January 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.11-00/001 IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Report of Letter Ballot 20 Ballot opened on: 11/27/1999 Ballot closed on: 1/7/2000 Voting members NOT responding: 13 ------
Motion number 1 The motion reads as follows: To submit the contents of document IEEE 802.11d/D1.0 to Sponsor Ballot
Number of people in Ballot Group of 802.11 : 80 Number of votes received : 67 Return ratio = 82 % (required >= 50 %)
Approved without comments : 56 (plus 4 aspirant members) Approved with comments : 0 Disapproved with comments : 10 (plus one ex-member) Approval ratio = 84 % (required => 75 %)
Abstain (Lack of Time) : 0 Abstain (Lack of Expertise) : 1 Abstain (Other) : 0 Abstention ratio = 1 % (required < 30 %) ------
Motion number 2 The motion reads as follows: To submit the contents of document IEEE 802.11b-cor/D1.0 to Sponsor Ballot
Number of people in Ballot Group of 802.11 : 80 Number of votes received : 67 Return ratio = 82 % (required >= 50 %)
Approved without comments : 67 (plus 4 aspirant members) Approved with comments : 0 Disapproved with comments : 0 Approval ratio = 100 % (required => 75 %)
Abstain (Lack of Time) : 0 Abstain (Lack of Expertise) : 0 Abstain (Other) : 0 Abstention ratio = 0 % (required < 30 %)
Report of Letter Ballot 20 page 1 Vic Hayes, Chair, Lucent Technologies January 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.11-00/001 Votes received Full name member Motion_ Motion_ Full name member Motion_ Motion_
Mr. Jeff Voter Approve Approve Dr. Chris Heegard Voter Approve Approve Abramowitz Mr. Robert Heile Voter Approve Approve Dr. Reza Ahy Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. Juha Heiskala Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. Matthew Voter Approve Approve Alspaugh Mr. Maarten Voter Do not Approve Hoeben approve with Mr. Keith B. Voter Approve Approve comment Amundsen
Mr. Carl F. Andren Voter Approve Approve Mr. Masataka Voter Approve Approve Iizuka Mr. James R. Voter Approve Approve Baker Mr. Masayuki Aspirant Approve Approve Ikeda Mr. Kevin M. Barry Voter Approve Approve Mr. Donald C. Voter Approve Approve Mr. Phil Belanger Voter Approve Approve Johnson Mr. Simon Black Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. Tal Kaitz Voter Do not Approve approve with Mr. Jan Boer Voter Approve Approve comment Mr. Ronald Voter Do not Approve Brockmann approve with Mr. Kevin Karcz Voter Approve Approve comment Mr. Mika Kasslin Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Naftali Chayat Voter Approve Approve Mr. Dean M. Voter Do not Approve Kawaguchi approve with Mr. W.C. Chen Voter Approve Approve comment Mr. Ken Clements Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Peter Voter Approve Approve Mr. Stuart J. Kerry Voter Approve Approve Ecclesine Dr. Ing. Jamshid Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. Richard Voter Approve Approve Khun-Jush Eckard Mr. Patrick Kinney Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Darwin Voter Do not Approve Dr. Steven Voter Approve Approve Engwer approve with with Knudsen comment comment Dr. John M. Voter Approve Approve Kowalski Mr. Greg Ennis Voter Approve Approve Mr. Bruce P. Voter Approve Approve Mr. John Voter Approve Approve Kraemer Fakatselis Mr. David S. Voter Approve Approve Mr. Michael Voter Approve Approve Landeta Fischer Mr. Changoo Lee Voter Approve Approve Mr. George Fishel Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. James S. Li Voter Approve Approve Mr. John Fisher Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. James S. Li Voter Approve Approve Mr. Ian Gifford Voter Approve Approve Mr. Stanley Ling Voter Did not vote Did not vote Mr. Motohiro Aspirant Approve Approve Gochi Mr. Michael D. Voter Approve Approve McInnis Mr. Tim Godfrey Voter Approve Approve Dr. Akira Miura Voter Did not vote Did not vote Dr. Steven D. Voter Abstain, lack Approve Gray of expertise Mr. Henri Moelard ex- Do not error member approve with Mr. Kei Hara Voter Did not vote Did not vote comment Mr. Victor Hayes Voter Do not Approve approve with with Dr. Masahiro Voter Approve Approve comment comment Morikura Mr. Peter Murray Voter Approve Approve Mr. Allen Voter Approve Approve Heberling Mr. Ravi P. Voter Approve Approve Report of Letter Ballot 20 page 2 Vic Hayes, Chair, Lucent Technologies January 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.11-00/001
Full name member Motion_ Motion_ Full name member Motion_ Motion_
Nalamati Mr. Chris Zegelin Voter Do not Approve approve with Dr. Richard van Voter Approve Approve comment Nee
Mr. Erwin R. Voter Approve Approve Mr. Jim Zyren Voter Approve Noble Approve
Mr. Bob O'Hara Voter Do not Approve approve with with comment comment
Dr. Tomoki Voter Approve Approve Ohsawa
Mr. Kazuhiro Voter Did not vote Did not vote Okanoue Mr. Richard H. Voter Approve Approve Paine
Mr. Al Petrick Voter Approve Approve
Ms. Victoria M. Voter Do not Approve Poncini approve with comment
Dr. Stanley A. Voter Approve Approve Reible Mr. Carlos A. Rios Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Kent G. Voter Did not vote Did not vote Rollins
Dr. Clemens C.W. Aspirant Approve Approve Ruppel Mr. Anil K. Voter Approve Approve Sanwalka
Dr. Matthew B. Voter Approve Approve Shoemake Mr. Thomas Siep Voter Approve Approve
Mr. David Skellern Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Donald I. Voter Approve Approve Sloan
Mr. Gary Spiess Voter Do not Approve approve with comment
Mr. Hitoshi Voter Approve Approve Takanashi Mr. Satoru Voter Approve Approve Toguchi
Ms. Cherry Tom Voter Approve Approve
Dr. Chih C. Tsien Voter Did not vote Did not vote
Mr. Tom Voter Approve Approve Tsoulogiannis Dr. Robert M. Voter Did not vote Did not vote Ward Jr. Mr. Alan Voter error error Winskowski
Mr. Harry Worstell Voter Approve Approve
Mr. Masaaki Yuza Aspirant Approve Approve
Report of Letter Ballot 20 page 3 Vic Hayes, Chair, Lucent Technologies January 2000 doc.: IEEE 802.11-00/001
Report of Letter Ballot 20 page 4 Vic Hayes, Chair, Lucent Technologies