La Parole Filmée in Rithy Panh's the Missing Picture

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

La Parole Filmée in Rithy Panh's the Missing Picture MEDIATION AND REMEDIATION: LA PAROLE FILMÉE IN RITHY PANH’S THE MISSING PICTURE (L’IMAGE MANQUANTE) Leshu Torchin The Missing Picture, where any production of memory can both preserve and veil lives. In L’image manquante (The Missing Picture, 2013), Rithy video footage, and painted clay figurines in stunningly Panh continues his exploration of the Cambodian genocide crafted—often multimedia—dioramas, the documentary in a manner that is both harrowing and lyrical, carrying on integrates Panh’s personal story with ruminations on media- the innovations he brought to his earlier films on the subject. tion, trauma, and history. Furthermore, the film reaches Combining Khmer Rouge propaganda films, contemporary beyond individual narrative and reflection, functioning as cinematic witness as it counters silences, fills historical gaps, Film Quarterly, Vol. 68, Number 1, pp. 32–41, ISSN 0015-1386, electronic ISSN 1533-8630. and provides a testimony that is polyphonic and collective. © 2014 by The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Please direct all requests for permission to photocopy or reproduce article content through Through his deployment of clips from his earlier films, the University of California Press’s Rights and Permissions website, http://www. Panh creates a sedimented text, suggestive of a past that ucpressjournals.com/reprintinfo.asp. DOI: 10.1525/FQ.2014.68.1.32. refuses to remain passed and of the magnitude of history, 32 FALL 2014 where any production of memory can both preserve and veil Rouge leaders to trial. Kaing Guek Eav, the commander of the lives of others. the S-21 prison, who was a subject of Panh’s film Duch, le Panh begins his story with the words, “In the middle of maître des forges de l’enfer (Duch, Master of the Forges of life, childhood returns,” as a camera bobs in the crashing Hell, 2011), was sentenced in 2010. And in August 2014, waves, submerging and resurfacing. This opening is a fitting Khmer Rouge leaders Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan parallel to the epigraph in Primo Levi’s crucial book on the were found guilty of being part of a “joint criminal enter- challenges and necessity of bearing witness to the Holocaust, prise” responsible for a “widespread and systematic attack The Drowned and the Saved. Taken from Samuel Taylor against the civilian population of Cambodia.” The charges of 3 Coleridge’s “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner,” it reads: genocide are yet to be tried. Meanwhile, the international community was slow to rec- Since then, at an uncertain hour ognize genocide, not only then, but in the aftermath, right up That Agony returns until the 1990s. The Khmer Rouge’s social reform policies de- And till my ghastly tale is told ployed forced labor, incarceration, torture, and executions, but This heart within me burns the nature of its victim groups seemed to confuse many. The Panh’s childhood is not simply invoked as a time of innocence, murderous campaign targeted Vietnamese and Chinese mi- a time fondly recalled in middle age, for it is also a ghastly tale norities as well as religious minorities: Muslims, Christians, and that must be shared, a traumatic memory that comes unbid- Buddhists. However, their ideology also dictated a purge along den. The Missing Picture becomes a testimony of suffering, social and class axes, meaning teachers, students, artists, intel- his own, his family’s, and Cambodia’s, which he imparts to the lectuals, and the professional classes of doctors and lawyers. Its viewer. This urgency for telling also finds a resonance in basis in political ideology as much as (if not more than) ethnic Levi’s book, wherein he cites Simon Wiesenthal’s recollection differencehasledsometotermthisan“autogenocide,” as if of the concentration camp guards and their taunts to the not all genocides were, in essence, just that, and as if such dis- 4 prisoners: tinctions don’t risk reifying ethnic differences. Although measures of transitional justice and international However this war may end, we have won the war criminal tribunals can be constrained, they nonetheless func- against you; none of you will be left to bear witness, but tion as means for redressing histories and giving voices to vic- even if someone were to survive, the world will not be- lieve him . we will destroy the evidence together with tims. Arthur and Joan Kleinman have observed that official you. We will be the ones to dictate the history of the silences around suffering contribute to a culture of terror, and Lagers [concentration camps].1 that in such contexts, “public witnessing . forges . an act of political resistance through keeping alive the memory of 5 This threat was practically realized in the case of the Cam- things denied.” bodian genocide, where indifference and silence have domi- On an official level, public processes forge official memory nated. Despite the existence of the Genocide Convention, through the use of testimony, that first-person narration of ’ there was no intervention into the Khmer Rouge s brutal re- suffering which harbors transformative potential. Often asso- ’ gime. Vietnam s invasion (which put an end to the camps) ciated with the courtroom, where one bears witness to the had more to do with tactical maneuvers than commitment to truth of an event in order to bring about justice, the term has human rights; the Khmer Rouge were allied with the Viet- been extended to additional venues and possibilities. Shoshana nam People’s Army of North Vietnam. Delay in due process Felman and Dori Laub have advanced testimony as a speech resulted in impunity for the perpetrators, many of whom act that both facilitates the recovery of an experience and a lived side by side with victims in the years to come. In the af- personal narrative and fosters an ethical community of re- 6 termath the Vietnamese occupiers held some trials, but these sponsibility between speaker and listener. Its political impli- were designed more to impugn the United States and China cations have been elaborated in the Latin American genre than to achieve justice or restore the historical record to the of testimonio where injustice is recorded and expressed in or- Cambodian survivors. Indeed, Cambodia’s UN seat remained der to restore a history that has been denied or buried, as well the purview of the Khmer Rouge for years afterward. as in numerous human rights films which rely on practices 7 It was only in 1997 that Pol Pot received a trial in absentia and tropes of witnessing and bearing witness. In such con- 2 (and not even for genocide) after twenty years of inaction. texts, testimony offers a means of uniting and rebuilding com- Since then, a joint process of the Cambodian government munities, reinforcing their relationship to the past and to their and the UN has brought a handful of the remaining Khmer lands, while trials that include testimony can provide public FILM QUARTERLY 33 Silences and suffering are remediated in The Missing Picture. performances that wrest control over history from the perpe- seemingly forgotten. Fingers manipulate one of the strips, trators and restore it to the victims. as if to try to animate the dancers on the celluloid. A cut to In the absence of such processes, or in conjunction with footage of a dancer—albeit not the one on the strip—points to them, film assumes that testimonial function. The Missing Pic- Panh’s cinematic efforts at recuperation and reconstruction, as ture is based in great part on Rithy Panh’s own experiences as a he acknowledges and integrates the multiple losses of culture, teenager during the genocide, during which he lost his family human life, and all their material traces. and was put to work in a labor camp. This is not a story re- Other strategies bolster the film’s function as storyteller of lated through an easy flashback of voiceover and archival foot- compounded absences and persistent damage. Panh deploys age. It is told more as recollection and struggle—as pursuit of Khmer Rouge propaganda footage in the exposition of a past, a missing image. The voiceover (and the promotional materi- but does not give it authority as the voiceover scans for evi- als) describe this image as a photograph taken by the Khmer dence of the harm not seen, and tells stories of what took place Rouge sometime between 1975 and 1979 that could act as offscreen and behind the camera. For his personal story, there 8 proof of this heinous crime. However, the broader aims seem are few, if any, photographic images. Clay figurines are ar- to be the recollection of all missing images: the Cambodia that ranged in elaborate dioramas that remind the viewer of what once was, the stories of the victim, and the childhood of Panh can no longer be accessed but which must be recreated if its himself. The opening images of the film suggest this to be a story is to be told. These scenes move back and forth between daunting if not insurmountable task as stacks of film canisters, life before the camps and life in the camps, both medium and rusted and piled haphazardly, appear on screen. Film spills out shifting temporalities gesturing to the elusiveness of memory of these and also lies in curled heaps on the floor, dusty and and the necessity of its preservation and transmission. The 34 FALL 2014 Clay figurines recreate events from Panh’s past in The Missing Picture. close of the film returns to the surf, where the voiceover ex- by the same words. “Tospare you is no profit; to destroy you 11 plains that with nothing left of the events, Panh has made this is no loss” reads one popular refrain.
Recommended publications
  • Recovering Life After Social Death in Post-Genocide Cambodia
    - The UNESCO Slave Route Project: Healing the Wounds of Slavery - Life After/Ward: Recovering Life After Social Death in Post-Genocide Cambodia Khatharya Um That which wounds me has no name- Rithy Panh1 1 Rithy Panh and Christophe Bataille, The Elimination (New York: Other Press, 2013), 4 - Life After/Ward: Recovering Life After Social Death in Post-Genocide Cambodia - Introduction When asked if he ever dreams of his tortured victims, Kaing Guek Eav, better known by his nom de guerre “Duch,” who oversaw the Tuol Sleng S-21 extermination center where at least 12,000 people were tortured and killed, said unequivocally: “No. Never.”2 The survivors of the genocidal regime of which he was a leading figure, however, are not afforded that luxury. Over four decades in the aftermath, in Cambodia and in the diaspora, genocidal haunting continues to torment not only the survivors but also the postgenocide generations. In commemoration of the 45th anniversary of the Khmer Rouge genocide during which almost a quarter of the country’s population perished in less than four years, this paper reflects on the afterlife of genocide. It illuminates the ways in which genocidal haunting continues to unfold in the postgenocide everyday, and the struggles of Cambodians to make meaning of, and work through, this historical trauma. Attentive to the gaps and tensions between state rhetoric and survivors’ agency, it interrogates the possibilities and limits of international tribunals in delivering justice, reconciliation and, above all, healing in the genocide aftermath, and reflects on acts of repair, big and small, public and private, that individuals and communities have undertaken to transcend, if not heal, this collective wounding.
    [Show full text]
  • Stephanie Cong an Examination of Forced Marriages and Their Impact Under the Khmer Rouge SEA10A 2016 Prof. Penelope Edwards & GSI Uyen 12/16/2016
    Stephanie Cong An Examination of Forced Marriages and their Impact Under the Khmer Rouge SEA10A 2016 Prof. Penelope Edwards & GSI Uyen 12/16/2016 I. Introduction In 1975, the Khmer Rouge, also known as the Communist Party of Kampuchea, seized power in Cambodia.1 The Khmer Rouge attempted to transform Cambodia into a classless society — they abolished basic institutions from schools to churches, and replaced these with farms, prisons, and education camps.2 Civilians were forced to move from their homes to participate in agricultural work, and many died during this process.3 The Khmer Rouge also removed concepts such as money and free markets, and furthermore, discouraged the display of affection, humor, or pity, even through familial relations — the party wanted full obedience and respect towards Angkar, a name the party used to refer to itself.4 Because of this, the Khmer Rouge put forced marriage into practice, and also used this as a method to grow the population, their potential workforce.5 Nearly a quarter of Cambodian citizens were forced into marriages under Khmer Rouge, and these marriages had many adverse effects on civilians.6 Through this paper, I will show that forced marriages led to abnormal and abusive dynamics between husband and wife, forced pregnancy and rape, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), and shame or the inability to remarry. These effects of forced marriages have lasted long beyond the regime of the Khmer Rouge, and these actions are now being tried as crimes against humanity.7 In order to show these adverse effects of forced marriages within the Khmer Rouge regime, the paper will be broken down into seven sections.
    [Show full text]
  • Delegates Guide
    Delegates Guide 15–20 March, 2019 Cultural Partners Supported by Friends of Qumra Media Partners Cover: ‘Six Months and One Day’, directed by Yassine Ouahrani 1 QUMRA DELEGATES GUIDE Qumra Programming Team 5 Qumra Masters 7 Master Class Moderators 13 Qumra Project Delegates 15 Industry Delegates 63 QUMRA PROGRAMMING TEAM Fatma Al Remaihi CEO, Doha Film Institute Director, Qumra Aya Al-Blouchi Quay Chu Anthea Devotta Mayar Hamdan Qumra Master Classes Development Qumra Industry Senior Qumra Shorts Coordinator Senior Coordinator Executive Coordinator Development Assistant Youth Programmes Senior Film Workshops & Labs Coordinator Senior Coordinator Elia Suleiman Artistic Advisor, Doha Film Institute Yassmine Hammoudi Karem Kamel Maryam Essa Al Khulaifi Meriem Mesraoua Qumra Industry Qumra Talks Senior Qumra Pass Senior Grants Senior Coordinator Coordinator Coordinator Coordinator Film Programming Senior QFF Programme Manager Hanaa Issa Coordinator Animation Producer Director of Strategy and Development Deputy Director, Qumra Vanessa Paradis Majid Al-Remaihi Nina Rodriguez Alanoud Al Saiari Grants Coordinator Film Programming Qumra Industry Senior Qumra Pass Coordinator Assistant Coordinator Film Workshops & Labs Coordinator Wesam Said Rawda Al-Thani Jana Wehbe Ania Wojtowicz Grants Coordinator Film Programming Qumra Industry Senior Qumra Shorts Coordinator Assistant Coordinator Film Workshops & Labs Senior Coordinator Khalil Benkirane Ali Khechen Jovan Marjanović Head of Grants Qumra Industry Industry Advisor Manager Film Training Senior Manager 4 5 Qumra Masters Eugenio Caballero Kiyoshi Kurosawa In 2015 and 2016 he worked on the film ‘A at Cannes in 2003, ‘Doppelganger’ (2002), Monster Calls’, directed by J.A. Bayona, ‘Loft’ (2005), and ‘Retribution’ (2006), which earning him a Goya on his third nomination screened at that year’s Venice Film Festival.
    [Show full text]
  • Rithy Panh” Arranging with the Notice Numbers *Note
    Bophana Audiovisual Resource Center Archives Department Collection of “Rithy Panh” Arranging with the notice numbers *Note: You cannot click the title to entry the Bophana Center database due to the Center using intranet. All right reserved by Bophana Center Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference Cambodia : between war and peace French, Khmer 1992 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000296 01:05:15 Bophana : a cambodian tragedy French, English, Khmer 1996 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000297 00:59:00 Spotlights on a massacre: 10 films against 100 million antipersonnel land French, English, Khmer, Deutsch/ Allemande 1997 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000298 00:04:47 mines 1 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference S21: The Khmer Rouge Death Machine French, English, Khmer 2002 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000299 01:40:52 The land of the wandering souls French, English, Khmer 1999 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000300 01:42:41 Let the boat break its back, Let the junk French, French 2000 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000870 01:34:06 break open The Tan's Family French, Khmer 1995 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_000871 00:31:56 [Rice People] French, English, Khmer, Deutsch/ Allemande, Italian 1994 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_001607 02:04:33 Site 2 French, English, Khmer 1989 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_001191 01:31:21 2 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference The Burnt Theatre French, English, Khmer 2005 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_001231 01:23:20 Paper cannot wrap up embers French, English, Khmer 2006 Rithy Panh RPA_VI_001437 01:27:03 The people of Angkor French, English,
    [Show full text]
  • John Vink” Arranging with the Notice Numbers *Note
    Bophana Audiovisual Resource Center Archives Department Collection of “John Vink” Arranging with the notice numbers *Note: You cannot click the title to entry the Bophana Center database due to the Center using intranet. All right reserved by Bophana Center Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference [Cambodia 1989-2003] 1989-2003 John Vink VIN_IF_001930 Cambodian Elections 2003 2003 John Vink VIN_IF_001936 [Audiovisual Production] 1999-2002 John Vink VIN_IF_001938 1 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference [Angkor Temples] 1989-1991 John Vink VIN_IF_001939 [Being 20 years old in Phnom Penh] 1999-2002 John Vink VIN_IF_001940 [Series of Buddhism] 1989-2002 John Vink VIN_IF_001941 [Khmer Boxing Fever 1/3] 1999-2003 John Vink VIN_IF_001942 [Khmer Boxing Fever 2/3] 2004-2005 John Vink VIN_IF_001943 [Khmer Boxing Fever 3 sur 3] 2005 John Vink VIN_IF_001944 [Cambodian trafic] 1989-2002 John Vink VIN_IF_001946 [Series of dances] 1989-2000 John Vink VIN_IF_001947 2 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference [Sports and leisure] 1989-2002 John Vink VIN_IF_001948 [Series of weddings] 1989-2003 John Vink VIN_IF_001949 [Khmer refugees 1 in 2] 1989 John Vink VIN_IF_001950 [Khmer refugees 2 in 2] 1989-1991 John Vink VIN_IF_001951 [Series of health] 1989-1999 John Vink VIN_IF_001952 [Cambodian School Children] 1989-2000 John Vink VIN_IF_001953 [Series of Takeo] 1989-2003 John Vink VIN_IF_001954 [Boats Competition in Tonle Sap River] 1989-2004 John Vink VIN_IF_001955 3 Archive
    [Show full text]
  • A Requiem for Cambodia Premieres in the US 40 Years Since the Cambodian Genocide Powerful New Work by Rithy PANH and HIM Sophy, Featuring Music, Visuals, And
    Bangsokol: A Requiem for Cambodia premieres in the US 40 years since the Cambodian genocide Powerful new work by Rithy PANH and HIM Sophy, featuring music, visuals, and movement, on stage in New York and Boston in December 2017 “…a reassuring light after utter darkness, a promise of resurgence…a moving, cogent experience…” – The Sydney Morning Herald FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE PHNOM PENH, 16 NOVEMBER 2017 – Oscar-nominated director Rithy PANH (The Missing Picture) and internationally acclaimed composer HIM Sophy, both survivors of the Khmer Rouge, join forces to create Bangsokol: A Requiem for Cambodia. An extraordinary new piece featuring music, film, movement, and voice, it pays tribute to the two million killed in the nation’s genocide (1975-1979). “Bangsokol is a vital act of memory,” says PANH. “It is an attempt to give dignity to the dead; to reconcile with our own past; to give a face and a name to the victims, to give their souls peace.” This requiem, unprecedented in form and composition, features ceremonial elements from bangsokol - Buddhist funeral rites performed to give rest to the spirits of the dead, as well as traditional Cambodian music and Western classical forms. After a successful world premiere at the Melbourne Festival in October, Bangsokol: A Requiem for Cambodia comes to the US this winter. On 15 and 16 December, it takes to the stage of the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM) as part of the Next Wave Festival 2017, and on 19 and 20 December, at Boston’s ArtsEmerson. Performances in Europe and Asia will follow in 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • A Requiem for Cambodia to Premiere
    Bangsokol: A Requiem for Cambodia to premiere nearly 40 years after the Cambodian genocide Powerful new work by Rithy PANH and HIM Sophy, featuring music, visuals, and movement, debuts at the Melbourne Festival on 13 October 2017 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE PHNOM PENH, 24 2017 – Oscar-nominated director Rithy PANH (The Missing Picture) and acclaimed composer HIM Sophy – two survivors of the Khmer Rouge – join forces to create Bangsokol: A Requiem for Cambodia. An extraordinary new piece featuring music, film, movement, and voice, it pays tribute to the two million killed in the nation’s genocide (1975-1979). “Bangsokol is a vital act of memory,” says PANH. “It is an attempt to give dignity to the dead; to reconcile with our own past; to give a face and a name to the victims, to give their souls peace.” This new requiem, unprecedented in form and composition, features ceremonial elements from bangsokol, Buddhist funeral rites performed to give rest to the spirits of the dead, as well as traditional Cambodian music and Western classical forms. The world premiere of Bangsokol will be presented at the Melbourne Festival on October 13 and 14, 2017 before being seen in New York and Boston in December, and in Europe and Asia in 2018. The 65-minute piece, commissioned by non-profit organization Cambodian Living Arts (CLA), with co-commissioner Asia TOPA / Arts Centre Melbourne, will return to Phnom Penh in 2019 – 40 years since the fall of the Khmer Rouge. The narrative of Bangsokol begins in the heavens and moves to a countryside funeral. It extends into remembrance of the horrors of the Khmer Rouge period, and culminates with the central Buddhist rite for the deceased, bringing peace and the acceptance of impermanence.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Contemporary Social Issues – Cambodia
    Contemporary Social Issues Global Contemporary Social Issues – Cambodia Study of major social issues facing human groups in modern society such as deviance, inequality, war and population. Emphasis placed on global social issues that arise as a result of institutional fluctuations in economy, family, government and war, religion and environment. Major trends specific to Southeast Asia and Cambodia are examined in relationship to contemporary socio - historical – cultural developments. Reflective Response: You will be answering weekly reflective questions designed to help you guide your reading make the connections to your writing. You may answer some or all of the questions and I encourage you to write about other points and ideas as you develop a sociological perspective and imagination in your reflective analyses. Extra Credit Opportunities: Visit The National Cambodian Heritage Museum & Killing Fields Memorial, located at 2831 West Lawrence Avenue, Chicago. (https://www.cambodianmuseum.org/) For up to 50 points extra credit, write a brief essay (3-5 pages, with a selfie) about the following: 1. Describe how you felt going through the Cambodian Museum from start to finish. What did you feel in the opening section? The final section? 2. Analyze your experience based on four of the issues listed in the syllabus. 3. Discuss the similarities and differences you see between the social issues that shaped the country between 1975 and 1979 and the social issues that shape Cambodia today. Film Analysis For up to 20 points, write a 4-5 page analysis of any of the films we view in class or a film you find of interest in the Documentation Center of Cambodia.
    [Show full text]
  • Venice Gap Financing-Market
    VENICE GAP – FINANCING MARKET BOOK OF PROJECTS FICTION AND DOCUMENTARY FEATURE FILMS VR, INTERACTIVE, WEB AND TV SERIES 01 – 03.09.2017 www.labiennale.org VENICE GAP– FINANCING MARKET BOOK OF PROJECTS FICTION AND DOCUMENTARY FEATURE FILMS VR, INTERACTIVE, WEB AND TV SERIES 74. Mostra Internazionale d’Arte Cinematografica Cinema Department Director Venice Gap-Financing Market La Biennale di Venezia Alberto Barbera VR, Interactive, Web and its collaborators and TV Series for Book of Projects The Venice Production Bridge welcomes the Cinema Department Valentina Bellomo th Managing Director Consultants Erika Giorgianni 47 selected teams and their projects to the 4 Luigi Cuciniello Lucas Rosant Elena Mantoan Eva Morsch Kihn Chiara Marin Venice Production Bridge Sara Mazzucchi edition of the Venice Gap-Financing Market Pascal Diot Collaborators Alessandro Mezzalira Savina Neirotti Violetta Bava Nikolas Montaldi Paolo Bertolin Since last year, the Venice Gap-Financing Market has expanded to host a larger number of projects [email protected] Matthieu Darras across different audiovisual forms. A total of 47 projects have been selected for this years' edition: www.labiennale.org Giacomo Durzi Francesco Giai Via feature fiction and documentary films, TV & web series and VR films. Elena Pollacchi Michel Reilhac Our hope was that this would bring variety, diversity, and the possibility for many decision makers that Liz Rosenthal were usually working only in one field to crossover to another, building bridges – as the new name of Jane Williams the Venice market suggests. We are proud to say that this has happened – and that in addition to the many feature films that in the past 3 years have closed their financing here in Venice and have then gone on to premiere at festivals worldwide, we can also celebrate the completion of documentaries, web series and virtual reality films.
    [Show full text]
  • The Perpetrator's Mise-En-Scène: Language, Body, and Memory in the Cambodian Genocide
    JPR The Perpetrator’s mise-en-scène: Language, Body, and Memory in the Cambodian Genocide Vicente Sánchez-Biosca Abstract: Rithy Panh’s film S-21. The Khmer Rouge Killing Machine (2003) was the result of a three- year shooting period in the Khmer Rouge centre of torture where perpetrators and victims exchanged experiences and re-enacted scenes from the past under the gaze of the filmmaker’s camera. Yet, a crucial testimony was missing in that puzzle: the voice of the prison’s director, Kaing Guek Eav, comrade Duch. When the Extraor- dinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) were finally established in Phnom Penh to judge the master criminals of Democratic Kampuchea, the first to be indicted was this desk criminal. The filmDuch, Master of the Forges of Hell (Panh, 2011) deploys a new confrontation – an agon, in the terminology of tragedy – between a former perpetrator and a former victim, seen through cinema language. The audiovisual document registers Duch’s words and body as he develops his narrative, playing cunningly with contrition and deceit. The construction of this narrative and its deconstruction by Panh can be more fully understood by comparing some film scenes with other footage shot before, during and after the hearings. In sum, this ‘chamber film’ permits us to analyse two voices: that of the perpetrator, including his narrative and body language; and the invisible voice of the survivor that expresses itself through editing, sound effects, and montage. Keywords: Perpetrator, audiovisual testimony, body language, cinema, Khmer Rouge, Cambodia Gémir, pleurer, prier est également lâche. Fais énergiquement ta longue et lourde tâche Dans la voie où le Sort a voulu t’appeler.
    [Show full text]
  • Cinema and Cultural Diffusion Department of Cambodia
    Bophana Audiovisual Resource Center Archives Department Collection of “Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC)” Arranging with the notice numbers *Note: You cannot click the title to entry the Bophana Center database due to the Center using intranet. All right reserved by Bophana Center Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference [Visit of Prince Norodom Sihanouk to China and Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000057 00:04:51 also his visit to the water festival in Phnom Penh] [Newsreels during the Lon Nol regime] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000058 00:18:04 [Cooperative Work in the Rice Field] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000066 00:14:40 1 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration Type Reference [Youth workers] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000101 00:09:57 [Newsreels n°123 - n°34] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000145 00:20:21 [Extraordinary Meeting of the Communist Party Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000146 00:25:58 of Kampuchea] [B40 Cannon] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000175 00:12:42 [Newsreel n°157] Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000221 00:18:57 [The official Visit of H.E. Mr. Lee Kuan Yew to Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000227 00:18:48 Cambodia] [After the fighting between the Khmer Rouge Department of Cinema and Diffusion (DDC) DDC_VI_000239 00:07:05 and the Vietnamese military] 2 Archive Image Title Versions Date Collection Duration
    [Show full text]
  • The Bophana Audiovisual Resource Centre and the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC)1
    Chapter 5 Showing now: The Bophana Audiovisual Resource Centre and the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC)1 Rachel Hughes The Bophana Centre is an audiovisual archive, a training centre and a venue for free film screenings in the centre of Phnom Penh, capital of Cambodia. The centre was founded in 2006 by two Cambodian film-makers, Rithy Panh and Pannakar Ieu.2 In the same year, the United Nations–supported Khmer Rouge Tribunal – formally the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) – was also established in Phnom Penh. Although vastly different initiatives, the organisation and tribunal share a concern to work towards some form of justice for victims of Khmer Rouge crimes and to foster dialogue about how to constitute a better present and future in light of this and other historical conflicts in the country. This chapter is based in fieldwork conducted in and around the ECCC between late 2011 and early 2017. It introduces the work of the Bophana Centre as a unique Cambodian organisation and critically explores its relationship to the ECCC in the wider context of what is generally termed Cambodian civil society. It argues that the practices fostered at Bophana are ontologically and epistemologically at variance with transitional justice theory and practice. The creative labour of Bophana’s film- and app-makers is cultural, material and relational. These kinds of practices have seen Bophana play a key role in the outreach and reparation activities of the ECCC, and in turn has changed the nature of these activities. Ten years after its inception, Bophana is a relatively large and well-organised NGO, with both international and Cambodian-based donors and upwards of 25 paid staff.
    [Show full text]