Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel s6

PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL

5th June, 2003

Meeting commenced: 10.00 a.m. " ended: 12 noon

PRESENT: Councillor J. Holt - in the Chair Councillors Antrobus, Broughton, Clague, Garrido, Heywood, Hincks, Kean, Smyth and Witkowski

Mr. J. Wheelton - Salford Disabled Motorists Association

ALSO PRESENT: Councillor Merry, Sheehy and Upton

398. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies for absence were submitted on behalf of Councillors E. Burgoyne and B. P. Murphy.

399. APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

(Full details of the matters referred to in this Minute and Minutes 400 to 401 (inclusive) are contained in the report of the Director of Development Services as amended, in the case of the applications marked * in his supplementary report).

RESOLVED: THAT, pursuant to the powers delegated to this Panel, the undermentioned applications for planning permission, be dealt with as indicated:-

Application Site Development Decision Number/ Applicant 02/43633 19 Mill Brow, Erection of a single storey side Refused I. Foulkes Worsley extension and a two storey rear extension +03/45570 Ellesmere Demolition of an existing Deferred for a Gachet House, 1 nursing home and erection of site inspection Developments Sandwich Road, one 4 storey building to assess the Ltd. Eccles comprising of twenty five impact of the apartments together with development associated car parking on the area +03/45579 Ellesmere Conservation area consent for Deferred for a Gachet House, 1 the demolition of existing site inspection Developments Sandwich Road, building to assess the Ltd. Eccles impact of the development on the area.

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc 03/45704 Former Erection of 42 dwellings Refused by Woodford Shopping together with associated car vote of 7 for Homes Ltd. Centre, parking, construction of new and 3 Liverpool Road, vehicular access and closure abstentions, Irlam of footpath to the northeast of due to the the site. scale and design of the proposed development and its relationship with existing properties. 03/45787 Land at Change of use of public open Granted Charlestown, Gloucester space to a children’s play area Lower Kersal, Place, (Upper and erection of 1.2m high NDC Gloucester fencing Partnership Street), Salford 6 *03/45890 Agecroft Hall Erection of 37 dwellings Granted George Residential Site, together with an amendment Wimpey Agecroft Road, to the road layout Manchester Pendlebury, Swinton *03/45908 Vacant Site at Details of the landscaping Granted Ainsworth Memorial Road/ scheme in respect of the Estates Stanley Road, erection of 27 dwellings Worsley *03/45950 Land at Erection of ten dwellings Granted Oakwood Southern End of together with the creation of a Homes Drywood new pedestrian and vehicular Limited Avenue, access Worsley 03/45951 Land at Barton Details of the siting, design See Minute Texas Group Hall, Hardy and external appearance of 74 400 PLC Street, Peel dwellings together with the Green, Eccles creation of a new vehicular and pedestrian access and associated landscaping including public open space 03/45956 ‘Edgely, 4 Erection of single storey rear Granted Mr. and Mrs. Enfield Road, extension and extension to D.P. Eccles existing garage Birchenough +03/45969 Units 24 and 26 Change of use from shop to Granted with Spurgeons Hulton District drop in community centre an additional Childcare Centre, condition Manchester restricting the Road East, Little hours of use

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc Hulton, Worsley 03/46004 9 Enfield Road, Erection of a two storey side Granted Mr. P. Swinton extension and a rear single Sharples storey extension *03/46016 Geith Works, Erection of four general Granted A.P. Rowlett Weymouth industrial units (Class B2) Road, Winton, together with associated car Eccles parking 03/46021 61 Wildbrook Erection of a single storey side Granted New Prospect Road, Worsley and rear extension Housing 03/46023 33 Firfield Erection of two storey side and Granted Mr. Surgenor Grove, two storey rear extensions Walkden, Worsley 03/46030 32 Farnham Erection of a single storey side Granted P.T. Rittaler Drive, Irlam extension *03/46031 Beechfield Conversion of existing Granted with Whispers House, Fourth building to six apartments and an additional Developments Avenue, erection of a two storey side condition Swinton extension to provide five requiring that additional apartments each tree removed, is replaced by two. *03/46038 15 Alfred Street, Erection of single storey rear Deferred for a D. Wright Eccles extension site inspection to assess the impact of the proposed development on the neighbouring property 03/46055 Land to rear of Erection of one pair of semi- Granted with Hedley Homes 54 Ringlow Park detached dwellings together additional Road, Swinton with associated landscaping conditions to (re-submission of planning protect the application 03/45373/FUL) access road and to require the removal of the balcony adjacent to Lampton Road 03/46078 Former Car Continued use of site for the Granted New Prospect Park adjacent to storage of plant and materials Housing 118 to 124 (renewal of planning Riverside, application 02/44712/DEEM3) Salford 7

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc 03/46085 5 Marlow Drive, Erection of a two storey side Granted Mrs. N. Moore Swinton extension and a single storey rear extension with detached garage *03/46086 Land to the rear Erection of a terrace of five Granted with S.J. Lee of 320 dwellings and garages and additional Ellenbrook construction of new vehicular conditions, (a) Road, Worsley access (Amendment to requiring that planning application each tree 03/45860/FUL) removed is replaced by two and (b) that the boundary wall be retained and maintained

+ Councillor Karen Garrido declared an interest in planning application nos. 03/45570 and 03/45579.

+ Councillor Alice Smyth declared an interest in planning application no. 03/45969.

400. PLANNING APPLICATION NO. 03/45951/REM, TEXAS GROUP PLC, LAND AT BARTON HALL, HARDY STREET, PEEL GREEN, ECCLES, DETAILS OF THE SITING, DESIGN AND EXTERNAL APPEARANCE OF 74 DWELLINGS, TOGETHER WITH THE CREATION OF A NEW VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS AND ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING INCLUDING PUBLIC OPEN SPACE – SECTION 106 AGREEMENT

RESOLVED: (1) THAT the Director of Corporate Services be authorised to enter into a legal agreement to secure the provision of an area of public open space, together with any necessary works, infrastructure and related equipment thereon, commensurate in scale and size with the total number of bed spaces to be provided on the site, together with a commuted sum of £45,585.00 equivalent to 10 years maintenance of such a site.

(2) THAT the applicant be informed that the Council is minded to grant planning permission subject to the conditions as detailed in the report now submitted and on completion of such legal agreement.

(3) THAT authority be given for the decision notice relating to the application to be issued, (subject to the conditions and reasons as detailed in the report now submitted) on completion of the abovementioned agreement.

(4) THAT authority be given to refuse the application if the applicant fails to complete the section 106 agreement within a reasonable period on the grounds that the proposals do not support the aims and objectives of policies H6 and H11 of the Unitary Development Plan.

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc

401. PROPOSALS OF DIRECTORATES AND SCHOOLS

The Director of Development Services submitted details of applications for planning consent submitted by directorates and schools.

RESOLVED: THAT, pursuant to the powers delegated to this Panel, the undermentioned applications be dealt with as follows:-

Application Site Development Decision Number/ Applicant 03/45994 Light Oaks Junior Erection of a single storey Granted Education and School, Lancaster extension and alteration to the Leisure Road, Salford 6 front elevation Directorate 03/45995 Light Oaks Infant Erection of a single storey Granted Education and School, Lancaster extension and alterations to the Leisure Road, Salford 6 elevation Directorate 03/46017 Belvedere Early Erection of a single storey infill Granted Belvedere Years Centre, extension to provide additional Early Years Belvedere Road, office accommodation Centre (FAO Salford 6 Mrs. A. More)

402. PLANNING APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY

The Director of Development Services submitted a report containing details of planning applications which had been determined under delegated authority during May, 2003, and were not, therefore, for consideration by the Panel. RESOLVED: THAT the undermentioned applications be noted:-

Application Site Development Date of Number/ Decision and Applicant Decision 03/45984 5 Ampney Erection of conservatory at rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Close, Eccles of dwelling 13th May, 2003 M. Pemberton 03/46047 Adelphi Court Provisions of cover strips to Approve Northern and Mathias horizontal movement joints and 20th May, 2003 Housing Court, Cannon enclosure of balconies with Association Street, Salford glazed units Ltd. 3 03/45847 2/4 Welbeck Erection of single storey rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Grove, Salford extension 16th May, 2003 Ehrentreu 7 03/45861 8 Norman Erection of two storey side/ Refuse

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc Mr. D. Kahan Road, Salford 7 single storey rear extension 16th May, 2003 and front porch 02/45270 Lower Stanley Erection of a detached Refuse A. Broster Bank Farm, bungalow together with 22nd May, 2003 Moss Road, alterations to existing vehicular Cadishead access 03/45828 JLD Haulage, Erection of a 20m high Refuse Orange PCS Fairhills telecommunications tower with 12th May, 2003 Industrial equipment cabinet, six Estate, antennae, four dishes and Woodrow Way, associated equipment Irlam 03/45855 531 Liverpool Erection of single storey Approve Mr. H.S. Road, Irlam side/front extension and 14th May, 2003 Heera erection of rear porch and alterations to roof at rear 03/45878 131 Lords Erection of detached garage at Approve N. Bailey Street, side of dwelling 20th May, 2003 Cadishead 03/45959 24 Rose Erection of rear conservatory Approve Mr. and Mrs. Avenue, Irlam 13th May, 2003 P. Griffiths 03/45962 25 Essex Erection of single storey side Approve N. Riordan Gardens, Irlam, extension and front porch 13th May, 2003 Cadishead 03/45881 14 Claremont Change of use from single Approve C. White Road, Salford 6 dwelling to two flats 21st May, 2003 03/45894 35 Orme Outline application for use of Approve B. Jones Avenue, Salford land for residential purposes 16th May, 2003 6 03/45789 8 Rutland Erection of first floor front and Refuse G. and P. Road, Eccles side extension and front porch 14th May, 2003 Simpson 03/45942 237/239 Erection of rear extension at Approve Bennett’s Monton Road, basement, ground and first 16th May, 2003 Furnishings Monton, Eccles floor levels (Re-submission of planning application 02/44727/FUL) 03/45947 8 Preston Prune one horse chestnut (T1) Approve Mrs. M. Platt Close, Preston 12th May, 2003 Avenue), Eccles 03/46048 Floor 3, Peel Change of use from offices to Approve Salford House, Albert temporary use as a clinic 22nd May, 2003 Primary Care Street, Eccles Trust (Fao M. Marney) 03/45725 204 Liverpool Erection of two storey side Refuse Mr. B. Road, Irlam extension 13th May, 2003 D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc Jessop 03/45830 49 Sunflower Demolition of garage and Approve Mr. and Mrs. Meadow, Irlam erection of two storey side 13th May, 2003 Ashton extension (resubmission of planning application 03/45342) 03/45852 93 Lyndhurst Erection of conservatory on the Refuse Ms. H. Night Avenue, Irlam side of the property 12th May, 2003 03/45650 Belz Erection of an annexe to Approve Belz Community, 28 synagogue 13th May, 2003 Community Broom Lane, Manchester Salford 7 03/45960 45 Broom Lane, Erection of single storey rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Salford 7 extension and part single/part 13th May, 2003 M. De Lange two storey side extension 03/46008 20 Oaklands Fell one sycamore (T1) Refuse Graeme Road, Salford 7 20th May, 2003 Kellett 03/46012 11 Old Hall Erection of two storey side Approve Mr. and Mrs. Road, Salford 7 extension/single storey 23rd May, 2003 Gutterman side/rear extension and two storey rear extension (resubmission of planning application 03/45515/HH) 03/46046 9 Westwood Erection of single storey rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Avenue, Salford extension 23rd May, 2003 Y. Hess 7 03/46163 43 Stanley Fell one rowan (T1) Approve G. Brodie Road, Salford 7 23rd May, 2003 03/45808 One Stop Shop, Display of externally illuminated Approve Salford Harrop Fold projecting sign 16th May, 2003 College School, Longshaw Drive, Little Hulton, Worsley 03/45869 Unit 3, King Erection of first floor extension Approve R. Fisher William Street, to provide additional office 20th May, 2003 Construction Salford 5 accommodation Ltd. 03/45928 Glenn House, Erection of single storey Approve World Houston Park, extension and two storey stair 15th May, 2003 Harvest Bible Montford Street, tower to front of church Church Salford 5 including creation of new pedestrian access to South Langworthy Road (resubmission of previous application number 03/45489/FUL) 03/45977 10 Oakwood Erection of two storey side Approve Mr. and Mrs. Avenue, Clifton extension 23rd May, 2003 D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc M. Nangle

03/46010 4 Batsmans Erection of a single storey rear Approve Mrs. A. Drive, Clifton extension 20th May, 2003 Harper 03/46033 1 Wakefield Demolition of existing Approve Mr. Lomas Drive, Clifton, conservatory and erection of 23rd May, 2003 Swinton single storey rear extension and extension to front of existing garage 03/46043 Salford College Retention of portal structure Approve Salford City Campus, teaching facility 20th May, 2003 College Lissadel Street, Salford 6 03/45835 Land to rear of Erection of a detached garage Approve Mrs. R. 91 Moss Lane, 20th May, 2003 Schofield Swinton 03/45844 15 Moss Bank Construction of dormer Refuse Mr. A. Road, Swinton extension in front and rear 13th May, 2003 Leeming roofspace 03/46009 21 Worcester Erection of conservatory at the Approve Mr. Gary Road, Wardley, rear of the property 16th May, 2003 Rawling Worsley 03/45914 37 Ashley Demolition of existing garage Approve S. Massey Drive, Swinton and outrigger and erection of 23rd May, 2003 part single/part two storey side/ rear extension 03/45989 59 Waverley Erection of conservatory to the Approve Mr. B. Road, Swinton rear of the property 16th May, 2003 Blinston 03/46027 23 Sheringham Erection of single storey side Refuse J. Farahani Drive, Swinton extension 23rd May, 2003 03/45996 32 Orlanda Erection of conservatory on the Approve Mr. and Mrs. Avenue, Salford side of the property 16th May, 2003 Cowell 6 02/45329 308 Worsley Erection of single storey rear Approve Wallwork Road, Swinton extension and construction of 13th May, 2003 Optician steps to entrance 03/45730 5 Leaconfield Erection of extensions to form Approve A.P. Rowlett Drive, Worsley two storey dwelling and 14th May, 2003 erection of conservatory at rear 03/45757 71 Vicars Hall Relocation of 1.83m high Approve D. Millar Gardens, existing fence 12th May 2003 Boothstown, Worsley 03/45822 22 Parkstone Erection of two storey side Approve Mrs. Walker Lane, Worsley extension 13th May, 2003 03/45843 St. Marks C.E. Siting of a mobile classroom Approve The Primary School, and erection of 2.4m high 12th May, 2003 D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc Governors of Aviary Road, security fencing St. Marks Worsley C.E. Primary School 03/45895 43 Lambton Erection of two storey side/rear Approve Michael Road, Worsley extension and conservatory to 14th May, 2003 Dawson the rear 03/45909 60 Douglas Erection of two storey side Approve M. Meadows Road, Worsley extension and part single/part 13th May, 2003 two storey rear extension 03/45910 2 Granby Road, Erection of single storey rear Approve P.H. Daley Swinton extension 14th May, 2003 03/45919 47 Farm Lane, Erection of two storey side Refuse G. Harding Worsley extension and single storey 20th May, 2003 side/rear extension 03/45944 Passageway Construction of covered fire Approve D. Myangar between 7/9 escape between properties 13th May, 2003 and 11 Leigh Road, Worsley 03/45955 231 Leigh Erection of single storey side Approve P. Edwards Road, Worsley extension and rear 22nd May, 2003 conservatory 03/45982 292 Leigh Construction of new vehicular Approve Broom Edge Road, Worsley and pedestrian access 16th May, 2003 Properties 03/46000 19 Sefton Drive, Replace flat roof of single Approve Mr. and Mrs. Worsley storey rear extension to sloping 23rd May, 2003 Birchby roof 03/46005 12 Turfnell Erection of two storey side Approve Damien Way, Worsley extension and erection of 16th May, 2003 McElvenny conservatory to the rear of the property 03/46019 1 Kempnough Erection of single storey side/ Approve Mr. and Mrs. Hall Road, rear extension 16th May, 2003 P. Goucher Worsley 03/46070 40 Birchfield Erection of side extension at Approve Lynn Drive, first floor level including 23rd May, 2003 Svolkinas Boothstown, construction of two dormers Worsley 03/45859 40 Cambell Erection of a two storey side Approve Mr. D. Road, Eccles extension 20th May, 2003 McNulty 03/45892 Land at rear of Outline application for the use Refuse Hopehold 356/358 of land for residential purposes 20th May, 2003 Limited Worsley Road, Winton, Eccles 03/45893 356/358 Erection of single storey rear Approve Holdhope Worsley Road, extension and erection of roller 20th May, 2003 Limited Winton, Eccles shutters over rear access doors D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc 03/45886 70 Walkden Display of externally illuminated Split decision Carl Road, Worsley sign above fascia and internally 20th May, 2003 Mollinson illuminated projecting sign 03/45917 12 Laurel Drive, Erection of single storey side/ Approve J. Winstanley Little Hulton, rear extension 23rd May, 2003 Worsley 03/45957 1 Greenoak Erection of conservatory at rear Approve Mr. Snelson Drive, Walkden, of dwelling 13th May, 2003 Worsley 03/45814 117 Manchester Erection of a two storey side Approve Ian Stewart Road East, extension 21st May, 2003 Little Hulton, Worsley 03/45829 Land adjacent Improvements to maintenance Approve The Coal to 15 Rose access to Ellen Brook culvert 12th May, 2003 Authority Acre, Worsley comprising of hardcore path timber edged step and safety fencing 03/45871 Recomac Siting of a temporary office Refuse Recomac Surfacing Ltd., building 20th May, 2003 Surfacing Parsonage Ltd. Road, Worsley 03/45970 141 Walkden Erection of part single/part two Refuse Mr. and Mrs. Road, Worsley storey rear extension (Re- 21st May, 2003 T. Worsley submission of 02/44331/FUL) 03/45988 475 Hilton Demolition of existing rear Approve Mr. S. Lane, Walkden, extension of a new single 14th May, 2003 Haydock Worsley storey rear extension 03/45990 1 Habergham Erection of a garage on the Refuse Mr. and Mrs. Close, Worsley side of the property 16th May, 2003 C. Bowers 03/45991 159 Newearth Demolition of existing kitchen Approve Mr. P. Road, Walkden, extension and erection of single 16th May, 2003 Murphy Worsley storey rear extension 03/45997 Mesne Lea Erection of a 2.4m high Approve Mesne Lea Primary School, palisade fence and 2.4m high 22nd May, 2003 C.P. School Henniker crusader railings (FAO T. Street, Barnes) (Walkden Road), Worsley 03/46013 38 Kingsway, Erection of conservatory at the Approve Mr. and Mrs. Walkden, rear of the property 22nd May, 2003 Hollowood Worsley 03/46026 342 Walkden Erection of conservatory at rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Road, Worsley of dwelling 16th May, 2003 Corless 03/46034 5 Edge Fold Construction of bay window to Approve Mr. and Mrs. Crescent, the front of the house and a 23rd May, 2003 A. Steeles Worsley pitched roof over the bay D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc window and existing front entrance 03/46035 14 Chilham Erection of single storey rear Approve Mr. and Mrs. Road, Walkden, extension 23rd May, 2003 Dickens Worsley 03/46044 136-138 Change of use from offices with Approve Manchester Walkden Road, living accommodation into two 20th May, 2003 Life and Worsley dwellings Pensions Ltd.

403. BEST VALUE INSPECTION

Dave Jolley reported that a Best Value Inspection would be carried out on 16 th June, 2003 and Members of the Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel were requested to attend a briefing session in relation thereto on 12th June, 2003, following the planning visits.

RESOLVED: THAT the information be noted.

404. ANNUAL TRAINING FOR MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL

Dave Jolley reported that the annual training session for Members of the Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel would be held in July, 2003 at Worsley Court House.

405. OMBUDSMAN INVESTIGATION – TELECOMMUNICATIONS MAST IN SWINDON

Tom Mitchell reported that (a) following a recent investigation relating to a local planning authority failing to notify a telecommunications operator of objections to the proposed erection of a mast, the Ombudsman instructed that Swindon Council should pay compensation to the local residents and (b) Salford City Council were aware of the timescales involved with such applications and procedures were in place to avoid similar action being taken.

D:\Docs\2018-05-01\0b13f94f730fbdf32b39381ffa740bbf.doc