IEEE 802.15 Wireless Personal Area Networks Ô

1July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 1 IEEE 802.15 Wireless Personal Area Networks 2 Project IEEE 802.15 Working Group for WPANs Title IEEE 802.15 Roll Call Vote for Chair Challenge

Date [July 13, 2004] Submitted

Sources Jim Allen Voice (585) 214-2465 Appairent Technologies, Inc. Fax: 150 Lucius Gordon Dr. E-mail: [email protected] Rochester, NY 14586 Re: []

Abstract [IEEE 802.15.3a roll call record]

Purpose [Database for roll call vote from 3a Task Group Plenary meeting in Portland.]

Notice This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.

Release The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

2Submission Page 1 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 3July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0

5Background 6 7During the 802.15.3a agenda discussion, there was an intent to move the down select vote, which 8was agreed to at the last interim meeting to be on Wednesday, to Monday evening. The Chair 9refused to open that item to debate to avoid disenfranchising those who were not available and 10those who expected that agenda item would remain on Wednesday as posted over a month ago. 11 12A member of the body challenged the Chair’s ruling and moved that the voting agenda item be 13open to debate and further motions. 14 15The majority voted against the Chair. Before the business to move the vote item could be held, 16the organizational staff announced that rooms were not available this evening (Monday) to the 17vote was withdrawn since it would have been ruled out of order for lack of a way to implement 18any conclusion other than the current one. 19 20The roll count is listed below. 21 22 YES NO ABSTAIN TOTAL Yes = Uphold Chair 59 65 9 133 Percentage 47.6% 52.4% 100% LAST NAME FIRST NAME FOR AGAINST ABSTAIN Adams Jon 1 Aggarwal Sudhir Ahn Jaemin 1 Aiello Roberto 1 Akagi Hiroshi Akahane Masaaki Alfvin Richard Allen James 1 Allen Richard 1 Anandakumar Anand Ann Jong Hoon Aoki Mikio 1 Aramaki Michimasa Arnett Larry 1 Asanuma Yutaka Askar Naiel 1 Bahl Venkatl Bahreini Yasaman Bain Jay 1 Baker James Balakrishnan Jaiganesh Balakrishnan Kannan 1 Ballentine Paul Barkway Michael

4Submission Page 2 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 5July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Barr John 1 Batra Anuj 1 Berjikly Armen Birru Dagnachew Boehlke Kenneth Bonneville Herve Bourgeois Monique 1 Bowles Mark 1 Brabenac Charles 1 Brenner David 1 Brethour Vern 1 Brown Ronald 1 Cain Peter Callaway Ed 1 Carson Pat 1 Cattenoz Regis Chang Kisoo 1 Chang Soo-Young 1 Chapman James Cheah Jonathon 1 Chew Chee Wei Chin Francois Po Shin 1 Choi Sangsung 1 Choi Yun Chong Chia-Chin 1 Choudhary Manoj 1 Conkling Craig Corral Celestino 1 Cragie Robert Charles Cypher David Dabak Anand Davis Scott 1 Decuir Joe 1 Del Prado Pavon Javier 1 Dombrowski Kai Drude Stefan 1 Dydyk Michael 1 Elders-Boll Harald Ellis Jason 1 Emami Shahriar 1 Erlich Yossi Escola Dwayne Evans Allan Fidler Mark W. Fisher Chris Fisher Reed 1 Fleming Kristoffer 1 Foerster Jeff 1

6Submission Page 3 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 7July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Fujita Etsumi Fukui Taketo Fuller John Furuno David Gandolfo Pierre Gehring Stephan Genossar Michael Ghazi Vafa 1 Gifford Ian 1 Gilb James 1 Godfrey Tim Goldenberg Sorin 1 Gorday Paul 1 Gravenstein Martin Green Evan Greer Kerry Grohmann Bernd Gummadi Srikanth Gurevitz Assaf Gutierrez Jose Hahn Dongwoon Hamaguchi Kiyoshi Hamilton Thomas 1 Harada Yasuo Harrington Drew Harris Jeff 1 Hassan Amer Hasty Vann Heberling Allen Heile Robert 1 Helal Didier Herold Barry 1 Heubaum Karl 1 Hinkel Reed Ho Jin-Meng Hoghooghi Michael Holland Julie Hosur Srinath Huang Robert 1 Huang Xiaojing 1 Hwang Syang-Myau Igler Eran Ikegami Tetsushi 1 Jamieson Phil Jang Yeong Min 1 Jechoux Bruno Jeon Ho-In Karaoguz Jeyhan 1

8Submission Page 4 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 9July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Katagiri Masami Kelly Joy 1 Kelly Michael 1 Kerry Nick Kerry Stuart J. 1 Khoo Hock Kido Ryoji Kim ChangJoo Kim Haksun Kim In Hwan Kim Kyoung-A Kim Myoung Kim Myoung Soo Kim Yongsuk 1 Kim Young Hwan 1 Kim Youngsoo Kimyacioglu Kursat 1 Kindler Matthias 1 Kinney Patrick 1 Kitaguchi Susumu Kleindl Guenter 1 Kobashi Toshiya Kohno Ryuji 1 Krishnamoorthy Rajeev Kuehnel Thomas Kuramochi Yuzo 1 Kwon Do-Hoon 1 Kwon Ted KyuMin Kang Lampe John V. 1 Lansford Jim Larsson Torbjorn Leach David Lee Dongjun Lee Hyung Soo 1 Lee Myung Lee Nag 1 Lee Simon Lee Woo-Kyung Leeper David 1 Legrand Fabrice 1 Li Liang Liang Jie Lin Susan 1 Lingam Srinivas Liu Yong 1 Lou Hui-Ling Ma Steve

10Submission Page 5 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 11July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Maeki Akira March Steven Martin Frederick 1 Matsuno Noriaki McCorkle John McInnis Michael 1 McLaughlin Michael 1 McLean James Meacham Daniel Meyer Jim 1 Miller Leonard Mimura Masahiro Miura Akira 1 Miyasaka Hitoshi Mo Shaomin Molisch Andreas 1 Mondragon Antonio Moore Mark Morelli Anthony Morton Steven Naeve Marco Naganuma Ken 1 Nakache Yves-Paul 1 Ngo Chiu Noble Erwin R. 1 Noda Masaki 1 Noens Richard 1 O'Connor Christopher O'Conor John C. 1 Odman Knut Ogawa Hiroyo 1 Ohyama Takashi Ojard Eric Okuma Yasuyuki Orlik Philip 1 Pardee John B. 1 Park Bonghyuk 1 Park Jonghun 1 Park Joon Goo Park Michael Patel Vijay Patton Dave 1 Pellon Miguel 1 Pendergrass Marcus Peng Xiaoming Poor Robert D. 1 Popescu Paul Raad Raad 1

12Submission Page 6 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 13July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Ranta Pekka 1 Rashi Yaron Rasor Gregg 1 Razzell Charles 1 Reede Ivan 1 Rhee Seung Rich Mark 1 Rikuta Yuko 1 Ritter Benno Robar Terry 1 Roberts Glyn 1 Roberts Richard 1 Rofheart Martin 1 Rogers Chris Rogerson Gerald Roh Jaeho 1 Rouzet Philippe 1 Rypinski Chandos 1 Saberinia Ebrahim Sahinoglu Zafer 1 Saito Shin Saito Tomoki 1 Sanada Yukitoshi Santhoff John Sarallo John 1 Sasaki Yasufumi Schrader Mark Schrum Sidney 1 Schuster Tom Schylander Erik 1 Seals Michael Sella Assaf Shao Huai-Rong Shelby Kevin Shellhammer Stephen J. Shimada Shusaku Shimazaki Yoshihito Shin Cheol-Ho 1 Shiraki Yuichi Shirron Etan Shoemake Matthew 1 Shor Gadi Shrader Lance Shvodian William 1 Siep Thomas Sim Michael Siwiak Kazimierz 1 Solomon Yoram

14Submission Page 7 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 15July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Somayazulu V 1 Soomro Amjad Stevenson Carl Struik Rene Sugahara Hiroto Sutton Robert A. Suzuki MItsuhiro Takahashi Kazuaki 1 Takizawa Kenichi 1 Tan Teik-Kheong 1 Tanahashi Mike Taylor James 1 Terry John 1 Tjia Jerome Tokuda Kiyohito Tsao Jean 1 Turner Stephen 1 Unsal Oltac van Leeuwen Hans Virk Bhupender 1 Wakeley Timothy Walrant Thierry Walton Chris Wandile Vivek G 1 Wang Jerry Wang Jing 1 Wang Yunbiao Watanabe Katsumi Watanabe Fujio Welborn Matthew 1 Wilson Richard 1 Wineinger Gerald 1 Wong Timothy Wood Stephen Yaish David Yamaguchi Hirohisa 1 Yekeh YazdandoostKamya

Yoon Wonyong Yoshida Yutaka Young Amos Young Song-Lin Yu Patrick Yung Hon 1 Yurdakul Serdar Zhang Honggang 1 Zhong Zhun Zhu Chunhui 1

16Submission Page 8 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies 17July 2004 IEEE 802.15-04-0362r0 Zyren James Johansson Peter 1 Boot John 1

18Submission Page 9 of 9 Jim Allen, Appairent Technologies