Modernizing National NOAA Modernizes Nautical Chart Production Mapping Workflow Implementing Next-Generation Charting System with PLTS for GIS Helps National Mapping Agencies Evolve Missions, ArcGIS—Nautical Solution Operations, and Service Delivery The Marine Chart Division (MCD) at NOAA Highlights National mapping agency: The name con- has embarked on an ambitious new deployment of GIS technology to create the next generation n Agencies are broadening their missions jures images of legions of cartographers labor- ing away at familiar maps of their respective of its Nautical Chart System (NCS II). MCD has while improving efficiency. used GIS for many years to improve workflows n Map and chart production timelines are countries—political, transportation, geologic, vegetation, and topographic. In truth, national and data management but wanted a commer- significantly reduced. mapping agencies (NMAs) have a vital and cial off-the-shelf enterprise-wide system for n Geographic data is more readily often underappreciated role in national gov- NCS II to gain efficiencies and streamline data exposed and shared with customers. ernment. They provide timely, relevant, and management and product generation. With the accurate geospatial intelligence in support of new system, NOAA MCD will continue to be continued on page 2 the world leader in hydrographic information management. Business Units Author, Serve, See the complete article on page 4. and Use Enterprise Content Aeronautical Transformation From Paper to Digits at the National Geospatial- Intelligence Agency By Charles L. (Chuck) McGaugh, Jr., Director, Office of Global Navigation, National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency
Transformation involves “a major change in form, nature, or function,” as defined byMer - riam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, Tenth Edition. Starting in early 2002, the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA) un- dertook a transformation in the way the agen- cy does business and supports customers by moving from a productcentric to a datacentric organization. The goal, in the words of former NGA director and retired Air Force Lt. Gen. James R. Clapper, Jr., was to provide customers “instant access to specific geo- spatial intelligence.” Headquartered in Bethesda, Maryland, NGA Enterprise GIS-based workflows help national mapping agencies meet growing customer is a U.S. Department of Defense combat support demand for more sophisticated products and greater access to data. continued on page 6
® ™ ESRI Ar c Ne w s Reprints • Vol. 29 No. 2 • Summer 2007
1 continued from page 1 Modernizing National Mapping Workflow economic development, scientific research, nat- delivered either as hard-copy maps or digital ticated products and greater access to the data. ural resource management, navigation, safety, files. Data was centered on the product sets There is growing recognition that the product- and national security. They are the leaders in and stored in a variety of databases and librar- centric system no longer meets customers’ collecting, managing, combining, and promot- ies while being processed by a disparate set of evolving demands nor is it efficient for the ing the use of accurate and up-to-date geospa- systems and tools. The specifications for these agencies. As geospatial information moves tial data for use by government, business, and products were fixed, with production require- from the realm of map publishing and special the public. Often, they are the only entity pro- ments established months or years in advance. projects to supporting mission-critical business viding these services. The acquisition of source material followed functions, customers require more content and similar timelines, and production processes currency, on-demand accessibility, and appli- Evolving Missions and Business Models depended heavily on manual operations. Cus- cation-ready formats. In many countries, there is more than one tomers ordered from an inventory of products This trend has led many NMAs to reevaluate NMA, with different agencies dedicated to and adapted them to their uses. how they interact with their customers. Many aeronautical, nautical, or topographic map- This business model is changing as the value agencies have taken steps to adapt their busi- ping. Most have focused on producing a lim- of geospatial information becomes more widely ness practices and production systems accord- ited number of standard products or series recognized and customers demand more sophis- ingly, but the demand for geospatial information
GIS-based systems simplify and accelerate map and chart production by helping mapping agencies streamline business processes, consoli- date data holdings across the enterprise, and standardize production workflows.
Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
2 3 is outstripping their ability to keep up with the • Facilitate collaboration between analysts environment. But while they are each differ- increasing sophistication of their customers. from different business units. ent in their specific data and map products and • Expose the enterprise data holdings within services based on whether their domain is aero- The Challenge the agencies, as well as among partners and nautical, topographic, or nautical, NMAs have To meet these demands, NMAs must achieve external customers. common business functions and associated pro- greater levels of performance and quality in • Facilitate data exchange among aeronauti- cesses and procedures. These include all business functions at an enterprise level. cal, nautical, and topographic agencies. Increasing staff or adding equipment resources • Retire legacy systems gracefully. • Defining their geography of interest can accomplish this in a limited way but are • Maximize the use of standards-based com- - Assembling information relating to the solutions with diminishing returns. To really mercial off-the-shelf (COTS) products. mapping task improve, agencies must - Assessing existing information sources Common Business Functions Among NMAs - Defining requirements for new geospatial • Streamline work processes. There is no single technical solution for all map- solutions • Increase accuracy and product quality. ping agencies. Each must adapt to the require- - Setting standards for new geospatial • Eliminate data redundancy between func- ments of its particular domain. Each must work solutions tional business units. within its own special business and regulatory continued on page 15
National mapping agencies provide timely, relevant, and accurate geospatial intelligence in support of economic development, scientific research, natural resource management, navigation, safety, and national security.
Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
2 3 continued from page 1 charts. The result will be the next generation of the hydrographic navigation environment, NOAA Modernizes the Nautical Chart System (NCS II). showing the nature and form of the coast; Nautical Chart Production MCD is a division in the Office of Coast the general configuration of the sea bottom, Survey (OCS), which is part of the National including water depths; locations of dangers Highlights Ocean Service (NOS), one of five NOAA to navigation; locations and characteristics line offices. NOS works to observe, -under of man-made aids to navigation; and other n GIS will be used to manage stand, and manage U.S. coastal and marine features useful to the mariner. In conjunc- production of nautical charts. resources, including navigation safety. OCS tion with supplemental navigational aids, the n Data is obtained from more than specifically oversees the Marine Transporta- nautical chart is used by the mariner to lay 50 entities. tion System. out courses and navigate ships by the short- n Project aims for gains in productivity NCS II will help MCD meet its critical est and most economical safe routes. and flexibility. challenge of providing navigation products that To produce these complex products, cover approximately 11 million square kilome- MCD uses source data including hydro- ters of coastal waters, including the Great Lakes graphic survey data, hazard updates, and The Marine Chart Division (MCD) at the Na- (areas collectively called the United States Ex- navigation aid information. From this data, tional Oceanic and Atmospheric Administra- clusive Economic Zone). Ninety-five percent MCD maintains a suite of more than 1,000 tion (NOAA) has embarked on an ambitious of U.S. commerce, by weight, travels through paper nautical charts and is in the process of new deployment of GIS technology in the these waters alongside 110,000 commercial providing complete coverage in Electronic management of hydrographic information and and recreational fishing vessels. continued on page 14 the production of digital and hard-copy nautical A nautical chart is a graphic portrayal of
The NCS II system uses PLTS for ArcGIS—Nautical Solution to create, manage, and publish hydrographic information in paper and ENC formats.
Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
4 5 Technology Solutions for National Mapping Agencies
While no one solution can fit all the require- ESRI has worked tirelessly implementing a national spatial data infra- ments of all national mapping agencies structure (NSDI) within their respective coun- (NMAs), ESRI has worked tirelessly to ensure to ensure its product suite tries to promote the interoperability of digital its product suite includes standards-based includes standards-based geographic data between various suppliers, COTS solutions that provide the foundational COTS solutions that provide agencies, and users. To support content dis- tools and specific technology that mapping the foundational tools and covery for an NSDI, ESRI offers GIS Portal agencies need. These solutions are special- Toolkit, a metadata catalog server extension ized applications built using ArcGIS. They specific technology that that supports metadata search services as a are designed to model and support particu- mapping agencies need. standard part of a GIS user’s Web site. This lar business functions and workflows with product includes many capabilities to do out-of-the-box tools that provide immedi- quality control (GIS Data ReViewer), carto- advanced searching, viewing, metadata har- ate business value. The following products graphic product generation (Map Production vesting, and other functions and supports have evolved out of repeated engagements System—Atlas), and workflow management FGDC and ISO metadata standards as well between the ESRI Professional Services orga- (Job Tracking for ArcGIS [JTX]). Foundation as OGC specifications: Web Catalog Service nization and key customers within particular provides users with a consistent, repeatable, (CS-W), Web Coverage Service (WCS), Web application areas. and well-managed production workflow. Feature Service (WFS), Web Map Content (WMC), and Web Map Service (WMS). Production Line Tool Set for ArcGIS Standards and Interoperability Production Line Tool Set (PLTS) for ArcGIS is Support for standards is an important part Support for Service-Oriented a suite of applications that organizes, man- of enabling interoperability, a crucial require- Architecture-Based Implementation ages, and enhances productivity for a multi- ment for NMAs. ESRI supports geospatial Service-oriented architecture (SOA) is a tude of map, chart, and database production standards from the Federal Geographic Data component-based software architecture activities. These applications provide flexible Committee (FGDC); International Hydro- model for enterprise application develop- workflow templates and data models that graphic Organization (IHO); International ment and integration. A service is a reusable help organize data automation, cartographic Organization for Standardization (ISO); Open component used in a business process and production, and data management. The PLTS Geospatial Consortium, Inc. (OGC); IT stan- generally defined according to Web service for ArcGIS suite includes specific solutions dards from Organization for the Advance- standards (SOAP, UDDI, WSDL, XML). Web for aeronautical, nautical, topographic, and ment of Structured Information Standards services are registered and loosely coupled, defense agencies. These solutions include (OASIS) and World Wide Web Consortium meaning that they can be combined and the generation of map series and data prod- (W3C); and various GIS-related domain stan- integrated on demand, increasingly on the ucts common to domains such as dards in its software. ESRI also offers various basis of an enterprise service bus integration interoperability enablers, such as direct read/ and messaging platform. • PLTS for ArcGIS—Nautical Solution lever- write of dozens of data formats; support for SOA delivers flexibility and enterprise agil- ages the PLTS for ArcGIS applications for hundreds of projections and datums; sup- ity, fostering collaboration, enabling interop- creation, management, and publication port for openly published data models; and erability across new and legacy systems, of hydrographic information in hard-copy, tools for spatial extraction, transformation, substantially reducing the cost and time of Electronic Navigation Chart (ENC), and and loading (ETL) of data. ArcGIS also sup- development, and generally better position- Digital Nautical Chart (DNC) formats. ports various metadata- and catalog-related ing an NMA to adapt to changing business • PLTS for ArcGIS—Aeronautical Solution specifications that provide practical ways conditions. Using an SOA, users can author provides end-to-end information manage- to publish, discover, and bind to geospatial and publish a variety of geospatial services. ment and support for standards-based data and services. These can be served to the larger enterprise, aeronautical charts and data exchange. ESRI leads and participates actively in where users can flexibly integrate them • PLTS for ArcGIS—Mapping Agency many of the standards committees and with new or legacy application services and Solution provides the database models, works closely with many draft standards. As thereby create new knowledge that enriches knowledge bases, and tools for topo- these standards are finalized, they are incor- the enterprise. ESRI is committed to ensuring graphic data and map production. porated into the entire ArcGIS product suite that its products and solutions are fully com- as required, including the solution products patible with SOA principles and standards. PLTS for ArcGIS—Foundation and mentioned above. Components More Information Each of the PLTS for ArcGIS solutions above Solutions for National Spatial Data For more information, visit www.esri.com/ comes with PLTS for ArcGIS—Foundation, Infrastructure nmasolutions. which includes tools for database editing, Many NMAs are the sole champions for
Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
4 5 continued from page 1 on a nationally and internationally mandated NGA standards and was similar across all schedule. The transformation began with the overlapping charts. Aeronautical implementation of GIS to change the way NGA The contractor used the data abstracts and/ Transformation Flight Information Publications (FLIPs) are or the hand-drawn lithographs to create sticky- produced and disseminated to customers. backed strip waxing (“stick-up”) film overlays Highlights for text and/or graphic symbols. Each change Outdated Processes was applied manually by scraping off old n NGA moved from a productcentric to a Until 2002, the process of producing NGA annotations and graphics and replacing them datacentric organization. FLIP global charts required a large staff of with the modification for the master versions n GIS changed the way flight informa- aeronautical analysts, quality assurance spe- of each chart. tion publications are produced and cialists, and contractor personnel. Significant With more than 1,000 changes per month, this distributed. effort and expertise were required for chart tedious process required great skill. Each of the n Geospatially enabled data enables fusion maintenance. Geographic area analysts used four colors used on charts required a separate with other data for additional analysis. drafting tools to create chart overlay litho- master layer, and screened colors required ad- graphs to meet precise standards. For less ditional layers. The stick-up overlays were then complex chart changes, the analyst crafted used as the positive in a photo process to create agency and a member of the national intelligence textually descriptive directions called data negatives for each layer for every chart. In the community. The agency’s mission is to provide abstracts using detailed format standards. busiest cycle, contractors produced more than timely, relevant, and accurate geospatial intel- Due to the complexity of the work and 145 charts with an average of six layers each. ligence in support of U.S. national security. technical writing involved, all information Accuracy was imperative to ensure the layers The agency’s mission includes providing received a second level of review by quality merged to form the completed Enroute Chart accurate aeronautical charts that are updated assurance specialists to ensure that it met when printed.
NGA has replaced its manual process for creating aeronautical charting products with a completely GIS-based process. Shown is an Enroute Chart being created using GIS. Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
6 7 With so many changes and the possibility of human error at many stages of production, A Brief History of Aeronautical Charting consistent quality required great effort. Review To understand the change that GIS has brought to the National Geospatial-Intelligence and rework prior to publication expended many Agency (NGA), it is helpful to be familiar with the history of aeronautical charting. work hours and required substantial lead time to Shortly after the Wright brothers made their historic first flights, the skies began to fill ensure the charts were finished before the next with aircraft. Visibility was the key navigational tool at that time. Aircraft were limited to cycle began. short flights in clear weather and used transportation routes to navigate by, flying low to the railroads during reduced visibility. Early pilots began making personal notes to help Sticky Crisis them navigate to and land at increasingly distant airports, and enterprising pilots sold these While the GIS and mapping community might notes to other pilots, but air travel remained limited by visibility. have been ready to support digital aeronautical In the 1930s, radio technology made it possible for pilots to navigate farther distances charting long before, it took a stick-up crisis to through unfamiliar surroundings in reduced visibility. In 1941, the first instrument approach force a change. The world’s only manufacturer and landing charts were developed, serving pilots with the need to land in low visibility. of stick-up stopped producing the material in By this time, aviation was a matter of interest worldwide. Many organizations began 2001, and a new supplier could not be found. All drafting standards for aviation-related maps, charts, and information. During World War remaining stock was purchased, but the clock II, the demand for charts increased dramatically. By 1943, production had increased from started ticking. There were no suitable substi- around 500,000 per year to more than 11 million. The U.S. Army and Navy air forces each tutes for the strip waxing film. A new method built their own custom charts to fit their wartime needs. for correcting the charts had to be found before By the end of the war, it was clear that standardized products and symbology were all the stick-up was gone. needed to support international air travel. The following years saw the establishment and maturity of many of the aeronautical- and aviation-related agencies and associations that A GIS solution was an obvious choice, but we see today, such as the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration and the United Nations there were many obstacles, most notably the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), each mandated to ensure the safe, effi- lack of data. An aeronautical database did ex- cient, and orderly evolution of international civil aviation. ist, it was kept current, and the attribution was Today, these organizations and others drive the look and feel of aviation products world- robust. The data quality was exceptional, but it wide. They have also mandated an update cycle to ensure that all aircraft are flying on was not geospatial. the same data. Depending on the region of the world, this cycle is effective every 28 days or multiples of 28 days. It is easy to see how a map of the world’s airports and airways, The Solution: Digital Enroute Charts updated every 28 days and limited by international standards, can become a huge chal- NGA’s Aeronautical Division turned to ESRI for lenge. This challenge is the mission of NGA’s Aeronautical Division. help in solving this critical problem. Together they worked on an ambitious program to create a completely GIS-based process to produce NGA from the NGA database to the geodatabase, NGA to give customers a variety of new aeronautical charting products. The foundation the change is automatically and immediately product options, from various digital formats of the approach was Production Line Tool Set reflected on all associated charts. Text associ- to various printing options. And now that the (PLTS) for ArcGIS—Aeronautical Solution, ated with modified features is automatically data has been transformed into geospatially which allowed NGA to develop a database- updated as well, using feature-linked annotation referenced digits, the data can be fused with driven system to support digital aeronautical capability. other information for additional analysis, chart production. The NGA aeronautical data- As a direct result of the automation, digital portrayals, and applications that have yet to base is imported into a geodatabase, and data is data is synchronized with the paper product, and be conceived. Using the geospatial knowledge preformatted for charts during the data ingest. product quality has dramatically improved. of NGA’s contracted experts, the aeronautical On a weekly basis, NGA provides database NGA continues to deliver hundreds of expertise of NGA analysts, and the power of updates, and these transactions are loaded into thousands of Enroute Charts to aviators every GIS, even the sky is no longer the limit. the geodatabase, which has been optimized for 28 days without delay, and the output product is cartographic output. Quality is ensured through so similar to the manually prepared charts that More Information several steps, and a Web-based scheduling tool customers never noticed. The digital Enroute Excerpted from “Aeronautical Transforma- monitors job progress, tracking every chart in Chart process supports direct-to-plate printing, tion: Paper to Digits—Changing the Way every phase of production. completely eliminating the need for film overlays the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency Using this foundation, NGA is able to produce and stick-up. Creates Aeronautical Products,” presented by charts of any scale, orientation, and projection, Charles L. (Chuck) McGaugh, Jr., at the 2004 in addition to the standard NGA series of aero- Success Transforms NGA ESRI International User Conference, available at nautical charts. PLTS for ArcGIS—Aeronautical to Datacentric Organization gis2.esri.com/library/userconf/proc04/docs/ Solution manages the chart series design and With NGA’s traditional methods, a large percent- pap2215.pdf. For more information, contact incorporates intelligent elements that are auto- age of energy was focused on the format and ap- the NGA Office of Corporate Affairs, Public matically updated based on the content in the pearance of products, rather than on the depth of Affairs Office (Web: www.nga.mil), or Brian geodatabase. knowledge behind the data. Through this effort, Cross, ESRI (e-mail: [email protected]; tel.: The database-driven system makes update its processes were transformed. Today, analysts 909-793-2853, ext. 1-1158). management many times more efficient than in devote their energy to creating and maintaining traditional manual chart production. Onetime quality aeronautical information. Technology data entry allows greater accuracy by eliminat- then transforms that quality data into a repre- ing the possibility of errors in the production sentation that the customer can utilize. chain. When a feature update is transferred The database-driven system also enables
Visit www.esri.com/nmasolutions.
6 7 GIS for National Mapping and Cartographic Production Modernizing National Mapping Workflows Air
Aeronautical The Challenges National mapping agencies face new and increasingly sophisticated customer demands, along with expanded responsibilities. To meet these challenges, they need to s )MPLEMENT WORK PROCESSES THAT ARE SIMPLE flexible, and measurable. s )NCREASE ACCURACY AND PRODUCT QUALITY WITH MORE automation. s %LIMINATE DATA REDUNDANCY BETWEEN FUNCTIONAL business units. s &ACILITATE