Searles Mazzacano Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Who Pollinates? Who Pollinates?
Understanding and sustaining Insect Pollinators insect pollinators in your garden
A. Importance of pollinators
B. Cast of characters
C. Creating habitat Mining bee; CASM
Celeste A. Searles Mazzacano, Ph.D. D. Sustaining habitat Presented for EMSWCD E. Projects & resources
Flower scarab; CASM
© 2016 C. A. Searles Mazzacano yellow-faced bumble bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano 1 2
Why are pollinators important? Why are pollinators important?
• pollination: transfer of pollen • 70% of flowering plants within or between flowers for pollinated by insects fertilization, seed & fruit set • ~1,000 plants grown • wind, insects, birds, mammals worldwide for food, fibers, drinks, spices, & medicine honey bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano pollinated by animals
Bat Conservation International • most pollinated by bees
Importance of bees to food production Bumble bee on echinacea; (Wilson & Carrill, 2016) Wikimedia Commons
3 4 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Who pollinates? Who pollinates?
More than bees!!!!! sand wasp; C.A.S. Mazzacano
More than insects!!!!! • Wasps
• Bats • Flies Tayler/naturepl.com • Hummingbirds • Beetles
• Moths & butterflies
Bee fly; C.A.S. Mazzacano
C.A.S. Mazzacano
5 6
Who pollinates? Who pollinates?
summer leafcutter bee, Bumble bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano “Managed” bees are Crown Bees catalog
Much more than economically important European honey bees!!!!! • honey bees, bumble bees, - native bees (> 4000 NA spp.) orchard mason bees, alfalfa leafcutter bees ‣ social: bumble bees
‣ solitary: mining, mason, leafcutter, orchard, sweat, digger, and carpenter bees
Sweat bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano CA almond grove; Kathy Keatley Garvey
7 8 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Challenges for pollinators Challenges for pollinators
Many stressors • Colony Collapse Disorder (2006) in managed honey • habitat loss bee hives
• pesticides fouldbrood-infected larvae; Univ. of GA • many bumble bees are also declining dead bees; Rodale’s • diseases (viruses, fungi, bacteria) • much less known about status of other wild bees • parasites (varroa mite, tracheal mite)
Varroa mite on bee pupa; Jason Graham, Univ. of FL Franklin’s Bumble Bee; Dana Campbell
9 10
Challenges for pollinators Bees
• managed bees may spread & intensify disease in wild bees
• wild bees pollinate many plants C.A.S. Mazzacano more efficiently C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano than honey bees
C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano
11 12 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Types of flowers pollinated vary
• short- vs. long-tongued bees
• generalist vs. specialist foragers
short-tongued Sphecodes cuckoo sweat bee; Tom Murray
long-tongued Eastern Bumble Bee; sankax, Flickr
13 14
Bees Social vs. solitary bees
Not all bees are pollinators • solitary: each female builds & provisions own nest • nest parasites (cuckoo bees) • social: shared nests, • “nectar robbers” castes with different roles
Coelioxys cuckoo bee; Laura Clark, iNaturalist wild honey bee nest; vickbird
nectar-robbing hole; mining bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano
15 16 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Social vs. solitary bees Social vs. solitary bees
Social (honey bees, bumble bees, Social (honey bees, bumble bees, some sweat bees) some sweat bees)
• several generations at one • members care for offspring C.A.S. Mazzacano time in colony or nest drone & workers; Max Westby, EoL that aren’t theirs
• nest may be perennial (honey • division of labor bee) or annual (bumble bee) (reproduction, hive cleaning, brood care, foraging)
Bumble bee nest; Panoramedia C.A.S. Mazzacano
17 18
Social vs. solitary bees Social vs. solitary bees
Solitary bees (mining bees, Solitary bees (mining bees, mason bees, sweat bees, mason bees, sweat bees, plasterer bees) plasterer bees) • tunnel nesters use existing • one female provisions “cells” interior of Alfalfa leafcutter bee nest board; tunnels in wood or chew USDA ARS in nest where she lays eggs Miner bee on nest; C.A.S. Mazzacano tunnels in pithy twigs • aggregated, communal, • ground nesters dig tunnels semisocial in patches of bare soil
Colletes nest aggregation; bumblebee.org Cellophane bee brood cell;NatureWorks
19 20 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
• Mining bees (Andrenidae) Bumble bees (Bombus) • Polyester & yellow-faced bees (Colletidae) • medium to large; robust, hairy
• Sweat bees (Halictidae) • yellow, black, orange, white, Anthophoridae; C.A.S. Mazzacano • Mason, carder, leaf-cutter bees or brown hair bands C.A.S. Mazzacano (Megachilidae) • carry pollen & nectar mix in stiff • Carpenter, bumble, hairs (scopa) in concave basket honey bees (Apidae) on hind legs (corbiculum)
• Oil-collecting bees (Melittidae) Tri-colored Bumble Bee; Honey bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano themountaincampus, iNat
21 22
Bees Bees
The short-haired bumblebee project
Bumble bees (Bombus)
• generalists on wide range of plants Annual bumble bee colony • buzz pollination Nevada Bumble Bee; Mike Patterson, iNat
Fog-belt Bumble Bee; Cara Fitchett, iNat
23 24 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Perennial Honey bees (Apis mellifera) honey bee colony • medium size; hairy body & eyes
• brown/black with golden bands wild honey bee hive; C.A.S. Mazzacano
• generalists on a queen mates with 12-15 variety of flowers drones
• carry pollen in corbiculae
Honey bee; C.A.S. Mazzacano
25 26
Bees Bees
Long-horned bees (Eucera)
• small to medium
• hairy head & thorax
• face may be yellow; pale hair bands on abdomens
Eucera; Alvesgaspar, Wikimedia Commons • males with very long antennae
27 28 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Long-horned bees (Melissodes) Long-horned bees (Eucera) • small to medium; robust; • generalist foragers hairy head & thorax • carry pollen on lower part Eucera; Biopix, EoL • hairy hind legs; pale hair of hind legs bands on abdomens • solitary ground-nesters; • males have very long brood cells lined with waxy antennae, may have waterproof secretion yellow face
Melissodes; John Baker, iNat
Eucera; Hank Wallays, iNat
29 30
Bees Bees
Long-horned bees (Melissodes) Small carpenter bees (Ceratina)
• prefer sunflower, • small; almost hairless; thick cylindrical abdomen aster, daisy • shiny/metallic black, • carry pollen on blue, green hind legs • may have pale • solitary ground-nesters; markings on face brood cells lined with Melissodes; Laura Jansen Simpson, iNat waxy waterproof secretion
Ceratina; Valter Jacinto, EoL
31 32 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Small carpenter bees (Ceratina) Digger bees (Anthophora)
• generalists • small to large; robust, hairy
• females carry pollen • head & thorax on hind legs densely hairy
• solitary nesters in old wood, • may have pale hair pithy stems (sunflower, bands on abdomen blackberry, elderberry)
Anthophora; Hank Wallays, EoL Ceratina; Valter Jacinto, EoL
33 34
Bees Bees
Digger bees (Anthophora) Metallic green bees (Agapostemon)
• generalists & specialists • medium size
• females carry pollen • bright metallic under hind legs green or blue
• solitary nesters in flat • some with white ground or sloping banks; abdominal bands
Anthophorine bee digging out nest tunnel; line cells with oily secretion C.A.S. Mazzacano
Agapostemon splendens; Sean McCann, EoL
35 36 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Metallic green bees (Agapostemon) Sweat bees (Halictus)
• generalists • medium; black/brown; slightly metallic • females carry pollen on hind legs • pale hair bands on outer portion of each • solitary or communal abdominal segment ground-nesters in deep burrows in flat or sloped soils
Agapostemon odoratissimus; Mary Keim, EoL Halictus fulvipes; Valter Jacinto, EoL
37 38
Bees Bees
Sweat bees (Halictus) Sweat bees (Lasioglossum)
• generalists • similar to Halictus
• females carry pollen • pale hair bands on hind legs at base of each abdominal segment • ground-nesters in loose soils; cells lined with waxy secretion
Halictus rubicundus; Stanislav Krejcik, EoL
Lasioglossum; Steven Miodinow, EoL
39 40 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees Mining bees (Andrena) Sweat bees (Lasioglossum) • small to medium; black, • generalists dull metallic blue/green, gray, brown, red • females carry pollen on hind legs • may have pale bands on abdomen • ground-nesters in loose soils; cells lined with waxy secretion • females with patch Lasioglossum; BioImages, EoL of velvety hairs between eyes
Andrena; CASM
41 42
Bees Bees
Mining bees (Andrena) Carder bees (Anthidium)
• generalists & specialists • small to medium
• females carry pollen • moderately hairy on hind legs head & thorax
• solitary ground-nesters, • black body with often in large aggregations incomplete yellow Andrena; Valter Jacinto, EoL bands on abdomen
Anthidium; Anita Gould, iNaturalist
43 44 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Bees
Carder bees (Anthidium) Leafcutter bees (Megachile)
• generalists & specialists • medium to large; stocky dark body • females carry pollen beneath abdomen • flattened abdomen with pale hair bands • solitary nesters in existing tunnels in • big serrated mandibles soil, wood, stems
Anthidium; Miroslav Deml, EoL
Megachile periharta; Ken Schneider, iNaturalist
45 46
Bees Bees
Leafcutter bees (Megachile) Mason bees (Osmia) • generalists & specialists Megachile periharta; North Thurston HS Science Club, BugGuide.net • small to medium; • females carry pollen metallic blue/green beneath abdomen • round broad head • solitary nesters in and abdomen crevices in rock or wood, pithy stems, beetle tunnels
Osmia ribifloris; USDA
47 48 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Bees Wasps
Mason bees (Osmia) Pollen wasps (Pseudomasaris) • generalists, some specialists; commonly visit Rose family • black or brown; yellow, white or red bands; • females carry pollen • clubbed antennae under abdomen Osmia lignaria; USDA
• • solitary nesters in cavities in generalists; prefer pithy stems, rocks, plant galls, pollen from waterleaf beetle tunnels, old bee nests & figwort families
Pseudomasaris coquilletti; Mathesont
Osmia rufa in nesting tube; BioImages
49 50
Wasps Flies
Flower flies Pollen wasps (Pseudomasaris) • bare or fuzzy • only wasps that feed young on nectar & • bee & wasp mimics pollen, collected in internal crop • characteristic hovering darting flight • solitary nesters
Thomas Bresson
Pseudomasaris vespoides; Hartmut Wisch
51 52 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Flies Flies
Flower flies Helophilis syrphid; C.A.S. Mazzacano Bee flies • adults eat nectar, pollen, honeydew • hairy, brightly-colored bumble bee mimics • larvae prey on aphids • wings may have dark Villa bee fly; C.A.S. Mazzacano markings, stick out sideways when perched
Toxomerus syrphid; MJ Hatfield Sinuous bee fly; Sam Kieschnick
53 54
Flies Beetles
Bee flies Soldier Beetles
• adults eat nectar, honeydew, pollen • long body, soft wing covers, long antennae • larvae mostly external parasitoids of soil- • yellow/orange & Podabrus Soldier Beetle; vncdatatech01 dwelling insect larvae black markings
Chrysanthrax cypris; Royal Tyler Podabrus tricostatus; Robert L. Curtis, iNat
55 56 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Beetles Beetles
Soldier Beetles Longhorned Beetles • adults eat nectar, pollen, and other insects • large, oblong body
Margined Leatherwing; David Hebert • • very long antennae prefer sunflower, Banded Alder Borer; C.A.S. Mazzacano coneflower, goldenrod • often bright colors/patterns • velvety larvae prey on insect eggs & larvae
Cantharis larva; Stanislav Krejcik
Locust Borer; Patrick Coin
57 58
Beetles Beetles
Blister Beetles Blister Beetles
• medium to large; dark, • adults feed on nectar, elongated,cylindrical body pollen, esp. aster, pea,
Black Blister Beetle; & sunflower families Bruce Marlin, EoL • some with bright warning colors • larvae parasitic on ground-nesting bees Meloe strigulosus; C.A.S. Mazzacano • wing cases rolled over abdomen
Red-eared Blister Beeetle; Ken-ichi Uchida Blister Beetle; Patrick Coin
59 60 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Beetles Beetles
Flower Scarabs Flower Scarabs
• medium to large; broad, • adults feed on pollen slightly flattened body Kern’s Flower Scarab; C.A.S. Mazzacano • larvae feed on roots, organic • flower scarabs often mater in soil, decaying wood brightly colored, bee mimics Texas Flower Scarab; vadalton, iNaturalist • antennae end in club made of small plates
Delta Flower Scarab; Patrick Coin, EoL Bumble Flower Beetle; C.A.S. Mazzacano
61 62
Beetles Beetles
Checkered Beetle Checkered Beetle • small to medium • adults & larvae prey on bark • long, narrow, hairy body beetles, weevils, wood-boring insects Ornate Checkered Beetle; • often patterned in red, Ken-ichi Ueda, iNaturalist yellow, orange, or blue • adults of some species Enoclerus eximius; CASM eat pollen
European Red-bellied Clerid; Jürgen Mangelsdorf, iNaturalist
63 64 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Beetles Beetles
Soft-winged Flower Beetle Soft-winged Flower Beetle
• small; dark hairy body • adults eat flower-visiting insects and pollen • bright red/orange markings Endeodes collaris; C.A.S. Mazzacano Scarlet Malachite Beetle; Jason Michael Crockwell, iNaturalist • larvae are predators in soil, • some have inflatable sacs leaf litter, under bark along abdomen
Four-spotted Collops; Ken-ichi Ueda, iNaturalist Anthocomus; oldbilluk, iNaturalist
65 66
Beetles Beetles
Tumbling Flower Beetle Tumbling Flower Beetle
• small, humpbacked, • adults are predators, wedge-shaped body also eat pollen
Hoshihananomia perlata; • pointy abdomen not Stanislav Ktejcik, EoL • prefer composite flowers covered by wings • larvae in decaying wood, • dark, hairy, some plant stems, fungi
Falsomordellistena hebraica; with light spots or bands Katja Schulz, iNaturalist
Mordellistena comata; kimberlietx, iNaturalist
67 68 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Moths & Butterflies Moths & Butterflies
Butterflies Butterflies
• thin antennae with • long straw-like proboscis club or hook at tip to feed on nectar
Western Pine Elfin; C.A.S. Mazzacano • day-flying • visit variety of flowers Queen butterfly; C.A.S. Mazzacano
• wings held vertically • not specialized to collect when perched or transfer pollen
Red-spotted Purple; C.A.S. Mazzacano Zabulon Skipper; C.A.S. Mazzacano
69 70
Moths & Butterflies Moths & Butterflies
Moths Moths • feathery antennae • can be important • often night-flying pollinators of night- blooming plants • wings held rooflike White-banded Black Moth; C.A.S. Mazzacano Primrose Moth; Susan Elliott or flat against surface • Yucca and Primrose when perched moths highly specialized
LeConte’s Haploa; C.A.S. Mazzacano Yucca Moth; Ann Cooper
71 72 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Moths & Butterflies Creating habitat
Moths
• hawk moths, owlets, underwings, geometers, many others
White-lined Sphinx; Mary Keim
Blinded Sphinx; C.A.S. Mazzacano
Grapevine Epimenis; Xestia mustelina; C.A.S. Mazzacano Portland OR; C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano
73 74
Planting for pollinators Planting for pollinators
Bees • Nectar & pollen sources • purple, yellow, orange - diverse flowers; often sweet scent - long bloom time • may reflect UV light
- native plants Flower Fly; Pat Reed • can have nectar guides - species groupings
• landing platform Foxglove; C.A.S. Mazzacano - low & tall plants
Sweat bees swarming red osier dogwood; C.A.S. Mazzacano Small-flowered penstemon; Paul Noll
75 76 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Planting for pollinators Planting for pollinators
Bees Bees
• different flowers for short- • different flowers for short- vs. long-tongued bees vs. long-tongued bees
- small, short-tongued - long-tongued bees can Phlox; C.A.S. Mazzacano access tubular flowers bees prefer clusters of Penstemon; C.A.S. Mazzacano tiny flowers (herbs, (penstemon, foxglove) daisy, marigold, phlox
English thyme; milkandhoneyherbs Grand Collomia; Mark Turner
77 78
Planting for pollinators Planting for pollinators
Tachninid on catmint; Beatriz Moisset, USDA Beetles Flies • dull white, green, or • small shallow flowers reddish flowers; can smell fruity, spicy, or bad • drab; pale or brown/purple
• open bowl shape; Prickly Poppy; CASM • bad odor may lack nectar • red trillium, elderberry, • magnolia, aster, sunflower, skunk cabbage rose, goldenrod, Spirea
Magnolia; Red trillium; USDA Plants Portland Nursery
79 80 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Planting for pollinators Planting for pollinators
Butterflies Clearwing on Blazing Star; Moths TG Barnes, Univ. of KY • composite flowers • white or pale flowers in clusters • orange, yellow, pink, blue
• open late afternoon or night • perching Blanketflower; C.A.S. Mazzacano platform • strong sweet smell • light scent • honeysuckle, Showy Milkweed; C.A.S. Mazzacano primrose • honeysuckle, lily, sages, trumpet flower
Funereal Duskywing; C.A.S. Mazzacano Joshua Tree; Marisa Anderson, USDA
81 82
Beyond the bloom Beyond the bloom
Western Tiger Swallowtails “puddling” for minerals; C.A.S. Mazzacano • • water & nutrients shelter & nesting sites
- dead snags (mason & - safe access for small insects leafcutter bees)
- rotting logs (sweat - “puddling” sources for butterflies bees, flower flies)
- old rodent burrows • sun (bumble bees)
standing dead tree; C.A.S. Mazzacano
83 84 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Beyond the bloom Beyond the bloom • shelter & nesting sites • Nesting & egg-laying sites - rock & brush piles - bare soil (miner bees) (beetles, caterpillars, pupae) - snags (leafcutter & brush pile; C.A.S. Mazzacano mason bees) - undisturbed soil Miner bees; C.A.S. Mazzacano (ground-nesting bees, - grass tussocks, brush beetle & fly larvae) piles (bumble bees)
- grass clumps (nesting - bee blocks & & overwintering) stem bundles
Leafcutting bees in block; fescue; C.A.S. Mazzacano Kathy Keatley Garvey/UC Davis
Flower Fly; Pat Reed 85 86
Sustaining habitat Sustaining habitat
Integrated pest management (IPM): • Reduce/eliminate pesticides • ecosystem-based strategy - disrupt natural enemies • long-term prevention of pests/damage using multiple techniques - pests faster to disperse & re-colonize treated areas - biological control, habitat manipulation, than natural enemies modification of cultural practices, use of resistant varieties
Oleander aphids on rush milkweed; - preserves natural system as much as possible C.A.S. Mazzacano
87 88 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Sustaining habitat Creating & maintaining habitat
• Reduce/eliminate pesticides Oleander aphids on rush milkweed; • use pesticides use only after C.A.S. Mazzacano monitoring indicates need - removing natural enemies may allow secondary • treat with goal of removing pests to establish target organism only
- non-lethal levels can • select & apply to minimize impair reproduction, risks to human health, foraging nontarget organisms, & environment Oleander aphids on rush milkweed; C.A.S. Mazzacano
89 90
Sustaining habitat Sustaining habitat
• build healthy soil • tolerate a certain level of damage
• proper plant • use multiple placement & irrigation compatible methods
• plant mostly natives Cluster Rose; C.A.S. Mazzacano • if pesticides necessary, select most suitable, • “scout” your gardens timely, selective, least toxic to non-targets
Oregon grape; C.A.S. Mazzacano
Black Twinberry; C.A.S. Mazzacano
91 92 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Resources Resources
Encyclopedia of Life
Great Sunflower Project
93 94
Resources Resources
http://www.fs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/ stelprdb5306468.pdf
www.oregon.gov/ODA
free entomology.oregonstate.edu
$3.99
95 96 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016 Projects
greatsunflower.org
Visit emswcd.org to find additional workshops and resources!
bumblebeewatch.org
97 98
Questions? Celeste A. Searles Mazzacano, [email protected]
Yellow-faced Bumble Bee; Netwinged Beetle, C.A.S. Mazzacano C.A.S. Mazzacano
Flower scarabs; C.A.S. Mazzacano Western Swallowtail, C.A.S. Mazzacano
Copyright © 2016 Celeste A. Searles Mazzacano. All rights reserved. This presentation or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or used in any manner whatsoever without the express written permission of the author.
99 Searles Mazzacano_Pollinators - September 12, 2016