Redemptive Suffering and Spiritual Service in the Works of James Baldwin
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University English Dissertations Department of English 2-2-2006 Reclaiming the Human Self: Redemptive Suffering and Spiritual Service in the Works of James Baldwin Francine LaRue Allen Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Allen, Francine LaRue, "Reclaiming the Human Self: Redemptive Suffering and Spiritual Service in the Works of James Baldwin." Dissertation, Georgia State University, 2006. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss/6 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of English at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in English Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. RECLAIMING THE HUMAN SELF: REDEMPTIVE SUFFERING AND SPIRITUAL SERVICE IN THE WORKS OF JAMES BALDWIN by FRANCINE LARUE ALLEN Under the Direction of Professor Thomas McHaney ABSTRACT James Arthur Baldwin argues that the issue of humanity—what it means to be human and whether or not all people bear the same measure of human worth—supersedes all issues, including socially popular ones such as race and religion. As a former child preacher, Baldwin claims, like others shaped by both the African-American faith tradition and Judeo- Christianity, that human equality stands as a divinely mandated and philosophically sound concept. As a literary artist and social commentator, Baldwin argues that truth in any narrative text, whether fictional or non-fictional, lies in its embrace or rejection of human equality. Truth-telling narrative texts uphold human equality; false-witnessing texts do not. Baldwin shows in four of his novels the prevalence of the latter narrative type. Within the fictional societies of Go Tell It on the Mountain (1953), Giovanni’s Room (1956), If Beale Street Could Talk (1974), and Just Above My Head (1979), Baldwin reveals how society’s powerful bear false witness against the marginalized through stereotyping social narratives. However, Baldwin uses his novels to show the humanity of the marginalized. In so doing, he connects his works, as well as the works of contemporary black literary artists, to the concept of Christian spirituality. INDEX WORDS: Humanness, Discourse, Faith, Prophet, Bible, Religion, Redemption, Modern African American writers, Apocalypse, Social Narratives RECLAIMING THE HUMAN SELF: REDEMPTIVE SUFFERING AND SPIRITUAL SERVICE IN THE WORKS OF JAMES BALDWIN by FRANCINE LARUE ALLEN A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the College of Arts and Sciences Georgia State University 2005 Copyright by Francine LaRue Allen 2005 Reclaiming the Human Self: Redemptive Suffering and Spiritual Service in the Works of James Baldwin by FRANCINE LARUE ALLEN Major Professor: Thomas McHaney Committee Mary Zeigler Warren Carson Electronic Version Approved: Office of Graduate Studies College of Arts and Sciences Georgia State University December 2005 iv Dedications This work is dedicated to my father and mother, Robert and Frances Allen Mayo, who have always been my very best friends, my greatest supporters, and my faithful counselors. I wish also to dedicate this work to the memory of William Allen, D.V.M. v Acknowledgments I would like to thank my dissertation director Dr. Thomas McHaney for his incisive reading. Thanks go also to Dr. Mary Zeigler and Dr. Warren Carson who blended encouragement with their critical reading of my work. Finally, my greatest thanks goes to God for the comfort of His divine presence. vi Table of Contents Acknowledgements . v Introduction . 1 A. Review of Literature . 1 B. Dissertation Focus . 11 C. Overview of Chapters .. 16 Chapter I No Longer an Outsider: The Biblical Underpinnings of James Baldwin’s Call for Human Equality . 20 A. The Scriptural Worldview Embraced by the Black Faith Community and Baldwin . 20 B. Human Equality as Viewed by the Black Faith Community and 25 Baldwin C. The Proclamation of Human Equality through Truthful Discourse .. 34 Chapter II Just Telling the Truth: The Battle between False-Witnessing Narratives and Truth-Telling Narratives in James Baldwin’s Fiction . 39 A. Humanness as an Issue for Exploration in Narratives . 40 B. Fundamental Beliefs about Humanness Revealed in Narrative Order . 41 C. The Prophetic, Truth-Telling Mission of Baldwin’s Fiction . 45 vii Chapter III Beauty from Ashes: Redemptive Suffering in James Baldwin’s Fiction . 62 A. Suffering Characters in Baldwin’s Novels. 63 B. Redemptive Suffering in the African-American Faith Tradition . 68 C. The Suffering that Saves Baldwin’s Characters . 73 D. The Suffering that Destroys Baldwin’s Characters . 87 Chapter IV James Baldwin’s Call to Service: Christian Spirituality in African-American Literature . 97 A. The Gradual Separation between Black Literary Works and Christianity . 98 B. Multiple Religious Choices within Black Culture . 101 C. The Emphasis upon Spirituality instead of Christianity . 103 D. Traditional Views of Spirituality Grounded in Service 106 E. Baldwin’s Attempt to Disconnect Traditional Spirituality from Faith 127 F. Traditional Spirituality Identified in Modern Works of Black Writers 131 Conclusion . 135 Review of Chapters . 136 James Baldwin’s Apocalyptic Vision . 138 Endnotes . 144 Works Cited . 147 1 Introduction Review of the Literature James Arthur Baldwin, born August 2, 1924, in New York City, joined the Fireside Pentecostal Assembly church in 1937 and became, at the age of 14, a boy preacher. At the time, according to biographer James Campbell, Baldwin “knew the Bible so well that he coloured his phrases with Old Testament rhetoric and poetry, with full conviction” (10). However, by the time Baldwin was 17, he had decided to leave the pulpit, unhappy about what he saw as the lack of love within the church and desiring to become a novelist and playwright, believing, Campbell says, that “the sacred . was not the only domain to scrutinize in search of ‘everlasting life’” and that “the Holy Ghost might be identified here on earth, among human beings, in works of art” (21-22). After graduating from high school and working several menial jobs, he began writing book reviews and essays for various publications while also trying to develop his fiction- writing skills. In 1948, frustrated with America’s racial problems, he left for Paris, eventually seeing the publication of his first novel, Go Tell It on the Mountain, in 1953 while there. He returned to America in 1957, engaging himself in the civil rights movement and becoming a lecturer at various universities. He eventually returned to France, dying there on December 1, 1987. His faith, his artistry, his social and political concerns—all serve as the diverse subject matter of his fiction and nonfiction. This diversity has given critics great flexibility when choosing issues to focus upon when examining his writings. 2 Baldwin’s Faith In the 1980s and 1990s, critics Sondra A. O’Neale and Michael Lynch investigated Baldwin’s complex relationship with Christianity. O’Neale focused primarily on Baldwin’s faith while Lynch connected Baldwin’s faith to his political concerns, a connection that Donald B. Gibson made twenty years earlier in his description of Baldwin as a moralist. In “Fathers, Gods, and Religion” Sondra A. O’Neale argues that Baldwin’s works speak of Christianity in non-traditional ways, questioning God’s working in the world and pointing out error in the traditional black church, an institution that so many African- American writers before him had highly regarded. According to O’Neale, Baldwin frequently observed the disconnect between the Christian believer’s profession of faith and the believer’s demonstration of that faith. In trying to understand God, Baldwin questioned why God allowed so many troubles to befall the black race despite its consistently demonstrated faith in Him. O’Neale says that Baldwin’s observations and questionings served as evidence of his belief in God and his attempt to discover God’s identity and His relationships to black people: On the surface one cannot ascertain whether or not Baldwin is a ‘religious writer’ because his works do not reflect the traditional treatment of Christianity in black American literature. Instead, Baldwin examines the enigmas of human affections absent in Christian professors; the failure of the Christian God to thwart the persistent onslaught of His African children; and the insistence of those children to forge a ‘normal’ dependent interaction with that God. These witnesses are empirical evidence of God in Baldwin’s world, 3 and he exploits them to excess so that he can mold a composite God, discover His personality, and fathom His intentions toward black people (1988, 126). According to O’Neale, Baldwin greatly changed African-American literature, not only as the last black writer in America to present a thorough discussion about African-Americans and their relationship with Christianity, but also as one writer, among others within the black literary establishment, who did not exalt the black church. Baldwin’s unwillingness to present the black church as an ideal entity was different, however, from the unwillingness of other black writers. Writers such as Nella Larsen in Quicksand (1928) and Richard Wright in Black Boy (1945) rejected Christian faith while criticizing Christian hypocrisy. Baldwin, on the other hand, continued to value many teachings of the faith even as he admonished the Church for its hypocrisy. O’Neale suggests that Baldwin’s primary concern with Christian philosophy, outside of its employment for hypocritical purposes, was its strict guidelines concerning sexual normalcy. In works such as Giovanni’s Room and Just Above My Head, he shows homosexuality to be “an acceptable form of human love” (1988,140). O’Neale says that because of Baldwin’s efforts to point out hypocrisy in the black church and to make homosexuality acceptable, he “opened the floodgate for contemporary anti-Christian, non- biblically based black American literature” (1988, 140).