DOCSLIB.ORG

Barebacking and Sexual Position: an Analysis of the Personal Accounts of HIV-Negative and Unknown Status Gay Men Who Have Condomless Anal Sex

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Barebacking and Sexual Position: an Analysis of the Personal Accounts of HIV-Negative and Unknown Status Gay Men Who Have Condomless Anal Sex City Research Online City, University of London Institutional Repository Citation: Grundy-Bowers, M.C.S. (2014). Barebacking and sexual position: An analysis of the personal accounts of HIV-negative and unknown status gay men who have condomless anal sex. (Unpublished Doctoral thesis, City University London) This is the accepted version of the paper. This version of the publication may differ from the final published version. Permanent repository link: https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/11872/ Link to published version: Copyright: City Research Online aims to make research outputs of City, University of London available to a wider audience. Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the author(s) and/or copyright holders. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and linked to. Reuse: Copies of full items can be used for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-profit purposes without prior permission or charge. Provided that the authors, title and full bibliographic details are credited, a hyperlink and/or URL is given for the original metadata page and the content is not changed in any way. City Research Online: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/ [email protected] CITY UNIVERSITY LONDON Barebacking and sexual position: An analysis of the personal accounts of HIV-negative and unknown status gay men who have condomless anal sex Matthew Christopher Stuart Grundy-Bowers A thesis submitted to City University London in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Public Health School of Health Sciences April 2014 CONTENTS Tables and illustrations ............................................................................................................... vii Figures .................................................................................................................................... vii Tables ...................................................................................................................................... vii Dedication .................................................................................................................................. viii Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................... ix Declaration .................................................................................................................................... x Abstract ........................................................................................................................................ xi Abbreviations and key terms ...................................................................................................... xii AbbreviationS ......................................................................................................................... xii Key terms............................................................................................................................... xiii Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 1 1.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 1 1.2 SECTION one: background to the study .............................................................................. 3 1.2.1 THE origins of the research .............................................................................................. 3 1.2.2 BAREBACKING: a contested concept ............................................................................... 6 1.2.3 The origins of barebacking ............................................................................................... 7 1.2.4 Barebacking: evolving use of the term ............................................................................ 7 1.2.5 Professional conceptualisations of barebacking .............................................................. 8 1.2.6 The prevalence of barebacking ........................................................................................ 9 1.2.6.1 Population and geographical considerations ..................................................... 11 1.2.7 Professional perceptions of those who have bareback sex ........................................... 12 1.2.8 HIV: an overview ............................................................................................................ 14 1.2.8.1 Transmission ........................................................................................................... 15 1.2.9 The prevalence of HIV and other sti’s among MSM ...................................................... 17 1.2.9.1 The prevalence of HIV among MSM ....................................................................... 18 1.2.9.2 The prevalence of sexually transmitted infections among MSM ........................... 19 1.2.10 HIV: a public health priority ......................................................................................... 21 1.3 Section two: A review of The literature ................................................................................ 22 1.3.1 The search strategy ........................................................................................................ 22 1.3.2 A description of the studies ........................................................................................... 27 1.3.3 A discussion of the findings of these studies ................................................................. 27 1.3.3.1 Theme 1: the management of risk .......................................................................... 27 i 1.3.3.2 Theme 2: The meanings men ascribe to bareback sex ........................................... 30 1.3.3.3 Theme 3: Barebacking in romantic relationships ................................................... 33 1.3.3.4 Theme 4: The negotiation of bareback sex ............................................................. 35 1.3.3.5 tHEME 5: Substance use and bareback sex............................................................. 36 1.3.3.6 Theme 6: Affective states and bareback sex ........................................................... 37 1.3.3.7 Theme 7: The spaces where individuals connect with partners ............................. 38 1.3.3.8 Theme 8: Partner attributes and bareback sex ....................................................... 40 1.4 The location of this study within the existing literature ....................................................... 40 1.4.1 The thorny issue of HIV .................................................................................................. 41 1.4.2 the top and bottom of sexual position .......................................................................... 42 1.4.3 The interconnectedness of factors associated with bareback sex ................................ 44 1.5 Aims and objectives .............................................................................................................. 46 1.5.1 Aims ................................................................................................................................ 46 1.5.2 Objectives ....................................................................................................................... 46 1.6 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................. 47 Method and methodology ......................................................................................................... 48 2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 48 2.2 Methodological considerations .................................................................................... 49 2.2.1 Epistemological position ................................................................................................ 50 2.2.2 Phenomenology ......................................................................................................... 50 2.2.3 Hermeneutics ................................................................................................................. 53 2.2.4 Ideography ..................................................................................................................... 54 2.2.5 guidelines for conducting the research ......................................................................... 54 2.2.6 Sampling ......................................................................................................................... 55 2.2.7 The Collection of data .................................................................................................... 55 2.2.8 The Analysis .................................................................................................................... 56 2.2.9 The presentation of self in everyday life ........................................................................ 58 2.2.10 Sexual Script Theory ..................................................................................................... 59 2.2.10.1 Intrapsychic scripts (experience) .......................................................................... 60 2.2.10.2 Interpersonal scripts (relationships) ..................................................................... 60 2.2.10.3 Intersubjective cultural surround ........................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • John's Schools & Why Men Pay For
    JOHN'S SCHOOLS & WHY MEN PAY FOR SEX by Michael E. Holtby, LCSW, BCD INTRODUCTION In this article I want to discuss the use of John's Schools, a diversion program which has become popular throughout the United States, as a way to deal with the customers of prostitution. However, in order to properly address John's Schools as an intervention strategy we must first understand what motivates men to seek anonymous sex. There are two conclusions from my experience with five hundred Johns: first, these men are not one group with one set of motivations and psychodynamics. If they have anything in common, besides the fact that they all paid for a sexual experience, it's that they all have an "attachment disorder" or some impairment in their ability to handle emotionally relational sex, or intimate relationships. However, to compare the "monger" or "hobbiest" who organizes much of his life around this activity, to the opportunist who impulsively pulls his car over when a woman waves at him from the sidewalk, is to ignore obvious differences. Likewise when designing a response to reducing the demand for commercial sex, specifically when addressing first time offenders, we need to design a program that recognizes that one size does not fit all. The most effective way to do this is to provide, in addition to an educational component, sessions with a psychotherapist to individually assess the underlying dynamics and provide counseling and referrals for further treatment. When compared with the current consequence in Denver for first time offenders - a $500 fine - John's School, as alternative sentencing seems much more relevant, and has proven in other cities to reduce their chance of reoffending by half.
    [Show full text]
  • Sexual Behavior Among 1
    Sexual Behavior Among 1 Sexual Behavior Among Costa Ricans and Euro-Americans Gloriana Rodríguez Arauz A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Health Psychology Department of Psychology Central Connecticut State University New Britain, Connecticut April 2010 Thesis Advisor Dr. Marisa Mealy Department of Psychology Sexual Behavior Among 2 Sexual Behavior Among Costa Ricans and Euro-Americans Gloriana Rodríguez Arauz An Abstract of a Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Health Psychology Department of Psychology Central Connecticut State University New Britain, Connecticut April 2010 Thesis Advisor Dr. Marisa Mealy Department of Psychology Key Words: Sexual Behavior, Culture, Costa Rica, United States Sexual Behavior Among 3 Abstract Sex is a vital part of oneself. Due to its biological and social functions, sex has a profound impact on an individual‟s physical and psychological health. Risky sexual behavior may have particularly harmful consequences, including contracting HIV/AIDS or other sexually transmitted infections, lowered self-esteem, unwanted pregnancy, and the experience of social stigma. There are moral battles fought over sex education or abstinence only programs, yet what exactly is understood by the word “sex” is often left to the interpretation of the individual. In fact, although evidence suggests that there is a high level of agreement indicating that both penile-vaginal and anal intercourse are considered “having sex,” this consensus does not extend to other behaviors, such as oral sex (Randall & Byers, 2003; Trotter & Alderson, 2007). Several factors are believed to influence variations in definitions of sex, including perceptions of behavioral appropriateness, the level of commitment in a relationship, and gender.
    [Show full text]
  • Conceptualized Heterosexual Theory and Identity Development
    Running head: CONCEPTUALIZED HETEROSEXUAL THEORY Conceptualized Heterosexual Theory and Identity Development Breyan N. Haizlip Georgia Southern University Scott Schaefle University of Colorado Denver Danica Hays Old Dominion University Jennifer Cates Regis University Authors Note Breyan N. Haizlip, Department of Leadership, Technology, and Human Development, Georgia Southern University. Danica Hays, Department of Counseling and Human Services, Old Dominion University Jennifer Cates, Division for Counseling and Family Therapy, Regis University This research project was partially funded by a grant from the Southern Association of Counselor Education and Supervision. Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Breyan Haizlip, Georgia Southern University, P.O. Box 8131, Statesboro, GA 30458. E-mail: [email protected] CONCEPTUALIZED HETEROSEXUAL THEORY 2 Abstract Through the use of consensual qualitative research and interpretative phenomenology, the present study examined how 50 heterosexually identified counselors-trainees conceptualized their sexual identity development. The results provide support for Conceptualized Heterosexual Theory, which indicates that how heterosexual counselors conceptualize their sexual identity is related to four developmental dimensions: inherent orientation responses, pre-conceptualized heterosexuality, heterosexual identity development, and identification, directed towards 3 distinct identities: interdependent heterosexuality, independent heterosexuality, and unresolved heterosexuality.
    [Show full text]
  • (YMSM) to Develop Ideas on Using the Internet for HIV Prevention
    Creating Space for Young Men Who Have Sex with Men (YMSM) to Develop Ideas on Using the Internet for HIV Prevention Dinar Saurmauli Lubis A thesis submitted to Auckland University of Technology in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) 2018 Faculty of Health and Environmental Science Abstract The prevalence rate of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) infection among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Bali, Indonesia, is currently estimated at 20% (Bali Province Health Office [BPHO, 2016c]). This is significantly higher than HIV prevalence among this cohort at the national level (8.5%) and in other South-East Asian countries such as the Philippines (1.7%), Thailand (7.1%) and Vietnam (4.0%). Given relatively high rates of HIV infection among YMSM in Bali, preventing the spread of the disease among this community is vital. In recent years, Internet-based initiatives have been gaining popularity as tools for HIV prevention among YMSM as they potentially provide a convenient, easily accessible and anonymous social space for individuals requiring information and advice compared to face-to-face venues – as well as potentially providing much-needed advocacy and support. However, research on Internet-based initiatives for HIV prevention is still in its infancy, and this is true for Indonesia. Further, in order to be effective HIV prevention must be based on YMSM’s unique needs and characteristics, as evidence shows that it is essential to relate the target group’s needs to the social context. Normative sexuality in communities which endorse a heterosexual norm, often have an implication for risk and vulnerability of YMSM as well as for HIV prevention.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reconstruction of Gender and Sexuality in a Drag Show*
    DUCT TAPE, EYELINER, AND HIGH HEELS: THE RECONSTRUCTION OF GENDER AND SEXUALITY IN A DRAG SHOW* Rebecca Hanson University of Montevallo Montevallo, Alabama Abstract. “Gender blending” is found on every continent; the Hijras in India, the female husbands in Navajo society, and the travestis in Brazil exemplify so-called “third genders.” The American version of a third gender may be drag queen performers, who confound, confuse, and directly challenge commonly held notions about the stability and concrete nature of both gender and sexuality. Drag queens suggest that specific gender performances are illusions that require time and effort to produce. While it is easy to dismiss drag shows as farcical entertainment, what is conveyed through comedic expression is often political, may be used as social critique, and can be indicative of social values. Drag shows present a protest against commonly held beliefs about the natural, binary nature of gender and sexuality systems, and they challenge compulsive heterosexuality. This paper presents the results of my observational study of drag queens. In it, I describe a “routine” drag show performance and some of the interactions and scripts that occur between the performers and audience members. I propose that drag performers make dichotomous American conceptions of sexuality and gender problematical, and they redefine homosexuality and transgenderism for at least some audience members. * I would like to thank Dr. Stephen Parker for all of his support during the writing of this paper. Without his advice and mentoring I could never have started or finished this research. “Gender blending” is found on every continent. The Hijras in India, the female husbands in Navajo society, and the travestis in Brazil are just a few examples of peoples and practices that have been the subjects for “third gender” studies.
    [Show full text]
  • What College Women Do and Do Not Experience As Rape
    Psychology of Women Quarterly, 28 (2004), 9–15. Blackwell Publishing. Printed in the USA. Copyright C 2004 Division 35, American Psychological Association. 0361-6843/04 2003 CAROLYN SHERIF AWARD ADDRESS: WHAT COLLEGE WOMEN DO AND DO NOT EXPERIENCE AS RAPE Arnold S. Kahn James Madison University College women who did (n = 33) and did not (n = 56) label their sexual assault experience as rape provided written descriptions of their sexual assaults. From these descriptions we identified eight different sexual assault situations. Women who labeled their experience as rape were most likely to have been assaulted forcefully by an acquaintance, awakened to an acquaintance performing sexual acts on them, or experienced the assault as a child. Women were least likely to call their experience rape if they submitted to a whining, begging boyfriend, gave in to a man because of being emotionally needy, were assaulted by a boyfriend, were severely impaired by alcohol or drugs and unable to resist, or were forced to engage in oral or digital sex. Observers who read these descriptions generally agreed with the victims regarding whether or not the experience constituted rape, although they could not agree on whether or not forced oral or digital intercourse or forced intercourse by a boyfriend constituted rape. Since 1989, together with my colleagues and students, I enced acts that seemed to fit the legal definition of rape, but have conducted research on rape and sexual assault. One who did not conceive of themselves as victims or survivors of particular stream of this research has focused on what de- rape.
    [Show full text]
  • Semen Arousal: Its Prevalence, Relationship to HIV Risk Practices
    C S & lini ID ca A l f R o e l s Klein, J AIDS Clin Res 2016, 7:2 a e Journal of n a r r DOI: 10.4172/2155-6113.1000546 c u h o J ISSN: 2155-6113 AIDS & Clinical Research Research Article Open Access Semen Arousal: Its Prevalence, Relationship to HIV Risk Practices, and Predictors among Men Using the Internet to Find Male Partners for Unprotected Sex Hugh Klein* Kensington Research Institute, USA Abstract Purpose: This paper examines the extent to which men who use the Internet to find other men for unprotected sex are aroused by semen. It also looks at the relationship between semen arousal and involvement in HIV risk practices, and the factors associated with higher levels of semen arousal. Methods: 332 men who used any of 16 websites targeting unprotected sex completed 90-minute telephone interviews. Both quantitative and qualitative data were collected. A random sampling strategy was used. Semen arousal was assessed by four questions asking men how much they were turned on by the way that semen smelled, tasted, looked, and felt. Results: 65.1% of the men found at least one sensory aspect of semen to be “fairly” or “very” arousing, compared to 10.2% being “not very” or “not at all” aroused by all four sensory aspects of semen. Multivariate analysis revealed that semen arousal was related to greater involvement in HIV risk practices, even when the impact of other salient factors such as demographic characteristics, HIV serostatus, and psychological functioning was taken into account. Five factors were found to underlie greater levels of semen arousal: not being African American, self-identification as a sexual “bottom,” being better educated, being HIV-positive, and being more depressed.
    [Show full text]
  • Spontaneous Erection and Masturbation in Equids. AAEP
    Spontaneous Erection and Masturbation in Equids Sue M. McDonnell, Ph.D.* INTRODUCTION Spontaneous erection accompanied by an activity thought to be and referred to as masturbation occurs in stallions. Spontaneous erection involves extension of the penis from the prepuce with engorgement to its full length and rigidity, in a solitary, rather than heterosexual, context. The activity known as masturbation involves rhyth- mic bouncing, pressing, or sliding of the erect penis against the abdomen achieved by rhythmic contraction of the ischiocavernosus muscles and/or pelvic thrusting (Fig. 1). With such stimulation, the glans penis usually enlarges as during copulation, and pre- sperm fluid may drip from the urethra. This behavior in horses seems analogous to spontaneous erection and masturbation noted in several other mammalian species. I-’ The significance of spontaneous erection and masturbation in horses, as in other species, is not well understood. Traditional views of spontaneous erection and mas- turbation in domestic horses follow those held for similar behavior observed in other domestic and captive wild animals. One theme is that these are aberrant behaviors, similar to other stable vices, resulting from regimentation or restricted activity of cap- tive or domesticexistence. 4-6Another theme is that spontaneous erection and mastur- bation represent an expression or “venting” of sexual frustration resulting either from inherent hypersexuality or from thwarted access to heterosexual activity. 6v7Further, it has been asserted that masturbation limits the potential fertility of an individual stal- lion by depleting semen reserves and sexual energy. Accordingly, spontaneous erec- tion and masturbation in horses are often discouraged. An array of management schemes and devices such as stallion rings, brushes, and cages have been employed to inhibit spontaneous erection and disrupt masturbation.8 Attempts to inhibit sponta- neous erection and masturbation involve considerable management effort as well as risk of genital injury to the horse.
    [Show full text]
  • 2008 Annual Report GMHC Fights to End the AIDS Epidemic and Uplift the Lives of All Affected
    web of truth 2008 annual report GMHC fights to end the AIDS epidemic and uplift the lives of all affected. From Crisis to Wisdom 2 Message from the Chief Executive Officer and the Chair of the Board of Directors 3 From Education to Legislation 4 From Baby Boo to Baby Boom 6 From Connection to Prevention 8 From Hot Meals to Big Ideals 10 The Frontlines of HIV Prevention 12 Financial Summary 2008 14 Corporate & Foundation Supporters 15 The Founders’ Circle 17 Individual Donors 18 The President’s Council / Friends for Life / Allies Monthly Benefactors / Partners in Planning Event Listings 23 House Tours / Fashion Forward / Savor Toast at Twilight / AIDS Walk 2008 GMHC fights to end the AIDS epidemic and uplift the lives of all affected. Gender 76% Male 23% Female 1% Transgender Race/Ethnicity 31% Black 31% White 30% Latino 3% Asian/Pacific Islander 5% Other/Unknown Sexual Orientation 56% Gay/Lesbian 9% Bisexual 35% Heterosexual Age 19% 29 and under 21% 30–39 33% 40–49 27% 50 and over Residence 14% Bronx 20% Brooklyn 47% Manhattan 12% Queens 1% Staten Island 6% Outside NYC 1 from crisis to wisdom HIV is a disease that thrives in darkness. In For 27 years, GMHC has born witness to HIV silence. In apathy. It thrives when connections from its frontlines. And in those 27 years, remain unseen—when the links between we’ve charted a pandemic that changes con- individuals and communities…between social tinuously and profoundly. Its demographics lives and sexual lives remain broken and have changed. Its challenges have changed.
    [Show full text]
  • Commentary Unprotected: Condoms, Bareback Porn, and the First Amendment
    Commentary Unprotected: Condoms, Bareback Porn, and the First Amendment Bailey J. Langnert ABSTRACT In November 2012, Los Angeles County voters passed Measure B, or the Safer Sex in the Adult Film Industry Act. Measure B mandated condom use by all porn performers in adult films produced within county borders and created a complex regulatory process for adult film producers that included permitting, mandatory public health trainings, and warrantless administrative searches. Shortly after its passage, Vivid Entertainment filed a lawsuit to enjoin the enforcement of Measure B, arguing that the Measure violated their First Amendment right to portray condomless sex in porn. In December 2014, the Ninth Circuit upheld the district court's decision upholding the constitutionality of Measure B. Notably, the mainstream discourse surrounding the Measure B campaign, as well as the legal arguments put forth in the lawsuit, focused exclusively on straight pornography while purporting to represent all porn. As a result, an entire genre of condomless pornography went unrepresented in the discussion: bareback porn, which portrays intentional unprotected anal sex between men. Excluding bareback porn from the lawsuit represented a missed opportunityfor Vivid in its challenge of Measure B. There are several political messages underlying bareback porn unique to that genre that might have resulted in the t The author received a law degree from the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law (Boalt Hall) in 2015. As a law student, the author worked as a Teaching Assistant in the First Year Legal Writing Program and served as a Senior Board Member of the Boalt Hall Women's Association.
    [Show full text]
  • Sexual Adventurism Cover 2
    Sexual AdventurismAdventurism among Sydney gay men Gary Smith Heather Worth Susan Kippax Sexual adventurismadventurism among Sydney gay men Gary Smith Heather Worth Susan Kippax Monograph 3/2004 National Centre in HIV Social Research Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences The University of New South Wales Copies of this monograph or any other publication from this project may be obtained by contacting: National Centre in HIV Social Research Level 2, Webster Building The University of New South Wales Sydney NSW 2052 AUSTRALIA Telephone: (61 2) 9385 6776 Fax: (61 2) 9385 6455 [email protected] nchsr.arts.unsw.edu.au © National Centre in HIV Social Research 2004 ISBN 1 875978 78 X The National Centre in HIV Social Research is funded by the Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing and is affiliated with the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences at the University of New South Wales. CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ii report summary 1 KEY FINDINGS 1 Part 1 Sexual adventurism and subculture 1 Part 2 Sexual practice and risk 1 Part 3 Drug use 2 RECOMMENDATIONS 3 introduction 5 background and method 7 BACKGROUND 7 Defining ‘culture’ and ‘subculture’ 8 METHOD 9 Recruitment and data analysis 9 The sample 9 thematic analysis 11 PART 1 SEXUAL ADVENTURE AND SUBCULTURE 11 Adventurism as non-normative sex 11 Individual and group change over time 13 Adventurous spaces for sex 15 Transgression 15 A subculture of sexual adventurism 16 PART 2 SEXUAL ADVENTURISM AND SAFE SEX 19 Casual sex, adventurism and risk 20 HIV-negative men and unsafe sex 20 HIV-positive men and unsafe sex 22 Disclosure of HIV status: a double bind 25 PART 3 DRUG USE AND ADVENTUROUS SEX 26 Managing drug use 27 Sexual safety and drug use 29 REFERENCES 31 i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This report is the product of the efforts many people.
    [Show full text]
  • Condomless Group Sex Is Associated with Hiv Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis Knowledge and Interest Uptake: a Cross-Sectional Study Of
    AIDS Education and Prevention, 31(2), 127–135, 2019 © 2019 The Guilford Press CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY CALLANDER ET AL. CONDOMLESS GROUP SEX IS ASSOCIATED WITH HIV PRE-EXPOSURE PROPHYLAXIS KNOWLEDGE AND INTEREST UPTAKE: A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY OF GAY AND BISEXUAL MEN IN PARIS, FRANCE Denton Callander, Su Hyun Park, Yazan A. Al-Ajlouni, John A. Schneider, Maria R. Khan, PhD, Steven A. Safren, and Dustin T. Duncan As a prevention strategy, HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) may benefit men who participate in group sex, but little is known about PrEP among this group internationally and virtually nothing is known of the European context. This study used an online survey of gay men living in Paris, France to assess associations between group sex and awareness of, use and interest in PrEP in its once-daily, episodic, injectable, and microbicidal forms. Men reporting recent (within 3 months) condomless group sex were much more likely to report once-daily PrEP use than men with no group sex experience (41.5% vs 7.7%, p < .001). Uptake was similarly low among men who had group sex with condoms (8.0%) and those with less-recent experience (6.43%). Overall, willingness to use PrEP—including its non-daily forms— was high among men reporting group sex, suggesting opportunities for outreach and implementation. Keywords: pre-exposure prophylaxis, condoms, MSM, collective sex, Europe Wow, having group sex to me means different things: certainly, part of it is, um, an element of freedom in being able to understand my own body, relating to oth- ers, and being able to experience other people sharing their bodies with a group.
    [Show full text]