Minutes of the Meeting of the BMW Committee- 3, Held on 04.06.2009

Minutes of the meeting of the BMW Committee- 3, held on 04.06.2009

The following officers attended the meeting.

Dr. Chandra Prakash, SEE Dr. R.A. Gautam, M.S. Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Sh. D.K. Singh, EE Sh. Sanjay Vatts, AEE Sh. Shyam Sunder AEE Ms. Swati Khari, Trainee Engineer

The following are the records of discussions.

General Decision:

It was decided that in cases where Authorizations have been granted, the validity of authorization shall be from the date of last authorization.It was brought to the notice of the Committee that the cases where the issue was pertaing to noise monitoring/stack height of DG Sets, a note may be put up to Chairman, DPCC, seeking clear directions, as per the decisions taken in BMW Commiittee-2 in its meeting held on 19.5.2009.

Agenda -1: ATR of Decisions taken in meeting held on 30.04.09

o As regards the pending inspections, it was brought to the notice of Committee members that since the trainee of BMW Committee-3 was transferred to the Head Office, the inspections could not be carried out.The trainee engineer was asked to expedite the inspections of 31 HCUs at the earliest. It was therefore decided that all cases where inspections have been made/yet to be made shall be discussed in the next meeting of the Committee.

o The matter regarding 23 cases which were put on hold, were decided in the form of minutes of Agenda -2.

o Regarding 390 cases, which were issued letters through speed post for applying for renewal of Authorization under BMW rules, it was decided that the complete status may be prepared based upon the replies received from them, it was informed that the task requires substantial time and labour. It was requested by the officials of BMW Cell that one more trainee may be given for carrying out the work related to BMW-3. SEE (BMW) suggested that matter may be put up administratively. It was reiterated that a complete status report must be brought out in the next meeting of the Committee positively.

o The committee also desired that since the letter has been sent to DHS for giving names of health care units registered with them, the reply received from the DHS may also be placed before the Committee. Further, Committee desired that after issuing the public notice, the response received against this public notice may also be placed before the Committee members in the next meeting.

o Committee also desired that the complete status along with the response received of those cases be put up where certain deficiencies were observed during inspection of by DPCC officials and the Health Care units were asked to remove those deficiencies.

Agenda 2: Fresh /Renewal Cases of Authorizations discussed in BMW Committee-3 meeting held on 30.4.2009

Regarding 23 cases which were recommended authorization in the last meeting, the committee took the cognizance of the Supreme Court order, staying the High Court order directing the closure of the nursing home operating without the registration. It was therefore, decided that the Authorization letter to these 23 cases may be issued immediately.

Agenda 3: Authorization pending in want of necessary compliance by Health Care Establishments

The decisions taken are given in Annexure-I.

Agenda 4: Fresh/Renewal Cases of Authorizations

The decisions taken are given in Annexure-II. S.No. Name of HCE Address of the HCE Distt.S. Beds Date of Status Decision Taken on 04.06.09 N. Appl. for Auth.

1 Aram bagh Aram Bagh,New Delhi C-024 0 6-Mar-07 Balance fee not Reminder Letter to be issued Dispensary submitted and copy of with copy to Director(Health). valid Agreement received 2 Dusaj's Diagnostic 4380/4B,Ansari road C-043 0 17-Oct-07 Communication received Authorization Granted Lab Darya Ganj New Delhi informing balance fee already been submitted copy enclosed 3 Marie Stopes 5439, Arya Samaj Road, C-057 4 13-Apr-07 Reply Received stating Enquiry Counter to verify the (Pariwar Sewa Karol Bagh, New Delhi-5 that payment of balance correct position. In case Sanstha) fee paid. payment not received, the unit to be asked to submit documentary evidence. 4 Sahara Nursing 1864, Turkmn Gate, C-069 8 10-Apr-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Home Delhi-6 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 5 Raja Medical 16/694E, Bapa Nagar, C-092 1 5-Feb-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Centre Padam Singh Road, Karol issued for refusal of Bagh, Delhi-05 application. 6 Eastend Hospital B5, New Ashok Nagar, E-063 8 30-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Delhi-96 issued for refusal of application. 7 Goyal Urology E 5/9 Krishan Nagar , E-073 5 22-Jun-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted &Maternity Centre Lajpat Rai Chowk,Krishna Nagar Delhi-51 8 M.M.R Eye B-15 Swasthya Vihar E-094 6 19-Mar- Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted and Institute Delhi-92 07 unit to be informed that there is no requirement of CTE. 9 Saxena Medical 113-A Pkt- B ,Mayur vihar E-125 4 12-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Centre. -II Delhi-91 issued for refusal of application. 10 Shakti Medical IX/32 , Kailash Nagar, E-126 7 19-Apr-06 Authorization valid till Authorization already issued. centre Delhi-31 16.08.10. Balance fee also received. 11 Sona maternity & 4/1925, Rama Block E-134 7 13-Mar- Balance fee received. Authorization Granted nursing Home Bhola Nath Nagar 07 Shahdara Delhi-32 12 Sunaina Maternity B-9, Acharya Niketan, E-136 5 16-Apr-07 Balance fee received. Authorization Granted & Nursing Home Mayur Vihar,Phase-I, Delhi-91 13 Sunil Dhingra 436-A,Main E-137 0 18-Oct-06 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Road,Mandawali issued for refusal of Faizalpur,Delhi-92 application. 14 Vimal Clinic B/94/4,Joshi Colony,Opp. E-150 0 16-Sep- Not applied for renewal. Well drafted letter for Bathla Apts(Near 05 submitting application for Church),Patparganj, Authorization Delhi-92 15 VR Sood and 139-A Mayur Vihar-II, E-151 0 9-Apr-07 Authrization already No action Anjali Sood Clinic Delhi-91 granted 16 East Delhi 70-b, Gali No-5, Old Arjun E-155 5 19-Mar- Proof of valid agreement If valid Agreement existswith Orthopaedic & Nagar, Beside PNB, 07 not submitted. any of 2 CBWTF operators Trauma Centre Delhi-51 issue Authorization, if not issue letter. 17 LEPROSY HOME TAHIR PUR, E-159 0 4-Jun-07 Reply received Authorization Granted SHAHDARA, DELHI-95 18 ESI DISPENSARY Quarter no.181-186, Shiv E-192 0 31-May- The HCU applied fresh No action NagarVISHWAKARMA 07 for authorization on NAGAR 31.05.07 along with fee DELHI of Rs. 3000/-.Authorization issued & valid till 30.4.2010 19 Genpact India Delhi IT park, Shastri E-209 0 24-Apr-07 No Reply Received for Place in the next meeting. Park, New Delhi-11053 deficiencies. 20 Maternity & Child GautamPuri Shahdara, E-225 0 16-Oct-08 Applied fresh for Authorization granted Welfare Centre Delhi authorization. 21 Munjal Clinic B-1430 A , Shastri Nagar , N-046 4 12-Oct-07 No Reply Received for Place in the next meeting. Delh-52 deficiencies. 22 Pathnet India (P) 27-A,Kamla Nagar, New N-051 0 22-Mar- Unit has not submitted The unit to be asked to apply Ltd. Delhi 07 fresh application for for fresh renewal. renewal of Authorization. 23 Saba Nursing A-1/1,DDA Flat Inderlok N-060 5 30-Aug- No Reply Received for Place in the next meeting. Home 07 deficiencies. 24 Satija Clinic 399, Main Bazaar subzi N-064 0 4-Apr-07 No Reply Received for Show Cause Notice to be Mandi(Old) Near Robin balance fees. issued for Refusal Cinema delhi-7 25 Shukla Clinic & B-1372 Shastri N-071 3 12-Jun-07 No Reply Received w.r.t To be Inspected Maternity Centre Nagar,Delhi-52 balance fees. Unit had informed that they have closed the maternity centre and running only clinic. 26 Sri Balaji 57-B,Shahzada Bagh,Old N-074 0 25-Apr-07 Balance fee received Authorization Granted Charitable Rohtak Road, Delhi-35 Dispensary 27 Delhi I.V.F& 23,Todar Mal Lane ND- 6 29-Jun-07 Ambient Noise Authorization Granted. Note Fertility Clinic Bengali Mkt Nd-1 008 exceeding to be submitted to Chairman. 28 Indian Red Cross Red Cross Bhawan, Golf ND- 0 9-Apr-07 No Reply Received Shifted to BMW-I Society Links, New Delhi-3 016 29 Gokulpuri (Delhi Bhagiratni Plant,Delhi NE- 0 6-Mar-07 Applied for renewal of Issue well drafted letter to Jal Board) Jalboard 042 authorization without Delhi Jal Board to make the Dispensary requisite fee. payment of fee. 30 Kohinoor Hospital G-3,Seelampur Delhi-53 NE- 4 22-Oct-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from 052 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 31 Mamta Medical C-9/12, Yamuna Vihar, NE- 5 29-Mar- Reply along with affidavit Authorization Granted Centre Delhi 110053 053 07 received. 32 R.C Sharma Clinic 70, Mohan Park NE- 0 23-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be NaveenShahdara Delhi- 064 issued for Refusal 32 33 Sai Charitable A-86, Jagat Puri ,100 Ft NE- 9 19-Dec- Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Dispensary & Road, Shahdara, Delhi-93 072 07 received. the last date of expiry of Nursing Home Authorization. 34 Sarvodya 12, Tagore Gali, NE- 4 11-Jul-07 No Reply Received. File Put up Administratively Medicare Centre Babarpur, Shahdara-32 073 not traceable. 35 Superb Medical F/126, New Seelampur, NE- 0 4-Jul-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Centre Delhi-53 090 issued for refusal of application. 36 Agarwal Hospital Main Road, Village NW- 4 3-Apr-07 Reply received. Authorization Granted Shalimar Bagh Delhi-88 031 37 Aggrawal Hospital B-1,Rohit Kunj, (Near L- NW- 0 31-Oct-07 NMR Case Authorization Granted. Note Block Shakurpur) 034 to be submitted to Chairman. Pitampura,Delhi-110034. 38 Bajaj Nursing 383, Kohat Enclave, NW- 5 12-Oct-07 Balance fee submitted. Authorization Granted Home Delhi-34 047 39 Dr. Ashok Wasan, C-7,Model Town-3,Delhi-9 NW- 0 26-Mar- No Reply Received. File Put up Administratively ENT Clinic 108 07 not traceable. 40 Garg Clinic 1973/2A, Lampur Road NW- 0 16-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Narela Delhi-40 123 07 issued for Refusal 41 Garg Nursing Shopping Center 5, NW- 6 21-Jan-08 Balance fee received. Authorization Granted home Avantika ,Sector 1, 125 Rohini, Delhi-85 42 Gopal Dass 10,Raj-Nagar,Pitampura NW- 6 22-Nov- Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Khurana Nursing Delhi-34 130 07 Home 43 Kanta Sethi A-777 - 778, Avantika , NW- 8 1-Jan-08 Reply received regarding Place in the next meeting. Hospital Sec2I, Rohini, Delhi-85 157 deficiencies. 44 Lab n Skin K-47,Model Town-II Delhi- NW- 0 7-Mar-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted 9 167 45 Mukesh U-86-C,Lampur Road NW- 2 9-Apr-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Orthopaedic & Narela Delhi-40 186 Trauma Centre 46 Reena J & S Gali No.2, Rajiv Colony, NW- 3 9-Aug-05 Authorization expired on Issue letter for submitting the Hospital Arya Samaj Road, Narela, 194 08.08.08 application for Renewal of Delhi-40 Authorization 47 Veena Nursing A-1/3 Sec-8,Rohini Delhi- NW- 5 12-Dec- reply received along with Place in the next meeting. Home 85 255 07 affidavit 48 Vinod Nursing 287,D-14 Sector-3 Rohini NW- 6 19-Apr-07 Noise level exceeeding. Authorization Granted Home & , Delhi-85 258 Mat.centre 49 Neelkanth BH/48 (East) Shalimar NW- 0 30-Mar- Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Surgical and Bagh New Delhi-88 273 07 received. the last date of expiry of Medical centre Authorization. 50 P.K. Gupta T-43, Shivaji Nagar, NW- 2 23-Apr-07 No Reply Received. File Put up Administratively Hospital Narela, Delhi-40 274 not traceable. 51 Jain Eye Hospital AG-152, Shalimar bagh, NW- 2 10-Jan-08 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from & Laser Centre Delhi-88 293 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 52 Swastic Maternity 23-24, Pocket, G-20, NW- 5 26-Sep- Applied for renewal of Authorization Granted Centre Sector-7, Rohini Delhi 317 08 authorization. 53 Goyal Dental C-8/147, Sector -8, Rohini NW- 4 22-Aug- No Reply Received Issue letter to the unit to Clinic 339 06 complete the documents. 54 Rithala Staff Quarter, Varun Kunj, NW- 0 4-Oct-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Dispensary Opp. Rithala Metro 357 received. the last date of expiry of Station, Rohini, New Dlhi- Authorization. 85 55 Jain Eye & AD- Block Shalimar Bagh, NW- 5 5-Feb-08 No Reply Received Place in the next meeting. Medical Centre Delhi-88 364 regarding deficiencies. 56 Sarthak Medical F-26/45, Sector-7, Rohini, NW- 5 7-Jul-08 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Centre Delhi-85 385 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 57 Dr. Dangs Lab D-1, Huaz Khas, New S- 141 0 19-Jul-07 NMR has been submitted Authorization Granted. Note Pvt.Ltd. Delhi -16 to be submitted to Chairman. 58 Amity Hospital S-18,Bapu Park Kotla MP S-048 5 16-Apr-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Near South Ext.New Delhi received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 59 Anjali Nakra Clinic 80/17 B,Malviya S-050 0 15-Mar- Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Nagar,New Delhi-17 07 60 Arpan Hospital A-254, Tigri,Khanpur, S-054 4 28-Oct-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from New Delhi-62 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 61 Delhi Government Kalkaji, New Delhi S-084 0 8-May-08 Reply Received. Authorization Granted Dispensary 62 ESI Dispensary, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, S-101 0 22-Oct-07 Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Sector-1, (Tigri) New received. the last date of expiry of Delhi Authorization. 63 Geekay X-Ray 32, Amar Colony Mkt. ND- S-106 0 12-Oct-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Centre Lab & 24 clinic 64 Medi Centre Lab C-5/32, Safdarjung S-139 0 22-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Dev.Area, (opp. IIT Main 07 issued for Refusal Gate), New Delhi. 65 Pathlab D-87A,East of S-156 0 13-Nov- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Kailash,ND-65 07 issued for Refusal 66 Pathnet India Pvt. Nil 26 AB, Ground Floor, S-166 0 22-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Ltd., Malviya Nagar, New 07 issued for refusal of Delhi-17 application. 67 Pattnaik's Laser C-2, Lajpat Nagar-3, New S-168 4 8-May-07 Balance fee received. Authorization Granted. Note Eye Institute Delhi-24 Noise level case. to be submitted to Chairman. 68 Sanghi Medical S-51, GK-I, ND-48 S-180 0 11-Sep- Applied for renewal of Authorization Granted Centre Pvt. Ltd. 08 authorization. ( Diagnostic) 69 Vinaya Bhavan 19/564, Madingir,New S-214 8 18-Feb- Balance fee Received Authorization Granted Maternity Centre, Delhi-62 08 70 Primary Health Fatehpur Beri, N.D-30 S-237 2 20-Jun-07 Authorization granted. Issue letter for rectification of Centre (MCD) Inspection carried out on deficiencies. 19.02.09 and deficiencies observed. 71 Mahajan Imaging K-18 Hauz Khas S-238 0 13-Jan-09 Reply received along Authorization Granted Centre Enclave,N.Delhi-16 with affidavit. 72 SUNRISE S-549,GREATER S-240 0 7-Nov-08 No Reply Received. File Put up Administratively MEDICARE KAILASH-II,NEW DELHI- not traceable. PRIVATE 48 LIMITED 73 Shadab Imaging & 177, Park View Apartment S-289 0 1-Nov-07 Letter for deficiencies Place in the next meeting. Diagnostic Center (Basement), Nehar Road, issued, no reply Opp. Okhla Head Bus Stop, Jamia Nagar, Okhla, New Delhi-25 74 NU-TECH 487, Hardev Puri, Gautam S-314 4 5-Jun-08 No Reply Received. File Put up Administratively MEDIWORLD Nagar, delhi not traceable. 75 Gupta Nursing RZH-40, West Sagarpur, SW- 0 5-Mar-08 Balance fee received. Authorization Granted Home ND-46 050 76 Poonam Verma RZ-401-A/2,Pradhan SW- 4 29-Jan-08 Balance Fee recd along Authorization Granted Nursing Home Chowk Sadh 071 with Affidavit stating No Nagar,Palam Colony New DG Set Delhi 77 Pathnet India Ltd E-36,Naraina Vihar,New SW- 0 22-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Delhi 074 07 issued for Refusal 78 Shakuntala RZ-1-8/A, Sagarpur West, SW- 8 11-Jul-07 No Reply Received Pertains to BMW-2 Nursing Home opp. Janak Cinema, New 083 Delhi. 79 Singh Nursing 70/13/2,WZ 31 A Palam SW- 5 7-Apr-08 Valid agreement not If valid Agreement existswith Home Village, New Delhi-45 085 submitted. any of 2 CBWTF operators issue Authorization, if not issue letter. 80 The Clinical E-13/9, Vasant Vihar, ND- SW- 0 16-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Laboratory 57 093 07 issued for Refusal 81 Vasisth Medical WZ-142,Naraina Ring SW- 2 11-Jul-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Centre Road,ND-28 099 issued for Refusal 82 DWARKA B-92, MJLP, PATEL SW- 6 31-Jan-08 Reply Received Authorization Granted HOSPITAL GARDEN, KAKROLA 124 83 Sheetal Chhaya F-82/3, Sadh Nagar-11, SW- 0 4-Nov-08 Reply received. Authorization Granted Diagnostics Palam Colony,New Delhi 129 84 Mty. & Child H.No. 825, Sector-1, SW- 0 28-Jul-08 Authorization granted in No action Welfare Centre R.K.Puram, Delhi-22 167 the meeting 11.08.08 85 Tilak Nagar Tilak Nagar , New Delhi- W-009 Reply received regarding To be Inspected Colony Hospital 18 temporary closure. 86 Apaar nursing A-26, Adarsh W-041 4 28-Jan-09 Application for renewal of Authorization Granted home Nagar,Uttam nagar,ND-59 Auhtorization Submitted 87 Dentplan Klinik Shop.No-13 Club Road W-097 0 13-Apr-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Market , North Waste Avenue .Punjabi Bagh(West) , New Delhi- 26 88 Dikshit Hospital G-10 Community Centre W-099 8 18-Nov- Balance fees not Authorization Granted from Vikas Puri ND-18 07 received. the last date of expiry of Authorization. 89 Friends Polyclinic C/C3A/436,Janakpuri ND- W-109 2 16-Oct-07 Balance fee received Authorization Granted 58 90 Harjus Nursing W-18,Rajouri W-129 4 23-May- Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Home Garden,New Delhi-27 07 along with affidavit for DG set 91 Kansal Nursing 9&10, Bal Udyog Marg, W-153 5 18-Dec- Applied of renewal of Authorization Granted Home Uttam nagarND-59 07 authorization. 92 Mittal Nursing C-3/6 Janak Puri , New W-182 2 21-Nov- Applied for renewal of Authorization Granted Home Delhi-58 08 authorization. 93 Nijhawan Clinic & Hospital, -21/23 W-194 0 17-Apr-07 Balance fee submitted Authorization Granted Diagnostics KaramPura Nd-15 94 Orthopaedic clinic A1/39, Janakpuri, New W-200 0 19-Mar- Balance fee received Authorization Granted Delhi 07 95 Pathnet India (P) F-54, Kirti nagar, New W-211 0 22-Mar- No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Ltd. Delhi 07 issued for refusal of application. 96 Popli Nursing B-1/512, Janak Puri New W-217 5 13-Aug- Balance fee received Authorization Granted Home Delhi-58 07 97 Prerak J-1/162-A,Main W-219 0 4-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Pahological Clinic Mkt.Rajouri Gdn. ND-27 issued for refusal of application. 98 Sadbhawana 79, Bhera Enclave W-233 6 15-May- Inspected. Found closed. Application becomes Nursing Home Paschim Vihar, New 07 No action as decided in infructuous. Delhi-87 committee meeting on 23.01.09. 99 Sethi Nursing D-95, Ajay Enclave, New W-247 6 13-Mar- Communication received Well drafted reply to be sent Home Delhi 110018 07 but no Balance fee submitted 100 Sharad Nursing Ganesh Mkt.Najafgarh W-250 5 2-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Home Rd.Opp.OBC Bank issued for refusal of Nangloi Delhi-41 application. 101 Sharma Nursing C-1/6, Janak Puri New W-251 0 4-May-07 Letter return back with To be Inspected Home Delhi-58 the remarks of postman left without Address 102 Singhal Heart A4/24, Paschim Vihar, W-261 4 12-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Care & Maternity ND-63 issued for refusal of Centre application. 103 Tagore Hospital & 1-A,M-Block Raghubir Ngr W-276 4 21-Jun-01 Inspected. HCU found Application becomes Maternity Centre ND-27 closed. infructuous. 104 Sharda Maternity H. No-3, Road No-65, W-277 4 1-May-07 Authorization already No action and Medical West Punjabi Bagh, Delhi` granted Centre 105 West Delhi 38 B, DDA Mkt. Pandav W-287 0 16-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Medical Centre & Nagar ND-8 issued for refusal of Pathological Lab application. 106 Uttam Hospital & 414, Hastsal Village, W-306 7 12-Apr-07 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be Maternity Centre Uttam Nagar, New Delhi- issued for refusal 59

107 Chandraleela P-13, Vijay Vihar, Uttam W-318 5 8-May-07 Balance fee Paid Authorization Granted Hospital Nagar, N.D-59 108 N.N. Health Care D-1/25, Janakpuri, New W-360 0 13-Sep- No Reply Received Reminder Letter to be issued Services Delhi-58 07 for fresh Application. 109 M & CW Centre, Uttam Nagar, Delhi-59 W-366 0 2-Jun-08 No Reply Received Show Cause Notice to be MCD issued for refusal of application. 110 ARCHITA CLINIC RZ-132, Indra Park W-378 Nil 20-Nov- Applied fresh for Authorization Granted (Bindapur Road), Uttam 08 authorization. Nagar, New Delhi-59

Valid Date of Case of Aggrement Decision Taken on Sl. No. Name of HCE Address of the HCE Distt.S. N. Beds Appl. for Fresh/Ext./ S.No. with 04.06.09 Auth. Renewal operator

Shora Kothi, M & CW 6-May- Authorization 1 121 Paharganj, New Delhi- C-117 0 Y Centre, 09 Granted 55

Plot no. 5, Chara Ortho Care 26-May- Authorization 2 122 Mandi, Tehsil Road, SW-162 6 Y Hospital 09 Granted Najafgarh, Delhi-43.