Environmental Scorecardscorecard 1997-1998 for Members of the 118Th Maine Legislature
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Maine League of Conservation Voters ENVIRONMENTALENVIRONMENTAL SCORECARDSCORECARD 1997-1998 FOR MEMBERS OF THE 118TH MAINE LEGISLATURE Environmental Votes Matter in Maine he natural environment is one of Maine’s most precious assets. For the health of our economy Tand quality of life, protecting our air, water, forests, and wildlife is extremely important. During Environmental Honor Roll each session of the Maine Legislature, our elected representatives determine the fate of bills that can (1997-1998 Maine LCV Score of 90% or better) have major implications — positive or negative — on the long-term quality of our environment. For Score these reasons, it is important for Maine people to know how their elected representatives have voted Senate (6) on the most important environmental protection issues that have come before the Legislature. Beverly C. Daggett (Kennebec) 90% That is why the Maine League of Conservation Voters (Maine LCV) has issued a scorecard at Lloyd P. LaFountain, III (York) 90% the end of each two-year legislative cycle since 1986 with the environmental voting record for Susan W. Longley (Waldo) 90% every member of the Maine State House of Representatives and Senate. Chellie M. Pingree (Knox) 100% As this year’s Environmental Scorecard reveals, the majority of Maine’s elected officials do not Anne M. Rand (Cumberland) 100% have strong environmental voting records. Maine’s legislators — on average — cast pro-environ- Sharon Anglin Treat (Kennebec) 100% ment votes only 42% of the time on a broad range of important environmental roll call votes that House (15) came before the House and Senate during 1997 and 1998. Twenty-one legislators earned very Brian Bolduc (Auburn) 100% strong environmental ratings (a score of 90% or higher), yet more than twice as many (49) had Joseph E. Brooks (Winterport) 92% sharply anti-environmental records (a score of 10% or lower). Thomas Bull (South Freeport) 92% Information such as provided by the Maine LCV scorecard is important for Maine voters to Elaine Fuller (Manchester) 100% consider as they decide which candidates to support at the polls. Kenneth T. Gagnon (Waterville) 92% Bonnie Green (Monmouth) 92% Our elected officials must be held accountable for the votes they cast on bills to conserve and Pamela Henderson Hatch (Skowhegan) 92% protect Maine’s environment. Conservation leaders in the State House should be supported for [Kyle W. Jones] (Bar Harbor) 92% their efforts, while those who repeatedly vote against environmental bills should be challenged. Linda Rogers McKee (Wayne) 100% We need a Legislature comprised of representatives who have a strong commitment to the careful Judith A. Powers (Rockport) 100% stewardship of Maine’s environment. Michael W. Quint (Portland) 100% The quality of our environment and our economy in the future will depend upon the decisions David C. Shiah (Bowdoinham) 92% we make now, including the decisions we make on Election Day. The Maine League of Conserva- Elizabeth Townsend (Portland) 100% tion Voters urges you to be an informed voter. Communicate with your representatives. Ask ques- Paul Volenik (Brooklin) 100% tions about the environmental positions of new candidates. Volunteer to work on the campaigns of Elizabeth Watson (Farmingdale) 92% those who promise to be champions for Maine’s environment. Join other voters who believe in [ ] = Legislator not running for re-election greater accountability for our elected officials by supporting the Maine League of Conservation Voters today. Environmental Dishonor Roll Henry L. Joy (Island Falls) 0% Roy I. Nickerson (Turner) 8% (1997-1998 Maine LCV Score of 10% or less) Steven M. Joyce (Biddeford) 0% [David N. Ott] (York) 8% [Jeffrey G. Joyner] (Hollis Center) 8% Reginald G. Pinkham (Brunswick) 8% Score Susan Kasprzak (Newport) 0% William D. Pinkham (Lamoine) 0% Senate (7) Richard Kneeland (Easton) 0% Vaughn A. Stedman (Hartland) 0% Vinton E. Cassidy (Washington) 10% [Priscilla Lane] (Enfield) 0% James H. Tobin, Jr. (Dexter) 8% [Jeffrey H. Butland] (Cumberland) 0% [James D. Layton] (Cherryfield) 0% Russell P. Treadwell (Carmel) 0% [Stephen E. Hall] (Piscataquis) 0% Jay MacDougal (North Berwick) 8% [John H. Underwood] (Mechanic Falls) 0% R. Leo Keiffer (Aroostook) 0% Adam Mack (Standish) 0% John W. Vedral, III (Bar Mills) 0% James D. Libby (York) 0% Jean Ginn Marvin (Cape Elizabeth) 8% G. Paul Waterhouse (Bridgton) 0% Betty Lou Mitchell (Penobscot) 0% Arthur F. Mayo, III (Bath) 8% Edgar Wheeler (Bridgewater) 0% Mary E. Small (Sagadahoc) 10% Michael J. McAlevey (Waterboro) 0% Tom J. Winsor (Norway) 0% House (42) [Rodney W. McElroy] (Unity) 8% [ ] = Legislator not running for re-election [Alvin L. Barth, Jr.] (Bethel) 0% Thomas W. Murphy, Jr. (Kennebunk) 8% Duane J. Belanger (Wallagrass) 8% Irvin G. Belanger (Caribou) 8% Donald P. Berry, Sr. (Morrill) 8% B U L K R A T E Maine U.S. POSTAGE [William E. Bodwell, II] (Brunswick) 8% League of P A I D Tarren R. Bragdon (Bangor) 0% Conservation AUGUSTA, ME John T. Buck (Yarmouth) 8% Voters PERMIT NO. 157 Richard H. Campbell (Holden) 0% P.O. Box 5271 [Joseph G. Carleton, Jr.] (Wells) 0% Augusta, Maine 04332 Peter E. Cianchette (South Portland) 0% [Dean F. Clukey] (Houlton) 0% Edward L. Dexter (Kingfield) 0% Clifton Foster (Gray) 0% Albion D. Goodwin (Pembroke) 0% Kenneth A. Honey (Boothbay) 0% Sumner A. Jones, Jr. (Pittsfield) 0% 1997-1998 / Maine League of Conservation Voters Environmental Scorecard Explanation of the Maine LCV Voting Charts ✱ ENDANGERED SPECIES LD 789: This bill placed twenty new species on the State’s list of endangered and threatened wildlife. Invertebrate The 1997-1998 Maine League of Conservation Voters (Maine LCV) Environmental Scorecard provides the species were added to the list for the first time. In the voting record of each state legislator on important bills relating to environmental issues addressed during prior legislative session, a law was passed requiring the 118th Legislature for which roll call votes were available. The votes tabulated are considered by the legislative approval of additions to the list, a responsibil- Maine LCV to be the most relevant roll call votes for each bill (on some bills there are several votes from ity that was previously delegated to the Commissioner of which to choose). Inland Fisheries and Wildlife. This vote represented the Any vote by itself may not be a fair benchmark of a legislator’s environmental record. However, the first chance for the Legislature to exercise its new au- percentage of pro-environmental votes cast, based on a series of votes as represented here, provides a thority. The bill was passed by the Legislature and signed reliable indication of a legislator’s overall environmental record. into law. Voting on important issues is a key responsibility of legislators. Therefore, the Maine LCV scores each House Roll Call #230 unexcused absence as an anti-environmental vote. In addition to reviewing the environmental scores for your legislators, you should note the number of times that your state representatives failed to vote on House Motion: Enactment important environmental matters. Pro-Environmental Vote: YES House Vote: May 20, 1997; Yes 80, No 50, Absent 21; Please keep in mind the following additional considerations when reviewing this scorecard: Motion Prevailed ■ Several important environmental bills addressed by the Legislature during the past two years are not included in this scorecard because roll call votes were not taken. ✱ FORESTRY INFORMATION ■ In comparing ratings among legislators, differences of 10 to 15 percent may not be very LD 1092: This bill would have provided the public with significant, but differences of 25 percent or greater are very revealing. expanded information regarding forest practices. The ■ The votes and ratings provided in this scorecard only measure decisions on roll call votes on Maine Forest Service would have been required to the floor of the House and Senate, and do not include committee votes. publicly release timber harvest reports prepared by pa- ■ Occasionally a pro-environmental legislator may intentionally vote the wrong way for proce- per companies and other forest landowners which are dural reasons. It is not possible to reflect such a consideration within this voting record. currently kept confidential. It also would have required forest landowners to report the establishment of tree plan- ■ Active leadership is very important to the fate of environmental legislation. Sponsoring bills, tations. Passage of this bill would have increased the leading a floor debate, forging important compromises, derailing environmentally damaging public’s understanding of current forest practices and proposals, and convincing other legislators to vote correctly are critical. However, this benefited the debate over the future of Maine’s forests. scorecard does not quantify such activities. The bill was killed by the Legislature. With regard to upcoming elections, the Maine LCV scorecard only includes the environmental records of House Roll Call #181 Senate Roll Call #149 those individuals who served in the Legislature during the past two years. To find out which candidates for the Legislature are seeking your vote at the polls, contact the Clerk of the House at (207) 287-1400. We House Motion: Accept Majority Ought Not to Pass encourage you to directly ask each candidate to explain their position on the issues included in this Report scorecard as well as on other environmental topics. Pro-Environmental Vote: NO House Vote: May 13, 1997; Yes 91,