Labour Retains Lead Greens Edge Forward

ELECTION SPECIAL €0.50

ELECTIONS

3 maltaISSUE 114 • THURSDAY, 04 JUNE 2009 • WWW.MALTATODAY.COM.MTtoday DAYS TO GO LABOUR RETAINS LEAD GREENS EDGE FORWARD Which party will you vote for? (Declared voters’ results excluding from the sample respondents who do not intend to vote or who are still undecided) Which candidate will you be giving your first preference? 51.2% 42.1% 5.5% 0.6% 0.6% Only respondents who expressed preference Candidates with ratings less than margin of error of 3.7% are -0.5% -0.3% +1.4% -0.4% -0.4% indicativindicative;e candidates with less than 2% are not included 24.5% PL PN AD AN OTHERS +0.8 6.2%6.2 6%6 +0.9+0 5.6% 4.9% -1.2-1 3.8%3 3.1% +3.4 2.4% +0.6 ++0.8 +1.2 +0.2

FULL SURVEY RESULTS PAGES 8-9

Labour MEP’s transparency pledge: PN candidate vents frustration Sliema local councillor - ‘Robert Attard-Montalto reveals partial accounts , page 14 Arrigo is not against Gonzi’ , page 22 Newspaper post Newspaper THIS IS A PAID ADVERT 10 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news ON THE RECORD Compiled by James Debono Alan Deidun Marlene Mizzi Nationalist Party Partit Laburista

On rationalisation of building whether any actionon is going to Onn workingworkingg was the best for my country. Five years schemes: be taken on the blatantatant squat-q underunnder Austin ago, I wanted Malta to join the EU, but I “One slight consolation offered by the ting at Baħar iċ-Ċagħaqgħaq and Gatt:Gatt: also wanted a change in government...” pro-scheme extension camp was that no Għajn Tuffieħa barracks,arracks, “I also told himhim May 2009, MaltaToday more ODZ developments would be con- and the ‘boathouse villages’illages’g (T((Thehe Prime Min- doned and that a minimal 0.4% increase at Ġnejna, Armier andd St ister) I was fed up On EU commission proposal was being proposed - if the Hondoq ir- Thomas Bay. These issuessues of working with to extend maternity leave to Rummien, Ta’ Cenc, Hal Ferh, Smart City may exceed the remit of ananyy Austin GGatt,ata t, that he 20 weeks: and any other developments still in the politician - maybe Azzopardiardi is not a people’speoe ple’s man, “Such“Su changes in working conditions pipeline do materialise, the 0.4% figure will prove me wrong and breakreak ththatat he treats people afaffectfec both the employee and the em- would have to be revised and any comfort the mould. lillikeke obsoleteobsolete computers.computers.”” plployer.oyer The state of the economy must it offered would have petered out.” September 2008, The Sundayunday JuJulyly 2005, MaltaTodaMaltaTodayy be taktakene into account at the time such September 2006, The Sunday Times Times prproposalsop are made because increasing On partisan politics: maternity leave has a financial impact On GonziPN’s promise to On divorce: “I have no interest in partisan popolitics.litic I on the employer and this may place fi- sanction Armier boathouses: “I am personally against divorce sinceince I really dislike this petty MalteseMaltese mental- nancial pressure on the firm which may “Even more galling (since public land believe in respecting commitments mamade.de. ity where one is brandedbranded redr or blue as not be sustainable. However, having is involved here) are the overtures by However, I am also conscious of the hard-ard- soon as one shows an opinion.o I am born said so, I think it is about time we make both political parties to the squatters at ships some people are facing as a result ooff a Maltese citizen.citizen I am not born red or things easier for working women who L-Aħrax, which straddles over all the bay wedlock – I am thus receptive to analysingg blblue.ue. I hahaveve also been born with a mind, are trying to raise a family.” from Marfa to White Tower Bay, for a to- individual cases where genuine hardships and I lilike to use my own not somebody May 2009, Pink Magazine tal of 1,200 ‘units’, made on the eve of the are being faced by any of the two partners elelse’s.” last election in an archetypal case of po- and considering granting divorce in such June 2005, MaltaToday litical clientelism… One may feel snug in cases only.” the conviction that public uproar against March 2009, Alan Deidun blogspot After being cleared such proposals will probably scupper the of any wrong doing unabashed proposals, as they did way back On campaign spending by other in an enquiry on in 2001. However, the groundwork is al- candidates: Sea Malta: ready being laid by statements to the tune “What happened to the financial lim- “I have no doubt that, of “it is difficult to speak of illegality when its imposed on candidates during their he would have loved to some of the owners are paying rent to the campaigns? Do these apply only to local crucify me if even the Lands Department, and when government elections? Are the MEP elections simply a slightest peccadillo were authorities have supplied the owners with contest of who speaks and shouts loudest? to be found… Evidently, electricity and water” by the Office of the Is the electorate being given the chance to my not having been pub- Prime Minister. This could effectively be- see through the rhetoric being thrown at licly hung, drawn, and come a rubber stamp of the misdemean- them? I trust in the discerning abilities of quartered by Austin Gatt ours carried out by the notorious Labour the Maltese electorate who, come June the is certainly not for lack of administration of the early 1980s.” 6th, will let arguments put forward to pre- his trying,” May 2008, The Sunday Times vail, rather than the hollow posturing and May 2007, MaltaToday vote-raking publicity stunts. Needless to On Armier: say, the next few months will see so many On voting Labour Parliamentary Secretary Jason Azzop- of these stunts.” after voting yes in ardi has bitten the bullet and is seeking to March 2009 Alan Deidun blogspot the referendum: move squatters from public land. While “Where’s the incon- such a stance deserves praise, Azzopardi On Simon Busuttil: sistency?” she instantly should go all the way and unravel several “There are elements present who will be replies. “Bear in mind at other contentious public land issues, be- around for another four years, and others the time I was a private sides those relating to billboards and tour- like Simon Busuttil, who – naturally, after citizen, not a public fig- ist zones. the Prime Minister has won many more ure, and really and truly Such a sentiment was also elaborately elections – I see as the next leader of the how I voted is my own expressed in the The Times’ online fo- PN.” affair. In any case, I used rum, with various readers asking about May 2009, addressing PN general council my vote to get what I felt news Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 3 heir guns on Muscat

Triccas said: “My message to pluralism is the way forward Joseph Muscat is that when- for Malta and it is now late in ever people try scoring with seeing how the European Par- political footballs, all we can liament works.” get is auto-goals, to the detri- Star candidate Simon Busut- ment of our children.” til urged greater voter partici- “We will be insisting to be pation on Saturday. heard in the European Par- “It is important for people to liament,” she continued. “PL vote, and to vote for PN can- MEPs either do not know didates, because it is the PN where they have to sit, or do candidates who know how to not know what they’re voting best use the membership tool for.” in the EU,” he said. On employment, the PN “We mentioned the exam- frontrunner said that this is ple of Iceland today, and it is “Malta’s biggest challenge.” important for us to remem- “We confront this challenge ber that it was Joseph Muscat instead of embarking on a himself who gave the wrong mudslinging campaign,” she advice to the Icelandic gov- charged. “The PN was always ernment in 2002. Thankful- the party for both the employ- ly, Malta did not take Joseph er and the employee, because Muscat’s advice. The PL want- its policies have always sought ed to make an Iceland in the to reach the balance between Mediterranean rather than a the two.” Switzerland in the Mediter- Tedesco Triccas went on to ranean. say: “Joseph Muscat should be “But this time round, the ashamed of himself for arriv- Icelandic government took ing 30 minutes late for a tel- advice from Lawrence Gonzi evised debate without apolo- and not from Joseph Muscat. gising to the Prime Minister, Tools must be entrusted to or even worse, to the PBS crew those who know how to use Concluding the event was PN I must also send my regards beings comes when times are whom he left waiting. The them. So here I am appealing general secretary Paul Borg to one of the youngest Sliema most difficult,” he said. “Now message is that the PL is al- not just to Nationalists, but Olivier, whose speech was people here – Thomas Gonzi the country is going through ways late. It was late in recog- also to Labourites and those characterised by eulogies to (the Prime Minister’s grand- difficult times, and this is nising that democracy is the who voted AD four years Gonzi. son), three months old, who is when we are being tested. way forward for Malta, it was ago, to see that the PN MEPs “Only 28 hours are left un- a symbol of the wealth we are Remember that the Icelandic late in recognising that the EU worked for them too. People til the campaign ends, and generating for the future. Minister did not go to France, is the way forward for Malta, staying home will let others I am here thanking all local “The Prime Minister 20 years or Spain, or Italy or any other it was late in recognising that vote for them.” council and MEP candidates. ago said that the test of human country. He came to Malta.” 2 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news PN candidates turn t Muscat’s advice to Iceland, Mangion’s DNA comment last year, and endless quips on the PL leader’s unpunctuality... yes, it’s open season on Labour. DAVID DARMANIN reports

JUST over 24 hours before the cession in Malta. Overtime People are now getting half were wrong. It is actually €1 someone once said that we end of the campaign, the PN decreased, people lost their the value of their pensions; million every week for the en- have something strange in our yesterday held its last in a se- part-time job and others pre- depositors cannot withdraw vironment only.” DNA. Of course we do. We ries of public dialogues, this viously working a five-day their money from banks. The Deidun went on to defend have Europe in our DNA.” time in the Nationalist heart- week roster are now working Icelandic minister told me that Gonzi’s delay in announcing In his final remarks, Deidun land of Sliema. on a four-day week. But this Malta’s EU membership saved measures for the much-await- said: “It was a good thing that Characterised by repeated country is still moving for- us. When, one and a half years ed MEPA reform, saying it the PN government decided barbs about PL leader Joseph ward. I visited the Toly Prod- ago, we said that ‘together eve- was “a good thing because the to leave Labourites occupying Muscat’s tardiness, the event ucts plant yesterday – which rything is possible’, we meant Prime Minister did not want public positions. But this now was attended predominantly committed itself to invest €13 it. And it is in this together- to make a political football seems to be working against by elderly supporters residing million in a new plant. ness that we joined the EU and out of MEPA.” us because some people are in Sliema or St Julian’s. “I arrived 30 minutes late got the Euro in our country.” Turning his guns on the PL, trying to put spokes in the The event preceded the time- there because Joseph Muscat Among the other speakers Deidun accused Joseph Mus- wheels (ifixxkluna).” ly inauguration of St Anne’s had left me waiting for the de- was environmentalist MEP cat for flaunting his efforts On her part, MEP candidate Square that evening, where the bate held before my appoint- candidate Alan Deidun, who “in trying to make Malta miss Roberta Metsola Tedesco Tric- Magic Kiosk formerly stood. ment at Toly,” he remarked. came dressed in an unusual out on €17 million for the cas was the first speaker to ac- In his opening speech, Prime The Prime Minister himself turquoise T-shirt bearing the Sant’Antnin recycling plant.” knowledge the Sliema Local Minister Lawrence Gonzi de- arrived 20 minutes late for words “I have European DNA” Deidun pointed out that the Council candidates present scribed the refurbishment yesterday’s public dialogue, on one side, and “I don’t burn PN does not “wave flags at and wish them luck. of the square as “a small but while MEP candidate Alex EU flags” on the other. such events, we leave our flags On immigration, Metsola strong symbol of what we are Perici Calascione was 40 min- “The environment is central home.” Tedesco Triccas said that this giving back to Sliema.” utes late. to PN strategy, and the PN Perhaps because this last “requires a European solu- “You suffered for so many The visit of the Icelandic will bring more investment statement was misinterpret- tion.” years with construction, noise foreign minister to Malta in the environment thanks to ed by some members of the “As EU citizens we have the and building debris, and we was mentioned repeatedly the EU,” he began. “A particu- crowd, a dozen supporters right to ask the EU to help understand this,” he said. throughout the event – with lar PL candidate did not even quickly produced EU flags and us out with immigration,” “The message I delivered the Prime Minister claiming know how many environmen- started waving them. she said. “Had it been up to at a business breakfast this that when he heard the story tal funds are allocated to Mal- In a feeble attempt to make Joseph Muscat, we would have morning is that we are going of how the Icelandic economy ta. So far we have spent €30 up for the gaffe, Deidun said: been left out of Europe and we through a storm,” he said. “So collapsed recently, he “froze”. million. From 2007 to 2012, “We don’t distribute flags to would have had to fight the this is not business as usual. “Because Iceland did not en- €300 million have been allo- supporters here.” problem alone.” Just like in other countries ter the EU and because it does cated. When the PL said they “The message on my T-Shirt Accusing the PL of making around the world, there have not use the Euro as its cur- we were going to get Lm1 mil- may be provocative,” he con- “a political football out of im- been victims of the global re- rency, the Kroner collapsed. lion in all from the EU, they tinued. “But this is because migration”, Metsola Tedesco Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday 15

14 MONTHS AGO AZZJONI NAZZJONALI SPOKE ABOUT:

•THE HUGE ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION PROBLEM • ENEMALTA’S DEEP FINANCIAL CRISIS FOR WHICH YOU HAVE TO PAY • THE DIRE LACK OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRASPARENCY • THE LACK OF DETAILED ACCOUNTS VIS-À-VIS PUBLIC FUNDS EXPENDITURE • NOW WE LEARN THAT SOME OF OUR EUROPEAN PARLIAMENTARIANS ARE EITHER ABSENT, ASLEEP OR NOT AWARE OF WHAT’S HAPPENING.

VOTE INTO EUROPE PEOPLE WHO HAVE ALWAYS BEEN SINCERE AND TRUE TO YOU.

MUSCAT JOSEPHSEYCHELL MALCOLM SPITERI GINGELL JOHN

YOUR OBVIOUS CHOICE! 8 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 maltatoday survey Labour retains a One week is a long time in politics – Joseph Cuschieri now emerges as Labour’s third most popular candidate

ties saw their support decrease JAMES DEBONO slightly since the last MaltaTo- day survey was held last week. TWO days before next Satur- At 33.3%, Labour saw support day’s election, MaltaToday’s decrease by 2.1%; the PN saw Frontrunners (according to PL/PN declared voters) (%) latest opinion poll predicts an support decrease by 1.6 per- absolute majority for Labour centage points. with 51.2% of declared voters, But AD saw support increase PL declared voters PN declared voters leading the PN by nine percent- from 2.8% to 3.6% – signifi- Louis Grech 12.1 Simon Busuttil 53.1 age points. cantly AD saw support among Edward Scicluna 11.7 David Casa 7.1 Alternattiva Demokratika has respondents aged 18 to 34 dou- seen its percentage rise from ble from 3.1% to 6.8%. Joseph Cuschieri 10.8 R. Tedesco Triccas 4.1 4.1% to 5.5%, while the major Marlene Mizzi 9.5 Alan Deidun 2 parties have seen a slight drop 29% of PN voters John Attard-Montalto 4.8 Edward Demicoli 2 in support. undecided The survey has a margin of er- A significant 28.9% of re- Steve Borg 2.6 Frank Portelli 2 ror of 3.65% and was conducted spondents who said they voted C. Abela Baldacchino 2.2 Marthese Portelli 2 among 700 respondents con- PN in 2008, are now undecided Vince Farrugia 2 tacted in the past week. on what to do next Saturday – Labour incumbent Louis an increase of 7.4 points over Others 4.1 Others 2.8 Grech has slightly surpassed the previous survey. Undecided 42.4 Undecided 30.7 Edward Scicluna as PL front- On the other hand, the runner, but it was former La- number of former PN voters Figures of candidates with less than +/-3.7% margin of error are only indicative. bour MP Joseph Cuschieri who who won’t vote decreased from Candidates with less than 2% are not included. made the most remarkable ad- 10% last week to 7.2%. vance, to emerge as Labour’s Only 16% of Labour voters third most popular candidate. remain undecided – 13% less Cuschieri’s campaign has em- than the number of undecided phasised his humble origins and PN voters. This indicates that his role in enthroning Joseph the PN has a greater potential Muscat as party leader by giv- pool of voters to persuade in the ing up his parliamentary seat. last days of the campaign. Which party will you vote for? Nationalist incumbent David But the PN is also losing more Casa, also popular with PN votes to AD: over the past week, Declared Voters Change All respondents grassroots, made significant in- the number of former PN votes PL 51.2% -0.5 33.3 roads by clinching the second who will vote for AD has in- PN 42.1% -0.3 27.4 place in the Nationalist camp, creased from 3% to 4%. surpassing Roberta Metsola Te- On the other hand, Labour AD 5.5% +1.4 3.6 desco Triccas. is still more successful in mo- AN 0.5% -0.4 0.3 The poll reveals 7.8% will not bilising its core support. 76% Others 0.5% -0.4 0.3 be voting in this election, and of those who voted Labour in No answer - 27.3 27.3% are either undecided or 2008 are sure to vote again for Not voting - 7.8 would not reveal their inten- the PL, as against to the 54% of (Declared voters’ results excluding from the sample respondents who do not intend to vote or who are still undecided) tions. 2008 PN voters who will do the Nearly two-thirds (64.9%) ex- same. pressed a preference for a par- But the number of former La- Voting intentions according to age bracket (%) ticular party. Among this cat- bour voters who would not vote egory Labour enjoys a majority in next week’s election has also PL PN AD AN Others Not Voting No Answer of 51.2%. increased from 3% to 4.7% - an 18-34 30.5 22.9 6.8 0 0 9.3 30.5 When all respondents are indication that overconfidence 35-54 33.9 23.2 1.5 0.6 0.6 10.2 30 taken into account, even those could be taking its toll on La- who intend t abstain or who are bour supporters. 55+ 35 33.8 2 0.3 0.3 3.5 25.1 still undecided, both major par- Significantly, while 4.8% of

Most Which party did you vote for in the 2008 general important election? (%) issue of PN 41.7 EMPLOYMENT PL 36.7 6.1% campaign AD 0.8 AN 0.3 No answer 13.3 Was under 18 2.2 Did not vote 5 IMMIGRATION DON’T KNOW 20.6 32.7% Voting intentions according to 2008 voters (%)

Voted PN in 2008 Voted PL in 2008 Will vote PL 4.8 76.6 Will vote PN 54.2 2 COST OF LIVING Will vote AD 4 0.4 Will vote AN 0.6 0 13% Will vote N. Lowell 0.3 0.4 OTHERS ENVIRONMENT Will vote for others 0.3 0 16.5% 2.4% No answer 28.9 16 HUNTING Not Voting 7.2 4.7 2.7% news Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 5 A rare glimpse of statesmanship

panies. “Now tell me where would we be today if La- bour was not progressive?” Joseph Muscat asked. I am not a Social justice is the tool which politician was and will con- “ tinue to be the PL’s main axis, he who likes flag to be what the PL has been des- make that change happen,” he started to believe in its promis- said, adding that the future still perately yearning for after last stressed. ing young leader, who carefully holds a place for all to have free waving. I hate year’s shock defeat at the polls. In his few political digs, amid explained the meaning of being access to healthcare, decent re- Eloquent in his delivery, Joseph applause and acknowledge- part of a “progressive” party. tirement pensions and most of Muscat took centre stage, and ment, Joseph Muscat explained A cross between former all, a sense that the State exists the political excusing himself for diverting that his party welcomes those British Prime Minister Tony to regulate and create the op- from the issues that character- thousands of workers from all Blair and US President Barack portunity for the advancement divide. ised the campaign, he stressed: sectors who have been taken Obama, Joseph Muscat dwelt of all those who wish to make a “Here I am, a believer in this for a ride by Lawrence Gonzi’s on bringing out the inner pride success out of their lives. country, and a believer in you. administration before last year’s of a nation that has risen to be He reached out to investors I am not a politician who likes general election. the what it is today from the and employees, to be comple- flag waving. I hate the political “Those of you out there, hunt- humble origins of a dependent mentary to each other’s success, divide. I am here to build bridg- ers and trappers, Go employees, colony. and for social jealousy to be es, preserve a free mind, to up- dockyard workers, teachers, Joseph Muscat admitted that eradicated once and for all. hold the strong values that have nurses, nursing aides, doctors, he himself hails from a “mixed” “Let us move on in this coun- built this nation, and most of bus and taxi drivers, architects family that votes both Labour try,” Joseph Muscat said pas- all, to change Malta.” and engineers: they promised and Nationalist, but he chose sionately, receiving a loud ap- Joseph Muscat insisted that you everything just to get your to militate within the PL for the plause of approval, and more he and his party are standing vote last year, and they betrayed reason that he believed in the when he spoke about Church- before a nation in a bid to build you. Now they are trying to lure “progressive” ideas that, during State relations. what he defined as a brand new you back into the trap because it the 1970s and the 1980s, put “I respect the Church as an au- “political project,” adding that is time again to vote... Malta a notch ahead of other thority, and I respect the State. this project enhances all those “Let me tell you this: they European states. We are friends, but they are two who believe that a brand new lied to you, and now I will tell He explained that the decrim- separate entities. I believe in a dawn is breaking for the coun- you, that we won’t lie, nor will inalisation of homosexuality secular society,” he stressed. try. we take you for a ride. This is back then by a Labour admin- At times pausing, and looking Beyond the usual political your chance to send the mes- istration was a progressive idea; straight into the TV cameras, rhetoric, Joseph Muscat sent a sage to those who deceived you as were the enfranchisement of Joseph Muscat explained that clear message to disgruntled and your families, and are now women the lowering of the vot- the PL stands for access for all Nationalist supporters. “The PL threatening your families’ fu- ing age to 18, the national mini- children to the tools that will is also their ‘common home’”, ture,” he said, while waving a se- mum wage, maternity leave, lead them towards successful and appealed to supporters to ries of personalised letters and pensions and the widening of lives, the value of equality, soli- fling their doors wide open to emails that were sent to various the middle class. darity and social justice. all who have never voted for the sectors a year ago on the eve of But Maltese pride is also re- He criticised the lack of de- PL before. the general election. flected in the progressive at- bate in Malta about the causes “We are a new coalition, bring- The atmosphere in and around titude borne out of a strong of the current global economic ing together all Maltese from the campaign tent was rife with belief in the nation, mention- crisis, and pledged that the PL all walks of life, with different optimism, and perhaps for the ing the establishment of Air believes in a state that does not aspirations, and who are eager first time in years, the PL grass Malta, strong banks, as well as a tolerate market abuses or the it and then send a clear message to start hoping again. We will root support appears to have number of solid parastatal com- dominance of the market over back to who sent you that,” he workers. said while he waved a utility bill He closed his in his hand. speech by ap- Joseph Muscat was then es- pealing to the corted out of the square amid undecided voter loud applause and tears from to stop and think: some supporters who saluted “Come next Sat- him with chants of “Joseph, urday, I ask you Joseph!” all to look into Behind the campaign tent was your drawers and a flurry of parked SUV’s that pull out your wa- were later seen transporting ter and electricity MP’s, candidates and activists bill, open it, read back home. sports Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 23 Chelsea deny £73.5m Kaka bid

CHELSEA dismissed as “totally never made an offer to AC Mi- president, and reports on Tues- untrue” reports that they have lan for Kaka and therefore not day evening in Spain claimed a tabled a world transfer record one at this extraordinary level. deal had been agreed between offer of £73.5million for AC Mi- “As a consequence we have the clubs during talks in the lan’s Brazilian superstar Kaka. not discussed a salary with the Spanish capital. Kaka has been strongly linked player either. Any reports to the But in a statement released on with a move to Real Madrid fol- contrary are totally untrue.” the club’s official website, Mi- lowing Florentino Perez’s re- Meanwhile AC Milan have lan insisted Galliani had only turn as president. denied that general manager travelled to Madrid to attend a Chelsea, who have just ap- Adriano Galliani was negotiat- dinner for Perez. pointed former AC Milan boss ing the sale of Kaka to Real Ma- The statement read: “The gen- Carlo Ancelotti as their new drid during a visit to Spain. eral manager of the Rosseneri, manager, insisted that they Speculation has been mount- Adriano Galliani, is in the city have not tabled any offer for ing that the Brazilian playmak- of Madrid exclusively for the Kaka. er will swap the San Siro for the investiture dinner of Floren- A statement on the club’s of- Bernabeu following Florentino tino Perez, the new president of Kaka - Chelsea are not interested ficial website read: “We have Perez’s return as Real Madrid Real Madrid.” Federer sweeps into French semifinals

Brabham could return Roger Federer of Switzerland plays a shot during his quarter-ﬁ nal match against Gael Monﬁ ls to Formula One ROGER Federer remains on tive Grand Slam semi-final. course to complete his set of After saving a set point, Fe- Grand Slam titles after a su- derer edged the opening tie- THE famous Formula 1 team back in 1992. The team won Brabham isn’t the only perb win over Gael Monfils break and went on to dominate Brabham could make its re- the Formula 1 championship team that wants to join For- in the French Open quarter- the 11th seed. turn to the Formula One four times with its drivers mula 1. Prodrive, Superfund, finals. He will next face fifth seed grid next season. German and won the constructors’ USF1 and Campos also con- The Swiss, 27, saw off home Juan Martin del Potro after the business man Franz Hilmer championship twice. firmed their entries favourite Monfils 7-6 (8-6) 6-2 Argentine beat Spain’s Tommy has submitted an entry for Franz Hilmer has owned The current 10 Formula 1 6-4 to reach his 20th consecu- Robredo 6-3 6-4 6-2. the 2010 F1 season accord- the Brabham brand for a teams also submitted their ing to German magazine while and bought up Su- entries which means there Motorsport Aktuell. per Aguri’s assets when the are a total of 15 entries Injury halts Haye title challenge The Brabham Formula 1 team went bankrupt one known so far while there is team completed its last race year ago. space for just 13 teams. DAVID Haye’s world heavyweight injury but say Haye can’t train. title fight against Wladimir Kl- We will get someone else but I itschko in Germany on 20 June can’t say yet who it will be. The Melita Malta Football Awards 2008/09 winners has been called off. “Ninety five percent of the fans The decision to postpone the who bought tickets did so be- Best Goalkeeper: Anthony Curmi (Tarxien R.) IBF, WBO and IBO title contest cause of Klitschko.” Best Defender: Luke Dimech (Valletta) was taken after Londoner Haye, A possible alternative opponent Best Midfielder: Clayton Failla (Hibernians) 28, suffered an injury in training for Klitschko could be WBA Best Forward: Terrence Scerri (Hibernians) at his base in Cyprus. champion Nicolai Valuev, the Best Coach: Mark Miller (Hibernians) The pair were due to meet in 7ft Russian whose fight against Most Promising Youngster: Jean Paul Farrugia (Hibernians) front of a 60,000 sell-out crowd at Ruslan Chagaev on Saturday was Best Local Player: Clayton Failla (Hibernians) Schalke O4 FC’s Veltins Arena. cancelled when Chagaev failed a Best Foreign Player: Daniel Mariano Bueno (Tarxien) Haye was hoping to become medical. Best Veteran Player: Gilbert Agius (Valletta) Britain’s first heavyweight world The build-up to the Haye-Kl- Best Goal of the Season: Adrian Pulis (Hibernians vs Birkirkara 18-May) champion since Lennox Lewis itschko bout had been mired in Best Female Player: Rachel Cuschieri (Birkirkara) retired in 2003. controversy over Haye’s contro- Best Futsal First Division Player: Alexander Ribic (White Eagles) A short postponement may al- versial behaviour when promot- Best GFA First Division Player: John Camilleri (Sannat) low the fight to be re-scheduled ing the fight. Best First Division Player: Anthony Eviparker (Vittoriosa) but Klitschko’s camp appears He attended media events Best Second Division Player: Matthew Borg (Melita) keen to fight on the allotted wearing a T-shirt depicting him Best Third Division Player: Ayrton Buhagiar (Mdina) date. proudly holding aloft the decapi- Career Award: Joe Cini “I’m speechless. We will have tated heads of Wladimir and his Public’s Favourite Player: Mario Muscat (Hibernians) to get someone else in. I will take elder brother Vitali. Special Awards: Malta Football Coaches Association and Malta Football who ever it is,” said Klitschko. Renaming Klitschko as Referees Association The Ukrainian’s manager, “Bitchko”, he also derided him as Bernd Bonte, added: “They an embarrassment to boxing and haven’t given any detail on the rubbished his record.

Today’s Weather WARNINGS: Nil PARTLY WEATHER: Mainly ﬁ ne. CLOUDY VISIBILITY: Good locally moderate to good at ﬁ rst 29 ºC / 17 ºC WIND: Light to moderate West to Northwest (force 3 to 4) locally moderate (force 4). UV INDEX: 8 SEA: Slight locally slight to moderate. SWELL: Low Northwest. news Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 7 RAY ATTARD PHOTOGRAPHY BY RAY

Alternattiva Demokratika say the sixth seat will be won with just 8% of the vote AD writes to Dimas over Mistra party

“Alternattiva Demokratika the last minute – until the last Under the Maltese electoral however the fifth seat is won CHARLOT ZAHRA believes that permitting these minute of 10 pm on Saturday,” system, where a quota of 16.6 with 10-11%, while the sixth activities, especially without the AD leader told the activists per cent is needed to elect an seat will be won with 7-8%,” he ALTERNATTIVA Demokra- any appropriate assessment present. MEP, the last two MEPs will be insisted. tika (AD) chairperson Arnold by the competent national au- “Tomorrow there is a poll in elected without a quota. At the end of the rally, the Cassola yesterday made public thority – the Malta Environ- MaltaToday, and I hope that “If AD obtains 7% at the first banner “Yes We Can”, which a letter sent by the party’s en- ment and Planning Authority like we did last time, when we count, then it would have ob- was AD’s final electoral cam- vironment spokesman Carmel (MEPA) – is a further infringe- increased our share a bit, we tained a seat because whoever paign slogan during the EP Cacopardo to EU Environment ment of the obligations of this will continue increasing our obtains the largest leftover will elections, was unfurled in the Commissioner Stavros Dimas, Directive, considering that no share,” Cassola added. get elected,” Cassola told his presence of MEP election can- asking the Commission to in- management plans are pres- Cassola explained how this activists. didate Yvonne Arqueros Ebe- vestigate the “general misman- ently being considered for such time, AD “can really make it Cassola explained that as the jer, and AD candidates Michael agement” by MEPA of the Nat- sites,” the AD spokesperson because we will be voting for counts progressed, the share Brigugilio and Mario Mallia, ura 2000 Sites in Malta, as well for Sustainable Development six seats in the EP – five will be of the bigger parties would de- who will be contesting the lo- as their use as open-air discos. added. elected immediately, while the crease, while the share of AD cal council elections in Sliema The sites in question were Cassola made this revelation sixth one will wait till Septem- would increase. and Birkirkara alongside Vic- ix-Xaghra tal-Kortin, Buskett as he was addressing the final ber or October. However the “Sixteen per cent might seem tor Galea, who is contesting for and Girgenti, and the part of rally for AD activists which votes that will be cast on Sat- too huge a percentage for AD to the Gharb local council. the Malta coastal cliffs in the packed a hall in the Juliani urday will count for the sixth obtain in the first, the second, Qammiegħ Area. Hotel in St. Julian’s yesterday seat.” the third and the fourth seat, [email protected] In his letter to Dimas, Ca- night. copardo said that “of par- “When we see you here so nu- ticular concern to Altern- merous – there are around 60- attiva Demokratika is the 70 people here – it gives us hope organisation of open-air discos that we are indeed represent- in the following sites – at Mis- ing somebody; that there are tra within ix-Xaghra tal-Kort- people behind us, and we hope in, Buskett and Girgenti, and at that on Saturday there will be Paradise Bay.” more votes than the number of In fact, a party was organised people present here,” the AD by Nationalist MP Jeffrey Pul- chairperson told the activists licino Orlando on his land in present. Mistra last Saturday evening, Cassola rubbished the poll in support of Nationalist MEP published in The Sunday hopeful Alex Perici Calas- Times, which had forecast a cione. poor showing for AD in the 6 “The use of high-powered June elections. laser beams and/or high-tech “I hope there we obtain more sound equipment in the open than the 50 votes that the poll air, together with the tram- in the Sunday Times of Malta pling by large numbers of peo- has forecast for us on Sunday ple, is surely not conducive to with 0.25 per cent,” Cassola re- proper management of these marked. Natura 2000 sites which Mal- “I think that this is really ta is internationally obliged something that will not be oc- to manage on behalf of future curring on Sunday. I think that generations,” Cacopardo said we will faring much better that in his letter to Dimas. that, but we have to fight till 16 maltatoday | Thursday 04 June 2009 6 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news EP elections ‘a phantom national election’ - Muscat RAY ATTARD PHOTOGRAPHY BY RAY Josie Muscat - “This election should not be a political football”

much to elect five MEPs to the cal football.” those people who are capable few days and weeks in the me- CHARLOT ZAHRA European Parliament but more He accused political parties of and have a vision,” Muscat in- dia and in the papers,” the AN to claim that one of them has preferring to do this, “because sisted. “They should look at the leader added. AZZJONI Nazzjonali (AN) lead- won.” the people do not know how the track record of these people and AN had always been consistent er Josie Muscat has lambasted Muscat contended that the EP works and the importance elect MEPs who are able to stand in its statements, both during the way in which the two major main parties were distorting of the EP today and how it is al- up in the EP to the other 739 the electoral campaign as well as political parties have treated this the purpose of the elections. “It ready affecting and will continue members to get the best deal for before it started. election as if it were a general looks as if one of them is going to affect our daily lives in this Malta,” he added. “We have never danced to the election, when there were more to be elected Prime Minister and country.” Malta should elect people “who tune of the moment,” Muscat important issues at stake. the other one is thinking that Over half (57%) the laws en- are capable of telling Europe that concluded. Addressing a press conference something will change. acted by the Maltese Parliament what is good for large EU Mem- Muscat complained about how yesterday morning at the party’s “In reality, things will remain were directives and laws ema- ber States might not necessarily the local council elections had headquarters in Sliema, Muscat the same – the government will nating from the EP. fit for Malta, a small island in the “completely disappeared” from said: “Unfortunately, the PL/PN remain in place while the Op- “If the Lisbon Treaty is ratified, Mediterranean,” the AN leader the 6 June 2008 electoral cam- leaders have decided to treat this position would stay where itis then almost all the most impor- charged. paign. “We pay a lot of lip serv- election as a nationwide elec- now.” tant laws that affect our daily “If the EU feels that it needs a ice to the importance of local tion. In fact they are treating is The only thing that will change, lives will originate from the EU,” lot of migrants to take the jobs councils, however in reality the as a phantom national election.” according to Muscat, “will be the the AN leader insisted. nobody else wants, it might not big parties have diluted their im- Muscat remarked that “as usu- five MEPs that are attending in The truth was, Muscat said, necessarily mean that we need portance,” he insisted. al, the two main parties were Brussels. This is a pity, because “that the PL/PN have no criti- the same amount or proportion He accused the main political arousing partisan sentiments we consider it as a very serious cism of the European Union, but of them,” Muscat claimed. parties of amalgamating the EP to get people out to vote, not so election, and not simply a politi- only praise. They have no reser- “Our problems are different elections with the local council vations whatsoever and there are and we should have the courage elections “to force people to go no things they wish to change in to stand up and declare what is in out and vote for the local coun- the EU.” the national interest,” he added. cils as well. We will see what the Muscat claimed that the main “We have to elect people who people will say about this,” the political parties have “shamed stop ‘shooting’ at each other; AN leader declared. the EP” with the type of cam- insulting each other as to how AN was against the participa- paign that they had conducted. many EP sessions they attended tion of political parties in local “They are telling the people and how many they failed to at- councils, and that was the rea- that the most important thing is tend, how much they slept, how son why AN did not field any whoever wins in partisan terms, often they were absent, how of- candidates for these elections. rather than the capabilities of ten they failed to press the right “My personal experience is that those people that we need to buttons, and their voting incon- as they stand now, local coun- send to the EP,” he insisted. sistencies,” Muscat said. cils are a huge waste of money,” He called on the Maltese peo- “We hope that the Maltese Muscat, an outgoing Marsascala ple to put the national interest people have learnt their lesson independent councillor, charged. before partisan considerations and five years from now, we do “AN has proposed the aggrega- in the 6 June elections. not have the same accusations tion of local councils into Re- “They should look at electing which we have seen in the past gional Councils. maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news AD slams transport tender for opting for polluting buses

CHARLOT ZAHRA asked during a press conference have to remove them, and in- in Marsa yesterday afternoon stead we are issuing a tender to ALTENATTIVA Demokratika to discuss AD’s proposals on issue Euro 3 buses!” he insisted. (AD) chairperson Arnold Cas- transport. If Malta introduced Euro 5 sola has slammed the tender for “Euro 3 is an obsolete tech- buses, they could stay on the the proposed national transport nology – we can expect the ar- road for 15 years. “If we intro- service under the public trans- rival of Euro 5 in the next few duced Euro 3 buses, we would port reform for opting for buses months,” Cassola insisted. have to change them after a few which are more polluting. Cassola explained that the years,” Cassola warned. “Why has Austin Gatt issued buses that were imported from In 2012, the Euro 7 standard a tender for public transport China a few years ago were al- would be introduced. AD candidate Arnold Cassola, left, says new buses reform that will be tendering ready Euro 3 buses. “Bus drivers “It is important that the cur- fall below European standards only for Euro 3 buses?” Cassola who imported those buses will rent bus drivers become stakeholders in this reform,” the AD chairperson insisted. Cassola explained that these people had forked out an enor- mous sum of money, two to three years ago, when they were told that it would have been the final public transport reform, they bought the buses imported from China. “Now they will have to sell Unlimited SMS for only €2 them, therefore a solution that is fair should be found for these Send an SMS to 16200 with the word SMS to bus drivers,” the AD chair- get unlimited SMS to over 200,000 Vodafone person insisted. “It would be important for the existing bus customers for just €2 a week drivers to be introduced as part of the national transport system Get more, more and more with Vodafone that is introduced,” he added. The AD chairperson explained www.vodafone.com.mt how the Nationalist Govern- ment had been announcing Life is now public transport reform for the past 22 years. “We hope that this reform is the right one at last,” Cassola added. He explained that public transport should be an investment for the benefit of the community, therefore it should not be considered exclusively as a for profit concern. Public transport, Cassola said, should also be considered as a social service which satisfied the needs of society and the community. “Therefore we need public transport that reduces emissions, rather than increasing them,” he added. Moreover, if we had a public transport service which was regular, efficient and trustwor- thy which ran for an extensive number of hours, then “we can start removing congestion from our roads,” Cassola said. A study that AD had conducted showed that to keep a private car and maintain it, one needed eight euros a day. “We are not saying to ban private cars, however one should balance their use with public transport,” Cas- sola added. “We are happy with the public transport reform, but we want buses that use clean fuel,” the AD chairperson insisted. “We want buses that work on gas, hydrogen and electricity.” AD also believed that trams should be introduced together with the underground in certain areas of the islands. Moreover, Cassola said that AD welcomed the introduction of the ferry service between Val- letta and the other ports in the area, which will ease the burden of traffic from the roads. He said that the EU had specific funds earmarked for shifting short- sea shipping from the roads to Offer available to all Vodafone prepaid customers. Pay Monthly customers can beneȣ t from UNLIMITED SMS to all Vodafone Malta customers for just €5 per month. The UNLIMITED SMS Summer offer is applicable the ports. For instance, the port when sending SMS locally to Vodafone Malta customers and is subject to Vodafone’s Fair Usage policy. For more information on the Vodafone UNLIMITED SMS Summer offer visit www.vodafone.com.mt, or any of Hamburg reduced pollution Vodafone Retail Outlet, or call 247 from your Vodafone, or 99999247 from any other line. last year by 9%, Cassola said.

0910 Voda Summer A4.indd 1 6/3/09 10:42:15 AM 4 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news A rare glimpse ofo statesmanship PHOTOGRAPHY BY DENISE SCICLUNA Joseph Muscat yesterday delivered the best speech of his campaign to date. KARL STAGNO-NAVARRA detects a change in stature in the PL leader

“LET there be no mistake. Mal- time to move on and aspire for In Fgura last night, Opposi- ered before him for the last pub- and red tie, Joseph spoke in a ta’s place is in Europe. The feu- brighter days, where all Maltese tion and PL Leader Joseph Mus- lic meeting before this evening’s declamatory tone, and gesticu- dal days of conflict between the can come together and start cat delivered a clear and impas- formal close to the European lated accurately. For the crowd yes and no camps, or red or blue changing this country’s politi- sioned speech that reached out Parliament election campaign. in the Labour stronghold of tribes, are history. This is the cal direction...” beyond the large crowd gath- Clad in a dark suit, white shirt Fgura, Joseph Muscat appeared

PARTITLABURISTA

ABILITY - CREDIBILITY - EXPERIENCE

because your interests should be better represented in the European Parliament Your Vote Counts

www.edwardscicluna.com I 2741 2812 22 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news ‘Arrigo’s like my second dad. Maybe that’s why I’m finding obstacles in the party’

formerly president. Sliema a one-stop shop?’ It was one who wanted to eliminate Prime Minister is seeing it dif- MARK ATTARD Dimech however confides that something we never discussed him… Some people wanted to ferently – maybe he has recog- his bid for re-election – possibly in the electoral programme. I depict Arrigo as being against nised my qualities. I appreciate SLIEMA’S Nationalist council- eyeing the mayorship left vacant froze. I’m not saying anything Lawrence Gonzi, but it’s un- this.” lor Nikki Dimech revealed all by Marina Arrigo, Robert’s wife about the party media, but these true.” Dimech also took umbrage at in a candid interview for sister – has not been easy. things hurt me.” Dimech said Arrigo had been the leak to Labour organ Kull- newspaper Illum – to be pub- “I can see it from the manoeu- Expressing deep admiration crucial for the PN to retain the Hadd of a confidential email he lished this Sunday – over his vres being orchestrated against for his mentor Robert Arrigo, elusive Sliema vote in the last sent to a member of the Sliema dissatisfaction at his mentor me. I was only invited to a Net Dimech says many in Sliema general election, and that the sectional committee, of which Robert Arrigo being left out of TV programme recently, after still remain baffled at the prime MP was hurt at having been left he is president, apparently brag- the Cabinet after being elected a four-week boycott,” Dimech minister’s decision to leave Ar- out of the new Cabinet. ging that Gonzi had “recognised from two districts in 2008. said. rigo out of the Cabinet. “I never saw him cry as much his capabilities” at an event he Dimech, who is seeking re- “I was one of the last candi- “I don’t know why he was never as he did that day,” referring to organised for the PM. election on the Sliema council, dates to be invited on to the made a minister. It’s something the day Gonzi chose his new As things stand, the commit- is the treasurer of Sliema Wan- party media. They just asked me many people ask to this day. Cabinet. “And he had all reason tee is evenly divided between derers FC, of which Arrigo was a senseless question such as: ‘Is Certainly there must be some- to, since he was elected on two two factions supporting Di- districts. Labourites actually mech, for his allegiance to Ar- voted for him out of respect rigo; and newcomer Cyrus En- for what he did for Sliema gerer, who enjoys the support of Wanderers.” the party machinery. Calling him his “second fa- “I am still stunned at how La- ther”, Dimech said that – “like bour got to know of this email. Arrigo” – he put the party be- I get serious doubts whether the fore anything else. party wants me or not. Maybe “In 2006 the Prime Minister the Prime Minister does not told me to make way for Ma- know of these things.” rina, Robert’s wife, who was Dimech said he will only con- contesting the Sliema council test the next general elections elections. I moved out of the if Arrigo decides to back out of way, for the party. Today the the running. “I am loyal towards Robert – he guided me, he’s al- Sliema’s PN councillor Nikki ways been honest with me and I Dimech hints that his want to be honest in everything re-election bid may not have with him. We’re united. If he been welcomed by everyone in doesn’t contest the next elec- Hurt - Roberto Arrigo the party. tion, I will contest.”

LET’S BE FRANK IN EUROPE opinion Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 17 A day in the life

Saviour Balzan takes a ﬁ ctitious trip around the political meanderings of MEP candidates Alan Deidun and Sharon Ellul Bonici

IT all starts with a telephone needs you.” “Very good,” Joseph replies, of what you do and you do not call. Paul Borg Olivier peeps at hoping that his tone will not do.” “Hello, is that Alan?” Simon. They both know that give him away. “Yes, but what will you do?” “Yes, I am Alan Deidun. Who the Prime Minister repeats the “Really? I am pleased to hear “Eh, I will do what I have to is it?” same thing to each and every that. Because you know I have do to allow you to practise your “This is from the Office of potential candidate. quite a budget for this cam- hobby.” the Prime Minister. Dr Gonzi “Bye, bye, Alan.” paign...” “Prosit, but can you tell me would like to talk to you. The Prime Minister turns “Good.” what exactly you will be do- Can you can find the time on to Paul and Simon after Alan “Will there be any budget ing?” Wednesday at 11am?” leaves, and tells them that this restrictions for any of the can- “Eh, I will be doing what the “Of course, of course.” one is definitely in. didates?” others have not done.” Alan hangs up and wonders Simon asks: “What if he says “No, not at all...” “Which is?” what it’s all about. something stupid?” “So, I can do as I please.” “Now please, you have to On Wednesday, he wakes up “It doesn’t really matter, does “Yes, you may.” believe that I am capable of with a queasy stomach. It must it? After all he has little or no “Thank you, Joseph, thanks so convincing the European Com- be the excitement, he says to chance of getting elected!” much.” mission to bring back hunting himself. He then drives to the And all of them break into a Joseph closes the door and to Malta.” PN HQ, walks in staring at the giggle, “Heh, heh, heh.... tee- then talks to himself, as he “I see, tridx thallina Sha- opulence around him, wonder- hee, zee, heh, heh...” looks out of his massive win- ron. When you get me back ing how much was donated Two weeks later Alan Deidun SAVIOUR BALZAN dow onto the Nationalist HQ my gamiema and summiena by which big contractor or is an official candidate of the some 400 metres away. in Spring give me a ring. My businessman to allow for this Nationalist Party. He launches “I only wish I had the balls number is *******.” extravagance. his campaign by organis- to tell her what I really think. Sharon is shocked. Does it really matter, he tells ing a press conference at the Nahseb blajna z*** kbir. James.” himself? Seated on the big proposed Ghadira road. One James looks on, not knowing Meanwhile, in another radio black leather sofas, he waits pa- passer-by asks the journalists what to say. station, Alan is taking part in tiently. He looks at the abstract present, “Is this guy from the a studio discussion with two paintings on the wall. He won- Greens?” Thirty days later other guests. It is Radio 101. All ders why the same artist never “No, he is a Nationalist can- We are in a radio station in participants are agreeing with changes his style, and still gets didate.” Marsa, Sharon has hardly wok- each other, arguing that Gonzi exhibited in every government “What? Doesn’t he know that en up. It’s her turn to review is their man. building or agency. his party wants the road, mela the newspapers on Super One. Alan interrupts. Then suddenly, the door dan m’ahniex jew?” She reads something from a “Let me tell you why I think opens and the Prime Minis- newspaper heading but then the PN campaign is a success. ter walks in, his smile filling In another part of Malta, far suddenly forgets about the First of all, our billboards light the room. Behind him; Paul away, far away, there is a grey subject and calls on hunters up at night and their billboards Borg Olivier, followed by the building with red aluminium and trappers to remember that do not.” pint-sized persona of Simon pillars. Another candidate is it was Gonzi who did not keep The other two guests look at Busuttil. waiting for a meeting with the his word. him in disbelief. One of them “Alan, kif ahna?” Leader. “Don’t trust him. Trust me, I makes a sign with his finger, “Very well. Mr Prime Minis- But this time her name is will fight to get you back hunt- tapping his temple to indicate ter.” Sharon Ellul Bonici. Sharon, ing, yes hunting for birds in that he is mad. “Still writing about MEPA... the great eurosceptic. spring. And if anyone needs to Alan tries to patch it up. heh-heh... and all those ques- Sharon is, as usual, gracefully “Well, it is not up to me to tell contact me you may do so on “No, that was a joke,” and tionable permits... heh, heh, dressed. She waits on the pink you what I think.” this mobile number ********.” then goes on to say in Monty heh, heh...” plastic chairs in the waiting Joseph looks at her, grinning The incredulous technician Python style. And Simon and Paul go, “Heh, room. She looks at the decor and trying very hard to keep behind the window screen “Just look at our billboards. In heh, heh, heh, heh....” and after in the room and wonders what his eyes to himself, and trying looks at her and signals to her our billboards we are walk- 10 minutes of absolute cods- it could take to make the HQ to avoid raising the question of that mobile numbers cannot be ing in one direction. We know wallop, the PM turns to Alan at Mile End a wee bit more her euro-scepticism. given over the airwaves. where our direction is, and and informs him that the party welcoming. “Will you guarantee that no As soon as the programme what success is all about. On would like him to stand as a Muscat walks by and asks her one in the Labour party will finishes, her mobile starts to the other hand Labour’s candi- PN candidate for the European to follow him. He is accom- work against my candidature?” ring. The ringtone is the same, dates are simply posing on the elections. panied by James Piscopo, the “No one under my command overplayed song by Coldplay. lawn and going nowhere.” Alan is shell-shocked and Labour party’s CEO. will work against your candida- “Hello.” There is a pause and silence starts to cry with joy. “Come in Sharon.” ture. Isn’t that true, James?” “’Ello, is that Sharon.” on the airwaves and one of “I am honoured, but please “Thanks for having me.” “Of course, of course,” James “Iva.” the people in the studio lands allow me to consult with my “So what can I do for you?” nods, looking so convincing “SHARR, can you explain to his forehead on the table, and family before giving you a “I would like to see what you his deceit takes both Muscat me how the **** you will bring raises his hands over his bald definitive answer.” really think about my candida- and Ellul Bonici by surprise. back spring hunting?” patch. “Yes, yes, of course, but ture for the European elec- “So what do you think about “Becauseecause I know that in We are completely f*****f*****,, he remember Alan: the country tions.” my chances?” Europeopeitisallaquestionope it is all a question says to himself.hi EXCLUSIVE Saviour Balzan interviews Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando THIS SUNDAY in MALTATODAY 12 maltatoday | Thursday 04 June 2009 Louis Grech ﬁl-Parlament Ewropew

"Jien ma Louis kelli x-xorti "Mhux qed nittkelmu fuq "Li nemmen li l-ewwel li niltaqa’ ħames snin ilu. bniedem li ser nippruvah għażla għandha tkun għall- Ftit li xejn konna nafu lil jew irriduh jagħti prova kontinwità; għandu jkollna xulxin. Nistqarr bla l-edba x’jiswa. Louis, bhala Kap tad-Delegazzjoni bħal kundizzjoni ta’ xejn li minn Kap tad-Delegazzjoni m’hemm illum... Louis dan ir-raġel tgħallimt u tal-Partit Laburista ﬂ- Grech. Louis akkwista ċerta tgħallimt ħafna. Għallimni li Ewropa, diġa tagħna esperjenza li, jien inħoss, u meta bniedem jagħti kelma, prova ta’ dak li jiswa." ngħidha b’responsabbilta’, dik il-kelma jrid iżommha Onor. Karmenu Vella MP ma nistgħux nitilfuh sa l-aħħar. Louis huwa mit-team li ser ikollna bniedem li jekk iwegħdek wara din l-elezzjoni." ħaġa, dik il-ħaġa jagħmilha Onor. George Vella MP u ħa jagħmilha jiġri x’jiġri.

Għalih l-irġulija tiġi u "Noħorgu nivvotaw "When mentioning the l-ewwel u qabel kollox. Lil għall-kandidati kollha u present Leader of the Louis rajtu jaħdem. Lil Louis nibdew b’Louis Grech. delegation, Louis Grech, rajtu jiddeliverja. Lil Louis Louis ta biżżejjed prova I want to make a special rajt kemm hu kapaċi jiġbed li għandna bżonn li jibqa tribute to him and the work rispett u jien inħalli kull hemm ħalli nkomplu he did in the last years in wieħed u waħda minnkom naħdmu u nagħmlu l-gid. the EU. A few years ago he jiddeċiedi, biss ngħidilkom Hemm min jiftaħar was one of two rapporteurs ħaga. Daqs kemm hu b’li ma jagħmilx, Louis of the budget of the EU rispettat fil-PE, tant kemm jagħmel ħafna u bil which was one of the most kiseb affarijiet mill-grupp ftit li xejn jiftaħar. important jobs you can soċjalista, tant kemm il- Bil-ħiliet tiegħu ħadem get in this Parliament." kelma tiegħu hija kelma mhux biss biex jipprezenta Jan Marinus Wiersma, Vici-President PSE ta’ l-azzar, meta ġejt biex lill-Ewropa f’Malta imma insir il-kap tad-delegazzjoni lil Malta fl-Ewropa." "Louis Grech is a very l-aħjar ħaġa għal pajjiżna u Onor. Evarist Bartolo MP reliable person who għall-Partit Laburista kien is well known for his illi Louis jibqa l-kap f’dak accomplishments and il-ħin u dak il-mument. a person that Malta U ma jiddispjaċini xejn." can be proud of." Onor. Joseph Muscat, Ralph Walter, Viċi President Kap tal-Partit Laburista tal-Kumitat tal-Budget, PE ›››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››› il-ħidma tkompli maltatoday survey Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 9 Labour retains absolute majority TIMELINE 41.7%

Feb March April 3 May 31 May June 46.5% No answer 44.4% 43.1% 41.7% 35.4% 33.3 29% 27.4 27.7% 26.3% PL 24.9% 25.5% 24.7% 27.3

18.7% 19.9% 17% 15% PN PN 10.6% 11.7% 6.9% 7.3% 6.8% 7.8 Not voting 2.8% 2.7% 2.7% 3.6 AD 1.7% 1.8% 0.3 AN Others

former PN voters will be vot- vote PN in 2008, and 37% who didate will be elected. ing for the PL this time around, voted Labour. Former Labour MP Joseph 2% of former Labour voters will Cuschieri has seen his support switch sides to PN. Casa and Cuschieri increase from 4% to 11% of de- This is an indication that make inroads clared Labour voters, edging Labour is not only benefiting Nationalist incumbent David closer to frontrunners Louis from apathy among Nationalist Casa has seen his support in- Grech and star candidate Ed- mt survey voters, but has also made small crease from 2.8% to 7.1% of de- ward Scicluna, and slightly inroads among PN voters. clared PN voters in the last week ahead of newcomer Marlene Former Nationalist voters con- of the campaign, surpassing Mizzi. Methodology stitute 72.2% of AD’s current Roberta Metsola Tedesco Tric- While Scicluna has seen a A total of 1127 respondents were randomly selected. Of level of support – a clear indi- cas who follows at 4.1%. slight drop in support since last these 720 accepted to be interviewed. The results were cation that the green vote con- But with the support of 53.1% week, incumbent Louis Grech weighted to reflect the age/sex balance of the popula- tributed to the GonziPN elec- of declared PN voters, front- has increased support from 10% tion as represented in the latest demographic review. The toral victory in 2008. runner and campaign architect to 12%. The other incumbent, survey has a margin of error of +/-3.65. The survey was Simon Busuttil remains by far John Attard-Montalto, has fall- Although the vote was evenly conducted between Wednesday 20th May and Wednesday split in the last general election, the most popular candidate. His en to fifth place among Labour’s 42% of the MaltaToday sample second preferences are likely to contenders. 27th May. was made up of people who determine which other PN can-

THIS IS A PAID ADVERT Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday 21

Some Mothers do have 'em

IT IS YOUR DUTY TO VOTE IN THE EUROPEAN ELECTION

BECAUSE over 80% of our laws come from the EU and we all pay contributions to the EU budget

BECAUSE the European Parliament is the only EU institution that directly represents you

BECAUSE if you dont stand up and be counted you will be ignored

BECAUSE you need someone who can safeguard your interests at a European level

This Saturday Vote for ACTION Sharon Ellul Bonici www.sharon4malta.com Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday 13

"Naf lil Louis Grech f'diversi "Lil Louis nipparagunah "Louis Grech huwa wieħed karigi fuq livell eżekuttiv tal- ma’ arloġġ Rolex ta’ veru, mil l-aqwa esponenti pajjiż. Rajniħ jaħdem tajjeb jaħdem il-ħin kollu, ma li għana fil-parlament ħafna fuq diversi issues jieqaf qatt, ma tisimgħux ewropow. Jien nixtieq li din għal pajjiżna, fosthom, il- jaħdem, u jtik rizultati il ħbiberija li għandu Louis kwistjoni ta’ l-immigrazzjoni kontinwi. Louis għamel lejn il-poplu laburista u illegali, il-VAT tal-karozzi ħafna kisbiet ﬁl-Parlament l-poplu Malti nirripagawha u anke il-kwistjoni li Ewropew. Minkejja li billi natuħ vot tajjeb, vot tolqot fil-qrib in-nisa, dik għandna team kbir, l-istess b’saħħtu, vot li tagħmlu ċert tal-maternity leave." bħall-inbid, inħarsu lejn li Louis ikun wieħed mill- Onor. Marie Louise Coleiro Preca, MP Louis u mmorru għall- membri parlamentari." aħjar fost l-aqwa." Onor. Owen Bonnici MP Onor. Leo Brincat MP

"Ta kontribut qawwi, tant "Jiena naħseb li fuq Louis "Nafuh għall-kontribut li l-kuntatti li għandi jien Grech m’hemm x’tgħid importanti li ta f'dak li għadhom isemmuh sal-lum. xejn għaliex ir-rizultati għandu x'jaqsam mar- Louis kien wieħed fost dawk jitkellmu weħidhom. F’kull refund tal-vat fuq ir- li dejjem ix-xogħol li għamel, qasam li kien fih Louis reġistrazzjoni tal-vetturi. għamlu tajjeb. Persważ illi Grech kien suċċess." Aħna nafu li b'inizjattiva jekk jerġa jitla, kif nawguralu Onor. Helena Dalli MP tiegħu fil-Parlament u naħseb li se jerġa jitla, Ewropew kienu ħarġu ċerti jagħti kontribut lil Malta "Kellu viżjoni, dejjem jaf fatti li ma konniex nafu." u jagħmel ġieħ lil Malta." fejn u kif irid jasal, dejjem Onor. Gavin Gulia MP Lino Spiteri, ex-ministru tal-finanzi wettqu, qatt ma qatgħa qalbu mill-ostakoli. Dejjem kien leader tajjeb ħafna. Deċizzjonijiet jeħodhom u jeħodhom sew." Ħaddiema ta’ l-Airmalta

›››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››››› LOUIS GRECH KAP TADDELEGAZZJONI LABURISTA FILPARLAMENT EWROPEW 18 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 opinion Transcript from a European election debate

Gonzi dahak bik! were at best paranoid, at worst clichés and cheap jibes, so he - U intom x’ghamiltu, ma completely misguided. And too has given into the tempta- dhaktux bin-nies intom? if there is one factor which tion to play the simplistic game - Nerga’ nirrepeti, Gonzi dahak proves that Europe hasn’t had being played all around him. bil-poplu Malti u Ghawdxi! the slightest effect on Malta’s Arnold Cassola, who is cogent - Ghalqu dawn il-hotels: A, B, way of doing things – on its and clear, has done his best to C u D. identity – then that must be get his message across without - Iss, iva, imma trid tghidilna the way guests (even some falling into the simplistic or Leaving Europe kemm fethu in the meantime. of its supposedly illustrious populist trap. to career - Ghandek il-figuri, Chris? ones) behave on talk shows on Europe is about so much “ - Staqsi lil Vince, dak jafhom local television. more than what this disap- il-figuri. The discussion may be tack- pointing electoral campaign politicians - Lilek qed nistaqsi, wegibni! ling European Parliament has made it out to be. It is - Jien ghidtlek ghalqu l-hotels elections with a selection of about so much more than ahna and chancers taht GonziPN. MEP hopefuls, but the whole and intom, than pressing the - Wegibni! business has a ring to it which right buttons and ‘defending was always - Xoghol! is miles away from anything Malta’s interests at all costs’. - Mhux vera. David Friggieri remotely European. It’s still It is certainly about more than going to yield - Ambjent! all intom and ahna, mhux the infantile ‘ibghatu messagg - Immigrazzjoni! vera and u zgur li vera, gdibtu lil Gonzi’. One only needed to us diminishing - Sahha! qas dhalna fl-EU and ghidna l-verità. When the tune into Rai’s European elec- - Pawza qasira ghar-riklami. - Ippermettili, jien ma nter- discussion moves away from tion debates to see what Europe returns Nirringrazzjaw lil W, X, Y, Z... rompejtekx. Mela... the usual cheap insults and is also about. Old battle horse - Ergajna lura fl-istudjo. - L-Ewropa rridu nibghatu actually manages to engage Marco Pannella, was yesterday - Gonzi dahak bin-nies... nies kapaci... with a couple of token issues, engaging with secularism, Im- - Il-Laburisti lanqas jafu jag- - Jekk joghogbok, tinterrompi- it does so in a superficial way: manuel Kant, Europe’s roots, hfsu l-buttuni. Inkonsistenti. nix... ahna vvutajna b’mod konsist- Altiero Spinelli’s legacy, politi- - (Dahka ironika) - (NB: angry, tense faces enti, ktibna rapport, nwieghdu cal theory, xenophobia and im- - Nista’ nurik dar-rapport, ha throughout) li nressqu mozzjoni. migration. arah. There are, thank God, one or But Malta’s writers, truly inde- - Mhux dak ir-rapport trid two exceptions. Simon Busuttil pendent journalists, research- turihom lin-nies, dan trid turi- Five years after Malta reluc- is a convincing orator who has ers, intellectuals and artists hom. tantly squeezed into the Euro- an unparalleled knowledge of must decide to engage in order - GonziPN ghadu jidhak bin- pean Union, it should have be- his directives, facts and figures. to stop the rot. Leaving Europe nies, ehe. Arroganti. come amply clear that all those But by and large, he too has to career politicians and chanc- - Ha nghidlek minn dahak bin- fears about losing our identity had to keep afloat in a sea of ers was always going to yield us nies. Kieku kien ghalikom lan- to some hegemonistic monster incoherent thoughts, mindless diminishing returns. The book trade, Malta and the EU

uring a PBS televised Meanwhile, while Malta is be- current Nobel Prize laureate, Maltese publishers who have during this European ing flooded by books arriving Jean-Marie Gustave le Clézio managed to improve their prod- DParliament electoral from overseas, at times bought spoke clearly about information uct content and presentation by campaign, when representing by the cubic metre, from ware- poverty: great personal efforts remark- the Labour Party, I mentioned houses in the United Kingdom, “Joint publication with develop- ably, are absent from meetings how the government had lost Maltese writers, publishers and ing countries, the establishment when purchasing orders are tak- all its willpower in ensuring booksellers have to strive through of funds for lending libraries en. Any student of the science of that Malta was represented in their own efforts to remain active and mobile libraries, and, over- librarianship would know that the European fora of the cul- since their limited run of copies all, greater attention to requests publications regarding Maltese tural industry where important printed keeps their price per unit from and works in so-called literature, archaeology, ethnog- decisions were being taken. relatively much more expensive. minority languages – which raphy, culture and history are of In the debate I referred to the This government, despite its are often clearly in the major- European, and not only local, in- publishing trade, a massive eco- false pretences that it is an inter- ity – would enable literature to terest. Rather than proposing a nomic sector that generates nationalist approach, remains co- continue to be this wonderful reading culture, Malta under the around €23 billion in annual cooned with an insular approach tool for self-knowledge, for the Gonzi administration is being sales. The European industry Steve Borg since the key players in these fora discovery of others, and for lis- inundated by gaming and gam- revolves on three entities – the do not seem able to think outside tening to the concert of human- bling centres that seemed to be European Writers’ Congress the box. Let us take, for example, kind, in all the rich variety of its sprouting everywhere. You can (EWC), the Federation of Euro- segment to our shores. Eurostat the Finnish writer Arto Tapio themes and modulations.” witness these sad developments pean Booksellers (FEP) and the statistics, however, expose our Paasilinna, whose works have He could have easily been even in the remote villages away European Booksellers Federation sad reality. been translated into eighteen speaking about Malta. The from the tourist resorts. (EBF). Most EU27 countries are An excellent Maltese language languages. Or the Slovene play- apologists, even though deep The local situation is pitiful members in all three, including publication – and they are more wright Ivan Cankar, translated down they are aware that this is and undermines the spirit of Cyprus, Estonia and Slovenia numerous than one may think - into seventeen languages. We actual reality, would definitely the Treaty of Lisbon that aims that all gained EU membership may have a run of two thousand all have a right to enquire the state that I am exaggerating. to further disseminate liter- with the Malta group. The only copies, that could possibly be role of the government’s contact However, following a number ary works from all over Europe Member State absent from all fo- sold within two years. I shud- points doing in this regard. of parliamentary questions, it is throughout the EU27. As a pro- ra is Malta. This is an unaccept- der when I realise that Malta is In my profession as a librarian, now public knowledge that the spective Labour MEP, I shall able situation, especially when losing the opportunity, through I have met many a decision-tak- Government’s voted expendi- strive to see that Malta becomes one remembers that Malta has being absent from the major ing government-appointed bu- ture for books for 2008 includes a member of these entities, since the highest illiteracy rate within European book expositions, of reaucrat, who seem to be unable the purchase of ten books for this proactive approach would the EU. exhibiting literary works by lo- to distinguish a clay brick from Senglea, nine for St. Julians and result in more royalties, book On state and Nationalist party cal writers, photographers and a hardbound book. The Castle six for Cospicua, amongst other orders for exportation, help dis- television, we are given the im- graphic designers, that may be may be the name of a pub in shameful data. This attitude seminate our people’s intellec- pression that, thanks to this translated in other European Paceville and not one of Kafka’s taken into context would then tual prowess and naturally gen- government, Malta quite natu- Union languages. This would masterpieces, and what a pity qualify when the Maltese book erate more employment in the rally utilizes the most compe- help disseminate their works about Virgil and Schopenhauer. trade is simply absent from the local publishing industry. tent human resources available into new territories and also in- Do they play for Milan or Inter? European fora. Our key players that shall help advance this increase their meagre local royal- In an interview published on are simply disinterested or ob- Steve Borg is a PL candidate dustry by attracting a market ties. The Guardian (8 Dec 2008) the lique to this market. for MEP opinion Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 11 POINTS OF VIEW

MaltaToday asks prominent personalities and opinion formers to comment on the campaign themes

Julian Vassallo tion adopted by the Maltese Par- introduced it will be partly up to liament is simply implementing our MEPs to reduce them or seek European EU law which has been adopted support or compensation. in the European Parliament. So 9. They will be considered the Parliament office, we need MEPs who can shape EU MEPs representing us, the Mal- legislation to Malta’s advantage tese people, whether we vote for Malta in the EP before it is passed down them or not. We owe it to our- for implementation when it is too It will make selves and we owe it to Europe to PEOPLE may have their legiti- late. send people who can represent mate reasons to stay home on 6. The EP has important budg- us with dignity and with energy. June 6th but the idea that it will etary powers, which will cover “a difference They will be charged to fight our not make a difference either way the whole of the EU budget in- corner but also to contribute to cannot be one of them. Who we cluding structural funds if the whether or the construction of Europe. We choose to represent us will make Lisbon treaty comes into force. might have joined the project late a difference, and here is why: In the years when Malta moves not we vote in the day but we have the same 1. There is no doubt that all the closer to the average EU income opportunity to forge its future candidates do not share the same problems that have a European and its right to large-scale fund- with our own ideas and initia- policies and qualities. Staying solution. ing becomes less obvious Malta because if we tives. Is it not time for us to make home means that your neighbour 4. EU citizenship bestows nu- will need representatives that en- our mark? Surely, whether and gets to choose what policies and merous economic, political and sure that we get all that it is due do not there how we do so will depend on the qualities your representatives social rights upon us that govern- and not a penny less. calibre of whom we choose to will have. ment is obliged to guarantee. It 7. Even five years after mem- represent us. 2. Being an effective MEP is not may well be that not all of those bership there is still more work will be no one 10. Finally, it will make a dif- an easy job. If you want people rights have been fully and cor- to be done to familiarise all EU ference whether or not we vote able to put Malta’s concerns on rectly implemented in Maltese institutions with the needs and to voice our because if we do not there will the table and convince their po- law and practice. Our MEPs can aspirations of the Maltese; with be no one to voice the con- litical groups to heed them, their play a central role in ensuring the strengths and vulnerabilities concerns cerns and air the disgruntle- Committees to endorse their that we enjoy all the protection, of our economy; with the peculi- ment that might be tempting proposals and the EP as a whole benefits and opportunities that arity of our culture and the fibre us to abstain. There will be to include them, choose carefully. EU citizenship bestows. Not all of our society. But you cannot de- no one to voice our aspira- Not everybody is up to it. candidates will be equally effec- fend the interests and aspirations strain and our current usage tions and our vision of where we 3. The EP Election is not an- tive at playing that role. of a country and a people you do of this planet’s resources is no want more Europe and where we other version of “who wants to 5. Yes, the laws and regulations not know well. Not every candi- longer considered sustainable. might want less. It makes a dif- be a millionaire”, but our MEPs that seem to have the most direct date will have the same ability to The next five years are likely to ference because if we do not vote will have the funds and facilities and immediate impact on our see the implications for Malta in see bold action in the EP and our interests will be defended by to hire staff and run Offices in lives seem to emanate from na- each new piece of legislation, and elsewhere addressing these chal- precisely nobody. Malta and Brussels. We need to tional authorities and not from more importantly, the ability to lenges. Maltese MEPs capable of choose candidates that will place the European Parliament. But turn them into opportunities for getting down to the nitty-gritty Dr Vassallo is head of those facilities at our service as this is often misleading because Malta. of things can ensure that the the European Parliament citizens – to answer our queries depending on how you calculate 8. We live in uncertain times. solutions chosen match our par- representation in Malta and obtain solutions to those it, more or less half all the legisla- Our economies are under heavy ticular needs. If new burdens are

Astrid Vella servation than Malta, where we future generations to unsustain- tourism and the very same prop- dispose of treated sewage and able buildings as well as more en- erty industry. Still both of the Flimkien ghal storm water to into the sea. Abu- ergy and water problems. large parties have failed to com- sive borehole pumping has been Environment NGOs have remit themselves to anything on Ambjent Ajhar rampant for years, with the repeatedly raised the issue of the issues of over-development, sult that the aquifer has been damaging revision of the Envi- stating that they will rely on AS our MEPs fight it out at the depleted and. in certain areas, ronment Impact Assessment lo- MEPA guidelines which have polls, many of their voters feel polluted. cal regulations which allow the proven to be extremely weak that their work at a European In spite of Malta’s much-pub- approval of large and potentially up to now. level has little relevance to our licised lead in climate change damaging projects in Malta. Much of the problem boils lives if local politicians are un- ye a r s a go, we h ave w a s t e d ye a r s This reflects the fact that all gov- down to the funding of the po- able or unwilling to have Malta before beginning to tackle the ernments for the last fifty years litical parties which are bank- conform to European standards matter, which is still not being have viewed the building indus- rolled by the large developers. on a number of basic and very handled in a holistic manner try as a main economic driver This is another issue which our important issues that are crucial by ensuring energy stability and the protection of developers’ MEPs should press their re- to the well-being of the citizens our high levels of asthma, heart and security through the tap- interests has always come before spective parties to conform to of the Maltese islands, such as disease and cancer. ping of a number of different that of residents and the environ- EU political party regulation, pollution and water as well as As regards noise pollution, if we sources of alternative energy. ment, as well as seriously damag- making full declaration man- clean and affordable energy. can’t even regulate noise abate- What’s more, we are being ing our tourist industry. In fact, datory over €500 and no do- The latest data on air pollution ment in the construction site presented with a series of en- the recent revamp of the MEPA nations allowed over €12,000. shows that Malta is in breach of regulations, how can we expect ergy-related reports which are website is yet again tailored to Until full accountability and EU regulations and the situa- to dictate such matters to our not only late in their prepara- suit developers and not the pub- transparency is established tion on certain pollutants is de- European counterparts. tion but also sometimes con- lic. in party funding, the issue of teriorating instead of improving. Management plans are still flicting (MRA Energy Policy, The EU is beginning to tackle over-development will remain Studies have shown that much missing in a number of im- CCC Strategy, MRRA Wind issues of over-development and unresolved, with the attendant of this is traffic-related and yet portant sectors, notably water, Farm reports, Enemalta Power even locally it has been recog- deterioration in the quality of calls for decisive action to clamp where Malta ranked no 172 in a Station contract). nised that by continuing to in- life of the Maltese population. down on offenders have for years UN rating of water resources in Similarly, EU Minimum Energy crease the supply of residential gone unheeded, while the popu- 180 countries. Even countries Efficiency Regulations which be- properties on our small overbuilt Astrid Vella is a lation continues to inhale toxic bordering the Sahara have been came law in January 2007 are still island, we are inevitably damag- spokesperson for Flimkien emissions which contribute to more successful in water con- not being enforced, condemning ing the natural environment, ghal Ambjent Ahjar 14 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news Attard-Montalto gives partial disclosure of MEP salary til was the first Maltese MEP der the 2009 reforms, all MEPs small snack and I almost al- Montalto said he requested MATTHEW VELLA to successfully push through will now receive the same sal- ways eat at the hotel, usually to pay his pension contribu- a party motion that will bind ary of €7,000 every month. in my room. The cost depends tion separately from his salary LABOUR MEP John Attard Nationalist MEPs to audit their However, he did not indicate on what one orders but a three- but the EP turned down the Montalto yesterday present- accounts and publish them on the total of daily allowances he course meal consisting of pasta, request due to administrative ed MaltaToday with a partial their website. received, which have ranged steak or fish, fruit and a carafe procedures. breakdown of his earnings “I’m ready, along with the sup- from €262 per sitting in 2004, equivalent to two glasses of lo- He operated five offices in in the last five years, the first port of one of my colleagues, to to €298 in 2008. To qualify for cal wine amounts to €60.” Malta and Gozo over the past Maltese MEP to offer a glimpse present a parliamentary motion these allowances, an MEP must decade, which are now down into his lucrative earnings. to bind all MEPs to publicise sign the register for a commit- Travel to three. He received a month- He announced he would sub- their earnings. I think we are tee, delegation or group meet- MEPs are also given a lump- ly allowance since 2004 that mit his yearly MEPs accounts obliged to show what we earn, ing; and in the case of the ple- sum, equivalent to the highest ranged from €3,700 to €4,202 for audit, and would publish and we are in a position to set nary, sign-in and vote in at least economy fare, together with a to pay for rent, maintenance, them in MaltaToday – two an example,” Attard Montalto 50% of the roll-call votes. “distance allowance” for trav- telecommunications, cleaning, weeks before publishing them told MaltaToday. MEPs usually can earn up to elling. Distance allowance is and transport. on his website. Extrapolations from the an additional €60,000 annually based on the distance in km Attard-Montalto rightly de- He is the only Labour MEP to MEP’s partial disclosure shows by claiming most of these al- from Malta International Air- scribed the pension fund as a have made this pledge, while Malta’s MEPs can earn up to lowances. port to Brussels/Strasbourg – “very good opportunity” – un- Nationalist MEP Simon Busut- €100,000 in annual salaries, Attard Montalto gave no to- which stands at 4314/3532 km doubtedly given the generous apart from havingg travel, of- tals for his taxi usage, subsi- correspondinglycorrespondingly for a return payout it guarantees MEPs well fices and assistants’assistants’ salaries dized by the EP at €50 per trip. trip. Payments area only made after the end of their parlia- fully subssubsidised.idised. “I have not been able to acquire upon the presentationpresen of the mentary career. AccoAccordingrding to the the total amount of taxis but I original boardingboardi passes by “Because of the recent finan- ininformationnformation hardly used the service to and MEPs.MEPs. cial crisis Parliament itself has supplieds from the airport as I do not Attard-MontaltoAttard-Montalt said MEPs had to guarantee the fund and byb Attard- usuallyusually travel on Sunday,Sunday, when had an agreementagreem with Air change certain conditions. Montalto,M the parliamentary service is Malta for a club-classcl seat, The age of entitlement has overo the past not available. This also applies “provided that wew book in ad- been raised and the procedure fifiveive years he for travel to the parliament as vance” at the raterate of €544, taxes whereby members can take the wass paid an I almost always use parliamen- and charges included.incl He only opportunity of a lump-sum has averageaveerage an- tary services. paid more than thist amount on been abolished. Technically nualnuual salary – “On the other hand, I usually three occasions. the portion which is paid by equivalentequivalent use a taxi service (which is re- Attard-MontaltoAttard-Montalt said he the MEP and which used to be to that of imbursed)imbursed) from parliamentparliament to claimed a distancedista allowance deducted from the allowance a Mal- the hotel when I used to reside from Brussels thatth ranged from known as the office expendi- tese MP in Sheraton Place Rogier, since €510 per return flight in 2004, ture had to be reimbursed by – of some I usually prefer to continue up to €559 in 2008.20 Consider- the Member for use in office €17,500.€117,500. In working late whilst the service ing that MEPs makem at least one expenditure to be used in ac- total,tootal, he ac- closes down at 9:30pm. Regard- return trip a weekwe during the cordance with the allowance cumulatedc umulated ing the use of taxis to other greater part of theth year, except above-referred to as office ex- €87,850€87,850 over destinations I doubt whether I in summer, Malta’sMal MEPs can penditure.” thethhe past five have made use of this service earn anything upu to €21,200 years. Un- moremore thanthan threethree to fourfour timestimes every year just forf a “distance Employees a year.” allowance” – aapart from all Attard-Montalto received a The MEP said most MEPs travel costs beingbeing subsidized. monthly allowance ranging choose to rent or buy apart- “As can be establishede the from €12,576 to €17,540 be- ments and use the dailydaily allow- lump-sumlump-sum is higherhi than the tween 2004-2009 to pay staff ance to pay the mortgage. “In actual cost, mostlymos due to the salaries. His staff compliment my case I have chosen to live in distance allowance,”allowa Attard- in 2008 consisted of 11 person- hotels. I was able to get favour- Montalto said. nel, comprising a full-time as- able rates because I undertook But in the nextne legislature, sistant and consultant in Brus- to stay for minimum terms.” payment will bebe made on the sels, eight assistants in Malta, Attard-Montalto said he paid actualactual costcost of thethe ticket. Attard- and a service provider to en- €130-140 per night to stay the Montalto also claimedc €3,736 sure compliance of employees Brussels’ Sheraton, and then for travel abroadabroad to attend con- and consultants. €169 per night since March ferences and seminarssem in 2005 He only provided a breakdown 2009 to stay in the Radis- (the full entitlement),entitle €3,555 of income and expenditure for son SAS. He paidpaid €179 to in 2006 (from a maximum the months of January, July and stay in the Holiday Inn of €3,826), just €920 in 2007 December 2008 – for example, Strasbourg. (from a maximummaximu of €3,895), in January, he received €15,496 He added that the and €2,575 out ofo a maximum which he used to pay salaries rate does not in- entitlement of €4,000€4 in 2008. and consultancies (€13,743); clude breakfast. He made no claimsc on the €1,602 in social security and “I do not cocomputermputer and llanguagea learn- tax; €732 for staff travel. normally ing funds availaavailableb to MEPs to eat lunch, enhance compcomputerut literacy and Visitors’ programme per- language skills. The MEP also made use of a haps a €535 per person allowance paid Pension cacashsh by the EP to invite 100 visitors Attard-MontaAttard-Montaltolt is also a every year to Brussels. This is member of the European Par- usually used to fund flights and liament’s extrextremelyem lucrative hotels for constituents to tour pension fund. the European Parliament and Each monthmonthlyl contribution pay them a trip to Brussels for is directldirectlyy ddeducted from three nights. the office allowancea paid “The programme we prepare to MEPsME by the Par- for the group consists of in- liliament,am and the formation visits to EU institu- EP also matches tions as well as a visit outside Labour MEP John Attard-Montalto said he will submit ttheir contribu- Brussels, usually to Bruges. his accounts for audit and publish them in MaltaToday ttion by twice On most occasions the visitors and on his website every year the amount. are activists who have either The cash helped me in my political cam- goes into a paign and/or delegates selected pension fund by their respective committees. registered In addition I have taken the op- in Luxem- portunity to offer band clubs, bourg. sports clubs etc. to select visi- Attard- tors.” 20 maltatoday election special | Thursday 04 June 2009 news Concerned stakeholders confront PM cant awaiting MEPA permits, prices.” DAVID DARMANIN Portelli said when it comes to De Cesare was alluding to granting of change of use per- an NSO statistic showing that EXPLOITING a face-to-face mits, “MEPA takes longer to hotels and catering establish- opportunity with the Prime issue permits than the gesta- ments in Malta witnessed an Minister at a business break- tion period of a mare.” 11% price hike – a datum the fast yesterday at Villa Arrigo Replying to Portelli’s com- MHRA publicly rubbished in San Pawl Tat-Targa, social plaints, Gonzi agreed and said shortly after it was released by partners and prominent mem- he was “waiting for EP elections the NSO. bers of the business commu- to be over before I announce But when Gonzi launched nity vented their frustrations the measures earmarked for the PN manifesto a couple of with Lawrence Gonzi, in a bid the MEPA reform.” weeks ago, he mentioned in to send government a message On his part, Public Transport passing that restaurant prices days before the impending EP Association president Victor in Malta remain unacceptable. elections. Spiteri solicited Gonzi’s inter- “This information is not true,” PN candidate Frank Portelli vention because of the manner de Cesare said, “and our mem- himself intervened with a long Transport Minister Austin bers feel very hurt by such re- list of complaints on MEPA re- Gatt is handling the ongoing marks. We stand accused of ceived from constituents, call- transport reform. inflation and this warrants a ing on the Prime Minister to “Thousands of workers de- clarification from your end.” bring about an “earthquake” pend on public transport,” Spi- In reaction, Gonzi said he rather than the overdue prom- teri said. “While we were con- was surprised when he saw the ise of a reform at the author- sulted on the reform with the Tell me what’s nagging you - Gonzi gets an early morning earful. Also in report published by the NSO, the picture are, from left, GWU secretary-general Tony Zarb, Forestals ity. preceding minister (Jesmond Group chairman Tancred Tabone and PN candidate Edward Demicoli “but I must bow my head to “Some businesses in Malta Mugliett), we are now being whatever the NSO publishes.” depend on the construction left out of discussions. As you Gonzi however suggested industry to survive, and as know, we met this particular ter replied, “You are doing the service.” an impending reform in the you know, construction de- Minister yesterday but the right thing in expressing the Some members in attend- NSO’s data-compiling meth- pends on that blessed MEPA only thing he was interested concerns of your members be- ance broke into applause upon odology, attributing the re- which you are responsible for,” in was to negotiate a package cause you are doing your duty, hearing Gonzi’s last remark. sults being off the mark to the Portelli said. “Mr Prime Min- to get us out of his way. I am but then I must do mine. Al- It was MHRA President NSO reading “rack rates – the ister, we don’t need a reform asking for your intervention though there is space for more Kevin de Cesare’s turn to ad- prices quoted by the hotels, at MEPA. We need an earth- in this matter because neither discussion, I don’t agree with dress the Prime Minister with and not those charged.” quake. You must set deadlines the thousands of people em- you that there is no consulta- his grievances. “Maybe the method needs to for applications, because it is ployed in the sector, nor the tion. Our challenge is to abide “The problems facing the be refined,” Gonzi said. “And not acceptable that goalposts rest of the population deserve by European rules, and al- tourism industry cannot all be the NSO will be proposing new keep changing before permits a repeat story of what we went though we tried avoiding issu- attributed to government, but methodologies to the MCESD. are granted, causing serious through last July.” ing a tender, the EU did not al- the situation is dire,” he said. If these are accepted we’ll go delays in application proc- Gonzi disagreed with Spiteri low us. It is within your rights “We are now faced with flawed ahead with them. But I agree esses.” about the Association not be- to ask for my intervention but information being used to in- with Kevin de Cesare.” After quoting an application ing consulted. then it is also within my rights dicate that hotels and restau- number of an aggrieved appli- “Victor,” the Prime Minis- to ask you to provide a good rants in Malta are raising their [email protected] editorial Thursday 04 June 2009 | maltatoday election special 19

An election without oomph

IT may not have been a memo- bour, even if the party wins a he has repeatedly sought to though it remains to be seen by elections became less visceral rable campaign, but by all ac- majority of seats. downplay the implications of what precise margin. Our poll and divisive in the new context counts it was unusual. If noth- For this reason, Muscat has Saturday’s result for the local today suggests an abstention of EU membership. Of course, ing else, because one essential approached this election as political scenario. But at the rate of around 7.8%, but in prac- it is debatable whether he will ingredient has to date been though it were his own be-all same time, he cannot afford tice it is likely to be considera- relish being vindicated, at the missing: election fever. and end-all. European issues to be entirely dismissive, as a bly higher, given the amount of expense of his own party’s Unlike last year’s general elec- have been largely absent from perceived lack of interest on his voters who are still undecided. standing. Nor can this par- tion – and arguably every other the Labour campaign, which part may serve to diminish the A clearer indication is provid- ticular campaign be taken as a election before that – there was instead has focused on matters importance of the European ed by the sheer quantity of un- precursor to the next general no discernable surge of popular of purely popular concern. In Parliament in the eyes of the collected voting documents. At election, where the stakes will enthusiasm in the dying days of a reversal of roles from March electorate. the time of writing, this stood no doubt be higher. the campaign. Events have on 2008 – when the Nationalist As the party that took Malta at over 19,000: almost double But the indications nonethe- the whole been low-key: small Party had pinned all its hopes into Europe in the first place, the corresponding statistic less point towards a gradual corner meetings in Gozo, “taht on the persona of its leader – and which still accuses the PL of for the 2004 election. Barring decrease in political hysteria in it-tinda” discussions here and the Labour Party has left no harbouring an anti-EU stance, a last-minute change of heart the years to come, and maybe there... no major mass meetings stone unturned to discredit the Nationalist Party cannot by around 10,000 voters, (the even the beginning of a slow of the kind we normally associ- the “GonziPN” motif, with a realistically depreciate the EU, deadline is midnight tonight), tailing off in the otherwise ate with election campaigns, al- billboard campaign almost ex- without also undermining its the number of uncollected doc- complete dominance of politi- though Labour came close with clusively targeting the Prime own credibility in the process. uments will almost certainly be cal parties in our daily lives. its “mass rally” at Ta’ Qali last Minister in person, as a man These two opposing forces much, much higher than usual. And when all is said and done, Sunday. who has “lost control” of the have therefore combined to Nowhere is this shortfall more that may not be such a bad In fact, what emerges at a cur- country. make the PN’s campaign a keenly felt than in the north thing after all. sory glance is that the PL took Irrelevant to the European somewhat half-hearted affair, of the island – a fact which this election considerably more theme, perhaps; but clearly the conspicuously less punchy and strongly suggests that the PN seriously than the PN. This is stakes for Labour are higher effective than Labour’s. All will suffer the most on account entirely understandable: it is than a majority of seats in Brus- things told, a far cry from the of voter abstention. after all the first major elec- sels and Strasbourg. PN’s usual approach to general Ironically, then, it seems that toral challenge for incoming Over to the PN side of things, elections, which are tradition- former Prime Minister Eddie MALTATODAY MIDWEEK, leader Joseph Muscat, less than and by the same token, an ab- ally fought on a “winner takes Fenech Adami is slowly being MEDIATODAY LTD, VJAL IR-RIHAN, SAN GWANN SGN 9016 18 months after his predeces- solute majority for Labour will all” basis. So in a sense, one can proved right in his prediction, MANAGING DIRECTOR: ROGER de GIORGIO sor lost a general election by a certainly be interpreted as a hardly be surprised that the some years back, that Maltese MANAGING EDITOR: SAVIOUR BALZAN whisker. Muscat therefore has massive defeat for the party in electorate appears to have lost politics would “calm down” af- EDITOR: RAPHAEL VASSALLO a point to prove: anything less government. This in turn may interest this time round. ter EU accession. Tel: (356) 21 382741-3, 21 382745-6 than an absolute majority of help to explain Gonzi’s curi- Indeed, indications point The architect of Malta’s EU Fax: (356) 21 385075 first-count votes can arguably ously ambivalent approach to heavily towards a decline in bid had even predicted an even- www.maltatoday.com.mt be described as a defeat for La- this election: on the one hand, voter participation since 2004, tual drop in voter turnout, as [email protected]