DOCSLIB.ORG

UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/8gn7f9w2 Author Blumenthal, Helaine Debra Publication Date 2012 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust By Helaine Debra Blumenthal A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in Charge: Professor John Connelly, Chair Professor John Efron Professor Yuri Slezkine Professor David Frick Spring 2012 Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust Copyright © 2012 By Helaine Debra Blumenthal Abstract Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust by Helaine Debra Blumenthal Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Berkeley Professor John Connelly, Chair In this study, I examine how Jews in the United States, Western Europe, and Israel reacted to the Slansky Affair, the Doctors’ Plot, and the general wave of overt Soviet antisemitism which took shape in late 1952 until Stalin’s death in early March 1953. I explore how the Holocaust, the creation of a Jewish state, and the Cold War affected Jewish conceptions of antisemitism as well as the nature and character of Jewish collective action on both the global and the domestic stage. After investigating the ways in which Jews understood and reacted to the trial culturally, religiously, organizationally, nationally, and politically, I assert that in the early 1950s, Jews were in a process of redefinition. The role of Israel in diasporic Jewish affairs, the relationship between Jews and the Left, the position of Jews in the Cold War, and the nature and character of Jewish central leadership figured prominently in the lives of individual Jews and Jewish communities in the years immediately following the end of the Second World War. This is not an investigation of the Slansky Trial itself. Rather, through examining how Jews understood and made sense of the Trial, I construct a narrative of Jewish identity politics in the early 1950s. 1 Dedication To the memory of my father, Norman C. Blumenthal. Your love and support continue to sustain me as much in death as they did in life. i Contents Dedication ...................................................................................................................................................... i Acknowledgments ........................................................................................................................................ iv Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. v Chapter One: Framing the Debate .......................................................................................................... 1 The Holocaust and the Realities of Genocide ........................................................................................... 1 The Nature of Soviet Antisemitism ........................................................................................................... 4 Halt the Hysteria ..................................................................................................................................... 11 Missing the Target .................................................................................................................................. 16 Historicizing the Trial .............................................................................................................................. 18 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................................. 27 Chapter Two: The Race Against Time .................................................................................................... 28 The Zionists ............................................................................................................................................. 29 Labor ....................................................................................................................................................... 34 The American Jewish Committee and The Liberal Agenda ..................................................................... 39 Western Europe ...................................................................................................................................... 51 The Zurich Controversy ........................................................................................................................... 53 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................................. 68 Chapter Three: Communism on Trial ................................................................................................... 70 Recruitment and Vigilance ...................................................................................................................... 71 Retreats from Communism ..................................................................................................................... 76 From the Communist Point of View ........................................................................................................ 94 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................................... 105 Chapter Four: The “State” of the Trial ................................................................................................. 108 Reaction to Prague ................................................................................................................................ 110 The Doctors’ Plot ................................................................................................................................... 116 The Bombing at the Soviet Legation ..................................................................................................... 124 The Rupture .......................................................................................................................................... 127 Jews, Israel, and the Cold War .............................................................................................................. 132 The United Nations and the Reversal of the Doctors’ Plot ................................................................... 141 Resumption of Diplomatic Relations .................................................................................................... 147 ii The Crisis Within ................................................................................................................................... 148 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................................... 162 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................. 164 Bibliography .............................................................................................................................................. 170 iii Acknowledgments First and foremost, I must thank Professor John Connelly whose guidance, advice, and critical eye over the last seven years have continually challenged me and made me into a better historian. I would also like to thank Professors John Efron, Yuri Slezkine, and David Frick for their careful review of the following work and their indispensible advice regarding its content. I would be remiss if I did not express my sincere thanks to Professor Peggy Anderson. Your mentorship, friendship, and caring attitude have helped me through some rough times, and your TV recommendations have always proved to be a much welcomed distraction. I am grateful for the institutional support of the History Department and Graduate Division of UC Berkeley, the Cahnman Foundation, and the Center for Jewish History. I am especially thankful to the staff of the Center for Jewish History for their patient help in navigating the archives. I owe special thanks to my research assistants, Scott Young, Claire Payton, Julia Lieken, and Hilary Kaplan. You made those long hours in the archives a little more lively, and I would not have been able to carry out my research without you. Many have helped me along this path, but I would not have begun the journey without the mentorship of my undergraduate advisor, Pieter Judson. I continue to value your friendship, both personally and professionally. I cannot begin to show my appreciation for the love and support my friends and family have shown me unconditionally throughout this experience. I think I owe my relative sanity to the almost daily conversations I had with Rebecca Eckstein Gerber and Ramie Gold. I owe special gratitude to my mother, Marcia Blumenthal, and brother, Saul Blumenthal. Your encouragement has sustained me
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Tt Issue331.Pdf
    RosebuDk Sports THE T.T. SPECIALISTS now at 119 WITTON STREET NORTHWICH CHESHIRE Tel. 0606 48989 Indicative of Destiny SWEDEN BEATEN IN POZNAN Fixtures for Jan. 12/'83 A study of'the results appertaining a't POLAND brought off the shock result of Hungary v Federal Germany the Yugos,lav and Fr'ench Open cham­ the season when, in the fourth series of Poland v Denmark pio,nships, i'n Split and Strasbourg, aga1in matches in the Super Division of the Sweden v Czechoslovakia underlines the do,miinance of the, European League, played on Dec. 15/'82, Yugoslavia v England P'eople's Republic of China as a table they accounted for previously unbeaten Fixtures for Feb. 9/'83 tennis nation. Sweden 4-3 in Poznan. Yugos,lavia v Hungary It was hearte,ning, of course, to no:te Andrzej Grubba was Poland's hero with Denmark v England an opening set win over Jan-Ove Waldner Federal Germany v Sweden the victory of European champion, Czechoslovakia v Poland B,ettine Vriesekoop of the Netherlands, followed by success in the mixed, with Jolanta Szatko, over Erik Lindh and Marie FIRST DIVISION in the women's s:ingles event in Siras­ Lindblad and, finally with the match score bourg and the victo,r'ie,s obtained in Split balanced at 3-3 beat Lindh 23-21 in the After two season's in the First Division, by Europ,e,an players i'n the men's, third to give Poland the victory. Scores: the Soviet Union would appear intent on women's and m'ixed doubles.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2014/15
    Annual Report 2014/15 For the year ended March 31, 2015 Incorporating season review 2014/15 Contents 3 Chair’s Foreword 4 Chief Executive’s Statement 5 Notable Achievements 6-7 Operations 8 Marketing & Communications 9 Membership & Ranking 10-12 Development 13 Coaching 14-15 Performance 16-17 Competitions & Events 18-19 Commonwealth Games 20-27 Season review 28-29 Awards & Thanks 30-31 Staff & Governance; Obituaries 32-34 Accounts 35 International matters 2 | Table Tennis England Annual report Chairman’s Foreword “I was honoured to present the St Brides Vase to Ma Long, men’s singles champion at the Worlds” – Sandra Deaton Sandra Deaton In last year's Annual Report, I wrote about the changes we were putting in place and the challenges which lay ahead to implement them. The past year has seen many of those necessary reforms come about. For some, these changes have been difficult, but I do believe they were essential if we were to build for the future. We had to take a long hard look at what we did and the way we did it. Since our team came into office two years ago, everything we have done has been geared at returning table tennis to a position where we could plan ahead with confidence. We have now arrived there. Earlier this year, we were delighted to learn that our main financial supporters, Sport England, decided that table tennis was ‘back on track’, removed us from the ‘special measures’ and returned us to secure funding to the end of this cycle. This means that we can prepare for the future with confidence.
    [Show full text]
  • Charles Bawden
    CHARLES BAWDEN Charles Roskelly Bawden 22 April 1924 – 11 August 2016 elected Fellow of the British Academy 1971; resigned 1980; re-elected 1985 by VERONIKA VEIT Charles Bawden, Emeritus Professor of Mongolian Studies at the School of Oriental and African Studies (in the University of London), was born in Weymouth on the south coast of England (Dorset), on 22 April 1924. Scholar—Poet—Man of His Word: in such terms may be characterised the three vocations which were to guide and form the life celebrated in this memoir. Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the British Academy, XVIII, 449–469 Posted 21 November 2019. © British Academy 2019. CHARLES BAWDEN The scholar Born of parents who were both school-teachers—the father at the local elementary school for boys—Charles himself describes his home as a modest one. ‘There were few books at home,’ he recalls, ‘but important among them were the pre-first world war edition of Arthur Mee’s Children’s Encyclopaedia, and the Harmsworth Encyclopedia, which between them served as my childhood library.’ In the late 1930s, however, Charles’ father bought a wireless set, which the young boy calls ‘his lifeline’: from that set he was first able to listen to spoken French and German, which later were to prove his main academic interests, and even to hear music—another of his future lifelong interests—for Weymouth itself was, in those days, ‘a cultural waste’, without even a public library available, as Charles remembers. A further step in what he describes as his, in some ways, ‘contradictory upbringing’, and which directed his interests more definitely towards what was to become his future career, might best be described in his own words: On the one hand my father, especially, was a real pioneer in some things.
    [Show full text]
  • ACROSS the NET Melton Table Tennis May 2020 Edition 56
    ACROSS THE NET Melton Table Tennis May 2020 Edition 56 NOT MUCH TO SAY, REALLY I spoke to a doctor last night, and she said that she was hopeful of the virus being eradicated very soon. Mind you, she’s a doctor of music, but it was nice to get some good news. In this edition, we look back over 6 years of previous editions and hope that there is a reason to write future editions. COVID-19 UPDATE Well, we are still in the grips of a lockdown. It’s tough on many of us, driving us crazy and leaving us with a feeling of hopelessness. It’s like umpiring a best-of-5 match between two defenders. You know it’s going to end sometime; you just don’t know if you can hang on until then. But hang tough, my friends. We will get through this. As you know, both of our venues are currently closed. We have had no word on when these are likely to re- open, so it’s just a waiting game. When we hear that the restrictions are going to be eased, your committee will need to meet to discuss how and when we can get back to playing. We’ll obviously keep you informed. The best you can do in the meantime is follow the medical advice given, look after each other, and stay safe. Until then, I thought I’d put together some of my favourite articles from the past 6 years of Across The Net, just to give you something to read while you wait for better times ahead.
    [Show full text]
  • Nahum Mandel Testemunho De Um Sonho (Brasil, 1935-1948)
    Nahum Mandel Testemunho de um sonho (Brasil, 1935-1948) 2009 239 Testemenho de um Sonho (Brasil – 1935-1948) Copyright © Nahum Mandel (2009) ISBN 978-965-90889-5-6 Todos os direitos reservados Permitido copiar até 5 linhas, citando da origem. Reprodução de textos maiores e de fotos exigem autorização do Autor. Kiburz Gaash, ISRAEL 2009 2 Dedico este livro a meus companheiros de sonho. Uns o realizaram, outros não. Entretanto, todos vivem em minha memória e no meu coração. N.M 3 Agradecimentos Graças às caprichosas revisões de meu primo Arnaldo Mandel e de meus amigos Etel Sara Wengier e Norberto Freund, o português deste livro é legível. Merecido beijo à minha esposa e companheira Shoshana, pela esmerada revisão ortográfica final. N.M. 4 Prefácio Historia é o que os historiadores escrevem. O que não está escrito na História – naõ aconteceu! (Nahum Mandel, "Autobiosophia"[1]) Martin Lutero King disse "eu tenho um sonho". Também eu fui um sonhador, e creio que ainda sou. Grande parte de meus sonhos, realizei: o relato deste livro, além de meu tesemunho pessoal, reflete a minha geração, que presenciou os dois eventos mais dramáticos da Histótia dos judeus na época moderna – o Holocausto e a declaração do Estado de Israel. Estatisticamente são raros os que se dão ao trabalho de documentar e escrever memórias do que presenciaram ao longo de suas vidas. Me incluo nesta minoria. Desde meus catorze anos, coleciono todos papeizinhos que dizem respeito a meus passos e desta maneira escrevi 6 livros, dos quais publiquei 4[2]. Este será o quinto. Este livro não é uma monografia, nem pretende ser um documento histórico-acadêmico.
    [Show full text]
  • Czech and Polish Table Tennis Players of Jewish Origin in International Competition (19261957)
    PHYSICAL CULTURE AND SPORT. STUDIES AND RESEARCH DOI: 10.2478/v10141-011-0023-7 Czech and Polish Table Tennis Players of Jewish Origin in International Competition (1926-1957) Wiesław Pięta, Aleksandra Pięta Jan Długosz University, Częstochowa, Poland ABSTRACT The beginnings of the 18 th century marked the birth of Jewish sport. The most famous athletes of those days were boxers, such as I. Bitton, S. Eklias, B. Aaron, D. Mendoga. Popular sports of this minority group included athletics, fencing and swimming. One of the first sport organizations was the gymnastic society Judische Turnverein Bar Kocha (Berlin – 1896). Ping-pong as a new game in Europe developed at the turn of the 20th century. Sport and organizational activities in England were covered by two associations: the Ping Pong Association and the Table Tennis Association; they differed, for example, in the regulations used for the game. In 1902, Czeski Sport (a Czech Sport magazine) and Kurier Warszawski (Warsaw’s Courier magazine) published first information about this game. In Czech Republic, Ping-pong became popular as early as the first stage of development of this sport worldwide, in 1900-1907. This was confirmed by the Ping-pong clubs and sport competitions. In Poland, the first Ping-pong sections were established in the period 1925-1930. Czechs made their debut in the world championships in London (1926). Poles played for the first time as late as in the 8th world championships in Paris (1933). Competition for individual titles of Czech champions was started in 1927 (Prague) and in 1933 in Poland (Lviv). In the 1930s, Czechs employed an instructor of Jewish descent from Hungary, Istvan Kelen (world champion in the 1929 mixed games, studied in Prague).
    [Show full text]
  • The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust
    Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust By Helaine Debra Blumenthal A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in Charge: Professor John Connelly, Chair Professor John Efron Professor Yuri Slezkine Professor David Frick Spring 2012 Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust Copyright © 2012 By Helaine Debra Blumenthal Abstract Fourteen Convicted, Three Million Condemned: The Slansky Affair and the Reconstitution of Jewish Identities After the Holocaust by Helaine Debra Blumenthal Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Berkeley Professor John Connelly, Chair In this study, I examine how Jews in the United States, Western Europe, and Israel reacted to the Slansky Affair, the Doctors’ Plot, and the general wave of overt Soviet antisemitism which took shape in late 1952 until Stalin’s death in early March 1953. I explore how the Holocaust, the creation of a Jewish state, and the Cold War affected Jewish conceptions of antisemitism as well as the nature and character of Jewish collective action on both the global and the domestic stage. After investigating the ways in which Jews understood and reacted to the trial culturally, religiously, organizationally, nationally, and politically, I assert that in the early 1950s, Jews were in a process of redefinition. The role of Israel in diasporic Jewish affairs, the relationship between Jews and the Left, the position of Jews in the Cold War, and the nature and character of Jewish central leadership figured prominently in the lives of individual Jews and Jewish communities in the years immediately following the end of the Second World War.
    [Show full text]
  • World Championships and Olympic Games Summary Venue MS WS
    World Championships and Olympic Games Summary Venue MS WS MD WD XD MT WT Notes R. Jacobi HUN Z. Mechlovits HUN D. Pecsi HUN 1. Hungary London R. Jacobi HUN M.Mednyanszky HUN M.Mednyanszky 1st World Championship 12, 22, 19 15, 19 15, 11, -19, 11 X 14, 8 2. Austria X Ivor Montagu becomes ITTF 1926 Z.Mechlovits HUN D.Gubbins WAL Mechlovits HUN R. Jacobi HUN 3. ENG = IND Chairman (later, President) Kehrling HUN Gleeson A. Liebster AUT F. Flamm AUT Z. Mechlovits Z.Mechlovits HUN M.Mednyanszky R. Thum AUT M.Mednyanszky M.Mednyanszky Hungary Stockholm Begin Women's Doubles -8, -18, 22, 12, 15 19, 20, 13 10, 13, 16 16, 21, 11 -19, 20, 16, 9 Austria X 1928 Score standard: 21-pts L.Bellak HUN E.Metzger GER F. Perry ENG D. Gubbins WAL D. Pecsi HUN England C. Bull ENG Sommerville E. Metzger GER V. Barna HUN E. Metzger GER I. Kelen HUN M. Szabados HUN Hungary Budapest F. Perry ENG Mednyanszky HUN M. Rüster GER A. Sipos HUN Fred Perry wins Singles, -14, 12, 21, 19 9, 15, 12 15, 14, 13 14, 15, 12 -19, 18, 13, 8 Austria X switches to tennis, wins 3 1929 Szabados HUN Wildam AUT L. Bellak HUN G. Wildam AUT L. Bellak HUN England consecutive Wimbledons S. Glancz HUN F. Flamm AUT M. Gal HUN V. Barna HUN M.Mednyansky M. Szabados HUN V.Barna HUN Mednyanszky HUN M. Szabados HUN A. Sipos HUN M.Mednyanszky Hungary Berlin V.Barna wins 1st Singles 14, -16, 16, 12 18, 15, -21, -10, 15 11, 14, 18 12, 12, 19 20, 18, -16, 19 Sweden X 1930 World Ch.
    [Show full text]
  • Champion WRITES on TABLE TENNIS
    .. Vol. VII. No.9 MAY. 1949 Victor Barna: The Artist of Table Tennis THROUGHOUT the world, the name of VICTOR BARNA is known. His personality and his mastery at the table have given to him a fame beyond that of any other player our game has so far produced, and a position among the small band of the truly great sportsmen of any country and any time. VICT<?R BAR;NA'S contribution to Table Tennis has been particularly great in this country, his adoptive home. The tours which he made in the nineteen-thirties, <chiefly with Szabados and Bellak, opened innumer­ able eyes to a new sport and fired the enthusiasm of thousands of new players. His willing efforts during the war helped thel E.. T'.T'.A. to raise thousands .of pounds for the Sportsmen's Red Cross Fund and other \var charities. Since' thie, war, he has been a. valued member of the English Swaythling Cup' team, and this season was only narrowly defeated in the final of the English Championships after a match that kept the crowd on the edge of threir chairs from beginning to end. RECENT~y, B~rna has annou~ced his intention of giving up serious com'petltlve SIngles play. ThIS does not mean that we shall not see him in action; there will be doubles events and exhibitions, and, Barna being the man He is, no doubt he will be willing to answer an occasional special caU for the next season or two. Nevertheless, this does signal the end of an epoch of some twenty years during which his name has been continuously included in everyone's list of the greatest active players of the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Peace, Peace, When There Is No Peace (Israel and the Arabs 1948–1961)
    Peace, Peace, When There Is No Peace (Israel and the Arabs 1948–1961) N. Israeli (Akiva Orr and Moshé Machover) Translated from Hebrew by Mark Marshall ii Introduction [to the first edition]................................................................................... xv Chapter 1: “Following Clayton’s Participation in the League’s Meetings”................ 1 Chapter 2: Borders and Refugees ................................................................................. 28 Map: How the Palestinian state was divided............................................................ 42 Chapter 3: Israel and the Powers (1948-1955)............................................................. 83 Chapter 4: Israel and Changes in the Arab World ................................................... 141 Chapter 5: Reprisal Actions......................................................................................... 166 Chapter 6: “The Third Kingdom of Israel” (29/11/56 – 7/3/57).............................. 225 Chapter 7: Sinai War: Post-Mortem........................................................................... 303 Chapter 8: After Suez................................................................................................... 394 Chapter 9: How is the Problem to be Solved?............................................................ 420 Appendices (1999) ......................................................................................................... 498 Appendix 1: Haaretz article on the 30th anniversary of “Operation Qadesh”
    [Show full text]
  • The Funny Peculiar Case of Ivor Montagu's Bluebottles Seb Manley, University of East Anglia, UK
    Comedy and Experimentation in British Alternative Film: The Funny Peculiar Case of Ivor Montagu's Bluebottles Seb Manley, University of East Anglia, UK In the same year that Ivor Montagu's Bluebottles was released, the Film Society programmes note three major events that worked to support the society's stated aim of "reinvigorating" British cinema on a production level: a lecture class by Eisenstein (February 1929); a lecture class by Pudovkin (November 1929); and a film production course ran by Hans Richter, which would yield the film Everyday (1929). This attention to "hands on" activity within the Film Society was important; it was always the intention of Montagu and the other founding members that the society would act not just in getting non-mainstream films seen in Britain, but in getting them made, in order that British cinema might be technically and artistically advanced. The events noted above suggest that such an advancement (in 1929 at least) was to proceed in the direction of montage, of abstraction, and of filmmaking grounded in modernity. Eisenstein, Pudovkin and other Soviet filmmakers of the time stood as hero-like figures for many British cinéphiles. Films such as Battleship Potemkin (Eisenstein, 1925) and Mother (Pudovkin, 1926) generated discussion of montage as an entirely new and essentially "cinematic" form of filmmaking, and the directors drew large and excited attendances for their lecture visits. Montagu, as head of the Film Society, was responsible for the organisation of study groups involving Eisenstein and Pudovkin, and also for translating Pudovkin's theoretical writing into English, so that they could be of benefit to British filmmakers.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Document File an INDICATIVE ARCHIVE: SALVAGING NAKBA DOCUMENTS
    Special Document File AN INDICATIVE ARCHIVE: SALVAGING NAKBA DOCUMENTS ILAN PAPPÉ This Special Document File examines the closure of documents on the Nakba in the Israeli archives and argues that this closure must be juxtaposed with recent Downloaded from http://online.ucpress.edu/jps/article-pdf/49/3/22/405154/jps_49_3_022.pdf by guest on 17 July 2020 intensified U.S. and Israeli attempts to depoliticize the Palestine question and to delegitimize the Palestinian narrative in general, and that of 1948 in particular. The documents are important because they expose the systematic nature of the 1948 ethnic cleansing of Palestine, both in planning and execution. Many of these documents have been copied and scanned by scholars over the years, but they are now no longer accessible to the public or to researchers. Collating, digitizing, and archiving these documents is the best response to the attempt to cover up the crimes against the Palestinian people in 1948. STARTING IN THE LATE 1980S, a group of Israeli scholars known as the New Historians published several monographs challenging the Israeli/Zionist narrative of the 1948 war that led to the dispossession and expulsion of three-quarters of a million Palestinians and the destruction of more than five hundred villages and localities in what had been Mandate Palestine. Palestinian historians had already written about the Nakba extensively prior to that, but never before had the narrative been substantiated by declassified archival material. The research made possible by such material, which constitutes the main contribution of the New Historians’ historiographical effort, categorically refuted a foundational Israeli propaganda claim that during what Israel calls its “War of Independence,” the Palestinians left their homes voluntarily to make way for the invading Arab armies coming to their rescue, thus becoming refugees by their own hands.
    [Show full text]