window in the development hereby approved until detailed specifications of the constructional details and appearance (including cross sections and means of opening), have been first submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The doors and windows shall be installed in accordance with the approved details.

7) The rooflights to be installed in the development hereby permitted shall be conservation style rooflights fitted flush with the face of the roof slope.

8) The external face of the frame to all new windows shall be set in reveals to match those of the existing windows. ALISON ROLAND

INSPECTOR

3 Appendix 2

List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 04/10/2018 to 28/11/2018 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 2015

Please note that the decision notice for each of the Authority’s applications listed in this report can be found by clicking on the application reference number.

York Potash/Sirius Minerals Delegated Applications

None.

Applications

Hambleton

NYM/2018/0291/FL Approved 09/10/2018 installation of replacement uPVC windows to west facing elevation at Kings Folly, Clack Lane Ends, Osmotherley for Mrs Amanda Pearson

NYM/2018/0423/FL Approved 02/11/2018 installation of replacement windows together with new timber glazed door and glazing to existing openings to south elevation together with blocking up of door in north elevation of attached building and hard surfacing works at Westwood Farm, Ingleby Greenhow for Mr & Mrs Simon Ashwell

NYM/2018/0424/LB Granted 02/11/2018 Listed Building consent for installation of replacement windows together with internal alterations and new timber glazed door and glazing to existing openings to south elevation together with blocking up of door in north elevation of attached building at Westwood Farm, Ingleby Greenhow for Mr & Mrs Simon Ashwell

NYM/2018/0465/FL Approved 04/10/2018 erection of 4 metre high Moorsweb community internet mast with ancillary equipment including solar panels and wind generator with associated perimeter fence at land west of Baysdale Wood, Kildale for Signa Technologies Ltd

NYM/2018/0477/FL Approved 19/10/2018 alterations, construction of two storey extension following demolition of garden room and relocated porch together with relocation of timber store and construction of detached domestic building at Withy Brook, Shepherd Hill, Swainby for Mr & Mrs J.F. Calje

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0479/FL Approved 26/10/2018 proposed maintaining of access track together with drainage works at Mount House Farm, Urra, Chop Gate for Mr Andrew Connelly NYM/2018/0510/FL Approved 12/10/2018 construction of single storey rear extension following demolition of conservatory at The Cottage, Carlton In Cleveland for Mr Anthony Storm

NYM/2018/0525/FL Approved 16/10/2018 erection of building to be part manure store/part cattle shed and concrete yard works at Whitley Hill Farm, Ingleby Greenhow for Timothy Hawman

NYM/2018/0551/FL Refused 18/10/2018 alterations and construction of first floor extension and porch at Underwood, Clack Lane, Osmotherley for Mr & Mrs Dodgson

NYM/2018/0560/FL Approved 07/11/2018 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2018/0269/FL to change design of side extension to include open sided roofed portico together with omission of window and rooflight at 6 Husthwaite Road, Coxwold for Mr Neil Baker

NYM/2018/0563/FL Approved 27/11/2018 conversion of and extension to building to form Estate workers dwelling at Home Farm, Thimbleby for Thimbleby Farms Ltd

NYM/2018/0568/LB Granted 27/11/2018 Listed Building consent for alterations and extension to building to enable use as Estate workers dwelling at Home Farm, Thimbleby for Thimbleby Farms Ltd

NYM/2018/0612/FL Approved 12/11/2018 construction of two storey rear extension at 4 Dikes Lane, Great Ayton for Mr Hart

Ryedale

NYM/2016/0708/FL Approved 26/10/2018 installation of 3 no. replacement double glazed timber windows at 1 Roxby Terrace, Thornton Le Dale for Mrs Karen Colley

NYM/2018/0124/FL Approved 16/10/2018 alterations and extension to and subdivision of existing dwelling to form 2 no. residential units together with demolition works, raising of roof height and extension to outbuilding to form 1 no. dwelling with associated parking and amenity spaces at Ginger Pig Pantry, Maltongate, Thornton Dale for Birkett Estates Ltd

NYM/2018/0183/FL Approved 24/10/2018 repair/rebuilding works to gable end of Outbuilding 1 and external stairs of Outbuilding 2 at High Cornfield and outbuildings, Bransdale Road to Cockayne, Bransdale for National Trust

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0190/LB Granted 24/10/2018 Listed Building consent for repair/rebuilding works to gable end of Outbuilding 1 and external stairs of Outbuilding 2, refurbishment works to dwelling, internal alterations including removal of wall and fixtures and rearrangement of space, installation of replacement windows, insertion of rooflight and re-roofing (revised scheme following withdrawal of NYM/2017/0590/LB) at High Cornfield, Bransdale Road to Cockayne, Bransdale for National Trust

NYM/2018/0366/FL Approved 24/10/2018 engineering works to reconfigure existing lake, creation of a new lake, construction of a footbridge, jetty and boathouse at Elleron Lodge, Stape for Mr M Smith-Hilliard

NYM/2018/0456/FL Approved 16/10/2018 construction of porch at 7 Black Swan Yard, Helmsley for Darren Stephenson

NYM/2018/0457/OU Approved 20/11/2018 outline application for demolition of existing commercial garage buildings and construction of 1 no. dwelling with detached double garage together with associated amenity space and landscaping works (some matters reserved) at High Street Garage, High Street, Thornton-Le-Dale for Mr John Garbutt

NYM/2018/0476/FL Approved 04/10/2018 alterations to outbuilding attached to existing dwelling to form additional living accommodation at 19 Bondgate, Helmsley for Mrs Doreen Davenport

NYM/2018/0512/FL Approved 08/10/2018 construction of replacement pavilion at Gillamoor Playing Field, south of Gillamoor off Woodhead Field Lane for Gillamoor and Fadmoor Playing Field Association

NYM/2018/0522/FL Approved 09/10/2018 alterations and construction of single storey side extension at High Dalby House, Thornton-Le-Dale for Reverend Ian Robinson

NYM/2018/0528/FL Approved 08/10/2018 variation of condition 5 of planning approval NYM/2018/0142/FL to sever the tie of the holiday letting accommodation with Wardfall House at Wardfall House, Main Street, Ampleforth for Mr and Mrs David and Moira Criddle

NYM/2018/0529/FL Approved 08/10/2018 variation of condition 4 of planning approval NYM/2018/0143/FL to sever the tie of the holiday letting accommodation with Wardfall House at Wardfall House, Main Street, Ampleforth for Mr and Mrs David and Moira Criddle

NYM/2018/0546/FL Approved 25/10/2018 removal of 2 no. dormer windows and demolition of conservatory to rear and construction of single storey extension and 1 no. dormer window at 2 Mowbray Terrace, West End, Ampleforth for Mr Stephen Demaine

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0548/FL Approved 09/11/2018 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2007/0188/FL to allow construction of link extension, alterations to internal layout, fenestration and doors together with installation of rooflights at Box Tree Cottage, High Street, Lockton for Messrs Bell & Atkinson

NYM/2018/0549/LB Granted 09/11/2018 Listed Building consent for construction of link extension and conversion of redundant buildings to form additional living accommodation at Box Tree Cottage, High Street, Lockton for Messrs Bell & Atkinson

NYM/2018/0550/FL Approved 16/10/2018 construction of single storey side extension following demolition of existing store (revised scheme to NYM/2018/0278/FL) at Little Moorlands, Low Street, Lastingham for Mr & Mrs Turner

NYM/2018/0566/FL Approved 19/10/2018 construction of conservatory to rear (revised scheme following refusal of NYM/2017/0182/FL) at Chapel Cottage, Back Lane, Hutton le Hole for Mr George Thompson

NYM/2018/0570/FL Approved 26/11/2018 installation of 12 no. ground mounted solar panels at Crag Cottage, Main Street, Oswaldkirk for Mr Nicholas Cowern

NYM/2018/0576/LB Granted 24/10/2018 Listed Building consent for internal alterations at Old Bar Cottage, High Street, Thornton-Le-Dale for Mr & Mrs Rajab

NYM/2018/0582/FL Approved 26/10/2018 construction of replacement porch at 4 Plane Trees, Daleside Road, Rosedale East for Mr Maldwyn Williams

NYM/2018/0592/FL Approved 30/10/2018 change of use of bar/restaurant to residential care bedrooms and external alterations including construction of lift shaft (resubmission of NYM/2015/0841/FL) at The Hall, Chestnut Avenue, Thornton-Le-Dale for York Heritage Ltd

NYM/2018/0600/LB Granted 29/10/2018 Listed Building consent for internal alterations to enable change of use of bar/restaurant to residential care bedrooms and external alterations including construction of lift shaft (resubmission of NYM/2015/0856/LB) at The Hall, Chestnut Avenue, Thornton-Le-Dale for York Heritage Ltd

NYM/2018/0602/FL Approved 08/11/2018 construction of single storey rear extension following demolition of conservatory at Gilligate, High Street, Thornton le Dale for Mr & Mrs Derek and Gaye Barber

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0616/FL Approved 19/11/2018 erection of 10 metre lattice mast with antennas and dishes together with siting of ground based equipment cabinets, generator and associated fencing at Newgate Bank, Northfield Lane, Pockley for The Secretary of State for the Home Department

NYM/2018/0617/CLE Issued 14/11/2018 Certificate of Lawfulness for use as a dwelling without compliance with agricultural occupancy condition for in excess of ten years at Long Grain Farm, Wass Bank Road, Wass for The executers of the estate of the Late Frank Cronin Esq

NYM/2018/0627/FL Refused 22/11/2018 construction of 1 no. dormer window and installation of rooflights at Orchard House, Hambleton Lane, Wass for Mr & Mrs D Harker

NYM/2018/0628/FL Approved 16/11/2018 variation of condition 1 of planning approval NYM/2013/0634/FL to allow use of two ground floor rooms of Prospect Farm as extension to Forge Tea Rooms for a further five years at The Forge Tea Rooms Prospect Farm Hutton le Hole for Paul Everett

NYM/2018/0631/FL Approved 22/11/2018 alterations and construction of car port to side and single storey rear extension at 4 Withington Road, Helmsley for Mr & Mrs Philip & Patricia Dale

NYM/2018/0634/CU Approved 16/11/2018 change of use of ground floor from shop (Use Class A1) to restaurant/cafe (Use Class A3) at White Rose Crafts, Maltongate, Thornton le Dale for Lucy Holdings

NYM/2018/0640/FL Approved 27/11/2018 erection of summerhouse at Corinium House, 18 Orchard Way, Helmsley for Ian Saggers

NYM/2018/0645/FL Approved 19/11/2018 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2018/0178/FL to allow the use of uPVC cladding to dormer window at Ryecroft, 6 Maltongate, Thornton Le Dale for Owner/Occupier

NYM/2018/0652/FL Approved 27/11/2018 alterations to garage to form games room with bedroom above together with construction of timber garden store building at The Old Chapel, Rosedale Abbey for Mr & Mrs S Smith

Appendix 2

Scarborough

NYM/2017/0412/FL Approved 23/10/2018 erection of livestock building at St Athanasius Monastery, Langdale Bridge to Black Beck, Langdale End for Fr Arsenius

NYM/2018/0014/FL Approved 29/10/2018 construction of lean-to extension to form store together with creation of field access track at Witchpost Cottage, Common Lane, Glaisdale for Mr S Chalton

NYM/2018/0087/FL Approved 15/10/2018 erection of timber shed/summerhouse at 2 Braithwaite Cottage, Green End, Goathland for Mr Michael Lyth

NYM/2018/0205/FL Approved 08/10/2018 construction of two storey side extension and detached garage at Bracken Hill, Glaisdale for Dawnay Estate

NYM/2018/0247/FL Approved 17/10/2018 conversion of and extension to redundant buildings to form 3 no. holiday cottages with associated parking, amenity spaces and landscaping works at Thirley Cotes Farm, Waite Lane, Harwood Dale for P & G Durbin Properties

NYM/2018/0358/LB Granted 25/10/2018 variation of condition 2 of Listed Building consent NYM/2015/0485/LB to allow the omission of front porch and increase in size of conservatory extension at Keepers Cottage, Rear of Park Hall, Main Road, Aislaby for Mr Alex Stevenson

NYM/2018/0390/FL Approved 19/11/2018 construction of 2 no. industrial units (Use Class B2) with associated access, hardstanding and landscaping works at Stainsacre Lane Industrial Estate, Coastal and Country Coaches, Fairfield Way, Whitby for Coastal and Country Coaches Ltd

NYM/2018/0400/FL Approved 23/10/2018 construction of single storey side extension at Horseshoe Cottage, Newlands Lane, Cloughton for Adrian Bury

NYM/2018/0405/FL Approved 12/10/2018 alterations and construction of single and two storey extensions and garage at South Beck House, Scalby for Mark Wilson

NYM/2018/0481/FL Approved 02/11/2018 proposed boardwalk extension, staircase and steps at Jugger Howe Moor, Fylingdales Moor for Sir Frederic Strickland-Constable

NYM/2018/0499/LB Granted 14/11/2018 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations to redundant buildings to enable use as 3 no. holiday cottages at Thirley Cotes Farm, Waite Lane, Harwood Dale for P & G Durbin Properties

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0502/FL Approved 23/11/2018 installation or replacement timber double glazed windows, timber door and replacement of rear dormer window and dormer roof covering. at 10 Church Street, Castleton for Mrs J Shaw and Mr A Diggles

NYM/2018/0516/FL Approved 05/11/2018 installation of replacement windows and 2 no. new windows at Prospect House, The Old Stubble Path, Staithes for Ms Jasvinder Sanghera

NYM/2018/0523/FL Approved 22/10/2018 variation of condition 3 of planning approval NYM/2004/0190/FL to allow the annexe to be used for holiday letting purposes at The Bungalow & Annexe at Summerfield Garage, Stainsacre for Summerfield Garage

NYM/2018/0526/FL Approved 05/10/2018 construction of single storey link extension and alterations to garage to form additional living accommodation at The Bank House, Front Street, Grosmont for Mr King

NYM/2018/0530/FL Approved 09/10/2018 variation of condition 4 of planning approval NYM/2006/0080/FL to sever the tie of the annexe accommodation with Ellerstang and allow the unit to become an independent dwelling at Ellerstang, 33 Church Street, Castleton for Mr Wayne Stephens

NYM/2018/0541/FL Approved 15/10/2018 erection of manure storage building at Suffield Farm, Suffield for JE Lockey and Son

NYM/2018/0553/FL Approved 31/10/2018 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2017/890/FL to allow the installation of additional rooflight to rear elevation at Providence Heath Cloughton for Mr & Mrs I Burnett

NYM/2018/0554/LB Granted 31/10/2018 Listed Building consent for installation of additional rooflight to rear elevation at Providence Heath Cloughton for Mr & Mrs I Burnett

NYM/2018/0558/FL Approved 25/10/2018 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) to allow erection of business name board and alteration to design of door and condition 4 to allow the sale of any cold food/drinks of planning approval NYM/2018/0177/FL at land in front of Beacholme on Quarterdeck, Covet Hill, Robin Hoods Bay for Ghyll Wood Developments Ltd

NYM/2018/0569/FL Approved 19/10/2018 demolition of chalet building and replacement with motorhome pitches and garden area, alterations to existing building to enable relocation of Park cafe and siting of check-in stand together with replacement of domestic shed with summerhouse at Whitby Holiday Park, Saltwick Bay, Whitby for Normanhurst Enterprises

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0572/FL Refused 30/10/2018 erection of manure storage building at Land off Swang Road, Suffield for J E Lockey and Son

NYM/2018/0578/FL Approved 25/10/2018 construction of replacement conservatory to rear at Eustace House, Raw for Mr & Mrs M McCabe

NYM/2018/0579/FL Approved 23/11/2018 improvement works to farm entrance together with proposed forwarder track at Thackside Farm, Thackside Farm Lane, Egton Grange for Forestry Commission

NYM/2018/0580/FL Approved 05/11/2018 alterations to and change of use of part of Low Hall and grounds to cafe/bar (Use Class A3) together with erection of pergola at Low Hall, Hackness Road, Scalby for Trustees of The National Union of Mineworkers (Yorkshire Area) Trust

NYM/2018/0583/FL Approved 27/11/2018 conversion of and extension to redundant chapel to form 1 no. dwelling with associated parking and amenity space at former Chapel, rear of Main Street, Westerdale for Mr & Mrs V & N Bradley

NYM/2018/0587/FL Refused 29/10/2018 demolition of former farm workers restroom and construction of domestic store building together with retaining wall (part retrospective) (revised scheme to NYM/2018/0372/FL) at Ainthorpe House, 1 Brook Lane, Ainthorpe for Mr Mark Hall

NYM/2018/0593/FL Approved 14/11/2018 construction of replacement front porch and alterations to dormer windows together with construction of detached garden room at Manor Cottage, Mires Lane, Newholm for Mr & Mrs N and S Grimshaw

NYM/2018/0596/FL Approved 02/11/2018 creation of manege for hobby use together with erection of extension to existing building at Land at Willow Wood Way, Stainsacre for Mr & Mrs Wayne and Deb Fletcher

NYM/2018/0604/FL Approved 02/11/2018 construction of single storey extension following demolition of conservatory at The Red House, Thorpe Lane, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Graham Whittle

NYM/2018/0609/FL Approved 08/11/2018 alterations to bow and dormer windows and creation of balcony at South View, Runswick Bay for Mr & Mrs Alton

NYM/2018/0624/FL Approved 16/11/2018 alterations and construction of single storey lobby extension to building approved for B1 use together with change of use of a section of agricultural building to business use (Use Class B1) and recladding works at Millinder House, Westerdale for Mr & Mrs Hopkins

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0625/FL Refused 15/11/2018 construction of dormer window together with first floor and single storey extensions to rear (revised scheme following refusal of NYM/2018/0257/FL) at Byways, 118 High Street, Hinderwell for Mr & Mrs Dan Porter

NYM/2018/0638/FL Approved 16/11/2018 variation of conditions 2 (material amendment) and 3 of planning approval NYM/2017/0023/FL to replace the stone columns and fascia with painted timber at Victoria Hotel, Station Road, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Fiddler

Notifications

Hambleton

NYM/2018/0584/AGRP Approved 26/10/2018 erection of general purpose agricultural lean-to extension at Low Cow Helm, Chop Gate for Mr George Allison

Scarborough

NYM/2018/0532/AGRP Approved 26/10/2018 demolition of cattle shed and grain silo and erection of grain store building at Ripleys Farm, Harwood Dale Road, Cloughton for The Duchy of Lancaster

NYM/2018/0539/AGRP Approved 12/10/2018 erection of covered manure store at Suffield Heights Farm, Limestone Lane, Suffield for Mr Benjamin Lockey

NYM/2018/0643/AGRP Approved 21/11/2018 erection of general purpose agricultural building at Hodgson Moor Farm, Gowland Lane, Cloughton for Mr David William Fenby

Appendix 2

Applications Determined by the Director of Planning on Expiry of Advertisement, Receipt of Further Amended Plans and Observations

NYM/2018/0244/FL & NYM/2018/0353/FL Both applications for erection of general purpose agricultural building with hardstanding area and associated access tracks at Valley View Farm, Old Byland

The above planning applications were approved by the Planning Committee on 20 September 2018, subject to the receipt of amended drawings showing revised materials to the exterior of the building comprising Yorkshire boarding to the upper parts of all elevations in place of the proposed Ventair cladding and locally quarried stone to the lower parts of the walls where they are visible in the wider landscape (i.e. the south and west elevations). In addition Members requested an amended landscaping scheme comprising large trees to help reduce the visual impact of the proposal on the wider landscape and details of an access track across the field to the southeast to provide suitable access for farm vehicles to and from the site across the area of archaeological importance.

These amended details have been received and in response the Authority’s Archaeologist and Historic England have confirmed that the route and constructional details of the proposed access track across the field to the southeast are satisfactory. With regard to the landscaping scheme Officers considered that the proposed planting of Sessile Oak along the various field boundaries at some distance to the west of the site will have a filtering effect and break up view of the buildings on the approach to Old Byland from the west.

The neighbours, Mr & Mrs Jarman at Fair View, Old Byland have commented that the planting of Oak trees is a surprising choice within fields grazed by livestock as they are toxic to sheep, cattle and horses and requested that the oak adjacent to their boundary is replaced. They also commented that no provision has been made for the screening of the new track over the archaeology and requested consideration to the planting of a hawthorn hedge along the shared boundary to help screened the development from the village.

In response to these comments the Authority’s Woodland Officer has responded that whilst acorns and other parts of Oak tree can cause issues with livestock if ingested in quantity, he is unaware of a single actual case where this has happened. He goes on to comment that Oak trees generally produce a significant amount of fruit on average once every seven years and in the Park most trees produce very little on average. Acorns fall over a short window of about two weeks and are rapidly gathered up by squirrels and birds. They are heavy and therefore spread little distance from the crown of the trees. In years where there are heavy falls it might be prudent to exclude livestock for a short period until they are naturally removed. He concludes that given the importance of Oak trees in our landscapes he would not wish to exclude them from planting schemes.

Appendix 2

However the applicant has removed the Oak tree from the landscaping scheme which was to be planted on the shared boundary with the neighbour to the east of the site and has replaced this with an Ash tree. This is considered appropriate as a hawthorn hedge planted so close to the buildings would provide very little screening.

Additional comments have also been received from Mr C Barnard of Garden Cottage, Old Byland in response to the amended plans. He commented that they are a significant improvement of the original proposal with the barns being set down at a lower level and the inclusion of mature trees on nearby farmland to provide screening in long distance views. He regrets that the barns will still be at some distance from the other farm buildings but welcomes the proposed access across the field linking the two.

In view of the above the decision notices have been issued with conditions. These notices can be viewed using the hyperlinks provided.

NYM/2018/0396/FL alterations and construction of single storey extensions to domestic outbuilding at Woodlands Farm, Dale Side Road, Thorgill, Rosedale

This application was approved by the Planning Committee on 18 October 2018, subject to Director of Planning to clear an additional condition requiring the extension to be set back by 30cm and amendment to condition 6 to ensure the use of vertical boarding. The decision notice has been issued with the following additional and amended conditions:

3. MISC00 Notwithstanding the submitted plans, the front elevation of the extension hereby approved shall be set back a minimum of 30cm from the adjacent wall of the original outbuilding. 7. MATS26 The external elevations of the building hereby approved shall, within three months of first being brought into use, be clad in dark brown vertical timber boarding and shall thereafter be so maintained unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority.

NYM/2018/0411/LB Listed Building consent for alterations and construction of single storey extensions to domestic outbuilding at Woodlands Farm, Dale Side Road, Thorgill, Rosedale

This application was approved by the Planning Committee on 18 October 2018, subject to Director of Planning to clear an additional condition requiring the extension to be set back by 30cm and amendment to condition 4 to ensure use of vertical boarding. The decision notice has been issued with the following additional and amended conditions:

3. MISC00 Notwithstanding the submitted plans, the front elevation of the extension hereby approved shall be set back a minimum of 30cm from the adjacent wall of the original outbuilding. 5. MATS26 The external elevations of the building hereby approved shall, within three months of first being brought into use, be clad in dark brown vertical timber boarding and shall thereafter be so maintained unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority.

Appendix 2

NYM/2018/0504/FL use of land for equestrian purposes and erection of stable block together with use of land for the siting of 5 no. shepherds huts for holiday purposes and creation of fire pond with associated track at Cropton Forest Lodge, Heads Road, Stape

This application was approved by the Planning Committee on 18 October 2018, subject to Director of Planning to clear an additional condition requiring extra landscaping to the rear of stable block. The decision notice has been issued with the following additional condition:

18. LNDS01 Prior to the development being brought into use details of a landscaping scheme for the site shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The scheme shall provide for additional hedge/tree planting along the western boundary adjacent the proposed stable building and shall include details of any existing hedges and trees to be retained on the site together with any measures for managing/reinforcing these and shall specify plant species, sizes and planting densities for any new areas of planting. The approved details shall be carried out no later than the first planting season following the occupation of the buildings, or completion of the development, whichever is the sooner, or in accordance with a programme agreed by the Local Planning Authority. The approved landscaping scheme shall be maintained in perpetuity unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority.

NYM/2018/0573/R3 application under Regulation 3 (Town and Country Planning General Regulations 1992) for alterations to ground levels, installation of safety grilles to the upcast and downcast shafts, gate to chimney and entrance to vault at Warren Moor Mine, Kildale

This application was approved by the Planning Committee on 18 October 2018, subject to the decision delegated to the Director of Planning to clear an amendment to a condition to ensure black painting applies only to the vertical door grills and not the horizontal capping grills which can have a galvanised finish. The decision notice has been issued with an amended condition as follows:

4. MATS00 The steel safety grille serving the chimney hereby permitted shall be coloured matt black and maintained in that condition in perpetuity unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority.

NYM/2018/0590/LB Listed Building consent for installation of safety grilles to the upcast and downcast shafts, gate to chimney and entrance to vault at Warren Moor Mine Kildale

This application was approved by the Planning Committee on 18 October 2018, subject to the decision delegated to the Director of Planning to clear an amendment to a condition to ensure black painting applies only to the vertical door grills and not the horizontal capping grills which have a galvanised finish. The decision notice has been issued with an amended condition as follows:

Appendix 2

Applications Adjacent to the National Park (3024)

R/2018/0621/OOM outline application (with some matters reserved) for erection of up to 60 residential dwellings with new vehicle and pedestrian accesses and associated landscaping at land off Nightingale Road, Galley Hill Guisborough

The Authority has assessed the details of the proposed development and advised that the National Park Authority has no objections to the above proposal. 18/01058/FUL & 18/01059/LBC repair to existing stone footbridge of full and Listed Building at Monks Bridge Abbey Precinct to Ampleforth Bank Ampleforth

The Authority has assessed the details of the proposed development and advised that the National Park Authority has no objections.

18/02458/OL residential development at Land Adjacent to 69 North Street, Scalby

The Authority has assessed the details of the proposed development and advised you that this Authority has no objections to the above proposal.

18/01026/PREAPP erection of dwelling at Knoll Hill Farm, Carr Lane, Ampleforth

Having looked at the proposals the Authority has advised of concerns regarding sporadic residential development and increasing domestic activity in the open countryside, which would have a resultant detrimental impact on the character and setting of, and important views into the National Park. It should be noted that as the proposal is both within and adjoining landscapes which are nationally protected the Local Planning Authority should also assess the proposal against paragraph 172 of the NPPF.

18/02302/MRC demolition of detached garage and side extension to existing dwelling at Brookside, Kilburn

The Authority has assessed the details of the proposed development and advised that this Authority has no additional comments to make following the original application.

Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports - dates as given 3022/1 2. Signed letter - dates as given 3024/1

Location North York Moors National Park Authority The Old Vicarage, Bondgate, Helmsley, York, YO62 5BP

Appendix 3

List of Enforcement Matters Determined By The Director of Planning

November Committee For the Period: 28 September 2018 to 1 November 2018

Development Description and File No. Decision Taken Site Address 13541 Unauthorised works to listed Remedial works completed building - Main Street Hutton Buscel 13731 Unauthorised fencing - Market Temporary planning permission granted Place Helmsley on appeal. 14025 Unauthorised UPVC windows in Windows removed and appropriate conservation area – High Kilburn timber design approved and installed 14167 Non compliance with conditions Not expedient to take enforcement and erection of sheds - Troutsdale action. 14194 Unauthorised works to create new Works approved under decision access – High Hawsker NYM/2015/0198/FL 14216 Unauthorised excavation works – Works constituted agricultural permitted Old Byland development 14263 Unauthorised benches and Benches have not been installed and the advertisements – Dalby Forest advertising has been removed 14314 Untidy site – Bank Lane Faceby Anonymous allegation unfounded. 14321 Unauthorised renovation works to Planning application submitted and building – Mount Pleasant Staithes approved. The site is currently being monitored for compliance 14352 Unauthorised track repairs – Lilla Permitted development Cross Harwood Dale 14363 Unauthorised converstion to Planning permission (1999) has been residential accommodation – approved for conversion. Grosmont 14377 Unauthorised shed – Goathland Permitted development 14396 Unauthorised material change of Planning application requested. use of land to domestic curtilage – Faceby Middlesbrough 14415 Unauthorised material change of Matter now subject to enforcement use of land to leisure plot – investigation. Overscar lane Lockton 14439 Unauthorised caravan – Beacon Caravan removed Bank Ampleforth 14466 Unauthorised works to domestic Permitted development property within the conservation area – West End Ampleforth 14627 Unauthorised works in association Planning application to be submitted. with a caravan site – Kilburn 14646 Unauthorised installation of a Immune from enforcement action satellite dish – Moor View Lockton 14687 Unauthorised garden building - Planning application to be submitted. Underhill Glaisdale

Appendix 3

14741 Unauthorised material change of Development ceased use to car repairs – Carlton Road Helmsley 14794 Unauthorised building works – Planning permission granted Church Lane Fylingthorpe 14796 Unauthorised construction of a Development is not planned to go ahead shed – Far Rosedale Port Mulgrave 14804 Unauthorised lake – Hackness Planning application submitted Road Scalby 14836 Unauthorised building – South Planning permission has been granted End Osmotherley 14847 Unauthorised Advert – Hutton Advert removed Buscel 14849 Unauthorised advert – Pickering Advert removed Road Thornton Dale 14867 Unauthorised waste transfer Matter subject of an enforcement station – Tig Tag Lane Kilburn investigation. 14883 Unauthorised UPVC windows – Permitted Development Nether Silton Thirsk 14887 Unauthorised removal of Permitted development vegetation – High Street Thornton Dale 14890 Unauthorised UPVC windows and Permitted development demolition of garage – Lead Lane Nether Silton 14919 Unauthorised gas cylinders – Permitted development Farmby Close Thornton Dale 14923 Right to light – Bank Lane Faceby This is not a planning matter

* Only complaints which score 6 or above will be further investigated. Those with a lesser score will be informed of the breach/likely breach and invited to remedy/regularise it. In both cases the complainant is to be notified of our actions.

Appendix 4

Monthly Performance Percentage Determined Running Average for Financial Year 2018/19 : Major 100% / Minor 73.2% / Other 78.7%

100 90 80 70 60 % 50 Major (Yearly Target 60%) 40 Minor (Yearly Target 65%) 30 Other (Yearly Target 80%) 20 10 0 Jul-18 Apr-18 Oct-18 Jan-18 Jun-18 Feb-18 Mar-18 Nov-17 Dec-17 Aug-18 Sep-18 Nov-18 May-18 Month

Monthly Percentage of Decisions Delegated to Officers Running Average for Financial Year 2018/19: 93.9% (Yearly Target 90%) 100

2016 % 85 2017 2018 80

70 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Quarterly Percentage of Appeal Decisions Allowed Running Average for Financial Year 2018/19: 66.6%%

100 90 80 70 60 % 50 40 30 20 Yearly Target 33% 10 0 Jul-Sep 15/16 Jul-Sep Jul-Sep 16/17 Jul-Sep Jul-Sep 18/19 Jul-Sep Apr-Jun 15/16 Apr-Jun Apr-Jun 16/17 Apr-Jun Apr-Jun 18/19 Apr-Jun Oct-Dec 14/15 Oct-Dec 14/15 Jan-Mar Jan-Mar 15/16 Jan-Mar Oct-Dec 16/17 Oct-Dec Jan-Mar 17/18 Jan-Mar Oct-Dec 18/19 Oct-Dec Oct -Dec 15/16 -Dec Oct Jul - Sep 17/18 - Sep Jul 17/18 -Dec Oct Apr - Jun 17/18 - Jun Apr Jan - Mar 16/17 - Mar Jan Quarter

Appendix 4

Planning Applications Outstanding for More Than 13 Weeks. Position as of 26 November 2018

NYM/2011/0389/FL Conversion of garage store and vacant shop to form local occupancy letting live/work unit together with 2 no. local occupancy letting dwellings at Central Garage, High Street, Castleton

Section 106 Agreement being drafted by the Authority’s Solicitor

NYM/2011/0800/CLE Certificate of lawfulness for use of land for the siting of a static caravan for holiday use in excess of ten years at Summerfield Farm, Hawsker

Awaiting legal advice from the Authority’s solicitor

NYM/2016/0353/FL Construction of 1 no. holiday letting cottage at Boulby Grange, Easington

Section 106 Agreement being finalised by the Authority’s Solicitor

NYM/2017/0170/FL Change of use of and alterations to building for commercial timber cutting use and improvement works to vehicular access (retrospective) (resubmission following withdrawal of NYM/2015/0657/FL) at Lanes Farm, Glaisdale

Decision due to go out imminently

NYM/2017/0395/LB Listed Building consent for conversion of stable block to cafe, farm shop, reception/shop/welcome area together with 3 no. holiday cottages, 47 holiday lodges with associated car park and ancillary facilities and the construction of a Gamekeepers Barn at Grinkle Park Hotel, Grinkle Lane, Easington

Application on hold until full application is ready to be determined

NYM/2017/0372/FL Conversion of stable block to cafe, farm shop, reception/shop/welcome area together with 3 no. holiday cottages, 47 holiday lodges with associated car park and ancillary facilities and the construction of a Gamekeepers Barn at Grinkle Park Hotel, Grinkle Lane, Easington

Application determined at August Committee awaiting conditions and Section 106 Agreement being finalised

NYM/2017/0455/FL Change of use and extension to existing agricultural building to allow use for livestock and siting of feed bin at Manor Farm, Gillamoor

Section 106 Agreement being drafted by the Authority’s Solicitor

NYM/2017/0469/FL Extension to existing farm building together with alterations to existing access at Land on Egton Lane, Glaisdale

Section 106 Agreement at draft discussion

NYM/2017/0692/FL Erection of a stable block with tack room (revised scheme to NYM/2017/0452/FL) together with change of use of land for the keeping of horses at Peat House, Delves Lane, Egton Grange

Reconsultation expired, awaiting Officer recommendation

NYM/2017/0806/AD Advertisement consent for the display of 3 no. non- illuminated post mounted signs at Hill Farm, Beck Hole, Whitby

Decision due to go out imminently

NYM/2017/0829/FL Erection of agricultural building at Manor House Farm, Cliff Brow, Roxby

Awaiting information from applicant as to how they wish to progress with the application

NYM/2017/0845/LB Listed Building consent for internal alterations, installation of replacement timber double glazed windows and timber door, installation of 2 no. rooflights together with erection of replacement decking at Gallery Cottage, 2 Martins Row, Robin Hoods Bay

Amended plans under consideration

NYM/2018/0016/FL Installation of replacement timber double glazed windows and timber door, installation of 4 no. rooflights together with erection of replacement decking at Gallery Cottage, 2 Martins Row, Robin Hoods Bay

Awaiting amended plans

NYM/2018/0037/OU Outline application for construction of up to 3 no. affordable dwellings (all matters reserved) at land to the east of Husthwaite Road, Coxwold

Awaiting for Local Housing Needs Survey

NYM/2018/0039/FL Construction of 4 no. open market dwellings with associated access, parking, garage/car ports, amenity space and landscaping works at land to the west of Byland Road, Coxwold

Awaiting amended plans

NYM/2018/0052/FL Conversion of and porch extension to redundant farm buildings to form 4 no. holiday cottages with associated parking together with reduction in size of existing portal framed agricultural building at Rudda Farm, North Side, Rudda Road, Staintondale

Awaiting Bat Survey

NYM/2018/0076/R3 Application under Regulation 3 (Town and Country Planning General Regulations 1992) for alterations and single storey extensions to Visitor Centre including the installation of solar PV together with modifications to existing car parking areas, creation of additional car parking areas, proposed paths and erection of a dark skies viewing/bird hide building at Sutton Bank Visitor Centre

Applicant working with the Highway Authority to resolve concerns

NYM/2018/0161/FL Raising of wall height to existing kitchen together with erection of pigeon cote/shed and siting of treatment tank at Lingberry Cottage, Oakley Walls, Lealholm

Amended plans received and under consideration

NYM/2018/0222/FL Variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2015/0014/FL to regularise changes to extension, decking and boiler room, raised ground level, water drainage and wall enclosing raised patio area (resubmission following refusal of NYM/2017/0016/FL) at Cottage One, Dunsley Hall, Dunsley

Awaiting consultation responses regarding drainage matters

NYM/2018/0310/FL Demolition of existing Filling Station and construction of Hotel Annexe to the Arncliffe Arms, comprising 7 no. letting rooms together with Tearoom and spa/beauty facility and associated parking and landscaping works at Honey Bee Nest, Glaisdale

Awaiting amended plans and clarification

NYM/2018/0324/FL Alterations and extensions to domestic building to form residential annexe accommodation together with construction of double garage at 14 North End, Osmotherley

Awaiting amended plans

NYM/2018/0374/FL Creation of car park to serve existing village centre (revised scheme to NYM/2017/0605/FL) at land adjacent to Botton Village Store, Botton Village, Danby

Application likely to be withdrawn

NYM/2018/0448/FL Conversion of former Methodist Chapel to form holiday accommodation at Methodist Church, Chop Gate

Ongoing discussions between applicant and Building Conservation

NYM/2018/0449/LB Listed Building consent for alterations to enable conversion of former Methodist Chapel to holiday accommodation at Methodist Church, Chop Gate

Ongoing discussions between applicant and Building Conservation

NYM/2018/0536/FL Alterations and construction of single and two storey extensions with decking to dwelling together with conversion of and extension to agricultural buildings to form 2 no. holiday cottages, revised access arrangement, parking and landscaping works at Green End Farm, Green End, Goathland

Amended plans received and under consideration

NYM/2018/0544/LB Listed Building consent for internal alterations, alterations to windows, doors and granary steps and removal of dormer window together with construction of replacement single storey extension and sun room to north west elevation at Atkinsons Wood Farm, Easby

Amended plans received and under consideration

NYM/2018/0542/FL Alterations to windows, doors and granary steps and removal of dormer window together with construction of replacement single storey extension and sun room to north west elevation (part retrospective) at Atkinsons Wood Farm, Easby

Amended plans received and under consideration

NYM/2018/0564/FL Construction of single storey link extension and alterations to outbuilding to form additional living accommodation at Eastmount, Suffield, Scarborough

Awaiting amended plans

NYM/2018/0559/FL Proposed internal and external restoration works at Pineapple House at Busby Hall, Carlton In Cleveland

Awaiting Historic Building Survey

NYM/2018/0561/LB Listed Building consent for proposed internal and external restoration works at Pineapple House at Busby Hall, Carlton In Cleveland

Awaiting Historic Building Survey

Appendix 5

North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

13 December 2018

List of Hedgerow Removal Notices determined by the National Park Officer for the period 16 August 2018 – 15 November 2018

File Ref Name of Applicant Location of Hedgerows 2076/3/1/18 Mott MacDonald Bentley East of Easington Spectrum 5 Spectrum Business Park Seaham SR7 7TT

1. Background

The Hedgerow Removal Notice was for the removal of 5 no. 5 metre sections of hedgerow. The reason given in the Notice for the removal of these lengths of hedgerow was to accommodate the construction of a new 1850 metre water main to replace the existing pipeline located between Grinkle Lane, Easington, along towards Boulby village and connecting to the Boulby Potash Mine meter house.

2. Decision

Following a field survey and an examination of existing records, the hedgerows were found to meet the criteria for an ‘important hedgerow’ under the Regulations on historical grounds, due to the hedgerows being recorded on either the Easington Draft Enclosure Map dated 1817 held at the County Records Office or the Easington Tithe Map dated 1838 held at the Borthwick Institute, York.

Although the hedgerows have been found to be important, having taken into account the reasons put forward for the hedgerows removal the Authority gave its consent for removal of a limited length subject to the following conditions:

i) Removal is to be limited to 5 metres within each hedgerow as shown on the map supplied with the application.

ii) Removal is to be undertaken outside of the bird breeding season (March – September).

iii) Replanting is to be undertaken on the sections of hedgerow removed.

iv) Planting should be undertaken at a density of no less than 6 plants per metre and protected with spiral guards. Hedge gaps must be replanted with native shallow rooted species that won’t disturb the pipe but will retain the integrity of the hedge line. The species mix should reflect the existing mix of species within the hedgerow. The area of disturbed ground must be minimised and any soil dug out from the hedgerows should be kept separate from other soils, and returned to the hedge line once the pipe has been laid to secure the organisms present within the soil.

v) The hedge should be fenced to protect from stock with the fence placed at least 1 metre from the line of the planting. Post-planting maintenance must be carried out to ensure successful establishment.

vi) The site is known to be locally important for harvest mice. As the mice breed into late autumn (up to mid-December if temperatures are warm enough) work should be undertaken between mid-December – March in order to prevent disturbance to nesting sites. Prior to removal the sections of hedgerow should be checked for harvest mice nests and any found should be left undisturbed until the young have left the nest.

Date of decision: 8 October 2018 N O R T H Y O R K M O O R S N A T I O N A L P A R K A U T H O R I T Y HEDGEROW REMOVAL NOTICE (under the Hedgerow Regulations 1997) CONSENT FOR REMOVAL

Location: Easington 5 metre sections of hedgerow NYMNPA File Ref: 2076/3/1/18 which can be removed