Social Network Analysis of Researchers' Communication And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 6-16-2014 Social Network Analysis of Researchers' Communication and Collaborative Networks Using Self-reported Data Oguz Cimenler University of South Florida, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the Industrial Engineering Commons Scholar Commons Citation Cimenler, Oguz, "Social Network Analysis of Researchers' Communication and Collaborative Networks Using Self-reported Data" (2014). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/5201 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Social Network Analysis of Researchers’ Communication and Collaborative Networks Using Self-reported Data by Oguz Cimenler A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Industrial and Management Systems Engineering College of Engineering University of South Florida Major Professor: Kingsley A. Reeves, Jr., Ph.D. José Zayas-Castro, Ph.D. Alex Savachkin, Ph.D. Adriana Iamnitchi, Ph.D. John Skvoretz, Ph.D. Date of Approval: June 16, 2014 Keywords: Informetrics, individual innovativeness, exponential random graph models (ERGMs), Poisson regression analysis, structural equation modeling Copyright © 2014, Oguz Cimenler DEDICATION I dedicate this dissertation to my adorable wife, Ummuhan Cimenler, who was always supportive to me during my study, to my beloved parents, Cumali and Emine Cimenler, particularly to my father, Cumali Cimenler, who is currently struggling with lung cancer, and to my dear brother, Omer Cimenler. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I cannot express the degree of my gratitude to my adviser, Dr. Kingsley A. Reeves, who has encouraged and supported me at the times that I most needed. To prosper in my study, he always challenged me in a positive and constructive way, which was neither obstructive nor demanding. I am very fortunate to have such an important scholar in the field of Social Network Analysis as Dr. John Skvoretz, on my dissertation committee. He was always helpful and guided me with his key and fruitful comments about my research. I would like to thank Dr. Alex Savachkin, Dr. Jose Zayas-Castro, and Dr. Adriana Iamnitchi for serving on my research committee and giving me valuable comments and feedbacks during the development stages of my research. Especially, I would like to make special thank you to Dr. Alex Savachkin for his motivational support during course of my study. I also would like thank to all of tenured and tenured-track faculty members in the University of South Florida’s College of Engineering. They have dedicated their time, energy and effort by filling out to my questionnaire which was one of the core tools I used in my study. Particularly, I would like to thank to Dr. Ali Yalcin and Dr. Gokhan Mumcu for their feedbacks and comments during the pilot-study stage of my questionnaire. Finally, I would like to thank to Dr. John Kuhn for being the chair of my dissertation defense meeting and Ms. Catherine Burton and Dr. Anna Dixon for her patience and corrections on my dissertation draft. TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ......................................................................................................................... iii LIST OF FIGURES .........................................................................................................................v ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................... vi CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................1 1.1. Statement of the Research Problem ..............................................................................1 1.2. Proposed Solution .........................................................................................................7 1.3. Statement of Research Objectives ..............................................................................10 CHAPTER 2: AN EVALUATION OF COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH IN A COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING: A SOCIAL NETWORK APPROACH.................................................15 2.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................15 2.2. Literature Review and Hypotheses .............................................................................16 2.2.1. The Field of Informetrics .............................................................................16 2.2.2. Scientific Collaboration ...............................................................................17 2.2.3. Relationship between Researchers’ Communication and Their Collaborative Outputs ..................................................................................18 2.2.4. Relationship between Researchers’ Demographic Attributes and Their Collaborative Outputs ..................................................................................21 2.3. Method ........................................................................................................................23 2.3.1. Sample and Questionnaire ...........................................................................23 2.3.2. Data Collection ............................................................................................26 2.3.3. Constructing Social Network Data Matrixes ...............................................28 2.4. Results .........................................................................................................................30 2.4.1. Visual Inspection of Networks.....................................................................30 2.4.2. Statistical and Descriptive Properties of Networks .....................................31 2.4.3. Network Comparisons .................................................................................38 2.4.4. Network Prediction ......................................................................................40 2.4.5. Centrality Comparisons ...............................................................................54 2.5. Discussion ...................................................................................................................59 i CHAPTER 3: A REGRESSION ANALYSIS OF RESEARCHERS’ SOCIAL NETWORK METRICS ON THEIR CITATION PERFORMANCE IN A COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING ......................................................................................................................69 3.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................69 3.2. Literature Review and Hypotheses .............................................................................70 3.2.1. A Performance Measure of Researchers: h-index .......................................70 3.2.2. Social Network Metrics ...............................................................................71 3.3. Method ........................................................................................................................75 3.3.1. Constructing Data Sets for Statistical Model ...............................................75 3.3.2. Poisson Regression Model ...........................................................................76 3.4. Results .........................................................................................................................77 3.5. Discussion ...................................................................................................................80 CHAPTER 4: A STRUCTURAL EQUATION MODEL TO TEST THE IMPACT OF RESEARCHERS’ INDIVIDUAL INNOVATIVENESS ON THEIR COLLABORATIVE OUTPUTS .............................................................................................85 4.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................85 4.2. Literature Review and Hypotheses .............................................................................86 4.2.1. The Effect of Individual Innovativeness (Iinnov) on Researchers’ Collaborative Outputs (CO) .........................................................................86 4.2.2. Tie Strength of an Individual to Other Conversational Partners (TS) .........92 4.3. Method ........................................................................................................................94 4.3.1. Constructing Dataset for Statistical Model ..................................................94 4.3.2. Statistical Model ..........................................................................................95 4.4. Results .........................................................................................................................95 4.4.1. Partial Least Squares (PLS) Path Models ....................................................95 4.4.2. Analysis of Partial Least Squares (PLS) Models .........................................98 4.4.2.1. Assessment of Measurement Models............................................98 4.4.2.2. Assessment of Structural Models................................................100 4.5. Discussion .................................................................................................................104