Action Against Torture Action Against Torture
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ActionAction against Torture A Practical Guide to the Istanbul Protocol forfor Lawyers in the Philippines NovemberNovember 20072007 This Manual was written by the REDRESS TRUST as Part of the Prevention through Documentation Project, an initiative of the International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims (IRCT), the World Medical Association (WMA), the Human Rights Foundation of Turkey (HRFT), and Physicians for Human Rights USA (PHR USA) For further information on this manual, please contact REDRESS at: 87 Vauxhall Walk, London SE11 5HJ Tel: +44 (0)20 7793 1777 Fax: +44 (0)20 7793 1719 [email protected] (general correspondence) ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This manual is the outcome of a collaborative effort spanning several years of cooperation and involving lawyers, human rights defenders, doctors and others in the Philippines and elsewhere. REDRESS is especially grateful to all those who have contributed to the drafting of the manual by providing information, comments and/or suggestions, in particular Ellecer E. Carlos, Balay Rehabilitation Center, Inc.; Neri Colmenares, Associate (Asian Law Centre), Faculty of Law, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia; Maria Socorro I. Diokno, Secretary General, FLAG (Free Legal Assistance Group); Rogel ‘Gil’ Navarro, Chairman, Peace Advocates for Truth, Healing and Justice (PATH); Atty. Soliman Santos; Antonio Villasor, Peace & Human Rights Coordinator, Asian Cultural Forum for Development (ACFOD), as well as David Gates and Varsha Goyal for their research assistance. The manual was written by Lutz Oette, and edited by Carla Ferstman. IINNDDEEXX PART 1: OVERVIEW OF THE ISTANBUL PROTOCOL .......................................... 6 A. INTRODUCTION..............................................................................................................................6 B. THE IMPORTANCE OF LEGAL PROFESSIONALS IN THE DOCUMENTATION AND INVESTIGATION OF TORTURE...............................................................................................8 C. THE IMPORTANCE OF MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS IN THE DOCUMENTATION OF TORTURE AND THE NEED FOR LAWYERS TO UNDERSTAND THE MEDICAL SYMPTOMS OF TORTURE..................................................................................................................................8 D. KEY INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS IN THE ISTANBUL PROTOCOL.........................................9 PART 2: GENERAL LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE OF TORTURE IN THE PHILIPPINES.................................................................................................. 12 A. THE PRACTICE OF TORTURE IN THE PHILIPPINES.................................................................12 B. PROHIBITION AND DEFINITION OF TORTURE IN THE PHILIPPINES......................................13 PART 3: INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS CONTAINED IN THE ISTANBUL PROTOCOL............................................................................................................ 17 A. GENERAL MEASURES OF PREVENTION IN THE PHILIPPINES..............................................17 B. SPECIFIC SAFEGUARDS IN PLACES OF DETENTION AND RIGHTS OF PERSONS DEPRIVED OF THEIR LIBERTY.............................................................................................19 I. SAFEGUARDS DURING ARREST PROCEDURES ...............................................................................................19 II. CUSTODIAL SAFEGUARDS ..................................................................................................................................20 (i) Right to access a lawyer of one’s own choice.........................................................................................................20 (ii) Right to communicate with and notify a third person of detention..........................................................................22 (iii) Right to access a doctor ........................................................................................................................................23 III. FURTHER SAFEGUARDS.....................................................................................................................................25 (i) Challenging the lawfulness of detention..................................................................................................................25 (ii) Lawfulness of confessions extracted under torture................................................................................................27 C. RIGHT TO COMPLAIN AND OBLIGATION TO EFFECTIVELY INVESTIGATE TORTURE ALLEGATIONS........................................................................................................................28 I. International standards.............................................................................................................................................28 II. Legal framework and practice in the Philippines.....................................................................................................29 1. Criminal offences applying in lieu of a specific offence of torture and penalties.....................................................29 2. Right to lodge complaints and to protection ............................................................................................................30 3. Investigating torture allegations "promptly", “impartially” and “effectively”..............................................................32 4. The Role of the Commission on Human Rights ......................................................................................................34 D. PROSECUTION OF ALLEGED PERPETRATORS OF TORTURE AND PUNISHMENT OF THOSE RESPONSIBLE ..........................................................................................................36 I. International standards.............................................................................................................................................36 II. Legal framework and practice in the Philippines.....................................................................................................36 E. RIGHT TO AN EFFECTIVE REMEDY AND REPARATION .........................................................37 1. International standards............................................................................................................................................37 2. Domestic remedial avenues/mechanisms available to torture survivors.................................................................38 2.1. Constitutional Law ................................................................................................................................................38 2.2. Civil Law ...............................................................................................................................................................38 2.3. Criminal Law.........................................................................................................................................................40 2.4. The Board of Claims.............................................................................................................................................41 2.5. Financial assistance provided by the Commission on Human Rights..................................................................43 2.6. Assistance to Victims of Sexual Violence.............................................................................................................45 2.7. Reparation for torture and other serious violations committed during the Marcos regime...................................45 2.8. Findings................................................................................................................................................................46 Effectiveness of remedies................................................................................................................................46 Adequate reparation ........................................................................................................................................46 PART 4: INTERNATIONAL REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO TORTURE SURVIVORS ................................................................................................................................ 46 1. International Human Rights Complaints Procedures ..............................................................................................46 UN Human Rights Committee .........................................................................................................................46 Committee against Torture ..............................................................................................................................50 2. International Human Rights Reporting Procedures.................................................................................................51 UN Committee against Torture........................................................................................................................51 UN Human Rights Committee .........................................................................................................................52 UN Special Rapporteur on Torture ..................................................................................................................53 ADDENDUM: TORTURE BY NON-STATE ACTORS IN THE PHILIPPINES ......... 55 PartPart 1: Overview of the Istanbul Protocol A.A. Introduction Recognising the prevalence of torture in the world