DANUBEPARKS Position Paper: Electric Power Lines and Bird Conservation along the Danube River
Project co-funded by the European Union (ERDF, IPA funds)
DANUBEparksCONNECTED ,PSULQW
In cooperation with BirdLife Österreich and Danube Delta National Institute
Editing & Text: Remo Probst (BirdLife Austria), Alexandru Dorosencu (Danube Delta National Institute) & Georg Frank (DANUBEPARKS)
Contributions: Stephanie Blutaumüller, Walter Böhmer, Gabriela Cretu, Attila Fersch, Andrea Froncova, 0ECłNA@$AEnHAN )Q?E=!AQPO?DKR¹ *=NAG$¹HEO $UQH=(EOO $=>NEAH=*KNKVKR 1E>KN*EGQĊG= &KJ*QJPA=JQ 1E>KN-=NN=C "IEHEU=-APGKR= 3HP=GK/KĜ=? 1DKI=O0?DJAE@AN
Layout: Maps:HAT=J@QN!KNKOAJ?Q !=IEN*=OE?Ġ!+2 "-/(0 /=LD=AH-NEJVĠ!+2 "-/(0
Cover Pictures: Georg Frank (DANUBEPARKS)
Proofreading: Benjamin Seaman
Print:(KJPN=OVP-HQOV(BP
1DEOLNKFA?PEO?KBQJ@A@>UPDA"QNKLA=J2JEKJĠ"/!# &-BQJ@O
KLUNECDPNAOANRA@ © DANUBEPARKS 2019 DANUBEparksCONNECTED
7DEOHRIFRQWHQWV
Synopsis and aims of the Position Paper4 Birds and power lines – introductory background5 4HEÒ$ANUBEÒkÒFACTSÒANDÒµGURES7 -NKłHA 7 =?G>KJABKN>EK@ERANOEPU7 0PQ@U=NA=8 Power line network10 Current knowledge13 Expert assessment and potential impacts14 Current mitigation measures14 Prioritisation of protection measures Need for prioritisation Collision Electrocution23 Bird-friendly solutions25 -NAHEIEJ=NUAT=JEI=PEKJO=J@LNKFA?P=OOAOOIAJPO25 +AA@O=J=HUOEO=J@HAC=H>=?GCNKQJ@25 3=NE=JP?DA?G25 New construction or conversion Construction versus operation phase 1A?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJO=C=EJOP?KHHEOEKJ 2J@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJC *=NGEJCKBLKSANHEJAOSEPD>EN@@ERANPANO27 !A?KJOPNQ?PEKJKBLKSANHEJAO29 %=>EP=PIK@Eł?=PEKJOPKIEJEIEOANEOGKB?KHHEOEKJ30 1A?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJO=C=EJOPAHA?PNK?QPEKJ30 Underground cabling30 -NEI=NUOQNB=?AOKHQPEKJO30 0A?KJ@=NUOQNB=?AOKHQPEKJO31 *EOOEJCKNQJOQEP=>HAOKHQPEKJO31 DANUBE FREE SKY – a model for bird conservation at large rivers in Europe32 Acknowledgements33 Literature34 Annex 1: Danube-wide inventory of power lines along the Danube river38 Annex 2: Electricity pylons and their risk for birds related to electrocution Annex 3: List of Special Protected Areas for Birds (Natura 2000 SPA) and Important Bird Areas (IBAs, in the case of Serbia) located in the project area 6\QRSVLVDQGDLPVRIWKH3RVLWLRQ3DSHU
• 1DA!=JQ>A/ERANEO=>=?G>KJAKB>EK@ERANOEPUEJ"QNKLA1DA=NA=EODKIAPKI=JU>EN@OLA?EAO PD=P>NAA@ NAOPKNOLAJ@PDASEJPANDANA
• 1DANAEO=J=>QJ@=J?AKBLKSANHEJAOPDNKQCDKQPPDAAJPENA!=JQ>A>=OEJ @A?NA=OEJCEJ@AJOEPU BNKISAOPPKA=OPĠSEPDPDAAT?ALPEKJKB/KI=JE= %KSARAN BQNPDANA?KJKIE?NA>QEH@EJC=J@ =J=OOK?E=PA@EJ?NA=OAEJAHA?PNE?EPU?KJOQILPEKJSEHHHA=@PK=JATL=JOEKJKBAHA?PNE?EPUCNE@OEJ =HHKBPDA!=JQ>AOP=PAO
• ,RANDA=@HEJAO?=JD=RA=JAC=PERAEIL=?PKJ>EN@O KHHEOEKJO=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ=NAL=NPE?QH=NHU SAHHGJKSJ=J@OANEKQONEOGO
• !AOLEPAPDA?NKOO>KN@AN=J@PN=JOJ=PEKJ=H@EIAJOEKJKB>EN@?KJOANR=PEKJ=HKJCLKSANHEJAO EJ PDA!=JQ>ANACEKJPDAJA?AOO=NU=PPAJPEKJD=OOKB=NKJHU>AAJL=E@KJ=NACEKJ=H>=OEO%KSAR AN PDADECDEILKNP=J?AKBPDEOIKNP=HEPUB=?PKNS=OJKPA@EJ=JATLANPOQNRAUĠMQAOPEKJJ=ENA =J@ EIIA@E=PAEILHAIAJP=PEKJKBLNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAOS=O?=HHA@BKN,QPKB=HHNAOLKJ@AJPO ?KJOE@ANA@=!=JQ>ASE@A=LLNK=?DPK>EN@LNKPA?PEKJ=HKJCLKSANHEJAOPK>ARANUEILKNP=JP ?KJOE@ANA@EPEILKNP=JP
• 1DALQNLKOAKBPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LANEOPKN=EOABQNPDAN=S=NAJAOOKBPDEOLNK>HAI=J@PKLNAOAJP =OOAOOIAJPIAPDK@O=OSAHH=OPA?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJOBKNIEPEC=PEKJ
• AJPN=H@AI=J@O=NAPD=PJKLKSANHEJAO>AANA?PA@=P=HHEJDECDN=JGEJCLNKPA?PA@=NA=OKN=NA=O SEPDDECD>EN@@AJOEPEAO =J@PD=PNAPNKłPPEJC>AOP=NPA@=O=I=PPANKBLNEKNEPUEJPDAOA=NA=O
• 1DAIAPDK@OBKN=OOAOOEJCPDAD=V=N@KQOJAOOKB=LKSANHEJA=NAOAL=N=PA@=??KN@EJCPKPDA PSKNEOGO ?KHHEOEKJ=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ =J@EJ?HQ@ALNEKNEPEO=PEKJ1DEOP=GAO=??KQJPKBPDAB=?PPD=P łJ=J?E=HNAOKQN?AO=NAHEIEPA@=J@PD=PL=NPE?QH=NHU@=JCANKQOHEJAOIQOP>A@ABQOA@łNOP
• +QIANKQOPA?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJO=NALNKLKOA@ EJ?HQ@EJCJAS?KJOPNQ?PEKJO NAPNKłPPEJC =J@?KJ OE@ANEJC@EBBANAJPR=NE=JPOKB?KJOPNQ?PEKJPULAO=J@PDAENNAOLA?PERALNK>HAIOKB?KHHEOEKJ=J@ AHA?PNK?QPEKJ
• 1DAKNC=JEO=PEKJ=H>=?G>KJABKNPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LANEO!+2 "-/(01DA!=JQ>A/ERAN+AP SKNGKB-NKPA?PA@NA=O4EPDEJPDA!+2 "L=NGO ,++" 1"!LNKFA?P BQJ@A@>UPDA&JPANNAC !=JQ>A1N=JOJ=PEKJ=H-NKCN=IIA PDA!+2 "#/""0(6EJEPE=PERAD=O>AAJH=QJ?DA@"BBKNPO =NAJKS>AEJCI=@A=HH=HKJCPDA!=JQ>APKIEJEIEOAPDAJAC=PERAEJŃQAJ?AKBLKSANHEJAOKJ >EN@O
• !+2 "#/""0(6OPNKJCHU>QEH@OKJ?NKOOOA?PKN?KKLAN=PEKJ>APSAAJPDA?KJOANR=PEKJ=J@ AJANCUOA?PKNO1DEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN=EIOPKBQNPDANLNKIKPAPDEOBNQEPBQH?KKLAN=PEKJPDNKQCDPDA @AIKJOPN=PEKJKBCKK@LN=?PE?AAT=ILHAO
• 1DA"2!=JQ>A/ACEKJ0PN=PACU-NEKNEPUNA=ļ EK@ERANOEPU=J@)=J@O?=LA=J@-NEKNEPUNA= ļ0QOP=EJ=>HA"JANCUOQLLKNP!+2 "#/""0(6KJ=LKHEPE?=HHARAH
• 1DALKOEPEKJL=LANEOEJPAJ@A@=O=CQE@AHEJABKNLNKPA?PA@=NA==@IEJEOPN=PEKJO J=PQNA?KJOANR= PEKJ=OOK?E=PEKJO LKSANHEJAKLAN=PKNO=J@AJRENKJIAJP=HLKHE?UI=GANO =OA@KJCKK@LN=?PE?A LEHKP=?PEKJO PDA!+2 "#/""0(6S=JPOPKLNKIKPAPDA?KJOAMQAJPOPAL>UOPALEILHAIAJ P=PEKJKB>EN@BNEAJ@HUOKHQPEKJOBKN=HHLKSANHEJAO=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A
• KJOE@ANEJCPDAEILKNP=J?AKBH=NCANERANOBKN>EN@HEBA=J@IECN=PEKJ PDA!+2 "#/""0(6 EJEPE=PERAODKQH@=?P=ONKHAIK@AHBKNKPDANNERANOEJ"QNKLA
4 %LUGVDQGSRZHUOLQHVăLQWURGXFWRU\EDFNJURXQG
EN@LKLQH=PEKJO=NAEJŃQAJ?A@>UJ=PQN=HHUHEIEPEJCB=?PKNOĠACBKK@ LNA@=PEKJ SA=PDAN AP? >QP =NAEJ?NA=OEJCHU=HOK=BBA?PA@@ENA?PHU=J@JAC=PERAHU>UDQI=JOJPDNKLKCAJE?EIL=?PON=JCABNKI the destruction or conversion of entire stretches of habitat, over the manifold negative effects of EJPAJOEłA@=CNE?QHPQNA=J@BKNAOPNU=J@PDAEJ?NA=OA@@EOPQN>=J?AO?=QOA@>UATL=J@EJCHAEOQNA=?PER EPEAO PKļPA?DJE?=HLKHHQPEKJ BKNAT=ILHAPDNKQCDSEJ@PQN>EJAOKNLKSANHEJAO =J@PDEOHEOPEO>UJK IA=JOATD=QOPERA -KSAN HEJAO =NA =J EJPACN=H L=NP KB PDA BQJ?PEKJEJC KB IK@ANJ OK?EAPEAO %KSARAN PDAU =HOK LKOA IQHPELHAD=V=N@OPKPDA>EN@SKNH@ SEPDAHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@?KHHEOEKJ>AEJCPDA>AOPGJKSJĠ#"//"/ '+00 1DAOAPSKB=?PKNO=NA=HOK@A=HPSEPDEJPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN%KSARAN EPODKQH@JKP>A forgotten that power lines also lead to a fragmentation of landscapes and alter the structure in open ?KQJPNUOE@A PDANA>ULKPAJPE=HHU@EONQLPEJC?KILAPEPERA?KJ@EPEKJO=J@ PDQO ?D=JCEJCPDA?KILKOE PEKJKBPDA=REB=QJ=Ġ+!/"40 "+ª1"7)¯-"7AP=H
=OE?=HHU EP?=J>A=OOQIA@PD=PPDAI=EJ?=QOAOKBIKNP=HEPUEJ>EN@O=HKJCLKSANHEJAO=NAAHA? PNK?QPEKJEJPDA?=OAKBIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAO =J@?KHHEOEKJEJPDA?=OAKBDECDRKHP=CAHEJAO1DEO EO@QAPKPDAB=?PPD=PEJOQH=PKN@EOP=J?AO=NAPKKCNA=PEJDECDRKHP=CALKSANHEJAOPK>AKRAN?KIA >U>EN@OJKBPAJB=P=HAHA?PNE?=H@EO?D=NCAK??QNOAEPDAN=O=NAOQHPKB=?KJ@Q?PKNA=NPD?KJP=?PKN = ?KJ@Q?PKN?KJ@Q?PKN?KJP=?P 1DA @EOPEJ?PEKJ >APSAAJ IA@EQIRKHP=CA =J@ DECDRKHP=CA HEJAO EO JKPQJEBKNIĢIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAON=JCABNKIG3QLPK=J@EJ?HQ@EJCG3Ġ=??KN@EJCPKhttps:// de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mittelspannungsnetz HHHEJAO=>KRAPDEON=JCA=NA?KJOE@ANA@DECDRKHP=CA =J@ATPN=DECDRKHP=CAHEJAO
"HA?PNK?QPEKJBNKIIA@EQIRKHP=CALKSANHEJAOD=OKBPAJ>AAJLNKRAJPK>A=I=FKN?=QOAKBDQ I=JEJ@Q?A@@A=PDEJ>EN@OĠAC-)& %00 %¶/"+ "/$ -/&+0"+AP=H (/6(&+ %,%"+"$$"/ 1KLNKRE@A=JEJPANJ=PEKJ=HAT=ILHA >APSAAJ=J@ IEHHEKJ>EN@O=NAAOPEI=PA@PK>AGEHHA@>UAHA?PNK?QPEKJEJPDA2JEPA@0P=PAOLANUA=NĠ),00AP=H &J=OPQ@U?KJ@Q?PA@PDNKQCDKQP%QJC=NU>APSAAJ =RE=J?=N?=OOAOSANA E@AJPEłA@ =BPAN OQNRAUEJC LUHKJO Ġ!"*"1"/ AP =H "HA?PNK?QPEKJ ?=OQ=HPEAO EJ?HQ@A@ OLA?EAOKBDECD?KJOANR=PEKJ?KJ?ANJOQ?D=O0=GAN#=H?KJĠ#=H?K?DANNQC /A@BKKPA@#=H?KJĠ#=H?K RAOLANPEJQO "QNKLA=J/KHHANĠ KN=?E=OC=NNQHQO =J@"=OPANJ&ILANE=H"=CHAĠMQEH=DAHE=?= &J= QH C=NE=JOPQ@U !"*"/!7%&"3Ġ BKQJ@RE?PEIO=HKJC AHA?PNE?EPULUHKJO4EPDEJ@ERE@ Q=HO 4DEPA0PKNGOĠ E?KJE=?E?KJE= SANA>UB=NPDAIKOPBNAMQAJPHUGEHHA@>EN@O1DAOAłJ@EJCO=CNAA SEPDPDABQJ@=IAJP=H=J=HUOEOKB "3+$"/Ġ PD=PH=NCAN>EN@ONACQH=NHULAN?DEJCKJLKHAO=NA IKOPBNAMQAJPHU=BBA?PA@1DAOAEJ?HQ@A EJL=NPE?QH=N OLA?EAOSEPDOHKSNALNK@Q?PEKJN=PAOOQ?D=O >EN@OKBLNAU B=H?KJO KSHO OPKNGO=J@=HOKOKIAOKJC>EN@OĠ?B=HOK0"/$&,AP=H $2&)AP=H O!"*"/!7%&"3Ġ S=O=>HAPKODKS >EN@O=NAAOLA?E=HHURQHJAN=>HAEJPDAKLAJ?KQJ PNUOE@A SDANAPNAAO=NAO?=N?A=J@LKHAO=NAKBPAJPDAKJHULAN?DAOLNKRE@EJC?KII=J@EJCREASO
1DA?KHHEOEKJKB>EN@OKJLKSANHEJAOEOSAHHOPQ@EA@EJOKIA?KQJPNEAO=J@PDANA=NAAOPEI=PAOKBKRAN =HHHKOOAO#KNPDA2JEPA@0P=PAO ),00AP=HĠ CERA=łCQNAKBIEHHEKJ>EN@OGEHHA@LANUA=N SDEHABKN =J=@= /&,25AP=HĠ AOPEI=PAIEHHEKJĠDANA DECDRKHP=CAHEJAOKJHU #NKI PDA!=JQ>ANEL=NE=JOP=PAO PDANAEO=JKRAN=HHłCQNAKBIEHHEKJ>EN@OGEHHA@LANUA=NEJ=??E@AJPO EJPDASDKHAKB$ANI=JUĠ1+)2*4")1-)+2+$ &J=@@EPEKJPKPDAOADECDłCQNAO EPODKQH@ >AJKPA@PD=PNERANO=NA?KJOE@ANA@DECDNEOG=NA=OBKN=JQI>ANKBNA=OKJO,JPDAKJAD=J@ NERANO J=PQN=HHUC=PDANH=NCAJQI>ANOKBS=PAN=OOK?E=PA@>EN@OĠ3!"#++ =J@KJPDAKPDAND=J@ I=JU KBPDAOA=NAL=NPE?QH=NHULKKNHU=>HAPK=RKE@K>OP=?HAO "3+$"/Ġ ODKSA@PD=POLA?EAOSEPD= DECDSEJCHK=@EJC=J@HKS=OLA?PN=PEKNQJ=DECDNEOGKB?KHHE@EJCSEPDLKSANHEJAO1DAOAOLA?EAO=NA ?D=N=?PANEOA@>UB=OPŃECDP SDANA=OPDA?KI>EJ=PEKJKB=DA=RU>K@U=J@OI=HHSEJCONAOPNE?POOSEBP NA=?PEKJOPKQJATLA?PA@K>OP=?HAO "3+$"/Ġ ?KJłNIOS=PAN=OOK?E=PA@>EN@CNKQLOHEGA@E vers, grebes, swans, ducks, cormorants and rails (all of which occur in high numbers along the Danube) PKD=RA=JEJ?NA=OA@?KHHEOEKJOQO?ALPE>EHEPU
5 %KSARAN PDAOA AJKNIKQO HKOOAO =NA =HOK FQTP=LKOA@ >U ?KJOANR=PEKJ LNKFA?P OQ??AOOAO CKK@ AT=ILHAEOLNKRE@A@>UPDAABBKNPOBNKI%QJC=NUĠ!"*"1"/AP=H *KNAPD=J KBPDA AHA?PNE?EPULUHKJOAT=IEJA@SANANAPNKłPPA@PK=RKE@AHA?PNK?QPEKJKB>EN@OO=NAOQHP KJHU KB=HH@A=@>EN@OSANABKQJ@QJ@ANOQ?DOA?QNA@LKHAO,J=RAN=CA KJA?=N?=OOS=OBKQJ@LAN JKJNAPNKłPPA@LUHKJOOQNRAUA@?KIL=NA@PKKJA?=N?=OOLANNAPNKłPPA@LUHKJO =J@EBBAN AJ?AEJBNAMQAJ?UOEIEH=NOQ??AOO?=J>AMQKPA@BKNPDA?KHHEOEKJLNK>HAI#KNAT=ILHA '²!& (" =J@?KHHA=CQAOĠ EJ$ANI=JUSANA=>HAPKODKSPD=PPDA?KHHEOEKJN=PAOKBI=JU>EN@OLA?EAOBAHH >U=BPANPDAA=NPD?=>HAS=OI=NGA@KJDECDRKHP=CAHEJAO1DAOAłCQNAOLNKRAPD=PLNKPA?PERA IA=OQNAO=?PQ=HHUSKNG
Fig. 1: Collision and electrocution – relevant risks for bird lives in the Danube Region. (photo: LIFE Energy/Raptor Protection of Slovakia)
6 7KH'DQXEHăIDFWVDQGILJXUHV
3.1. Profile 1DA !=JQ>A EO PDA OA?KJ@ H=NCAOP NERAN EJ "QNKLA =BPAN PDA 3KHC= SEPD = HAJCPD KB GI &P KNECEJ=PAOEJPDA H=?G#KNAOP $ANI=JU =J@ŃKSOPDNKQCDH=NCAL=NPOKB0KQPD"=OP"QNKLAPKPDA !=JQ>A!AHP=1DA!=JQ>A?NKOOAOKNPKQ?DAOI=JU?KQJPNEAO J=IAHU$ANI=JU QOPNE= 0HKR=GE= %QJC=NU NK=PE= 0AN>E= /KI=JE= *KH@KR==J@2GN=EJA&PO@N=EJ=CA>=OEJSEPDJKHAOOPD=J OMQ=NAGEHKIAPNAOATPAJ@OEJPKJEJAIKNA?KQJPNEAO#KNPDEONA=OKJ PDA!=JQ>AEOKJAKBPDAIKOP EJPANJ=PEKJ=HNERANOEJPDASKNH@SA=HPDKBBQNPDANCAJAN=HEJBKNI=PEKJ?=J>ABKQJ@ BKNAT=ILHA on the homepage of the International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River (https:// www.icpdr.org/main EJ>KKGOHEGAPDAKJA>U01+Û&(',3+,3&ÛĠ KNEJLKLQH=NKRAN REASSKNGOOQ?D=OPD=PKB30&ÙĠ
3.2. Backbone for biodiversity HPDKQCDNERANO=??KQJPBKNKJHUKBPDA"=NPDOOQNB=?AS=PAN NERANO=J@OPNA=IO=OSAHH=OPDAEN =@F=?AJP ŃKK@LH=EJO =J@ =HHQRE=H BKNAOPO =NA @EOPEJCQEODA@ >U = NE?D B=QJ= =J@ ŃKN= ĠAC ))+ #)" ("/ 4/!AP=H !3&0 #KNPDA!=JQ>A PDEO?=J>A@AIKJOPN=PA@ BKNAT=I LHA BKNłOD=J@=ILDE>E=JO =J@JKPHA=OPBKNPDA>EN@O SDE?D=NAKBL=NPE?QH=NEJPANAOPEJPDEOLKOEPEKJ L=LAN2HPEI=PAHU KQPKB=HHP=TKJKIE?CNKQLO >EN@O=NAIKOP=BBA?PA@>UPDAJAC=PERAABBA?POKBLKSAN lines, with the exception of a few electrocutions in climbing mammals and the collisions of bats, which ODKQH@JKP>AQJ@ANAOPEI=PA@
*KNAPD=J>EN@OLA?EAO>NAA@=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A&PEO=JEILKNP=JPNAOPEJCLH=?A=J@=>=?G>KJAKB >EN@IECN=PEKJ=J@=HOK=PPN=?POI=JU>EN@OSDKKRANSEJPANKJPDANERANKNEJPDAEIIA@E=PARE?EJEPUO EOPK>AATLA?PA@ S=PANBKSH=J@OLA?EAO=J@CNKQLO=OOK?E=PA@SEPD=MQ=PE?D=>EP=PO=NAL=NPE?QH=NHU ?KIIKJ1DAUEJ?HQ@ANALNAOAJP=PERAOKBJOANEBKNIAOĠ@Q?GO CAAOA=J@OS=JO -K@E?ELA@EBKNIAO (grebes), Gruiformes (rails, gallinule, coot and cranes), Otidiformes (bustards), Gaviiformes (loons), Ciconiformes (storks), Suliformes (cormorants), Charadriiformes (waders, pratincoles, gulls and terns), ??ELEPNEBKNIAOĠ>EN@OKBLNAU =J@#=H?KJEBKNIAOĠB=H?KJO =J@-AHA?=JEBKNIAO1DAH=OPCNKQLEJ?HQ@AO PDA$HKOOU&>EO(Plegadis falcinellus) and Eurasian Spoonbill (Platalea leucordia)BNKIPDA1DNAOGEKNJEPD E@=AB=IEHU =HHDANKJOĠN@AE@=A =J@PDAALKJUIKQOLAHE?=JOĠ-AHA?=JE@=A PDAIOAHRAO
1DABKHHKSEJCAT=ILHAOODKQH@DECDHECDPPDA!=JQ>AOAJKNIKQOEILKNP=J?A JKPKJHUBKN>NAA@EJC OLA?EAO >QP=HOKBKNIECN=PEJC=J@SEJPANEJC>EN@O0P=NPEJCSEPDJAOPEJCOLA?EAO PDA!=HI=PE=J-AHE can (Pelecanus crispus) and Great White Pelican (Pelecanus onocrotalus)>NAA@=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A1DA PKP=H-=HA=N?PE?LKLQH=PEKJKB$NA=P4DEPA-AHE?=JOEOAOPEI=PA@=P L=ENO=P?KHK JEAO SEPD L=ENO=PPDA!=JQ>A@AHP=EJ/KI=JE==HKJAĠ"))&,11AP=H= 1DEOSKQH@ NAOQHPEJ=OD=NAKBPDAPKP=H-=HA=N?PE?LKLQH=PEKJ%KSARAN */&+,3AP=HĠ= >=OA@ KJOPQ@EAOSEPD=JQJI=JJA@=ANE=HRADE?HAĠ@NKJA EJ@E?=PA=LKLQH=PEKJKB >NAA@EJC L=ENOBKNPDA!=JQ>A@AHP==HKJA SDE?DNAOQHPOEJ=?KILHAPAHU@EBBANAJP=OOAOOIAJPKBPDA=?PQ=HOEP Q=PEKJ&J?E@AJP=HHU PDAOEPQ=PEKJEOOKIASD=PNARANOA@BKNPDA!=HI=PE=J-AHE?=J SDANA"))&,11AP =HĠ> ?KJłNIL=ENOBKNPDA!=JQ>A@AHP= >QP*/&+,3AP=HĠ> KJHUEJ@E?=PA L=ENOBKNPDASDKHAKB/KI=JE=
1DANERAN=J@EPOATPAJOERASAPH=J@O=NAGAUSEJPANEJCCNKQJ@OBKNI=JUS=PAN>EN@LKLQH=PEKJOO=J example, the eastern and central part of the Danube course region at times holds almost the entire SKNH@LKLQH=PEKJKB/A@>NA=OPA@$AAOAĠ%UDQWDUXƓFROOLVĢ("/ $,/&2-AP=H 2HPEI=PA HU PDA=NA=EO=HOKKBKQPOP=J@EJCEILKNP=J?A=O=OPKLKRANOEPABKNIECN=PKNU>EN@O A?=QOAKBEPO HK?=PEKJ=PPDAFQJ?PEKJKBPDA*A@EPANN=JA=J -KJPE?=J@"QN=OE=JOQ>VKJAOKBPDA-=HA=N?PE?B=QJ=H NA=HI IEHHEKJOKB>EN@OQOAPDAHKSAN!=JQ>APKNALHAJEODPDAENAJANCU@QNEJCIECN=PEKJĠ+"41,+ 0+!,/AP=H
7 #KNPDA4DEPAP=EHA@0A=A=CHA PDA!=JQ>AEO=JEILKNP=JP>NAA@EJC NAOPEJC=J@SEJPANEJCLH=?AO BKNSEJPANEJC -/, 01=J@?KHHA=CQAOĠ ?KQJPA@QLPKA=CHAO@QNEJCPDAłNOPSEJPAN?AJOQO EJ'=JQ=NU%KPOLKPOKBK??QNNAJ?ASANAPDA AJPN=H!=JQ>AŃKK@LH=EJOPDA=NA=AJ?KIL=OO EJCPDAHKSAN%QJC=NE=JOA?PEKJĠ!=JQ>A!N=R=+=PEKJ=H-=NG (KL=ÜGENEP+=PQNA-=NGĠ NK=PE= PDA $KNJFA-K@QJ=RHFA0LA?E=H+=PQNA/AOANRAĠ0AN>E= =J@PDA!=JQ>A!AHP= EKOLDANA/AOANRAOB=N =O>NAA@EJCEJ@ERE@Q=HO=NA?KJ?ANJA@ +"*"0%7&AP=HĠ D=RAODKSJPD=PPDANAEO=?ANP=EJ CAJAPE?=QPKJKIUKBPDA4DEPAP=EHA@0A=A=CHALKLQH=PEKJEJPDA =NL=PDE=J =OEJ EAEJ=NACEKJ SDKOA>=?G>KJAEOPDA!=JQ>A JKPDAN=LLNK=?DEOPKHKKG=PPDA+=PQN==NA=O=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A SDE?D=NADKIAPKI=JU @EBBANAJPNALNAOAJP=PERA>EN@OLA?EAOPK>ALNKPA?PA@=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A1DANAOQHPKBPDA0LA?E=H-NK tected Areas and Important Bird Areas standard data forms (https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and- maps/data/natura-9; http://datazone.birdlife.org/site/factsheet/gornje-podunavlje-iba-serbia/de- tails; http://natura2000.eea.europa.eu/#) show the high relevance of these sites when it comes to >EN@O?KJOANR=PEKJEJ"QNKLA
3.3. Study area 1DAP=NCAP=NA=KB!+2 "#/""0(6EOCAJAN=HHUPDA!=JQ>ANERAN=J@PDA=@FKEJEJCNEL=NE=JVKJA Ġ=HHQRE=HBKNAOPO PNE>QP=NEAO KLAJH=J@ EP@KAOJKP?KNNAOLKJ@SEPDPDAļ!=JQ>A>=OEJ=O=SDKHA #KN?HA=N=J=HUOAOEPS=OJA?AOO=NUPK@AłJAPDEO=NA=AT=?PHU SDE?DS=O@KJA=OBKHHKSOġłNOP=HEJA OD=LAłHAKBPDANERAN!=JQ>AĠhttp://www.danubegis.org/ S=O=@@A@PK.Q=JPQI$&01DAJ =>QBBANSEPD=@EOP=J?AKBPDNAAGEHKIAPNAOKJA=?DOE@AKBPDANERANS=O?NA=PA@0A?KJ@ =HH=?PERA =J@K>OANR=>HANEL=NE=JVKJAOĠhttps://land.copernicus.eu/local/riparian-zones/riparian-zones-de- lineation KBPDA!=JQ>ASANA=@@A@PKPDAH=UAN"RANU=?PERA=J@K>OANR=>HANEL=NE=JVKJALKHUCKJ SEPDEJPDA=BKNAIAJPEKJA@PDNAAGEHKIAPNA!=JQ>A>QBBANS=OOAHA?PA@1DAJ=OA?KJ@>QBBANSEPD =@EOP=J?AKBPDNAAGEHKIAPNAOS=O?NA=PA@=NKQJ@PDAOAHA?PA@LKHUCKJO(KL=ÜGENEP=J@PDA!=J Q>A @AHP= SANA =@@A@ OAL=N=PAHU Ġhttps://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/data/natura-8/nat- ura-2000-spatial-DATANATURA SHAPEµLE OEJ?A>KPD=NARANUH=NCA=J@EILKNP=JPSAPH=J@O =HKJCPDA!=JQ>A=J@PDAEN=NA=SKQH@KPDANSEOA>AQJ@ANNALNAOAJPA@>UPDALNAREKQOOAHA?PEKJ PDNAAGEHKIAPNA>QBBANS=O=HOK?NA=PA@=NKQJ@PDAOAPSK+=PQN==NA=O#EJ=HHU =HHLKHUCKJO SANAIANCA@PK=OEJCHA H=NCALNKFA?P=NA=1DAłJ=H@AHEIEPA@=NA=D=O=OEVAKB OMQ=NA GEHKIAPNAO=J@?=J>AOAAJEJ#EC
Fig. 2: The Danube River – a backbone for biodiversity and one of Europe´s most important bird flyways (photo: D. Petrescu)
8 9 Fig. 3: Project area along the Danube. It comprises the river itself as well as the neighbouring riparian zone.
3.4. Power line network &JPDAJATPOPAL PDAHK?=PEKJOKBLKSANHEJAOD=@PK>A@APANIEJA@BKNPDALNKFA?P=NA=Ġ@AłJA@EJ?D=L PAN 2JBKNPQJ=PAHU PDANAEOJKOEJCHAH=UANPD=PEONA=@EHU=??AOOE>HA=P=J"2HARAH OKSAD=@PKOQI I=NEOAOARAN=HOKQN?AODANA1DEONAOQHPOEJ=JEJRAJPKNUSDE?DEOH=NCAHU >QPJKPMQEPA?KILHAPA1DA I=EJOKQN?AKBEJBKNI=PEKJS=O,LAJ0PNAAP*=L,LAJOKQN?A@=P=Ġhttp://www.geofabrik.de/) was @KSJHK=@A@BKNA=?D?KQJPNU=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A1DA,LAJ0PNAAP*=LłHAOSANAEILKNPA@EJPK.Q=J PQI$&0=J@LNAL=NA@BKNBQNPDANLNK?AOOEJC1KLKHKCUS=OATLKNPA@PK=JASH=UAN>U?DKKOEJC LKHUHEJAO=J@OAHA?PEJCKJHU=PPNE>QPAOSEPDPDABKHHKSEJCP=COġļJ=IA ļLKSAN ļRKHP=CA ļKLAN=PKN =J@ļNABJ0.)MQANUS=OQOA@PKOAP=LNKRE@ANłHPANKJPDA=PPNE>QPAP=CCA@ļLKSAN DKOAJ R=HQAOSANAP=CCA@ļHEJA=J@ļIEJKN;HEJA1DEOS=O@KJABKNARANU?KQJPNU NAOQHPEJCEJKJAH=UANLAN ?KQJPNU?KJP=EJEJC=HHLKSANHEJAOSDE?D?=J>ABKQJ@KJ,LAJ0PNAAP*=LHHH=UANOSANAIANCA@PK KJA>ECH=UAN SDE?DS=OPDAJOLHEP>URKHP=CA=PPNE>QPAOEJPKPDNAAOD=LAłHAOġKJASEPDARANUHEJA=>KRA G3 KJASEPDARANUHEJAAMQ=HPKKN>AHKSG3KNARANUHEJAP=CCA@ļIEJKN;HEJA =J@KJABKN=HH NAI=EJEJCLKSANHEJAOSEPDIEOOEJCRKHP=CAR=HQAO@@EPEKJ=HHU A=?DL=NPJANNACEKJLNKRE@A@@=P=BNKI HK?=HJAPSKNGKLAN=PKNOPK?KILHAPAPDAI=LKBPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJAO=O>AOPLKOOE>HA1DA?KKN@EJ=PANAB ANAJ?AOUOPAIQOA@S=O"1/0)""QNKLAHHLKSANHEJAOEJPANOA?PEJCPDALNKFA?P=NA=SANA ?HELLA@SEPD.Q=JPQI$&0=J@QOA@BKNBQNPDAN?=H?QH=PEKJO &JOQII=NU =NKQJ@ GEHKIAPNAOKBDECD=J@IA@EQIRKHP=CALKSANHEJAONQJ=HKJC=J@=?NKOO PDEOļ!=JQ>A?KNNE@KN*KNAPD=JDECDRKHP=CAHEJAOOL=JPDANERAN SDEHAI=JUKPDANIA@EQI=J@ HKSRKHP=CAHEJAO?NKOOPDANERANH=J@O?=LAĠ?KIL#EC 1SKPDEN@OKBLKSANHEJAO=NAIA@EQIRKHP =CAHEJAO SDEHAKJAPDEN@=NADECDRKHP=CAHEJAO,BPDADECDRKHP=CAHEJAO =LLNKTEI=PAHUEJPANOA?P Natura 2000 areas and therefore represent the highest risk to protected bird species regarding colli OEKJIKJCPDAIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAO =NKQJ@=NAOEPQ=PA@EJ+=PQN==NA=O=J@LKOAPDA >ECCAOPLNK>HAIEJPANIOKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJ
10 11 Fig. 4: Power lines along the Danube. In the selected project area, power lines generally decrease from west to east (see Annex 1). Exemplary maps are shown for the Upper Dan- ube (Germany), the Middle Danube (Hungary south of Budapest) and the Lower Danube (Danube Delta).
%KSARAN PDALKSANHEJAO=NAJKPARAJHU@EOPNE>QPA@=?NKOOPDAOPQ@U=NA=O?=J>AOAAJBNKI1=>HA PDAPKP=HHAJCPDKBLKSANHEJAOEJPANOA?PEJCPDALNKFA?P=NA=LAN?KQJPNUCAJAN=HHU@A?NA=OAOBNKI SAOPPKA=OP KJOE@ANEJC BKNAT=ILHA PD=PQOPNE==J@%QJC=NUD=RALN=?PE?=HHUPDAO=IAPKP=HHAJCPD KBLKSANHEJAO >QP>KN@ANPDANERANBKNGEHKIAPNAO=J@GEHKIAPNAONAOLA?PERAHU PDEO@EBBAN AJ?A?=J>AOPNEGEJC NK=PE= 0AN>E==J@ QHC=NE= IA=JSDEHA KJHUD=RA?KIL=N=PERAHUOI=HHAHA?PNE?EPU CNE@OJAT?ALPEKJPKPDEOļCAJAN=HNQHA DKSARAN EO/KI=JE= SDE?DEOI=NCEJ=HHU=DA=@EJPANIOKB DECDRKHP=CAHEJAHAJCPD =J@?HA=NHU=DA=@EJPANIOKBIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAHAJCPD
OPDA=R=EH=>EHEPUKBLQ>HE?@=P=@EBBANOOECJEł?=JPHUBNKI?KQJPNUPK?KQJPNU PDEOOP=PEOPE?=HOKNAŃA?PO PDAMQ=HEPU=J@MQ=JPEPUKB@=P=OQNRAUA@=J@LNKRE@A@SEPDEJPDA!+2 "#/""0(6EJEPE=PERA
Voltage/ GER AUT SK HU HR RS BG RO country High 1,002.38 664.29 147.95 526.20 46.00 311.88 122.97 1,097.48 Medium 1,369.81 670.66 509.08 694.71 59.63 5.94 5.99 3,150.95 Low 2.25 9.44 0.00 29.51 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Unknown 3.44 11.45 19.19 111.60 5.22 172.99 357.45 634.01 Sum 2,377.88 1,355.84 676.22 1,362.02 110.85 490.81 486.41 4,882.44
Tab. 1: Length of the power lines in the investigation area along the Danube, divided accord- ing to different voltages.
12 3.5. Current knowledge &JOQII=NU EPIQOP>AOP=PA@PD=PGJKSHA@CANAC=N@EJCPDAJAC=PERAABBA?POKBLKSANHEJAOKJ>EN@O EJPDAOPQ@U=NA=EON=PDANHEIEPA@HPDKQCDPDANA=NAOKIARANUR=HQ=>HAABBKNPO=PPDAJ=PEKJ=HHARAH ĠAC!"*"1"/AP=H KNQJ?KJJA?PA@PKPDANERANĠAC$"/!7%&(,3!"*"/!7&"3 !"*"/!7%&"3 BASOPQ@EAOD=RA>AAJ?=NNEA@KQP@ENA?PHUKJPDA!=JQ>AEPOAHB1DAIKOPEI LKNP=JPKBPDAOAOPQ@EAO=J@PDAENNAOQHPO=NALNAOAJPA@>AHKS
1DANA=NAJKOLA?Eł?!=JQ>ANAH=PA@OQNRAUOEJ$ANI=JUKNQOPNE=OKB=N%KSARAN EJ$ANI=JUPDANA EO=SA=HPDKBEJRAOPEC=PEKJO?KJ?ANJEJCPDEOPKLE?ĠAC1+)2*4")1-)+2+$ '²!& ("AP=H SDEHAEJQOPNE=PDAłNOP?=IAN=>=OA@EJRAOPEC=PEKJOKBPDA!=JQ>A=NA?QNNAJPHUEJLNKCNAOOĠ0 >ANHA QOPNE=J-KSAN$NE@ LANO?KII
&J0HKR=GE= =H=NCA)""JANCULNKFA?PS=OOP=NPA@EJĠ*$¹HEO LANO?KII OLA?E=HHUPN=EJA@ łAH@=OOEOP=JPOD=RAOQNRAUA@=HIKOP GEHKIAPNAOKBLKSANHEJAOĠG3=J@G3 EJ0-O =J@OLAJP=HIKOP @=UOEJłAH@PKP=HKB >EN@?=N?=OOAOĠ>AHKJCEJCPKE@AJPEłA@OLA?EAO D=RA>AAJNA?KN@A@&JPDAI=FKNEPUKB>EN@O PDA@APANIEJA@?=QOAKB@A=PDS=OAHA?PNK?QPEKJĠ=>KQP KN?KHHEOEKJĠ=>KQP 1DAOLA?EAOIKOPLNKJAPKAHA?PNK?QPEKJSANA"QN=OE=J QVV=N@ĠButeo buteo KB?=OQ=HPEAO =J@"QN=OE=J*=CLEAĠPica pica 1DAOLA?EAOIKOPLNKJAPK?KHHEOEKJ SEPDSENAOSANA*QPA0S=JĠCygnus olor =J@ KIIKJ-DA=O=JPĠPhasianus colchicus ,BPDA>EN@OLA?EAO=BBA?PA@ PDKOASEPD=L=NPE?QH=NHUDECDJ=PQNA?KJOANR=PEKJR=HQAEJ?HQ@A"=CHA,SH (Bubo bubo) and White Stork (Ciconia ciconia EJPDA?=OAKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJ =J@-QNLHA%ANKJĠArdea purpurea), Lapwing (Vanellus vanellus =J@0GUH=NGĠAlauda arvensis EJPDA?=OAKB?KHHEOEKJ"HA?PNK ?QPEKJ?=OAOSANA?KJ?AJPN=PA@EJłAH@OĠKBPAJ=HB=HB= LNK>=>HU>A?=QOAPDAOAD=>EP=POKBPAJ?KI>EJA =DECDOQLLHUKBOI=HHI=II=HO=OLNAUSEPD=HKSJQI>ANKBLAN?DAO KHHEOEKJOK??QNNA@RANUKBPAJ SDANASAPH=J@O=J@BAA@EJC=NA=O=NAOAL=N=PA@>ULKSANHEJAO IA=JEJCPDAUD=RAPK>ABNAMQAJPHU ?NKOOA@>U>EN@OOSEP?DEJC>APSAAJNAOPEJC=J@BKN=CEJCOEPAO,RAN=HH PDEOH=NCAOPKB=HHEJRAOPEC=PEKJO SEPD=OD=NAEJKQNOPQ@U=NA=ODKSOPD=PPDA!=JQ>A =O=OQLN=NACEKJ=HHUEILKNP=JPSAPH=J@=NA= EO =HOK=DECDNEOG=NA=BKN>EN@IKNP=HEPUKJLKSANHEJAO,BPDA GEHKIAPNAOEJRAOPEC=PA@ GEHK IAPNAOB=HHSEPDEJPDAOPQ@U=NA=OAHA?PA@BKNPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN,BPDAOA GIĠ B=HHEJPKPDA DECDAOPNEOG?H=OOBKN>EN@?KHHEOEKJO
&J%QJC=NU >EN@LNKPA?PEKJKJKRANDA=@HEJAOD=O=PN=@EPEKJKBIKNAPD=JUA=NO1DA!=JQ>ANACEKJ S=OJKPOLA?Eł?=HHUKNOAL=N=PAHUPNA=PA@Ġ#&!)¯ 7(6AP=H !"*"1"/AP=H =J@ =BPAN =NEOG=J=HUOEO PDAIKOPLNK>HAI=PE?=NA=OĠ=PHA=OPNAC=N@EJCAHA?PNK?QPEKJKJIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAO SANABKQJ@PK>AEJPDAA=OPANJ%QJC=NE=JHKSH=J@O4EPDEJPDABN=IASKNGKB!+2 "#/""0(6 łNOPOQNRAUOSANA?KJ@Q?PA@>UPDA#ANPÌ%=JO¹C+=PEKJ=H-=NG!ENA?PKN=PAEJPDA0VECAPGÌVNACEKJ
&J NK=PE= EJRAOPEC=PEKJOSANA?=NNEA@KQPKJHUEJ?K=OP=H=NA=O EAB=N=S=UBNKIPDA!=JQ>AĠ1*E GQOG=*7A? LANO?KIIĢ7" (1+,3&ÙEJLNAL 4EPDEJ!+2 "#/""0(6 =łNOPEJRAJ PKNUKBPDAIKOP?NEPE?=HOA?PEKJOKBLKSANHEJAOEJ(KL=ÜGENEP+=PQNA-=NG=J@PDA NK=PE=J-K@QJ=RHFA NACEKJS=O?KJ@Q?PA@
&J0AN>E= PDANA=NAJKOPQ@EAO@A=HEJCSEPDPDAPKLE?OKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@?KHHEOEKJOKB=NJEJRAOPE C=PEKJEJPKAHA?PNK?QPEKJD=OFQOP>ACQJEJPDA =J=P/ACEKJKBPDA!=JQ>AĠ*/QĜEÚ LANO?KII
&J QHC=NE= CNA=P ABBKNPO D=RA >AAJ I=@A PK EILNKRA >EN@ LNKPA?PEKJ KJ LKSAN HEJAO *KOP KB PDA IA=OQNAOSANA?=NNEA@KQPEJKLAJ=J@DEHHU N=LPKNNE?D=NA=OKBPDA?KQJPNUĠ/DK@KLAO=J@0KQPD"=OP Bulgaria), within the framework of the projects Save the Raptors LIFE+, LIFE for Safe Grid, Neophron )" 0=GAN #=H?KJ )" =J@ )" BKN QNC=O )=GAO 1DA H=OP LNKFA?P =HOK =EIO PK LNKPA?P I=JU S=PAN>EN@O=HKJCPDA3E=-KJPE?=ŃUS=U >QPJKPEJPDA!=JQ>A=NA=EPOAHB%KSARAN PDAKLAN=PEKJ=H PANNEPKNUKBPDAKJCKEJC)EBA EN@OKJ-KSAN)EJAOLNKFA?P=HOKEJ?HQ@AOL=NPOKBPDA!=JQ>ALH=EJEJ QHC=NE=&PSEHH?KRANPDA0-O AHAJA&OH=J@O KILHAT 0REODPKR AHAJAHKSH=J@ +EGKLKHOGKLH=PA=Q 7H=PE=U=P= =J@,NOKU=łODLKJ@OĠ0 DAODIA@FEAR!!K>NAR LANO?KII
13 &J/KI=JE= PDANAEOKJHU=OEJCHAO?EAJPEł?=NPE?HAPD=PATLNAOOHUNABANOPKPDA?KHHEOEKJKB>EN@OLA?EAOEJ PDA?QNNAJPLANEIAPANKBPDA!=JQ>A!AHP= EKOLDANA/AOANRAĠ(&00*/&+,3 &JPDAOPQ@U SDE?DS=OHEIEPA@PKKJHUPSKOQNRAU@=UOEJPDA?K=OP=H=NA=KBPDA!=JQ>A!AHP= =PKP=HKB?=@=R ANOSANABKQJ@KRANGEHKIAPNAO>EN@OLA?EAOPD=P?KHHE@A@SEPDPAHALDKJAHEJAOSANAE@AJPEłA@ 1DADECDAOPIKNP=HEPUS=ONA?KN@A@BKN4DEOGANA@1ANJĠChlidonias hybrida) with 24 dead individuals, BKHHKSA@=POKIA@EOP=J?A>U*=HH=N@ĠJ=OLH=PDUNDUJ?DKO =J@ KKPĠFulica atra) with four individuals each, and Caspian Gull (Larus cachinnans SEPDPDNAAEJ@ERE@Q=HO
3.6. Expert assessment and potential impacts &PEO?HA=NBNKISD=PD=O>AAJKQPHEJA@EJ?D=LPANPD=PEJRAOPEC=PEKJO=NAEJODKNPOQLLHU1DEOEO@QA PKPDADECDLANOKJJAHATLAJ@EPQNAKBOQ?DOPQ@EAO SDE?DEJPQNJAJP=EHODECDłJ=J?E=H?KOPO!QAPKPDA HEIEPA@@=P==R=EH=>HA SA=NAQJ=>HAPKI=GA=O?EAJPEł?=HHU=??ALP=>HAAOPEI=PAKBPDAJQI>ANKB>EN@O GEHHA@EJKQNEJRAOPEC=PEKJ=NA==O=NAOQHPKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJKN?KHHEOEKJ%KSARAN >=OA@KJ@=P=BNKIPDA 20 =J=@= $ANI=JU=J@0HKR=GE=Ġ),00AP=H /&,25AP=H 1+)2*4")1-)+2+$ Ģ*$¹HEO LANO?KII SAIQOPNA?GKJSEPDPDKQO=J@OKB>EN@OGEHHA@>UAHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@PAJO KBPDKQO=J@O LNK>=>HUARAJDQJ@NA@OKBPDKQO=J@O KB>EN@OGEHHA@>U?KHHEOEKJ=HKJCPDA!=JQ>AARANU UA=N 1KC=EJ=JEILNAOOEKJKBPDAEILKNP=J?AKBPDEOLNK>HAI !+2 "#/""0(6?KJ@Q?PA@=JATLANP MQAOPEKJJ=ENAOQNRAUO=NAOQHP NALNAOAJP=PERAOBNKILNKPA?PA@=NA=OOP=PA@PD=P>KPDAHA?PNK?Q PEKJ=J@?KHHEOEKJKJKRANDA=@HEJAO=NANAHAR=JPKNRANUNAHAR=JPLNK>HAIOEJ>EN@LNKPA?PEKJ0LA?Eł?=H HU KBATLANPOOQNRAUA@OP=PA@PD=P?KHHEOEKJS=O=RANUNAHAR=JPIKNP=HEPUB=?PKNBKNPDALNKPA?PA@ =NA=O=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A SDEHAN=PA@EP=OEILKNP=JP"HA?PNK?QPEKJS=OOAAJ=O=RANUEILKNP=JP IKNP=HEPU B=?PKN >U KB NAOLKJ@AJPO =J@ =O EILKNP=JP >U SDEHA KJHU KB ATLANPO OQNRAUA@N=PA@EP=OEJOECJEł?=JP!AOLEPAPDA?HA=NEILKNP=J?A=PPNE>QPA@PKPDANEOGKBLKSANHEJAO KJHUKBPDAOQNRAUA@LNKPA?PA@=NA=NALNAOAJP=PERAOO=E@PDAUD=@=HNA=@UEILHAIAJPA@O=BAPU IA=OQNAOHOK OQ?DIA=OQNAONAH=PA@KJHUPKOEJCHALUHKJOKNHEJAO SDEHAKBPDAAHA?PNE?EPU JAPSKNG=NA?KJOE@ANA@?KILHAPAHUQJLNK?AOOA@&J=@@EPEKJ KNNAOLKJ@AJPOOP=PA@PDAUD=@ JARAND=@=JU?KJP=?PSEPD=PN=JOIEOOEKJOUOPAIJKLAN=PKN>ABKNA!+2 "#/""0(62HPEI=PAHU EJPANAOPEJ?KJ?NAPA>EN@LNKPA?PEKJLNKFA?POS=ODECDĠ PKRANUDECDĠ
3.7. Current mitigation measures +KPHA=OP@QAPKPDA!+2 "#/""0(6EJEPE=PERA PDANAD=ONA?AJPHU>AAJ=J=>QJ@=J?AKBLNKPA?PERA IA=OQNAO&PS=OCAJAN=HHUNA?KCJEOA@PD=PPDALNK>HAIEOOKK>REKQOPD=P ARAJSEPDKQPHAJCPDU=J@ ATLAJOERAEJRAOPEC=PEKJOĠSDE?DEJI=JU=NA=OD=RAJK?D=J?AKBNA=HEO=PEKJEJPDAJA=NBQPQNA EI IA@E=PA=?PEKJIQOP>AP=GAJ4EPDNAC=N@PKPDAEJ@ERE@Q=HOP=PAO PDABKHHKSEJC?=J>AOQII=NEOA@ġ
&J$ANI=JU =!+2 "#/""0(6J=PEKJ=HIAAPEJCSEPDPN=JOIEOOEKJOUOPAIKLAN=PKNONAOQHPA@EJ PDA=CNAAIAJPPKE@AJPEBULKSANHEJAO?NKOOEJCPDA!=JQ>ANERANSDE?D?=J>AI=NGA@EJPDAODKNP PANI+APVA =@AJ4ÐNPPAI>ANCEILHAIAJPA@PDAI=NGEJCKB=LKSANHEJA?NKOOEJCPDA!=JQ>A?HKOA PK0ECI=NEJCAJĠI=NGEJCSEPDłNAŃEAO>U@NKJA 1KCAPDANSEPD =UANJSANG$I>%=LEHKPI=NGEJCKB !=JQ>A?NKOOEJCLKSANHEJAOEJ&JCKHOP=@P=J@+AQ>QNCEOAJREO=CA@BKN4EPDOQLLKNPKB!+2 "L=NGO ,++" 1"! IA=JSDEHA !AQPO?DA =DJ+APVA )"43ANPAEHJAPV$I>%=J@ =UANJSANG+APV $I>%ATLNAOOA@PDAENEJPANAOPPKFKEJPDA)" !+2 "#/""0(6BKHHKSQLLNKFA?PSEPDłJ=J?E=H ?KJPNE>QPEKJO=J@?KJ?NAPA=?PEKJO
&JQOPNE= PDA?KKLAN=PEKJSEPD-$ĠQOPNE=J-KSAN$NE@ =J@JQIANKQOKPDANKLAN=PKNOĠ"3++APV +EA@ANÌOPANNAE?D 4EAJAN+APVA +APV,>ANÌOPANNAE?D =OSAHH=O EN@)EBAQOPNE= NAOQHPA@EJPDA!+ 2 "#/""0(6=CNAAIAJPPKI=NGJA=NHU=HHHEJAO?NKOOEJCPDA!=JQ>AO=łNOPOPAL PDACNKQJ@ SENAEOI=NGA@SEPDH=IAHH=A@AŃA?PKNO#ENOPLEHKPI=NGEJCOPKKGLH=?AEJSEJPAN EILHA IAJPA@=J@łJ=J?A@>UPDALKSANHEJAKLAN=PKNO0PAL>UOPAL IKNAEJOP=HH=PEKJOPKKGLH=?AEJ &JPDA!+2 "#/""0(6BKHHKSQL)" LNKFA?PLNKLKO=H EJOQH=PEKJ=?PEKJO=NABKNAOAAJBKN=N=EH S=UHEJA=HKJCPDA!=JQ>AŃKK@LH=EJOEJ?KKLAN=PEKJSEPDPDAQOPNE=J#A@AN=H/=EHS=UĠ²
14 &J0HKR=GE= GIKBLKSANHEJAONALNAOAJPEJCPDADECDAOPNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJD=RAOKB=N>AAJI=NGA@>U EJOP=HH=PEKJKB@ERANPANO QOEJC#ENA#HU>EN@LNKPA?PEKJ ,N=JCA0LEN=H=J@/& "H=IAHH=A&JIKOP?=OAO =HHHEJAOĠ?KJ@Q?PKNO=OSAHH=OPDAA=NPDSENA SANAI=NGA@0EJ?ALNEH łAH@=OOEOP=JPOD=RA S=HGA@=HIKOP GIEJ=>KQPDKQNOĠ@=UO QJ@ANPNA=PA@LKSANHEJAOOA=N?DEJCBKNLKOOE>HA ?KHHEOEKJRE?PEIO,JHUEJ@ERE@Q=HRE?PEIO?KQH@>ABKQJ@ SDE?D?KJłNIOPDADECDABł?EAJ?UKBLNKPA? PEKJ=?PEKJO=J@PDA=HIKOPABBA?PERAJAOOKBPDAPDNAAPULAOKB@ERANPANOEJOP=HHA@%KSARAN KBPDAGEHKIAPNAOOA?QNA@OKB=N KJHUKJAEOSEPDEJPDAOPQ@U=NA=OAHA?PA@BKNPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN 1DEOIA=JOPD=P@KVAJOKBGEHKIAPNAOKBDECDNEOGLKSANHEJAO=NAOPEHHQJOA?QNA@=HKJCPDA!=JQ>AĠ?B ?D=LPAN &JOLNEJC =?NEPE?=HG3LKSANHEJAEJPDA!=JQ>A?KNNE@KNS=OI=NGA@SEPD#ENA#HU @ERANPANO=HKJC=HAJCPDKBGI ?KłJ=J?A@>U!+2 "#/""0(6
&J%QJC=NUKRANPDAL=OP@A?=@AO R=NEKQOLNKFA?POD=RAI=EJHUBK?QOA@KJIA=OQNAO=C=EJOPAHA?PNK ?QPEKJ&JPDA!QJ=&LKHU=J@!QJ=!N¹R=+=PEKJ=H-=NGO=HKJA IKNAPD=J LUHKJOD=RA>AAJ @ABQOA@4EPDEJPDALEHKP=?PEKJEJ!+2 "L=NGO ,++" 1"! PDA!QJ=&LKHU+=PEKJ=H-=NG=J@PN=JO IEOOEKJOUOPAIKLAN=PKN*3&/I=NGA@=G3LKSANHEJA=PNERANGEHKIAPNA1SKPULAO KB>EN@ŃECDP@ERANPANOSANAQOA@EJKN@ANPK=?DEARAI=TEIQINAOQHPO EN@@ERANPANOKBPDA EN@I=NG BPANCHKSPULASANAEJOP=HHA@>U@NKJAOĠPKP=HKBLEA?AO =J@/& "PULA@ERANPANOĠLEA?AO SANA EJOP=HHA@>U*3&/OLA?E=HEOPO)=PANEJ =JKPDANBKHHKSQL=?PEKJS=OEILHAIAJPA@>U*3&/ OKQPDKB Q@=LAOPĠ$(EOO LANO?KII
=OA@KJPDAOQNRAUEJPDA#ANPÌ%=JO¹C+=PEKJ=H-=NGĠOAA PDADECDAOPNEOGIA@EQIRKHP=CALU HKJOD=RA>AAJNAPNKłPPA@SEPDEJPDABN=IASKNGKB!+2 "#/""0(6&JPDA!QJ=!N¹R=+=PEKJ=H -=NG PDA!+2 "#/""0(6EJEPE=PERANAOQHPA@EJPDAIK@Eł?=PEKJKBPDADA=@OPNQ?PQNAOKBLUHKJO EILHAIAJPA@>UPN=JOIEOOEKJOUOPAIKLAN=PKN",+=HKJC=GEHKIAPNAOPNAP?DKBIA@EQIRKHP=CA LKSANHEJAEJPDA?KNA>NAA@EJC=NA=KB4DEPAP=EHA@0A=A=CHA=J@ H=?G0PKNG@@EPEKJ=HHU PDAOA? PEKJOKBPDEOLKSANHEJASANAI=NGA@=C=EJOP?KHHEOEKJ
&J NK=PE= OK B=N JK IEPEC=PEKJ IA=OQNAO D=RA >AAJ EJOP=HHA@ SEPDEJ PDA OPQ@U =NA= Ġ* 7A? LANO ?KII 1DA!+2 "#/""0(6J=PEKJ=HIAAPEJCO>APSAAJ(KL=ÜGENEP+=PQNA-=NG=J@PN=JOIEOOEKJ OUOPAIKLAN=PKNONAOQHPA@EJ=FKEJPLNKFA?PL=NPJANODELBKN?KJOANR=PEKJ=?PEKJOSEPDEJPDABN=IASKNG KBPDA)" BKHHKSQLLNKFA?P@@EPEKJ=HHU *AIKN=J@QIKB KKLAN=PEKJOD=RA>AAJOECJA@>APSAAJ (KL=ÜGENEP+=PQNA-=NG=J@LKSANHEJAKLAN=PKNOSEPDEJ!+2 "#/""0(6 PK@AłJABQPQNAOPALOKB ?KKLAN=PEKJ
1DANA=NAD=N@HU=JUEILHAIAJP=PEKJIA=OQNAOEJ0AN>E=OKB=N >QP=PPAILPO=NA?QNNAJPHU>AEJCI=@A to prevent the construction of a power line over the Important Bird Area Labudovo Okno, an area of ATPN=KN@EJ=NU>EK@ERANOEPU=J@=J=PEKJ=HOPNKJCDKH@KBSEJPANEJCS=PANBKSHOQ?D=OCAAOA @Q?GO ?KN IKN=JPO OS=JO AP?Ġ*/QĜEÚ LANO?KII
&J QHC=NE= PDA!+2 "#/""0(6EJEPE=PERANAOQHPA@EJPDANAPNKłPPEJCKBHKS=J@IA@EQIRKHP=CA LUHKJO=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A >=OA@KJEJRAOPEC=PEKJOKBLKSANHEJAO>APSAAJ/QO=J@0EHEOPN=1DANAEO JKDECDRKHP=CALKSANHEJA?NKOOEJCPDA!=JQ>A*KOPKBPDAJQIANKQOIA=OQNAOEILHAIAJPA@OKB=N SANAKQPOE@AKBPDA!=JQ>ANACEKJ JKPHA=OPEJPDARANUEILKNP=JPS=PANBKSH=NA=KBPDA QNC=OH=GAO HIKOP @ERANPANO=C=EJOP?KHHEOEKJSANAEJOP=HHA@=J@=NKQJ@LUHKJOSANA@ABQOA@=C=EJOP AHA?PNK?QPEKJEJPDEO=NA=%KSARAN PDANA=NALH=JOPKEJOP=HH>EN@@ERANPANOEJPDA0- AHAJA&OH=J@O KILHATĠ-ANOEJ&OH=J@ =J@PDA0-0REODPKR AHAJAHKSH=J@ @QAPKPDAH=NCA?KJ?AJPN=PEKJOKBS= PANBKSHPDANA#KN=HHLNKFA?P0-OĠ AHAJA&OH=J@O KILHAT 0REODPKR AHAJAHKSH=J@ +EGKLKHOGKLH= PA=Q 7H=PE=U=P= =J@,NOKU=łODLKJ@O PDANA=NALH=JOPKEJOQH=PAPDAIKOPD=V=N@KQOAHA?PNE?EPULUHKJO SEPDPDADECDAOPEILKNP=J?ABKNPDAP=NCAPOLA?EAOĠ0 DAODIA@FEAR LANO?KII
&J/KI=JE= PDA!=JQ>A!AHP= EKOLDANA/AOANRAQPDKNEPUEILHAIAJPA@PDAEJOP=HH=PEKJKB@ERANP ANO=HKJCGIKBLKSANHEJAOSEPDRANUDECD?KHHEOEKJNEOG#ENA#HU@ERANPANOSANAQOA@EJPDEO?=OA 1DAEJOP=HH=PEKJPKKGLH=?AEJ=OL=NPKBPDA!+2 "#/""0(6?KKLAN=PEKJ
15 3ULRULWLVDWLRQRISURWHFWLRQPHDVXUHV
4.1 Need for prioritisation &PEO?HA=NPD=PO=BAPUIA=OQNAO=NAQNCAJPHUJAA@A@%KSARAN OEJ?AłJ=J?E=H=J@DQI=JNAOKQN?AO =NA HEIEPA@ PDA ?DKE?A KB EILHAIAJP=PEKJ HK?=PEKJ IQOP >A LNEKNEPEOA@ &P EO JKP BA=OE>HA PK S=EP BKN OPQ@EAO >A?=QOAPDAU=NAHAJCPDU=J@?KOPHU*APDK@KHKCE?=HHU EPEOJKPOEILHAPK=OOAOOIKNP=HEPU N=PAOKJLKSANHEJAO SDE?DEONAŃA?PA@EJPDADECDLANOKJJAH?KOPOKN?KOPOBKNKPDANLNK?A@QNAOĠAC ?=IAN=OUOPAIO &JPDAKJAUA=N$ANI=JOPQ@U>U'²!& ("AP=HĠ BKNAT=ILHA PA=IO?=NNEA@ KQPOA=N?DNQJOARANUPSK@=UO@QNEJCPDA>EN@IECN=PEKJLANEK@O =J@ARANUłRA@=UOKPDANSEOA1DQO IKNAPD=JEJOLA?PEKJOSANAJA?AOO=NU#QNPDANIKNA IAPDK@KHKCE?=HANNKNOSANA=PPAILPA@PK >AGALPPK=J=>OKHQPAIEJEIQI1KPDEOAJ@ OETATLANEIAJPOKJPDAOA=N?DN=PAĠļ%KSIQ?D@KK> OANRANOKRANHKKG =J@?=IAN=>=OA@ATLANEIAJPOKJPDA?HA=N=J?AN=PAĠļ%KSI=JU?=N?=OOAO =NANAIKRA@>UO?=RAJCANO SANA?=NNEA@KQP&J=@@EPEKJ >EN@OLA?EAO ŃECDP@ENA?PEKJO=J@ŃECDP >AD=REKQNSANANA?KN@A@?KILNADAJOERAHU OKPD=P=JAH=>KN=PA@=P=I=PNETEOJKS=R=EH=>HAPD=PEO ?KILHATPKEJPANLNAP #KNPDEONA=OKJ EJ?D=LPANO=J@ SALNAOAJPOEILHAIAPDK@OKBLNEKNEPEO=PEKJ OAL=N=PA@=? ?KN@EJCPK?KHHEOEKJ=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ1DAU?=J>A=LLHEA@=P=JUOL=PE=HHARAH=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A=J@ CQ=N=JPAAN=LE@=?PEKJ=C=EJOP=LNK>HAIPD=PD=OOKB=N>AAJDECDHUQJ@ANAOPEI=PA@
4.2 Collision 1DANA=NA=IEJEIQIKB GIKBATEOPEJCPN=JOIEOOEKJ=J@@EOPNE>QPEKJKRANDA=@AHA?PNE?HEJAOEJ PDA!=JQ>AOPQ@U=NA=Ġ GI &PEO=JPE?EL=PA@PD=PPN=JOIEOOEKJ=J@@EOPNE>QPEKJQLCN=@AOSEHH >ANAMQENA@EJPDA?KIEJCUA=NOPKBQHłHPDAAJANCU@AI=J@EJPDEOOPN=PACE?=NA=1DEOLNKFA?PA@CNKSPD EJPN=JOIEOOEKJ=J@@EOPNE>QPEKJHEJAOSKQH@EJAREP=>HUHA=@PKDECDAN>EN@?KHHEOEKJNEOGO&PEOEILKNP=JP PKJKPAPD=P?KHHEOEKJO?=JK??QNAMQ=HHUSEPDPN=JOIEOOEKJ=J@@EOPNE>QPEKJHEJAO =J@ARAJK??=OEKJ=HHU SEPDPAHALDKJAHEJAOĠ=HPDKQCDIQ?DHAOOBNAMQAJPHU =OPDAU=NAQOQ=HHUIKNAREOE>HA In order to prioritise the collision risk of birds with overhead electric lines along the Danube, we used $&0@=P==R=EH=>HABKNPDAOPQ@U=NA=/ERANO ?=J=HO SAPH=J@OĠH=GAO I=NODAO NAOANRKENO AP? =J@ ?K=OP=HS=PANOPD=PKRANH=UPDAOPQ@U=NA=SANAOAHA?PA@BNKIPDA KNEJA)=J@ KRANRA?PKN@=P=OAP ĠDPPLOġH=J@?KLANJE?QOAQHK?=HNEL=NE=JVKJAONEL=NE=JVKJAO@AHEJA=PEKJ 4EPDEJPDA+=PQN=JAP SKNG PDA0LA?E=H-NKPA?PA@NA=O?KILNEOAPDAIKOPR=HQ=>HA=NA=OBKN>EN@O=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A1DAOA areas are documented as being the most important breeding, migration, feeding and resting areas for birds (https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/data/natura-9 #KNPDAJKJ"2?KQJPNEAOĠAC 0AN>E= PD=P=NAJKPUAPL=NPKBPDA+=PQN=JAPSKNG PDA&ILKNP=JP EN@NA=JAPSKNGD=O>AAJ ?KJOE@ANA@PK>APDA>AOP=R=EH=>HA@=P=OKQN?AKJPDEOPKLE? -KSANHEJAOPD=POL=JS=PAN>K@EAOLHQO=IAPNAN=@EQO=J@KN=NAHK?=PA@EJ0-+=PQN= OEPAONALNAOAJPPDADECDAOPLNEKNEPUBKNPDAEILHAIAJP=PEKJKBPDALNKPA?PEKJIA=OQNAO=C=EJOP?KHHEOEKJ Ġ#"//"/ =OA@KJPDAHEPAN=PQNA=J@LN=?PE?=HłAH@ATLANEAJ?ASA?H=OOEłA@BKQNNEOG?H=OOAO SEPDNAC=N@PK?KHHEOEKJġ
1. Waterbodies in Natura 2000 - SPAs:,RANDA=@AHA?PNE?HEJAO?NKOOEJCS=PAN>K@EAO=J@KN=@F= ?AJP=NA=OĠIAPNAN=@EQO EJ0-O3ANUDECDLKPAJPE=HNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJBKNDECD IA@EQI=J@ HKSRKHP=CALKSANHEJAOEJPDA=NA= 2. NATURA 2000 - SPAs further than 100 m from waterbodies: Overhead electric lines in SPAs, >QPJKP?NKOOEJCS=PAN>K@EAOKN=@F=?AJP=NA=OĠIAPNAN=@EQO %ECDLKPAJPE=HNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJ BKN DECD =J@ IA@EQIRKHP=CA LKSAN HEJAO EJ PDA =NA= #KN HKSRKHP=CA HEJAO PDA NEOG EO OEPQ= PEKJ@ALAJ@AJP 3. Waterbodies outside of SPAs:,RANDA=@AHA?PNE?HEJAO?NKOOEJCS=PAN>K@EAO=J@KN=@F=?AJP =NA=OĠIAPNAN=@EQO KQPOE@AKB0-O%ECDLKPAJPE=HNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJBKNDECD IA@EQI=J@ HKSRKHP=CALKSANHEJAOEJPDA=NA=
16 4. Outside NATURA 2000 - SPAs: Overhead electric lines outside of SPAs and not crossing water >K@EAOKN=@F=?AJP=NA=OĠIAPNAN=@EQO #KNDECD=J@IA@EQIRKHP=CALKSANHEJAO PDANEOGEO OEPQ=PEKJ@ALAJ@AJP SDEHA=HKSNEOGEO?KJOE@ANA@BKNHKSRKHP=CAHEJAO
Risk of collision Prioritisation of conservation measures High-voltage Medium-voltage Low-voltage power lines power lines power lines
Waterbodies Very High Very High Very High in SPAs
SPAs further Situation- than 100 m High High dependent Worthiness from waterbodies of Protection Waterbodies High High High outside of SPAs
Situation- Situation- Outside SPAs Low dependent dependent
Fig. 5: Matrix for the prioritisation of conservation measures against collision on overhead lines. On the one hand, a distinction must be made between NATURA 2000 sites and Non-NAT- URA 2000 sites (Worthiness of Protection), and on the other hand the risk of collision is taken into consideration.
Interpretation guide for the matrix:
Very High Risk: An immediate need for action exists!
High Risk: An immediate need for action exists! Only “very high” risk power lines have to be secured with even greater priority.
Situation-dependent: The security measures must be implemented in the medium term. They are to be weighed up according to local distributions and concentrations of birds, resources for implementation etc.
Low Risk: The security measures must be implemented in the long term
17 ??KN@EJCPKPDALNEKNEPEO=PEKJ?NEPANE= PDAļJAA@BKN=?PEKJ mined (maps: A. Dorosencu). 4,520 km of power lines pose a situation-dependent risk (37%). For 44% of power lines (5,263 km) a low risk bird collision w Fig. 6: According to these criteria for prioritisation, there are 2,347 km of power lines in the categories “very high risk” an I=LEOLNAOAJPA@BKNA=?DL=NPJAN?KQJPNU=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A?KQ NOAĠ#EC d “high risk” (19%). as pre-deter-
18 Fig. 7: Need for action map for Germany
Fig. 8: Need for action map for Austria
19 Fig. 9: Need for action map for Slovakia
Fig. 10: Need for action map for Hungary
20 Fig. 11: Need for action map for Croatia
Fig. 12: Need for action map for Serbia
21 Fig. 13: Need for action map for Bulgaria
Fig. 14: Need for action map for Romania
22 4.3. Electrocution For the prioritisation of the protection measures against electrocution on overhead lines three aspects SANAP=GAJEJPK?KJOE@AN=PEKJġ#ENOP L=NPE?QH=NHUR=HQ=>HA>EN@O=J?PQ=NEAOSEPD=DECDJQI>ANKBN=NA OLA?EAO ODKQH@>ACERAJLNABANAJ?A0A?KJ@ OLA?E=H=PPAJPEKJODKQH@>ACERAJPKDECDNEOGD=>EP=PO J@PDEN@ L=NPE?QH=NHUNEOGULKSANHEJAOODKQH@>A@ABQOA@łNOP#=?A@SEPDHEIEPA@łJ=J?E=H=J@DQI=J NAOKQN?AO PDEO=LLNK=?DEOOQLLKOA@PKI=TEIEOAPDALKOEPERAEIL=?PKJ>EN@?KJOANR=PEKJ@@EPEKJ =HHU DECDRKHP=CAHEJAOKBG3KNIKNA=NA?H=OOEłA@=OD=NIHAOOEJPANIOKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJ&JPDAOA ?KJOPNQ?PEKJO PDAEJOQH=PKNOA?PEKJO=NAOKHKJCPD=P>EN@O?=JD=N@HUKRAN?KIAPDAI#KNPDEONA=OKJ JKIA=OQNAOJAA@PK>AQJ@ANP=GAJ=C=EJOPAHA?PNK?QPEKJEJOQ?DLKSANHEJAO KJHU=C=EJOP?KHHEOEKJ 4EPD NAC=N@ PK PDA =NA=O SKNPDU KB LNKPA?PEKJ SA D=RA @EOPEJCQEODA@ >APSAAJ +=PQN= =J@ JKJ+=PQN= 1DEO I=GAO OAJOA >A?=QOA PDA IKOP EILKNP=JP >EN@ =NA=O =HKJC PDA !=JQ>A =NA EJPACN=PA@EJPDA+=PQN=JAPSKNG+=PEKJ=HL=NGO J=PQNAL=NGO >EKOLDANANAOANRAO=J@J=PQNA NAOANRAO=NA=HHL=NPKBPDA+=PQN=LNKPA?PA@=NA=JAPSKNG=J@?KNNAOLKJ@EJCHU=HOK?KJOPEPQPAPDA IKOPEILKNP=JP>EN@IECN=PEKJ NAOPEJC=J@>NAA@EJC=NA=O&J0AN>E= =O=JKJ"2?KQJPNU PDAJAPSKNG KB&ILKNP=JP EN@NA=OEOP=GAJEJPK?KJOE@AN=PEKJ As far as habitats are concerned, numerous studies show that the risk of electrocution is greater in KLAJ?KQJPNUOE@APD=JEJBKNAOPOĠAC!"*"/!7%&"3 1DEOEOJKPOQNLNEOEJC>A?=QOAEJKLAJ ?KQJPNUOE@AAHA?PNE?EPULUHKJO=NAKBPAJPDAKJHULAN?DAO=R=EH=>HA1DEOB=?PD=O>AAJP=GAJEJPK=? ?KQJPEJKQNLNEKNEPUI=PNET SEPDSKK@H=J@PDANABKNA>AEJCLH=?A@EJ=HKSANNEOG?=PACKNU OB=N=OAOPEI=PEJCIKNP=HEPUNEOGEO?KJ?ANJA@ SABK?QOA@I=EJHUKJPDAR=HQ=>HA=J@HKJCOP=J@EJC ATLANEAJ?AEJ0HKR=GE=Ġļ-NKFA?P)""JANCU =J@PDA=OOAOOIAJPOKB=L=JAHKBATLANPO,JPDEO>= OEO SA?H=OOEłA@AHA?PNK?QPEKJNEOGEJPKPDNAA?H=OOAO&HHQOPN=PERAAT=ILHAO?=J>ABKQJ@EJLLAJ@ET
High risk:4A?H=OOEBUIAP=H?NKOO=NILUHKJO EJL=NPE?QH=N =J@CAJAN=HHU=HH?KILHAT?KJOPNQ?PEKJO =J@LUHKJOSEPD?KI>EJ=PEKJOKBATLKOA@FQILANSENAHK?=PEKJO IKOPHUSDAJ=>KRAPDA?KJOKHA =O DECDNEOG Medium risk:4A?H=OOEBU=HHGEJ@OKB@EOPNE>QPEKJLKSANHEJA?KJOKHAOSEPD=RANPE?=HLKOEPEKJKBPDA OQLLKNPEJOQH=PKNO @EOPNE>QPEKJPN=JOBKNIANO=J@DKNEVKJP=HOSEP?D@EO?KJJA?PKNO=OIA@EQINEOG Low risk:4A?H=OOEBU=HHGEJ@OKB@EOPNE>QPEKJLKSANHEJA?KJOKHAOSEPD=DKNEVKJP=HKND=JCEJCLKOEPEKJ of the support insulators, special constructions with console shapes that prevent birds from perching KJPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJ KN?KJłCQN=PEKJOKBOQLLKNPEJOQH=PKNO=J@ATLKOA@FQILANSENAOPD=P=HHKS>EN@ EJ@ERE@Q=HOPKLAN?DO=BAHU=OHKSNEOG
Risk of electrocution Prioritisation of conservation measures High Medium Low
Open countryside Very High Very High High in SPAs
Situation- Situation- Woodland in SPAs High Worthiness dependent dependent of protection Open countryside Situation- High High outside of SPAs dependent
Woodland outside Situation- Situation- Low of SPAs dependent dependent
Fig. 15: Matrix for the prioritisation of conservation measures against electrocution on over- head lines.
23 Interpretation guide for the matrix:
Very High Risk: An immediate need for action exists!
High Risk: An immediate need for action exists! Only “very high” risk power lines have to be secured with even greater priority.
Situation-dependent: The security measures must be implemented in the medium term. They are to be weighed up according to local distributions and concentrations of birds, resources for implementation etc.
Low Risk: The security measures must be implemented in the long term
Fig. 16: Installations of bird diverters reduce the risk of collision by up to 79% - 91%. Pi- lot actions within DANUBE FREE SKY found positive response in media and public. (photo: G. Frank/DANUBEPARKS)
24 %LUGIULHQGO\VROXWLRQV
PPDA>ACEJJEJCKBPDEO?D=LPAN EPODKQH@>AJKPA@PD=POP=NPEJCLKEJPO@EBBANCNA=PHU>APSAAJPDA!=J Q>ANEL=NE=JOP=PAO1DAOALANP=EJ BKNAT=ILHA PKPDA@AJOEPUKBPDAAHA?PNE?EPUCNE@ PDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJKB LKSANHEJAOKNPDAJ=PEKJ=HHAC=HNAMQENAIAJPO1DANABKNA EPEOJKPLKOOE>HAPK@A=HSEPDA=?DEJ@ERE@Q=H ?=OAEJPDABKHHKSEJC >QPN=PDAN=CAJAN=HEJOPNQ?PEKJI=JQ=HEOPK>ALNAOAJPA@&PEO=GEJ@KB=DEAN=N ?DE?=H?DA?GHEOP SDE?DODKQH@>A=LLHEA@BNKIPKLPK>KPPKI
5.1. Preliminary exanimations and project assessments ABKNASKNGEJCKJOLA?Eł?PA?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJOEJ>EN@LNKPA?PEKJBKNKRANDA=@HEJAOĠOAA=J@ PDABKHHKSEJC>=OE?MQAOPEKJO=J@LNKFA?PNAMQENAIAJPOODKQH@łNOP>A?H=NEłA@
5.1.1. Needs analysis and legal background &PODKQH@>AJKPA@KJ?A=C=EJPD=PPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJKB=LKSANHEJA=HS=UONALNAOAJPO=OQ>OP=JPE=H AJ?NK=?DIAJPKJJ=PQNA=J@PDAH=J@O?=LAO=HNA=@UATLH=EJA@=>KRA PDEONAOQHPOEJ=JEJ?NA=OA@ NEOGKBB=P=HEPEAO@QAPKAHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@?KHHEOEKJ >QPPDAH=J@O?=LABA=PQNAO=NA=HOK?D=JCA@1DEO OPNQ?PQNEJC=J@BN=CIAJP=PEKJ?=JQHPEI=PAHUHA=@PK=@EBBANAJP?KILKOEPEKJKBOLA?EAOĠ?D=JCAOEJ D=>EP=P =HPANA@?KILAPEPERA?KJ@EPEKJO ?D=JCAOEJLNA@=PKNLNAUN=PEKO AP? #NKI=J=PQNA?KJOANR=PEKJLANOLA?PERA PDAOK?=HHA@ļVANKR=NE=JP EA=>=J@KJIAJPKB?KJOPNQ?PEKJ KB=LKSANHEJA EO=HS=UOPDA>AOPOKHQPEKJ&PEOEILAN=PERA PDANABKNA PD=PPDAJAA@PKQLCN=@APDA AHA?PNE?EPUCNE@IQOP>ALNKRAJ>UPDA=LLHE?=JPO=J@RANEłA@>UJ=PQNA?KJOANR=PEKJLLNKLNE=PAAJRE NKJIAJP=HEIL=?P=OOAOOIAJPOIQOPPDANABKNA>A?=NNEA@KQP&BPDANA=NAOPEHH?KQJPNEAOEJPDA!=JQ>A NACEKJSEPD=JEJOQBł?EAJPNECDPKB=LLA=H PDAHAC=HOEPQ=PEKJIQOPłNOP>A?DA?GA@BKN?KJBKNIEPUSEPD "2H=S=J@=@FQOPA@EBJA?AOO=NU&JLNEJ?ELHA DKSARAN EPODKQH@>AJKPA@PD=P=HH!=JQ>ANEL=NE=JOP=PAO D=RA?KIIEPPA@PDAIOAHRAOPK>EN@LNKPA?PEKJEJEJPANJ=PEKJ=H=CNAAIAJPO1DEO?=J>ASAHHEHHQOPN=PA@ >UPDAAT=ILHAKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJĠBKN=JKRANREAS OAA ²%*"/%0 SDANA/AOKHQPEKJ ļ"HA?PNK?QPEKJKB*ECN=PKNU EN@OS=OOECJA@>UIKNAPD=JOP=PAO=PPDAPD KJBANAJ?AKBPDA KJRAJPEKJKJPDA KJOANR=PEKJKB*ECN=PKNU0LA?EAOKB4EH@JEI=HOĠ *0Ģļ KJJ KJRAJPEKJ EJ 1DAOAOP=PAO=HOKEJ?HQ@APDA!=JQ>A?KQJPNEAOĠhttp://www.cms.int/en/parties-range-states In addition, in 2004 the Standing Committee of the Bern Convention in Strasbourg adopted the rec KIIAJ@=PEKJOLNAOAJPA@>U+ 2=J@ EN@)EBA AOE@AO>EN@LNKPA?PEKJKJIA@EQIRKHP=CALUHKJO PDAU=HOKEJ?HQ@ANAMQENAIAJPOBKN=RKE@EJC?KHHEOEKJOKJ?KJ@Q?PKNNKLAO BKNQJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJC BKN NKQPALH=JJEJC =OSAHH=OBKNOUOPAI=PE?@=P=?KHHA?PEKJ=J@=??KIL=JUEJCO?EAJPEł?NAOA=N?D1DEO =CNAAIAJPS=OOECJA@>U"QNKLA=J?KQJPNEAO1DAOA@N=BPNA?KIIAJ@=PEKJONAMQENAPDAIAI>AN J=PEKJOPKOKHRAPDALNK>HAI>UK>OANREJCPDAOP=PAKBPDA=NPEJAJCEJAANEJC
5.1.2. Variant check As a rule, variant tests are carried out prior to the implementation of construction projects on the scale KBLKSANHEJAO*=PPANOKB?KJ?ANJ=NAJKPKJHUPDAJ=PQN=HDANEP=CA >QP=HOKPDAKRAN=HH=LLA=N=J?A KBPDAH=J@O?=LA LNKFA?P?KOPO=J@IQ?DIKNA&J=JU?=OA LNKFA?PO=NA@AłJEPAHUPK>A@AOECJA@PK AJOQNA PD=P ?KJOPNQ?PEKJ EO =O AJRENKJIAJP=HHU BNEAJ@HU =J@ NAOKQN?AO=REJC =O LKOOE>HA +QIANKQO OPQ@EAOD=RAODKSJPD=PDECDRKHP=CALKSANHEJAOODKQH@JKP?NKOOI=EJŃECDPNKQPAO =OPDAU?=JD=RA PDADECDAOPJAC=PERAEIL=?P=P>EN@IECN=PEKJŃUS=UOKNSDAJ>QEHP=O>=NNEANOPKBAA@EJCCNKQJ@O EN@ ?HQOPANOODKQH@=HOK>A=RKE@A@1DAOAB=?PKNOODKQH@>AP=GAJEJPK=??KQJPEJR=NE=JPPAOPEJCĠOAAAC "3+$"/ !IE?KAP=H !/"4&11)+$01,+ '00 -ÀNAV$=N?Ä=AP=H &JPDA?=OAKB=?KJ?NAPALNKFA?P PDANAIQOP=HS=UO>A=JEJ@ERE@Q=HAT=IEJ=PEKJKBJ=PQNA?KJOANR= PEKJH=SEJ=??KN@=J?ASEPDJ=PEKJ=HH=S =J@OQ?D=NAOQHP?=JJKP>ALNAFQ@E?A@>U=CAJAN=HLKOEPEKJ L=LANOQ?D=OPDEOOB=N=OKNJEPDKHKCUEO?KJ?ANJA@ PDASAHHGJKSJIAPDK@KHKCE?=HOP=J@=N@OĠOQ?D =OPDKOAKB0¶! " (AP=H IQOP>A=@DANA@PK,JHUPDAAT=?PGJKSHA@CAKBPDA=?PQ=H=RE B=QJEOPE?OP=PQOMQK=HHKSO=@ANER=PEKJKBPDA@ACNAA=J@PDAEILKNP=J?AKBPDAEJPANRAJPEKJ =J@łJ=HHU KB=JULNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAO
25 %KSARAN BNKIPDALKEJPKBREASKBPDA=QPDKNOKBPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN =J@KB=HHLANOKJO=J@OQLLKNPEJC KNC=JEO=PEKJOEJRKHRA@ PDALNKPA?PA@=NA=O?AJANUEOKBL=NPE?QH=NEILKNP=J?AOATLH=EJA@EJPDALNA REKQO?D=LPANO PDALNKPA?PA@=NA=O=HKJCPDA!=JQ>A=NAPDA>=?G>KJAKB>EK@ERANOEPULNKPA?PEKJ=J@ >EK@ERANOEPU#KNPDEONA=OKJ PDANAEO=?HA=N@AI=J@DANAPD=PLNKPA?PA@=NA=OKB=HHGEJ@O>AATAILPA@ BNKILH=JJEJCBKNLKSANHEJAO1DEOEOL=NPE?QH=NHUPNQAKB+=PQN=OEPAO1DAOA=NA=O=NAOQ>FA?PPK =HAC=HLNKDE>EPEKJKB@APANEKN=PEKJ SDE?DSA>AHEARASEHH>AREKH=PA@EJ=JU?=OA>UPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJ KB=LKSANHEJA+=PQN=OEPAOĠKN=J=HKCQA=NA=OEJ0AN>E= IQOPPDANABKNA>AAT?HQ@A@BNKIPDA ?KJOPNQ?PEKJKB=HHGEJ@OKBLKSANHEJAO=LNEKNEĠQJHAOOQJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJCEOQOA@
5.1.3. New construction or conversion ABKNA=OOAOOEJC=?KJOPNQ?PEKJLNKFA?P EPODKQH@=HS=UO>A?H=NEłA@SDAPDANEPEO=JAS?KJOPNQ?PEKJ KN=?KJRANOEKJL=NPBNKIPDA=OLA?PO@EO?QOOA@EJ=J@SEPDNAC=N@PKJAS?KJOPNQ?PEKJ PDANA=NA=HOKBQJ@=IAJP=H@EBBANAJ?AOKB=PA?DJE?=HJ=PQNA&JPDA?=OAKBNAPNKłPPEJCATEOPEJCLKSAN HEJAO EPEOKBPAJJA?AOO=NUPKP=GA=??KQJPKBOPNQ?PQN=H=OLA?POĠACHK=@?=L=?EPU =J@OEIEH=NB=?PKNO 1DANABKNA OA?KJ@=NULNKPA?PEKJIA=OQNAOOQ?D=O>EN@LNKPA?PEKJDKK@OĠOAABKN@AP=EHO SEHHQOQ =HHU>APDAIA=JOKB?DKE?A PDKQCDPDAUSEHHJARANLNKRE@A?KILHAPALNKPA?PEKJKN=NAI=EJPAJ=J?AEJ PAJOERA4DANARANLKOOE>HA PDANABKNA JAS?KJOPNQ?PEKJOKNI=FKN=HPAN=PEKJOIQOP>ALH=JJA@ HA=@ EJCPKLANI=JAJP ļ?KJOPNQ?PERAOKHQPEKJOPD=P=NA?KILHAPAHUD=NIHAOOBKN>EN@OĠJKPAġPDEO=LLHEAO KJHUPKAHA?PNK?QPEKJ =J@PDANAEO=HS=UO=NAOE@Q=HNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJ
5.1.4. Construction versus operation phase &PODKQH@>AAILD=OEOA@PD=PI=JULNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAOļKJHUNABANPKPDAKLAN=PEJCLD=OA%KSARAN PDAOK?=HHA@EJ?NA=OA@IKNP=HEPUNEOGIQOP=HOK>A=RKE@A@@QNEJCPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJOP=CA1DEOEOJKP JA?AOO=NUBKNAHA?PNK?QPEKJĠ>A?=QOAPDANAEOJK?QNNAJPŃKSEJCUAP >QPEPEOLKOOE>HA=J@EILKNP=JP SEPDNAC=N@PK?KHHEOEKJ ABKNAPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJEO?KILHAPA@=J@=HHLNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAOOQ?D=OS=NJEJC>=HHO H=IAHH=AAP? D=RA>AAJEJOP=HHA@ =JEJ?NA=OA@NEOGKB?KHHEOEKJIQOP>A=RKE@A@ARAJ@QNEJCPDA?KJOPNQ?PEKJLD=OA 1DEO?KQH@>A=?DEARA@ BKNAT=ILHAĠHEGAEJOKIALNKFA?POEJQOPNE= >UOA?QNEJCPDAA=NPDNKLAEI IA@E=PAHUSEPDPN=?AN>AHPO=J@ =PIKOPKJAIKJPDH=PAN NALH=?EJCPDAISEPDPDAS=NJEJC@ERANPANO =C=EJOP>EN@OPNEGA1DANKQPEJCP=LAOIQOP>A=PHA=OPKJAIAPNAHKJC NA@SDEPAEJ?KHKQN=J@JKP BQNPDANPD=JIAPNAO=L=NPBNKIA=?DKPDAN&J=@@EPEKJ PDAQJI=NGA@LEHKPNKLANAMQENA@PKLQHHQL PDAA=NPDSENANKLAIQOPJKP>A=PP=?DA@BKNHKJCANPD=JPSK@=UO>ABKNAPDA=?PQ=HA=NPDSENANKLA EO=PP=?DA@=J@I=NGA@,PDANSEOA PDALEHKPNKLAIQOP=HNA=@U>AI=NGA@ARANUISEPDIAPNA S=NJEJCP=LAO PDQOKBBANEJCEIIA@E=PALNKPA?PEKJ&JPDEO?=OA PDALEHKPNKLAIQOP>ANALH=?A@>UPDA @AłJEPERAA=NPDSENANKLASEPDEJ@=UO
#QNPDANIKNA EPCKAOSEPDKQPO=UEJCPD=PLKSANHEJAOSDE?D=NAJKPĠKNJKHKJCAN =?PERALKOAPDAO=IA LKPAJPE=HNEOGKB?KHHEOEKJ=OLKSANHEJAOEJKLAN=PEKJ1DAU=NAPK>A@A?KJOPNQ?PA@=OOKKJ=OLKOOE>HA
5.2. Technical solutions against collision 5.2.1 Underground cabling 2J@ANCNKQJ@AHA?PNE?EPU?=>HAO=NAQOA@EJ=HIKOP=HH"QNKLA=J?KQJPNEAO I=EJHUBKNL=NPOKBPDAAHA?PNE? PN=JOIEOOEKJ=J@@EOPNE>QPEKJJAPSKNGOEJQN>=J=NA=O =OSAHH=OEJPDA?KQJPNUOE@ASDANARANA?KHKCE ?=HKNDEOPKNE?=HEJPANAOPOJAA@PK>ALNAOANRA@
1DA?KOPKBQJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HAO=PRKHP=CAOKBQLPKG3=NAAOPEI=PA@PK>A=NKQJ@@KQ>HAPDA?KOP KBKRANDA=@HEJAOĢ=PRKHP=CAOKBG3PDAAOPEI=PAEO=NKQJ@PDNAAPEIAOPDA?KOP SDEHA=PG3 the estimates are around ten times the cost of overhead lines (a current project in Denmark, however, ODKSOPD=PPDA?KOPKB>QNUEJCG3HEJAOEOKJHUPEIAODECDANPD=JKRANDA=@HEJA
$KK@LN=?PE?ALNKFA?POĠACBKN$NA=P QOP=N@ ODKSPDAABł?EAJ?UKBQJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJCBKN>EN@?KJ OANR=PEKJ#KN?KNALKLQH=PEKJO=J@EJ?KNA=NA=OĠACEJDECDNEOG=NA=OEJPDA!=JQ>A!AHP= EKOLDANA /AOANRA CNKQJ@?=>HEJCD=OPK>A?KJOE@ANA@=O=JKLPEKJ=J@OKIAPEIAO=O=LNEKNEPUOKHQPEKJ =HOK EJPDA!=JQ>ANACEKJ
26 &J$ANI=JU =??KN@EJCPKPDA"JANCEASENPO?D=BPOCAOAPVĠ"J4$]D QJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJCEOK>HEC =PKNUBKNG3HEJAOĠ>QPJKPBKNDECDAOPRKHP=CALKSANHEJAO SEPDAT?ALPEKJKBOA?PEKJOSDANAPDA PKP=H?KOPOBKNPDAEJOP=HH=PEKJSKQH@EJ?NA=OAPDAANNA?PEKJPDAKRANDA=@LKSANHEJAO>U=B=?PKNKB Ġ4 ÌDIAN + 2!AQPO?DH=J@ LANO KII 1DEOB=?PKNEOKBPAJNA=?DA@ACEJIKQJP=EJQO=NA=O
5.2.2. Marking of power lines with bird diverters KHHEOEKJD=V=N@O?=J>ACNA=PHUNA@Q?A@PDNKQCDIK@Eł?=PEKJOPKATEOPEJC@AOECJOP=J@=N@O AOE@AQJ derground cabling (which is a permanent solution for both electrocution and collision), the line markers NALNAOAJPPDA>AOP=R=EH=>HA=HPANJ=PERA
-KSANHEJAIK@Eł?=PEKJEOPDALNK?AOOSDANAOPALO=NAP=GAJPKI=GA=LKSANHEJAIKNAREOE>HAPK >EN@OEJŃECDP*=NGEJCPDA?KJ@Q?PKNO=J@KNCNKQJ@SENAOEOPDAIKOP?KIIKJLKSANHEJAIK@Eł?= PEKJNAOLKJOA>UAHA?PNE?QPEHEPU?KIL=JEAOĠ),+0,AP=H -)& ,JPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJAO marking the ground wire has received particular focus because it appears to be the wire most often OPNQ?G>U>EN@OEJŃECDPĠ0 ,11AP=H 4&))/!4&))/! #+"0 ),+0,AP=H Ġ BKQJ@PD=P>KPD?KHHEOEKJO=J@ŃECDPEJPAJOEPU@A?NA=OA@>U=BPANODEAH@SENAOSANAI=NGA@ BEAULAURIER (1981) summarised the results from 18 studies and found that, on average, marking PDAODEAH@SENAOKN?KJ@Q?PKNONAOQHPA@EJ?KHHEOEKJO@A?NA=OEJC>U&J0?DHAOSEC%KHOPAEJ PDA EJOP=HH=PEKJKB>EN@@ERANPANOKJPDACNKQJ@SENANAOQHPA@EJ=NA@Q?PEKJKB>EN@?KHHEOEKJ>U @ALAJ@EJCKJPDAOLA?EAOĠ'²!& ("AP=H
1DANA=NAJQIANKQOPULAO=J@R=NE=PEKJOKBI=NGANO=R=EH=>HAKJPDAI=NGAP1DANAD=O>AAJ=PNAIAJ dous amount of research conducted on marking power lines and the effectiveness of marking power HEJAO =HPDKQCDBASOPQ@EAOD=RA>AAJ=>HAPKRANEBUPDA=?PQ=HABBA?PKB?ANP=EJ@ARE?AOĠAC "3+ $"/ /l0"1% *=NGEJCSEPDPDASNKJC?KHKQNKNSNKJCPULAKB@ARE?AI=UJKP>AABBA?PERA =P OKHREJC PDA LNK>HAI =J@ I=U >A?KIA = I=EJPAJ=J?A LNK>HAI BKN PDA LKSAN ?KIL=JU KN ARAJ ?=QOAHEJAOPKCK@KSJEJATPNAIA?=OAOĠ /&!$"0+!"/0,+ 1DANABKNA EPEOEILAN=PERA PD=PABBA?PERA@ARE?AO=NAQOA@PKI=NGLKSANHEJAO
JQI>AN KB @ARE?AO D=RA ODKSJ CKK@ OQ??AOO =J@ =NA NA?KIIAJ@A@ BKN PDA !=JQ>A ?HEI=PAġ #ENA#HU EN@ #H=LLAN #HECDP !ERANPAN Ġļ#ENAŃU EN@I=NG BPANCHKS EN@ #HECDP !ERANPAN Ġ #! =J@ EN@#H=LLANOĠ/& "PULA Ġ#ECQNA https://birddiverter.eu/; http://www.hammarprodukter.com/; http://preformed.com/; https://www.ribe.de/en
1D=JGOPKPDAEN=>EHEPUPKNAŃA?P23HECDP >EN@@ERANPANOSEPD=OK?=HHA@=BPANCHKSABBA?PD=RAPDA=@R=J P=CAKB>AEJCREOE>HAEJHKSHECDP?KJ@EPEKJO SDAJ?KHHEOEKJO=NAIKOP?KIIKJ1DA@ARE?AO=HOKCHKS at night for up to 10 hours and can therefore provide a visual cue to night migrants and other birds that =NA=?PERA=PJECDP
27 Fig. 17: A wide range of bird diverters are available on the market to reduce bird collision with overhead power lines. Afterglow effects make them visible even during the night. © Clydes- dale Ltd and Lucia Deutschová Raptor
All bird diverters presented provide a visual stimulus that helps birds to avoid collisions with power HEJAO$QE@AHEJAOBKNPDAEJOP=HH=PEKJKB>EN@@ERANPANO=NA=R=EH=>HAĠAC3!"#++ 1DAENI=TEIQI ABBA?PEO=?DEARA@EBPDAU=NAEJOP=HHA@ARANUIAPNAO
*=NGANOODKQH@>AEJOP=HHA@ARANUIAPANOKJPDAKRANDA=@CNKQJ@SENAĠO &BIKNAPD=JKJACNKQJ@ SENAEOLNAOAJPĠKNEO=IA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJA PDAJI=NGANO=NALH=?A@=PIAPNAEJPANR=HO KJ=HPANJ=P EJCSENAOĠ#"//"/*$#"'+00ĠĢA@O
28 Fig. 18: Recommended placement method (10-metre intervals on alternating wires) for high effectiveness in reducing risk of bird collision with overhead electric lines.
/AOA=N?DEO=HOKQJ@ANS=UPK@ARAHKL=J=BBKN@=>HA EN@0PNEGA&J@E?=PKNĠ 0& =J@ EN@?PEREPU*KJE PKNEJCĠ * OUOPAIPKNAIKPAHU@APA?P=J@NA?KN@?KHHEOEKJO=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJOKJ=H=NCAO?=HA1DA EN@0PNEGA&J@E?=PKNĠ 0& EO=J=QPKI=PA@RE>N=PEKJOAJOEJC=J@NA?KN@EJCPKKH@AOECJA@PK@APA?P>EN@ OPNEGAOKJKRANDA=@?=>HAOOQ?D=OLKSANHEJAO=J@CQUSENAO&PLNKRE@AOOUOPAIKLAN=PKNOPDA=>EH EPUPK=BBKN@=>HUE@AJPEBUPDAIKOP@=JCANKQOHEJAOACIAJPO=J@@APANIEJAPDAABBA?PERAJAOOKBHEJA I=NGEJC@ARE?AO1DA 0&QOAO=??AHANKIAPANOPKNA?KN@OPNAOOS=RAO=J@RE>N=PEKJO?=QOA@>U=>EN@ OPNEGA1DA 0&OAJOKNO=NAEJOP=HHA@KJPDAIKJEPKNA@SENAO=J@PN=JOIEPOPNEGA=?PEREPUSENAHAOOHUPK= JA=N>U>=OAOP=PEKJ SDANAPDA@=P=EONA?KN@A@ EN@?PEREPU*KJEPKNĠ * EO=JEJPAHHECAJPEI=CA>=OA@OAJOEJC=J@NA?KN@EJCPKKHPK=OOEOPSEPD @AP=EHA@OPQ@UKBSEH@HEBAEJPAN=?PEKJOSEPDR=NEKQOPULAOKBOPNQ?PQNAO1DEO@ARE?AEO=>HAPK?=LPQNA store, and transmit video images of the interaction of birds with power lines, communication lines, and KPDANDQI=JI=@AOPNQ?PQNAO *O?=J=HOKABł?EAJPHUIKJEPKNPDAEIL=?PKBNAPNKłPPA@LKSANHEJAO Ġ%/+"00/ -+!"6 -%&))&-0$
5.2.3. Deconstruction of power lines and removal of the ground wire 1DANAIKR=HKBPDACNKQJ@SENABKNOKIAPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJAOI=U>A=JKPDANLKOOE>HAIEPEC=PEKJKLPEKJ &JOKIAOEPQ=PEKJO QLPKKB?KHHEOEKJOSEPDPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJAOI=UK??QNKJPDAKRANDA=@CNKQJ@ SENA>A?=QOAEPOOI=HHAN@E=IAPANI=GAOEP@EBł?QHPPKOAAEJHKSHECDP BKC=J@KPDANLKKNREOE>EHEPU?KJ @EPEKJOOPQ@U>U "3+$"/ /l0"1%Ġ BKQJ@PD=PSDAJPDACNKQJ@SENAS=ONAIKRA@ ?KHHEOEKJO@A?NA=OA@>UD=HBHPDKQCD=RE=>HAKLPEKJBKNNA@Q?EJC?KHHEOEKJO CNKQJ@SENANAIKR=HSEHH NAJ@ANPDALKSANHEJAIKNAOQO?ALPE>HAPKHECDPJEJC@=I=CAĠ(2/170%,"*("/ 1DANA BKNA NAIKR=HKBPDEOSENAEOJKP=HS=UO=RE=>HAKLPEKJ AOLA?E=HHUEJ=NA=OSDANAHECDPJEJCEO?KIIKJ (JKSHA@CA=J@?KKLAN=PEKJ=NAAOOAJPE=H?KILKJAJPOEJPDAOA=N?DBKNRE=>HAOKHQPEKJOBQHHU=@=LPA@ PKHK?=HOEPQ=PEKJO
29 5.2.4. Habitat modifications to minimise risk of collision %=>EP=PIK@Eł?=PEKJEO=JAJRENKJIAJP=HI=J=CAIAJPEJEPE=PERAPD=P?KQH@>AQOA@EJ?ANP=EJ?EN?QI OP=J?AOPKNA@Q?A?KHHEOEKJNEOGO1DANA=NAPSKH=J@IK@Eł?=PEKJKLPEKJOPD=P?=J>A?KJOE@ANA@ġ
*K@EBUD=>EP=PJA=NLKSANHEJAOPK@APANIEJA>EN@OŃECDPL=PDO#KNAT=ILHA LH=JPPNAAOPD=PSEHH CNKS?HKOAPKKN=>KRAPDADAECDPKBPDALKSANHEJAO1DEOSEHH?=QOA>EN@OPKC=EJ=HPEPQ@APK?HA=N PDAPNAAHEJA=J@OQ>OAMQAJPHU=HOK?HA=NPDALKSANHEJA *K@EBUH=J@QOAPKNA@Q?A>EN@O=?PEREPU=NKQJ@PDALKSANHEJA#KNAT=ILHA ?NA=PABAA@EJC habitat on the same side of the power line as roosting or nesting habitats so that birds have less NA=OKJPK?NKOOPDALKSANHEJA
%KSARAN D=>EP=PIK@Eł?=PEKJI=UJKP=HS=UO>ABA=OE>HA1DANA?KQH@>AHAC=H A?KJKIE?KN?KJOAN R=PEKJ=NCQIAJPO=C=EJOPOQ?DIK@Eł?=PEKJ#KNAT=ILHA EPI=UJKP>A@AOEN=>HAPKIK@EBUD=>EP=PEJ =NA=OSEPDN=NA OAJOEPERAKNOECJEł?=JPJ=PERAD=>EP=PO
5.3. Technical solutions against electrocution L=NPBNKIPDALKOOE>EHEPUKB=>OP=EJEJC?KILHAPAHUBNKI?KJOPNQ?PEJC=LKSANHEJA =O=HNA=@U@EO?QOOA@ EJ PDABKHHKSEJCIA=OQNAO?=J>AP=GAJPKLNKPA?P>EN@O=C=EJOPAHA?PNK?QPEKJ1DAOAIA=OQNAO =NAHEOPA@EJOAMQAJ?A=??KN@EJCPKPDAENJ=PQNA?KJOANR=PEKJR=HQA EAIA=OQNAOIAJPEKJA@łNOP=NA PK>ACERAJLNEKNEPUSDAJARANLKOOE>HA
5.3.1. Underground cabling 2J@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJCEOPDAQHPEI=PAIAPDK@KB?DKE?A =OEP?KILHAPAHU=J@LANI=JAJPHUAT?HQ@AO>KPD AHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@?KHHEOEKJ%KSARAN PDEOLNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAEOATLAJOERA=J@@EBł?QHPPKEILHAIAJPEJ NK?GUPANN=EJ1DAAOPEI=PA@?KOPEO=>KQPPDKQO=J@"QNKLANGEHKIAPNABKN=G3LKSANHEJAĠ* $¹HEO LANO?KII +ARANPDAHAOO EJPDAEJPANAOPKB=LANI=JAJPOKHQPEKJ QJ@ANCNKQJ@?=>HEJCODKQH@ =HS=UO>A?KJOE@ANA@=J@EILHAIAJPA@=O=I=PPANKBLNEKNEPU
5.3.2. Primary surface solutions 4AQJ@ANOP=J@PDAOAOKHQPEKJOPK>APDKOAPD=PLNKRE@AHKJCPANI=J@=HIKOPLAN?AJPLNKPA?PEKJ &JLN=?PE?A EPD=O>AAJODKSJPD=PPDAOALNKPA?PERAłPPEJCO@KJKPEJ?NA=OAPDAI=EJPAJ=J?ASKNG NAMQENA@>UPDAOUOPAIKLAN=PKN0Q?DOKHQPEKJO?=JAEPDAN>AĠ =PP=?DA@PKPDALKSAN?=>HAEPOAHBKN Ġ PKPDALKHA?KJOPNQ?PEKJ &JPDAł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Ġ3!"#++ BNKISDE?DSAMQKPAPDABKHHKSEJCIEJEIQI@EIAJOEKJO=J@NA?KIIAJ@=PEKJOġ 4DAJARANLKOOE>HA LUHKJ?KJOPNQ?PEKJOSEPDOQOLAJOEKJĠD=JCEJC EJOQH=PKNO=NAPK>A?=NNEA@KQP&J KN@ANPK=RKE@Ġ= ?KJ@Q?PKNA=NPD?KJP=?PO LAN?DAOBKN>EN@OKJA=NPDA@L=NPOIQOP>A=PHA=OPI =S=UBNKI=?PERAL=NPOPD=P=NAJKPLNKPA?PA@=C=EJOP@ENA?P?KJP=?P1DEOIEJEIQI@EOP=J?A=HOK=L LHEAOPKLAN?DAOKJ=?PERAL=NPONAC=N@EJCA=NPDA@L=NPO&JPDA?=OAKBA=NPDA@LAN?DAOBKN>EN@O>AHKS =?PERAL=NPOJKPLNKPA?PA@=C=EJOP@ENA?P?KJP=?P =J=@@EPEKJ=HRANPE?=H@EOP=J?AKBIIQOP>AI=EJ P=EJA@ĠEAIEJPKP=H &JKN@ANPK=RKE@Ġ> ?KJ@Q?PKN?KJ@Q?PKN?KJP=?PO PDADKNEVKJP=H@EOP=J?A IQOP>AJKPHAOOPD=JIBKN>EN@LAN?DAO>APSAAJPDA?KJ@Q?PKNOĠKJKRANDA=@HEJAO>APSAAJ L=NPOJKPLNKPA?PA@=C=EJOP@ENA?P?KJP=?P
30 5.3.3. Secondary surface solutions 0A?KJ@=NUOKHQPEKJO@EBBANBNKILNEI=NUOKHQPEKJOEJPD=PPDAUNAMQENAEJ?NA=OA@I=EJPAJ=J?A=J@=NA JKPLAN?AJPO=BA =PHA=OPKRANPEIA#KNAT=ILHA ATPNAIASA=PDAN?KJ@EPEKJOKNI=PANE=HB=PECQA ?=JI=GAPDAR=HRAOEJRKHRA@QJQO=>HA=J@=OOAI>HUANNKNO?=JJARAN>A?KILHAPAHUNQHA@KQP%KS ARAN LNKPA?PERAIA=OQNAOOQ?D=O>EN@LNKPA?PEKJDKK@O=NA=CKK@IA=JOKBI=GEJCLUHKJOO=BA>U NAPNKłPPEJC &JLNEJ?ELHA PDAO=IAO=BAPU@EOP=J?AOIQOP>AK>OANRA@=OSEPDLNEI=NUIA=OQNAOĠ?B 1DEO means that there must be no potential perch below the bird protection cover in a vertical distance of I %KSARAN >EN@LNKPA?PEKJDKK@OKB=PHA=OPIEJHAJCPD=NANAMQENA@Ġ=OIPQNJA@KQPPK>APKK ODKNPEJOKIA?=OAOĢ4 ÌDIAN + 2 LANO?KII =J@PDAUIQOP>A=PP=?DA@PKPDAOQLLKNPEJ OQH=PKNOKJIA@EQIRKHP=CAHEJAO #EJ=HHU ?KILHAPAJAOOKBPDAOA?QNEPUIA=OQNAOIQOP=HOK>AAJOQNA@#KNAT=ILHA EPEOJKPAJKQCDPK EJOP=HH>EN@LNKPA?PEKJDKK@OKJHUKJ=LKSANHEJA=??KIL=JUEJC=N=EHS=ULKSANHEJA1DAQLLAN?=JPE HARANPQ>AIQOP=HOK>AOA?QNA@=C=EJOPAHA?PNK?QPEKJKB>EN@OĠEBPDEOEOJKP=HNA=@UCQ=N=JPAA@>UEPO ?KJOPNQ?PEKJ ACSEPD=HKJCNK@EJOQH=PKN It is not possible to list all the options in this position paper, but it should be kept in mind that such IA=OQNAO ?=J >A DECDHU ?KILHAT EN@ LNKPA?PEKJ DKK@O DKOAO ?UHEJ@ANO HKJC NK@ EJOQH=PKNO NEJC CNE@O AP?=NAQOA@BKNPDEOLQNLKOAĠKJAATPNAIAAT=ILHAEOPDAOA?QNEJCKB=?KILHATPN=JOBKNIAN 1DAOAIQOP>ALH=JJA@BKNA=?DEJ@ERE@Q=H?=OA=J@NAREASA@>U=JATLANP
5.3.4. Missing or unsuitable solutions &JLNEJ?ELHASA=OOQIAPD=P EJ=IK@ANJOK?EAPU PDAJACHECAJPGEHHEJCKB>EN@O=J@KPDAN=JEI=HOLA?EAO PDNKQCDDQI=JEJBN=OPNQ?PQNAEOJKHKJCAN=??ALP=>HA#KNPDEONA=OKJ PDANA=NA=HNA=@UHAC=HBN=IA SKNGO KN RKHQJP=NU =CNAAIAJPO >APSAAJ KLAN=PKNO =J@ J=PQNA ?KJOANR=PEKJ KNC=JEO=PEKJO EJ I=JU ?KQJPNEAO,JHU=>OKHQPAHUO=BAOKHQPEKJOODKQH@>A?DKOAJEJJAS?KJOPNQ?PEKJO =J@NAPNKłPPEJCIQOP >A?=NNEA@KQP=PHA=OP=PļDKPOLKPOSEPDEJ=NA=OKJ=>HA=J@BA=OE>HALANEK@KBPEIAĠģUA=NO %KSARAN OKIAPEIAOSAHHEJPAJ@A@IA=OQNAO?=JLNKRAPK>AEJABBA?PERAKNARAJ?KQJPANLNK@Q?PERA Ġļ>=@AJCEJAANEJC 4A?=JJKP@A=HSEPD=HHARAJPQ=HEPEAODANA >QPSKQH@HEGAPKEHHQOPN=PAPDEOPKLE? SEPDPSKBNAMQAJPHUK??QNNEJCAT=ILHAO "T=ILHA?KJ?ANJOPDAJEI=H$Q=N@ =@AŃA?PKN>=OA@KJ=JAHA?PNKOP=PE?OUOPAI1DAIK@AKBKL AN=PEKJ =HECDPAHA?PNE?ODK?G EOJKPQJ?KJPNKRANOE=H4DEHAOKIA=QPDKNO@KJKPATLA?P=JUJAC=PERA ?KJOAMQAJ?AOBKNPDA>EN@O>K@U@QAPKPDA=LLHE?=PEKJKBPDAJEI=H$Q=N@BKN=JEI=HLDUOEKHKCE?=H NA=OKJOĠ&3&0 + 2$ANI=JUD=OJKP>AAJ=>HAPKNQHAKQPOA?KJ@=NUABBA?POKJPDAJANRKQO OUOPAIKB>EN@EJ@ERE@Q=HO&JKN@ANPK?H=NEBUPDEOPA?DJE?=H@EOLQPA =JATLANEIAJPSEHH>A?=NNEA@KQPEJ Ġ4 ÌDIAN LANO?KII 4A?=JJKPNA?KIIAJ@=LKPAJPE=HHU@=JCANKQO@AŃA?PKNQJPEHPDEO łJ=H?H=NEł?=PEKJD=O>AAJI=@A "T=ILHA?KJ?ANJOPA?DJE?=HHULNKRE@A@LAN?DAO/ALA=PA@HU OQLLKOA@HUIKNA=PPN=?PERA>EN@LAN?D AO=NA=PP=?DA@>UPDAKLAN=PKNOKJLUHKJDA=@O SDE?D=NAAEPDANJKP=??ALPA@>UPDA>EN@O=P=HH KN ?KJPEJQAPK>A=N=RANUDECDNAOE@Q=HNEOGKBAHA?PNK?QPEKJ%00 %¶/"+ "/$Ġ CERAJQIAN KQOAT=ILHAOSDANA?KJOPNQ?PEKJOKBPDEOPULA@E@JKP=?DEARAPDA@AOENA@ABBA?P&PODKQH@>AOP=PA@ ?HA=NHUDANAPD=POKHQPEKJOOQ?D=OPDAOA?=JKJHU>AQOA@EJ=JAIANCAJ?UOEPQ=PEKJKNEJ=@@EPEKJPK KPDANO =J@PD=PPDAU?=JJKPNALH=?AO=BAEJOQH=PEKJKN ARAJ>APPAN =LANI=JAJPHUO=BA?KJRANOEKJ &J?E@AJP=HHU PDAO=IAPDEJC?=J=HOKD=LLAJEJPDAKLLKOEPA?=OA EB=J=PPAILPEOI=@APKLNARAJP H=J@EJC>UOK?=HHA@OLEGA@AŃA?PKNO1DAH=PPAN=NAKBPAJECJKNA@>U>EN@O=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJOPEHHK??QNO ĠOAAłCEJ ²%*"/%0
31 '$18%()5((6.<ăDPRGHOIRUELUGFRQVHUYDWLRQDWODUJH ULYHUVLQ(XURSH
&J=@@EPEKJPKJ=PEKJ=HJ=PQNA?KJOANR=PEKJH=SO PDA%=>EP=PO!ENA?PERAĠ"" AJOQNAOPDA?KJ servation of a wide range of rare, threatened or endemic animal and plant species, and an addition =H=LLNKTEJBNAMQAJP=J@?D=N=?PANEOPE?D=>EP=PPULAOĠhttp://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/ legislation/habitatsdirective 1DA EN@O!ENA?PERAĠ"" =EIOPKLNKPA?P=HHKBPDA=LLNKT SEH@>EN@OLA?EAOJ=PQN=HHUK??QNNEJCEJPDA"QNKLA=J2JEKJĠhttp://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/ legislation/birdsdirective JEILKNP=JPL=NPKBPDAOA@ENA?PERAOEOPDA@AOECJ=PEKJKB+=PQN= OEPAOEJKN@ANPKAJOQNAPDA?KJOANR=PEKJKB"QNKLAOJ=PQN=HDANEP=CAEJPDEOJAPSKNGKBLNKPA?PA@=N A=O!=JQ>A?KQJPNEAOPD=P=NAJKPUAPIAI>ANOEJPDA"2 OQ?D=O0AN>E= D=RA=@KLPA@?KIL=N=>HA HACEOH=PEKJKBPDAENKSJ
1DAH=NCAJQI>ANKB+=PQN=OEPAO=HKJCPDA!=JQ>ANERAN?KQNOAEO=?HA=N?KIIEPIAJPPKPDA ?KJOANR=PEKJKB"QNKLAOJ=PQN=HPNA=OQNAOKJ=?KJPEJAJP=HO?=HA
1DAI=?NKNACEKJ=HOPN=PACUJKSLNKRE@AO=NAH=PERAHUJASLKHE?UBN=IASKNGBKNPDA!=JQ>ANACEKJ 1DA!=JQ>A/ACEKJ0PN=PACU=@@NAOOAO SEPDEJPDA-NEKNEPUNA=O=J@ PDAPKLE?OKB0QOP=EJ=>HA"J ANCU=J@ EK@ERANOEPU)=J@O?=LAO NAOLA?PERAHU1DAAJANCU-NEKNEPUNA=P=GAO=PDNAABKH@=LLNK=?D EJ?HQ@EJCPDA?KKN@EJ=PEKJKBNACEKJ=HAJANCULKHE?EAOEJKN@ANPKATLHKEPPDABQHHLKPAJPE=HKB=JEJPACN=P A@AJANCUI=NGAP PDAEJPACN=PEKJKBPDAAJANCUI=NGAPOKBPDAJKJ"2?KQJPNEAO =J@PKH=QJ?D?QP PEJCA@CAPA?DJKHKCU@ARAHKLIAJPO PKEJ?NA=OAPDAAJANCUABł?EAJ?UKBPDANACEKJ=J@AJD=J?APDA QOAKBNAJAS=>HAAJANCUOKQN?AO1DAP=NCAPOKB-NEKNEPUNA==NABKQNBKH@ġPK=?DEARA=OECJEł?=JP =J@IA=OQN=>HAEILNKRAIAJP =@=LPA@PKPDAOLA?E=HJAA@OKBPDAOLA?EAO=J@D=>EP=PO?KRANA@>UPDA EU nature legislation in the Danube Region, to enhance the work on establishing green infrastructure =J@PDALNK?AOOKBNAOPKN=PEKJKB=PHA=OPKB@ACN=@A@A?KOUOPAIO>U PKE@AJPEBU=J@LNEKN EPEOAEJR=OERA=HEAJOLA?EAO=J@PDAENL=PDS=UOEJKN@ANPK?KJPNKHKNAN=@E?=PALNEKNEPUOLA?EAO =J@PK continue the ongoing work and efforts to securing viable populations of Danube sturgeon species and KPDANEJ@ECAJKQOłODOLA?EAOĠhttps://www.danube-nature.eu
!+2 "#/""0(6EOOQLLKNPA@>UPDA"20PN=PACUBKNPDA!=JQ>A/ACEKJ KPD-NEKNEPUNA=ļ0QO P=EJ=>HA"JANCU=J@-NEKNEPUNA=ļ EK@ERANOEPU=J@)=J@O?=LA?KJOE@ANPDEOEJEPE=PERA=O=CKK@ AT=ILHABKN?NKOOOA?PKN?KKLAN=PEKJ=J@=O=?KJ?NAPA?KJPNE>QPEKJPK>EN@?KJOANR=PEKJ=HKJCLKSAN HEJAOPDNKQCDEJJKR=PERAPA?DJE?=HOKHQPEKJO #QNPDANIKNA !+2 "#/""0(6=EIOPK?KJPNE>QPAPKN=EOA=S=NAJAOOBKNPDEOEOOQA=J@PK?KJPNE>QPA SEPD?KJ?NAPA=?PEKJOPKPDA KJJ=J@ ANJ KJRAJPEKJO=J@PDA EK@ERANOEPU0PN=PACU !AOLEPAPDA?HA=NEJ@E?=PEKJPD=PH=NCANERANO=NALNEKNEPU=NA=OBKN>EN@?KJOANR=PEKJ=HKJCLKSANHEJAO !+2 "#/""0(6EO=łNOPQJEMQAEJEPE=PERAKJ=NERANSE@AO?=HA 1DA=S=NAJAOON=EOA@=?NKOO>KN@ANO=J@=?NKOOOA?PKNOEJEPE=PA@=OPN=PACE?=LLNK=?D=J@NAOQHPA@EJ D=NIKJEOA@=J@OPAL>UOPALEILHAIAJP=PEKJKB?KJOANR=PEKJ=?PEKJO PPDA!+2 "#/""0(6?KJBANAJ?AEJ1QH?A=Ġ0ALPAI>AN LKOOE>HABQPQNA?KKLAN=PEKJOSANA @ARAHKLA@PKCAPDANSEPD EN@)EBA&JPANJ=PEKJ=H 1DA!+2 "#/""0(6LKOEPEKJL=LANEOJKS=J=LLA=HBKNBQHHEILHAIAJP=PEKJKB>EN@?KJOANR=PEKJKJ LKSANHEJAO=HKJCPDA!=JQ>ANERAN=J@ODKQH@OAPOP=J@=N@OBKN=HHKPDANH=NCANERANOEJ"QNKLA
32 $FNQRZOHGJHPHQWV
4A=NACN=PABQHPKD=RA>AAJCERAJPDAKLLKNPQJEPUPKSNEPAPDEOLKOEPEKJL=LAN SEPDEJPDABN=IASKNG KBPDA!+2 "L=NGO ,++" 1"!LNKFA?P BQJ@A@>UPDA&JPANNAC!=JQ>A1N=JOJ=PEKJ=H-NKCN=IIA *$¹HEOS=OL=NPKBPDAATLANPPA=IBKNPDA=OOAOOIAJPKBPDA@=JCANKQOJAOOKBLKSANLUHKJO! *=ĊEÚS=ONAOLKJOE>HABKNPDA$&0=J=HUOEO /-NEJVLNKRE@A@EHHQOPN=PERAI=LO%KSARAN EPSKQH@D=RA >AAJEILKOOE>HAPKLNK@Q?APDEOOPN=PACE?@K?QIAJPSEPDKQPPDAEJLQPKBI=JUATLANPOBNKIPDA!=J Q>A?KQJPNEAO =J@SASKQH@HEGAPKPD=JGPDAIIKOPOEJ?ANAHUĠ=J@EJ=HLD=>APE?=HKN@AN ġ0>ANHA 0 HQP=QIÐHHAN 4 ÌDIAN $U ÄNÉ ' D=RGK 0 DAODIA@FEAR $ NAPQ #ANO?D #NKJ?KR= 0$AEnHAN )!AQPO?DKR¹ !!K>NAR 3"ÜEIKREÚ "%=LH %%ANVEC 7%ACUE !%QHA= 3'KOELKREÚ /(=VE $U(EOO '(H=NEÚ 7(KR¹?O **=HAJE?= $*KNKVKR 1*EGQĊG= &*QJPA=JQ "+AQHEJC 1-=LL 1-=NN=C "-APGKR= *-KLEÚ '/=ĊEÚ 3/KĜ=? */QĜEÚ 10?DJAE@AN 1KIEG 1ÉPD *1Q?=GKR 'ĉIÄ@ %0PKPV 0/=GE? !3=NC= ,4EA@EJC=J@*7A?#EJ=HHU SA=NACN=PABQHPK 0A=I=JBKNPDALNKKBNA=@EJC
&JL=NPE?QH=N KQN=?GJKSHA@CAIAJPONABANPK=HHATLANPOEJPDAAJANCUOA?PKN1DABNQEPBQH?KKLAN=PEKJ SEPDJQIANKQOPN=JOIEOOEKJOUOPAIKLAN=PKNO =J@PDAENABBKNPOPKLH=J PKLNAL=NA=J@PKEILHAIAJP PDAI=JU@EBBANAJPLEHKP=?PEKJOSEPDEJPDABN=IASKNGKB!+2 "#/""0(6 SANAPDAI=EJOKQN?A KBATLANEAJ?AOC=EJA@
33 /LWHUDWXUH
))+'!0#)" ("/Ġ ġ EK@ERANOEPU?KJOANR=PEKJEJNQJJEJCS=PANO EKO?EAJ?Aġ ),+0, ' ),+0, ' =J@ *2,7-2)&!, / *EPEC=PEKJ KB >EN@ ?KHHEOEKJO PDNKQCD CNKQJ@SENAI=NGEJC EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJġ +!/"40Ġ ġ#N=CIAJP=PEKJKBD=>EP=P>UNK=@O=J@QPEHEPU?KNNE@KNOġ=NAREASQOPN=H7KKHK CEOPġ -)& ĠRE=J-KSAN)EJA&JPAN=?PEKJ KIIEPPAAĢ ġ*EPEC=PEJC EN@ KHHEOEKJOSEPD-KSAN)EJAOġ 1DA0P=PAKBPDANPEJ"@EOKJ"HA?PNE?&JOPEPQPAĠ""& 4=ODEJCPKJ ! L -)& ĠRE=J-KSAN)EJA&JPAN=?PEKJ KIIEPPAAĢ ġ0QCCAOPA@LN=?PE?AOBKN=RE=JLNKPA?PEKJKJ LKSANHEJAOġPDAOP=PAKBPDA=NP"@EOKJ"HA?PNE?&JOPEPQPA -)& =J@PDA =HEBKNJE="JANCU KI IEOOEKJ 4=ODEJCPKJ ! =J@ =HEBKNJE= 20 "2)2/&"/ !*EPEC=PEKJKB>EN@?KHHEOEKJOSEPDPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJAO KJJAREHHA-KSAN@IEJ EOPN=PEKJ 20!AL=NPIAJPKB"JANCU KQH@AN KHKN=@KL "+ª1"7)¯-"7 HGAI=@A/=J@3ANSAEF-Ġ ġ1DAEIL=?POKBNAK=@O=J@KPDANEJBN=OPNQ? PQNAKJI=II=H=J@>EN@LKLQH=PEKJOġIAP==J=HUOEO EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJġ "3+$"/(Ġ ġ EN@EJPAN=?PEKJOSEPDQPEHEPUOPNQ?PQNAOġ?KHHEOEKJO=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ ?=QOAO=J@ IEPEC=PEJCIA=OQNAO&>EOġ "3+$"/(Ġ ġ EKHKCE?=H=J@?KJOANR=PEKJ=OLA?POKB>EN@IKNP=HEPU?=QOA@>UAHA?PNE?EPULKSAN HEJAOġ=NAREAS EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJġ "3+$"/ (=J@ /l0"1% % EN@ KHHEOEKJOSEPDLKSANHEJAO=JATLANEIAJPSEPDLP=NIE C=JĠ)=CKLQOOLL EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJġ ²%*"/4!%0Ġ ġ0PNKIPK@RKJ3ÌCAHJ)ÌOQJCO=JO¼PVA=QBJ=PEKJ=HAIQJ@EJPANJ= PEKJ=HAI+ERA=Q,NJ*EPPġ /&!$"0 '*=J@+!"/0,+ 1/*EPEC=PEJCPDAEIL=?POKBAHA?PNE?B=?EHEPEAOPK>EN@O"JRE NKJIAJP=H KJ?ANJOEJ/ECDPOKB4=U*=J=CAIAJPġ0ARAJPD&JPANJ=PEKJ=H0UILKOEQIĪ"HOARE AN0?EAJ?A)P@LL !IE?K* =PNU& *=NPEJO/ O?AJO»K# =NNEAJPKO/*KNEAEN=#Ġ ġ EN@KJPDASENAġ )=J@O?=LALH=JJEJC?KJOE@ANEJC?KOPO=J@>AJAłPOBKN>EN@LKLQH=PEKJO?KATEOPEJCSEPDLKSANHEJAO Ambio, https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-018-1025-zQJ@-ÀNAV$=N?Ä='* !A3=QHP1 KPAHH=# 0¹J?DAV7=L=P='Ġ ġ2OEJCNEOGLNA@E?PEKJIK@AHO=J@OLA?EAOOAJOEPEREPUI=LOBKNH=NCAO?=HA E@AJPEł?=PEKJKBEJBN=OPNQ?PQNANAH=PA@SEH@HEBALNKPA?PA@=NA=Oġ1DA?=OAKB>EN@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJ !3&0-*Ġ ġ HEI=PA?D=JCAEILHE?=PEKJOBKNNERANNAOPKN=PEKJEJCHK>=H>EK@ERANOEPUDKPOLKPO /AOPKN=PEKJ"?KHġ !"*"/!7%&"3!Ġ ġ#=?PKNOEJŃQAJ?EJC>EN@IKNP=HEPU?=QOA@>ULKSANHEJAOSEPDEJOLA?E=H LNKPA?PA@=NA=O=J@QJ@ANP=GAJ?KJOANR=PEKJABBKNPO?P=VKKH QHCġ !AIAPAN& %KNR¹PD* +=CU( $ÌNÌCD7 1ÉPD- =CUQN=' 0KHP0 (KR¹?O !SUAN'#/ "%=NJAOOĠ ġ!K?QIAJPEJC=J@NA@Q?EJC=RE=JAHA?PNK?QPEKJOEJ%QJC=NUġ=?KJOANR=PEKJ?KJPNE >QPEKJBNKI?EPEVAJO?EAJPEOPO1DA4EHOKJ'KQNJ=HKB,NJEPDKHKCU !/"4&11)/%4)+$01,+Ġ ġ KHHEOEKJABBA?POKBSEJ@LKSANCAJAN=PKNO=J@KPDAN K>OP=?HAOKJ>EN@O+AS6KNG?=@AIUKB0?EAJ?Aġ !2!$",+! /1%&+$1,+% $"00+"/*, (4 17& (+,4)"/!' )¦3§.2" +&*+/' -/&"2//& %/!% 0,1,! 01&00+6*)' 02))&3+Ġ ġ#NAOD S=PAN>EK@ERANOEPUġEILKNP=J?A PDNA=PO OP=PQO=J@?KJOANR=PEKJ?D=HHAJCAO EKH/ARġ "))&,11 %/&01&"! '21$)/# $/ &"#'$*(&/4+Ġ= $NA=P4DEPA-AHE ?=JĠ-AHA?=JQOKJK?NKP=HQO &Jġ!")%,6,' "))&,11 0/$1)' %/&01&"!"!"'2+ ĠA@O ġ %=J@>KKG KB PDA EN@O KB PDA 4KNH@ HERA )UJT "@E?EKJO =N?AHKJ= ĠNAPNEARA@BNKI https:// www.hbw.com/node/52610 on 17 January 2018)
34 "))&,11 %/&01&"! '21$)/# (&/4+$* '0%/-"Ġ> !=HI=PE=J-AH E?=J Ġ-AHA?=JQO?NEOLQO &Jġ!")%,6,' "))&,11 0/$1)' %/&01&"! "!"'2+ ĠA@O ġ%=J@>KKGKBPDA EN@OKBPDA4KNH@HERA)UJT"@E?EKJO =N?AHKJ=ĠNAPNEARA@BNKIhttps://www. hbw.com/node/52613 on 17 January 2018) #+"0 EN@>AD=REKN=J@IKNP=HEPUEJNAH=PEKJPKLKSANHEJAOEJLN=ENEAD=>EP=PO#EOD=J@ 4EH@HEBA1A?DJE?=H/ALKNP2JEPA@0P=PAO!AL=NPIAJPKBPDA&JPANEKN#EOD=J@4EH@HEBA0ANRE?AL #"//"/*$#"'+00ĠĢA@O ġ EN@O=J@LKSANHEJAO KHHEOEKJ AHA?PNK?QPEKJ=J@>NAA@EJC .QAN?QO *=@NE@ LL #"//"/*Ġ ġ EN@O=J@LKSANHEJAO#NKI?KJŃE?PPKOKHQPEKJ"+!"00=J@#QJ@=?EKJ*& $/"0 0AREHH= LL #E@HÉ?VGU' =CUQN=' +=CU( 1ÉPD- 0VEPP=1)%=N=OVPDUĠ ġ EN@?KJOANR=PEKJKJAHA? PNE?LKSANHEJAOEJ%QJC=NUġ+AOP>KTAOBKNO=GANB=H?KJ=J@=RE=JLNKPA?PEKJ=C=EJOPAHA?PNK?QPEKJO -NKFA?PONALKNP0HKR=G/=LPKN'KQNJ=Hġ $)&0* !"210 %,3) ĉ*ª!1' %-)"' %3(,Ġ ġ3UOKG¹?AJ=V=LKDK@HEA=HA>K NEVEGKRKOĹAHAGPNE?GÑ?DRA@AJÄLNARKĸJAĜEFÎ?A@NQDURP¹GKR&Jġ(/2*-),37 7&$,3*#12 )&0ĠA@O ġ7KKHÉCE=7>KNJÄGLNÄOLARGKRVRA@A?GÀDKGKJCNAOQ +EPN=+KRAI>AN $)&0* !"210 %,3) ĉ*ª!1' %-)"' %3(,Ġ ġ3LHURGKJĊPNQGÜJÀDKLNARA@A JE=GKJVKHUOPòLQG3=FAFKĊAPNAJE=J=ÎINPJKOĹRP¹GKR&Jġ /6'' %,/0(* %,/0(,33 ă"%(7'72()ĠA@O ġ7KKHKCE?GÀ@JU NJK0>KNJÄG=>OPN=GPđVGKJBANAJ?AÎJKN= $AN@VDEGKR$-!!AIAN@VDEARĠ ġ!=P=KJ>EN@IKNP=GEPUEJĽ0=G=N& Ġ $ ?=QOA@ >AD=V=N@KQOLKSANHEJAO"?KHKCE= =HG=JE?=ġ $,/&2-- ,&+2$' %"/+& %(,Ġ ġ1DA!=JQ>A!AHP=ġ"QNKLAONAI=NG=>HASAP H=J@ NEPEOD EN@Oġ $QEH# KHKIAN**KNAJK,LK/*=NC=HE@=Ġ ġ0L=?APEIAPNAJ@OEJ0L=JEOD>EN@AHA? PNK?QPEKJN=PAOBNKI=HPANJ=PERAEJBKNI=PEKJOKQN?AO$HK>=H"?KHKCU=J@ KJOANR=PEKJġ %0! 0 %¶/"+ "/$ĠĢ%NOC ġ0PNKIPK@RKJ3ÌCAHJ$NQJ@H=CAJQJ@0P=J@=N@OVQI 3KCAHO?DQPV=J#NAEHAEPQJCAJ0P=J@@AN"NGAJJPJEOOA $AOAPVHE?DA3KNC=>AJ &JPANJ=PEKJ=HA>GKI IAJ 4AHPSAEPAN%=J@HQJCO>A@=NB²GKHKCEA@AN3ÌCAH =J@ 0 %/+"00/ -+!"6 -%&))&-0$Ġ ġ EN@0PNEGA&J@E?=PKN EN@?PEREPU*KJEPKN=J@ Field Assessment of Avian Fatalities, EPRI, Palo Alto, CA, Audubon National Wildlife Refuge, Colehar bor, ND, Edison Electric Institute, Washington, DC, Bonneville Power Administration, Portland, OR, =HEBKNJE="JANCU KIIEOOEKJ 0=?N=IAJPK +KNPD4AOPANJ"JANCU QPPA *1 ,PPAN1=EH-KSAN KIL=JU #ANCQO#=HHO *+ 0KQPDANJ =HEBKNJE="@EOKJ /KOAIA=@ 4AOPANJNA=-KSAN@IEJ EOPN=PEKJ )=GASKK@ ,ġ %" ( +0Ġ ġ#ENAŃU>EN@ŃECDP@ERANPANġ@QN=>EHEPUPAOPEJC2JLQ>HEODA@OPQ@UHP=)EJG*=J=CA IAJP)P@ %,%"+"$$"/'Ġ ġJPDNKLKCAJRANQNO=?DPA GKHHEOEKJOQJ@AHAGPNKGQPEKJO>A@EJCPA3ANHQOPA >AE3ÌCAHJĠRAO I AEOLEAHAEJAN =DJOPNA?GAEIJÌN@HE?DAJ+EA@ANÌOPANNAE?D#=?D>ANAE?DO=N>AEP =QO EKHKCEAQJ@2ISAHPGQJ@A QJ@AOCUIJ=OEQI%KNJ 0AEPAJQJ@VQO¼PVHE?DA1=> H¼PPAN & -!/Ġ ġ0PQNCAKJLNKCN=IBKNPDALNKPA?PEKJ=J@NAD=>EHEP=PEKJKB!=JQ>AOPQNCAKJO & -!/ !=JQ>A0PQNCAKJ1=OG#KN?A!=JQ>A/ACEKJOPN=PACU 3EAJJ=&JPANJ=PEKJ=H AJPNA LL &3&0Ġ ġ3ANEłVEANQJCQJ@ ANA?DJQJC@AOJEI=H$Q=N@BÐNG3QJ@ %V$QP=?DPAJ@AO &JOPEPQPOBÐN3ANGADNOEJBN=OPNQGPQNEIQBPN=C@AN² &JBN=OPNQGPQN$ )QVANJ 0 '+00$"#Ġ ġRE=JIKNP=HEPUBNKILKSANHEJAOġ=IKNLDKHKCE?=LLNK=?DKB=OLA?EAOOLA?Eł? IKNP=HEPU EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJġ 'Ì@E?GA( )AIGA%**AN?GANĠ ġ4ENGO=IGAEPRKJ3KCAHO?DQPVI=NGEANQJCAJ=J"N@OAEHAJ RKJ%Ì?DOPOL=JJQJCOHAEPQJCAJ+=PQNO?DQPVQJ@)=J@O?D=BPOLH=JQJC (/6(&+&3Ġ ġ EN@OKBLNAU=J@LKSANHEJAOEJ+KNPDANJ"QN=OE=ġ4D=P=NAPDALNKOLA?POKB OQNRER=H/=LPKNO KJOANR=PEKJġ
35 (&00' */&+,3*Ġ ġ3=CAHQJB=HHA=J1AHABKJHAEPQJCAJ3KCAH@AN%AEI=PRKHJK LL (A=N 'ĠĢA@ ġ!Q?GO $AAOA=J@0S=JO,TBKN@2JERANOEPU-NAOO ,TBKN@ (2/17 " 0%,"*("/ 1* Ġ ġ 1DA )EJAI=JO =J@ =>HAI=JO D=J@>KKG PD "@EPEKJ *?$N=S%EHH &J? ),000/ 4&))1*//--Ġ ġ/AłJEJCAOPEI=PAOKB>EN@?KHHEOEKJ=J@AHA?PNK?QPEKJIKN P=HEPU=PLKSANHEJAOEJPDA2JEPA@0P=PAOhttps://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0101565 */&+,3* -,$+1 !,/,ć"+ 2 +& %"/02& )"5"3 1/+,3 ,7$&"3& &/ 1,ĉ&Ù(' (&00Ġ= ġ*KJEPKNEJCPDA$NA=P4DEPA-AHE?=JĠ-AHA?=JQOKJK?N=PKHQO)EJJ=AQO >NAA@EJCLKLQH=PEKJQOEJC@NKJAOEJPDA!=JQ>A!AHP=Ġ/KI=JE= 0?EAJPEł?JJ=HOKBPDA !=JQ>A!AHP=&JOPEPQPAġ */&+,3* !,/,ć"+ 2 )"5"3 ++2 ' (&00Ġ> ġ+ASJAOPEJCOEPABKN!=H I=PE=J-AHE?=JĠ-AHA?=JQO?NEOLQO EJ=LKHUOLA?Eł??KHKJUKB=MQ=PE?>EN@OKJ1=Ĉ=QH)=GAĠ/KI=JE= 0?EAJPEł?JJ=HOKBPDA!=JQ>A!AHP=&JOPEPQPAġ *&(20('1*&(20(Ġ ġ EN@OKBPDA!=JQ>AR=HHAUEJ NK=PE=J=HE7=RK@=V=VJ=JOPRAJE N=@Q,OEFAGQ %72ġ *6"/0+ *&11"/*"&"// *&11"/*"&"/ $ !#,+0" $ '("+1Ġ ġ EK @ERANOEPUDKPOLKPOBKN?KJOANR=PEKJLNEKNEPEAO+=PQNAġ +"*"0%7&" (²3¦/0 7 %,0#" %,/31%7 1&%+6&$ *¯/, 7 *&(20(1 %*& )&1"/(& -,++&(00 *&7"/1(07 ¯Ġ ġ+=PQN=H=J@=JPDNKLKCAJE?EJŃQ AJ?AOKJPDALKLQH=PEKJOPNQ?PQNAKBSDEPAP=EHA@A=CHAOEJPDA =NL=PDE=J =OEJ=J@?AJPN=H"QNKLA' RE=J EKHġ +"41,+&Ġ ġ1DAIECN=PEKJA?KHKCUKB>EN@O?=@AIE?-NAOO )KJ@KJ LL -ÀNAV$=N?Ä='* !A3=QHP1 KPAHH=#0¹J?DAV7=L=P='Ġ ġ2OEJCNEOGLNA@E?PEKJIK@AHO =J@OLA?EAOOAJOEPEREPUI=LOBKNH=NCAO?=HAE@AJPEł?=PEKJKBEJBN=OPNQ?PQNANAH=PA@SEH@HEBALNKPA?PA@ =NA=Oġ1DA?=OAKB>EN@AHA?PNK?QPEKJ EKHKCE?=H KJOANR=PEKJ -/&+0"+%* ,"/"$ -ª/"0+''0*))&"''Ġ ġ/AREASKBPDA?KJŃE?P>A PSAAJIECN=PKNU>EN@O=J@AHA?PNE?EPULKSANCNE@OEJPDABNE?=J"QN=OE=JNACEKJ *0"41A?D JE?=H0ANEAO KJJ LL -/, 01/ ,!"$) +! 2!0 ,%2ĉ* %"0%*"!7%&"30 $ ,/&( $"&00)"/ 0 %,!,/ 3 &,+"0 2!1 (,"33 *&(20(1 +$67 -//$1 /,ě 3 0 %*&!1 * 0 %+"&!"/1 ĉÙ& +* 11&0 1,!,/,3" 12 (,3* 3 7&*$#/+(Ġ ġ 1DAłNOP?KILNADAJOERAAOPEI=PAKBSEJPANLKLQH=PEKJKBPDA4DEPAP=EHA@"=CHA%=HE=AAPQO=H>E?EHH= =HKJCPDA!=JQ>A?NK?ALD=HQOġ /EKQT 0 '-)0=R=N@ =J@$ANE?GĠ ġRE=JIKNP=HEPEAO@QAPKPN=JOIEOOEKJHEJA?KHHEOEKJOġ =NAREASKB?QNNAJPAOPEI=PAO=J@łAH@IAPDK@OSEPD=JAILD=OEOKJ=LLHE?=PEKJOPKPDA =J=@E=J AHA?PNE?JAPSKNGRE=J KJOANR=PEKJ=J@"?KHKCUĠ ġ 0+!,/ ! *Õ/ 2ċ+ ! & !*& , $ $%"/*+ * !2*&1/ %" * , ! *&%) Ġ ġ!KPDAPE?GOKB>EN@O=JEILKNP=JPIECN=PEKJDKPOLKPNAŃA?PPDAOA=OKJ=H@UJ=IE?O KB&TK@QONE?EJQO=PPDAIECN=PEKJEJEPE=PEKJOEPA?=OAOPQ@UEJPDA!=JQ>A!AHP=-)K0,+"Ġ ġ Ahttps://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0089378. 0 ,11 /" )'/, "/0 =J@ ' ! 2/6 EN@@A=PDOBNKILKSANHEJAO=P!QJCAJAOO NEPEOD EN@Oġ 0"/$&,# */ %"0&) -"!/&+&- #"//"/*3-"+1"/&+&Ġ ġ"HA?PNK?QPEKJ=HPANOPDA @EOPNE>QPEKJ=J@@AJOEPUKB=PKLLNA@=PKN PDAA=CHAKSH Q>K>Q>K'LLHEA@"?KHġ 0,2)¦*"Ġ ġ KJOANR=PEKJġP=?PE?OBKN=?KJOP=JP?NEOEO0?EAJ?Aġ 01+Û&(0',3+,3&ÛĠĢA@O ġ%U@NKHKCUKBPDANERAN!=JQ>A-Q>HEODEJC%KQOA-NEPK@= N=PEOH=R= LL 0¶! " (- +!/"17("% #&0 %"/0 $"!",+( 0 %&(,/"1 0 %/²!"/( 02! #")!1Ġ ġ*APDK@AJOP=J@=N@OVQN"NB=OOQJC@AN NQPRÌCAH!AQPO?DH=J@O/=@KHBVAHH 0 1+)2*4")1-)+2+$Ġ ġ3KCAH(KHHEOEKJOKLBAN=J%K?DQJ@%Ì?DOPOL=JJQJCOBNAEHAEPQJCAJEJ
36 !AQPO?DH=J@AEJ>O?D¼PVQJC ANE?DPRKJ1+)2ISAHPLH=JQJC=J@AJ+ 2+=PQNO?DQPV>QJ@ !AQPO?DH=J@A3 %QJCAJ 0 12 (,3* (), 0 *&(20(1 1*0" ě2)'"3&Ù "/$ 1!"*"Ġ ġ1DA H=?GOPKNG E?KJE=JECN=>APSAAJPDA0EK=J@PDA!N=R=/ERANEJPDA?AJPN=H!=JQ>AŃKK@LH=EJġ1N=JO >KQJ@=NUIKJEPKNEJC=J@LNKPA?PEKJLH=J EKP=ġ 30&Ù3Ġ ġ%EHF=@AHE?=!QJ=R=#QPQN=ġ 3!"#++ Ġ ġ 3KCAHO?DQPVI=NGEANQJCAJ =J %K?D QJ@ %Ì?DOPOL=JJQJCOHAEPQJCAJ #KNQI +APV PA?DJEG+APV>APNEA>EI3!" ANHEJ 0 4/!'3 1, (+"/(#0 %&"*"/Ġ ġ EK@ERANOEPUKBŃKK@LH=EJNERANA?KOUOPAIOġA?K PKJAO=J@?KJJA?PEREPU/ACQH/ERANOġ/AO*CIPġ 4&))/! !"4&))&/! 'Ġ ġ1DAEJPAN=?PEKJ>APSAAJOKIADQI=JK>OP=?HAO=J@>EN@O "JRENKJIAJP=H*=J=CAIAJPĠ ġ 7A?*&(=P=JKREÚĠEJLNAL ġ*EPEC=PEKJKB>EN@AHA?PNK?QPEKJEJ NK=PE==LN=CI=E?=LLNK=?D
37 'DQXEHZLGHLQYHQWRU\RISRZHUOLQHV $QQH[ DORQJWKH'DQXEHULYHU
Map 1 (Germany): Donaueschingen – Sigmaringen
38 Map 2 (Germany): Sigmaringen - Ehingen
Map 3 (Germany): Ulm
39 Map 4 (Germany): Leipheim – Tapfheim
Map 5 (Germany): Donauwörth – Neuburg – Ingolstadt
40 Map 6 (Germany): Ingolstadt – Saal an der Donau
Map 7 (Germany): Saal an der Donau - Regensburg – Straubing
41 Map 8 (Germany): Straubing - Vilshofen
Map 9 (Germany): Vilshofen - Passau
42 Map 10 (Germany/Austria): Passau – Linz - Mauthausen
Map 11 (Austria): Mauthausen – Pöchlarn
43 Map 12 (Austria): Pöchlarn – Krems
Map 13 (Austria): Krems – Klosterneuburg
44 Map 14 (Austria): Klosterneuburg – Wien – Orth an der Donau
Map 15 (Austria/Slovakia/Hungary): Orth an der Donau – Samorin – Dunakiliti
45 Map 16 (Slovakia/Hungary): Dunakiliti – Zlatná na Ostrove
Map 17 (Slovakia/Hungary): Zlatná na Ostrove – Tát
46 Map 18 (Slovakia/Hungary): Mužla – Budapest
Map 19 (Hungary): Budapest – Ercsi
47 Map 20 (Hungary): Ercsi - Dunaújváros
Map 21 (Hungary): Budapest – Paks
48 Map 22 (Hungary): Paks – Szekszárd
Map 23 (Hungary): Paks – Mohács
49 Map 24 (Hungary/Croatia/Serbia): Mohács – Apatin
Map 25 (Croatia/Serbia): Apatin – Dalj
50 Map 26 (Croatia/Serbia): Dalj – Vukovar - Celarevo
Map 27 (Serbia): Celarevo – Novi Sad
51 Map 28 (Serbia): Karlovci – Panèevo
Map 29 (Serbia): Panèevo – Belgrad – Smederevo
52 Map 30 (Serbia/Romania): Smederevo – Golubac
Map 31 (Serbia/Romania): Golubac – Donji Milanovac
53 Map 32 (Serbia/Romania): Donji Milanovac – Dobreta-Turnu Severin
Map 33 (Serbia/Romania/Bulgaria): Dobreta-Turnu Severin - Vinarovo
54 Map 34 (Bulgaria/Romani): Vinarovo - Lom
Map 35 (Bulgaria/Romania): Lom - Kozloduy
55 Map 36 (Bulgaria/Romania): Kozloduy - Ostrov
Map 37 (Bulgaria/Romania): Ostrov – Turnu Magurele
56 Map 38 (Bulgaria/Romania): Turnu Magurele – Svistov
Map 39 (Bulgaria/Romania): Ruse – Giurgiu – Gostinu
57 Map 40 (Bulgaria/Romania): Nova Cherna – Tutrakan – Popina
Map 41 (Bulgaria/Romania): Popina – Oltina
58 Map 42 (Romania): Oltina – Cernavoda
Map 43 (Romania): Cernavoda – Hârºova
59 Map 44 (Romania): Hârºova - Gropeni
Map 45 (Romania): Gropeni – Braila – Isaccea
60 Map 46 (Romania/Molodva/Ukraine): Galati – Isaccea
Map 47 (Romania/Ukraine): Tulcea – Sulina
61 Map 48 (Romania): Danube Delta southern part
62 (OHFWULFLW\S\ORQVDQGWKHLUULVNIRUELUGVUHODWHGWR $QQH[ HOHFWURFXWLRQ
Fig. 1: High Risk: Metal cross-arm pylon with a combination of support insulators and exposed jumper wire locations. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
63 Fig. 2: High risk: Corner pylon with a combination of support insulators and exposed jumper wire locations. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
64 Fig. 3: High risk: Electric pole with one exposed jumper wire above the console. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
65 Fig. 4: High risk: Electric pole with three exposed jumper wires above the console. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
66 Fig. 5: Medium risk: Electric pole with a vertical position of support insulators on console. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
67 Fig. 6: Medium risk: Electric pole with a pair of support insulators in vertical position on console. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
68 Fig. 7: Medium risk: Electric pole transformer with a combination of exposed jumper wires locations. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
69 Fig. 8: Medium risk: Power line switch disconnector. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
70 Fig. 9: Medium risk: Electric pole with hanging exposed jumper wires below the console. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
71 Fig. 10: Low risk: Electric pole with 45° angle of the arms. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
72 Fig. 11: Low risk: Double circuit electric pole with hanging insulators. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
73 Fig. 12: Low risk: Electric pole with hanging insulators. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
74 Fig. 13: Low risk: Double circuit electric pole with 45° angle of the arms. © Raptor Protection of Slovakia
75 /LVWRI6SHFLDO3URWHFWHG$UHDVIRU%LUGV $QQH[ 1DWXUD63$ DQG,PSRUWDQW%LUG$UHDV ,%$VLQWKHFDVHRI6HUELD ORFDWHGLQWKHSURMHFWDUHD
1.1 List of SPAs and their surface in the study area
% of SPA SPA SPA surface surface Country No. Site code Site name surface within study within name (ha) area (ha) study area (%)
1 Austria AT1202V00 March-Thaya-Auen 14832.76 700 5
2 Austria AT1204V00 Donau-Auen östlich von Wien 9100.06 9100 100
3 Austria AT1205000 Wachau - Jauerling 21110.56 16359 77
4 Austria AT1207000 Kamp- und Kremstal 24282.67 1800 7
5 Austria AT1211000 Wienerwald - Thermenregion 79812.84 2001 3
Sandboden und Praterter- 6 Austria AT1213V00 16019.79 1113 7 rasse
7 Austria AT1216V00 Tullnerfelder Donau-Auen 17763.56 17723 100
8 Austria AT1218V00 Machland Süd 1226.97 1227 100
9 Austria AT1219V00 Pielachtal 1025.57 303 30
Nationalpark Donau-Auen 10 Austria AT1301000 2258 2201 97 (Wiener Teil)
11 Austria AT1304000 Bisamberg (Wiener Teil) 340 167 49
12 Austria AT3112000 Oberes Donautal 924 925 100
13 Austria AT3114000 Traun-Donau-Auen 664 610 92
14 Bulgaria BG0000237 Ostrov Pozharevo 975.79 976 100
15 Bulgaria BG0000241 Srebarna 1448.22 1430 99
16 Bulgaria BG0002006 Ribarnitsi Orsoya 475.43 475 100
17 Bulgaria BG0002007 Ostrov Ibisha 399.32 399 100
18 Bulgaria BG0002008 Ostrov do Gorni Tsibar 218.43 218 100
19 Bulgaria BG0002009 Zlatiyata 43498.73 4553 10
20 Bulgaria BG0002017 Kompleks Belenski ostrovi 7009.77 7010 100
21 Bulgaria BG0002018 Ostrov Vardim 1167.55 1168 100
22 Bulgaria BG0002024 Ribarnitsi Mechka 2582.34 2582 100
23 Bulgaria BG0002025 Lomovete 33451.32 626 2
24 Bulgaria BG0002030 Kompleks Kalimok 9429.22 9428 100
25 Bulgaria BG0002031 Stenata 79.73 80 100
76 26 Bulgaria BG0002064 Garvansko blato 324.27 324 100
27 Bulgaria BG0002065 Blato Malak Preslavets 372.22 372 100
28 Bulgaria BG0002067 Ostrov Golya 414.56 415 100
29 Bulgaria BG0002074 Nikopolsko plato 22246.4 3648 16
30 Bulgaria BG0002083 Svishtovsko-Belenska nizina 5439.8 3630 67
31 Bulgaria BG0002091 Ostrov Lakat 1260.94 1261 100
32 Bulgaria BG0002104 Tsibarsko blato 909.76 910 100
33 &URDŀLD HR1000016 Podunavlje i donje Podravlje 66335.33 46586 70
Felsen und Hangwälder im 34 Germania DE7037471 Altmühl-, Naab-, Laber- und 4831.19 1308 27 Donautal
35 Germania DE7040402 Wälder im Donautal 1289 893 69
Donau zwischen Regensburg 36 Germania DE7040471 3276.43 3276 100 und Straubing
Felsen und Hangwälder im 37 Germania DE7132471 Altmühltal und Wellheimer 3610.89 4 0,12 Trockental
Donau zwischen Straubing 38 Germania DE7142471 6914.13 6910 100 und Vilshofen
39 Germania DE7229471 Riesalb mit Kesseltal 12068.95 443 4
Donauauen zwischen 40 Germania DE7231471 6995.12 6985 100 Lechmündung und Ingolstadt
41 Germania DE7243402 Isarmündung 2132 1994 94
Wiesenbrüterlebensraum 42 Germania DE7330471 3994.55 3185 80 Schwäbisches Donauried
43 Germania DE7427471 Schwäbisches Donaumoos 2592.66 1606 62
44 Germania DE7428471 Donauauen 8084.84 7744 96
45 Germania DE7527441 Donauried 4253.18 610 14
46 Germania DE7624441 Täler der Mittleren Flächenalb 5692.36 1202 21
Südwestalb und Oberes 47 Germania DE7820441 43030.98 8192 19 Donautal
Baggerseen Krauchenwies/ 48 Germania DE7921401 750.13 736 98 =LHOƓQJHQ
49 Germania DE8017441 Baar 37701.59 9712 26
50 Germania DE8018401 Höwenegg 20.74 21 100
51 Germania DE8116441 Wutach und Baaralb 14002.46 339 2
52 Romania ROSPA0001 Aliman - Adamclisi 18908.7 423 2
53 Romania ROSPA0002 Allah Bair - Capidava 11715.7 7623 65
54 Romania ROSPA0005 %DOWD0LFÅD%UÅLOHL 25802 25702 100
77 55 Romania ROSPA0007 Balta Vederoasa 2139.6 1807 84
56 Romania ROSPA0009 %HľWHSH0DKPXGLD 3654.2 3187 87
57 Romania ROSPA0011 %ODKQLŀD 44003.3 24698 56
58 Romania ROSPA0012 %UDŀXO%RUFHD 13299.2 13196 99
59 Romania ROSPA0013 &DODIDW&LXSHUFHQL'XQÅUH 29379.3 18049 61
60 Romania ROSPA0017 &DQDUDOHOHGHOD+¤UľRYD 7304.8 7234 100
61 Romania ROSPA0021 &LRFÅQHľWL'XQÅUH 801.2 801 100
62 Romania ROSPA0023 &RQŴXHQŀD-LX'XQÅUH 19530.2 7459 38
63 Romania ROSPA0024 &RQŴXHQŀD2OW'XQÅUH 20483.8 12517 61
&XUVXO'XQÅULL%D]LDľ 64 Romania ROSPA0026 10331 10326 100 3RUŀLOHGH)LHU
'HOWD'XQÅULLľL&RPSOH[XO 65 Romania ROSPA0031 508302.3 488570 96 Razim - Sinoie
66 Romania ROSPA0032 Deniz Tepe 1896.6 425 22
67 Romania ROSPA0038 'XQÅUH2OWHQLŀD 5927.8 5880 100
68 Romania ROSPA0039 'XQÅUH2VWURDYH 16243.8 16235 100
69 Romania ROSPA0040 'XQÅUHD9HFKH%UDŀXO0ÅFLQ 19011.8 16040 84
70 Romania ROSPA0046 Gruia - Gârla Mare 2963.9 2918 98
71 Romania ROSPA0051 ,H]HUXO&ÅOÅUDľL 5008.7 1938 39
72 Romania ROSPA0052 Lacul Beibugeac 469 469 100
73 Romania ROSPA0053 Lacul Bugeac 1385.4 1384 100
74 Romania ROSPA0054 /DFXO'XQÅUHQL 1269.7 1269 100
75 Romania ROSPA0056 Lacul Oltina 3309.9 2185 66
76 Romania ROSPA0060 /DFXULOH7DľDXO&RUEX 2734 199 7
77 Romania ROSPA0073 0ÅFLQ1LFXOLŀHO 67308.8 4580 7
78 Romania ROSPA0074 Maglavit 3642.5 3641 100
79 Romania ROSPA0076 0DUHD1HDJUÅ 149143.9 53553 36
80 Romania ROSPA0080 0XQŀLL$OPÅMXOXL/RFYHL 117770.7 46521 40
81 Romania ROSPA0090 Ostrovu Lung - Gostinu 2544 2543 100
82 Romania ROSPA0091 3ÅGXUHD%DEDGDJ 57912 1423 2
83 Romania ROSPA0102 Suhaia 4516 3516 78
84 Romania ROSPA0108 9HGHD'XQÅUH 22404.2 17525 78
%HUWHľWLLGH6XV*XUD,DOR- 85 Romania ROSPA0111 6864.6 1 0,02 PLŀHL
86 Romania ROSPA0120 .RJÅOQLFHDQX*XUD,DORPLŀHL 7087.6 2204 31
87 Romania ROSPA0121 /DFXO%UDWHľ 15878.9 3185 20
78 88 Romania ROSPA0135 1LVLSXULOHGHOD'ÅEXOHQL 11009.2 9130 83
89 Romania ROSPA0136 2OWHQLŀD8OPHQL 12405 9382 76
90 Slovacia SKCHVU004 Dolné Pohronie 229.32 78 34
91 Slovacia SKCHVU005 'ROQ«3RYDĻLH 31195.5 567 2
92 Slovacia SKCHVU007 Dunajské luhy 16511.58 17572 100
93 Slovacia SKCHVU016 Záhorské Pomoravie 31072.92 98 0,32
94 Slovacia SKCHVU029 6\VýRYVN«SROLD 1772.94 297 17
95 Ungaria HUDD10003 Gemenc 19641.18 17279 88
96 Ungaria HUDD10004 Béda-Karapancsa 8722.01 7715 88
Börzsöny és Visegrá- 97 Ungaria HUDI10002 49556.83 12405 25 di-hegység
98 Ungaria HUDI10003 Gerecse 29597.89 2510 8
99 Ungaria HUDI10006 Tatai Öreg-tó 2623.98 556 21
100 Ungaria HUFH10004 Mosoni-sík 13096.43 78 1
101 Ungaria HUFH30004 Szigetköz 17183.02 11938 69
)HOVĎNLVNXQV£JLV]LNHVSXV]- 102 Ungaria HUKN10001 15776.02 1096 7 ták és turjánvidék
Kiskunsági szikes tavak és az 103 Ungaria HUKN10002 35722.19 174 0,49 ĎUMHJLWXUM£QYLG«N
Total SPA 1,095,581 36%
1 Serbia Karadjordjevo 48494.8 4734.9 98
2 Serbia Usce Save u Dunav 98098.9 8993.6 92
3 Serbia Gornje Podunavlje 22606.7 17799.7 79
4 Serbia Koviljski rit 95942.1 9556.4 100
5 Serbia Fruska gora 49205.3 3053 6
6 Serbia Mala Vrbica 19142.8 1914.2 100
7 Serbia Djerdap 77163.5 38892.3 50
8 Serbia Labudovo okno 64886.9 6488.6 100
9 Serbia Dunavski lesni odsek 53043.8 5304.3 100
Total IBA Serbia 96737.6 52%
79