Vol XXXI No 4 KDN PP 987/11/2003 ISSN 01268538 December 2002 COLLOQUIUM ISSUE Current Judicial Trends and the Rules of Justice Published by the Bar Council, Nos. 13, 15 & 17, Jalan Leboh Pasar Besar, 50050 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Tel No. (03) 2031 3003. Fax Nos. (03) 2026 1313 / 2034 2825 / 2072 5818. E-mail:
[email protected] C ONTENTS Editorial 1 ‘Who Judges the Juges?’ by The Hon Mr Justice Alex Chernov 2 ‘Justice Is Not A Cloistered Virtue’. Are Judicial Criticisms Inter Se Permissible? by Dato’ Param Cumaraswamy 32 Judicial Appointments: Who Should Have The Say? by YM Raja Aziz Addruse 43 The Importance of Judicial Review by Dr Venkat Iyer 60 ‘Life’ Under Article 5: What Should It Be? by Dato’ Dr Cyrus Das 68 Recent Cases In The Criminal Justice System: Is Consistency A Virtue? by Manjeet Singh Dhillon 82 INSAF PUBLICATION COMMITTEE 2002/2003 EDITOR M Mathialagan MEMBERS Mah Weng Kwai D C Alfred Hj Kuthubul Zaman Bukhari P K Yang Dato’ Mohd Sofian Abd Razak Hj Mohamed Apandi Ali Cecil Rajendra N Surendran S Gunasegaran Malik Imtiaz Sarwar Hj Hamid Sultan Abu Backer Ragunath Kesavan BAR COUNCIL 2002/2003 OFFICE BEARERS Mah Weng Kwai (Chairman) Hj Kuthubul Zaman Bukhari (Vice-Chairman) Mohd Sofian Abdul Razak, Dato’ (Secretary) Hj Mohamed Apandi Ali (Treasurer) MEMBERS R Anantha Kumar Alosius Ng Chee Seng Benedict Cheang Chu Yong Ong Siew Wan R R Chelvarajah Sivarasa Rasiah S Gunasegaran Hjh Shamsuriah Sulaiman Hj Hamid Sultan bin Abu Backer Ambiga Sreenevasan Hendon Mohamed R Rajasingam Hon Kai Ping Malik Imtiaz Sarwar Dr Cyrus Das, Dato’ Steven Tai Tet Chuan Jegadeeson Thavasu S Ravichandran Terrance Kanagaratnam Yasmeen Shariff Lee Leng Guan Zamani Mohammad Low Beng Choo Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera M Mathialagan Yeo Yang Poh Ragunath Kesavan Pretam Singh Petra Oon Beng Ai Roy Rajasingham Hj Mohd Abu Bakar Rautin, Dato’ Cecil Rajendra The Insaf Publication Committee welcomes articles for publication in INSAF.