List of Cases Filed on Grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy

List of cases filed on grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy

GRANT OF MACP ON PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY:

LIST OF CASES FILED

The list of cases filed on the subject is given below for your reference.

O.A.No., S Date of Name of CWP.No. SLP Parties Remarks L Order court Civil (CC) No

RAJPAL Vs UoI & Others

OA Raj Pal s/o OA is allowed for No.1038/CH/2 Tilak Ram, 31.5.201 CAT, grant of MACP in 1 010 (Advocate CAT, 1 Chandigarh. the hierarchy of : Mr. Chandigarh Promotional post. V.K.Verma) 2 CWP Union of India 19.10.20 High Court Order dated 31-

No.19387 of represented by 11 of Punjab 5-2011 of

(O&M) DoP&T and and Hon’ble CAT,

(Advocate : others Vs. Raj Haryana at Chandigarh is

D.K.Bhisnoi) Pal and Chandigarh upheld. CWP filed by

another. Respondents

dismissed. SLP No.cc- Union of India 7467 of 2013 represented by against order Supreme SLP filed by the DoP&T and 15.4.201 3 dated 19-10- Court of Union of India is others Vs. Raj 3 2011 of the India dismissed Pal and Hon’ble High another. Court

SANJAY KUMAR & Ors Vs UoI & Ors

OA is allowed for Sanjay Kumar, OA grant of MACP in UDC and 18 CAT, No.904/2012 next promotional others Vs. UOI 26.11.20 Principal 4 (Mr. post i.e. nted byMinistry 12 Bench, New M.K.Bhardwaj Assistant in PB- of Defense and Delhi. ) 2+Grade others. PayRs.4200. 5 W.P.(C) UNION OF Delhi High Hearing Date

4552/2013 INDIA Vs. Court Court No. 5 Next [PENDING] SANJAY

(Mr. M.K. KUMAR & Date: 04/09/2014

Bhardwaj) ORS. M V Mahanan Nair Vs UoI & Ors

M.V.Mohanan

Nair, S/o

M.R.Vishwanat CAT, OA is allowed for han Nair, PrincipalBen consideration of Photocopier 29.1.201 6 OA No.816/12 ch MACP in the CAT, 3 Ernakulam hierarchy of Ernakulam Bench promotional post. Bench & others

Vs Union of

India UOI & In the result, this OP(CAT). ORS. .Vs. High court 24.06.20 original petition is 7 NO.2000 OF M.V. of Kerala at 13 dismissed in 2013 (Z) MOHANAN Ernakulam limine NAIR 8 Special Leave UOI & ORS. Supreme PENDING

Petition (Civil) .Vs. M.V. Court of 21803 OF MOHANAN India 2014 NAIR Mahendra

Kumar Dubey,

S/o Sh. R.D.

Dubey,

Working as OA is allowed for

OA No.1798 Programme consideration of

of 2014 Executive, In MACP in the 22.05.20 9 Advocate : Doordarsan Cat Delhi hierarchy of 14 Shri Yogesh Kendra, Delhi promotional post

Sharma VS UOI within a period of

through the one month

Secretary,

Ministry of

lnformation &

Broadcastin KISHAN SWARUP SHARMA Vs SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF

AGRICULTURE

1 OA Kishan Swarup 31.07.20 CAT, New OA is allowed Sharma,

No.2548/2014 working as For consider the MA PPO(E), case of the No.2167/2014 Meerut & 28 0 14 Delhi applicants in the (Advocate : others V/S light of the Shri Secretary, aforesaid orders M.K.Bhardwaj Ministry of

Agriculture, PRADEEP KUMAR Vs SECRETARY MIN. OF INFORMATION &

BROADCASTING

1 OA No.988 of Pradeep 22.03.20 CAT. New in view of the

1 2014 MA Kumar. AE (C) 14 Delhi above position.

No.872 of Rohini, Delhi & we dispose of

2014 20 others VS this OA at the

(Advocate : Secretary, admission stage

Shri M.K. Ministry of itself with the

Bhardwaj Information & direction to the

Broadcasting, respondents to

Shastri consider the

Bhawan. New representations Delhi of the applicants

in the light of the

judgment of

Punjab and

Haryana High

Court in CWP

No.19387/2011

(supra) as upheld

by the Apex

Court in SLP

No.7467/2013(su

pra) and decide

their cases under

intimation to

them. The

aforesaid

exercise shall be

completed within

a period of one

month from the date of receipt of

a copy of this

order. There

shall be no order

as to costs. 1 O.A. No. Mohd Hamid 23.05.20 Central In view of the

2 1834/2014 Hussain, 14 Administrati aforesaid

Advocate: Shri Working as ve Tribunal submission made

Yogesh APRO PrincipalBen by the applicants

Sharma. (Defence), ch New and the

Sr.Grade Delhi documents

Group B available on

Officer In the record. we

office of: DPR, dispose of this

Ministry of OA at the

Defence New admission stage

Delhi- & 34 itself with a

others VS UOI direction to the

through the respondents to

Secretary, consider the

Ministry of case of the applicants in

terms of the

aforesaid orders

within a period of

two months from

Information the date of

and receipt of a copy

Broadcasting, of this order. if

the applicants

are similarly

placed, they shall

also be treated

alike OM PRAKASH Vs SECRETARY, NCERT

1 OA 864/2014 Shri Om 12.3.201 Central In view of the

3 Advocate: Shri Prakash 4 Administrati above position.

M.K. NCERT, New ve Tribunal we dispose of

Bhardwaj) Delhi VS PrincipalBen this OA at the

Secretary ch, New admission stage

(NCERT) New Delhi itself with the Delhi direction to the

respondents to

consider the

representations

of the applicants

in the light of the

judgment of

Punjab and

Haryana High

Court in CWP

No.19387/2011

(supra) as upheld

by the Apex

Court in SLP

No.7467/2013(su

pra) and decide

their cases under

intimation to

them. The

aforesaid exercise shall be

completed within

a period of one

month from the

date of receipt of

a cop of this

order. NCERT,New High court CWP filed by 1 W.P.(C) Delhi VS Shri 14.07.20 of Delhi at Respondents 4 3608/2014 Om Prakash & 14 New Delhi dismissed. others BABU RAM VS UoI

1 O.A. Sh. Babu Ram, 09.05.20 CAT allow this OA in

5 1281/CH/2012 working as 13 CHNDIGAR terms of the view

ADVOCATE: Upper Division H BENCH obtained in terms

SHRI ROHIT Clerk, working of the view

SETH in the Central obtained in the

Administrative OA.

Tribunal, 1038/CH/11and

opposite the judgments (Annexures A-11

to A-13). The

compliance of

the order must

ideally come Shivalik View about within two Hotel, Sector months from the 17, Chandigarh date a copy of VS UOI this order is

presented in the

office of the

competent

authority. see order of even

date passed in HIGH U.O.I. .Vs. CWP No.24278 1 CWP No. 07.11.20 COURT OF BABU RAM & of 2013 (UOI and 6 24279 of 2013 13 PUNJAB & ORS. another versus HARYANA Smt.Reeta Devi

and another 1 Special Leave U.O.I. .Vs. Supreme Pending to Petition BABU RAM & Court of 7 (Civil)10435 ORS India OF 2014 DHIRENDER SINGH & Ors Vs UoI

For orders, see

order of even

Civil Writ date passed in High Court Petition U,O.I. .Vs. CWP No.24278 1 07.11.20 Of Punjab & No.24253 of DHIRENDER of 2013 (Union of 8 13 Haryana At 2013 Date of SINGH & ORS. India and another Chandigarh Decision: versus Smt.

Reeta Devi and

another). Special Leave

to U.O.I. .Vs. Supreme 1 Petition(Civil) DHIRENDER Court of Pending 9 …. 10436 OF SINGH & ORS. India

2014 2 O.A. Smt. Reeta 22.05.20 Cat After going

0 12/CH/2013 Devi, Senior 13 Chandigarh through the

By Advocate: Library Bench judgment passed Mr.Madan Attendant, CAT in the case of Raj

Mohan Bench. Pal (supra), we

Chandigarh. are in full

Versus Union agreement with

of India the learned

counsel for the

parties.

Accordingly, the

present original

application is

allowed in same

term as of Raj

Pal (supra).

Consequently,

we quash the

orders at

Annexures A-1 &

A-2. The

respondents are

further directed

to grant the benefit of 2nd

MACP in the pay

band of Rs.9300-

34800 with grade

pay of Rs.4600/-

from 1.3.2009

(which is the pay

scale of next post

in the hierarchy).

The respondents

are directed to

comply with the

judgment within a

period of three

months from the

date of receipt of

a copy of this

order. 2 CWP No. Union of India 07.11.20 High Court CWP filed by

1 24278 of 2013 VS Smt. Reeta 14 Of Punjab Respondents

Devi, & and &Haryana dismissed others Special Leave U.O.I. & ORS. Supreme 2 Petition(Civil) Vs. REETA Court of pending 2 22181 OF DEVI India 2014 NARAYAN KALITA Vs UoI

OA is allowed.

for grant of Narayan Kalita Date of MACP in the CPWD order hierarchy of Guwahati VS 25.06.20 Promotional O.A. No. UOI CAT 2 14 Date post. 040/00052/20 Represented Guwahati 3 of Respondent is 14 by Secretary Bench Delivery directed to grant GOI, Ministry of Order scale of pay (PB- of Urban and 7.8.2014 3) of Rs. 15600- Develoment 39100 + Grade

pay 6600/- 2 OA( 1727/201 CAT, next date of its

4 4) was filed Principal hearing has been

by CPWD Bench, New fixed by CAT on Engineers‘

Association in

regarding

MACP as per Delhi on 24/09/2014

promotional

hierarchy on

19.5.2014 case filed by

the Junior next date of its

2 Clerks of hearing has been CAT Kolkata 5 Railway -OA fixed by CAT on

No. 1509 of 8th Dec. 2014