Planning Committee Meeting (18/09/2019)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
September 12th, 2019 Notice Of Meeting You are invited to attend the Planning Committee Meeting to be held on Wednesday, 18th September 2019 at 11:00 am in Boardroom, District Council Offices, Monaghan Row, Newry. * MEETING TO COMMENCE AT 11.00AM *. Committee Membership:- Councillor M Larkin (Chair) Councillor H Reilly (Deputy Chair) Councillor G Bain Councillor W Clarke Councillor L Devlin Councillor G Hanna Councillor V Harte Councillor C Mason Councillor D McAteer Councillor H McKee Councillor M Ruane Councillor J Trainor Agenda 1.0 Apologies Cllr. Devlin 2.0 Declarations of Interest 3.0 Declarations of Conflicts of Interest in relation to Paragraph 25 of Planning Operating Protocol LA07/2017/1182/F - Strategic roadside services facility - all Councillors can take part in the discussion /decision on this application with the exception of Cllrs. Bain, Devlin and Mason. LA07/2018/1913/O - Infill site for 1No. dwelling, Ballard Road, Lislea - all Councillors can take part in the discussion / decision on this application with the exception of Cllrs. Clarke and Devlin Minutes for Confirmation 4.0 Minutes of Planning Committee Meeting held on Wednesday 21 August 2019. (copy attached). Planning Committee Minutes - 21 August 2019.pdf Page 1 For Discussion/Decision 5.0 Addendum list - planning applications with no requests for speaking rights /written submissions. (Attached) Addendum list - 18-09-2019.pdf Page 16 Development Management - Planning Applications for determination (with previous site visits) 6.0 LA07/2017/1182/F - Strategic roadside service facility incorporating petrol station, shop and restaurant services, child play area, picnic area, car, coach, lorry parking, bunkering facilities, landscaping, access roads and associated highway and site construction / excavation works - location (see below). (Case Officer report attached). Lands east of the (A1) Belfast Dublin Dual Carriageway (Southbound) off slip signposted towards Newry / Craigavon (A27) and Armagh (A28) at Newry. Lands are south of the link road connecting the (A27) Tandragee Road and (A28) Armagh Road approximately 300m west of the (A27) Tandragee Road / Carnbane Road / Shepherds Way roadabout, Newry BT35 6QA. A request for speaking rights has been received from Eunan Duffy objecting to the application. (Submission attached). A request for speaking rights has been received from The Dublin Road Services Operators Group, objecting to the application. (Submission attached). A request for speaking rights has been received from Conor Cochrane on behalf of Five Ways Shop and Service Station, objecting to the application. (Submission attached). A request for speaking rights has been received from James McKevitt, Barney McKevitt and Stephen Hughes, objecting to the application. (Submission attached). A request for speaking rights has been received from Eamonn Loughrey (Inaltus), Jim Manelly (Clarman Architects) and Tim Robinson (AECOM) (Submission attached). Rec: REFUSAL LA07.2017.1182.F Strategic Filling Station (c).pdf Page 17 LA07.2017.1182.F - Eunan Duffy - obj.pdf Page 39 LA07.2017.1182.F - The Dublin Road Services Operators Group - obj.pdf Page 40 LA07.2017.1182.F - C Cochrane for 5 - Ways Shop Service Station - obj.pdf Page 46 LA07.2017.1182.F James McKevitt - obj.pdf Page 48 Applicant-agent in support LA07-2017-1182-F.pdf Page 51 LA07.2017.1182.F - Agents Speaking Notes Addendum Sept 19.pdf Page 78 Development Management - Planning Applications for determination 7.0 LA07/2018/1732/F - Replacement dwelling and re-positioning of access - 16 McKays Road, Castlewellan. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Eoin Morgan, agent and Majella Cunningham, applicant, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07-2018-1732-F - 16 McKays Road.pdf Page 80 LA07.2018.1732.F .pdf Page 87 8.0 LA07/2019/0830/O - Erection of 2 no. infill dwellings - Land NW of 11 Wateresk Road, Dundrum. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Eoin Morgan, agent, in support of the application. (Submission attached). A submission in support of the application has been received from DEA Councillor Gallagher. (Submission attached). LA07_2019_830_O NW of 11 Wateresk Road.pdf Page 89 LA07.2019.0830.O.pdf Page 94 LA07.2019.0830.O - DEA Cllr Gallagher.pdf Page 96 9.0 LA07/2018/1855/F - Proposed 2 no. infill dwellings and garages - Between No. 124a and 126 Carsonstown Road, Saintfield, Ballynahinch. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Ryan McBirney and Lisa Shannon, Gravis Planning, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07-2018-1855-F Report 2 infill carsonstown road.pdf Page 97 LA07.2018.1855.F.pdf Page 106 10.0 LA07/2019/0799/F - Proposed widening and regrading of sections of the existing race course and realignment of existing ambulance track at Downpatrick Racecourse, Downpatrick - Lands at Downpatrick Racecourse, 24 Ballydugan Road, Downpatrick.. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: APPROVAL Addendum list LA07-2019-0799-F Racecourse .pdf Page 109 11.0 LA07/2015/1302/F - Proposed new retail development at ground floor with 4 No. 2 bedroom apartments at first floor level, relocation of existing NIE sub-station and provision of associated car parking and landscaping - Lands to the rear of 11-29 Thomas Street and adjacent to access road to Buttercrane shopping centre. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Richard O'Toole and Ronan Sheehy, Planning Consultants, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07.2015.1302.F Thomas Street.pdf Page 118 LA07.2015.1302.F.pdf Page 140 12.0 LA07/2017/1235/F - Demolition of No. 31 and erection of two shop units on ground floor with 4 No. apartments on first and second floors - No. 31 Cardinal O'Fiaich Square, Crossmaglen. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Michael Graham, WYG Planning and Aidan Cole, Cole Partnership in support of the application. (Submission atttached). LA07.2017.1235.F Cardinal O Fiach Square.pdf Page 142 LA07.2017.1235 .F.pdf Page 160 13.0 LA07/2018/1670/F - Proposed two storey dwelling with integral garage as a change of house type from approval LA07/2015/1171/F with revised vehicular access from Church Rock Road - 30m North East of 6 Main Street, Camlough, Newry. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Sam McKee, agent, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07.2018.1670.F Main St Camlough.pdf Page 162 _LA07-2018-1670-F.pdf Page 172 14.0 LA07/2018/1913/O - Infill site for 1 No. dwelling - Site between 33 and 37 Ballard Road, Lislea. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL Speaking rights submission received from Anthony O'Hare, agent, attached. LA07-2018-1913-O Ballard Road.pdf Page 173 LA07-2018-1913-0 (Lislea).pdf Page 178 15.0 LA07/2019/0008/F - Site for infill dwelling and garage - Circa 70m East of No. 14a Ayallogue Road, Newry. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Barry Owens, agent, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07.2019.0008.F Ayallogue Rd, Newry.pdf Page 180 LA07.2019.0008.F.pdf Page 184 16.0 LA07/2019/0307/O - Dwelling - Between 125b and 135 Cullaville Road, Crossmaglen. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Richard O'Toole, agent, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07.2019.0307.O Cullaville Rd, Crossmaglen.pdf Page 186 LA07.2019.0307.O.pdf Page 191 17.0 LA07/2018/1543/O - Site for infill dwelling and garage (revised site location plan) - Cullion Road, Mayobridge (immediately adjacent to and South of 6A Cullion Road). (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Martin Bailie, agent in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07_2018_1543_O-Cullion Road.pdf Page 193 LA07.2018.1543.O .pdf Page 199 18.0 LA07/2018/1614/O - Dwelling on a farm - 50 metres South of No. 24 Island Road, Attical, Kilkeel. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from John Cole, agent in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07. 2018. 1614.O Island Road.pdf Page 200 LA07.2018.1614.O.pdf Page 205 19.0 LA07/2019/0207/F - Erection of dwelling (change of house type from that approved under P/2013/0631/F) - 70m East of No. 53 Cullion Road, Mayobridge, Newry. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL Addendum list LA07_2019_0207_F- East of 53 Cullion Road.pdf Page 212 20.0 LA07/2019/0602/F - Retention of 2 No. mobile / containers used as, 1 - changing / shower block and 2 - toilet block & proposed third mobile / containers to be used as a changing / shower block and paladin type boundary fence (amended plans) - Shandon Park Playing Fields, Cloughanramer Road, Newry. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: APPROVAL Addendum list LA07_2019_0602_F- Shandon Park.pdf Page 218 21.0 LA07/2019/0620/O - New dwelling and garage - Adjacent and SW of 76 Drumlough Road, Mayobridge. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Colin O'Callaghan, agent, in support of the application. (Submission attached). LA07.2019.0620 O Drumlough Rd.pdf Page 222 LA07.2019.0620.O.pdf Page 225 Development Management - Planning Applications for determination (in closed session) 22.0 LA07/2018/0860/F - Proposed replacement dwelling (amended drawings) - 45 metres North East of No. 14 Rath Road, Clonallon GlebeTb. Warrenpoint. (Case Officer report attached). Rec: REFUSAL A request for speaking rights has been received from Colin O'Callaghan, agent, in support of the application. (Submission to follow under separate cover).