In ancient times, citizens sought answers to their most important inquiries by consulting oracles. Myths were part of daily life, and mythological creatures People living with HIV/AIDS were feared or defeated. Oedipus deciphered the riddle of the Sphinx, a 34 million creature that was part primate (human) and part feline (lion). In modern times, people living with HIV/AIDS worldwide in 2011 many astute scientists have worked diligently to decipher a modern riddle, Number of people (all ages) living with HIV i.e., understanding human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and using this Mortality knowledge to halt the AIDS pandemic. Although we endeavor to solve this 1.7 million riddle with the tools of science, we should keep in mind that, like Oedipus, we people died of AIDS-related illnesses worldwide in 2011 may find clues hidden in the intricate biology of primate and feline lentiviruses. Number of deaths due to HIV
Going Wild: Lessons from Naturally Occurring T-Lymphotropic Lentiviruses. VandeWoude & Apretrei Clinical Microbiology Reviews 27:728 (2014) Retroviruses • Over 40 nonhuman primate (NHP) species harbor species-specific simian Subfamily: Spumaretrovirinae (1 Genus) immunodeficiency viruses (SIVs). Subfamily: Orthoretrovirinae (6 Genera) Genus: Alpharetrovirus (9 Species) • More than 20 species of nondomes c Genus: Betaretrovirus (5 Species) felids and African canids demonstrate Genus: Deltaretrovirus (4 Species) seroreac vity against feline Genus: Epsilonretrovirus (3 Species) immunodeficiency virus (FIV) an gens. Genus: Gammaretrovirus (17 Species) • Rarely detected increased morbidity or Genus: Lentivirus (9 Species) impaired fecundity/survival of naturally infected SIV- or FIV-seroposi ve versus -seronega ve animals Len viruses • Cross-species transmissions of these Species: Bovine immunodeficiency virus agents are rare in nature Species: Caprine arthritis encephalitis virus • len viral infec ons have been Species: Equine infectious anemia virus iden fied in horses, goats, sheep, and Species: Feline immunodeficiency virus ca le, the majority of these infec ons Species: Human immunodeficiency virus 1 appear to be clinically silent Species: Human immunodeficiency virus 2 Species: Puma lentivirus • Sheep and Goat len viral infec ons Species: Simian immunodeficiency virus may result in neurological disorders, Species: Visna/maedi virus arthri s, and pneumonia, while horse len viral infec ons result in recurrent fever and blood diseases HIV-1 Entry • HIV, and other primate lentiviruses, infects CD4+ T lymphocytes and will cause them to die during a productive infection. • HIV infects other cells but does not cause cell death, at least at the same rate as CD4 T cells: – Natural killer cells – CD8+ killer T-cells – Macrophages – Cell of the nervous system (e.g., astrocytes, neurons, glial cells, and brain macrophages) – Dendritic cells HIV Entry
• The infectious virus is always specific for CD4 and CCR5 present on memory T cells and macrophages • The rapid progression to AIDS can be associated with a switch in co-receptor preference to CXCR4 • HIV enters cells via a cellular receptor and co-receptor – Major cellular receptor: CD4 present on T-lymphocytes (also present in low concentrations on macrophages) – Co-receptor on T lymphocytes: CCR5 (memory) or CXCR4 (naïve) – Co-receptor on macrophages: CCR5 Schematic of HIV Virion
Different HIV particles have highly variable protein spikes, Glycoprotein 120 or gp120 and random mutations in the HIV genome causes random changes in the structure of the spikes on different HIV virion. Extends out from the viral envelope as a trimer. The CD4 molecule interacts with gp120 The structure of CD4 CD4’s role in antigen recognition The union between HIV and its host T-lymphocyte GP120 trimers bind with CD4 and change shape gp120 interacts with CCR5 or CXCR4 (fusins), causing further shape changes and causes the viral gp41 trimers to be exposed
The gp41 molecule darts out and pierces the cell membrane of the macrophage or T-lymphocyte.
CD4 Viral envelope and cell membrane lipids fuse, delivering the HIV nucleocapsid into the cytoplasm HIV membrane fusion
The infec on with HIV1 isini ated by the interac on of viral gp120 envelope protein with CD4 protein expressed mainly by cells of the T lymphocyte and macrophage lineages. The interac on between gp120 and CD4 induces a conforma onal change in gp41, resul ng in the inser on of the N-terminal hydrophobic fusion-pep de region into cell membrane. Further intra-protein interac on between the N- and C-terminal of the gp41 ectodomain regulates the membrane fusion and the entry of HIV contents into cytoplasm. Besides the CD4 receptor, coreceptors CCR5 or CXXR4 also help the entry of HIV. The binding of gp120 to CD4 and its affinity for coreceptor largely depend on the sequence pa ern of its V3 and V4 variable regions. The replication cycle of HIV 1 and 2
Uncoating Removal of the genome from the nucleocapsid. Cellular enzymes strip the protein capsid away and the genome is released.
Capsid removal When the capsid is removed, RNA, two proteins (p24 and p17), and reverse transcriptase are released
Synthesis of viral nucleic acid and protein ssRNA is reverse transcribed into a dsDNA strand, which migrates to the nucleus of the host cell The DNA molecule is incorporated into the cell’s DNA at a random site by integrase, and becomes part of the cell’s 46 chromosomes. The viral DNA molecule within the chromosome is termed a provirus. This phenomenon is known as lysogeny The replication cycle of HIV 1 and 2 Assembly The provirus DNA is transcribed into RNA. Some is mRNA that is translated into viral proteins (e.g., gp120, reverse transcriptase, etc.). Other full-length RNA strands are used to construct a new generation of HIV genomes. Genomes, capsid proteins, and enzyme molecules are assembled at the edge of the cell, forming a circular structure that binds to the cell membrane
Protease snips out enzyme molecules and capsid proteins, then sections the capsid proteins into segments that unite and form an icosahedral capsid. Collapses to yield a conical capsid surrounding the RNA genome and enzymes. Note that p120 and gp41 extend from the cell’s membrane as spikes. The assembled viral nucleocapsid localizes to just under the membrane of the cells and buds through the membrane to form the envelope The replication cycle of HIV 1 and 2
Budding Virus coats itself with the cell membrane and pinches off, taking the membrane and spike proteins with it as the envelope. The virus is then released to the extracellular environment and HIV replication is complete. The capsid and matrix proteins and HIV enzymes need to be cleaved by a protease inside of HIV for the virus to be infectious.
Adapted from Vella, S., et al., AIDS Soc. 4 (1996): 15-18. Electron Micrograph Showing Mature HIV Particles
Courtesy of Louisa Howard, Dartmouth College, Electron Microscope Facility Figure 9-13 Basic retroviral genome HIV genome Know what gag, pol, and env encode, pls
Important drug targets
burst of replication when infected T cells are stimulated
necessary for the reverse transcription of RNA to DNA
enhances the movement of genetic messages into the cytoplasm One of the normal functions of the nef gene is to downregulate host antigen presentation. It does so by binding to HLA class I receptors via its binding motif thus interfering with intracellular HLA class I antigen processing Figure 9-15 part 1 of 4 Figure 9-15 part 2 of 4 Figure 9-15 part 3 of 4 Figure 9-15 part 4 of 4 Primary (acute) HIV infection Fever, pharyngitis, adenopathy, and rash Measures of virus and symptoms decline precipitously with seroconversion Early infection, virus completely homogeneous, late infection, viral heterogeneity
Immune response to Loss of CD4 T virus or loss of cells and CD4 memory opportunistic cells infections CD4 counts with time for individual patients (months after onset of primary illness) 32 years!
B T Grenfell et al. Science 2004;303:327-332 Viral infec on results in produc on of INTERFERONS
re noic acid inducible gene-1 (RIG-1) dsRNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR)
The host type I interferon response to viral and bacterial infec ons Andrea K PERRY, Gang CHEN, Dahai ZHENG, Hong TANG and Genhong CHENG, Cell Research Restriction factors = proteins that prevent viral replication, transmission, etc.
1. Proteins that exhibit antiviral activity 2. Virus infection signaled by TLRs & other PRRs, resulting interferon production 3. Constitutively expressed or induced by interferons 4. Often themselves antagonized by virus proteins (virulence factors) 5. Most often, cell-autonomous (act within the cells) 6. Exceptions are the interferons themselves: cytokines that act upon the interferon-producing cell (autocrine) and between cells (paracrine) 7. Cell intrinsic factors can be increased by interferons 8. Restriction factors target specific steps in the HIV-1 life cycle, but unlike antiretroviral drugs, they do so in a way that makes it difficult for HIV-1 to evolve resistance to the inhibitor through simple evasive mutations (maybe) 9. Intrinsic Cellular Defenses Are Determinants of Viral Host Range 10. Blocks to cross-species transmission are imposed by APOBEC3G and TRIM5 proteins that appear particularly powerful a. They are especially potent anti-viral proteins b. Constitutively expressed lentiviral target cells: T cells and macrophages APOBEC-3 • APOlipoprotein B Editing Catalytic subunit-like 3 (cytidine deaminases) • APOBEC3G (384 amino acids, 46.4 kDa) is the prototype antiretroviral cytidine deaminase • Expressed in virus infected cells and incorporated into progeny virions • Upon virion entry into a new target cell, APOBEC3G acts during reverse transcription, primarily during the synthesis of the negative sense DNA strand • Deaminates the C4 position of 2’-deoxycytidine producing 2’-deoxyuridine • APOBEC3G preferentially acts on the third cytosine of the sequence 5’-CCCA-3’ • Causes major disruption of the coding potential of the viral genome • Viral counter measures: Vif proteins bind to APOBEC3 and recruit proteosome degradation. SIVcpz Vif and SIVsmm Vif both active against HIV-1 and HIV-2
APOBEC3A, APOBEC3B, APOBEC3D, APOBEC3F, and APOBEC3H, Immunity Review
TRIM5α • TRIpartite Motif family of proteins • Targets the incoming viral capsid prior to reverse transcription • Consequence, capsid disruption and degradation • Acts to promote proteosome-mediated capsid degradation, but proteosomeImmunity inhibitors do not block anti-viral activity • SPRY domain highly variable in primates Review • Dictates the retroviruses that are restricted by a particular TRIM5 variant • Human TRIM5α largely ineffective against primate lentiviruses, but monkey TRIM5α very effective
A proposed model of TRIM5a activity suggests that TRIM5a forms a complementary three- dimensional lattice around the incoming capsid.
Figure 2. Structure and Antiretroviral Activity of Restriction Factors (A) Architecture of APOBEC3G. (B) Ribbon representation of the C-terminal CDA domain of APOBEC3G (PDB entry 3IR2) consisting of a five-stranded b-sheet core surrounded by six a-helices. The b2-sheet (shown in green) is distorted to various degrees in all reported NMR (PDB entries 2JYW, 2KBO, and 2KEM) and X-ray structures (PDB entries 3IQS and 3IR2), due to the differential hydration of residues in each structure. The three flexible loops near the CDA catalytic site (shown in red) contribute to substrate binding. The residues coordinating the zinc atom (black sphere), either directly or via a water molecule (blue sphere), are shown as a stick representation. (C) Architecture of TRIM5a. (D) Left: NMR structure (PDB entry 2ECV; residues 1 to 78) of the RING domain of human TRIM5a. The putative E2 enzyme-binding domain is shown in brown. The Figure 2. Structure and Antiretroviral Activity of Restriction Factors residues coordinating the zinc atom (black sphere) are shown as a stick representation. Right: NMR structure (PDB entry 2YRG; residues 86 to 131) of the B-box (A) Architecture of APOBEC3G. domain of human TRIM5a. A hydrophobic cluster of residues (shown in pink) and Arg 119 (shown in green) in particular are critical for higher-order oligomerization. (B) Ribbon representation of the C-terminal CDA domain of APOBEC3G (PDB entry 3IR2)(E) consisting A proposed model of a five-strandedof TRIM5a activity suggestsb-sheet that core TRIM5 surroundeda forms a complementary by six a-helices. three-dimensional lattice around the incoming capsid. The RING domain (green circles), the coiled-coil and B-box domains (black lines), and the SPRY domain (pink rectangles) are indicated. The b2-sheet (shown in green) is distorted to various degrees in all reported NMR (PDB entries(F) Architecture 2JYW, of Tetherin.2KBO, and 2KEM) and X-ray structures (PDB entries 3IQS and 3IR2), due to the differential hydration of residues in each structure. The three flexible(G) loops A model near for the possible CDA catalytic configurations site adopted (shown by tetherinin red) dimers contribute (PDB entry to substrate 2XG7) during virion tethering. Tetherin dimers might trap virions by the binding. The residues coordinating the zinc atom (black sphere), either directly or via a waterincorporation molecule of one pair (blue of anchors sphere), into theare viral shown envelope as (left a stick and center representation. panels). Alternatively, tethering might be achieved through the multimerization of tetherin molecules that are distributed between virion envelope and cell membrane (right panel). N and C represent the termini of tetherin. (C) Architecture of TRIM5a. (H) Architecture of SAMHD1. (D) Left: NMR structure (PDB entry 2ECV; residues 1 to 78) of the RING domain of human TRIM5(I) Ribbona representation. The putative of the E2 HD enzyme-binding domain of SAMHD1 (PDB domain entry 3U1N) is shown with an in expanded brown. view The of the active site. The residues coordinating the zinc atom (gray sphere), water molecule (blue sphere) and the phosphate ion are shown as a stick representation. residues coordinating the zinc atom (black sphere) are shown as a stick representation. Right:For (A), (C), NMR (F), and structure (H), domains (PDB and motifs entry critical 2YRG; for function residues are highlighted 86 to 131) in color of theand numbers B-box indicate the amino acid positions. Stars indicate catalytic site domain of human TRIM5a. A hydrophobic cluster of residues (shown in pink) and Arg 119 (shownresidues. in green) in particular are critical for higher-order oligomerization. (E) A proposed model of TRIM5a activity suggests that TRIM5a forms a complementary three-dimensional lattice around the incoming capsid. The RING domain (green circles), the coiled-coil and B-box domains (black lines), and the SPRY domain (pink402 Immunity rectangles)37, September are indicated. 21, 2012 ª2012 Elsevier Inc. (F) Architecture of Tetherin. (G) A model for the possible configurations adopted by tetherin dimers (PDB entry 2XG7) during virion tethering. Tetherin dimers might trap virions by the incorporation of one pair of anchors into the viral envelope (left and center panels). Alternatively, tethering might be achieved through the multimerization of tetherin molecules that are distributed between virion envelope and cell membrane (right panel). N and C represent the termini of tetherin. (H) Architecture of SAMHD1. (I) Ribbon representation of the HD domain of SAMHD1 (PDB entry 3U1N) with an expanded view of the active site. The residues coordinating the zinc atom (gray sphere), water molecule (blue sphere) and the phosphate ion are shown as a stick representation. For (A), (C), (F), and (H), domains and motifs critical for function are highlighted in color and numbers indicate the amino acid positions. Stars indicate catalytic site residues.
402 Immunity 37, September 21, 2012 ª2012 Elsevier Inc. Immunity
Review Genes encoding APOBEC3G and TRIM5α are under postive selection in human beings… They have among the highest dN/dS ratios of all human genes
What is an dN/dS ratio? Remember this selection pressure occurred in the distant past, long before HIV infected human beings
Figure 3. Evolution of Restriction Factor and Accessory Gene Function (A) Nef proteins of SIVs antagonize tetherin by interacting with the tetherin cytoplasmic tail. The diagram is a schematic representation of the genetic conflict between them. Colored figures indicate tetherin sequences in the cytoplasmic tail that are recognized by Nef and are hence rapidly evolving under positive selection. (B) Cumulative frequency distribution of dN/dS ratios for 12,404 human-chimpanzee orthologous gene pairs. Adapted from previously computed data (Chim- panzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium, 2005). Positive selection (dN/dS > 1) and purifying selection (dN/dS < 1) are indicated by purple and orange arrows, respectively. The dN/dS value for each restriction factor is indicated by the dotted lines. The percentage of orthologous gene pairs with lower dN/dS ratios is indicated by the solid lines. (C) Evolution of Vpu and Nef function as primate lentiviruses were transmitted between species. See text for details. a population of host variants by different viral species or strains. Blocks to cross-species transmission are imposed by Thus, the mere presence or absence of signatures of positive APOBEC3G and TRIM5 proteins that appear particularly power- selection in a given gene cannot, by itself, be construed as diag- ful, perhaps because (1) these two restriction factors are espe- nostic of the presence or absence of a virus-host interaction. cially potent inhibitors, and (2) they are constitutively expressed Nevertheless, each of the four classes of HIV and SIV restriction in the natural target cells of primate lentiviruses. HIV-1 and SIV factors exhibits signatures of positive selection over at least Vif proteins are universally capable of antagonizing APOBEC3G a portion of its sequence, in at least some mammalian lineages. proteins in their natural hosts but are often impotent when con- fronted with APOBEC3G proteins from other primates (Mariani Intrinsic Cellular Defenses Are Determinants of Viral et al., 2003; Malim and Bieniasz, 2012). Indeed, the inability of Host Range many SIV Vif proteins to induce degradation of human Positive selection causes high interspecies protein sequence APOBEC3G might explain why many SIVs have not been found variability in restriction factors. Consequently, viral adaption to in humans. Notably, SIVCPZ Vif and SIVSMM Vif are both active antagonize or evade a particular restriction factor variant in one against human APOBEC3G (Gaddis et al., 2004), and both of host species can come at the cost of susceptibility to restriction these lineages have successfully colonized humans (as HIV-1 factor variants in another potential host. Thus, antagonistic and HIV-2, respectively). coevolution of virus and a particular host can reduce the proba- Although human TRIM5a is largely ineffective as an inhibitor of bility that an individual viral species can evade or antagonize the primate lentiviruses (Kratovac et al., 2008), TRIM5a variants array of defense mechanisms that confront it when the opportu- found in monkeys can be very potent inhibitors, and those found nity to colonize a new host species arises. in some species are capable of restricting an impressively
Immunity 37, September 21, 2012 ª2012 Elsevier Inc. 405 Does Variation in Restriction Factors Contribute to AIDS Susceptibility in Human Beings?
• Some variation in HIV/AIDS susceptibility in humans can be attributed to CCR5 (rare) and MHC polymorphisms (e.g., HLA B57) • Subpopulations of humans encode inactivating or destabilizing polymorphisms in genes encoding TRIM5α, APOBEC3B, APOBEC3H • Variation among APOBEC3H haplotypes in terms of antagonism by Vif. Polymorphic mutations are found in TRIM5a (H43Y) and APOBEC3G (H186R) that decrease activity • Actual resistance or sensitivity to HIV correlated with TRIM5 or APOBEC3 polymorphisms in human beings has not been consistently found! • Resistance due to polymorphisms in TRIM5 family members in macques HAS been shown • How can we use this information: inhibitors of Vif has been identified HIV 3EXUALLY 4RANSMITTED $ISEASES
4ABLE 53 &OOD