E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

Enhancement Program on Day Care Children’s Development Aileen V. Elarco

Southern Luzon State University Lucban, Quezon Philippines [email protected]

ABSTRACT

This study intended to design an enhancement program on day care children’s development in Quezon Province. It used a mixed-method research design in which qualitative and quantitative data were collected. A total of 168 respondents were the target beneficiaries, which included 16 day care workers, 8 MSWD workers, 24 parents and 120 day care children. The instruments used in this study were checklist/observation forms, structured and open- ended interview forms, and questionnaires. The gathered data were computed, analyzed and interpreted by utilizing weighted mean, percentage, mean, Pearson r and t-test. The results showed that the day care children’s development program has several problems in curriculum, guidance and interactions and assessment. Hence, an enhancement program on day care children’s development was developed. Besides, it included the outputs subjected to tryout such as rubric compilation, and prototypic session guide for day care workers. After the tryout, the findings revealed that there was a significant difference in the post-assessment scores between the experimental and control groups of respondents in all selected locales at Quezon Province. The age and length of service of day care worker respondents also affect the day care children’s performance. The enhancement program was highly accepted as the performance of the experimental groups has shown highly advanced performance. It is likely that the government, particularly the DSWD, may support the needs of day care workers and children. Day care workers need trainings on the integration of gender fairness and prevention from abuse and exploitation, material development, child-directed and small group activities.

Keywords enhancement, enhancement program, day care, day care children, development, children’s development

INTRODUCTION

The early childhood years are special time in the life of young children. During this period, they begin to trust others outside the family. They gain independence, self-control and learn to take initiative in socially acceptable ways. At the same time, they become keen observers of their world and experiment with their surroundings to find out what happens when they interact with other people and maneuver objects and materials. Indeed, children are little people who develop differently. Understanding their development helps day care workers know the things that give impact in children’s lives, and expectations from them.

Boyse (2012) defines child development as to child’s progress in doing complex things as they get older. It is about developing core capabilities such as motor, language, cognitive and social- emotional skills, called developmental milestones which directly affect later performance. Failure to reach milestones during early childhood leads to poor development of those skills upon reaching teenagehood and adulthood, even with extraordinary intervention later in life.

Day care centers in the country have concern to help young children develop target milestones. The day care program’s curriculum, guidance and interactions, and assessment give emphasis to the importance of preparing children for school and future success. This is possible since the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) aims to review and update the program on children’s development as indicated in its User’s Manual for the Accreditation of Center-based Early Childhood Care and Development Programs.

In view of this, an enhancement program can help day care workers improve their services towards children’s development. Thus, providing them with the learnings needeed for better life and work in the 21st century. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

FRAMEWORK

Day care workers develop day care children in Quezon Province. Their demographic characteristics, such as age, sex, length of service and educational attainment, affect children’s progress. Besides, the day care program areas of curriculum, guidance and interactions and assessment also influence children’s advancement.

To help day care children, there is a need for enhancing the program in the mentioned areas. It starts with needs assessment to identify the existing problems. Besides, a good plan of activities and available resources benefit the learners.

More so, several theories serve as foundations in this purpose. The theories of play by Piaget, multiple intelligences by Gardner, and interactive learning by Vygotsky have bearing on the outputs of this study, such as rubric compilation and prototypic session guide.

The process of the study included a structured observation in curriculum, guidance and interactions and assessment procedure of the day care worker respondents. A structured and open-ended interviews with several respondents supported and verified the quantitative results of the study. Consequently, the instruments and enhancement program were developed and validated by MSWD workers.

The dependent variable is the developed enhancement program on day care children’s development. Its acceptability depends on program’s quality, usefulness to others and educational significance.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

Generally, this study attempts to design an enhancement program on day care children’s development in Quezon Province. Specifically, the study aimed to determine the status of day care children’s development program in terms of curriculum, guidance and interactions and assessment; identify the problems on day care children’s development program; determine the significant difference in the post-assessment scores between the two groups of respondents in the target locales; correlate day care children’s performance and day care workers’ characteristics; and to determine the acceptability of the enhancement program in terms quality, usefulness to others and educational significance.

METHODOLOGY

This study used a mixed-method research design. It utilized the combination of the following quantitative approaches such as observation questionnaires, survey and experiment and the interview qualitative approach. Being able to mix different approaches has the advantages of enabling triangulation. Thus, the researcher used a concurrent triangulation designed to confirm, and corroborate findings within the study (Creswell & Clark, 2007). In this strategy, the quantitative and qualitative research and data analysis take place at the same time (Pole, 2007).

In the tryout of the prototypic session guide, this study also utilized an experimental method following the matched-pair design. There were two groups: the control group, which is exposed to common session guide and the experimental group exposed to the researcher’s self-made session guide. In this design, the groups were matched according to their 1st evaluation and pre- assessment results.

A total of 168 respondents were the target beneficiaries, broken down as, 16 day care workers, 8 MSWD workers, 24 parents and 120 day care children. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

The instruments used in this study were observation and interview forms, acceptability questionnaire and pre/post assessments. An observation form secured from the Provincial Social Welfare Development Office (PSWO) in Lucena City was used to determine the status of the day care children’s development program.

A 54- item observation form included statements on curriculum, guidance and interactions, and assessment with a scale of 4= highly observed, 3= observed, 2= moderately observed and 1= not observed.

Structured and open-ended interview forms written in English and Filipino were constructed patterned after PSWO to determine the status of day care children’s development program and acceptability of the enhancement program. The structured interview form contains questions on curriculum, guidance and interactions, and assessment answerable by yes or no. On the other hand, the open-ended interview form contains questions on quality of program, usefulness to others and educational significance.

A 21- item acceptability questionnaire on the enhancement program patterned after the Rhode Island Department of Elementary and Secondary Education program evaluation questionnaire, 2007 was developed. It included statements on quality of program, usefulness to others and educational significance.

The 35- item pre/post assessments patterned after ECCD checklist, 2004 and Bethlehem Central School District Preschool Skills Rubrics, 2010 were developed to measure the performance of the day care children respondents before and after the tryout of the enhancement program. These intended to measure the skills in gross motor, fine motor, self-help, receptive language, expressive language, cognitive, and social-emotional domains.

Responses of the participants were analyzed using weighted mean, percentage, mean, Pearson r and t-test.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

1. Demographic Characteristics of Day Care Workers

Results of the study revealed that day care workers were predominantly female, aged 35- 64. Most of them were undergraduates and have been serving in day care centers for more than ten (10) years.

2. Status of Day Care Children’s Development Program

Management of curriculum was not a serious problem among the respondents. They were willing to comply in session planning, documenting, and reviewing the curriculum since they have concern on children’s development. They had adjusted with the mentioned tasks through their experiences with the help of MSWD heads/ workers .

Moreover, they executed physical exercises, interactive games, group indoor/ outdoor games at least twice a week and special activities once a year. These were going on field trips, inviting resource persons, gardening, cooking and making books.

All respondents had television and/ or karaoke in the center since parents or barangay council were supportive sponsors of audio-visual facilities. The day care children could view educational shows, sang, and dance with music. Thus, there was development of language, literacy, numeracy and problem solving skills. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

More so, the respondents used materials from natural environment that promote inquiry and self- discovery. They love collecting local resources from nature since these could be used freely. They also have resource center for children’s use located at the corner.

Despite its strengths, curriculum has problems in content and activities, as well as, in learning materials. Respondents have not observed integration of gender fairness and preventive education on child abuse and exploitation, as well as provision of puppetry, table games, dramatic play and poetry.

In terms of guidance and interactions, the respondents demonstrated meaningful gestures and desired behavior to children. They made eye contact while speaking, listening and responding to the children and let the children say what they feel as they gave positive reactions.

Despite its strengths, guidance and interactions have problems in the execution of child-directed and small group activities. They wanted to attend seminars on teaching strategies. But attending seminars was expensive so only few could avail them free.

In administering assessment, the respondents have been using mother tongue in assessment since it was mandated by DSWD and had been easy to use for communication. However, most of them had no rubrics and they had no idea to create even a single rubric. Use of rubrics started few years ago so they were not familiar with those.

3. Problems on Day Care Children’s Development Program

The foremost problem was neglect of executing child-directed and small group activities of guidance and interactions category. The second major problem was absence of rubrics and varied materials, especially in dramatic play, followed by neglect of integrating gender fairness and prevention from abuse and exploitation in some lessons. The least problem concerns varied creative activities.

4. Enhancement Program on Day Care Children’s Development

Based on the problems in the different areas, the enhancement program aimed to provide different activities such as child-directed and small group activities, integration of gender fairness and prevention from abuse and exploitation, provision of varied learning materials, different activities, and development of rubric compilation.

There was a tryout of the program’s outputs through the collaboration of the researcher, LGU, MSWD heads and day care workers. The LGU and sponsors were the sources of funds.

The tryout was successful since the experimental groups in the target locales performed better than the control groups.

5. Results of Test of Difference Between Experimental and Control Groups

It was hypothesized that experimental groups in all target locales performed better than the control groups.

There was rejection in the null hypothesis since there was a significant difference in the post- assessment scores between the two groups of respondents in all target locales. Thus, their mean performances in the post-assessment differed.

6. Results of Test of Correlation Between Day Care Children’s Performance and Day Care Workers’ Demographic Characteristics E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

The t-values of all target locales were significant. Thus, there was rejection in the null hypothesis since there was a significant correlation in the day care children’s performance and day care workers’ age and length of service. The age of day care workers normally affected children’s performance. The younger the day care worker, the higher the performance of the day care children. Their length of service influenced the highly advanced performance of the children.

7. Acceptability of the Enhancement Program on Day Care Children’s Development

The respondents highly accepted the enhancement program for the following reasons:

The mother-tongue based rubric compilation was appropriate to the present needs of the day care workers and children. Besides, the developed prototypic session guide and varied learning materials corresponded to the objectives of the enhancement program.

The program tied in with the objectives of Republic Act 8980, Section 5. It followed the national program goals and guidelines, instructional objectives and content outlines integrating local learning, experiences and indigenous learning materials.

More so, the program is useful since it is adaptable in multiple settings. The respondents trusted the program’s flexibility and usefulness since the indicated activities were appropriate for the children residing in Quezon province.

To further, the respondents believe that the program addresses important individual and societal needs with its design to improve learning among day care children for a wide spectrum. Thus, it has educational significance as it created significant difference in the children’s development as discovered during the tryout that the developed prototypic session guide and rubric compilation.

CONCLUSIONS

The respondents performed their tasks in curriculum, guidance and interactions, and assessment but they overlooked the integration of gender fairness and preventive education on child abuse and exploitation, provision of varied activities and materials, execution of child-directed and small group activities, and utilization of rubrics.

The demographic characteristics of day care workers, particularly age and length of service, have been affecting day care children’s performance. Children have higher performance under the care of younger and more experienced day care worker. However, sex and educational attainment of the day care worker did not affect the performance of the day care children.

More so, the enhancement program on day care children’s development was highly accepted as the performance of the experimental groups has shown highly advanced performance.

RECOMMENDATIONS

The government, particularly the DSWD, may support the needs of day care workers and children. Investment in day care program is important since it has immediate and long-term benefits to children. Hence, financial support is greatly needed.

More so, day care workers need trainings on the integration of gender fairness and prevention from abuse and exploitation, child-directed and small group activities. Seminars on instructional development, particularly on dramatic play props, and different early childhood activities may help them become more creative. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

Due to the successful tryout of the enhancement program, other municipalities may use the prototypic session guide and rubric compilation.

LITERATURE CITED

Aguiar, C. & Barros, S. 2010 Assessing the quality of Portuguese child care programs for toddlers. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, pages 527- 535.

Aina, O. & Cameron, P. 2011 Why does gender matter? counteracting stereotypes with young children. Retrieved fromhttp://www.southernearlychildhood.org/upload/pdf/Why_Does_Gender_Matter_Cou nteracting_Stereotypes_With_Young_Children_Olaiya_E_Aina_and_Petronella_A_Cam eron.pdf

Aldridge, J. & Goldman, R. 2012 Child development theories. Retrieved from http://www.education.com/reference/article/child-development-changing-theories/

Alexander, G.M. 2003 An Evolutionary Perspective of Sex-Typed Toy Preferences: Pink, Blue and the Brain. Archives of Sexual Behavior 32(1): 7-14.

Annenberg Institute for School Reform 2004 Professional learning communities: Professional development strategies that improve instruction. Retrieved from http://www.annenberginstitute.org /pdf/ProfLearning.pdf

Arellano Law Foundation 2013 Republic act 6972. Retrieved from http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1990/ra_6972_1990.html

Aussie Childcare Network 2009 Programming and planning. Retrieved fromhttp://www.aussiechildcarenetwork.com/programming_and_planning.php

Bago, A.L. 2008 Supervision of instruction: The philippine perspective. Manila:C & E Publishing Inc.

Baker-Sennett, J., et al 2008 Children's Planning of Classroom Plays with Adult or Child Direction. Social Development, 17(4), 998-1018. doi:10.1111/sode.2008.17.issue-4

Barron, I. G. and Topping, K. J. 2009 “School-based child sexual abuse prevention programs: A review of effectiveness”. In Review of Educational Research, Vol. 79, No. 1, 431-63

Behrman, J.R., H. et al 2004 Hunger and malnutrition. In Global crises, global solutions, edited by B. Lomborg. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Boonroj, P. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

2010 Use of mother tongue vital, studies show. Retrieved from http://www.nationmultimedia.com/home/2010/11/15/national/Use-of-mother-tongue- vital-studies-show30142230.html

Boyse, K. 2012 Developmental milestones. Retrieved from http://www.med.umich.edu/yourchild/topics/devmile.htm

Brizee, A. 2009 APA formatting and style guide. Retrieved from http://owl/english.purdue.edu/

Buivydas, R., et al 2011 Reinventing professional development. Behavioral Healthcare. Vol. 31, Iss. 1; pg. 34, 2

Burke, L. 2013 Effective communication techniques for child care. Retrieved from http://www.ehow.com/info_8017665_effective-communication-techniques-child- care.html

Cammilleri A.P, & Hanley G.P. 2005 Increasing varied selections of classroom activities. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 38:111–116

Chen, N. 2009 Tips on communicating with young children. Retrieved from http://missourifamilies.org/features/divorcearticles/relations64.htm Child Welfare Information Gateway 2009 Understanding the effects of maltreatment on brain development. Retrieved from https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/issue_briefs/brain_development/brain_development.p df

Colbert, J. 2008 Classroom design and how it influences behavior. Retrieved from http://www.earlychildhoodnews.com/earlychilhood/article_view.aspx?ArticleID=413

Cox, J. 2013 Teach cooperative learning strategies. Retrieved from http://k6educators.about.com/b/2013/04/12/teach-cooperative-learning-stategies.htm

Dean, K. 2008) Review child’s progress report. Retrieved fromhttp://www.mlive.com/opinion/flint/index.ssf/2008/10/review_childs_progress_repo rt.html

Department of Social Welfare andDevelopment 2002 Revised manual for day care workers. Manila: DSWD.

Department of Social Welfare andDevelopment 2006 User’s manual for the accreditation of center-based early childhood care and development programs. Manila: DSWD.

DepEd Order No. 74, s. 2009

Earl, L. 2003 Assessment as learning: Using classroom assessment to maximizestudent learning. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

Early Childhood Care Development Checklist 2004 Manila:DSWD ebook browse 2010 Bethlehem central school district preschool skills rubrics. Retrieved from http://ebookbrowse.com/gdoc.php? id=198381234&url=8130cc2514a0dc9b8af3569a645a96e3

Finkelhor, D. 2007 “Prevention of sexual abuse through educational programs directed toward children”. Paediatrics, Vol. 120 No. 3, 640-45

Gultiano, S. & King E. 2006 A better start in life: Evaluation results from an early childhood development program. Philippine Journal of Development. Volume 33, Numbers 1 & 2, pages 101- 126. Guyana Ministry of Education 2013 Early childhood education some key issues and challenges. Retrieved from http://www.stabroeknews.com/2009/guyana-review/08/20/early-childhood-education- some-key-issues-and-challenges/

Harder, A. 2012 The developmental stages of erik erikson. Retrieved from http://www.support4change.com/index.php? option=com_content&view=article&id=47&Itemid=108

Hashim, et al. n.d. Preparing lesson plans: Preschool teachers as instructional designers. Retrieved from http://ijg.cgpublisher.com/pro duct/pub.154/prod.182

Head Start 2008 What does research say about early childhood education? Retrieved from http://eclkc.ohs.acf.hhs.gov/hslc/tta- system/teaching/eecd/Curriculum/Planning/edudev_art_00421_081806.html

Hebert, M. 2011 Building a team: Developmental stages of a teacher. Retrieved from http://www.marciahebert.com/2011/02/building-a-team-the-developmental-stages-of-a- teacher/

Isenberg, J. & Quisenberry, N. 2002 Play: Essential for all children. Retrieved fromhttp://www.ci.pleasanton.ca.us/services/recreation/gb/gbplayessentials.html

Klein, L. & Knitzer, J. 2006 Effective preschool curricula and teaching strategies. Retrieved from https://docs.google.com/viewer? a=v&q=cache:EFQZl6KF2VQJ:academiccommons.columbia.edu/download/fedora_cont ent/download/ac:127347/CONTENT/text_668.pdf+why+do+childcare+providers+need+t raining+on+teaching+strategies&hl=fil&gl=ph&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESgwFIRhRX2rW JXgaWvrQzXcr7UCsAs0XQolplKshaJCIXcJdBLZz8iatIFP1I9iNiOmOeF8himiAIuPgwf 9KNvPAvJ3uONXhTApr1aJdAd1DRGHjSQNzlEaEcSYlH1jeggfU&sig=AHIEtbTaB6_ KbAvFjaW75_uNvE6ZQuhHZA

Kroeger, J., & Cardy, T. 2006 Documentation: A hard-to-reach place. Early Childhood Education Journal 33 (6): 389– 98. E-International Research Journal Vol. 6 Issue 3, 2014

Latzko, L. 2013 Anti bias activities in the classroom. Retrieved from http://www.ehow.com/info_8662761_anti-bias-activities-classroom.html

Lee, L. 2008 Understanding gender through Disney’s marriages: A study of young Korean immigrant girls. Early Childhood Education Journal, 36(1), 11-18.

Louv, R. 2005 Last child in the woods: Saving out children from nature-deficit disorder. Chapel Hill, NC: Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill.

Mayglothling, R. 2009 How to teach preschoolers to read. Retrieved from http://www.helium.com/items/1654223-tips-on-teaching-kids-preschoolers-and- kindergarteners-to-read

McCain, M. N., & Mustard, J. F. 2002 The early years study three years later. Toronto, ON: The Founders’ Network.

Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India 2012 Early childhood education framework (draft). Retrieved from http://wcd.nic.in/schemes/ECCE/curriclum_draft_5%5B1%5D %20%281%29%20%289%29.pdf

Mitchell, S., et al 2009 The negotiated project approach: Project-based learning without leaving standards behind. Early Childhood Education Journal, 36 (4), 339-346.

National Childcare Accreditation Council 2004 Child care adviser Q& A- keeping records of children’s progress. Retrieved fromhttp://ncac.acecqa.gov.au/educator-resources/pcf-articles/ACCA_K eeping_Records_Sept04.pdf

NAEYC) & NAECS/SDE 2003 Position Statement: Early childhood curriculum, assessment, and program evaluation: Building an effective, accountable system in programs for children birth through age 8. Washington DC:NAEYC.

Natoli, C. 2011 The importance of audio-visual materials in teaching and learning. Retrieved from http://www.helium.com/items/20 78804-