Use of Near-Infrared Spectroscopy to Determine the Composition of High-Density/Low-Density Polyethylene Blend Films
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Haverford College: Haverford Scholarship Haverford College Haverford Scholarship Faculty Publications Chemistry 1993 Use of Near-Infrared Spectroscopy to Determine the Composition of High-Density/Low-Density Polyethylene Blend Films Charles E. Miller Haverford College Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.haverford.edu/chemistry_facpubs Repository Citation Miller, Charles E. "Use of near-infrared spectroscopy to determine the composition of high-density/low- density polyethylene blend films." Applied spectroscopy 47.2 (1993): 222-228. This Journal Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Chemistry at Haverford Scholarship. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of Haverford Scholarship. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Use of Near-Infrared Spectroscopy to Determine the Composition of High-Density/Low-Density Polyethylene Blend Films CHARLES E. MILLER* MATFORSK, Norwegian Food Research Institute, Osloveien 1, N-1430 As Norway The ability of near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy,combined with principal efficient quality assessment and process control for such component regression (PCR), to nondestructively determine the blend films requires the frequent, and preferably nondestruc- ratio of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and low-density polyethylene tive, determination of the relative amounts of HDPE and (LDPE) in extruded films is demonstrated. Results indicate that the NIR LDPE. FT-IR reflectance and transmission spectroscopy7 spectrum in the region 2100 to 2500 nm can be used to determine the can be used to perform such thin film analyses. However, HDPE mass percentage of 60-80-~m-thick film samples to within 2.5%, over a range of 0 to 100%. NIR spectral effects from scattering are because of the high absorptivities of IR bands, the film important for the determination of the HDPE % for HDPE contents thickness must often be limited (up to approximately 50 above 50%, and spectral effects from changes in the methyl group con- t~m, depending on the specific IR bands used for the centration and perhaps the PE crystallinity are important for the de- analysis) in order to perform an accurate quantitative termination of the HDPE % for HDPE contents below 50%. In addition, analysis. Other IR methods, such as attenuated-total- a large variation between the spectra of replicate samples, probably reflectance (ATR) s and photoacoustic 9,1° methods, can caused by variations in the degree or direction of molecular orientation provide IR spectra of optically thick materials, because in the samples, was observed. they sample only a very thin layer at the surface of a Index Headings: Near-infrared; Polyethylene; Principal components re- material. However, it is important to note that the ef- gression. fective pathlength (or sampling depth) for the ATR and photoacoustic methods depends on the refractive index INTRODUCTION and thermal diffusivity of the material, respectively. Polyethylene (PE) is the major component of many Therefore, the use of these techniques for the quanti- food packaging products, including laminates, bags, and tative analysis of nonhomogeneous materials, such as bottles. PE possesses the mechanical, optical, water-va- multi-layer laminate films, can be difficult. por-resistance, and heat-sealing properties that are very If the optical thickness of a film sample is too large useful for food packaging applications, t-3 for FT-IR transmission analysis, then spectroscopy in Although a PE molecule could be simply thought of the near-infrared (NIR) region can also be used for quan- as a long chain of connected ethylene units, real poly- titative analysis. 11,12 Because NIR bands have lower ab- ethylene polymers contain a significant number of side sorptivities than IR bands, thicker and more highly scat- branches that are attached to the main polymer chains. tering films can be sampled by NIR transmission than Two commonly used types of PE, high-density polyeth- by IR transmission. In addition, the use of transmission ylene (HDPE) and low-density polyethylene (LDPE), spectroscopy for quantitative analysis can be accurately refer to PE polymers that have relatively low and high implemented through the Beer-Lambert law. Further- degrees of branching, respectively. The amount of more, NIR spectroscopy is easily adaptable to optical branching significantly affects the morphological prop- fibers, 13,14 which enable remote sampling for process or erties of PE, 4,5 which in turn affects optical, physical, and quality control analyses. Earlier works ls-17 have shown thermal properties. Therefore, HDPE and LDPE have the usefulness of NIR spectroscopy for the nondestruc- significantly different quality properties with respect to tive and noninvasive quality control of multi-layer lam- food packaging applications. inate films. Recently, the strategy for preparation of polymeric The purpose of this work is to assess the ability of NIR materials for specific applications has focused on the spectroscopy to determine the percentage of HDPE in blending of easily obtainable polymers. In the case of blend films of HDPE and LDPE. PE, studies have shown that the blending of HDPE and LDPE can result in materials that have morphological EXPERIMENTAL properties that are intermediate between those of pure Materials. Melt-extruded blend films of HDPE and HDPE and LDPE. 4,6 As a result, a special polyethylene LDPE at seven different blend ratios (0, 2.5, 5, 10, 25, with a specific quality can, in many cases, be prepared 50, and 100% HDPE) were provided by STAT-OIL by simply blending two readily available PE materials. (Stathelle, Norway). For each of the seven different blend For food packaging laminate applications, PE blends ratios, HDPE pellets (STAT-OIL H930, M. = 35,000, are commonly extruded into a thin film. Effective and Mw = 223,000, CHJl000C = 5) and LDPE pellets (STAT- OIL L412, M. = 29,900, Mw = 215,000, CH3/1000C = 27) Received 1 October 1992. were weighed and mechanically mixed before extrusion. * Present address: DuPont Polymers, Industrial Polymers Research, Films were then prepared with a circular-die extruder P.O. Box 1089, Building 10, Orange, TX 77631-1089. (Windm511er and HSlscher, Varex 60.30D), with a 200- 222 Volume 47, Number 2, 1993 0o03-7028/93/4702-022252.0o/o APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY © 1993 Society for Applied Spectroscopy 100% proximately 45 ° (about the axis of the incident NIR light beam) and another scan was obtained; and two additional scans of the sample, rotated approximately 90 ° and 135 ° from its original position, were then obtained. Data Analysis. Multiplicative scatter-correction 5O% (MSC) TM was applied to the NIR spectra before multi- variate modeling. The MSC-corrected spectra of the samples, and the known percentages of HDPE used in the different extrusions, were used to construct a prin- : 25% , cipal component regression (PCR) (Unscrambler, CAMO A/S, Trondheim, Norway) calibration model that sub- sequently enables the prediction of the HDPE percent- age of a PE film sample from its NIR spectrum. The 10% calibration error (RMSEE) was determined as the root- validation mean-square of the differences between the known HDPE set 1 % values and the HDPE % values that were estimated validation from the PCR model. Cross-validation was used to estimate both the pre- 5% set 2 diction error and the optimal number of factors to be used in the PCR model. This procedure involved the removal of validation samples from the original set of samples, the construction of PCR models (that use dif- 2.5% ferent numbers of factors) from the remaining samples, m _ and the use of these models to estimate the HDPE per- centage values for the removed samples. The prediction error (RMSEP), for each number of factors, was esti- 0% mated as the root-mean-square of the differences be- tween the known HDPE percentages and estimated Fic. 1. Designof HDPE/LDPE blend film samples used for calibra- HDPE percentages, for the removed samples only. The tion, indicating the selectionof the two cross-validationprediction sets. optimal number of factors in the PCR model was deter- Percentages refer to HDPE %. mined as the number at which the addition of another factor did not greatly decrease the RMSEP. Two sepa- mm-diameter die and 1.2-mm die gap. The melt tem- rate cross-validation analyses were done, and the re- perature and pressure depended on the blend ratio, and ported RMSEP is simply the average of the individual varied between 215 and 231°C and 174 and 278 bar, re- values obtained from the two cross-validation analyses. spectively. The blow-up ratio was 2.85 for all extrusions. Figure 1 shows the sample selection for the two cross- After extrusion, the films were allowed to relax for 24 h validation analyses. before cutting. For each blend ratio, about 10 to 20 in- It was found that the first two principal components dividual pieces were cut at various points along the ex- obtained from the PCR calibration model had to be ro- truded film. The resulting film pieces were approxi- tated to enable better interpretation of the model. This mately 30 cm x 30 cm and 25 to 40 ~m thick. Observation rotation was done as described in other referencesJ649 of the films under polarized visible light indicated that with the use of a LOTUS-123 spreadsheet routine. It they were highly oriented. should also be noted that one of the five 0% HDPE Spectroscopy. Five replicate NIR samples were pre- samples was removed from the analysis, because the error pared for each HDPE percentage. Because 25 to 40 um of its PCR-estimated HDPE % value was found to be is much less than the optimal sample thickness for NIR unusually large. spectroscopy, each sample used in this analysis was in For the sample rotation study, the NIR spectra were fact a "double-layer" of two 25- to 40-#m-thick pieces first corrected by the MSC method and then analyzed (where the two layers were obtained from two adjacently by principal component analysis 2° (Unscrambler, CAMO extruded pieces).