Ev27n1p65.Pdf

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ev27n1p65.Pdf Feature 444 Oswald0 Cruz and the Flowering of Public Health in Brazil1 umanity’s penchant for neglecting from further harm; but all vulnerable adult H the unpleasant has helped us to for- visitors, immigrants, and nonimmune get that as recently as 1900 the city of Rio residents afoot in Rio during yellow fever de Janeiro was a running sore. Sanitation season ran a high risk of quick and horrid was poor, medical knowledge limited, death. public health weak.3 There, as elsewhere While it may seem surprising that this in Brazil, the ordinary run of diseases like health picture has been forgotten, the tuberculosis, diarrhea, and measles took really surprising thing is how it changed. their toll, while certain more dramatic Beginning in 1903, a broad public health killers like smallpox and bubonic plague campaign began. Some measures, like were rife. widening of narrow streets and im- But the great terror of Rio in those days, proved sanitation, were fairly general. the ill that slew waves of immigrants and Others, like destruction of plague-bear- really gave the city its bad name, was ing rats and yellow fever mosquitoes, were yellow fever. Also known as the “black more specific. Al1 in all, the results were vomit,” yellow fever reached Rio in 1849, startling. As if some enchanter had waved erupted into a fearsome epidemic that a magic wand, plague retreated, yellow killed some 4 000 residents, and for the fever vanished, the death rate fell, and next half-century lingered as a shadowy Rio’s health, happiness, international assassin claiming hundreds or thousands prestige, and self-esteem began to rise. of lives a year. In time it became well The person who spearheaded this known that all who survived a yellow transformation was a quiet, strong-willed fever attack (including a mild or unno- young man named Oswald0 Cruz. When ticeabIe childhood attack) were immune he became director of Brazil’s diminutive public health department in 1903, Cruz took the bull by the horns. In three years ‘This is the sixth in a series of profiles on individ- he vastIy expanded the department, uals who have made outstanding contributions to planned and managed large national public health in the Americas. gonathan Leonard is a freelance medical writer and campaigns against various problems in- editor of the Bulletin of PAHO. cluding plague and yellow fever, and es- 3Bacellar RC, p 237. tablished a permanent beachhead for Bullefin of PAHO 27(l), 1993 65 Pictures taken of Oswald0 Cruz in 1903 (right) and in 1911 (below, left). The 1908 cartoon at lower right appeared over the caption “This is the way the country receives its sons that honor and love the nation; it crowns and blesses them.” (Drawing by Klixto, Fan-Fen magazine, Rio de Janeiro, January 1908; photos courtesy Casa de Oswald0 Cruz Archive.) 66 Bulletin of PAHO 27(l), 1993 medical research in Brazil. In the process Higiene PtibZica); by 1890 he was assistant he roused fiery political controversy, to Brazil’s top public health officer, the achieved spectacular success, and be- Inspector General of Health; and in 1892, came his country’s first and greatest pub- a few months before his death at the age lic health hero. of 47, he himself became Inspector Gen- It is true that Cruz, trained in micro- eral of Health. biology and aware of key public health In those days, of course, the scope of discoveries abroad, was a man in the right Brazilian medical science and public health place at the right time. But he also started was limited. Medical laboratories and basic in 1903 as a virtual unknown with limited tools like microscopes were rare. Medical experience in medicine, laboratory sci- schools existed in Bahia and Rio, but these ence, public health administration, and had serious shortcomings. As Nancy politics. He worked so fast that his feats Stepan reports in her excellent book The seemed the stuff of legend-like medical Beginnings of Brazilian Science, there was sleight of hand. And no other Latin no chair in microbiology anywhere until American country ever experienced such 1901, and as late as 1904 the lone pro- a swift, self-generated public health rev- fessor of microbiology at the Rio de Ja- olution, though at least one other, Ar- neiro School of Medicine “was attempt- gentina, was medically more advanced. ing to instruct one hundred and fifty So it is worth looking closely at who students with a single microscope. The Oswald0 Cruz was and what he did. situation in histology and pathology was much the same.“4 EARLY YEARS Public health laws existed in these years, but ignorance of disease origins, effective Oswald0 Gongalves Cruz was born in quarantine rules, and appropriate sani- the small Brazilian town of SZio Luis de tary measures prevented such laws from Paraitinga on 5 August 1872. Perhaps being effective. The resources at the com- partly because he was an only son (he mand of public health authorities were had six sisters but no brothers), from early few. And despite the explosive growth childhood he tried hard to follow in his in medical knowledge then under way father’s footsteps. That took him inter- outside Brazil, principally in Europe, the esting places-because his father, Bento circle of Brazilians directly involved with Goncalves Cruz, was a private physician public health was very small. with uncommon dedication to learning, Oswald0 Cruz, who grew up within medical science, and public health. that circle, was quiet, studious, and pre- In 1877, when Oswald0 was five, Bento cocious. His mother taught him to read and his wife Amalia moved their family at age 5. He then proceeded to finish from Sao Luis to Rio de Janeiro so the school in 9 years. After that, at age 14,5 children could get a regular education. he began university studies equivalent to There they lived in Jardim Botanico, then college plus medical school at the Na- a poor neighborhood, where Bento got a tional School of Medicine in Rio, the same morning job as physician at a textile fac- institution his father had attended. tory, the Fdbrica de Tecidos Corcovado, and At the university, Cruz came in close ran a private practice in the afternoon. contact with several well-known clini- As time passed his reputation grew. Nine years later, in 1886, Emperor Dom Pedro II made him a member of the country’s *Stepan N, Beginnings of Brazilian science, p 55. public health board (the @zfu Central de 5Moreira M, pp 29-30. Feature 67 cians. One of these, Professor Rocha Faria, ian’s second language. Moreover, the supervised the medical school’s first mi- Emperor Dom Pedro II had invited Louis crobiology laboratory. Cruz, who worked Pasteur to visit Brazil in 1883; and though for some time as an assistant there, found the invitation was declined on account of himself increasingly drawn to microbi- Pasteur’s ill health and age, Dom Pedro ology and wound up doing his medical remained unabashedly impressed by thesis under Rocha Faria on transmission Pasteur’s work against rabies and con- of microbes by water. tributed generously when the Pasteur In- That could have been the end of his stitute was founded in 1885. involvement with research. By 1892, when When Cruz applied-around the time Cruz received his medical degree, he had Louis Pasteur died in X395-the Pasteur exhausted the training available in Brazil. Institute was impressive. Organized to His father’s death the same year left him combine basic research, applied research, with scant resources. And his marriage and student training, it consisted of five in 1893 to a girl named Emflia Fonseca, departments-one dealing with rabies, with whom he ultimately had six chil- one with microbe morphology, and three dren, obliged him to settle down. So he with microbiology. Its department heads, took his father’s old job at the Fdbrica de charged with pursuing research in their Tecidos Corcovado and for some years pur- own areas while working as fully as pos- sued a career in clinical medicine. sible with others, included some of the Fortunately, Oswaldo’s interest in mi- most original scientific minds in Europe. crobiology got strong backing from his And its approach to advanced medical re- father-in-law, whose wedding present was search, combined as it was with student the cash Oswald0 needed to build a small training, tended to forge close associations home medical laboratory. Dr. E. Sales between researchers and students. Guerra, a prominent physician and head When Cruz began his Paris studies in of the Internal Disease Service of the 1896, excitement about serum therapy was General Polyclinic of Rio, was impressed high, and the institute’s work was strongly by the laboratory and asked Oswald0 to focused on developing immune sera and set up and run a diagnostic laboratory for vaccines. So Cruz received extensive the polyclinic. Another leading clinician, training in the most advanced techniques Dr. Francisco de Castro, was also im- emerging within this branch of medicine. pressed and aroused Cruz’s interest in But he also planned to return to Brazil; continuing his scientific training at the he knew his country’s research under- Pasteur Institute in Paris. pinnings to be weak, and so he studied Cruz followed up on both suggestions. many other things. He put on a work- He set up the diagnostic laboratory at the man’s blue shirt and learned glass-blowing polyclinic, where he and Sales Guerra be- techniques used to make scientific glass- came close friends; and in due course he ware at a local factory; he kept up with applied to the Pasteur Institute, was ac- published research on various ills, most cepted, and with his father-in-law’s fi- notably yellow fever, which he likened nancial support took his family to Paris in his letters home to “an invisible stain and began two-and-a-half years of study.
Recommended publications
  • 1 Universidade Federal De Santa Catarina Centro De
    1 UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE SANTA CATARINA CENTRO DE COMUNICAÇÃO E EXPRESSÃO PÓS-GRADUAÇÃO EM ESTUDOS DA TRADUÇÃO WILLIAM FRANKLIN HANES MEMÓRIAS DO INSTITUTO OSWALDO CRUZ FROM THE AGE OF EMPIRE TO THE POST-GUTENBERG WORLD:LINGUA FRANCA AND THE CULTURE OF TROPICAL MEDICINE Florianópolis 2016 2 3 WILLIAM FRANKLIN HANES MEMÓRIAS DO INSTITUTO OSWALDO CRUZ FROM THE AGE OF EMPIRE TO THE POST-GUTENBERG WORLD:LINGUA FRANCA AND THE CULTURE OF TROPICAL MEDICINE Tese submetida ao Programa de Pós- Graduação em Estudos da Tradução da Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina para a obtenção do Grau de Doutor em Estudos da Tradução. Orientador: Prof. Dr. José Cyriel Gerard Lambert Co-orientador: Prof. Dr. Peter Flynn (KU Leuven) Florianópolis 2016 4 5 6 7 In memoriam: Dr. Nicolau Serra Freire (1948-2015) 8 9 “Language is a part of our organism and no less complicated than it.” Ludwig Wittgenstein 10 11 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Intellectual contribution: Members of the examination board (Berthold Zilly, John Milton, Walter Costa, Yuri Brunello and Viviane Heberle) and the pre- examination board (Walter Costa, Lincoln Fernandes); José R. Coura and Marco Antonio Fiori; Language consultants (Berthold Zilly, Jean- François Bruneliere); CETRA professors (especially Yves Gambier, Andrew Chesterman and Christina Schaeffner); Anthony Pym and Patrick Cattryse. Very special thanks to my supervisor José Lambert and co-supervisor Peter Flynn. Academic and Reference support: PGET: Andréia Guerini, Fernando and Gustavo; UFSC Professors Sergio Romanelli, Noemia Soares, Viviane Heberle and Markus Weininger; ITG-Antwerpen library staff; FIOCRUZ: as anjinhas das obras raras (Iara, Maria Claudia, Leila, Giulia); pessoal da Biblioteca de Manguinhos, Mauricio & Giuliana; Leiven D’Hulst of KULeuven and Ellen Valle of the University of Turku.
    [Show full text]
  • Malaria and Quinine Resistance: a Medical and Scientific Issue Between Brazil and Germany (1907–19)
    Med. Hist. (2014), vol. 58(1), pp. 1–26. c The Authors 2014. Published by Cambridge University Press 2014 doi:10.1017/mdh.2013.69 Malaria and Quinine Resistance: A Medical and Scientific Issue between Brazil and Germany (1907–19) ANDRÉ FELIPE CÂNDIDO DA SILVA1∗ and JAIME LARRY BENCHIMOL2∗ 1Department of History, Faculty of Philosophy, Languages and Literature and Human Sciences (FFLCH), University of Sao˜ Paulo, Av. Professor Luciano Gualberto, 315, Cicade Universitaria,´ CEP: 05508.900, Sao Paulo - SP, Brazil 2Casa de Oswaldo Cruz – FIOCRUZ, Av. Brasil, 4036/403, CEP 21040.361, Rio de Janeiro - RJ, Brazil Abstract: This article addresses the discussion about quinine- resistant malaria plasmodium in the early decades of the twentieth century. Observed by Arthur Neiva in Rio de Janeiro in 1907, the biological and social resistance of malaria sufferers to preventive and curative treatment with quinine was corroborated three years later by Oswaldo Cruz during the construction of the Madeira-Mamore´ Railway in the Brazilian Amazon. Likewise in 1910, ailing German workers were transferred from Brazil to Hamburg’s Institute for Maritime and Tropical Diseases, where quinine resistance was confirmed by Bernard Nocht and Heinrich Werner. When the First World War saw failures in treating and preventing malaria with quinine along with violent outbreaks of the disease on the Turkish and Balkan fronts, resistance to this alkaloid became the topic of the day within the field of experimental medicine in Germany. New attempts were made to account for the resistance, especially by the physician Ernst Rodenwaldt, who explored the topic by applying modern theories on heredity.
    [Show full text]
  • Historical Introduction Adolpho Lutz and Dermatology in Historical Perspective
    Apresentação histórica - Historical introduction Adolpho Lutz and dermatology in historical perspective Jaime Benchimol SciELO Books / SciELO Livros / SciELO Libros BENCHIMOL, JL., and SÁ, MR., eds. and orgs. Adolpho Lutz : Dermatologia e Micologia = Dermatology and Micology [online]. Rio de Janeiro: Editora FIOCRUZ, 2004. 620 p. Adolpho Lutz Obra Completa, v.1, book 3. ISBN: 85-7541-043-1. Available from SciELO Books <http://books.scielo.org >. All the contents of this chapter, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported. Todo o conteúdo deste capítulo, exceto quando houver ressalva, é publicado sob a licença Creative Commons Atribuição - Uso Não Comercial - Partilha nos Mesmos Termos 3.0 Não adaptada. Todo el contenido de este capítulo, excepto donde se indique lo contrario, está bajo licencia de la licencia Creative Commons Reconocimento-NoComercial-CompartirIgual 3.0 Unported. TRABALHOS SOBRE DERMATOLOGIA E MICOLOGIA 153 Adolpho Lutz and Dermatology in Historical Perspective Jaime Benchimol n the early months of 1882, Adolpho Lutz settled down to work as a general I practitioner in Limeira, in the interior of the State of São Paulo, Brazil. Limeira was an important center for the cultivation of coffee, sugarcane and cereals, and had a population of approximately four thousand inhabitants, including a sizeable Swiss-German colony. He soon wrote to a Swiss periodical in which he had already described his life as a teacher and physician in Brazil.1 He did not want to lose contact with European medicine, and he now described a plan he had in mind to study questions that might be important to his fellow physicians in the Old World.
    [Show full text]
  • Women Scientists in Typhus Research During the First Half of the Twentieth Century
    Gesnerus 62 (2005) 257–272 Women Scientists in Typhus Research During the First Half of the Twentieth Century Jean Lindenmann Summary Several women scientists have contributed to typhus research, which carried an exceptionally high risk of laboratory infection. The work of five of them, Ida Bengtson (1881–1952), Muriel Robertson (1883–1973), Hilda Sikora (1889–1974), Hélène Sparrow (1891–1970) and Clara Nigg (1897–1986), is reviewed and the names of several others are mentioned. The lives of these women seem typical of rickettsiologists and reflect the disasters that befell the world during the first half of the twentieth century. Keywords: history of typhus; women scientists; Bengtson; Robertson; Sikora; Sparrow; Nigg Zusammenfassung Mehrere Wissenschafterinnen haben Beiträge zur Erforschung des Fleck- fiebers geleistet,was mit einem besonders hohen Infektionsrisiko verbunden war. Die Arbeiten von fünf dieser Frauen, Ida Bengtson (1881–1952), Muriel Robertson (1883–1973), Hilda Sikora (1889–1974), Hélène Sparrow (1891– 1970) und Clara Nigg (1897–1986), werden vorgestellt und die Namen ande- rer erwähnt. Die Lebensläufe dieser Frauen scheinen typisch für Rickett- sienforscher zu sein und widerspiegeln die Katastrophen der ersten Hälfte des zwanzigsten Jahrhunderts. * Acknowledgments: I would like to thank Heinz Arnheiter,Adrian Reuben,Arthur Silverstein, Catherine Thalmann and Monika Wiget for their help. Jean Lindenmann, Obere Geerenstrasse 34, CH-8044 Gockhausen (jean.lindenmann@access. unizh.ch). 257 Downloaded from Brill.com10/02/2021 01:25:51PM via free access Introduction Typhus, whose “tragic relationship to mankind” has been admirably de- scribed1, caused immense suffering in the first half of the 20th century. The Balkan Wars, the First World War, the Russian Revolution and the Second World War, each saw a resurgence of this dreaded disease, illustrating the statement that “the history of typhus is the history of human misery”2.
    [Show full text]