House of Assembly Thursday 18 March 2021

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

House of Assembly Thursday 18 March 2021 PARLIAMENT OF TASMANIA HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY REPORT OF DEBATES Thursday 18 March 2021 REVISED EDITION Thursday 18 March 2021 The Speaker, Ms Hickey, took the Chair at 10 a.m., acknowledged the Traditional People, and read Prayers. QUESTIONS TasTAFE - Cost of Government Advertising Ms WHITE question to PREMIER, Mr GUTWEIN [10.03 a.m.] Today, as you escalated your plans to blow-up TAFE, you have used taxpayer funds to pay for full-page advertisements in the state's three major newspapers to try to sell your politically motivated attempt to destroy TAFE. This wreaks of the attack you launched on TasWater with taxpayer funds to peddle misinformation and half-truths that ultimately failed. It proved that you could not bully your way to fixing a problem. Why have you not learned from your past mistakes? You have used statements from respected peak bodies to support your war on TAFE but can you advise if they were even told about the nature of the ad before you quoted them? How much taxpayer money do you intend to spend on advertising to try and sell your war on TAFE and how many advertisements have you already booked and paid for? ANSWER Madam Speaker, I thank the Leader of the Opposition for that question. Given the time that the Leader of the Opposition had yesterday, I was actually anticipating that she might ask me about one of their policies first up this morning, but obviously they do not have any. Mr O'Byrne - Send us an email; we will consider it and we will do it next week. Madam SPEAKER - Order, please. Mr O'Byrne. It is not your birthday today. Mr GUTWEIN - What was quite evident yesterday is it appears that the Leader of the Opposition has simply given up. The shadow treasurer was a little more nimble in his commentary yesterday, setting himself up, no doubt. The commentary from Labor about this was interesting. It gives me a great opportunity to talk about PESRAC and the very strong recommendations which we have all committed to. Ms O'BYRNE - Point of order, Madam Speaker, on relevance. The question was very specific. It was the amount of money - taxpayers' dollars - that this Government is spending. Madam SPEAKER - Unfortunately, that is not a point of order. Thank you. Mr GUTWEIN - It surprises me that they would so quickly jump - 1 Thursday 18 March 2021 The point I was going to make is, in terms of PESRAC, I made it very clear on Tuesday that this Government is going to secure Tasmania's future. We are going to secure Tasmania's future and we have accepted all 52 recommendations of PESRAC. The lack of commentary by the Leader of the Opposition regarding the PESRAC report yesterday was interesting. Members interjecting. Madam SPEAKER - Order. This is unruly right from the word go. You are making the Premier yell. Mr GUTWEIN - The point I was making is that the complete absence of any commitment to any of PESRAC recommendations yesterday - not even one on that side of the House - Mr O'Byrne interjecting. Madam SPEAKER - Order, Mr O'Byrne. Mr GUTWEIN - Our policy is to ensure that TAFE is nimble, that TAFE can meet the needs of young Tasmanians and Tasmanians in regional areas, that TAFE can provide jobs for young Tasmanians. I make no apology for letting Tasmanians know about that policy; a policy that is going to ensure - Ms WHITE - Point of order, Madam Speaker. It goes to standing order 45 on relevance. The question was specifically about how much taxpayer money has been spent on this campaign. If the Premier cannot answer, he should sit down. Madam SPEAKER - I point out that, given the traditions of this House, I am not able to put words into the Premier's mouth. I draw his attention to the question but I cannot put words in his mouth. Please proceed, Premier. Mr GUTWEIN - Regarding the question that was asked, it was much broader than just that particular issue and anyone reading Hansard would draw that same conclusion. We make no apologies for letting Tasmanians know that we have a policy that is going to provide jobs for young Tasmanians, is going to ensure that our TAFE is nimble, is more like the businesses it is there to serve, which importantly - and I would have thought on that side of the House they would support this - is going to get more young Tasmanians into tradie jobs, into traineeships, into apprenticeships and will help us secure Tasmania's future. Mr O'BYRNE - Point of order, Madam Speaker. Madam SPEAKER - Order. Goodness, I hope this is not going to be a day of points of order. Mr O'BYRNE - The question was clearly about how much taxpayers' money was he spending on advertising campaigns. 2 Thursday 18 March 2021 Madam SPEAKER - Again, that is not a point of order. I will not take another point of order on this subject. Mr GUTWEIN - Thank you, Madam Speaker. It is quite appropriate that the Government explains its policy to Tasmanians. In fact, I am reminded of the advertising that occurred under the previous Labor-Greens government, which was certainly headed up for Tasmania's forest industry, signed by Lara Giddings and Bryan Green, which led to not securing Tasmania's future but destroying Tasmania's future. It cost jobs and decimated regional communities. I will come back to the nub of this. PESRAC has brought down a series of recommendations. All 52 of them have been accepted by this side of the House and we are going to get on and implement those recommendations. The single most important recommendation that they made in terms of securing Tasmania's future is ensuring that we can put young Tasmanians and Tasmanians in regional areas into the jobs that are available. We can make certain that they are skilled up; that they are trained. Its beggars belief that that side of the House will not support it. Housing and Homelessness Ms WHITE question to PREMIER, Mr GUTWEIN [10.10 a.m.] Madam Speaker, what a terrible answer from the Premier. Your mean-spirited nature knows no bounds with your latest attack on the pay pockets of ambulance paramedics, firefighters, quarantine security guards, your plan to sack Hydro workers, and your new threat to make it harder for jobseekers to get qualifications with your plan to blow up TAFE. The uncaring 'look the other way' attitude at the core of your Government is no clearer than in housing and the homelessness crisis that you have created and failed to fix, and the desperate situation this has left thousands of Tasmanians in. Tasmanians want to know why you are so out of touch. They want to know why you have no compassion or understanding of the often-desperate situation that families are finding themselves in. They want to understand why you simply do not care what is happening in this state when almost 3600 families are on the housing waiting list and when even the most urgent of those families needing a roof over their head will have to wait a minimum of 64 weeks to be housed, on average. Can you show Tasmanians today that you have at least an understanding of the housing crisis you are overseeing, by telling us how many people on average are turned away from each of Tasmania's emergency shelters across the state each day? 3 Thursday 18 March 2021 ANSWER Madam Speaker, I thank the Leader of the Opposition for that question, wide ranging as it was. Let me deal with a couple of things. First, I have been advised regarding ambulance staff and the challenge they have been facing in terms of past payments related to travel recovery, that no past payments will need to be recovered. We are in the process of communicating that widely to staff and working with them and so, Madam Speaker, fixed. Regarding the issue with our firefighters, I understand that 12 out of the 13 have now received their backpay. We will still seek clarity because it is important that on the point of law that we have clarity. Regarding quarantine hotels, my understanding is the deeds are currently with the hotels themselves. We are waiting on them to come back from them. I believe we have one back already but, as I have said, back payments will occur as soon as we receive those deeds. And so, one, two and three: fixed. Ms O'Byrne - You forgot about - Madam SPEAKER - Order, Ms O'Byrne. Mr GUTWEIN - I do not have that detail in the final point of the question that the member asked but I will say that, on Tuesday of this week, we released a comprehensive housing package that will put downward pressure on rents, that will enable people to put ancilliary dwellings, granny flats in their backyards, with no permit required. It will ensure that landlords are able to put downward pressure on rent because of the significant changes we have made to land tax. We will continue with our comprehensive program to put roofs over peoples' heads. However, as I have said, the only way you can deal with the demand problem is to build more houses. Last year for the 12 months we have a record level of dwelling approvals. We are doing exactly what is required and that is getting on with the job and building more houses. That side of the House cannot even make their mind up whether they will agree with anything out of the PESRAC report.
Recommended publications
  • House of Assembly Tuesday 1 May 2018
    Tuesday 1 May 2018 FIRST SESSION OF THE FORTY-NINTH PARLIAMENT The House met at 11 a.m. pursuant to the proclamation of Her Excellency the Governor. The Clerk read the proclamation. OPENING OF PARLIAMENT The Usher of the Black Rod was admitted and delivered a message from the Commissioners requesting the attendance of members in the Legislative Council Chamber. Members accordingly proceeded to that Chamber and, having heard the Commission read, returned to the House of Assembly. MEMBERS SWORN The Clerk laid on the Table writs for the election of the following members of the House of Assembly. Elise Nicole Archer (Denison) William Edward Felix Hodgman (Franklin) Scott Bacon (Denison) Jennifer Louise Houston (Bass) Guy Barnett (Lyons) Roger Charles Jaensch (Braddon) Shane Thomas Broad (Braddon) David James O'Byrne (Franklin) Adam Richard Brooks (Braddon) Michelle Anne O'Byrne (Bass) Jenna Butler (Lyons) Cassandra Stanwell O'Connor (Denison) Sarah Jane Courtney (Bass) Jacqueline Anne Petrusma (Franklin) Anita Joy Dow ((Braddon) Jeremy Page Rockliff (Braddon) Michael Darrel Joseph Ferguson (Bass) Mark David Shelton ((Lyons) Peter Carl Gutwein (Bass) Alison Standen (Franklin) Eloise Rafia Haddad Rebecca Peta White (Lyons) Susanne Lynnette Hickey (Denison) Rosalie Woodruff Marinus Theodoor Hidding (Lyons) All members were sworn or made the necessary affirmation and subscribed to codes of ethical conduct and race ethics. ELECTION OF SPEAKER Mr HODGMAN (Franklin - Premier) - I move - That Marinus Theodoor Hidding do take the Chair of this House as Speaker. Mr ROCKLIFF (Braddon - Deputy Premier) - I second the motion. 1 1 May 2018 CLERK - Does the member consent to such nomination? Mr HIDDING (Lyons) - I do.
    [Show full text]
  • Book 1 Tuesday, 23 December 2014
    PARLIAMENT OF VICTORIA PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL FIFTY-EIGHTH PARLIAMENT FIRST SESSION Book 1 Tuesday, 23 December 2014 Internet: www.parliament.vic.gov.au/downloadhansard By authority of the Victorian Government Printer The Governor The Honourable ALEX CHERNOV, AC, QC The Lieutenant-Governor The Honourable Justice MARILYN WARREN, AC The ministry Premier ......................................................... The Hon. D. M. Andrews, MP Deputy Premier, Minister for Education ............................. The Hon. J. A. Merlino, MP Treasurer ....................................................... The Hon. T. H. Pallas, MP Minister for Public Transport and Minister for Employment ............ The Hon. J. Allan, MP Minister for Industry and Minister for Energy and Resources ........... The Hon. L. D’Ambrosio, MP Minister for Roads and Road Safety and Minister for Ports ............. The Hon. L. A. Donnellan, MP Minister for Tourism and Major Events, Minister for Sport and Minister for Veterans .................................................. The Hon. J. H. Eren, MP Minister for Housing, Disability and Ageing, Minister for Mental Health, Minister for Equality and Minister for Creative Industries ........... The Hon. M. P. Foley, MP Minister for Emergency Services and Minister for Consumer Affairs, Gaming and Liquor Regulation .................................. The Hon. J. F. Garrett, MP Minister for Health and Minister for Ambulance Services .............. The Hon. J. Hennessy, MP Minister for Training and Skills .................................... The Hon. S. R. Herbert, MLC Minister for Local Government, Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Minister for Industrial Relations ................................. The Hon. N. M. Hutchins, MP Special Minister of State .......................................... The Hon. G. Jennings, MLC Minister for Families and Children, and Minister for Youth Affairs ...... The Hon. J. Mikakos, MLC Minister for Environment, Climate Change and Water ................. The Hon. L.
    [Show full text]
  • DPAC Annual Report 2016-17
    DPAC ANNUAL REPORT 2016 –17 Department of Premier and Cabinet Annual Report 2016–17 Department of Premier and Cabinet ABOUT THIS PUBLICATION This Annual Report provides information for all stakeholders with an interest in the machinery of government, policy services, whole-of-government service delivery, local government, information technology, State Service management, legislation development, security and emergency management, Aboriginal affairs, women’s policy, climate change, community development and sport and recreation. It includes the highlights of the year, an overview of our operations, major initiatives, and performance during 2016-17. The report is presented in several sections: Section Page Submission to the Premier and Ministers 1 Our Year in Review 2 Secretary’s Report 4 Our Department 6 Our Strategic Priorities – How we performed 11 Our Performance Measures 40 Our People and Policies 44 Our Divisions 55 Our Finances 60 Our Compliance Report 74 Compliance Index 84 Abbreviations 86 Index 88 Our Contacts Inside back cover All of our annual reports are available for download from the Department’s website, www.dpac.tas.gov.au. © Crown in the Right of the State of Tasmania For copies or further information regarding this Report please contact: Department of Premier and Cabinet GPO Box 123 Hobart TAS 7001 Call 03 6270 5482 Email [email protected] www.dpac.tas.gov.au ISSN 1448 9023 (print) ISSN 1448 9031 (online) Submission to the Premier and Ministers Hon Will Hodgman MP Hon Jeremy Rockliff MP Premier Minister for Education
    [Show full text]
  • Premier of Tasmania - Anniversary of June 2016 Floods a Time for Reflection
    Premier of Tasmania - Anniversary of June 2016 floods a time for reflection Search Home News About Cabinet Speeches Budget Contact Will Hodgman Premier of Tasmania 5 June 2017 Jeremy Rockliff, Minister for Primary Industries and Water Anniversary of June 2016 floods a time for reflection In marking the 12-month anniversary of last June’s devastating floods, it is a time to reflect on the tragic loss of life and the many families, farms and communities that were impacted. Once in a century floods swept across 20 of Tasmania’s 29 municipalities with enormous speed and causing catastrophic damage to farms and infrastructure and people’s livelihoods. It is difficult to adequately describe the heartache of missing family members, farmers losing stock or a family seeing their home go under water – it has a different impact on every individual. The community, including the Tasmanian Government, stood beside these families and communities as they rebuilt and we continue to help with rehabilitation grants, loans and financial advice. The total damage bill is estimated in excess of $180 million and my thanks go to the many organisations like the local councils, TFGA, Dairy Tas, Rural Business Tasmania, Rural Alive and Well, and DPIPWE who all worked magnificently together to help affected families and communities. The Tasmanian Government quickly responded with a series of Emergency Assistance Grants, Community and Primary Producer Clean-up Grants, funding to the Rural Relief Fund, established the Flood Recovery Taskforce, the Flood Recovery Loan Scheme and also successfully liaised with the Australian Government for the affected regions to be covered by the National Disaster Relief and Recovery Arrangement.
    [Show full text]
  • Rti-Dl-Release-Dpipwe
    From: O'Brien, Megan (DPaC) [mailto:Megan.O'[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, 22 December 2016 8:50 AM To: @tasracing. com. au>; Mark Tarring <rn. tarring@tasracing. com. au>; @tasracing. com. au> Cc: @tasracing. com. au>; @tasracing. com. au> Subject: Christmas break Good morning alt, A quick note to let you knowthat this office is closing at 12pm tomorrow. i will be on leave for the first week of January, returning Monday 9th January. Leanne will be your first contact while I'm away, however I'll still be available on my mobile. I want to wish the whole team at Tasracinga Merry Christmas and Happy NewYear! Enjoy the break, and thank you for all the fantastic work you've done throughout the year Warm regards, Megan RTI-DL-RELEASE-DPIPWE ^^w ^idau^ O'Brien, Me an (DPaC) From: Mark Tarring <rn.tarring@tasracing. com. au> Sent: Wednesday, 7 December2016 1127 AM To: O'Brien, Megan (DPaC) Cc: Casey Commane Subject: RE: GBE paper for checking Hi Megan, this is correct. I have spoken to Tascorp so give me a call and I can provide an update. Regards Mark Tarring | Tasracing Chief Financial Officer Luxbet Park Hobart 6 Goodwood Road Glenorchy TAS 7010 e: m. tarrin tasracin . corn. au w: www.tasracin .corn. au From: O'Brien, Megan (DPaC) [mailto:Megan. O'Brien@dpac. tas. gov. au] Sent: Wednesday, 7 December 2016 10:26 AM To: Mark Tarring <[email protected]> Cc: Casey Commane <[email protected]> Subject: GBE paper for checking Hi Mark, Can you please check the attached is correct, it has been through the Treasurer's office too - letters of comfort were in the Mercury today.
    [Show full text]
  • Ministerial Careers and Accountability in the Australian Commonwealth Government / Edited by Keith Dowding and Chris Lewis
    AND MINISTERIAL CAREERS ACCOUNTABILITYIN THE AUSTRALIAN COMMONWEALTH GOVERNMENT AND MINISTERIAL CAREERS ACCOUNTABILITYIN THE AUSTRALIAN COMMONWEALTH GOVERNMENT Edited by Keith Dowding and Chris Lewis Published by ANU E Press The Australian National University Canberra ACT 0200, Australia Email: [email protected] This title is also available online at http://epress.anu.edu.au National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Title: Ministerial careers and accountability in the Australian Commonwealth government / edited by Keith Dowding and Chris Lewis. ISBN: 9781922144003 (pbk.) 9781922144010 (ebook) Series: ANZSOG series Notes: Includes bibliographical references. Subjects: Politicians--Australia. Politicians--Australia--Ethical behavior. Political ethics--Australia. Politicians--Australia--Public opinion. Australia--Politics and government. Australia--Politics and government--Public opinion. Other Authors/Contributors: Dowding, Keith M. Lewis, Chris. Dewey Number: 324.220994 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Cover design and layout by ANU E Press Printed by Griffin Press This edition © 2012 ANU E Press Contents 1. Hiring, Firing, Roles and Responsibilities. 1 Keith Dowding and Chris Lewis 2. Ministers as Ministries and the Logic of their Collective Action . 15 John Wanna 3. Predicting Cabinet Ministers: A psychological approach ..... 35 Michael Dalvean 4. Democratic Ambivalence? Ministerial attitudes to party and parliamentary scrutiny ........................... 67 James Walter 5. Ministerial Accountability to Parliament ................ 95 Phil Larkin 6. The Pattern of Forced Exits from the Ministry ........... 115 Keith Dowding, Chris Lewis and Adam Packer 7. Ministers and Scandals .........................
    [Show full text]
  • Parliamentary Questions
    About Parliament - Sheet 22 Parliamentary Questions Parliamentary questions are an important means Questions without Notice used by members of Parliament to ensure the (Question Time) government is accountable for its policies and actions to the Parliament and, through the Parliament, to the Questions without Notice are asked orally by people. Opposition or Government backbench members during Question Time in the House. Question Time is In the parliamentary chambers, questions are used a set part of each sitting day, and occurs in both by members on both sides of the house to ask a houses. minister about matters of concern relating to government policy within the minister’s portfolio. In the Legislative Assembly, ministers are asked Questions may also be asked of a member regarding questions for approximately 45 minutes every sitting any matter connected with the business of the house day starting at 2.00 pm or shortly thereafter. for which the member has charge, and also to a In the Legislative Council, Question Time typically member chairing a committee. takes place for approximately 30 minutes starting at 4.30 pm each sitting day. Questions must conform to the rules or the Standing Orders of each house. The Speaker in the Legislative Question Time is one of the liveliest times in a Assembly and the President in the Legislative Council parliamentary sitting day. Generally all members are may disallow or edit a question that is considered to in attendance in the house at this time, when current not conform to the house’s Standing Orders. issues are raised. For this reason, Question Time attracts media attention, with televised extracts Questions asked of a minister must be brief, must not being regularly used in television news programs.
    [Show full text]
  • Report of the Tasmanian Chapter of the ASPG
    Report of the Tasmanian Chapter of the ASPG Membership The Tasmanian Chapter’s current members are: 1. Hon. Elise Archer MP, Attorney-General; 2. Mr Todd Buttsworth, Second Clerk-Assistant, House of Assembly; 3. Mr Shane Donnelly, Clerk of the House of Assembly; 4. Ms Anita Dow MP, Member of the House of Assembly; 5. Hon. Craig Farrell MLC, Member of the Legislative Council; 6. Hon. Ruth Forrest MLC, Member of the Legislative Council; 7. Hon. Michael Gaffney MLC, Member of the Legislative Council; 8. Dr Richard Herr, University of Tasmania; 9. Ms Stephanie Hesford, Clerk-Assistant & Sergeant-at-Arms, House of Assembly; 10. Hon. Sue Hickey MP, Speaker of the House of Assembly; 11. Hon. Leonie Hiscutt MLC, Member of the Legislative Council; 12. Mr David O’Byrne MP, Member of the House of Assembly; 13. Ms Michelle O’Byrne MP, Deputy Leader of the Opposition; 14. Mr David Pearce, Clerk of the Legislative Council; 15. Hon. Jeremy Rockliff MP, Deputy Premier; 16. Ms Laura Ross, Deputy Clerk, House of Assembly; 17. Ms Alison Standen MP, Member of the House of Assembly; 18. Ms Catherine Vickers, Deputy Clerk, Legislative Council; 19. Mr Stuart Wright, Clerk-Assistant & Usher of the Black Rod, Legislative Council. Chapter activities The Tasmanian Chapter hosted the 2017 Annual Conference from 27 to 29 September 2017. No other activities were undertaken by the Tasmanian Chapter. Corporate membership votes at AGM These votes will be exercised by: Scott Hennessy, House of Assembly Finance During the period 1 July to date the Chapter received $540.00 in membership fees.
    [Show full text]
  • Tasmania: Majority Or Minority Government? *
    AUSTRALASIAN PARLIAMENTARY REVIEW Tasmania: Majority or Minority Government? * Michael Lester and Dain Bolwell PhD Candidate, Institute for the Study of Social Change, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Tasmania Associate, Institute for the Study of Social Change, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Tasmania * Double-blind reviewed article. INTRODUCTION While the outcome of the March 2018 Tasmanian State Election was predictable,1 the controversies that dogged the campaign were not. Yet it was the aftermath of the election that was most astonishing—not only to the public but also to members of Cabinet. Tasmania is different. Its parliamentary institutions are unusual and its electoral system is distinctive. So were the issues on which the March 2018 state election was fought. In the lead up to the election both major parties campaigned to govern alone or not at all—neither in minority nor in coalition with the Greens. As well as this apparently overarching concern, there were three other major issues prominent during the campaign—an acute housing shortage, the thousands of poker machines in pubs and clubs, and the surprise matter of gun control. Health, education, law and order, the economy and who would best manage the budget were, as usual, also policy battle grounds; however, the minority government fear campaign, a television blitz on the benefits of poker machines and considerable 1 N. Miragliotta, ‘As Tasmania Looks Likely to Have Minority Government, The Greens Must Decide How to Play Their Hand’, The Conversation, 26 February 2018. Accessed at: https://theconversation.com/as-tasmania-looks- likely-to-have-minority-government-the-greens-must-decide-how-to-play-their-hand-91985.
    [Show full text]
  • Parliamentary Debates (Hansard)
    PARLIAMENT OF VICTORIA PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY FIFTY-NINTH PARLIAMENT FIRST SESSION THURSDAY, 20 JUNE 2019 Internet: www.parliament.vic.gov.au/downloadhansard By authority of the Victorian Government Printer The Governor The Honourable LINDA DESSAU, AC The Lieutenant-Governor The Honourable KEN LAY, AO, APM The ministry Premier ........................................................ The Hon. DM Andrews, MP Deputy Premier and Minister for Education ......................... The Hon. JA Merlino, MP Treasurer, Minister for Economic Development and Minister for Industrial Relations ........................................... The Hon. TH Pallas, MP Minister for Transport Infrastructure ............................... The Hon. JM Allan, MP Minister for Crime Prevention, Minister for Corrections, Minister for Youth Justice and Minister for Victim Support .................... The Hon. BA Carroll, MP Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change, and Minister for Solar Homes ................................................. The Hon. L D’Ambrosio, MP Minister for Child Protection and Minister for Disability, Ageing and Carers ....................................................... The Hon. LA Donnellan, MP Minister for Mental Health, Minister for Equality and Minister for Creative Industries ............................................ The Hon. MP Foley, MP Attorney-General and Minister for Workplace Safety ................. The Hon. J Hennessy, MP Minister for Public Transport and Minister for Ports and Freight
    [Show full text]
  • Does Question Time Fulfil Its Role of Ensuring Accountability?
    Does Question Time fulfil its role of ensuring accountability? Parameswary Rasiah University of Western Australia Discussion Paper 14/06 (April 2006) Democratic Audit of Australia Australian National University Canberra, ACT 0200 Australia http://democratic.audit.anu.edu.au My argument is that Question Time (i.e. Questions Without Notice) does not fulfill its role of ensuring the government is held accountable for its actions, based on three premises. Firstly, ministers do evade answering questions, specifically those asked by opposition MPs; secondly, the speaker’s inaction or rulings when evasion occurs and thirdly, ‘Dorothy Dixers’ (friendly questions) are widely used by the government to evade accountability. Evasion The popularly held belief that ministers frequently evade answering questions during Question Time is supported by empirical evidence. My study is based on an analytical framework derived from works by others1 in the field of evasion (or equivocation) in political news interviews. It involved the classification of responses as ‘answers’ (direct or indirect), ‘intermediate responses’ (such as not having the information at hand or pointing out incorrect information in the question), and ‘evasions’ based on specific criteria. The data were Hansard transcripts of the House of Representatives’ Questions Without Notice in February 2003 dealing only with questions and responses on the topic of Iraq. This topic was chosen because it was and still is a relevant topic of discussion today especially in terms of whether the Iraqi regime posed a sufficient enough threat to justify military action by Australia the following month (March 2003) as part of the ‘coalition of the willing’. There were 41 such questions which represented approximately one third of all questions on Iraq for the whole of that year.
    [Show full text]
  • Report: Inquiry Into the Implementation of The
    7 CHAPTER 2 APOLOGIES, REDRESS AND JUDICIAL INQUIRIES 2.1 This chapter considers some of the major issues raised in evidence concerning the implementation of the recommendations of the Forgotten Australians and Lost Innocents reports. These are: • the requirement for the Commonwealth to provided national leadership in ensuring coordinated and comprehensive responses to care leaver issues; • national and State apologies to care leavers; • reparation and redress schemes; and • the need for judicial inquiries and/or a Royal Commission. 2.2 In most cases, both the Lost Innocents and Forgotten Australians reports made specific recommendations going to these issues. However, it is also the case that many of the recommendations in Forgotten Australians applies to care leavers more generally, and should be understood as being potentially relevant to any person who experienced out-of-home care in Australia in the last century, regardless of whether they experienced care in a State, religious or charitable institution; or indeed in some other setting, such as foster care.1 The term 'care leavers' as it is used in the following chapter thus may include, as relevant, former child migrants and members of the stolen generation.2 National leadership role required from the Commonwealth Lost Innocents 2.3 The former Commonwealth government issued its response to the Lost Innocents report on 14 May 2002. In the preamble to its response the government welcomed the report as a 'sensitive, comprehensive and insightful appraisal of child migration schemes and child migrants' experiences in Australia'; and acknowledged that the legacy of the child migration schemes must be addressed.
    [Show full text]