1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)

December 2013 doc.: IEEE 802.11-13/1517r0

IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs

May-July Teleconference Minutes

Date: 2014-06-11

Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Hitoshi Allied Telesis R&D 2-14-38 Tenjin, Chuo-ku, +81 92 771 7630 hmorioka@root- Morioka Center Fukuoka 810-0001 JAPAN hq.com

Abstract Minutes of the TGai teleconference held on May 27th, June 3rd and 10th.

Submission page 1Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center December 2013 doc.: IEEE 802.11-13/1517r0

Tuesday May 27th, 2014 10:00ET

1. Attendee 1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info) 1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed) 1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center) 1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT) 1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei) 1.6. Hiroki Nakano (Trans New Technology) 1.7. Mark Rison (Samsung) 1.8. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm) 2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:05. 3. Agenda: 11-14/0726r0. 4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy. 5. Current status of the draft (Lee Armstrong) 5.1. Now clean up the draft. 6. Comment Resolutions 6.1. Mark Rison 6.1.1.No presentation materials 6.1.2.Questions have been posted to the reflector. 6.1.3.Santosh Abraham takes these questions to George Cherian. 6.1.4.Mark will prepare the resolutions after getting answers. 6.1.5.Reschedule Mark to 17th June. 7. 24th June is in the WFA week. (Ping Fang) 8. We should skip 24th June. (Hiroshi Mano) 9. The chair will post new schedule to the reflector. 10. Adjourned at 10:29.

Tuesday June 3rd, 2014 10:00ET

1. Attendee 1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info) 1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed) 1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center) 1.4. Ping Fang (Huawei) 1.5. Mark Rison (Samsung) 1.6. George Cherian (Qualcomm) 1.7. Jeongki Kim (LGE) 1.8. Peter Yee (NSA/IAD) 1.9. Rene Struik (Strik Security Consultancy) 2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:02. 3. Agenda: 11-14/0726r1. 4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy. 5. Comment Resolutions 5.1. CID5148 5.1.1.Reassigned to the editor. 5.2. LB201-Comment resolution on AP-CSN related CIDs in 6.3.3.2.2. 11-14/739r0 Jeongki Kim 5.2.1.CID4001, 4407, 4408, 4409, 4686, 5050 5.2.1.1. Change "APConfigurationChangeCount" to "APConfigurationSequenceNumber". 5.2.1.2. "Accept" means applying exact proposed resolution. So additional explanation should be removed. (Ping Fang) 5.3. LB201-Comment resolution on CIDs for 8.4.2.178 AP-CSN element. 11-14/740r0 Jeongki Kim 5.3.1.CID4547, 4991, 5059, 5102 5.3.1.1. Need more discussion. (Ping Fang) 5.3.1.2. I’ll prepare r1 after discussion. (Jeongki Kim) 5.3.2.CID4046, 4454, 4667 5.3.2.1. These CIDs will be also revised in r1. (Jeongki Kim) 5.3.3.CID4047, 4455, 4548 5.3.3.1. These CIDs will be also revised in r1. (Jeongki Kim) 5.3.4.CID4992, 5103 5.3.4.1. Keep as r0. 5.3.5.CID4993, 5104 5.3.5.1. Keep as r0. 5.3.6.CID5084 5.3.6.1. The reason to reject, described in “discussion” section, should be copied to the resolution field. (Ping Fang) 5.4. LB201-Comment resolution on CIDs for AP-CSN related active scanning procedure (10.1.4.3.5) 11-14/741r0 Jeongki Kim 5.4.1.CID4012, 5069, 5196 5.4.1.1. What is the “enhanced FILS active scanning”? You should talk with Jarkko. (Ping Fang) 5.4.1.2. I’ll change the title of clause 10.1.4.3.5 in r1. (Jeongki Kim) 5.4.2.CID4589 5.4.2.1. Keep as r0. 5.4.3.CID4437, 5070, 5077, 5198, 4699 5.4.3.1. “Maintain” should be used instead of “retain”. (Mark Rison)

5.4.3.2. “Retain” is used in several clauses in our draft. Should we replace “retain” with “maintain” throughout the draft? (Ping Fang) 5.4.3.3. Yes. (Mark Rison) 5.4.3.4. What is the difference between “maintain” and “retain”? (Ping Fang) 5.4.3.5. “maintain” = keep up-to-date, “retain” = not throw away. (Mark Rison) 5.4.4.Continue in next week. 5.5. Peter Yee has been rescheduled to next week. 5.6. George Cherian has been rescheduled to San Diego ad-hoc meeting. 6. Adjourned at 11:03.

Tuesday June 10th, 2014 10:00ET

1. Attendee 1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info) 1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed) 1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center) 1.4. Ping Fang (Huawei) 1.5. Mark Rison (Samsung) 1.6. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm) 1.7. Jeongki Kim (LGE) 1.8. Peter Yee (NSA/IAD) 1.9. Rene Struik (Strik Security Consultancy) 2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:02. 3. Agenda: 11-14/0726r2. 4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy. 5. Chair requested to review meeting minutes, 11-14/633r0 for Waikoloa meeting and 11-14/731r1 for teleconferences. 6. Current Status of TG Draft 6.1. Nothing to tell. (Ping Fang) 7. Comment Resolutions 7.1. LB201-Comment resolution on AP-CSN related CIDs in 6.3.3.2.2. 11-14/739r1 Jeongki Kim 7.2. LB201-Comment resolution on CIDs for 8.4.2.178 AP-CSN element. 11-14/740r1 Jeongki Kim 7.2.1.CID4547, 4991, 5059, 5102 7.2.1.1. Still discussing. 7.3. LB201-Comment resolution on CIDs for AP-CSN related active scanning procedure (10.1.4.3.5) 11-14/741r1 Jeongki Kim 7.3.1.CID4012, 5069, 5196 7.3.1.1. Jeongki will discuss with Jarkko and revisit. 7.3.2.CID4699 7.3.2.1. Change “retaing” to “retaining”. (Mark Rison) 7.3.3.CID5011, 5122 7.3.3.1. Change “by the AP and the STA” to “by both the AP and the STA”. (Mark Rison) 7.3.3.2. Change “which is” to “which are”. (Mark Rison) 7.3.4.Change “r0” to “r1” in the resolution fields to refer the correct document. (Mark Rison) 7.3.5.Why do you use “retain”, not “maintain”? (Mark Rison) 7.3.6.I’m not sure but I thought I could use “retain” here. (Jeongki Kim) 7.3.7.I’ll change “retain” to “maintain”. (Jeongki Kim) 7.4. CCM CIDs for LB201 11-14/733r1 Peter Yee 7.4.1.Replace CCM with GCM for key wrapping algorithm. 7.4.2.Both 128bit and 256bit are mandatory in GCMP? (Mark Rison) 7.4.3.Yes. (Peter Yee) 7.4.4.Marc Emmelmann requested Mark Rison and Santosh Abraham to ask their company thought. 8. Adjourned at 10:53.

Submission page 5Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D Center