IHBC SW Bulletin 29 MJ Final 170715
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IHBC South West Region covering: Avon, Cornwall, Devon, Dorset, Gloucestershire, Scilly Isles, Somerset & Wiltshire SW Bulletin No. 29 - July 2015 Regional Training News Looking Forward: A better deal for all of our heritage? Your Bulletin is much later than scheduled Well, the General Election has come and gone and the various manifestos made for a variety of reasons which I won’t bore passing references to the built environment without anything specific about you with! The good news is that we have run two successful training events so far heritage. So nothing new there although the period of ‘stability’ which we are now this year and have others in the pipeline. entering gives a key opportunity to lobby Government for more essential funding for urgent repairs and buildings at risk, better protection, improved interpretation Despite the showers and wind, 19 May and so forth. The heritage of this country, its overall setting and sheer diversity are saw over 40 delegates attending the the envy of the world and explain why so many visitors flock to see it. Visitor Conservation of Traditional Thatch day at numbers to the UK in 2014 are estimated to be in excess of 34 million, spending South Petherton, Somerset. This was a over £21 bn. The heritage ‘boost’ to these figures cannot be insignificant and joint event organised by the IHBC and surely warrants a proportionate return from Government in helping ensure that Historic England, with specialist speakers our heritage continues to ‘attract’ and be maintained into the bargain. The New from the thatching industry and practical Statesman goes one step further and calls for the restoration of the demonstrations of the various materials. Ministry for Tourism and Heritage. I’ll vote for that! Malcolm James An illustrated write-up of the day will appear in Bulletin 30. Many thanks to Greg Anyone for Tea? Venn for organising the event and negotiating highly competitive rates! A recent addition to the statutory list is and the paintings had been lightly the former tea room at Priding Farm cleaned to remove surface dirt. Highcliffe Castle in Dorset was the setting overlooking the lower reaches of the for a June tour of this fascinating Grade I River Severn near Arlingham in listed ‘Picturesque’ building which is Gloucestershire. currently undergoing major restoration works. James Webb laid on a packed Dating from circa 1910, the modest schedule which allowed delegates to ‘go single-storey timber-framed structure behind the scenes’ and comment on the standing on a brick plinth features a conservation methodology for the series of painted panels of named Victorian kitchen and historic panelling. topographical, marine, genre and botanical subjects in oil, with a wax top Surface treatments provide an essential varnish. Structures of this type built ingredient of the historic environment exclusively for leisure and recreational One of the painted panels depicting a which is all too often overlooked. The purposes are comparatively rare; more topographical scene; possibly St Mary’s at SPAB and Historic England are partnering so when the delicate nature and nearby Fretherne with Saul (as enlarged on a research project that will investigate 1857-59 by Francis Niblett) © Historic England originality of the interior decoration the survival, care and repair of cobbled scheme are factored in. pathways in Devon; in order to define The former tea room is listed Grade II best-practice guidance for their ongoing and has list entry no. 1422531: care, as well as tackling associated access The Grade II listed farmhouse and and safety issues. The project findings will ancillary buildings had been the subject be presented at a conference to be held in of a photographic survey by English http://list.historicengland.org.uk/ resultsingle.aspx?uid=1422531 Exeter on 27 November 2015. Bookings Heritage in 1997, some time after the can be made through the SPAB: tea room structure fell into disrepair. Subsequent inspection in 2014 revealed NB. Access to the site is restricted but https://www.spab.org.uk/spab-events- the structure much better maintained, the structure can be seen from the awards/events Severn Way footpath. Tel. 0207 456 0915 Malcolm James IHBC SW Bulletin No.29 July 2015 - page 1 Regional Planning Matters Planning Appeal: Regents Circus, prominence and siting of the proposed Planning Appeal: Land at Swindon, Wilts. SN1 3DQ kiosk would detract from the openness of Longleat, Swindon Village, (APP/U3925/A/13/2204424) the area and thereby negatively affect the Cheltenham, Gloucestershire setting. (APP/F1610/A/13/2203411) A number of Prior Approval applications for some telephone kiosks were applied The appeal was dismissed on the grounds The Swindon Village Conservation Area for under Part 24 of Schedule 2 to the that the proposed development would be forms an outlying part of Cheltenham Town and Country Planning (General “harmful to the character and appearance Borough which is largely urban, and on Permitted Development) Order 1995 to of the area and would fail to preserve the land that forms part of the setting of enable Swindon Borough Council to setting of the listed building” as stated Swindon Hall; a Grade II listed building consider their siting and appearance. under section 66 of the Planning (Listed and historically part of its grounds. Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act The main considerations included the 1990. The appeal was lodged following refusal effect of siting and appearance on the of the appellant’s proposals to erect a timber clad, single storey dwelling with safety and convenience of public Liz Smith-Gibbons glazed link corridor and part ‘green’/ part highway users, and in the case of one zinc roof which would bridge across a kiosk, whether it would preserve the Planning Appeal: Land at Little small lake on to a central island. setting of a Grade II listed building? The Chalfield, nr. South Wraxall, Cheltenham Borough Council cited the building in question was the 19th century Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire potential harm to the designated Swindon Town Hall, built in red brick (APP/Y3940/A/14/2228679) conservation area and the adverse 1890-91 and originally known as the impact on the setting of Swindon Hall. ‘New Swindon Local Board Offices’; today An appeal by Solar Planning Ltd. against the decision of Wiltshire Council to The inspector agreed with the local it is a library and community arts centre. refuse Planning consent for 36,000 solar authority’s Conservation Officer panels spread over a 25 hectare site has concerns that the form and materials of been dismissed (ref. 14/05253/FUL). the proposed dwelling would contrast markedly with the simple form and The inspector highlighted the fact that appearance of other buildings in the the proposed scheme would “introduce a immediate vicinity, namely several development of industrial appearance chalet-style, detached stone-faced into an otherwise agricultural landscape bungalows. Furthermore, that it would for what would be at least a generation”; be an intrusive and incongruous building although the topography of the site visually noticeable and uncharacteristic would go some way to limiting the of the conservation area as a whole. It impact on the landscape character. Also was further stated by the inspector that noted were the significant number of the proposed dwelling, despite being a heritage assets within 1.5 km of the site, subservient ‘counter-balance’ to including Grade I and Grade II listed Swindon Hall in terms of scale and buildings, two conservation areas and a appearance, would sit within the open Grade II Registered Park and Garden. setting and reduce the positive contribution that the ‘verdant character’ The inspector weighed many diverse of the appeal site makes to the listed Swindon Town Hall; the proposed telephone kiosk would have been to the left of the tree factors in reaching a decision, including building’s setting. the planning balance, conflicts with the Wiltshire Core Strategy policies and the The inspector rejected the appellant’s The local authority refused the three dimensions of sustainable case that the local authority was unable subsequent Planning application (ref. development (i.e., projected economic to demonstrate a five year housing land S/TC/13/0781) and so the applicant went benefits, social role and environmental supply, stating that the development to appeal. In assessing the impact of the role). Despite the renewable energy would not satisfy the environmental role proposals, the Inspector had regard to contribution that the proposed scheme as a result of the harm to the the openness of the area around the would undoubtedly make towards conservation area and the setting of the Town Hall (partly the result of a recent achieving Government’s climate change listed building. Although the harm was landscaping scheme) and noted that it policy objectives, the projected benefits considered to be less than substantial, it provided “a fitting setting for the listed in this case were not deemed to was not outweighed by any apparent building”; thus making “an important outweigh the harm that would be caused public benefits or by a clear and contribution to the designated heritage to the setting of the listed buildings. justification for that harm. asset”. The Inspector reasoned that the Malcolm James Wendy Tomlinson Cheltenham Borough Council IHBC SW Bulletin No.29 July 2015 - page 2 Heritage & Regeneration Projects around the Region: Gloucester - 1 Officers from Gloucester City Council and realise the enormous potential that exists Gloucester Cathedral recently hosted the for collaborative partnership working in ‘Gloucester Heritage Project Forum’ at Gloucester”. Phillippa Davies from HLF Gloucester Cathedral to inform fellow added “The event was a really useful colleagues developing other HLF-funded opportunity for the sharing of information, projects in the city. joining up of contacts and partnership work in Gloucester; which could really Although the projects varied in terms of contribute to the heritage of Gloucester nature of heritage asset, scale and and the surrounding area”.